Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:30407
:1:
W.P.(C). No.10240 of 2020
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE VIJU ABRAHAM
WEDNESDAY, THE 2ND DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 12TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO. 10240 OF 2020
PETITIONERS:
MANO ALEX
AGED 53 YEARS
W/O.ALEX MATHEW, NEDUMCHIRAYIL HOUSE, PEROOR.P.O.,
KOTTAYAM-686637. CORRECTED AS.
THE NAME OF THE HUSBAND OF THE PETITIEONR IS
CORRECTED AS 'ALEX THOMAS' INSTEAD OF 'ALEX MATHEW,
AS PER ORDER DATED 20.08.2020 IN IA NO.2/2020.
ADDL.P2.ANDREW ALEX,
AGED 1 YEARS
S/O. ALEX THOMAS, NEDUMCHIRA HOUSE, PEROOR P.O.,
KOTTAYAM - 686637, REPRESENTED BY HIS POWER OF
ATTORNEY HOLDER, SRI.ALEX THOMAS.
ADDL.P2 IS IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER DATED 20.08.2020
in I.A.NO.1/2020.
BY ADV C.K.SHERIN
RESPONDENTS:
UNION OF INDIA,
REPRESENTED BY SECRETARY TO MINISTRY OF ROAD
TRANSPORT AND HIGHWAYS, TRANSPORT BHAWAN, SANSAD
MARG, NEW DELHI-110001.
NATIONAL HIGHWAYS AUTHORITY OF INDIA,
G.5 AND 6, SECTOR - 10, DWARKA, NEW DELHI-110075,
REPRESENTED BY ITS CHAIRMAN.
2025:KER:30407
:2:
W.P.(C). No.10240 of 2020
THE PROJECT DIRECTOR,
NATIONAL HIGHWAYS AUTHORITY OF INDIA (MINISTRY OF
ROAD TRANSPORT AND HIGHWAYS), OFFICE OF THE PROJECT
DIRECTOR, CHANDRANAGAR, PALAKKAD-7.
*4
ADDL.R4: STATE OF KERALA,
REPRESENTED BY SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT DEPARTMENT
OF REVENUE, SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN 695001
*5
ADDL.R5: REVENUE DIVISIONAL OFFICER ,
PARAKKUNNAM, VIDYUT NAGAR, PALAKKAD, KERALA, PIN
-678001
*6
ADDL.R6: DEPUTY COLLECTOR,
CIVIL STATION, KUNATHURMEDU, PALAKKAD, KERALA, PIN
- 678013
*ADDL.R4 TO R6 ARE IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER DATED
13.03.2025 IN I.A.2/2025 IN WP(C)10240/2020
BY ADVS.
SHRI.C.DINESH, SENIOR PANEL COUNSEL
M/S.M.V.KINI AND CO., SC, NHAI
SRI.E.C.KURIAKOSE
OTHER PRESENT:
SC- LEJO JOSEPH GEORGE
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
02.04.2025,
FOLLOWING:
THE
COURT
ON
THE
SAME
DAY
DELIVERED
THE
2025:KER:30407
W.P.(C). No.10240 of 2020
:3:
“CR”
---
VIJU ABRAHAM, J.
-- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -W.P.(C) No.10240 of 2020
-- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -Dated this the 2nd day of April, 2025
JUDGMENT
The above writ petition is filed challenging Ext.P1 notification
issued under Section 3A of the National Highways Act, 1956 (in
short 'the Act, 1956'). Going by Section 3A of the Act, 1956 the
acquisition could be made if the land is required for a public
purpose, for the building, maintenance, management or operation
of a national highway or part thereof and the contention of the
petitioner is that the present acquisition is not for any of the
purposes mentioned in Section 3A of the Act, 1956 and therefore,
the proceedings initiated as per Ext.P1 is liable to be interfered
with. It is seen that subsequently the petitioner restricted the
reliefs to the extent of seeking a direction to the NHAI to acquire
the small portion of land left out from the 3A notification as the
same cannot be utilised by the petitioner for any other purpose
and to pay compensation for the acquired land treating the
2025:KER:30407
W.P.(C). No.10240 of 2020
:4:
property as “purayidom”.
