Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CMA No.4246/2019 and
CMA Nos.1221, 1224 & 1228/2021
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 21-07-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE N. ANAND VENKATESH
CMA No. 4246 of 2019
and
CMA Nos.1221, 1224 & 1228 of 2021
and
CMP Nos. 6194, 6203 & 6210 of 2021
1. Manjula,
W/o. Paulraj
2. Minor. Vibinu,
Rep. by Natural Guardian and Mother Manjula,
3. Minor. Ramprasad
Rep. by Natural Guardian and Mother Manjula,
No.2/310, MGR Nagar, D.S.P.Nagar,
T.Manarai, Tirupur Taluk and District.
All are residing at No.181, Kaveri Road,
Karungalpalayam, Erode District.
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. Chellamani
S/o. Ramasamy
No.376, N.No.360, Tagore Nagar, Thirupalai,
Madurai Taluk and District.
2. United India Ins. Co. Ltd.,
Rep. by its Manager, Having its Registered
Office at No.139, CG Complex, III Floor,
Kumaran Road, Coimbatore – 641 601.
3. Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation
Madurai, Rep by its General Manager, Having
Registered Office at Bye Pass Road, Madurai.
4. Kathiresan,
S/o. Balagurusamy,
__________
Page1 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No.4246/2019 and
CMA Nos.1221, 1224 & 1228/2021
Akkaraipatti, Peraiyur Taluk,
Madurai District.
5. V.S. Murugan
S/o. Sankaralingam,
No.1/1053e/power line 2nd Street,
Nerupperichal, Tiruppur.
6. Royal Sundaram Alliance Ins.Co.Ltd.,
Rep. by its Manager, Having its Registered
Office At Sundaram Towers, No.46, Whites
Road, Royapettah, Chennai.
7. Viji
M/o. Late. Paulraj,
No.2/310, MGR Nagar, D.S.P.Nagar,
T.Manarai, Tirupur Taluk and District.
8. Minor. Vidhya
D/o. Late. Paulraj, Rep. by Guardian Mother
Viji, No.2/310, MGR Nagar, DSP Nagar, T.
Manarai, Tirupur Taluk and District.
9. Chandran
S/o. Soundarajan, No.2/310, MGR Nagar,
DSP Nagar, T. Manarai, Tirupur Taluk and
District.
..Respondent(s)
CMA No. 1228 of 2021
Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Co Ltd
Rep. by its Manager, Having its Regd, Office At
Sundaram Towers, No.46, Whites Road,
Royapettah, Chennai - 600014.
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. Manjula
W/o.Late Paulraj, Resi At No.2/310 Mgr
Nagar, DSP Nagar, T Mannarai, Tiruppur
Taluk and District, Presently Resi at No.181,
Kaveri Road, Karungalpalayam, Erode District.
__________
Page2 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No.4246/2019 and
CMA Nos.1221, 1224 & 1228/2021
2. Vibinu (minor)
D/o.Late Paulraj, Resi At No.2/310 MGR
Nagar, DSP Nagar, T Mannarai, Tiruppur
Taluk and District, Presently Res At No.181,
Kaveri Road, Karungalpalayam, Erode
District. (respondents 2 And 3 Minors Rep. By
Mother And NF 1st Respondent)
3. Ramprasad (minor)
S/o.Late Paulraj, Resi At No.2/310 MGR
Nagar, DSP Nagar, T Mannarai, Tiruppur
Taluk And District, Presently Resi At No.181,
Kaveri Road, Karungalpalayam, Erode
District. (respondents 2 And 3 Minors Rept By
Mother And NF 1st Respondent)
4. Viji
W/o.Chandran And M/o.Late Paulraj,
Respondents 4 To 6 are Resi At No.2/310,
MGR Nagar, DSP Nagar, T.Mannarai,
Tiruppur.
5. Vidhya (minor)
S/o Late Paulraj, Respondents 4 to 6 are Resi
At No.2/310, MGR Nagar, DSP Nagar,
T.Mannarai, Tiruppur. 5th Respondent Minor
Rept by Mother And NF 4th Respondent)
6. Chandran
S/o.Soundarajan, Respondents 4 To 6 Are Resi
At No.2/310, MGR Nagar, DSP Nagar,
T.Mannarai, Tiruppur.
7. Chellamani
S/o.Ramasamy, Old No.376, New No.360
Tagore Nagar, Thirupalai, Madurai Tk And
District.
