Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:MLHC:397
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP (C) No.232 of 2019
Date of Hearing: 06.05.2025
Date of Decision: 16.05.2025
Shri. Manik Dhar
S/o (L) D.R. Dhar,
R/o Laki Tori Building
Keating Road, Shillong-793001
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya
….. Petitioner
-VERSUS1. Indian Overseas Bank, a body corporate and duly constituted
Under the banking companies (Acquisition & Transfer
of Undertaking) Act, 1970 having its central office at 763,
Anna Salai, Chennai-600002.
2. Branch Manager, Indian Overseas Bank, Shillong
Morellow Building, M.G. Road
Shillong -793001
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya
….. Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. K. Paul, Sr.Adv
Mr. S. Thapa, Adv
Mr. B. Snaitang, Adv
For the Respondent(s)
: Mrs. T. Yangi B, Sr.Adv
Ms. R. Gurung, Adv
Judgement and Order
This writ petition has been filed by the petitioner assailing the
2025:MLHC:397
impugned publication dated 19.06.2019 by the respondent Bank published
in the local dailies on 21.06.2019 whereby the name and photograph of the
petitioner was published declaring him as a ‘wilful defaulter’.
1.
The fact of the case, as can be derived from the materials on record
is that, in the year 2002, the petitioner had applied for credit facilities from
the respondent Bank under the fund-based account namely Term Loan and
working Capital Term Loan account with varying limits for setting up a
Brick Kiln Unit at Dharmanagar, Tripura. On 28.09.2002 the respondent
Bank sanctioned the credit facilities in favour of the petitioner on terms and
conditions contained in the sanction letter. The credit facilities granted
were enhanced from time to time by the respondent Bank. As the petitioner
failed to repay the respondent Bank, his loan account was classified as
Non-Performing Asset (NPA) on 01.07.2004. Thereafter, the respondent
Bank initiated recovery proceeding against the petitioner. In addition, the
respondent Bank vide publication dated 19.06.2019, published the name
and photograph of the petitioner in the local dailies on 21.06.2019
declaring him as a wilful defaulter. Being aggrieved by the publication
made by the respondent Bank, the petitioner has approached this Court by
way of this writ petition.
2.
Mr. K. Paul, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. S. Thapa,
learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that the impugned
publication was made by the respondent Bank by resorting to abuse of
power and in complete violation of the mandatory guidelines issued by the
Reserve Bank of India (RBI) vide Master Circular on Wilful Defaulters
dated 01.07.2015. He submits that the photograph of the petitioner could
not have been published by the respondent Bank by terming him as a wilful
defaulter without following the binding instructions laid down in clause
2.1.3 and clause 3 of the said guidelines. He submits that no show-cause
notice was issued to the petitioner and he was not afforded with any
2025:MLHC:397
opportunity by the respondent Bank before the impugned publication was
made. He contends that the guidelines dated 01.07.2015 of the RBI has
statutory force by virtue of provision of section 35A of The Banking
Regulation Act 1949 and the decision of the Apex Court reported in (2020)
10 SCC 274, Internet and Mobile Association of India vs. Reserve Bank of
India and hence, the respondent Bank could not have ignored the
guidelines while taking a decision on the impugned publication.
The
learned Senior counsel submits that there is a deliberate attempt by the
respondent Bank to mislead the Court inasmuch on the one hand, at para 12
of the affidavit-in-opposition, it is stated that notice was issued to the
petitioner but the same could not be retrieved or recovered, whereas on the
other hand, at para 18 it is affirmed that the statements made at para 12 are
true to the information derived from official records. He further contends
that failure of the respondent Bank to produce the related official record
despite the order of this court would go to show that no procedure as
mandated by the guideline dated 01.07.2015 was ever followed by the
respondent Bank in the matter and prays for quashing of the impugned
publication made by the respondent Bank.
3.