2. When the matter came up for consideration on 17.07.2020
this Court clarified that the National Highway Authorities are
entitled for 3D publication, but they were injuncted from taking
further action after the 3D publication, without obtaining further
orders from this Court. Later a subsequent order was issued on
20.08.2020 wherein this Court has observed that the petitioner's
genuine concern is that the remaining land will be rendered
useless and if that portion of the land is also acquired, her
grievance will be redressed to a certain extent. Thereupon the
petitioner's request was directed to be addressed by the Project
Director for acquiring the remaining land which cannot be utilised
by the petitioner for any purpose or to refix the alignment, so that
the petitioner is able to use the balance land and also directed that
appropriate decision shall be taken by the Project Director.
3. The learned Standing Counsel appearing for the National
Highway Authority would submit that the issue was considered,
and the Authority has decided to acquire the balance land, for
which a fresh notification is to be issued.
4. The issue now projected by the petitioner is in respect of
2025:KER:30407
W.P.(C). No.10240 of 2020
:5:
the determination of the land value of the property covered by
Ext.P1, 3A notification published as per the Act, 1956. The learned
counsel appearing for the petitioner would submit that at the time
of 3A notification the property was classified as a paddy land in the
revenue records though the same was converted even prior to the
coming into force of Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and
Wetland Act, 2008(in short 'the Act, 2008'). The Form 5 application
filed by the petitioner before the Revenue Divisional Officer as per
the provisions of the Act, 2008 was allowed as per Exts.P5 and P6
ordering removal of the property of the petitioner from the data
bank. Later, Form 7 application under Section 27A of the Act, 2008
was submitted by the petitioner and a direction was issued by this
Court in W.P.(C)Nos.35050 & 35289 of 2024 to the authorities to
consider the Form 7 application submitted by the petitioner. The
petitioner submits that till date no action has been taken on the
same. The learned counsel for the petitioner contended that the
petitioner is entitled for compensation by treating the nature of the
land as 'purayidom' and not as a paddy land.
5. The learned Standing Counsel appearing for the National
Highway Authority as well as the learned Government Pleader
2025:KER:30407
W.P.(C). No.10240 of 2020
:6:
would submit that as per the Act, 1956 there are several other
stages of proceedings as part of the acquisition of land, which
includes proceedings under Section 3G of the Act, 1956 which
deals
with
the
determination
of
the
amount
payable
as
compensation. Going by Section 3G(i), if any land is acquired
under the Act, 1956 they shall be paid an amount which shall be
determined by an order of the competent authority and that going
by Section 3G, public notice will be issued inviting claim from all
persons interested in the land notified to be acquired. It is further
submitted that any claim of the petitioner for payment of amount
towards compensation treating the property as “purayidom”, could
be raised by the petitioner in the said proceedings. It is also
submitted that going by Section 3-I of the Act, 1956 the competent
authority shall have all the powers of a Civil Court to accept
documents etc., so as to determine the compensation to be paid. It
is also pointed out that if the petitioner has any grievance
regarding the determination of the compensation amount, she can
approach the Arbitrator for enhancement of the same as provided
in Section 3G(5) of the Act, 1956.
6. I have considered the rival contentions on both sides.
2025:KER:30407
W.P.(C). No.10240 of 2020
:7:
7. The grievance projected by the petitioner is that going by
Section 3G(7), of the Act, 1956 the competent authority while
determining the compensation, have to take into consideration the
market value of the land on the date of publication of the
notification under Section 3A and that if directions are not issued
by this Court, the competent authority will take a decision
regarding payment of the compensation taking the market value
based on the nature of the land as on the date of publication of the
notification under Section 3A. The petitioner would contend that
Ext.P1 notification under Section 3A was issued only in 2019 and
the petitioner has submitted the necessary application as early as
in 2010 for removing the property from the data bank, as evident
from Exts.P7 to P11, which were submitted much before Ext.P1 3A notification. Going by Ext.P5 and P6, the Form 5 application
submitted by the petitioner has been allowed by removing the
property from the data bank. What remains is only the change of
nature of land in the revenue records, for which Form 7
application submitted by the petitioner is pending consideration. I
am of the view that the impact of issuance of Ext P5 and P6 order
on the Form 5 application submitted by the petitioners removing
2025:KER:30407
:8:
W.P.(C). No.10240 of 2020
the property from the data bank is a declaration that the property
in question was not a paddy land as on the date of coming into
force question of the Act, 2008 and that the property ought not to
have been included in the data bank. The Division Bench of this
Court had occasion to consider an almost identical issue in State
of Kerala v. Mary John [2024 KHC OnLine 1428], wherein the
contention taken by the authorities was that the property is a
wetland in the revenue records and therefore, the land value can
be fixed only treating the said property as a wetland. Though the
acquisition was in the year 2006, ie., before coming into force of
the Act, 2008, the Court on the basis of the Commission report
filed in the said case, which reveals that it is a converted land,
entered a finding to the effect that merely for the reason that in
the revenue records the land is shown as wetland, it cannot be
differentiated
with
dry
land
for
the
purpose
of
awarding
compensation. Paragraph 3 of the said judgment reads as follows:
“3. The commission report shows that there were coconut trees in
that land. Therefore, it is clear that it is a converted land. Merely
for the reason that in the revenue record, the land was shown as
wetland, it cannot be differentiated with dry land, for the purpose
of awarding compensation. It is to be noted that the Kerala
2025:KER:30407
:9:
W.P.(C). No.10240 of 2020
Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008 came into
force only with effect from 12.08.2008. There was no rigor in
utilising the land as a classified wetland prior to 12.08.2008.