8. M/s.United India Insurance Co Ltd
Rep. By Its Manager, Having Its Registered
Office At 139, C G Complex, III Floor,
Kumaran Road, Coimbatore 641601.
__________
Page3 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No.4246/2019 and
CMA Nos.1221, 1224 & 1228/2021
9. TNSTC Madurai
Rept By Its General Manager, Having Regd
Office At Bye Pass Road, Madurai.
10.Kathiresan
S/o.Balagurusamy, Akkaraipatti, Periyur
Taluk, Madurai District.
11.V.S.Murugan
S/o.Sankaralingam, No.1/1053-e, Power line,
2nd Street, Neruperichal, Tirupur 641602.
12.V.Mahalakshmi
W/o.Late S.Venkatesan, Both Are Resi At
D No.2/323, DSP Nagar, MGR Colony,
T.Mannarai, Tiruppur.
13.V.Ramakrishnan (minor)
S/o.Late S.Venkatesan, Both Are Resi At
D No.2/323, DSP Nagar, MGR Colony,
T.Mannarai, Tiruppur. 13th Respondent Minor
Rept By Mother And NF 12th Respondent.
..Respondent(s)
CMA No. 1224 of 2021
Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Company Ltd,
Rep By Its Manager, Having its Regd Office At
Sundaram Towers, No.46, Whites Road,
Royepettah, Chennai-600 014.
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. Viji
W/o. Chandran, No.2/310, M.G.R. Nagar,
D.S.P.Nagar, T.Manarai, Tiruppur Taluk And
District. Presently Residing At No.181, Kaveri
Road, Karungalpalayam, Erode District.
2. Chellamani,
S/o. Ramasamy, Old No.376, New No.360,
Tagore Nagar, Thirupalai, Madurai Taluk And
District.
__________
Page4 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No.4246/2019 and
CMA Nos.1221, 1224 & 1228/2021
3. M/s.United India Insurance Company Ltd,
Rep By Its Manager, Having Its Registered
Office At, 139, C.G.Complex, III Floor,
Kumaran Road, Coimbatore-641 601.
4. TNSTC Madurai,
Rep By Its General Manager, Having Regd
Office At Bye Pass Road, Madurai District.
5. Kathiresan
S/o. Balagurusamy, Akkaraipatti, Peraiyur
Taluk, Madurai District.
6. V.S.Murugan
S/o. Sankaralingam, No.1/1053-e, Powerline,
2nd Street, Neruperichal, Tirupur-641 602.
7. V. Mahalakshmi
W/o. Late S.Venkatesan, D.No.2/323,
D.S.P.Nagar, M.G.R.Colony, T.Mannarai,
Tiruppur.
8. V. Ramakrishnan (minor)
S/o. Late S. Venkatesan, D.No.2/323,
D.S.P.Nagar, M.G.R.Colony, T.Mannarai,
Tiruppur.
..Respondent(s)
CMA No. 1221 of 2021
Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Company
Limited,
Rep. by its Manager, Having Its Regd. Office At
Sundaram Towers, No.46, Whites Road,
Royapettah, Chennai 600 014.
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. N.Veeranagalakshmi
W/o.Nagamuthu, and Daughter of
Ranganayagi, Old No.31, New No.31,
Valavikara Street, Periyakulam 625 601,
Theni District.
__________
Page5 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No.4246/2019 and
CMA Nos.1221, 1224 & 1228/2021
2. V.Meena
W/o.Velusamy, And Daughter of Ranganayagi,
Old No.7, New No.31, Sudhanthira Street,
Periyakulam 625 601, Theni District.
3. K.Muthuraj
S/o.Krishnasamy,
No.7/215, T.V.Renganathapuram,
Rajagopalanpatti 625 512 Theni District.
Presently Residing At No.181, Kaveri Road,
Karungalpayalam, Erode District.
4. K.Murugan
S/o.Krishnasamy,
No.7/215, T.V.Renganathapuram,
Rajagopalanpatti 625 512 Theni District.
Presently Residing At No.181, Kaveri Road,
Karungalpayalam, Erode District.
5. Chellamani
S/o.Ramasamy, Old No.376, New No.360,
Tagore Nagar, Thirupalai, Madurai Taluk And
District.
6. United India Insurance Co. Ltd.,
Rep. by its Manager, Having its Registered
Office At, 139, C.G.Complex, III Floor,
Kumaran Road, Coimbatore 641 601.
