Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/7
GAHC010256412023
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : I.A.(Civil)/3537/2023
MANJU KALITA AND 4 ORS
W/O JOY CHARAN DEKA R/O AMAR PATH HOUSE NO. 3 GEETANAGAR
M.T. ROAD GUWAHATI-24 DIST. KAMRUP (M) ASSAM
2: KANIKA DAS @ KANIKA KALITA DAS
W/O AJOY DAS R/O COLLEGE ROAD KUNDIL NAGAR HOUSE ON. 12
BELTOLA GUWAHATI-29 DIST. KAMRUP (M) ASSAM
3: NIYOTI DAS @ NIYOTI KALITA DAS
W/O DEBEN CHANDRA DAS D.B. ROAD MELACHAKRA TINIALI
SIBASAGAR PIN-785640
4: DEBAJANI KALITA @ DEBEJANI KALITA DUTTA
W/O DIPENJYOTI DUTTA R/O HOUSE NO. 15 OPPOSITE GENESH MANDIR
PUB SARANIA HILL SIDE ROAD CHANDMARI SILPUKHURI GUWAHATI-3
DIST. KAMRUP (M) ASSAM
5: JYOTSNA KALITA @ JYOTSNA KALITA CHOUDHURY
W/O NABARUP CHOUDHURY R/O HOUSE NO. 5 BASISTHAPUR II
HATIGAON GUWAHATI-24 DIST. KAMRUP (M) ASSA
VERSUS
ROBITA BARMAN@ROBITA BARMAN KALITA,
W/O LT. GAURI SHANKAR KALITA, R/O HOUSE NO. 15, PUB SARANIA ,P.S.
CHANDMARI, GUWAHATI-3, DIST. KAMRUP (M), ASSAM.
Advocate for the Petitioner
G K MEDHI
: MS. P R MAHANTA, MR P UPADHYAY,MS. JYOTI CHETRY,MR.
Advocate for the Respondent : MR. M A SHEIKH, MR. M HOSSAIN
Page No.# 2/7
BEFORE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ROBIN PHUKAN
ORDER
07.01.2026
Heard Mr. P. Upadhyay, learned counsel for the applicants and also heard Mr. M.
Hossain, learned counsel for the opposite party.
2.
This interlocutory application is preferred by 5(five) applicants, namely, (i) Smt.
Manju Kalita, (ii) Smt. Kanika Das @ Smt. Kanika Kalita Das, (iii) Smt. Niyoti Das @ Smt.
Niyoti Kalita Das, (iv) Smt. Debajani Kalita @ Debajani Kalita Dutta and (v) Smt. Jyotshna
Kalita @ Jyotsna Kalita Choudhury, who are the respondents in CRP(IO) No.12/2023 and
the plaintiffs in Title Suit No.26/2017, for rejection of the CRP(IO) No.12/2023, filed under
the provision of Article 227 of the Constitution of India, on the ground of maintainability,
as the impugned order dated 15.12.2022, passed in Misc.(J) Case No.855/2022, arising
out of Title Suit No.26/2017, by the learned Civil Judge (Sr. Division) No.3, Kamrup(M),
Guwahati, under the provisions of Order XII Rule 6 read with Section 151 of the Code of
Civil Procedure, is a judgment on admission and therefore, it is appealable under the
provisions of Section 96 read with Order XLI Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
3.
Mr. Upadhyay, learned counsel for the applicants submits that the plaintiffs have
instituted a title suit, being Title Suit No.26/2017, before the Court of learned Civil Judge
(Sr. Division) No.3, Kamrup(M), Guwahati, for declaring right, title, interest and
possession with regard to 1/6 th share, each of the plaintiffs over the suit land (ScheduleA) and for a decree, declaring that the plaintiff Nos.1 and 4 are entitled to peaceful
possession and/or residence of the aforesaid RCC building in Schedule-'B', standing over
the suit land (Schedule-A) and also for a decree declaring that the plaintiff No.4 is entitled
to peaceful possession and/or residence of the aforesaid CI sheet pucca house (ScheduleC) and for a decree confirming the possession of the plaintiff Nos.1 and 4, in their
aforesaid RCC building (Schedule-B) and a decree confirming the possession of the
plaintiff No.4 in the CI sheet pucca house (Schedule-C) standing over the suit land
Page No.# 3/7
(Schedule-A) and for a preliminary decree for partition of the suit land (Schedule-A)
amongst the plaintiffs and the defendants and for a final decree for partition of the suit
land (Schedule-A) amongst the plaintiffs and the defendants by metes and bounds and
delivery of khas and vacant possession of the respective shares to the plaintiffs.
