Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT: HYDERABAD
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE K. LAKSHMAN
WRIT PETITION No.17839 OF 2024
(CNR No.HBHC010344042024)
AND
CONTEMPT CASE No.1435 OF 2024
(CNR No.HBHC010378492024)
Reserved on: 19.06.2026
Pronounced on: 03-09-2026
Uploaded on : 05-09-2026
Between:
Manik Rao
.. Petitioner
Vs
The State of Telangana rep. by its Prl.
Secretary, Revenue Dept., Hyderabad & others
.. Respondents
This Court delivered the following:
COMMON ORDER:
Heard Mr. M.S. Anwar Siddiqui, learned counsel for the
petitioner, Ms. Tekuru Swetcha, learned Assistant Government
Pleader for Revenue and Mr. K. Jaya Kumar and Mr. Ch. Venkat
Raman, learned counsel appearing for the unofficial respondents in
W.P.No.17839 of 2024.
2. The writ petition is filed to declare the action of respondent
Nos.1 to 4 herein in deleting Sy.Nos.110 and 131 of Rompally village,
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
Bantwaram Mandal, Vikarabad District, without issuing prior notice
to the registered holders in the Record of Rights by contravening
principles of natural justice, audi alteram partem, as illegal and
consequently to direct the respondent Nos.1 to 4 to sign them up, add
them in Dharani Portal in its original position as on the date of
30.01.2024.
3. The petitioner is claiming that the land to an extent of
Acs.14-27 guntas in Sy.Nos.110 and 131, situated at Rompally
Village, Bantwaram Mandal, Vikarabad District ( for short, ‘the
subject property’) was allotted to his father’s share by virtue of family
partition dated 09.04.1972. The petitioner, his sister-in-law and his
brothers i.e. respondent Nos.6 to 8, are legal heirs of his father late Sri
Manohar Rao. They were given e-passbooks in the LRUP (Land
Records Updation Programme) conducted by Telangana State and in
pursuance of the directions of the Government that the lands should
not be kept in the names of the dead persons. The petitioner was also
given e-pass book for his 1/4th share. He is in physical possession and
enjoyment of the said lands since 1972 onwards and till date. The
official respondents have, un-signed the subject survey numbers in
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
Dharani Portal, without notice to him and his family members, in
contravention of Section 7 of the Telangana Rights In Land And
Pattadar Pass Books Act, (Act,9 of 2020) 2020 (for short, ‘the Act,
2020’) w.e.f.29.10.2020.
4. Respondent No.5 has gone in adoption to the family of
Kotapalli Kishan Rao and had got lands in Kotapalli Village. It is
settled legal position held by Three Judge Bench of this Court in
Anumolu Nageswara Rao v. AVRI Narasimha Rao [2023 (5) ALD
716 (TS)] that on adoption, a child ceases to be coparcener of family
of his birth and forgoes interest in ancestral property in family of his
birth. Respondent No.5 has suppressed the fact ab-initio in all the
proceedings and obtained fraudulent orders. The said proceedings are
nullity and non-est under law.
The actual heirs and legal
representatives i.e. natural brothers of respondent No.5 i.e., Mr.
Rajaram Rao and Mr. Ravinder Rao, have consistently gave their
statements before the Revenue authorities that subject lands were
allotted to the father of the petitioner i.e. Sri Manohar Rao, younger
brother of their father late Sri Vithal Rao and that after the death of
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
petitioner’s father, the said property devolved on the petitioner, his
brothers and sisters-in-law.
5. Pursuant to the common order dated 01.02.2022 in
W.P.Nos.6107 and 28211 of 2019, respondent No.5 got deleted names
of his father and brothers from the possession column. Respondent
No.5 got order dated 01.02.2022 by misleading the Court that the
subsequent action of the authorities pursuant to the order dated
20.06.2015 passed by Lokayukta are under challenge, which led to
miscarriage of justice.
6. On 15.03.2022, respondent No.5 herein filed a petition in
I.A. No.1 of 2022 to review the order dated 01.02.2022 in W.P.No.
