Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:5598]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No.17213/2025
1.
Managing Director, Chokhi Dhani, Raj Bhawan Road, Civil
Lines, Jaipur through Shri Mahendra Singh S/o Shri
Charan Singh, Area Manager, Chokhi Dhani Group, Jaipur.
2.
Regional Manager, Chokhi Dhani, 12 Meal, Sanganer,
Jaipur through Shri Mahendra Singh S/o Shri Charan
Singh, Area Manager, Chokhi Dhani Group, Jaipur.
----Petitioners
Versus
Shri Kailash Chand Jogi S/o Shri Shankar Lal Jogi, resident of
Gram Shri Ram Kinagta (correct address Gram Shri Ram Ki
Nangal), Tehsil Sanganer, District Jaipur through Shri Kunal
Rawat Labour Advisor, Jaipur.
----Respondent
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Manoj Goyal
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANAND SHARMA
Order
06/02/2026
1.
Petitioner has filed the instant writ petiton challenging
award dated 22.11.2024 passed by Labour Court No.1, Jaipur,
whereby
reference
in
relation
to
validity
and
propriety
of
termination of respondent-workman w.e.f. 19.04.2006 has been
answered against the petitioners-employer and while holding the
termination to be illegal, compensation of Rs.3,00,000/- has been
awarded to the respondent-workman.
2.
It is stated that the respondent-workman initiated
industrial dispute under the provisions of Industrial Disputes Act,
1947 (for short, 'the Act of 1947') stating therein that he was
(2 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JP:5598]
[CW-17213/2025]
engaged as 'waiter' with the petitioners-employer on 14.02.2002,
however, without making compliance of mandatory provisions of
the Act of 1947, his services were terminated vide oral order
dated 19.04.2006. As no conciliation could take place before the
Conciliation Officer, therefore, failure report was submitted to the
appropriate
government
and
ultimately,
the
appropriate
government referred the matter for adjudication to the Labour
Court.
3.
While submitting statement of claim, the respondent-
workman impleaded Managing Director and Regional Manager of
Chokhi Dhani, Jaipur, as employer/industrial institutions and
submitted
that
the
respondent-workman
had
worked
from
14.02.2002 to 18.04.2006 as 'waiter'. It was submitted that
without making compliance of provision of Section 25F of the Act
of 1947 and without giving any notice or conducting any enquiry
or without even making payment of any compensation, services of
the petitioner were terminated by oral termination order dated
19.04.2006. It was submitted that the respondent-workman had
worked for more than 240 days just immediately preceding 240
days from the date of termination, therefore, the termination
order being contrary to law be held illegal and directions for
reinstatement along with all consequential benefits be given.
4.
Reply to the statement of claim was filed by the
petitioner mentioning therein that the workman has not indicated
as to whether he was employed with non-claimant No.1 or 2 and
since he was never employed with the petitioner, therefore, there
was no question of any termination or making compliance of
provisions of the Act of 1947.
(3 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JP:5598]
5.
Thereafter,
the
[CW-17213/2025]
respondent-workman
submitted
his
affidavit in evidence and repeated the contentions made in the
statement of claim. He was cross-examined by the employer,
however, no suggestion whatsoever was given during the crossexamination that the respondent-workman has never worked with
the petitioner.
6.
In counter, affidavit of Mr. Mahendra Singh, Area
Manager, Chokhi Dhani Group, Jaipur, was submitted to negate the
claim of the respondent-workman. During his cross-examination it
was admitted by the witness Mr. Mahendra Singh that entire
record such as entry register, payment vouchers, muster roll,
attendance register, documents with regard to EPF & ESI are duly
maintained
by
the
petitioners,
however,
on
the
date
of
examination in Court such record was not available with him and
he assured that on directions of the Court such record could be
produced by him.
7.
Thereupon,
an
application
was
submitted
by
the
respondent-workman seeking directions to the petitioners to
produce the record. Such application was allowed by the learned
Labour Court vide order dated 23.04.2015. Despite directions,
since the record was not produced. Instead thereof, an affidavit
was filed that the record was since relating to the year 2006,
hence, being quite old record it was not preserved by the
petitioners.
8.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that non-
production of the record and such affidavit filed by the petitioners
was taken as non-compliance by the learned Labour Court and
quite erroneously an adverse inference was drawn. Merely by
(4 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JP:5598]
[CW-17213/2025]
drawing adverse inference, it was presumed that the respondentworkman had worked with the petitioners and only on the basis of
surmises and conjunctures perverse finding has been given that
his services were terminated in violation of provisions of the Act of
1947 and liability of compensation of Rs.3,00,000/- has been
illegally fastened upon the petitioners.
9.