Therefore, the reference court was rightly justified in equating this
land in the same category of IV and V. We have dismissed the
State’s appeal preferred against enhancement of the market value
in respect of category IV and V. In the light of above, we dismiss
the State’s appeals”
(underline
supplied)
It is also profitable to refer to the judgment in M. Aboobacker v.
Union of India [2021 (6) KLT 1] wherein this Court has
considered the parameters to be taken into consideration by the
Competent
Authority
for
Land
Acquisition
(CALA),
while
determining the compensation. Paragraphs 26 to 30 of the said
judgment reads as follows”
“ 26. Now we come to the acme stage of this litigation: an
examination if the CALA is constrained to value the lands, when he
does so under Section 3-G of the NH Act, solely being guided by
the entries in the Revenue Records.
27. Upfront, the answer to this has to be to the negative, because
the NH Act imposes no such limitation. On the contrary and more
importantly, Section 3-G(7) of the NH Act commands the 'CALA'
(as
also
the
Arbitrator
in
the
next
stage),
to
take
into
consideration, among the other criteria mentioned therein, the
market value of the land on the date of publication of the
2025:KER:30407
: 10 :
W.P.(C). No.10240 of 2020
notification under Section 3A, while determining compensation
under Section 3G(1) of the Act. Therefore, it is the 'market value'
of the land at the time of the Section 3-A notification which is to be
taken into account by the 'CALA', which will have to be
ascertained through relevant and applicable enquiry, based on all
germane inputs – one of which alone can be the classification of
the land in the Revenue records.
28. That so said, it is here that the submissions of Sri.Bidan
Chandran - learned Standing Counsel for the NHAI, assumes
significance. As rightly shown by him, while the 'CALA' acts under.
Section 3-G of the 'NH Act', he is vested with the powers of a Civil
Court, including for summoning and examining witnesses; delivery
and
production
of
documents;
reception
of
affidavits
and
requisitioning any public record. These powers are unequivocally
granted to him by Section 3I of the 'NH Act'.
29. Therefore, if the 'CALA' is to merely assess the value of the
acquired properties confined by the entries in the Revenue
Records, or even by the Fair Value notification, such expansive
powers would not have been statutorily vested on him. The
purpose sub-serving Section 3-I of the NH Act is to equip the
'CALA' to determine the real market value of the property, at the
time of issue of the notification under Section 3-A; which he will
have to accomplish, adverting to all genuine materials and inputs,
among which would be the Revenue Records and Fair Value
notifications.
30. To paraphrase, the 'CALA' is statutorily obliged to make a
comprehensive enquiry – adverting to the documents of title; the
physical nature of the property; the purposes for which it had been
put to use prior to acquisition; the nature of the locality; the
infrastructural development of the area where is situated; the
2025:KER:30407
W.P.(C). No.10240 of 2020
: 11 :
nature of the road which it abuts; the ease of access to it etc., –
juxtaposed by the entries in the Revenue Records and the Fair
Value notifications. The considerations above enumerated, of
course, are not exhaustive. “
(underline supplied)
This Court in Aboobacker’s case cited supra, has held that while
determining compensation for the acquired land, the authority
need not be solely guided by the entries in the revenue records
and the authority is statutorily obliged to make a comprehensive
enquiry adverting to the documents of title, physical nature of the
property, the purpose for which the property was put to use prior
to
the
acquisition,
nature
of
the
locality,
infrastructural
development of the area, nature of the roads it abuts, the ease of
access to it, to assess the value of the acquired property even
looking into the fair value notification etc., juxtaposed by the
entries in the revenue records and the fair value notification.