6107 of 2019 and the same is pending. The matter is sub judice and
has not attained finality. Suppressing the pendency of said review
petition, respondent No.5 herein, filed two writ petitions and two
Contempt Cases i.e. (i) W.P. No. 19757 of 2022 filed with regard to
same subject matter but only against official respondents herein,
without making the unofficial respondents in the said W.P. Nos. 6107
and 28211 of 2019 as parties. This Court disposed of the said writ
petition vide order dated 03.04.2023 directing the Collector,
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
Vikarabad to conduct enquiry and pass reasoned orders after giving
notice to the unofficial respondents in W.P. Nos. 6107 and 28211 of
2019.
7. In the said W.P. No. 19757 of 2022, this Court was misled
by respondent No.5 that the orders in W.P. Nos. 6107 of 2019 and
28211 of 2019 have attained finality. This Court specifically recorded
the same in its orders. Thus, the said orders were fraudulent by
suppressing stage of the case.
8. Respondent No.5 also filed a writ petition in W.P.No.2155
of 2024 on 25.01.2024 assailing the order of the Collector, Vikarabad
District in File No. E2.724 of 2023 dated 13.12.2023 in compliance of
order in W.P.No.19757 of 2022, without mentioning about pendency
of Rev.I.A.No.1 of 2022 to review the orders in W.P.No.6107 of
2019. This Court granted status quo in W.P.No.2155 of 2024 vide
order dated 30.01.2024 and thereafter the same was extended. On
27.01.2024, he filed C.C.No.153 of 2024 in W.P.No.19757 of 2022
against the Collector, Vikarabad District without mentioning about the
pendency of the said review petition. He got orders in the said
C.C.No.153 2024 by suppressing the fact of filing of W.P.No.2155 of
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
2024. It was misrepresented to the Court that the petitioner is
intending to challenge the said rejection orders and addressed a letter
dated 22.02.2024 to the Registrar (Judicial) to the said effect.
9. As on 01.03.2024 and also on 22.02.2022,W.P.No.2155 was
already filed and was pending and the interim order were also in force,
as such, the question of the petitioner intending to challenge the said
rejection orders, did not arise.
10. On 05.03.2024, after two years from the date of the orders
dated 01.02.2022, respondent No.5 filed C.C.No.485 of 2024 against
the Collector, Vikarabad District wherein also the pendency of
Rev.I.A.No.1 of 2022 is not mentioned.
11. Common order is dated 01.02.2022. Review petition in
I.A.No.1 of 2022 in W.P.No.6107 of 2019 was filed on 15.03.2022.
As on the date of filing of C.C.No.485 of 2024 i.e. 05.03.2024, the
contempt case was prima facie, barred by limitation and was not
maintainable, being filed after two years from the date of common
order dated 01.02.2022 and in the interregnum period, respondent
No.5 submitted several applications through Mee Seva, for correction,
even after obtaining interim orders dated 30.01.2024. Therefore,
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
respondent No.5 and his counsel are repeatedly misleading the Court
and obtaining orders by playing fraud. The official respondents are
also sailing with respondent No.5 neglecting the status quo orders
dated 30.01.2024. It was misrepresented in C.C.No.485 of 2024 that
the Court gave liberty to the writ petitioner to file fresh contempt
against the orders in C.C.No.153 of 2024. In fact, the Court has not
granted any such liberty to file fresh contempt.
12. The official respondents deliberately disobeyed the orders
of this Court in W.P.No.2155 of 2024 and have deleted subject survey
numbers, from Dharani Portal and caused miscarriage of justice. Up to
17.04.2024, their names were there in Dharani Portal but on
23.04.2024, their names were unsigned without issuance of notice to
them. Entering the name of respondent No.5 clearly amounts to
tampering the record of rights. It is settled law that the fraudulent
orders can be assailed even in collateral proceedings.
13. In the common order dated 01.02.2022, the rights of
respondent No.5 are not confirmed. As per Section 7 of the Act,
2020, it empowers a person who acquires right by decree of a Court
and seeks to change the entries in Record of Rights by applying
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
through the website prescribed for this purpose. The order dated
01.02.2022 is not a decree to entitle respondent No.5 to seek any
changes in the admitted revenue records, as none is a decree holder
nor judgment debtor to entertain any application under Section 7 of
the Act, 2020. This Court in the said common order, held that the
Court is not intended to comment anything upon the revenue entries
which were existing prior to passing of the order by the Lokayukta
and therefore, the parties shall be free to take recourse to the legal
remedies available under the law.
14.