Ms. T. Yangi B, learned Senior counsel assisted by Ms. R. Gurung,
learned counsel appearing for the respondents, submits that the petitioner is
a habitual defaulter in the payment of outstanding dues in his Loan
Account and the loan became a Non-Performing Asset (NPA). She submits
that since a publication has been made terming the petitioner as a wilful
defaulter, there is a presumption that all the necessary procedures were
followed before the publication was made. She further submits that inspite
of sincere efforts, the related official record could not be placed before this
Court and prays for taking of a lenient view of the matter considering the
fact that the respondent Bank is a large establishment having number of
branches throughout the country and the difficulty in maintaining large
2025:MLHC:397
number of files in proper order. She further submits that no vested right of
the petitioner has been violated by the respondent Bank and there is no
occurrence of any miscarriage of justice to the petitioner. She submits that
there is no merit in the writ petition and the same deserves to be dismissed.
4.
Before embarking into the factual aspect of this case, it is
imperative to take notice of section 35A of the Banking Regulation of 1949
which lays down as under: “[35A. Power of the Reserve Bank to give directions. - (1)
Where the Reserve Bank is satisfied that(a) in the [public interest]; or
[(aa) in the interest of banking policy; or]
(b) to prevent the affairs of any banking company being
conducted in a manner detrimental to the interests of the
depositors or in a manner prejudicial to the interests of the
banking company; or
(c) to secure the proper management of any banking company
generally,
It is necessary to issue directions to banking companies generally or
to any banking company in particular, it may, from time to time,
issue such directions as it deems fit, and the banking companies or
the banking company, as the case may be, shall be bound to comply
with such directions.
(2) …..”
5.
Further, the Apex Court in the case of Internet and Mobile
Association of India (supra), at para 150 observed: “150. Law is well settled that when RBI exercises the powers
conferred upon it, both to frame a policy and to issue directions for
its enforcement, such directions become supplemental to the Act
itself. In Peerless General Finance & Investment Co.Ltd. v. RBI, this
Court followed the decisions in State of U.P. v. Babu Ram Upadhya
and D.K.V. Prasada Rao v. State of A.P. to hold that Rules made
under a statute must be treated as if they were contained in the Act
and that therefore they must be governed by the same principles as
the statute itself. Useful reference can also be made in this regard to
the following observations in ICICI Bank Ltd. v. Official Liquidator:
(SCCp. 25, Para 40)
“40. When a delegate is empowered by Parliament to enact a policy
and to issue directions which have a statutory force and when the
delegate (RBI) issues such guidelines (policy) having statutory force,
such guidelines have got to be read as supplement to the provisions
2025:MLHC:397
of the BR Act, 1949. The “banking policy” is enunciated by RBI.
Such policy cannot be said to be ultra vires the Act.”
(emphasis supplied)”
6.
It emerges from above that where the RBI is satisfied that it is
necessary to issue directions to banking companies generally or to any
banking company in particular, it may, from time to time, issue such
directions or guidelines as it deems fit and the banking companies are
bound to comply with such directions. It is also clear that when the RBI
issues such directions or guidelines, it must be treated as if they were
contained in the Act and therefore, must be governed by the same
principles as a statute itself. Such directions or guidelines have got to be
read as supplement to the provisions of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949.
It is, therefore, apparent that the guidelines dated 01.07.2015 has a binding
effect requiring strict adherence by the banks and financial institutions
functioning under the supervision and control of the RBI.
7.
In the present case, the petitioner in his writ petition has asserted
that the impugned publication dated 19.06.2019 published by the
respondent Bank in the local dailies on 21.06.2019 classifying the
petitioner as a wilful defaulter was made in total contravention of the
guidelines issued vide the Master Circular on Wilful Defaulters dated
01.07.2015 containing mandatory instructions on matters relating to wilful
defaulters. The petitioner also contended that no show cause notice was
ever issued to him and he was not given any opportunity by the respondent
Bank before the impugned publication was made in the local dailies.
8.
