Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:6189
Digitally
signed by
JYOTI
SHARMA
JYOTI
SHARMA Date:
NAFR
2026.02.06
11:23:16
+0530
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
SA No. 590 of 2024
Manager, D.B. Power Limited Bada Dahra, Tahsil - Dabhara,
District - Janjgir-Champa, Chhattisgarh. --- (Defendant No. 5)
... Appellant(s)
versus
1. Jagdish Prasad Aghariya S/o Rooplal Aged About 59 Years R/o
Badadahra,
TahsilDabhara,
District
Janjgir-Champa,
Chhattisgarh.
2. Salikram Aghariya, S/o Dayaram Aged About 50 Years R/o
Badadahra,
TahsilDabhara,
District
Janjgir-Champa,
Chhattisgarh.
3. Haradhar Aghariya S/o Dayaram Aged About 59 Years R/o
Badadahra,
TahsilDabhara,
District
Janjgir-Champa,
Chhattisgarh.
4. Tohar Ram Aghariya, S/o Kartikram Aged About 75 Years R/o
Badadahra,
TahsilDabhara,
District
Janjgir-Champa,
Chhattisgarh.
5. Ghasneen, W/o Late Shri Rohit Kumar Patel, Aged About 70
Years R/o Village- Basanpali, P.O. Sondka, Tahsil - Kharsiy,
District Raigarh. Chhattisgarh.
6. Rambai W/o Gopal Patel, Aged About 54 Years R/o Village
Nandeli, Tahsil -District Raigarh. Chhattisgarh.
7. Rambh W/o Late Shri Malimram Patel, Aged About 52 Years R/o
Village- Kondatarai, Tahsil -District Raigarh. Chhattisgarh.
8. Ramula, W/o Lakshmi Prasad Patel Aged About 49 Years R/o
Village - Taarpur, Tahsil -District Raigarh. Chhattisgarh.
9. Lakshmin Bai, W/o Nandlal, Aged About 49 Years R/o Village
Kondatarai, Tahsil -District Raigarh. Chhattisgarh.
10. Sher Singh S/o Late Shri Rohit Kumar Patel Aged About 46
Years R/o Village - Basanpali, Po. R-Sondka, Tahsil - Kharsiya,
District Raigarh, Chhattisgarh.
11. Chudamani (Since Dead/deleted)
11.(A) Smt. Ahilya W/o Late Shri Chudamani Patel, Aged About 70
Years R/o Village - Basanpali, P.O. - Sondka, Tahsil - Kharsiya,
District - Raigarh, Chhattisgarh.
11.(B) Satyanarayan Patel S/o Late Shri Chudamani Patel Aged
About 38 Years R/o Village - Basanpali, P.O. - Sondka, Tahsil Kharsiya, District - Raigarh, Chhattisgarh.
11.(C) Roopkala Patel S/o Late Shri Chudamani Patel Aged About
50 Years R/o Village - Basanpali, P.O. - Sondka, Tahsil - Kharsiya,
District - Raigarh, Chhattisgarh.
11.(D) Champa Bai Patel D/o Late Shri Chudamani Patel Aged
About 50 Years W/o Thandaram Patel, R/o Village - Post - Bharari,
Tahsil - Masturi, District - Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh.
11.(E) Rajni Patel D/o Late Shri Chudamani Patel Aged About 40
Years W/o Keshav Prasad Patel, R/o Village-Khurramuda, Post Baihamuda, Tahsil - Ghardhoda, District - Raigarh, Chhattisgarh.
12. Puranjan S/o Tarachand, Aged About 51 Years R/o Village Basanapali, Post - Sondka, Tahsil- Kharsiya, District Raigarh,
Chhattisgarh.
13. Narbada Bai, D/o Tarachand Aged About 53 Years R/o Village Basanapali, Post - Sondka, Tahsil- Kharsiya, District Raigarh,
Chhattisgarh.
14. Gomti D/o Tarachand Aged About 54 Years R/o Village Basanapali, Post - Sondka, Tahsil- Kharsiya, District Raigarh,
Chhattisgarh.
15. Malti Bai D/o Tarachand Aged About 49 Years R/o Village Basanapali, Post - Sondka, Tahsil- Kharsiya, District Raigarh,
Chhattisgarh.
16. Dosh Kumari D/o Tarachand, Aged About 45 Years R/o Village
- Basanapali, Post - Sondka, Tahsil- Kharsiya, District Raigarh,
Chhattisgarh.
17. Aasmati W/o Late Shri Chetan Aged About 70 Years R/o Village
- Basanapali, Post - Sondka, Tahsil- Kharsiya, District Raigarh,
Chhattisgarh.