Respondent No.5 herein and his counsel with their
deliberate suppression of facts, misrepresentation, misleading
statements, adopting forum shopping and playing fraud upon the
Court, expanded the scope and filed multiple writ petitions, both prior
to 2019 and after 2019.
15. He has placed reliance on the principle laid down by the
Apex Court in S. P. Chegalvaraya Naidu (dead) by L.Rs. v.
Jagannath (Dead) by L.Rs1, State of A.P. v. T. Suryachandra
Rao2, Badami (deceased) by her L.R. v. Bhali3, Ramchandra
. (1994) 1 SCC 1
. (2005) 5 SCC 149
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
Singh v. Savitri Devi4, Bhaurao Dagdu Paralkar v. State of
Maharashtra5,
judgment
of
this
Court
in
Visweswara
Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. v. Telangana State Industrial Infrastructure Corporation Ltd, Hyderabad6 and the judgment of
erstwhile High Court of Andhra Pradesh in A.V. Papaya Sastry v.
Government of A.P7.
16. Respondent No.6 filed counter denying the claim of the
petitioner and contended that she and respondent No.8 are cultivating
their agricultural lands. They are all entitled to reliefs as heirs and
legal representatives of late Sri Manohar Rao. To protect their rights
over the properties covered under the writ petition, on 16.02.2022, she
complained to the official respondents including the CCLA, the Chief
Secretary and the Chief Minister to take action but the official
respondents did not entertain the said complaint. Due to change of
officials and the government in the State of Telangna, the revenue
officials in collusion with respondent No.5, tampered the revenue
records. The official respondents have no right to give away their
. (2012) 11 SCC 574
. (2003) 8 SCC 319
. (2005) 7 SCC 605
. 2023 (5) ALD 316 (DB)
. 2007 (6) ALD 68 (SC)
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
property, as they being registered holders and having e-pass books,
without issuing notice to them. They ignored her complaint dated
16.02.2022. There was no change in situations or circumstances from
16.02.2022 to mid-April, 2024.The sons of late Sri Vithal Rao, i.e.
Mr. Rajaram Rao @ Raju and Ravinder Rao @ Ravi, the real and
actual heirs and legal representatives, are not parties of the dispute till
this date. Respondent No.5 does not belong to their family having
gone in adoption.
17. The real and actual heirs of late Sri. Vithal Rao, admitted
the partition, allotment of share to her father-in-law and have already
given their sworn statements, declarations and letters, etc., in the
Police and Revenue Department as well as in Court, and also even
during making entries in Dharani portal about 6 or 7 years ago in the
revenue records updation undertaken by the Government of
Telangana. After due enquiry in Tahsildar Office, Revenue Divisional
Office, Collector Office, only, proceedings were issued to them and
their names were entered in the revenue records and e-pass books
were also issued in the year 2019 and they are getting Rythu Bandhu
too. They are raising crops in the subject property. As respondent
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
No.5 is not their family member, he is not connected with their
properties. He got lands in Kotapally Village. His claim is totally
based on collusion, fraud, cheating and manipulation of records.
Therefore, she seeks to grant the same relief as sought in the writ
petition.
18. Respondent Nos.9 to 11 filed counter denying the
allegations made by the petitioner and contended that originally, one
Sri Vittal Rao S/o Khande Rao is the actual owner and possessor of
the subject property, as per the revenue records. After demise of the
said Vittal Rao, the names of his legal representatives were mutated in
the revenue records vide proceedings dated B/424/2007, dated
17.03.2007 and the same was continued up to the year 2015.
Aggrieved by the above entries, husband of respondent No.9 i.e.,
respondent No.5 along with several others approached the Lokayukta
and obtained a common order dated 20.06.2015 in Complaint
Nos.2557/2011/B1 and 3, the names of the petitioner and respondent
Nos.6 to 8 herein were incorporated in revenue records duly removing
her husband/respondent No.5’s name from the revenue records.
Aggrieved by the revenue entries made in the revenue records
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
pursuant to the orders dated 20.06.2015, her husband filed
W.P.Nos.6107 and 28211 of 20189. This Court vide order dated
01.02.2022 set aside the order dated 20.06.2015 and all subsequent
orders/accused pursuant to the aforesaid order passed by the
Lokayukta.