The respondent Bank in its affidavit-in-opposition has not made any
specific disclosure as to the initiation of any process in terms of the Master
Circular on Wilful Defaulters dated 01.07.2015 against the petitioner in
relation to the impugned publication terming the petitioner as a wilful
defaulter. There is no mention of any date and place of initiation of any
such process and the designation of the official authority of the respondent
2025:MLHC:397
Bank who initiated the process. The averments made in the affidavit-inopposition is entirely centered around the fact that the petitioner had taken
a huge amount of loan from the respondent bank and has defaulted in
repaying the loan amount. There is only one statement at paragraph 12 of
the affidavit in opposition in so far as the question of adherence to the
guidelines dated 01.07.2015 is concerned. The relevant statement reads as
follows: “12. ……… It is denied that the respondent Bank has not
complied with the mandatory RBI guidelines as alleged. In fact, the
Respondent Bank through its Head Office in Chennai has issued
notice to the petitioner in this regard some time back, as per the
RBI Guidelines but unfortunately the same could not be retrieved
or recovered. ………”
9.
As pointed out by the learned Senior counsel for the petitioner, the
statement of affirmation made at paragraph 18 of the affidavit in opposition
discloses that the statements made at paragraph 12 of the affidavit in
opposition are made on the basis of the information derived from official
record. Thus, it becomes difficult for this court to comprehend as to how a
statement with regard to issuance of notice to the petitioner was made in
the affidavit-in-opposition on the basis of official record when the very
notice was not traceable in the record and that the deponent had no personal
knowledge of the same. Hence, the very statement is questionable and not
worthy of acceptance by this court.
10.
Perusal of the guidelines issued vide Master Circular on Wilful
Defaulters dated 01.07.2015 indicates that the same was formulated to put
in place a system to disseminate credit information pertaining to wilful
defaulters for cautioning banks and financial institutions so as to ensure
that further bank finance is not made available to them. Clause 2.1.2
thereof defines the term ‘unit’ to include individuals besides other entities
mentioned therein. Clause 2.1.3 lays down the events when a ‘wilful
default’ would be deemed to have occurred. The clause reads hereunder: Page 6 of 10
2025:MLHC:397
“2.1.3 Wilful Default: A ‘wilful default’ would be deemed to have
occurred if any of the following events is noted:
(a) The unit has defaulted in meeting its payment/repayment
obligations to the lender even when it has a capacity to honour the
said obligations.
(b) The unit has defaulted in meeting its payment/repayment
obligations to the lender and has not utilized the finance from the
lender for the specific purposes for which finance was availed of
but has diverted the funds for other purposes.
(c) The unit has defaulted in meeting its payment/repayment
obligations to the lender and has siphoned off the funds so that the
funds have not been utilized for the specific purpose for which
finance was availed of, nor are the funds available with the unit in
the form of other assets.
(d) The unit has defaulted in meeting its payment/repayment
obligations to the lender and has also disposed off or removed the
movable fixed assets or immovable property given for the purpose
of securing a term loan without the knowledge of the bank/lender.
The identification of the wilful default should be made keeping in
view the track record of the borrowers and should not be decided on
the basis of isolated transactions/incidents. The default to be
categorized as wilful must be intentional, deliberate and calculated.”
In the instant matter, nothing has been brought into the record of
this court to show that the petitioner has defaulted to discharge his
obligation of repayment inspite of having the capacity to honor the said
obligation. There is also no material to show that the default in payment
was because of the fact that the petitioner has not utilized the loan amount
for the specific purpose for which loan was availed of but has diverted the
funds for other purposes. No finding has been recorded by the respondent
Bank that the petitioner has defaulted in repayment and siphoned of the
funds so that funds have not been utilized for the specific purpose for
which finance was availed of, nor are the funds available with the petitioner
in the form of other assets. Further, there is no assertion that the default of
payment by the petitioner was for the reason that he has disposed of or
removed the movable fixed assets or immovable property given for the
2025:MLHC:397
purpose of securing the loan without knowledge of the respondent Bank.
