Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction)
Crl. A. No. 04 of 2020
Mani Kumar Rai @ Tere Naam
Upper Wok,
South Sikkim,
at present State Central Prisons,
Rongyek, East Sikkim
…
Appellant
…
Respondent
Versus
State of Sikkim.
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUP KUMAR GOSWAMI, CJ.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, J.
For the appellant :
Ms. Gita Bista, Advocate (Legal Aid Counsel)
For the respondent:
Dr. Doma T. Bhutia, Public Prosecutor, Sikkim
Date of hearing
:
09.10.2020
Date of judgment :
09.11.2020
JUDGMENT
(Arup Kumar Goswami, CJ)
This appeal is directed against the judgement dated 28.11.2019
passed by the learned Sessions Judge, South, Namchi in S.T Case
No.05/2017
convicting the appellant under Section 302 IPC and sentencing
him to suffer imprisonment for life and to pay a fine of Rs.10,000/-. By the
judgement under appeal, compensation of Rs.50,000/- was also directed to
be paid to the wife of the deceased under Sikkim Compensation to Victims or
his Dependants Scheme, 2016 by the Sikkim State legal Service Authority.
2.
On 15.06.2017, Kinga T. Bhutia (PW-25), who at the relevant point
of time was posted as Station House Officer (SHO), Jorethang Police Station
(P.S), registered Jorethang P.S U.D case No.07/2017 under Section 174
Crl. A. No.04 of 2020
(Mani Kumar Rai vs State of Sikkim)
Cr.P.C on the basis of a complaint made by Kharga Maya Manger (PW-13),
Ward Panchayat, Upper Wok to the effect that one Krishna Prasad Rai was
found lying dead with face downwards at Forest Area, Upper Wok and he
endorsed the U.D Case to Sub-Inspector Prashant Rai (PW-20). PW-20 had
proceeded to the place of occurrence (P.O) and had started investigation.
However, as it was about 09.00 pm, being dark, no further investigation
could be carried out on that day. P.O was cordoned-off and inquest was
conducted over the dead body of the deceased on the morning of
16.06.2017 in presence of Kharka Maya Manger (PW-13) and Mani Kumar
Subba. Inquest Report (Exhibit-5) was prepared indicating the injuries
noticed. A rough sketch map (Exhibit-17) was drawn. Blood stains found in
the kutcha foot path and some items found near the P.O were seized vide
Exhibit-16 in presence of Prakash Manger (PW-15) and Dhan Bahadur Rai
(PW-18). After inquest was done, PW-20 forwarded the dead body for postmortem examination, initially to District Hospital Namchi and later on, to
STNM Hospital Gangtok because of non-availability of Medico Legal Specialist
at District Hospital, Namchi. Post-mortem on the deceased was conducted
on 16.06.2017 by Dr. O.T Lepcha (PW-09) and Medico Legal Autopsy Report
(Exhibit-10) was prepared by him and he had also handed over to the
Investigating Officer (I) clothing (ii) blood in filter paper (iii) hair and (iv)
nail clippings of the deceased to the Investigating Officer.
3.
Coming to the conclusion that cause of death of Krishna Prasad Rai
was unnatural and homicidal, an FIR (Exhibit-18) was lodged by PW-20
before the SHO, Jorethang P.S stating the above facts. Accordingly,
Jorethang P.S case No.30/2017 under Section 302 IPC was registered
against unknown persons and the case was endorsed to Jigmee W. Bhutia
(PW-24). PW-20 handed over the seized articles and the related documents
to SHO, Jorethang P.S and charge of investigation was taken over by PW-24.
Crl. A. No.04 of 2020
(Mani Kumar Rai vs State of Sikkim)
He examined witnesses and based on the revelations made the appellant
was arrested vide Exhibit-31 on 16.06.2017 at 06.50 p.m.
4.