18. Dileshwar Prasad S/o Late Shri Chetan Aged About 48 Years
R/o Village - Basanapali, Post - Sondka, Tahsil- Kharsiya, District
Raigarh, Chhattisgarh.
19. Bhagirathi D/o Chaitan Aged About 46 Years R/o Village Basanapali, Post - Sondka, Tahsil- Kharsiya, District Raigarh,
Chhattisgarh.
20. Mathura D/o Chaitan Aged About 50 Years W/o Yuvraj, R/o
Village - Aurabhata, Post - Taarpur, Thana- Tahsil- District-
Raigarh, Chhattisgarh.
21. Gayatri D/o Chaitan Aged About 42 Years W/o Late Shri
Chintamani, R/o Village - Baghanpur, Po.R.-Kirodimal, ThanaTahsil- District- Raigarh, Chhattisgarh.
22. Sohadra (Since Dead / Deleted)
22.(A) Puroshottam S/o Shri Chintalal Aged About 22 Years R/o
Village- Gojamuda, Post - Dhanagar, Thana- Tahsil- District Raigarh, Chhattisgarh.
22.(B) Sunita D/o Shri Chintalal Aged About 35 Years W/o Dilip, R/o
Village - Post - Dolesara, Thana- Tahsil- Tamnar, District - Raigarh,
Chhattisgarh.
22.(C) Sarita D/o Shri Chintalal Aged About 33 Years W/o Prakash,
R/o Village- Chhatamuda, Thana- Tahsil- District - Raigarh,
Chhattisgarh.
23. State Of Chhattisgarh, Through The Collector, Janjgir, District
Janjgir-Champa, Chhattisgarh.
... Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. Shantam Awasthi, Advocate
For Respondent No. 1 : Dr. Sudeep Agrawal along with Mr.
Ramakant Patel, Advocate
For Respondent/ State : Mr. Malay Jain, P.L.
Hon'ble Shri Bibhu Datta Guru, Judge
Judgment on Board
04.02.2026
1. The defendant/ appellant has preferred this second appeal under
Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for brevity CPC)
against the judgment & decree dated 31.07.2024 passed by the
Learned II District Judge, Sakti, District Janjgir-Champa in Civil
Appeal No. 55A/2019 (Manager D.B. Power Limited Vs. Jagdish
Prasad Aghariya and Ors) whereby the appeal by the defendant
No. 5/ appellant herein has been allowed in part and counter claim
of appellant/ defendant No. 5 is allowed which was preferred
against the judgment and decree dated 12.04.2019 passed by the
Learned Civil Judge, Class-II, Dabhara, District Janjgir Champa in
Civil Suit No. 22-A/2008 (Jagdish & Ors. Vs. Rohit & Ors.) whereby
the learned trial Judge has allowed the suit of the plaintiff/
respondent herein and dismissed the counter claim of the
defendant No. 5/ appellant herein. For the sake of convenience,
the parties would be referred as per their status before the learned
trial Court.
2. The plaintiffs preferred the suit for declaration of nine registered
sale deeds dated 19.06.2008 as null and void and for injunction
pleading inter alia that the plaintiffs and defendants No. 1 to 4 are
members of the same family and jointly own agricultural land
situated at village Badadarha, Patwari Halka No. 2, Tehsil Dabhra,
District Janjgir-Champa, Chhattisgarh, bearing Khasra No. 64
admeasuring 30.22 acres, as described in Schedule-A. The suit
land is stated to be jointly held by the plaintiffs and defendants No.
1 to 4 in equal 1/3rd shares and under their respective cultivating
possession. It is alleged that defendants No. 1 to 4, without the
consent of the plaintiffs, executed nine registered sale deeds dated
19.06.2008 in favour of defendant No. 5 in respect of the land
described in Schedule-B, which includes the plaintiffs’ share.
According to the plaintiffs, the said sale deeds were executed in
collusion with defendants No. 5 and 6 on the basis of forged
documents and are, therefore, voidable and not binding upon the
plaintiffs. On these pleadings, the plaintiffs sought a declaration
that the nine sale deeds dated 19.06.2008 are null and void and a
permanent injunction restraining the defendants from interfering
with their possession or raising any construction over the suit land.