Moreover, no supporting material was placed before this Court by the
respondent Bank to project that the identification of the petitioner as a
wilful defaulter was made keeping in view his track record and that the
petitioner defaulted in repayment intentionally and deliberately in a
calculated manner. Hence, there remains no iota of doubt that the
respondent Bank has not followed the procedure prescribed in the
guidelines dated 01.07.2015.
11.
Clause 2.5 of the guidelines dated 01.07.2015 lays down procedure
for initiation of panel measures by the bank and financial institutions
against the wilful defaulters identified as per the definition of paragraph
2.1.3 of the guidelines. Clause 3 stipulates mechanism for identification of
wilful defaulters. The relevant portions of clause 3 of the guidelines reads
as follows: “3. Mechanism for identification of Wilful Defaulters.
The mechanism referred to in paragraph 2.5 above should generally
include the following:
(a)
The evidence of wilful default on the part of the borrowing
company and its promoter/whole-time director at the relevant time
should be examined by a Committee headed by an Executive
Director or equivalent and consisting of two other senior officers of
the rank GM/DGM.
(b) If the committee concludes that an event of wilful default has
occurred, it shall issue a Show Cause Notice to the concerned
borrower and the promoter/whole-time director and call for their
submissions and after considering their submissions issue an order
recording the fact of wilful default and the reasons for the same. An
opportunity should be given to the borrower and the
promoter/whole-time director for a personal hearing if the
committee feels such an opportunity is necessary.
(c)
The Order of Committee should be reviewed by another
committee headed by the Chairman/Chairman & Managing
Director or the Managing Director & Chief Executive
Officer/CEOs and consisting, in addition, to two independent
directors/ non-executive directors of the bank and the Order shall
become final only after it is confirmed by the said Review
Committee. However, if the identification Committee does not pass
2025:MLHC:397
an Order declaring a borrower as a wilful defaulter, then the
Review Committee need not be set up to review such decisions.
(d) ………
(e) ………..”
There is no averment in the affidavit-in-opposition of the
respondent Bank that any committee headed by an Executive Director or
equivalent and consisting of two other senior officers of the rank of
GM/DGM was ever constituted in accordance with sub-clause (a) of Clause
3 of the guidelines and that a review committee was formed in terms of
sub-clause (c) of Clause 3 thereof to look into the matter of wilful default
pertaining to the petitioner.
12.
During the proceeding of this writ petition, by order dated
19.08.2024 the respondent Bank was directed to produce the related official
record of the matter. After availing extension of time on many occasions
for production of the official record, a submission was made on behalf of
the respondent Bank on 08.04.2025 that the record could not be traced and
the matter may proceed for hearing without the production of the official
record. The aforesaid fact, coupled with the averment made in the affidavitin-opposition at paragraph 12, is sufficient for this court to infer that the
respondent Bank had never initiated any process in terms of the guidelines
dated 01.07.2015 to identify the petitioner as a wilful defaulter before the
impugned publication was made.
13.
For what has been discussed above, this writ petition succeeds. The
impugned publication dated 19.06.2019 by the respondent Bank published
in the local dailies on 21.06.2019 is set aside and quashed. Looking at the
manner in which the respondent Bank has handled the entire matter, the
petitioner is found entitled to some costs. Accordingly, the respondent
Bank is directed to pay an amount of Rs.30,000/- as cost of litigation to the
petitioner within a period of 1 (one) month. It is made clear that the
observations and findings made above are specific to the issue of
2025:MLHC:397
identification of the petitioner as a wilful defaulter and will not have any
bearing on the merits of the recovery proceedings initiated by the
respondent Bank against the petitioner.
14.
The writ petition stands allowed in the aforesaid terms.
Judge
Meghalaya
16.05.2025
“Shrity,PS”
CH MOMIN
Date: 2025.05.16 15:48:09 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review