Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:910
Serial No.02
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C). No. 344 of 2024
Date of Decision: 14.10.2024
Manaksia Aluminium Company Limited,
Represented by Mr. Anand Kumar Chaudhary,
Sr. Manager, 8/1, Lal Bazar Street,
Bikaner Building, Third Floor,
Kolkata -700001.
…Petitioner
-Versus1.
The State of Meghalaya, Represented by
The Chief Secretary to the Government of
Meghalaya, Shillong- 793001.
2.
The Secretary to the Government of
Meghalaya, Housing Department,
Government of Meghalaya,
Shillong – 793001.
3.
The Director, Directorate of Housing,
Housing Department, Government of
Meghalaya, Shillong – 793001.
…Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Applicant(s) :
Mr. Philemon Nongbri, Adv.
Mr. R.Pahsyntiew, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. N.D.Chullai, AAG with
Mr. E.R.Chyne, GA.
:
2024:MLHC:910
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
As the matter is of some urgency, this writ petition even though an
affidavit on behalf of the State respondents is not yet on record, the same is
being disposed of today itself as the last date for submission of bids is
fixed on 15-10-2024 at 2 PM.
2.
The writ petitioner which is a registered company being aggrieved
with the impugned Notice Inviting Quotation (NIQ) dated 10-09-2024,
calling for bids for supply of Aluminum Roofing Sheets on the ground that
the general terms and conditions as contained in the NIQ have limited the
bidding to local entrepreneurs only is before this Court assailing the same.
3.
Mr. Philemon Nongbri, learned counsel for the petitioner has
submitted that the NIQ at clauses 1, 3, 6, and 13 has prescribed conditions
wherein clause 1 restricts the bidders to local entrepreneurs having their
manufacturing units in the State of Meghalaya, clauses 3 and 6 that all
quotationers be registered with the Meghalaya Industrial and Investment
2024:MLHC:910
Promotion Policy, 2024 and clause 13 that non-tribal quotationers, should
furnish Trading license from the concerned District Council, which he
contends has restricted eligible firms such as the petitioner from
participating, thereby denying reasonable opportunity, which is in violation
of Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. It is further submitted that
the respondents in the NIQ have inserted these conditions which are
arbitrary and discriminatory and the same is not in line with the earlier
quotations in the past years for the same product, inasmuch as, in clause 3
of the financial bid, it has been stated that the provision of clause 8 (i) of
the Meghalaya Procurement Preference Policy for Micro and Small
Enterprises, 2020 shall apply, and that the decision of the tender committee
will be final, whereas the said item i.e. Aluminum Roofing Sheets is not a
reserved item only for MSME bidders as per the website of the Ministry of
Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises.
4.
Learned counsel submits that the tender conditions being offensive
and discriminatory and in violation of Article 14, the instant case is a fit
case for interference by this Court in exercise of powers under Article 226
of the Constitution of India. In support of his contentions, the learned
counsel has placed reliance on the judgment of Union of India & Ors. vs.
Hindustan Development Corporation & Ors. reported in (1993) 3 SCC
2024:MLHC:910
499, to impress upon the point that in the matter of awarding contracts,
inviting tenders is considered to be one of the fair ways and that any
reservations or restrictions should not be arbitrary and must be justifiable.
5.
Mr. N.D.Chullai, learned AAG assisted by Mr. E.R.Chyne, learned
GA in the course of proceedings on 01-10-2024, had produced a
corrigendum dated 30-09-2024, whereby he had submitted that the terms
of the tender especially at clause 1 had been relaxed to include all bonafide
citizens of India and changed to bidders preferably having their
manufacturing units in the State of Meghalaya, which has thus removed
the offending clauses. He has further submitted that the clauses as framed,
were in furtherance and in line with the Meghalaya Industrial and
Investment Promotion Policy, 2024 to specifically encourage investment
and to create employment within the State of Meghalaya. In this context,
he submits that the MIIPP Policy, 2024 had been put in place by the State
Government, as a strategic unified framework to draw investments and the
policy is aligned with the Govt. of India’s Uttar Poorva Transformative
Industrialization Scheme (UNNATI), 2024, which is designed to
strengthen the Industrial Eco-System in the Northeast and attract New
Investment.
6.