Thereafter,
her
husband/respondent
No.5
filed
W.P.No.19757 of 2022 to restore the entries in the revenue records
relating to the subject property, in terms of common order dated
01.02.2022 in W.P.No.28211 and 6107 of 2019, and the same was
disposed of vide order dated 03.04.2023 directing respondent No.3
therein to consider the online application, issuance of e-pattadar
passbook, and pass orders strictly in accordance with law by putting
the petitioner and the unofficial respondents in W.P.Nos.28211 and
6107 of 2019 on notice and affording them an opportunity. Thereafter,
respondent No.5 filed C.C.No.485 of 2024 against the orders in
W.P.No.28211 of 2019. In compliance with the common orders dated
01.02.2022, the revenue authorities have processed the online
application of her husband and restored revenue entries prior to the
impugned Lokayukta order dated 20.06.2015. Pursuant to the said
orders, the District Collector, took up the matter on record and issued
notices to all the interested parties and passed order dated 13.12.2023
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
holding that there is dispute about partition of lands among family
members, the said court has no jurisdiction on civil disputes/family
disputes, and advised the parties to approach competent Court for
redressal of their dispute.
19. Aggrieved by the said order, respondent No.5 filed
W.P.No.2155 of 2024, wherein this Court passed interim order dated
30.01.2024 granting status quo and the petitioner herein and the
respondent Nos.6 to 8 were also parties to the said writ petition and all
of them have filed their counters in the said writ petition and the said
interim order was extended up to 12.03.2024, while that was so, the
respondent Nos.7 and 9 therein/respondent Nos.6 and 8 herein, have
filed contempt case vide C.C.No.1379 of 2024 against the status quo
order 30.01.2024 against the petitioner and respondent No.5, who
filed counter in the said CC. This Court vide order dated 25.08.2025
held that the Court is not inclined to entertain the contempt case and
closed the same. However, liberty was granted to the petitioner and
Mr. Manik Rao - respondent No.6 therein –party-in-person, to pursue
review application in W.P.No.6107 of 2019 and also in W.P.No.2155
of 2024.
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
20. The revenue authorities have corrected the entries, recorded
name of respondent No.5 and issued E-pattadar pass books in their
favour. While the subject matter is pending and subjudice before this
Court, the Petitioner has filed the present writ petition alleging that the
revenue authorities without issuing any prior notice to him, deleted his
name in revenue records. In fact, the revenue authorities have issued
notices to all the interested persons, called for enquiry and on
clarification of the subject land, passed order dated 13.12.2023 and the
petitioner and respondent No. 6 to 8 are well aware of the
proceedings.
21. While the matter stood thus, in view of closing of C.C.No.
1379 of 2024, dated 25.08.2025, respondent Nos.6 and 8 herein have
filed Letters Patent Appeal vide LPA. No. 15 of 2025 and on hearing,
the Division Bench of this Court, vide order dated 12.02.2026
dismissed the said LPA, holding that there is no deliberate attempt on
the part of respondent No.1 therein in flouting the order of the learned
Single Judge dated 30.01.2024, more so, there was no subsisting of
any interim order as on the date of restoration of entries i.e. on
08.07.2024. The learned Single Judge has considered all the issues in
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
a proper perspective and it does not require any interference. Liberty
is also granted to the parties to ventilate their grievances in the
pending proceedings before this Court. There is no status quo while
restoring entries in the revenue records and the revenue authorities
have also issued proceedings, dated 08.07.2024 for restoration of
entries and also issued pattadar passbooks to respondent No.5. Unless
and until there is no violation of the orders of the Court, there is a
clear title in favour of respondent No.5. The petitioner and respondent
Nos.6 to 8 though not have right and title over the subject land, filed
complaints before relevant authorities.
C.C.No.1435 of 2024:
22. This contempt case is filed by the petitioner alleging wilful
disobedience and gross violation of the orders dated 09.07.2024
passed in W.P.No.17839 of 2024 (present writ petition) by this Court
by the respondents herein/respondent Nos.2 and 4 in the writ petition.
Vide the aforesaid order, this Court directed the petitioner and
respondent Nos.2, 4, 5 to 8 to maintain status quo, with regard to the
entries in the revenue records in respect of the subject property, till
20.08.2024.