After arrest, the accused was examined under Police custody on
16.06.2017 by Dr. Anand Subba (PW-7), the Medical Officer of Jorethang
PHC. No injury was noticed on his body by him and he had prepared a
Medical Report (Exhibit-8). Accused was also taken to Namchi District
Hospital on 21.06.2017 for psychiatric evaluation and one Dr. C.L Pradhan
(PW-6), who examined him, found no past or present history of mental
illness and he noted that the accused had given a history of alcohol addiction
for the past 15 years. On 22.06.2017, the accused was brought to Jorethang
CHC and his blood sample was collected in presence of Om Prakash Gupta
(PW-8), who had gone there for his own treatment and Rinku Rai (PW-19),
who had gone for treatment of his ailing son.
5.
Based on a statement, stated to be a Disclosure Statement (Exhibit-
25) made by the accused under Section 27 of the Evidence Act in presence
of Rajesh Sarkar (PW-21) and Pravesh Lohagan (PW-22), the weapon of
offence, a khukuri (a kind of knife), was seized by PW-24 on 18.06.2017
under Seizure Memo (Exhibit-22). Certain items like vests, etc., details of
which will be noted in a subsequent part of the judgment, were also seized
by him in presence of PW-21 and PW-22. On 17.06.2017, the Sr.
Superintendent of Police had passed an order transferring investigation of
the case with immediate effect to PW-25 and thereafter, on 20.06.2017, PW24 handed over papers and documents of the case to PW-25, who then took
charge of investigation. On 25.07.2017, PW-25 forwarded the case exhibits
to RFSL Kolkata for forensic expert opinion and analysis (Exhibit-39) and on
the basis of his application dated 31.07.2017, statement of Sarika Rai (PW12) and Himalaya Rai (PW-13) and Laxuman Thapa (PW-14) were recorded
by the Magistrate under Section 164 Cr.P.C.
Crl. A. No.04 of 2020
(Mani Kumar Rai vs State of Sikkim)
6.
On completion of investigation, PW-25 had submitted a Charge
Sheet on 06.09.2017. After receipt of RFSL report dated 17.09.2017, he had
also submitted a supplementary charge sheet.
7.
In
the
Court
of
learned
Sessions
Judge,
South,
S.T
Case
No.05/2017 was registered. On consideration of materials on record, charge
was framed against the appellant under Section 302 IPC. The same being
read over and explained to the appellant, he pleaded not guilty and claimed
to be tried.
8.
During trial, prosecution examined 25 witnesses and after closure of
the evidence of the prosecution, statement of the accused was recorded
under Section 313 Cr.P.C where he had taken a plea of denial. However, no
witness was examined on his behalf.
9.
The learned Sessions Judge opined that the circumstantial evidence
produced by the prosecution in the form of evidence of PW-1, PW-9, PW-10,
PW-11, PW-12, Pw-14, PW-19 and PW-21 unerringly pointed out that it was
the accused who had committed the crime with pre-mediation, intention and
knowledge. The learned Trial Court noted that the evidence of PW-11, PW12 and PW-14 proved that the deceased and the accused were with them at
a labour camp in the evening of the day before the discovery of the body of
the deceased. It was also recorded that it is proved by PW-21 that accused
had confessed in his presence as well as in the presence of PW-24 and
another witness that he had stabbed the deceased with his khukuri (MO-VI).
Reliance was also placed on the
Disclosure Statement (Exhibit-25).
Accordingly, the learned Trial Court held that the offence punishable under
Section 302 IPC was established against the appellant beyond reasonable
doubt.
10.
Ms. Gita Bista, learned Legal Aid Counsel appearing for the
appellant submits that the learned Trial Court was not correct in holding that
Crl. A. No.04 of 2020
(Mani Kumar Rai vs State of Sikkim)
evidence on record clearly proved that it was the accused who had killed the
deceased. She submits that the evidence of PW-1 and PW-10, upon which
much reliance was placed by the learned Trial Court, suffers from gross
contradictions. She submits that according to PW-5 dead body was first
noticed by Suresh Chettri but he was not examined without any explanation.