Learned AAG then submits that the issuance of the tender is purely
within the purview and discretion of the State respondents, and that the
2024:MLHC:910
conditions therein are based on the local requirements keeping in mind the
cause of local manufacturers as per policy. He further submits that the
tender conditions cannot be said to be arbitrary and that the petitioner is at
liberty to submit its bids which will be duly considered by the Tender
Committee. Judicial review, he contends, in the instant case is not
warranted as a tenderer cannot challenge a tender clause which might not
suit him and that the authority floating the tender is the best judge of the
requirements. In support of his arguments, the learned AAG has cited the
following decisions:
(i)
Directorate of Education & Ors. vs. Educomp Datamatics
Ltd. & Ors. (2004) 4 SCC 19.
(ii)
N.G.Projects Limited vs. Vinod Kumar Jain & Ors (2022) 6
SCC 127.
(iii)
Airport Authority of India vs. Centre for Aviation Policy,
Safety & Research (CAPSR) & Ors. (2022) SCC Online SC
1334.
(iv)
V.P.Enterprises vs. Karnataka Institute of Medical Sciences
WP No. 105292 of 2024.
(v)
Manjeet Plastic Industries vs. State of Jharkhand & Ors.
W.P.(C) No. 3857 of 2024.
7.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2024:MLHC:910
8.
The pointed challenge of the writ petitioner company which is stated
to be having its manufacturing facilities at Kolkata, is with the
requirements given in the tender clauses especially at clauses 1, 3, 6 and
13. The said clauses of the NIQ as it was originally published on 10-092024 are reproduced hereinunder for the sake of convenience:
“1. Local
Entrepreneur(s)
representing
industries/Units who are Reputed Manufacturers of
Aluminium Roofing Sheets having their manufacturer
Units/Industries in the state of Meghalaya and having
ISO 9001, 14001, 45001 Certification to maintain
standard and quality, can participate for this quotation.
The quotationer for supply of Aluminium Roofing
Sheets should have a valid GSTIN.
(3) Every quotationer should furnish the company/
firm’s name, registered no. on MIIPP, full postal
address along with contact details and email id. Letter
sent by email by the Department to the address
mentioned by the quotationer shall be deemed to have
been received by the quotationer. Any change of details
provided shall be duly informed to the Department in
time.
(6) All Quotationer should furnish a valid
registration certificate registered under “Invest
Meghalaya” (as per Meghalaya Industrial and
Investment Promotion Policy 2024).
(13) The Non-Tribals quotationer should furnish the
Trading
license
from
concerned
District
Council/Income Tax Clearance certificate for the past
3(Three) years along with the tender papers documents
mentioned herein.”
2024:MLHC:910
9.
On the matter appearing before this Court, the State respondents had
by a corrigendum dated 30-09-2024, then amended the original clauses in
the NIQ firstly from bonafide resident of Meghalaya to bonafide citizens
of India, and from having manufacturing units in the State of Meghalaya to
preferably having their manufacturing units in the State of Meghalaya.
Other clauses which were also subject to change was the removal of clause
A (3) and clause B (12) which had initially in the NIQ, required the bidder
to furnish the Company Firm’s name, registration number on MIIPP and
Licensing under Factories Act, 1948 within the State of Meghalaya. The
last date for submission of bids was also postponed to 15-10-2024.
10.
In this backdrop, and on the allegation that the tender conditions
inspite of the amendments still breached Article 14 which called for
judicial review, this Court is to examine as to whether the said impugned
conditions as prescribed in the NIQ, fail the test of relevant factors that are
to be taken into consideration. The purpose and scope of this examination
or scrutiny therefore, will be limited only to ascertain and to discern if
there is any arbitrariness, irrationality, unreasonableness, bias and mala
fides, present in the tender process to warrant interference.
2024:MLHC:910
11.
First in the considered view of this Court, it is important to note that
the State of Meghalaya launched the MIIPP, a policy document in the year
2024 itself, which was made with the stated objective to foster economic
and human capital growth and to harness the State’s optimum potential.
The policy document contains the policy roadmap, framework, policy
enablers, implementation, apart from covering other areas under different
heads. A holistic perusal of the MIIPP 2024 document, reflects that the
policy was designed to provide advantages to investors, to streamline
administrative processes and to consolidate multifaceted initiatives under a
single platform to promote economic development and employment
opportunities in the State. The policy itself at clause 2.5.3 provides for the
manner of registration of units which would make them eligible to avail of
incentives/subsidies/ reimbursements and has classified the manufacturing
and service enterprises therein. As such, it is noted that this policy was
framed with the deemed objective for the economic development of the
State.
