Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 41
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Case No:-WP(C) No. 4262/2019
CM No. 2877/2025
Manjeet Singh, Age 33 years, S/o S. Sudhagar Singh,
R/o H.No. 144, Digiana Camp, Gangyal, Jammu.
…..Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. Anuj Sawhney, Advocate.
Vs
1. Central University of Jammu, RahyaSuchani
(Bagla), District Samba Th. Its Registrar;
2. Vice-Chancellor, Central University of Jammu,
Suchani (Bagla), District Samba Th. Its Registrar;
3. Dean, School of Business Studies,
Central University of Jammu, Suchani (Bagla),
District Samba;
4. Head of Department,
Department of Tourism and Travel Management,
Central University of Jammu, Suchani (Bagla),
District Samba;
5. Finance Officer, Central University of Jammu,
Suchani (Bagla), District Samba;
6. Secretary,
University Grants Commission (UGC),
I GDelhi.
H
Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg,HNew
.…. Respondent(s)
OF JAMMU &
Through:
Mr.UD.C.
CO
R TRaina, Sr. Advocate with
K A S HMr.
M Govind
I R A Raina,
N D Advocate for R-1 to 5.
Mr. Sunny Mahajan, Advocate for R-6.
LADAKH
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE JAVED IQBAL WANI, JUDGE
ORDER(ORAL)
09.07.2025
1.
The petitioner in the instant petition filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India has prayed for the following reliefs:A. Certiorari seeking to quashCommunication/order No. CUJ/Dean
/SBS/2019/142-149 Dated:- 4-11-2019issued by respondent no.3&4
(Annexure-I) by virtue of which the services ofPetitioner as
Assistant Professor werere-designated as Guest faculty that to
with retrospective effect after 30th ofJune,2019 and also reducing
petitioner'ssalary from last drawn salary i.eRs.57,675/- per month
to the maximumextent of ₹30,000/- as payable toGuest lecturers to
the disadvantage of petitioner that too in an arbitrary, unfair
and illegal manner;
B. Any order, writ or direction in the natureof mandamus
commanding therespondents not to replace or substitute
the petitioner by any other temporaryappointee or by contractual
WP(C) No. 4262/2019
arrangementor by any other manner and also allow the Petitioner
to continue his services as Assistant Professor, B. Voc (Tourism
Management) in Department of Tourismand Travel Management,
CentralUniversity of Jammu till the Posts werefilled by regular
vacancy; as the petitioneris working as Assistant Professor for the
last four years and grant himconsequential benefits including the
comparative salary @ Rs 67,675/- per month as per UGC
Guidelines;
C. An appropriate writ, order or direction inthe nature of writ of
mandamuscommanding the respondents to releasethe salary of the
petitioner w.e.f. July,2019 to till date which has been
illegallywithheld by the respondents and alsodirect them to grant
extension to thepetitioner as Assistant Professor, B. Voc(Tourism
Management) in Department ofTourism and Travel Management,
CentralUniversity of Jammu till the Posts werefilled by regular
vacancy and also directthem to continue paying the same to the
petitioner regularly in future;
D. Any other writ, order or direction whichthis Hon'ble Court may
deem fit or properin the facts and circumstances of the
case.”
2.
The background facts under the shade and cover of which the
aforesaid reliefs have been prayed and as are stated in the instant petition are
that the petitioner herein came to be engaged as Assistant Professor by the
Central University of Jammu (for short, “CUJ’) on 17.09.2015 on contract basis
against the consolidated salary of ₹53,736/- (Rupees Fifty-Three Thousand,
Seven Hundred and Thirty-Six) per month, which engagement was extended
upon satisfactory performance of the services by the petitioner from time to time
and lastly in terms of order dated 31.10.2019 came to be extended w.e.f.
24.05.2019 upto 01.07.2019 on the existing terms and conditions set out in the
initial appointment order.
3.
It is being stated that after the expiry of the extension period
provided in terms of order dated 31.10.2019, respondent 3 herein addressed a
Communication bearing No. CUJ/Dean/SB/2019/142-149 dated 04.11.2019 to
the petitioner, wherein it came to be stated that the University did not receive
any financial allocation for meeting expenses on account of salary and other
WP(C) No. 4262/2019
heads for current financial year 2019-20, as such, the services of the petitioner
cannot be continued as Assistant Professor after 30.06.2019 and that payment
for the services rendered shall be met out of the available funds with the
University on account of the same as per the University Policy or otherwise on
per day/lecture basis to a maximum extent of ₹30,000/- per month, as payable to
Guest Faculty members already appointed in the department.
4.
The petitioner has challenged the Communication (supra) dated
04.11.2019 on the premise that the respondent-University could not have either
declined the payment of consolidated salary to the petitioner in terms of order
dated 31.10.2019 or further extension in his services as Assistant Professor and
offered him engagement as a Guest Lecturer.
5.
Objections to the petition have been filed by the respondents.
6.