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
23. It is contended by the petitioner that the respondents herein
have violated the orders dated 09.07.2024 and entered the name of
respondent No.5 in respect of Sy.No.131 only on 11.07.2024. Even as
on 10.07.2024, night at 11.45 p.m., the status of entries in Dharani
Portal had shown both the survey numbers, as unsigned. On
11.07.2025, there was entry of name of respondent No.5 against the
Sy.No.131, leaving Sy.No.110. Thus, the respondents herein have
committed willful disobedience and gross violation of the order dated
09.07.2024.
24. Respondent No.2 filed counter, adverting to the averments
made by the petitioner and narrating the filing of various cases,
contending that the petitioner himself has also admitted in
W.P.No.17839 of 2024 that the revenue entries were already restored
by 09.07.2024, the date of interim order. Therefore, there is no
question of violation of said interim order. The interim order is dated
09.07.2024, dispatched on 12.07.2024 whereas the revenue entries
were restored on 08.07.2024. They came to know about the interim
order in W.P.No.17839 of 2024 after approval by the District
Collector on 08.07.2024 of online application filed by respondent
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
No.5. There is no violation much less willful violation of the orders of
the Court.
With the above submissions, he sought to close the
contempt.
25. In view of the aforesaid rival submissions, it is the specific
case of the petitioner that his father was allotted the subject lands in a
partition took place on 09.04.1972. Since then, his father was in
possession and enjoyment of the subject lands, his name was also
recorded in revenue records under possession column and was issued
pattadar passbook. In 1999-00 and 2001-02, the names of his father
and elder brother were deleted from possession column and the name
of father of respondent No.5 was incorporated by tampering the
records. The then VRO, Sri Bugga Rao, was also dismissed. The said
entries tampered were set aside by the RDO, Vikarabad in 2007.
However, finally the names of legal heirs of his father including
himself were incorporated in revenue records. Respondent No.5 went
in adoption and, therefore, he has no right, title or interest over the
subject lands as the moment when he went to adoption, he ceases to be
their family member. Challenging the entries of the father of the
petitioner and his elder brother made in revenue records, respondent
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
No.5 also approached the Revenue Authorities as well as before this
Court.
26. Perusal of record would reveal that Mr. Manohar Rao,
father of the petitioner, Mr. Vithal Rao, father of respondent No.5 and
Mr. Rama Rao are own brothers and are the sons of Kande Rao.
There was a partition said to have taken place among them on
09.04.1972. According to the petitioner, as per the said partition, the
subject lands were allotted to his father. Basing on the said partition,
the names of his father and his elder brother were recorded in revenue
records and since then they were in possession and enjoyment of the
same. Perusal of pahani patriks filed by the petitioner would disclose
the same.
27. The petitioner herein, respondent Nos.7 and 8 and the
husband of respondent No.6 are the sons of late Manohar Rao.
Respondent No.5, Mr. Raja Ram Rao and Mr. R. Ravinder Rao are the
sons of late R. Vittal Rao. During pendency of the present writ
petition, respondent No.5 died and his wife and children are brought
on record as respondent Nos.9 to 11.
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
28. It appears respondent No.5 and his 2 brothers gave a joint
affidavit before the Mandal Revenue Officer, Bantwaram Mandal, to
mutate their names in respect of the subject lands.
In the said
affidavit, they did not mention with regard to the partition said to have
taken place among his father, father of the petitioner and their uncle.
On the other hand, they requested the MRO to mutate their names in
respect of subject lands in the manner mentioned therein i.e.,
Sy.No.131, admeasuring Acs.14.27 guntas situated at Rompally
Village in favour of respondent No.5 herein, the land in Survey No.10
admeasuring Acs.2.20 guntas in favour of Mr. R. Raja Ram Rao and
the land in Survey No.110 admeasuring Acs.2.20 guntas in favour of
Mr. R. Ravinder Rao. Pursuant to the said joint affidavit, the then
Tahsildar granted succession mutating their names in the said manner,
vide order dated 17.03.2007 in Proceedings No.B/424/2007.
Challenging the same, the petitioner herein preferred an appeal before
the Revenue Divisional Officer, Vikarabad Division under Section - 5
(5) of ROR Act, 1971 in File No.C/1047/2007. Vide order dated
02.07.2007, the RDO set aside the said proceedings dated 17.03.2007,
directing the Tahsildar to consider the case afresh duly following the
procedure.
