The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. For the reasons aforesaid, while the order of the Labour Court direc0ng reinstatement with con0nuity of service and all other aHendant bene1ts is con1rmed, however, the backwages, which has been awarded in https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis full is modi1ed and the respondent would be en0tled only to 25% backwages. The pe00oner is directed to reinstate the respondent in service, if not already reinstated and pay the backwages at 25% as ordered by this court above within a period of four weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order, if not already paid.
19. The writ pe00on is disposed of with the aforesaid modi1ca0on and direc0on. Consequently, connected miscellaneous pe00on is closed. There shall be no order as to costs.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
____________
W.P. No.7807/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATE : 27.04.2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.DHANDAPANI
W.P. NO.7807 OF 2026
AND
W.M.P. NO. 8413 OF 2026
Management
SRF Limited, rep. By
HR Manager Ranjini. N
Plot No.K1, SIPCOT Industrial Complex
Gummidipoondi,
Tiruvallur District.
.. Pe00oner
- Vs Ragavendra Narayana Kulal
.. Respondent
Writ pe00on 1led under Ar0cle 226 of the Cons0tu0on of India praying
this Court to issue a writ of cer0orari to call for the records pertaining to the
award passed by the learned Presiding O7cer, II Addl. Labour Court, Chennai,
in I.D. No.149 of 2016 dated 29.10.2025 and quash the same.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
For Pe00oner
:
Mr. R.Ganesan
For Respondent
:
Mr. Balan Haridas
____________
W.P. No.7807/2026
ORDER
Aggrieved by the order of the II Addl. Labour Court, Chennai, direc0ng
reinstatement of the respondent with con0nuity of service and full
backwages, the present writ pe00on has been 1led by the pe00oner.
2. It is the case of the pe00oner that the pe00oner is a limited
company and the respondent herein was employed as Area Leader
(Mechanical Maintenance) under the pe00oner. It is the further case of the
pe00oner that on the intervening night of 5.8.2015 and 6.8.2015, while
working in the ‘C’ shiB at Loom No.16, the 1 st respondent deliberately caused
extensive damage to cord bobbins with a mala 1de and criminal inten0on to
cause heavy 1nancial loss to the pe00oner, which cons0tutes an ac0onable
misconduct under the Cer01ed Standing Orders.
3. It is the further case of the pe00oner that due to the said act, the
respondent was placed under suspension on 11.8.2015 and a charge memo
was issued on 14.8.2015 and upon 1nding the explana0on oDered by the
respondent not being sa0sfactory, a full Eedged enquiry was conducted which
culminated in the 1ling of a report holding the charges proved and aBer
calling for further explana0on on the report, the pe00oner dismissed the
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.7807/2026
respondent from service on 11.12.2015 along with a cheque being one
month’s wages in lieu of no0ce.
4. It is the further case of the pe00oner that the said dismissal was
challenged by the respondent by 1ling I.D. No.149 of 2016 before the II Addl.
Labour Court, Chennai. Before the Labour Court, the respondent/workman
examined himself as W.W.1 and marked Exs.W-1 and W-2 and on the side of
the pe00oner/management M.W.s 1 to 4 were examined and Exs.M-1 to
M-23 were marked.
The Labour Court, upon apprecia0on of oral and
documentary evidence allowed the dispute and directed reinstatement of the
workman/respondent in service along with con0nuity of service and full
backwages. Aggrieved by the said order, the present writ pe00on has been
1led by the pe00oner.
5. Learned counsel appearing for the pe00oner submiHed that the
Labour Court commiHed a gross error in trea0ng that the workman was
dismissed even on 30.11.2015 though it is not even the conten0on of the
respondent that he was dismissed on 30.11.2015; rather it is the admission of
the workman that he was dismissed only with eDect from 11.12.2015 which
strikes at the root of the 1nding rendered by the Labour Court.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.7807/2026
6. It is the further submission of the learned counsel that there is no
allega0on by the respondent that the enquiry has not been held in a proper
manner and no 1nding also has been rendered by the Labour Court to
disbelieve that the enquiry was not conducted impar0ally and further, there is
no reason also for the Labour Court, as could be evidenced from the order, to
disbelieve that the witnesses, M.W.s 1 to 4 are not acceptable as no
contradic0on has been elicited in their cross examina0on by the workman.
7. It is the further submission of the learned counsel that the oral
tes0mony of M.W.s 1 to 4 coupled with the Exs.M-12, M-13 and M-23, the
scien01c evidence unerringly proves that it is the workman who had
commiHed the mischief.
Further the Labour Court did not have any
conclusive evidence to disbelieve that the 1gure which had been exhibited in
the videograph through the CCTV footage was not that of the respondent and
the Labour Court have appreciated the evidence on the touchstone of
preponderance of probabili0es and not akin to evidence in a criminal trial and
when the evidence has not been discredited in any manner in cross
examina0on, the Labour Court ought to have accepted the evidence and
upheld the order of dismissal.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.7807/2026
8. It is the further submission of the learned counsel that the 1nding
arrived at by the Labour Court with regard to the scale of damage is wholly
unreasonable and arbitrary as the Labour Court has no technical exper0se to
analyse all the intrinsic factors connected with the manner in which the
damage to the rolls has to be assessed. Further, the genuineness of the
suspension order, Ex.M-17, which has been doubted by the Labour Court, also
has not been properly appreciated by the Labour Court.