3.1
In the said title suit, the defendant No.1, who is the petitioner in CRP(IO)
No.12/2023 and the opposite party herein this application, had filed written statement
and in the said written statement she had admitted the statement made in paragraph
Nos.4 and 9 of the plaint filed by the applicants herein and thereafter, the applicants
herein had filed one petition, No.2271/2021, under Order XII Rule 6 of the CPC, before
the learned Trial Court praying for judgment and decree on admission. In the said
petition, the opposite party herein this application, had filed her written objection and
thereafter, hearing both the parties upon the said Misc.(J) Case No.855/2022, the learned
Trial Court vide order dated 15.12.2022, had passed the impugned order, considering the
facts admitted by the opposite party in their pleadings as well as submission of learned
counsel for both the parties and thereafter, the opposite party herein this application has
preferred one civil revision petition, being CRP(IO) No.12/2023. But, Mr. Upadhyay
submits that the said CRP(IO) is not maintainable in view of the fact that the impugned
order was passed under the provision of Order XII Rule 6 read with Section 151 of the
Code of Civil Procedure and the said order is a judgment on admission and therefore, an
appeal will lie against the impugned order under Section 96 read with Order XLI Rule 1 of
the Code of Civil Procedure and as such, the CRP(IO) No.12/2023 is not maintainable and
therefore, it is contended to allow this application and to dismiss the CRP(IO)
No.12/2023.
4.
Per contra, Mr. Hossain, learned counsel for the opposite party has vehemently
opposed the application. Mr. Hossain has drawn the attention of this Court to sub-section
(3) to Section 96 of the CPC and submits that no appeal shall lie from a decree passed by
the Court with the consent of the parties. However, Mr. Hossain submits that though the
learned Trial Court has reflected in the impugned order that he has consented in passing
the impugned order, yet, he has never made any such submission before the learned Trial
Page No.# 4/7
Court and after passing of the said order, he has raised objection before the learned Trial
Court also. But, when a question was put to Mr. Hossain, learned counsel for the opposite
party/defendant No.1, as to whether he had filed any application to that effect before the
learned Trial Court, Mr. Hossain submits that he had not filed any application before the
learned Trial Court raising his objection in the observation made by the learned Trial Court
in the impugned order. He also submits that he has preferred the present civil revision
petition against the impugned order and therefore, it is contended to dismiss the
interlocutory application. In support of his submission, Mr. Hossain has relied upon a
decision of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Himani Alloys Limited v. Tata
Steel Limited, reported in (2011) 15 SCC 273.
5.
Having heard the submission of learned counsel for both the parties, this Court has
gone through the application and the documents placed on record and also perused the
impugned order dated 15.12.2022, passed in Misc.(J) Case No.855/2022, arising out of
Title Suit No.26/2017.
6.
For better appreciation, the impugned order is reproduced herein below:“15/12/2022
Parties are represented.
Learned counsel for the OPs/defendants has filed written objection. Heard both sides on
petition no. 2271/21 under Order 12 Rule 6 CPC filed by the petitioners/plaintiffs praying
for judgment and decree on admission.
Also perused the written objection filed against the petition.
The plaintiffs have filed the main suit for declaration, confirmation of possession, partition
and permanent injunction. A meaningful reading of the rival pleadings of the parties
discloses it is an admitted position that late Sashi Kalita@Kashi Kalita was the owner of the
suit property and the parties to the suit are admittedly the legal heirs of the deceased owner.
It is also not in dispute that the suit property is yet to be divided amongst the parties.
Further, defendant no. 1 has also admitted that she has been collecting rent from the tenants
of the suit land.
Page No.# 5/7
During hearing learned counsel for the OPs submitted that the O.P has no objection against
the relief claimed by the petitioners for partition of the suit property in as much as the
relationship between the parties and the nature of the suit property are not in dispute.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that if the OPs agree to partition the suit
property and the parties get their entitled share, the petitioner shall not press for the other
reliefs in the suit except partition.