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
29. Thereafter, respondent No.8 made a representation dated
01.07.2010 to the Tahsildar, Bantwaram Mandal, with a request to
note down physical features, conduct enquiry as to who are in physical
possession of the subject lands and made entries to that effect in
revenue records. It appears that in the said enquiry, the other two
brothers of respondent No.5 i.e., Mr. R. Rajaram Rao and Mr. R.
Ravinder Rao gave sworn statements on 28.08.2010 before the
Tahsildar, Bantwaram Mandal in Case No.B/4273/2010. In the said
sworn statements, they deposed that the subject lands stood in the
name of their father as pattedar had fallen to the share of father of the
petitioner and the father of petitioner and husband of respondent No.6
were in actual, physical possession and enjoyment of the same.
Basing on the said sworn statements of brothers of respondent No.5,
vide order dated 15.12.2010 in proceedings No.B/6992/2010, the
Tahsildar while entering the names of other two brothers of
respondent No.5 in pattadar column, the names of petitioner and
respondent Nos.6, 7 and 8 were entered in cultivator/possessor
column.
30.
According to respondent No.5, while so, when the
petitioner herein and respondent Nos.6 to 8 are trying to interfere with
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
his peaceful possession and enjoyment, he filed a suit in O.S. No.135
of 2010 on the file of Junior Civil Judge, Vikarabad, seeking perpetual
injunction and obtained interim orders in I.A. No.323 of 2010.
Thereafter, the said interim order dated 16.07.2010 was modified to
that of status quo vide order dated 25.10.2010 in I.A. No.323 of 2010.
Assailing the said order dated 25.10.2010 in I.A. No.323 of 2010,
respondent No.5 herein preferred an appeal vide CMA No.30 of 2012.
Vide order dated 12.03.2013, learned Additional District Judge,
Vikarabad, dismissed the said appeal. Challenging the said order,
respondent No.5 herein filed a revision vide C.R.P. No.1828 of 2013
before this Court.
Vide order dated 13.06.2013, this Court also
dismissed the said revision.
31. While so, when the petitioner and his brothers are also
trying to mutate their names in revenue records, the revenue officials
revised the proceedings dated 04.02.2019 in file No.F/269/2016 and
pursuant to the same, the Tahsildar was proceeding to mutate the
names of petitioner and his brothers. Thereafter, respondent No.5
filed a writ petition in W.P. No.6107 of 2019 to declare the action of
respondent Nos.2 to 4 herein in incorporating the names of the
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
petitioner and respondent Nos.6 to 8 in the pahanies in respect of
subject
lands
pursuant
to
the
revised
proceedings
in
file
No.F/269/2016 dated 04.02.2019 even without waiting for outcome of
the judgment in O.S. No.135 of 2010 based on the adverse report
dated 26.02.2019 furnished by respondent No.2 as illegal. However,
the Revenue Officials issued latest pattadar passbooks-cum-title deeds
in favour of the petitioner and respondent Nos.6 to 8.
32. During pendency of the said writ petition, respondent No.5
came to know that the petitioner herein and his brothers approached
the Lokayukta and obtained an order dated 20.06.2015 in Complaint
No.2557/2011/B1 for issuance of pattadar passbooks and title deeds in
respect of the subject lands without making him as a party.
Challenging the said order passed by Lokayukta, respondent No.5 also
filed a writ petition in W.P. No.28211 of 2019 before this Court. Vide
common order dated 01.02.2022, a Division Bench of this Court
allowed both the writ petitions, setting aside the impugned order dated
20.06.2015 passed by Lokayukta. It was observed by the Division
Bench that W.P. No.6107 of 2019 was filed challenging the
subsequent action of authorities pursuant to the order dated
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
20.06.2015 passed by the Lokayukta and that since the said order of
the Lokayukta is set aside, all subsequent orders/actions pursuant to
the said order of Lokayukta are also set aside.