Similarly, Bari, in whose residence the accused was working as a helper was
not examined. Such non-examination of material witnesses casts doubt
about the prosecution case, she contends. It is submitted that approximate
time of death of the deceased was also not indicated in the Autopsy Report,
Exhibit-10 and therefore, in any view of the matter, last seen theory sought
to be projected by the prosecution has no legs to stand. It is submitted by
her that though in the remarks column of Exhibit-22, the Seizure Memo, it
is indicated that one khukuri was recovered from the kitchen of the accused
as per his Disclosure Statement recorded under Section 27 of the Evidence
Act, such recovery is belied by the evidence of PW-22 and therefore, no
reliance can be placed on the said so-called Discovery Statement, more so,
when it was impossible for the accused to have pointed out the place where
the khukuri was kept as the hands of the appellant was tied from behind by
a rope. She has placed reliance on the judgment in the case of Pulkuri
Kotayya and others vs. The King Emperor, reported in AIR 1947 PC
67.
11.
Dr.Doma T. Bhutia, learned Public Prosecutor submits that evidence
of PW-1 and PW-10 goes to show that the appellant had made an ominous
statement two days before the deceased was found dead that they would
have to observe religious rites and the evidence of PW-1 further goes to
show that the appellant had stated before her that he would eliminate a
person who had annoyed him. Such utterances, as the events unfolded, are
pointer to the fact that the appellant was contemplating to murder the
deceased, she submits. It is contended by her that the evidence of PW-3,
Crl. A. No.04 of 2020
(Mani Kumar Rai vs State of Sikkim)
PW-4, PW-11, PW-12 and PW-14 establishes beyond reasonable doubt that
the accused was in the company of the deceased before his death. She
asserts discovery of khukuri (MO-VI) at the instance of the accused is firmly
established on the evidence on record and therefore, the learned Trial Court
was justified in convicting the appellant. She has placed reliance on the
judgements in the cases of Sahoo vs State of U.P reported in AIR 1963
SC 40, Himachal Pradesh Administration vs. Om Prakash, reported in
AIR 1972 SC 975, Kishore Bhadke vs. State of Maharashtra, reported
in AIR 2017 SC 279 and Gajoo vs. State of Uttarakhand, reported in
2012 (9) SCC 532.
12.
We have considered the submissions of the learned Counsel for the
parties and have examined the materials on record.
13.
That the deceased had died a homicidal death is not in dispute. PW-
9, who conducted autopsy, had found the following ante-mortem injuries on
the deceased:
“1. Incised chop wound
(16 x4cms x spinal cord over the right
side of neck). The death of the cut was more over the right side.
2. Chop wound (19x4x3cms placed 4 cm below the left earlobe).
3. Reddish abraded contusion (6x3 cms over the left temple).
4. Abraded contusion (3x2 cms over the right forehead).”
According to him, the cause of death was due to hypovolaemic
shock as a result of incision of the carotid artery due to chop wound, which
is homicidal in nature.
14.
Evidence of PW-1, who is the sister of the deceased, goes to show
that the deceased had left for his work at a work site on 14.06.2017 but he
did not return home and in the morning of 15.06.2017 at 08:00 am the
accused had come to their house searching for the wife of the deceased, PW6
Crl. A. No.04 of 2020
(Mani Kumar Rai vs State of Sikkim)
10, who was then in the kitchen. According to her, the accused told PW-10
in her presence, the English translation of which is something to the effect
that after about two days, the family members would have to observe
“Chhak Barnu” (death rites). On being asked by him she called her brother
thrice but his mobile was switched off and then the accused started
laughing. On being asked the accused told her that he had met her missing
brother the previous day but he had returned home and slept. It is stated by
her that three days prior to the aforesaid visit, the accused had also visited
their house and had told her that a man had made him angry and he would
eliminate him in seven days. She stated that on 15.06.2017 the dead body
of her brother was recovered about 100 feet above their house. It is to be
noted that in her statement under section 164 Cr.P.C (Exhibibt-1) recorded
on 04.08.2017, she had stated in similar lines.
In cross-examination, however, she admitted that she was not
present in the kitchen but was present in another room adjacent to the
kitchen.
15.
PW-10, the wife of the deceased, had stated in her evidence that
the accused had told PW-1 that they have to observe death rituals in two
days. According to her, the accused failed to notice her as she was in the
extreme corner of the kitchen and she had heard the accused asking PW-1
about her whereabouts. She stated that as the accused and her husband
used to be together on previous occasions, PW-1 had asked the accused the
whereabouts of her husband and as stated by PW-1, she also deposed that
PW-1 had made telephone calls but the phone was found to be switched off.