Learned counsel for the petitioners while assailing the
award submits that the award is totally against the facts of the
case, material on record and law prevailing at the relevant time.
10.
Learned counsel for the petitioners relies upon Section
13A of the Payment of Wages Act, 1936 (for short, 'the Act of
1936'), to contend that employer is under an obligation to
preserve the record only for a period of three years and not
thereafter.
11.
Learned counsel for the petitioners also relies upon the
judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of R.M. Yellatti
vs. Asstt. Executive Engineer reported in 2006 (1) SCC 106
to contend that it was the primary duty of the workman to prove
his statement of claim and mere non-production of record cannot
be a ground to accept the plea of the workman.
12.
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and perused
the record.
13.
It is not disputed that immediately after termination of
services
w.e.f.
18.04.2006,
the
respondent-workman
raised
industrial dispute, which was ultimately referred vide reference
dated 09.1.2007 to the learned Labour Court for adjudication.
14.
This Court examined the statements given by the
employer's witness Mr. Mahendra Singh, who admitted that record
(5 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JP:5598]
[CW-17213/2025]
was although available, yet on the date of examination he did not
bring the same with him and on directions, the same can be
produced. Thereupon, application for summoning the record was
filed by the workman, which was allowed. Admittedly, record was
not produced and thereafter affidavit of some other person Ms.
Sanchi Gupta was filed stating therein that since the record was
old, therefore, it was not preserved and maintained.
15.
Thus, it is clear that self-contradictory stand has been
taken by the employer before the learned Labour Court and
despite the fact that employer's witness admitted that the record
was available with him, it was not produced by the petitioneremployee. So far as contention of the learned counsel for the
petitioners that in view of Section 13A of the Act of 1936, the
employer was under an obligation to preserve the record only for
three years, it is sufficient to observe that firstly the provisions of
the Act of 1936 cannot applied while deciding reference under the
Act of 1947, due to having altogether different operational and
jurisdictional subject matter and mechanism, yet even otherwise
the period for which the employer was required to submit his
record was commencing from 14.02.2002 to 19.04.2006. It is also
a matter of record that after undergoing process of conciliation
and failure report the reference was sent by the appropriate
government to the learned Labour Court vide notification dated
09.01.2007.
Thus,
the
respondent-employer
was
having
knowledge of the fact that dispute with regard to termination of
respondent-employee w.e.f. 19.04.2006 was pending before the
learned Labour Court, under these circumstances, even in view of
Section 13A of the Act of 1936, even if assumed to be applicable,
(6 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JP:5598]
[CW-17213/2025]
the employer was having legal duty to preserve the record relating
to the period at least prior to three years preceding from the date
of reference made by the appropriate government to the learned
Labour Court. Since, the date of reference is 09.01.2007, hence,
there was no sufficient reason available to the petitionersemployer to weed out the record of the period immediately
preceding three years from the date of reference. Since, the
record called by learned Labour Court was of the same period
which falls within the said period of three years, hence, alleged
justification given by the petitioners-employer for not producing
the record before the learned Labour Court was totally untenable
in the eye of law and was an attempt to hide the evidence from
Court.
Under
these
circumstances,
no
error
or
illegality
whatsoever has been committed by the learned Labour Court in
drawing adverse inference against the petitioners.
16.
Learned counsel for the petitioners has relied upon the
judgment of R.M. Yellatti (supra), wherein Hon'ble Supreme
Court laid down the principle that primary duty rest upon the
workman to prove his case. There can be no quarrel with the
principle laid by the Hon'ble Supreme Court, however, in the facts
and circumstances of the case, where the workman was not in
power and possession of the sole evidence i.e. service record and
admittedly the petitioners-employer is custodian of the record and
was supposed to produce the record summoned by the learned
Labour Court but for no good reasons the record was withheld by
the employer and even the provision of Section 13A of the Act of
1936 would not come to the rescue of the petitioners-employer,
[2026:RJ-JP:5598]
(7 of 7)
[CW-17213/2025]
the judgment of R.M. Yellatti (supra), would not be applicable in
the present case.
17.
As regards, other findings of the learned Labour Court,
they are factual in nature which cannot be interfered in exercise of
writ jurisdiction under Articles 226 & 227 of the Constitution of
India.
18.
So far as, relief granted by the learned Labour Court is
concerned, this Court finds that looking to the fact that there was
considerable gap between date of termination and award, instead
of granting benefit of reinstatement, merely just and fair
compensation has been awarded, which is in consonance with the
recent judgments delivered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. Hence,
this Court does not find any reason to interfere in the award dated
22.11.2024 passed by the learned Labour Court.
19.
Accordingly, the writ petition filed by the petitioners is
dismissed.
20.
Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
(ANAND SHARMA),J
DAKSH/17
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review