33. Thereafter, respondent No.5 made online application dated
22.12.2022 with a request to respondent No.2 herein, to correct the
wrong entries by deleting the entries in respect of the petitioner and
respondent Nos.6 to 8. As respondent No.2 did not take any action, he
filed another writ petition in W.P. No.19757 of 2022 against the
official respondents to declare their action in not restoring the entries
in revenue records in respect of the subject lands in terms of the
common order dated 01.02.2022 in W.P. Nos.28211 and 6107 of 2019
as illegal. Vide order dated 03.04.2023, this Court disposed of the said
writ petition directing respondent No.2 herein to consider the same in
accordance with law. Pursuant to the same, respondent No.2 herein
passed an order dated 13.12.2023, disallowing the aforesaid online
application dated 22.12.2022, wherein respondent No.2 observed that
the issue is family dispute about partition of lands among family
members. Therefore, he has no jurisdiction on civil disputes/family
disputes and accordingly advised both the parties to approach
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
competent Court for the redressal of their dispute. In view of the
same, the contempt case filed by respondent No.5 in C.C. No.153 of
2024 was closed on 01.03.2024. However, C.C. No.485 of 2024 filed
by respondent No.5 against the order dated 01.02.2022 in W.P.
No.485 of 2024 was also closed.
34. Challenging the said order dated 13.12.2023, respondent
filed one more writ petition in W.P. No.2155 of 2024, wherein vide
order dated 30.01.2024, this Court ordered to maintain status quo as
on that day with regard to the revenue entries in respect of the subject
lands and the same was extended on 20.02.2024.
While so,
respondent No.5 also made online application dated 14.06.2024 for
missing survey number/sub-division. Vide order dated 08.07.2024 in
file No.E2/724/2024, respondent No.2 passed the order restoring the
name of respondent No.5 recorded in revenue entries prior to the
impugned order passed by Lokayukta and accordingly considered the
said online application. However, it was observed that missing survey
number addition does not mean granting mutation in favour of anyone
as per his office orders dated 13.12.2023 the entry was kept in inactive
mode until further orders from the competent Court. While status quo
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
order was in force, the official respondents entered the name of
respondent No.5 by removing the names of family members of the
petitioner. Thereafter, respondent No.5 withdrew W.P. No.2155 of
2024 on 21.08.2024. However, as there was no clarity on what basis
the revenue entries have been changed and pattadar passbook was
issued in favour of respondent No.5, a review application vide I.A.
No.1 of 2022 in W.P. No.6107 of 2019 was filed and the same is
pending. Similarly, respondent Nos.6 and 8 filed a contempt case in
C.C. No.1379 of 2024 in W.P. No.2155 of 2024 against the official
respondents and respondent No.5 herein contending that they not only
willfully violated the orders dated 30.01.2024 passed by this Court in
W.P. No.2155 of 2024 but also suppressed the pendency of review
petition in I.A. No.1 of 2022 in W.P. No.6107 of 2019 dated
15.03.2022 before the Division Bench of this Court. Vide order dated
25.08.2025, this Court declined to entertain the contempt case and
accordingly closed the same. However, liberty was granted to the
parties to pursue review petition in W.P. No.6107 of 2019 and also in
W.P. No.2155 of 2024. Challenging the said order, respondent Nos.6
and 8 filed Letter Patent Appeal No.15 of 2025 before the Division
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
Bench. Vide order dated 12.02.2026, the Division Bench of this Court
dismissed the said LPA.
35. In view of the aforesaid discussion, it is clear that the
disputes between the parties, essentially concerns the title and the
alleged partition in respect of the subject lands. One set of family
members asserts that the subject lands fell to their share pursuant to a
partition said to have taken place long ago among their ancestors,
whereas the other set of family members disputes the same. It is also
apparent that, on account of the continuing dispute between the
parties, successive writ petitions have been filed before this Court.
The competent Revenue Authority, upon consideration of the rival
claims, has rightly observed that the disputed rights and title of the
parties cannot be conclusively determined in revenue proceedings and
that the parties ought to approach the competent Civil Court for
adjudication of their respective claims.
In the circumstances, the
disputed questions relating to title, partition, possession and
entitlement to the subject lands involve questions of fact and law
which require appreciation of evidence and cannot appropriately be
adjudicated in proceedings under Article - 226 of the Constitution of
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
India. The writ jurisdiction of this Court cannot be invoked for
determining disputed questions of title between rival private parties,
particularly when an efficacious remedy before the competent Civil
Court is available.
36. As far as contempt case is concerned, it is the case of the
petitioner that he filed the above writ petition to declare the action of
official respondents in deleting the subject lands without issuing prior
notice to the registered holders in the Record of Rights by
contravening principles of natural justice.
Vide order dated
09.07.2024, this Court passed the following order:
“Therefore the petitioner and respondent Nos.2, 4,
5 to 8 are directed to maintain status quo, with
regard to the entries in the revenue records in
respect of the land admeasuring Acs.14.27 gts., in
Sy.No.110 and 131 situated at Rompally Village,
Bantwaram
Mandal,
Vikarabad
District,
till
20.08.2024.”