PW-10, in her statement under Section 164 Cr.P.C (Exhibit-12), had given
the same version.
16.
PW-2 stated that the accused used to work in her household as a
domestic helper earlier and the deceased used to go to his house taking the
Crl. A. No.04 of 2020
(Mani Kumar Rai vs State of Sikkim)
foot path in front of her house. She stated that on his last visit to her house
the deceased was accompanied by four friends from Rabangla but the
accused was not with them though, subsequently, the accused had come
and left after some time.
17.
PW-3, who is a petty contractor, deposed that the deceased was
working as a petty contractor at a different site under a different contractor.
The evidence of PW-3 is to the effect that on 14.06.2017 he had met and
talked with the deceased, who is also known as Dilay. He had gone to the
house of one Bari (Aunt) and the accused had also come there after about 5
minutes. He did not know where the deceased had gone and was also not
aware after how much time the accused had left the house of Bari.
In his cross-examination, he stated that the accused used to stay in
the house of Bari.
18.
PW-4 is also a petty contractor who had taken the work of
construction of a retaining wall of a newly constructed road along with PW-3,
PW-16 and three others. He deposed that all of them used to go to the
house of Bari for tea/milk after work. The deceased was also a petty
contractor in respect of a different site one kilometre away and his labour
camp was on the way to the house of Bari. On 14.06.2017, the deceased
had accompanied him to the house of Bari and on being asked to return a
measuring tape which he had taken earlier, the deceased had left the house
of Bari but he did know where the deceased had gone. He deposed that after
about 5-6 minutes the accused came to the house of Bari and had left again
after 5 minutes.
He also deposed in cross-examination that the accused was staying
in the house of Bari.
19.
PW-5 deposed that on 14.06.2017, at about 2.00-3.00 pm, he had
received a call from Prakash Rai, brother of the deceased, informing him
Crl. A. No.04 of 2020
(Mani Kumar Rai vs State of Sikkim)
about the recovery of the dead body of his brother and requesting him to
accompany Jorethang police to the P.O as he resided in Jorethang. According
to him, he had reached the P.O on his own as the police had already left. He
had remained in the P.O with police the whole night and he was a witness to
Inquest Report, Exhibit-5. He stated that he came to learn at the P.O that
one Suraj Chettri, who was residing with the family, had seen some blood
stains on the foot path and he discovered the dead body after following the
trail of blood stains.
20.
PW-11 stated that he had taken a contract along with PW-12 and
deceased from PW-14 for construction of a retaining wall of a new road and
while he and PW-12 used to stay in the labour shed, the deceased used to
work from his house which is located at a distance of 20 minutes. On the
relevant day at around 04.30 to 5.00 pm, PW-14 had brought some meat
and liquor and at around 05.30 pm, the accused had come and had some
food. After 15-20 minutes of the deceased having left the shed, the accused
had also left. Thereafter, they had taken meal and had gone to the house of
the accused, where there were four other labourers also. While he along with
PW-12 went inside, PW-14 left for his house. But neither the accused nor the
deceased was present in the house of the accused. On the evening of the
following day they learnt from Bari, the owner of the house where the
accused used to reside during the relevant time, that the deceased died as a
result of a fall from a height.
21.
In cross-examination, PW-11 stated that in the kitchen of Bari they
used to play carrom and charge mobile phones. There are two houses and a
separate kitchen of Bari and an old man used to reside in the wooden house
where the accused also resided. He stated that the house of the deceased
was located below the house of the accused and house of PW-14 is located
below the house of deceased and all of them have to take the same road to
Crl. A. No.04 of 2020
(Mani Kumar Rai vs State of Sikkim)
go to their respective houses. He stated that PW-14 had left the shed after
the deceased had left.
22.
PW-12 deposed in similar lines as PW-11. He further stated that
when he had reached the house of Bari, neither the deceased nor the
accused was present there. He also deposed that PW-14 had left the house
by the same route after the deceased had left for his house.
23.