8. Admittedly, as evident from Exts.P5 and P6 orders, the
property was a converted land much prior to the coming into force
of Act 2008. In the light of the declaration of law as stated above, I
am of the view that the authority while determining the
compensation has to fix the land value not merely on the basis of
2025:KER:30407
W.P.(C). No.10240 of 2020
: 12 :
the entries in the revenue records but on the basis of the
parameters enumerated above and also the nature of the land. In
light of the above, I am of the opinion that the property which was
declared to be not 'paddy land' as on the date of coming into force
of Act, 2008, and which was ordered to be removed from the data
bank as per Exts.P5 and P6 orders cannot be treated as 'paddy
land' for the purpose of determination of the compensation only for
the reason that the nature of the property is entered in the
revenue records as 'Nilam'. It is also to be noted that Form-7
application was also submitted by the petitioner to change the
nature of land in the revenue records and a direction was issued
by this Court to consider the same and is pending consideration
before the authority concerned.
In the above facts and circumstances, the above writ petition
is disposed of permitting the petitioner to raise all her contentions
in the enquiry to be initiated by the competent authority for
determination of compensation as provided under Section 3G of
the Act, 1956. The petitioner will be free to produce all the
documents in support of her claim and the claim of the petitioner
for
payment
of
compensation
treating
the
land
as
dry
2025:KER:30407
: 13 :
W.P.(C). No.10240 of 2020
land/purayidom shall be duly considered by the competent
authority with specific reference to the fact that the property has
already been removed from the data bank and such removal is a
declaration that the property was not a paddy land as on the date
of coming into force of the Act, 2008 and the parameters stated
above. The competent authority shall issue notice to the petitioner
before determining the compensation amount and the petitioner
shall be afforded an opportunity of being heard. As regards the
additional land to be acquired, necessarily, the authorities shall
issue
a
fresh
compensation
notification
shall
also
be
and
the
taking
determination
into
of
the
consideration
the
parameters enumerated above.
Sd/-
VIJU ABRAHAM
JUDGE
sm/
2025:KER:30407
W.P.(C). No.10240 of 2020
: 14 :
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 10240/2020
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT P1
TRUE COPY OF THE NOTIFICATION DATED
9.8.2019 ISSUED BY THE MINISTRY OF ROAD
TRANSPORT AND HIGHWAYS.
EXHIBIT P2
TRUE COPY OF THE SKETCH PREPARED BY THE
PETITIONER TO GIVE A CLEAR IDEA REGARDING
THE LAND PROPOSED TO BE ACQUIRED BY THE
RESPONDENTS.
EXHIBIT P3
TRUE COPY OF THE POWER OF ATTORNEY
EXECUTED BY ANDREW ALEX IN FAVOUR OF ALEX
THOMAS.
EXHIBIT P4
TRUE COPY OF THE PROPOSED MAP FOR THE
ACQUISITION OF THE PETITIONERS PROPERTY
Exhibit P5
A TRUE COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS OF THE RDO
PALAKKAD DATED 08.02.2024 BEARING NO.
1669/2024 BELONGS TO THE 1ST PETITIONER
Exhibit P6
A TRUE COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS OF THE RDO
PALAKKAD DATED 08.02.2024 BEARING NO.
1676/2024 BELONGS TO THE 2ND PETITIONER
Exhibit P7
TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION SUBMITTED BY
THE 2ND PETITIONER BEFORE THE VILLAGE
OFFICER
Exhibit P8
A TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION CERTIFIED
BY THE VILLAGE OFFICER WITH REGARD TO THE
PROPERTIES IN SY. NO. 217/10 AND 257/13
Exhibit P9
A TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION CERTIFIED
BY THE VILLAGE OFFICER WITH REGARD TO THE
PROPERTIES IN SY. NO. 217/8 AND 257/12
2025:KER:30407
W.P.(C). No.10240 of 2020
: 15 :
Exhibit P10
A TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION DATED NIL
SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONERS BEFORE THE
RDO
Exhibit P11
A TRUE COPY OF THE COMMUNICATION DATED
03.09.2012
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review