7. TNSTC Madurai
Rep. by Its General Manager, Having Reg.
Office At Bye-pass Road, Madurai.
8. Kathiresan
S/o.Balagurusamy, Akkaraipatti, Peraiyur
Taluk, Madurai District.
9. V.S.Murugan
S/o.Sankaralingam, No.1/1053-e, Powerline,
2nd Street, Neruperichal, Tirupur 641 602.
10.Krishnasamy,
T.V.Renganathapuram,
__________
Page6 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No.4246/2019 and
CMA Nos.1221, 1224 & 1228/2021
Rajagopalanpatti 625 512, Theni District.
11.V.Mahalakshmi
W/o.Late S.Venkatesan, Door No.2/323,
D.S.P. Nagar, M.G.R.Colony, T.Mannarai,
Tiruppur.
12.V.Ramakrishnan(minor)
S/o.Late S.Venkatesan,
(12th Respondent Minor Rep. By Mother And
Next Friend 11th Respondent)door No.2/323,
D.S.P. Nagar, M.G.R.Colony, T.Mannarai,
Tiruppur.
..Respondent(s)
PRAYER in CMA No.4246/2019:
Civil Miscellaneous Appeal filed
under Section 173 of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, to prefer this
Memorandum of Grounds of Civil Miscellaneous Appeal against the Judgment
and Award of the MACT (Special District Court) Erode in MCOP No.609 of
2014 dated 16.09.2016.
PRAYER in CMA No.1228/2021:
Civil Miscellaneous Appeal filed
under Section 173 of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, to against the
Judgment and Decree in MCOP No.609 of 2014 dated 16.09.2016, on the file of
the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Special District Court, Erode.
PRAYER in CMA No.1224/2021:
Civil Miscellaneous Appeal filed
under Section 173 of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, to against the
Judgment and Decree in MCOP.No.610 of 2014, dated 16.09.2016, on the file
file the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Special District Court, Erode.
PRAYER in CMA No.1221/2021:
Civil Miscellaneous Appeal filed
under Section 173 of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, to against the
judgment and decree in MCOP.No.614 of 2014, dated 16.09.2016, on the file of
the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Special District Court, Erode.
__________
Page7 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No.4246/2019 and
CMA Nos.1221, 1224 & 1228/2021
For Appellant(s):
Mr.R.P.Ruban Chakravarthy
For M/s.S. Kaithamalai Kumaran
in CMA 4246/2019
Ms.C.Harini,
For M/s.M.B.Gopalan Associates
in CMA Nos.1221, 1224 & 1228/2021
For Respondent(s):
Mr.R.P.Ruban Chakravarthy
For M/s.S. Kaithamalai Kumaran
For R1 to R6 in CMA No.1228/2021
For R1 in CMA No.1224/2021
For R1 to R4 in CMA No.1221/2021
Mr.S.Santhosa Kumar,
Standing Counsel for TNSTC
For R3 in CMA No.4246/2019
For R3 in CMA No.1221/2021
For R4 in CMA No.1224/2021
For R9 in CMA No.1228/2021
COMMON JUDGMENT
All these appeals arise out of the common award passed by the Special
District Judge, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Erode in M.C.O.P.Nos. 609,
610 and 614 of 2014 dated 16.09.2016, wherein the Insurance Company in three
appeals has questioned the 25% liability attributed against them, and the
claimants in C.M.A.No.4246 of 2019 are seeking for enhancement of
compensation.
2. The case of the claimants is that on 13.07.2014, the deceased in each
case was travelling to attend a family function in a TATA Sumo car on
__________
Page8 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No.4246/2019 and
CMA Nos.1221, 1224 & 1228/2021
Dharapuram – Ottanchathiram road and at about 16.10 hours the driver-cumowner of the vehicle, drove the same in a rash and negligent manner, and
overtook the vehicle in front of the TATA Sumo car and dashed on a bus
belonging to the Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation. Due to the impact,
six occupants of the car died on the spot. Out of the same, three claim petitions
were filed in M.C.O.P.Nos.609, 610 and 614 of 2014.
3. The Tribunal, on considering the facts and circumstances of the case
and on appreciation of the oral and documentary evidence, came to the
conclusion that 50% negligence is attributable to the driver of the bus belonging
to the Transport Corporation, 25% negligence is attributable to the driver of the
TATA Sumo car, and the balance 25% negligence is attributable to the driver of
the Maruthi Suzuki car.