As noted earlier, PW-13 is a witness to the Inquest Report (Exhibit-
5). According to her, on 14.06.2017, in the afternoon some boys of the
village and Sukbir Rai, father of the deceased, had informed her regarding
recovery of the dead body of the deceased.
24.
PW-14 is a contractor who had hired the deceased, PW-11 and PW-
12. According to him, on 14.06.2017 he had snacks with PW-11, PW-12 and
the deceased and they were joined by the accused later on. When some
workers from another work site came, the deceased left with them. When
requested to stay for dinner he said that he would come back again.
Immediately after the deceased had left the accused also left and proceeded
in the same direction in which the deceased had gone. They waited for the
deceased till 08.30 pm but since he did not come they had dinner and then
had left for their respective homes.
He stated in his cross-examination that he left for his house at around
09.00 pm. While PW-11 and PW-12 stated that after around 15-20 minutes
of the deceased having left the shed the accused also left, PW 14 stated the
accused had left almost immediately.
25.
PW-16 had come to work with his brother about 6-7 months ago. His
evidence does not throw any light on the prosecution case and his crossexamination was declined.
Crl. A. No.04 of 2020
(Mani Kumar Rai vs State of Sikkim)
26.
PW-17 is a cook and he had come for a short visit to join his uncle
who is a petty contractor. Name of the uncle is, however, not indicated. His
evidence does not throw any light and therefore, his cross-examination also
declined.
27.
PW-21 deposed that in the month of June 2017 there was a fight
between the accused and deceased at Wok Chemchey and that he had
confessed in his presence as well as in presence of PW-24 and another
witness that he had stabbed the deceased with his khukuri which was carried
by him and that he had also stated that he can show the place where he had
kept the weapon of offence. Accordingly, he along with another witness and
PW-24, accompanied by the accused, had gone to the house of the accused
where he used to live and on reaching there the accused pointed out the
place in the kitchen where he had kept the khukuri. Accordingly, the khukuri
was recovered and seized and he had affixed his signature in the Seizure
Memo (Exhibit-22). He had identified the khukuri. He had also stated that on
search being made in the house of the accused the police recovered the
blood stained clothes of the accused, i.e. blue coloured track paint, cream
coloured vest, orange coloured vest, bed cover, pillow covers under Seizure
Memo (Exhibit-23) to which he was a witness. He also identified the material
objects seized vide Exhibit-23. He stated that after the Disclosure Statement
(Exhibit-25) was recorded, they had recovered materials objects including
the khukuri.
In cross-examination he admitted that when the accused was taken to
P.O his hand was tied with rope from behind.
28.
PW-22 had also accompanied PW-24 and PW-21 along with the
accused to the house of the accused. He stated that the accused showed
them the weapon of offence which was kept by him above the „chulha‟ inside
Crl. A. No.04 of 2020
(Mani Kumar Rai vs State of Sikkim)
the kitchen. He was also witness to Exhibit-22 and Exhibit-23. He had also
identified the material objects seized by the Police.
In cross-examination he stated that he went to Jorethang Police
station to stand as witness on being called by his brother-in-law. He stated
that PW-24 and his brother-in-law had told him that the accused had killed a
boy. He stated that Exhibit-25 was prepared after completion of search and
seizure and that he had signed in Exhibit-25 after the recovery of alleged
weapon of offence at Chemchey. He stated that the hand of the accused was
tied with a rope when he was taken to his residence. He also stated that
accused used to stay in the house as a helper.
29.
PW-23 is a Junior Scientific Officer working in the Central Forensic
Science Laboratory, Kolkata. On the basis of result of examination of
specimen, it was concluded by her as follows:
“1.The human blood stains present on exhibit B2/MO-XI
(vest) belongs to Mr. Mani kumar Rai.
2.The human blood stains present on exhibit D/MO-XXIII(Blood
stained mud),exhibit G/MO-XIX (coll)(Nail clipping) and exhibit
H/MO-XXI (coll.)(Hair) belongs to the deceased.
3.Human blood present on exhibit B5/MO-XII(Quilt cover) is
from another male individual.
4.The genetic profile could not be developed from exhibit A/MOVI,
B1/MO-IX,
B3/MO-X,
B4/MO-XIV
and
E/MO-XXV.