12.
Coming to the impugned general terms and conditions given in the
NIQ, as quoted above, initially the bidding was restricted to local
entrepreneurs representing Industries/Units who are reputed manufacturers
of aluminum roofing sheets limited to bonafide residents of Meghalaya.
This was subsequently changed to include entrepreneurs who are bonafide
2024:MLHC:910
citizens of India representing Industries/Units under the provision of the
Company/Partnership Act, the MIIPP, 2024, preferably having their
manufacturing Units/Industries in the State of Meghalaya duly registered
under the Factories Act. After these amendments, the petitioner however
still harboured grave reservations with regard to the necessity of
registration under the MIIPP, and it was argued that registration was not
possible without a bidder having manufacturing facilities in the State of
Meghalaya, which effectively made the petitioner an ineligible bidder.
13.
Though on the first blush, the contention of the writ petitioner
seemed valid, as the stipulated conditions in the NIQ appeared to have
restricted the field of bidding to only the registered manufacturers under
the MIIPP, however this Court cannot lose sight of the fact that the same
had been occasioned, in furtherance of and in pursuance to the adoption of
the policy by the State Government, in a matter concerning tender
specifications and award of contracts, which is in the realm of commercial
transactions. It is settled law that the scope of judicial review in such
matters is very limited, and as held by the Supreme Court of India in
Airport Authorities of India vs. Centre for Aviation Policy (supra) which
followed the decision rendered in Michigan Rubber (India Limited) at
para 30 thereof, which is extracted herein below, certain principles have
been enunciated.
2024:MLHC:910
“30. In the case of Michigan Rubber (India) Ltd.
(Supra), after considering the law on the judicial
scrutiny with respect to tender conditions, ultimately it
is concluded in paragraph 23 as under:
23. From the above
principles emerge:
decisions,
the
following
(a) The basic requirement of Article 14 is fairness in
action by the State, and non-arbitrariness in essence
and substance is the heartbeat of fair play. These
actions are amenable to the judicial review only to the
extent that the State must act validly for a discernible
reason and not whimsically for any ulterior purpose. If
the State acts within the bounds of reasonableness, it
would be legitimate to take into consideration the
national priorities;
(b) Fixation of a value of the tender is entirely
within the purview of the executive and the courts
hardly have any role to play in this process except for
striking down such action of the executive as is proved
to be arbitrary or unreasonable. If the Government acts
in conformity with certain healthy standards and norms
such as awarding of contracts by inviting tenders, in
those circumstances, the interference by courts is very
limited;
(c) In the matter of formulating conditions of a
tender document and awarding a contract, greater
latitude is required to be conceded to the State
authorities unless the action of the tendering authority
is found to be malicious and a misuse of its statutory
powers, interference by courts is not warranted;
(d) Certain preconditions or qualifications for
tenders have to be laid down to ensure that the
contractor has the capacity and the resource to
successfully execute the work; and
2024:MLHC:910
(e) If the State or its instrumentalities act
reasonably, fairly and in public interest in awarding
contract, here again, interference by court is very
restrictive since no person can claim a fundamental
right to carry on business with the Government.”
14.
In the series of judgments which have been cited by the learned
AAG, and other judgments, similar views have been expressed especially
on the point that the Courts must realise that the authority floating the
tender, is the best judge of its requirements and that merely because the
Court feels that some other terms would have been more preferable, would
not make it open to interference. In the instant case, the NIQ though
having been amended and notwithstanding the fact, that reservations and
restrictions still existed with regard to the necessity of registrations of units
under the MIIPP, the said clause being founded on the basis of the stated
Government policy, that is for promotion of the economic environment in
the State of Meghalaya, the said restriction is therefore justifiable and
cannot be held to be arbitrary or discriminatory.
15.
The other contentions raised as to the product not being under the
list of items reserved for purchase from Micro and Small Enterprises is not
significant to vitiate the tender process in any manner, as there is no
restriction in the manner of procurement by the authorities of products not
listed in the said list. Further, the contention with regard to the Trading
2024:MLHC:910
license is not relevant for consideration as the same is a consequential
factor on the bidder being eligible or awarded with the contract.
16.
As such, as discussed and for the reasons aforementioned, no
interference is called for and the writ petition is dismissed.
Judge
SAMANTHA ANNA LIYA
RYNJAH
Date: 2024.10.14 18:31:38 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review