Despite the aforesaid order passed by this Court, the official
respondents entered the name of respondent No.5 in writ petition in
respect of Survey No.131 only on 11.07.2024. Even as on 10.07.2024
night 11.45 P.M., the status of entries in Dharani Portal had shown
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
both the Survey numbers as unsigned/deleted only. But, only on
11.07.2024, the name of respondent No.5 was seen, that too in respect
of Survey No.131 only, leaving Survey No.110.
Thus, the
respondents in the contempt case willfully and deliberately disobeyed
the aforesaid status quo orders passed by this Court and, therefore,
they are liable to be punished.
37. Whereas, it is contended by the respondents that they came
to know about the aforesaid status quo order passed by this Court only
after approval of online application of respondent No.5 by respondent
No.2 in the writ petition vide proceedings dated 08.07.2024. Further,
the petitioner himself admitted that the revenue entries were already
restored by 09.07.2024. Thus, there is no violation of interim orders
passed by this Court as this Court passed the interim orders on
09.07.2024, dispatched the same on 12.07.2024, whereas the revenue
entries were restored on 08.07.2024.
38. However, having regard to the subsequent developments
and the nature of the disputes between the parties, this Court is of the
view that it would not be appropriate to continue the contempt
proceedings. The disputes between the parties are in respect of title,
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
taking place of partition and their entitlement over the subject lands.
One set of parties’ claims that the properties had fallen to their share
pursuant to an ancestral partition said to have taken place long ago,
while the other party dispute the same. The Revenue Authorities
themselves have taken the view that the rival claims with regard to
title and partition cannot be adjudicated in revenue proceedings and
that the parties have to approach the competent Civil Court. In such
circumstances, continuance of present contempt proceedings would, in
effect, requires this Court to examine and determine the very rights
which are yet to be adjudicated by the competent Civil Court. Such an
exercise would be beyond the legitimate scope of contempt
jurisdiction.
39. It is also well settled that, before a person can be held guilty
of civil contempt, the disobedience of the order of the Court must be
established to be deliberate and wilful. Contempt jurisdiction is
essentially concerned with ensuring compliance with the orders of the
Court and is not intended to adjudicate complicated questions of title
or to resolve substantive disputes between the parties. Where the
circumstances disclose a bona fide dispute as to the scope, effect or
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
applicability of the order, and the underlying rights of the parties
themselves remain to be adjudicated by the competent Civil Court, it
would not be appropriate to continue the proceedings merely on the
basis of an allegation of disobedience.
40.
In the present case, the subsequent order directing the
parties to work out their respective rights before the competent Civil
Court substantially alters the context in which the alleged violation is
required to be examined. The parties are required to establish their
respective claims before the competent Civil Court and the Revenue
Authorities are bound to act in accordance with the order or decree
that may ultimately be passed by the competent Civil Court. In view
of the above circumstances, and without expressing any opinion on
the merits of the rival claims or on the title to the subject lands, this
Court is of the considered view that no useful purpose would be
served by keeping the contempt proceedings pending. The contempt
case is accordingly dismissed. However, it is made clear that the
closure of the contempt case shall not be construed as an adjudication
or acceptance of the rights or claims of either party in respect of the
KL,J
W.P. No.17839 & CC No.1435 of 2024
subject properties. All such questions are left open to be decided by
the competent Civil Court.
41. In the light of the aforesaid discussion, the writ petition is
accordingly dismissed. However, the parties are at liberty to agitate
their respective claims and rights in respect of the subject lands before
the competent Civil Court, which shall adjudicate in accordance with
law, uninfluenced by any of the observations made herein. The
Revenue Authorities shall thereafter abide by and give effect to the
decree or order passed by the competent Civil Court, in accordance
with law. In view of the above, no adjudication of the disputed title or
partition rights is warranted in the present writ petition, and the parties
are relegated to the remedy of approaching the competent Civil Court
for appropriate relief. In the circumstances of the case, there shall be
no order as to costs.
As a sequel thereto, miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in
the Writ Petition and the Contempt Case shall stand closed.
3rd September, 2026
Mgr
_________________
K. LAKSHMAN, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review