But
presence of 'XY' peak shows male individual(s).”
30.
From the conclusion as indicated above, it appears that blood of the
deceased was not detected in any of the aforesaid items belonging to the
accused. Though blood stain of the accused is found in Exhibit-B2/MO-11, it
is to be noticed that when the accused was examined on 16.06.2017 by PW12
Crl. A. No.04 of 2020
(Mani Kumar Rai vs State of Sikkim)
7, no injury was detected on his body and therefore, blood-stain in ExhibitB2/MO-11 is not of any consequence.
31.
In Sharad Birdhichand Sarda vs. State of Maharashtra,
reported in (1984) 4 SCC 116, the following observations were made:
“153. A close analysis of this decision would show that the
following conditions must be fulfilled before a case against an
accused can be said to be fully established:
(1) the circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is to be
drawn should be fully established.
It may be noted here that this Court indicated that the
circumstances concerned “must or should” and not “may be”
established. There is not only a grammatical but a legal
distinction between “may be proved” and “must be or should be
proved” as was held by this Court in Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade v.
State of Maharashtra [(1973) 2 SCC 793 : 1973 SCC (Cri) 1033
: 1973 Crl LJ 1783] where the observations were made: [SCC
para 19, p. 807: SCC (Cri) p. 1047]
“Certainly, it is a primary principle that the accused must be and
not merely may be guilty before a court can convict and the
mental distance between „may be‟ and „must be‟ is long and
divides vague conjectures from sure conclusions.”
(2) the facts so established should be consistent only with the
hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is to say, they should
not be explainable on any other hypothesis except that the
accused is guilty,
(3) the circumstances should be of a conclusive nature and
tendency,
Crl. A. No.04 of 2020
(Mani Kumar Rai vs State of Sikkim)
(4) they should exclude every possible hypothesis except the
one to be proved, and
(5) there must be a chain of evidence so complete as not to
leave any reasonable ground for the conclusion consistent with
the innocence of the accused and must show that in all human
probability the act must have been done by the accused.”
32.
The evidence adduced by the prosecution is circumstantial in
nature with no direct proof of the perpetration of the alleged offence by the
appellant. It is no longer res integra that circumstantial evidence if is to form
the basis of conviction must be such so as to rule out every possible
hypothesis of innocence of the accused and must without any element of
doubt unerringly point to such culpability.
33.
A careful analysis of the evidence of PW-3, PW-4, PW-11, PW-12 and
PW-14 would indicate that though at some point of time along with them the
deceased and the accused were present, their evidence does not even
remotely suggest that both of them were seen together alone in the evening
of 14.06.2017 or any point of time thereafter. The accused leaving them
after the deceased had left cannot lead to an inference that the accused had
followed the deceased, more so, when there is contradiction with regard to
time that had separated their respective departures. While PW-11 and PW12 had stated that the accused left after 15-20 minutes of departure of the
deceased, PW-14 stated that the accused had left almost immediately.
Having regard to the evidence on record, the theory of “last seen together”
as an incriminating factor qua the appellant is, thus, of no avail to the
prosecution.
34.
PW-3, PW-4, PW-11, PW-12 and PW-14 had not deposed that
there was any fight or ill feeling between the deceased and the accused.
They were most likely persons who could have known if there was a fight
Crl. A. No.04 of 2020
(Mani Kumar Rai vs State of Sikkim)
between the accused and the deceased. However, PW-21 referred to a fight
without amplifying whether he had witnessed the fight. He did not depose
that he was at Chemchey on the day when there was a fight. PW-21 is a
resident of Jorethang and distance between Jorethang and the P.O. is 38
kms. Even PW-1 and PW-10 did not say that there was enmity between the
accused and deceased. Therefore, in absence of any corroboration we are
not inclined to place any reliance with regard to the fight as deposed by PW21, who, for reasons not known, was called to the Police Station to stand
witness by PW-24.
35.
The Disclosure Statement, Exhibit-25, reads as follows.