In the objections filed by the respondent Nos. 1 to 5, the petition is
being opposed on the premise that none of the fundamental rights of the
petitioner have been violated. It is being further stated that the engagementin the
Universityof the faculty on contractual basis is being made strictly in terms of
the provisions of Statutes 18(6) of the Central Universities Act, 2009 and that
the contract period of the petitioner as contractual Assistant Professor expired in
the month of May, 2019, which was further extended upto 01.07.2019,
whereafter the expiry of the same, the said contractual engagement of the
petitioner was not extended on one hand and, on the other hand, no other
contractual employee was engaged in place of the petitioner.
It is being further stated that the petitioner was engaged in
B.Voc(T.M)programme under National Skill Qualification Framework
(for
short, ‘NSQF’) on contractual basis in terms of the University Grants
WP(C) No. 4262/2019
Commission (UGC) guidelines, in respect of which, the financial implications
were met out of the specific Grant-in-aid from UGCand the CUJ did not receive
any separate allocation for the session 2019-20 and for the said reason,
no fresh/further engagements were made in the CUJ of the teaching faculty for
teaching further/fresh admitted candidates under NSQF.
7.
In the reply filed by the respondent 6 to the petition, it is being
stated that the respondent-University was granted approval by the UGC to offer
B.Voc Programmes in tourism management, retail management in the years
2014-15 & 2018-19 (with financial assistance) and for the years 2019-20 &
2020-21 (without financial assistance). It is being further stated that as per the
UGC’s
Communication
dated
21.08.2019,
institutions
running
skill
programmes/courses in the year 2018-19 were being approved by the UGC.
It is being next stated that Letter dated28.01.2019, circulating the revised
guidelines for enhancement of the rates of honorarium of the Guest Faculty is
self-explanatory and mandatory in nature and such Guest Faculty is a temporary
need based arrangement made by the institutions and such remuneration is paid
as per lecture basis, subject to the maximum ceiling per month, which
engagement of the Guest Faculty cannot be treated as full time Lecturer.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
8.
Having regard to the case set up by the petitioner, the grievances
projected therein is two-fold; one that the petitioner was not paid by the
respondent-University the consolidated salary upto 01.07.2019 for the services
rendered in terms of the extension order dated 31.10.2019 while issuing the
impugned order dated 04.11.2019 on the ground that the respondent-University
did not receive approval for such extension beyond 30.06.2019 and secondly,
WP(C) No. 4262/2019
that the contractual engagement of the petitioner extended from time to time
pursuant to the initial order of engagement dated 15.09.2015 and extension in
terms of the last extension order dated 31.10.2019 came to be proposed to be
altered to that of a Guest Lecturer instead of Assistant Professor unilaterally to
the detriment and prejudice of the petitioner, and instead that the services of the
petitioner were required to be extended as Assistant Professor.
9.
It is an admitted fact emerging from the record that the contractual
services of the petitioner came to be extended by the respondent-University
lastly in terms of order dated 31.10.2019 upon the approval of the Vice
Chancellor upto 01.07.2019 on the terms and conditions governing the
engagement of the petitioner rendering the petitioner entitled to receive
consolidated salary as Assistant Professor from the respondent-University uptill
01.07.2019 instead of 30.06.2019, as is provided in the impugned order dated
04.11.2019 and the respondent-University cannot deny the payment of the said
consolidated salary to the petitioner on any ground whatsoever including those
referred in the impugned Communication dated 04.11.2019.
10.
Insofar as the grievance of the petitioner that his engagement from
the Assistant Professor on contractual basis ordered by the respondentUniversity came to be altered unilaterally to that of the Guest Lecturer pursuant
to the impugned Communication dated 04.11.2019 and that instead the services
of the petitioner were required to be extended as Assistant Professor is
concerned, law stands settled and is no more res-integra that a contractual
employee has no right to have his or her contractual services renewed.
A reference in this regard to the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court passed in
case titled as, “Yogesh Mahajan Vs. Professor R.C. Deka, Director, All
WP(C) No. 4262/2019
Institute of Medical Sciences, reported in (2018) 3 SCC 218” would be relevant
and appropriate herein.
The petitioner, thus, under these circumstances, cannot seek
indulgence of this Court for seeking a relief against the respondent-University
qua extension of his contractual services, more so, in view of categoric stand of
the respondent University that the engagement of the petitioner on contractual
basis was made from time to time upon receipt of funds from the UGC, which
funds, however, were not allotted to the respondent-University for the year
2019-20 for the said purpose, as such, the respondent-University could not
continue the contractual services of the petitioner after the last extension order
dated 31.10.2019.
11.
It is significant to mention here that the working of the petitioner as
Guest Lecturer after the expiry of extension period as Assistant Professor, is not
in dispute, however, as per the stand taken by the respondent UGC, the Guest
Lecturer is to be paid the remuneration set out by the UGC as per lecture basis.
The petitioner, as such, for his working as Guest Lecturer is also required to be
paid the same strictly in tune with the UGC norms on lecturer basis, subject to
the maximum ceiling by the respondent University.
12.
The instant petition, accordingly, in view of above analysis, shall
stand disposed of.
(Javed Iqbal Wani)
Judge
Jammu
09.07.2025
Ram Krishan
Whether the order is speaking?
Whether the order is reportable?
Ram Krishan
2025.07.15 09:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Yes
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review