4. The Tribunal, having rendered the above finding, fixed the
compensation in M.C.O.P.No.609 of 2014 as follows:
Sl.
No.
Compensation awarded
under the head
Amount
(in Rs.)
1.
For Loss of Consortium
Rs.1,00,000/-
2.
For Funeral Expenditure
Rs.25,000/-
3.
For Transportation
Rs.10,000/-
4.
For Loss of Love and Affection
Rs.40,000/-
5.
For the Loss of income
Rs.15,79,392/Total Rs.17,54,392/__________
Page9 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No.4246/2019 and
CMA Nos.1221, 1224 & 1228/2021
5. In M.C.O.P.No.610 of 2014, the Tribunal fixed the compensation as
follows:
Sl.
No.
Compensation awarded
under the head
Amount
(in Rs.)
1.
For Funeral Expenditure
Rs.25,000/-
2.
For Transportation
Rs.10,000/-
3.
For Loss of Love and Affection
Rs.10,000/-
4.
For loss of dependency
Rs.51,996/Total
Rs.96,996/-
6. In M.C.O.P.No.614 of 2014, the Tribunal fixed the compensation as
follows:
Sl.
No.
Compensation awarded
under the head
Amount
(in Rs.)
1.
For Funeral Expenditure
Rs.25,000/-
2.
For Transportation
Rs.10,000/-
3.
For Loss of Love and Affection
Rs.40,000/-
4.
For loss of income
Rs.58,500/Total
Rs.1,33,500/-
7. The above compensation was directed to be paid with interest at the
rate of 7.5% per annum.
8. C.M.A.Nos.1221, 1224 and 1228 of 2021 has been filed by the
Insurance Company questioning attributing 25% negligence on the Maruthi
Suzuki car. The claimants in M.C.O.P.No.609 of 2014 have filed
C.M.A.No.4246 of 2019 seeking for enhancement of compensation.
__________
Page10 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No.4246/2019 and
CMA Nos.1221, 1224 & 1228/2021
9. This Court heard the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
appellants and respondents in all the appeals.
10. This Court carefully considered the submissions made on either side
and the materials available on record. This Court carefully went through the
award passed by the Tribunal.
11. In the case in hand, the Tribunal, on appreciation of oral and
documentary evidence, has rendered a categorical finding that the Maruthi
Suzuki car was proceeding from East to West and the Tata Sumo car was
coming behind the Maruthi Suzuki car in the same direction, and the bus
belonging to the Transport Corporation was coming in the opposite direction
from West to East. The Tribunal, at paragraph 55 of the award, has also
categorically held that if the driver-cum-owner of the Tata Sumo car had
avoided overtaking the Maruthi Suzuki car till the bus belonging to the
Transport Corporation had passed the said two cars, the entire accident could
have been averted. Thus, what becomes evident is that the Tata Sumo car was
coming behind the Maruthi Suzuki car, and the driver-cum-owner of the Tata
Sumo car had overtaken the Maruthi Suzuki car, and there was a head on
collision with the bus belonging to the State Transport Corporation, as a result
of which six precious lives were lost.
__________
Page11 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No.4246/2019 and
CMA Nos.1221, 1224 & 1228/2021
12. On assessment of the evidence, the above findings rendered by the
Tribunal does not in any way establish any negligence on the part of the driver
of the Maruthi Suzuki car. However, curiously, the Tribunal relies upon Rule 23
of the Road Regulations, which deals with the distance that has to be maintained
by a vehicle from the vehicle that is going in front. The Tribunal holds that the
Maruthi Suzuki car did not maintain the safe distance behind the Tata Sumo car
and therefore 25% negligence is attributable to the driver of the Maruthi Suzuki
car. The above finding rendered by the Tribunal is baseless and it completely
contradicts the manner in which the accident had taken place, and which was
rightly described by the Tribunal on appreciation of evidence. Admittedly, in
this case, the Maruthi Suzuki car was not coming behind the Tata Sumo car, and
it is only the Tata Sumo car which was coming behind the Maruthi Suzuki car
and the driver of the Tata Sumo car, overtook the Maruthi Suzuki car and
collided head-on, on the bus belonging to the Transport Corporation.