“This is my true statement that on 14/06/2017 at evening time
at
around 07.30, there had been an argument between me and
Krishna Prasad Rai just below my house. I took out the
„khukhuri‟ (knife) that had been strapped on my waist and
attacked Krishna Prasad Rai on his neck. That „‟khukhuri‟ (knife)
I have kept in a corner of the wooden kitchen, which is just
beside my house; and I can show the place where I have kept
the „khukhuri‟ (knife).”
36.
In the celebrated decision of Pulukuri Kottaya (supra), the scope
and ambit of Section 27 of the Evidence Act had been stated and the
relevant portion of the same is extracted herein below:
“it is fallacious to treat the "fact discovered" within the section as
equivalent to the object produced; the fact discovered embraces the
place from which the object is produced and the knowledge of the
accused as to this, and the information given must relate distinctly
to this fact. Information as to past user, or the past history, of the
object produced is not related to its discovery in the setting in which
it is discovered. Information supplied by a person in custody that "I
Crl. A. No.04 of 2020
(Mani Kumar Rai vs State of Sikkim)
will produce a knife concealed in the roof of my house" does not lead
to the discovery of a knife; knives were discovered many years ago.
It leads to the discovery of the fact that a knife is concealed in the
house of the informant to his knowledge; and if the knife is proved
to have been used in the commission of the offence, the fact
discovered is very relevant. But if to the statement the words be
added "with which I stabbed A", these words are inadmissible since
they do not relate to the discovery of the knife in the house of the
informant.”
37.
in
The Apex Court in Anter Singh vs. State of Rajasthan, reported
(2004) 10 SCC 657, summed up various requirements of Section 27 of
Evidence Act as follows: “(1) The fact of which evidence is sought to be given must be
relevant to the issue. It must be borne in mind that the provision
has nothing to do with the question of relevancy. The relevancy of
the
fact
discovered
must
be
established
according
to
the
prescriptions relating to relevancy of other evidence connecting it
with the crime in order to make the fact discovered admissible. (2)
The fact must have been discovered. (3) The discovery must have
been in consequence of some information received from the accused
and not by the accused's own act. (4) The person giving the
information must be accused of any offence. (5) He must be in the
custody of a police officer. (6) The discovery of a fact in
consequence of information received from an accused in custody
must be deposed to. (7) Thereupon only that portion of the
information which relates distinctly or strictly to the fact discovered
can be proved. The rest is inadmissible.”
Crl. A. No.04 of 2020
(Mani Kumar Rai vs State of Sikkim)
38.
The policy underlying Section 25 and 26 of the Evidence Act is to
make it a substantive rule of law that confession whenever and wherever
made to the police or while in the custody of the police to any person
whosoever, unless made in the immediate presence of a Magistrate shall be
presumed to have been obtained under the circumstances mentioned in
Section 24 and therefore, inadmissible, except so far as provided by Section
27 of the Act. Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act is based on the view
that if a fact is actually discovered in consequence of information given,
some guarantee is afforded thereby that the information was true, and
accordingly can be safely allowed to be given in evidence.
39.
The only portion of the Disclosure Statement which is admissible
under Section 27 of the Evidence Act is the statement of appellant that he
had kept the “khukuri” in the corner of the kitchen, which is beside his house
and he can show the place where he had kept the “khukuri”. The rest of the
Disclosure Statement is inadmissible, being confessional and prohibited by
Section 25 and 26 of the Evidence Act.
40.
The Disclosure Statement, Exhibit-25, which is reduced to in the
form of a Memorandum shows that the place of Memorandum is Jorethang
Police Station and the time shown as 11.20 am. Under the heading „details
of further Memorandum‟, at Sl. No. 8 ,recording the time as 3.40 pm, it is
stated that as per the Disclosure Statement recorded under Section 27 of
the Evidence Act, one khukuri, with description indicated therein, was
recovered from the wooden kitchen of the accused. In the Seizure List
(Exhibit-22) also time was shown as 3.40 pm of 18.06.2017. In Sl. No. 13 of
Exhibit-22, under the heading „remarks of Investigating Officer‟, it is noted
that the seized exhibit i.e. the khukuri was disclosed and recovered as per
the Disclosure Statement recorded under Section 27 of the Evidence Act.