3. Defendants/Respondents No. 1 to 4, in their written statement,
denied the averments made in the plaint and contended that the
plaintiffs have suppressed the true facts relating to the ancestral
properties. It was pleaded that the common ancestors of the
plaintiffs and defendants No. 1 to 4 held approximately 200 acres
of land in a joint account, which stood partitioned long ago among
Hirdaram, Kartikram and Ruplal, pursuant to which their respective
revenue records and accounts were separately maintained. It was
further pleaded that the partition deed relating to the shares of
Hirdaram and Kartikram is in the possession of Hiradhar and
Toharram, whereas the partition deed relating to Ruplal is in the
possession of Jagdish and Salikram. According to the defendants,
the lands described in Schedule-A had already been partitioned
during the lifetime of the ancestors and do not retain the character
of joint family property. The defendants further asserted that the
plaintiffs themselves have alienated their respective partitioned
lands in favour of third parties as well as defendant No. 5 and,
therefore, are neither owners nor in possession of any 1/3rd share
in the suit land. It was contended that the lands described in
Schedule-A no longer exist in the form claimed by the plaintiffs and
that defendants No. 1 to 4 have sold only their self-acquired land
from their individual holdings. On these grounds, it was pleaded
that the plaintiffs have not approached the Court with clean hands
and that no cause of action arose for institution of the suit.
4. Appellant/defendant No. 5, in his written statement, denied the
averments made in the plaint and pleaded that the land sold by
defendants No. 1 to 4 to defendant No. 5 belonged exclusively to
defendants No.1 to 4 and was their self-acquired property, over
which the plaintiffs had no right, title or possession. It was
contended that respondents No. 1 to 4 lawfully sold the said land to
respondent No. 5 on 19.06.2008 for valid consideration and
executed nine registered sale deeds in his favour. It was further
pleaded that pursuant to the said sale deeds, defendant No. 5 got
his name mutated in the revenue records and came into lawful
possession of the land. On these grounds, it was prayed that the
suit filed by the plaintiffs be dismissed with costs.
5. Along with the written statement, the appellant herein/ defendant
No. 5 has also filed a counter-claim, the facts of the counter-claim,
in brief, is that he purchased the lands described in Schedule-C,
situated at village Badadarha, from respondents No. 1 to 4 through
nine registered sale deeds dated 17.06.2008 and was put in
possession thereof. It is pleaded that his name has been duly
recorded in the revenue records and that he has been in
continuous possession of the said land. The counter-claim pertains
to 18.39 acres of land forming part of Schedule-A. It is further
pleaded that the plaintiffs have no right, title or possession over the
lands purchased by respondent No. 5. Without prejudice, it is
averred that if the lands purchased by respondent No. 5 are held to
be joint family property of the plaintiffs and respondents No. 1 to 4,
then respondent No. 5 is entitled to allotment of the lands
described in Schedule-C in the partition of respondents No. 1 to 4
and to a declaration of his ownership and possession thereof.
6. The reply filed by the plaintiffs/respondents No. 1 to 4 to the
counter-claim is that defendant No. 5 purchased the lands
described in Schedule-C from defendants No. 1 to 4 through nine
sale deeds dated 17.06.2008. It is pleaded that the lands in
Schedule-C constitute ancestral joint family property of the
plaintiffs and defendants No. 1 to 4. It is further pleaded that the
sale deeds executed by defendants No. 1 to 4 in favour of
defendant No. 5 on 17.06.2008, without the consent, permission or
approval of all the co-sharers, were fraudulent, illegal and void,
having been executed behind the back of the plaintiffs with the
intention of depriving them of their lawful 1/3rd share. It is
contended that defendants No. 1 to 4 had no authority to alienate
the suit land. On these grounds, it is prayed that the counter-claim
filed by defendant No. 5 be dismissed.
7.
On the pleadings of the parties, the learned trial Judge heard the
suit and the counter claim together and framed as many as 6
issues in the plaint and one issue with regard to the counter claim
and given opportunity to the parties to adduce evidence, both oral
and documentary and after a full fledged trial allowed the suit of the
plaintiffs and declared all the sale deeds dated 19.06.2008 as null
and void and also dismissed the counter claim of the defendant
No. 5 mainly on the grounds that though defendants No. 1 to 4
pleaded prior partition in their written statement, but they led no
evidence and did not appear before the court and were proceeded
ex parte, nor did they specify allotment of any land under the
alleged partition. Defendant No. 5 also failed to prove partition. In
contrast, the plaintiffs proved joint family ownership and absence
of partition through unrebutted revenue records. In the absence of
proof of partition, defendants No. 1 to 4 had no authority to alienate
the plaintiffs’ undivided share. Consequently, the sale deeds dated
19.06.2008 were held not binding on the plaintiffs, warranting
interference and thus the suit of the plaintiffs was allowed and the
counter claim of the defendant No. 5/ appellant herein was
dismissed.
8. Against the judgment and decree passed by the trial Court the
defendant No. 5/ appellant herein has preferred first appeal before
the First Appellate Court which has been allowed in part vide
judgment and decree impugned and the counter claim of the
appellant herein/ defendant No. 5 was allowed. The learned First
Appellate court has categorically observed that the suit land
described in Schedule-A had not been partitioned between the
parties and continued to be jointly recorded in their names.