Considering facts admitted by the OPs in their pleadings as well as the submissions of
learned counsel for both sides, I am of the opinion that this Court is in a position to pass a
judgment on admission as far as partition of the suit property is concerned given that the
petitioner is not pressing for the other reliefs. Accordingly, the petitioners' prayer for
judgment on admission is allowed in terms of this order.
The instant Misc(J) is allowed and disposed of on contest accordingly.”
7.
It appears that the learned Trial Court had passed the impugned order under Order
XII Rule 6 of the CPC, on the petition No.2271/2021, filed by the plaintiffs for judgment
and decree on admission. The learned Trial Court, having considered the statement and
averment made in the written statement by the opposite party and also observing that a
meaningful reading of the rival pleadings of the parties discloses that it is an admitted
position that late Sashi Kalita @ Kashi Kalita was the owner of the suit property and the
parties to the suit are admittedly the legal heirs of the deceased owner and it is also not
in dispute that the suit property is yet to be divided amongst the parties. The learned Trial
Court also found that the defendant No.1 has admitted that she has been collecting rent
from the tenants of the suit land. It has also been observed that the learned counsel for
the opposite party submitted that the opposite party has no objection against the relief
claimed by the petitioner for partition of the suit property in as much as the relationship
between the parties in the nature of suit property are not in dispute. And thereafter, the
learned Trial Court has passed the judgment on admission and allowed the application.
8.
It is to be noted here that though the learned counsel for the opposite party
submits that under sub-section (3) to Section 96 of the CPC, no appeal shall lie from the
decree passed by the Court with the consent of the parties, yet, Mr. Upadhyay, learned
Page No.# 6/7
counsel for the applicants has pointed out that the impugned order was not a consent
order, but an order on admission passed under Order XII Rule 6 of the CPC.
9.
It is to be noted here that in the case of Smt. Shyamala Bai & Ors. v. Smt.
Saraswathi Bai & Ors., reported in 1996 ILR(Kar) 3091, the Karnataka High Court
has held that a reading of Order XII Rule 6 of the CPC and the plain language of this
provision read with Section 2(2) CPC makes it clear that any order passed by the Trial
Court allowing the plaintiffs claim either partly or fully on the basis of defendant's
admission at any stage of the suit is a 'judgment' to be followed by a 'decree', either
preliminary or final, and that it is not merely an interim order passed in the proceeding
deciding the rights and obligations of the parties and therefore, there cannot be any
dispute as to the legal position that any order passed under Order XII Rule 6 CPC by the
Trial Court is a 'decree' within the meaning of Section 2(2) of the CPC.
10.
In view of the aforesaid position and also considering the facts and circumstances,
this Court is of the view that the order passed by the learned Trial Court under Order XII
Rule 6 of the CPC is a 'decree' within the meaning of Section 2(2) of the CPC and as such,
appeal will lie under Section 96 read with Order XLI Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
11.
This Court has considered the submission of Mr. Hossain, learned counsel for the
opposite party and also gone through the decision in Himani Alloys Limited (supra),
referred by him. But, in the given factual and legal matrix, this Court is unable to record
concurrence with his submission. Though it is provided in sub-section (3) of Section 96 of
the CPC that no appeal shall lie from a decree passed by the Court with the consent of
the parties, yet, consent decree is passed under Order XXIII Rule 3 of the CPC, which
arises from a valid, lawful compromise between the parties recording mutual agreement
on the suit claims, which bind both the parties as a contract, but gains decree
enforceability distinct from unilateral admission. It demands bilateral consent not mere
acknowledgment by one side unlike judgment on admission, whereas judgment on
admission is passed under Order XII Rule 6 CPC, which allows the Court to pronounce
judgment at any suit stage upon clear admission (oral, written or in pleadings) without
Page No.# 7/7
awaiting full trial. Thus, a decree follows such judgment immediately, which may be
preliminary or final, but requires unequivocal admission and the Court exercises its
discretion while passing a judgment on admission. Under the given facts and
circumstances, this Court is of the view that the ratio laid down in the case law, referred
by him, would not advance his argument.
12.
In the result, this Court finds sufficient merit in this application and accordingly, the
same stands allowed. The civil revision petition, preferred by the opposite party is liable
to be dismissed and accordingly, the same stands dismissed, being not maintainable.
However, liberty will remain with the petitioner to avail appropriate remedy as provided
under the law.
Sd/- Robin Phukan
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review