However, evidence of PW-22 goes to show that Exhibit-25 was prepared
after completion of search and seizure which negates that recovery was
Crl. A. No.04 of 2020
(Mani Kumar Rai vs State of Sikkim)
made after recording of Disclosure Statement. It is also seen from the
evidence of PW-22 that he had signed in Exhibit-25 after recovery of the
alleged weapon of offence at Chemchey, though the Memorandum was
written at Jorethang Police Station. Evidence of PW-22 casts a serious doubt
about the Disclosure Statement and the alleged discovery of the khukuri. It
is also surprising that two witnesses had been taken by PW-24 to a distance
of 38 kms, as if there would be no witness available there. It is also to be
noted that genetic profile could not be detected from Exhibit-A, the khukuri.
41.
PW-3, PW-4 and PW-11 had all stated that the accused was staying
in the house of Bari. The accused in his statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C
stated that the khukuri belongs to his landlady (Bari) and that the police
took out the khukuri of his landlady from the kitchen. It is to be stated that
khukuri is a very common household implement in these areas. It is
surprising that Bari was not even cited as a witness in the Charge-Sheet.
PW-3, PW-4, PW-7, PW-10, PW-11, PW-12 and PW-14 have all referred to
regularly going to the house of Bari. It appears that PW-2 is the daughter-inlaw of Bari‟, whose name is Nar Maya Mangar. PW-2 deposed that the
accused used to work in her house as domestic help and after he had left
their house, he had started working as a labourer. From her evidence it does
not appear whether she was residing with the Bari or living separately. In
the circumstances of the case, it is also very surprising that Suraj Chettri,
who had discovered the dead body was not examined as a witness.
42.
In Gajoo (supra), the Hon‟ble Supreme Court had observed that
while in case of defective investigation the Court has to be circumspect while
evaluating the evidence it would not be right in acquitting an accused person
solely on account of defect as to do so would tantamount to playing into the
hands of the investigating officer if the investigation is designedly defective.
Crl. A. No.04 of 2020
(Mani Kumar Rai vs State of Sikkim)
43.
In Sahoo (supra), the Hon‟ble Supreme Court had held that a
confessional soliloquy is a direct piece of evidence and Dr. Doma T. Bhutia,
sought to contend that the statement made by the accused as deposed by
PW-1 and PW-10 fall into the category of a confessional soliloquy. We are
unable to accept the aforesaid contention. There is a serious contradiction in
the evidence of PW-1 and PW-10. While PW-1 stated that the statement was
made to PW-10, PW-10, on the contrary, stated that accused was talking to
PW-1 and the accused had not even noticed her. It is not possible to
reconcile such a contradiction. It is also established that PW-1 and PW-10
were not in the same room. Furthermore, it is also noticed that PW-1 and
PW-10 did not refer to any conversation between them consequent upon the
statement allegedly made by the accused that they have to perform death
ritual which would have been the normal course of conduct if the statement
was really alarming.
Moreover, the statement, even if accepted on face
value, is not an admission of guilt.
44.
In Omprakash (supra), the Hon‟ble Supreme Court had observed
that benefit of doubt to which the accused is entitled is reasonable doubt —
the doubt which rational thinking men will reasonably, honestly and
conscientiously entertain. It is further held that it does not mean that the
evidence must be so strong as to exclude even a remote possibility that the
accused could not have committed the crime. If that were so the law would
fail to protect society as in no case such a possibility can be excluded .It will
give room for fanciful conjectures or untenable doubts and will result in
deflecting the course of justice if not thwarting it altogether. The mere fact
that there is only a remote possibility in favour of the accused is itself
sufficient to establish the case beyond reasonable doubt.
45.
On due appreciation of the evidence on record, we are of the opinion
that that the prosecution has not been able to establish the guilt of the
Crl. A. No.04 of 2020
(Mani Kumar Rai vs State of Sikkim)
accused beyond reasonable doubt and in the given facts and circumstances
of the case, the appellant is entitled to benefit of doubt.
46.
Resultantly, the appeal is allowed. The impugned conviction and
sentence is set aside. The appellant is set at liberty.
47.
Lower Court record be sent back.
(Bhaskar Raj Pradhan)
Judge
(Arup Kumar Goswami)
Chief Justice
Jk/Avi
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review