13. The upshot of the above discussion leads to the only conclusion that
there is no negligence on the part of the driver of the Maruthi Suzuki car and the
finding of the Tribunal attributing 25% contributory negligence on the driver of
the Maruthi Suzuki car is hereby set aside. This Court is inclined to fix 50%
negligence on the owner-cum-driver of the Tata Sumo car and sustain 50%
negligence that has already been fixed against the driver of the bus belonging to
the State Transport Corporation. The compensation shall be payable by the State
__________
Page12 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No.4246/2019 and
CMA Nos.1221, 1224 & 1228/2021
Transport Corporation and the insurer of the Tata Sumo car, namely the United
India Insurance Company Limited, in the proportion of 50% : 50%.
14. Insofar the appeal filed by the claimants for enhancement of
compensation is concerned, it is seen that the deceased had left behind his wife,
two minor sons and mother. The age of the deceased is 25 years at the time of
the accident. The Tribunal has fixed the notional monthly income at Rs.6,500/and calculated the compensation under the head of loss of income. The accident
had taken place in the year 2014, and there are four claimants in this case. In
view of the same, this Court is inclined to fix the notional monthly income at
Rs.11,000/- per month. Accordingly, the compensation under the head of loss of
income is calculated as follows:
Monthly income
: Rs.11,000/-
Add Future Prospects @ 50%
: Rs.5,500/-
Total Monthly income (11,000 + 5,500)
: Rs.16,500/-
Deducted 1/4 towards personal expenses
:Rs.4,125/- (16,500 / 4)
Monthly contribution (16,500 – 4,125)
: Rs.12,375/-
Annual income (12,375 x 12)
: Rs.1,48,500/-
Multiplier at ‘18’ (1,48,500 x 18)
: Rs.26,73,000/-
15. The Tribunal has awarded compensation of Rs.1,00,000/- under the
head of loss of consortium and Rs.40,000/- under the head of loss of love and
__________
Page13 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No.4246/2019 and
CMA Nos.1221, 1224 & 1228/2021
affection. This Court is inclined to consolidate both the heads and grant
compensation of a sum of Rs.1,60,000/- under the head of loss of consortium (4
x Rs.40,000/-).
16. The Tribunal has granted a sum of Rs.25,000/- as compensation under
the head of funeral expenses and the same is reduced to Rs.15,000/-. This Court
is inclined to grant compensation of Rs.15,000/- under the head of loss of estate.
17. In the light of the above discussion, the award passed by the Tribunal
is modified as follows:
Sl.
No.
Compensation awarded
under the head
Amount awarded Amount awarded
by the Tribunal
by this Court
(in Rs.)
(in Rs.)
1. For Loss of Consortium
Rs.1,00,000/-
Rs.1,60,000/-
2. For Funeral Expenditure
Rs.25,000/-
Rs.15,000/-
3. For Transportation
Rs.10,000/-
Rs.10,000/-
4. For Loss of Love and Affection
Rs.40,000/-
Nil
5. For the Loss of income
Rs.15,79,392/-
Rs.26,73,000/-
Rs.17,54,392/-
Rs.28,58,000/-
Total
18. The compensation awarded by the Tribunal at Rs.17,54,392/- is
enhanced to Rs.28,58,000/-. The compensation shall be payable by the transport
corporation and the second respondent Insurance Company in the proportion of
50% : 50%, less the amount already deposited, together with interest at the rate
of 7.5% per annum from the date of claim petition till the date of deposit within
__________
Page14 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No.4246/2019 and
CMA Nos.1221, 1224 & 1228/2021
a period of six (6) weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment and
on such deposit, the claimants are entitled to withdraw the same on due
application as apportioned by the Tribunal. Insofar as the enhanced
compensation is concerned, the deficit court fee, if not paid, shall be paid by the
appellants. The other directions issued by the Tribunal with regard to the mode
of payment of compensation remains unaltered.
19. In the result, C.M.A.Nos.1228, 1221, 1224 of 2021 is allowed and
C.M.A.No.4246 of 2019 is allowed in the above terms. No costs. Consequently,
the connected miscellaneous petitions are closed.
21-07-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
SSI
To:
1. The Special District Judge,
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal,
Erode.
2. The Section Officer,
V.R.Section,
High Court of Madras.
__________
Page15 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No.4246/2019 and
CMA Nos.1221, 1224 & 1228/2021
N.ANAND VENKATESH J.
SSI
CMA No. 4246 of 2019 and
CMA Nos.1221, 1224 & 1228 of 2021 and
CMP Nos.6194, 6203 & 6210 of 2021
21-07-2026
__________
Page16 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review