Defendants No. 1 to 4, being co-owners, were entitled under
Section 44 of the Transfer of Property Act to alienate only their
undivided 1/3rd share in the joint property. However, they sold land
in excess of their lawful share to defendant No. 5 through various
registered sale deeds. To the extent the sale deeds executed land
beyond the vendors’ (defendants No.1 to 4) 1/3rd undivided share,
the same were held to be illegal and void, while the sale was held
valid only to the extent of the vendors’ 1/3rd share. Further it was
held that as the property remained unpartitioned, it was uncertain
as to which specific portion constituted the share of defendants No.
1 to 4. Consequently, defendant No. 5, as a purchaser of an
undivided share, was held not entitled to possession of any
specific part of the joint property and was only entitled to seek
partition and allotment of the vendors’ share by filing a separate
suit. The remaining portion of Schedule-A covered by the
impugned sale deeds, except those relating to the self-acquired
properties, were declared illegal and void. The Court further held
that the lands covered under registered sale deeds Exs. P-5, P-7
and P-10 were the self-acquired properties of defendants No. 1 to
4, and therefore, defendant No. 5 was declared the lawful owner
and possessor thereof. Accordingly, the appeal was allowed in part
and the judgment and decree of the trial Court were set aside, and
the counter claim was also allowed.
9. I have heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the material
available on record.
10.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that both the
learned trial Court and the learned appellate Court have committed
a manifest error in treating the suit property as joint family property,
despite clear evidence showing that the same was the self-acquired
property of defendants No. 1 to 4 by virtue of prior partition and
separate possession. It is contended that material documentary
evidence, including the Rin Pustika and separate Khata records,
demonstrating individual ownership, has been ignored. It is further
submitted that the courts below failed to consider the appellant’s
counter-claim seeking adjustment of the purchased land against
the vendors’ share in the event the property was held to be joint.
The learned counsel argues that alienation of self-acquired
property post-partition is legally valid and that the impugned
findings are contrary to settled principles and judicial precedents
governing partition and alienation, thereby giving rise to substantial
questions of law warranting interference by this Court. He further
submits that PW-1, in his cross-examination, has admitted that
partition had already taken place between the parties, therefore, the
appeal deserves to be allowed.
11. From the material available on record, it is evident that, upon due
appreciation of the oral and documentary evidence adduced by the
parties, the Appellate Court has recorded a categorical finding that
the suit land in Schedule-A remained unpartitioned and jointly
recorded. Defendants No. 1 to 4, as co-owners, could lawfully
alienate only their undivided 1/3rd share, hence, the sale deeds in
favour of defendant No. 5 were held valid only to that extent and
illegal and void insofar as they conveyed land beyond the vendors’
share. As the property was unpartitioned, defendant No. 5 was
held entitled only to seek partition of the vendors’ share and not
possession of any specific portion. The sale deeds relating to the
self-acquired properties of defendants No.1 to 4 (Exs. P-5, P-7 and
P-10) were upheld.
12. Further it is trite law that purchaser of a coparcener's undivided
interest in the joint family property is not entitled to possession of
what he had purchased. He has a right only to sue for partition of
the property and ask for allotment of his share in the suit property.
13. Even otherwise, the scope of interference in a Second Appeal
under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure is extremely
limited. Interference is permissible only when the appeal involves a
substantial question of law. Findings of fact recorded by the Court
cannot be interfered with unless such findings are shown to be
perverse, based on no evidence, or contrary to settled principles of
law.
14. In the present case, the First Appellate Court has recorded finding,
on the basis of evidence available on record. The appellant has
failed to demonstrate any perversity, illegality, or misapplication of
law in the findings so recorded.
15. The questions sought to be raised in the present Second Appeal
essentially relate to re-appreciation of evidence and challenge to
findings of fact. Such questions do not give rise to any substantial
question of law within the meaning of Section 100 of the Code of
Civil Procedure.
16. Be that as it may, the argument advanced by learned counsel for
the appellant and the proposed question of law cannot be regarded
as satisfying the test of being ‘substantial question of law’ within the
meaning of Section 100 of CPC. These questions, in my view, are
essentially question of facts. The appellants failed to raise any
substantial question of law which is required under Section 100 of
the CPC. In any event, the Second Appeal did not involve any
substantial question of law as contemplated under Section 100 of
the CPC, no case is made out by the appellants herein. The
judgment impugned passed by the learned First appellate Court is
just and proper and there is no illegality and infirmity at all.
17.Accordingly, the present appeal is liable to be and is hereby
dismissed at the motion stage itself.
SD/(Bibhu Datta Guru)
Judge
Jyoti
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review