9. In 1ne, it is the submission of the learned counsel that the Labour
Court has not appreciated both the oral and documentary evidence in proper
perspec0ve, more speci1cally on preponderance of probabili0es and,
therefore, the award allowing the reinstatement of the respondent/workman
along with all other consequen0al bene1ts deserve to be set aside.
10. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondent
submiHed that the Labour Court, in a clear exposi0on of law and 1nding that
there are very many discrepancies in both the oral and documentary evidence
submiHed by the pe00oner/Management and further there is no clinching
evidence to establish that it was the respondent/workman whose image is
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.7807/2026
appearing in the CCTV camera and applying the principle of preponderance of
probability, has rightly set aside the order of dismissal through the award with
consequen0al direc0ons, which is on clear logic, apprecia0on of materials and
also the value of evidence and, therefore, submiHed that no interference is
warranted with the order passed by the Labour Court.
11. This Court gave its careful considera0on to the submissions
advanced by the learned counsel appearing on either side and perused the
materials available on record.
12. The main evidence to link the respondent with the commission of
delinquency is Ex.M-23, the CCTV footage, which pertains to the period 02.30
hours on the early morning of 6.8.2015. The same has been considered by the
Labour Court, wherein the Labour Court has recorded a 1nding that though
the CCTV footage shows that a person is seen moving near Loom No.16,
where the damage to the rolls is alleged to have occurred, however, the
iden0ty of the person is not clear from the footage. It also further transpires
from the oral evidence of M.W.2 that though at that par0cular 0me, a person
in blue uniform is found walking near Loom No.16, however, as to the iden0ty
of the person, the witness has not given any clear answer and further the
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.7807/2026
perusal of the CCTV footage by the Court also did not clearly reveal the
iden0ty of the person. Therefore, the Labour Court rendered a categorical
1nding that the workman/respondent cannot be said to be the person who
had caused the damage, as there is no clear and convincing evidence that
pinpoints the respondent as the person, who was near Loom No.16 at about
02.30 hours on the early morning of 6.8.2015. Further, the Labour Court held
that no workers, who were in the shiB along with the respondent had been
examined to prove that it is the respondent who had commiHed the
delinquency.
In the absence of establishing the iden0ty of the person who
had gone near the par0cular Loom No.16 at the 0me alleged by the pe00oner,
the complicity of the respondent in commiKng the oDence was rejected.
13. The other allega0on against the respondent relates to damaging
the rolls. Though the iden0ty of the respondent is not established, the Labour
Court has gone into this aspect as well and had rendered a 1nding that
damage to one roll alone was aHributed to the respondent while 37 rolls,
which have been damaged, no proper explana0on has been adduced by the
pe00oner. However, it is even the admiHed case of the pe00oner, through
M.W.2 that it is a normal phenomenon for the rolls to get damaged and out of
the damaged rolls, rolls have also been reworked. In view of the said 1nding,
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.7807/2026
the Labour Court had held that the damage to the rolls cannot be aHributed
to the respondent, moreso, when the presence of the respondent has not
been established.
14. Though the Labour Court had gone into the date on which the
suspension order has been issued and the date of issuance of charge memo
and had rendered a 1nding that the respondent had been suspended without
even sta0ng the misconduct, however, this court is not inclined to enter into
the said fact, as the iden0ty of the respondent as the person who had
commiHed the alleged act had not been established. Therefore, the order of
suspension and charge memo would not stand the test of legal scru0ny and
does not require any further apprecia0on.
15. Rightly apprecia0ng all the aforesaid facts, the Labour Court has set
aside the order of dismissal of the respondent and had ordered reinstatement
along with con0nuity of service, which does not require any interference.
16. The only issue that requires considera0on is the order of full
backwages by the Labour Court. It has been the consistent view of the Courts
that the principle of no work no pay should generally be followed. However,
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.7807/2026
the said principle is not without caveat. When the dismissal is found to be for
other reasons, which is set aside by the judicial forum and the workman had
not been gainfully employed anywhere during the said period, the plight of
the workman has also to be considered in the award of backwages and merely
applying the principle of no work no pay should not be resorted to.
17. In the present case, there is no iota of material to connect the
respondent with the commission of the alleged act. Further, there is also no
material placed by the pe00oner to establish that during the period during
which the respondent was out of service, he was gainfully employed.
Considering all the above, this Court is of the considered view that the scales
of jus0ce should be balanced in such a manner that both the pe00oner as well
as the respondent are not detrimentally aDected monetarily. In such view of
the maHer, this Court deems it 1t and proper that backwages at 25% for the
period during which the respondent has been out of service would be just and
reasonable and rendering substan0al jus0ce to both the par0es.
18. For the reasons aforesaid, while the order of the Labour Court
direc0ng reinstatement with con0nuity of service and all other aHendant
bene1ts is con1rmed, however, the backwages, which has been awarded in
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.7807/2026
full is modi1ed and the respondent would be en0tled only to 25% backwages.
The pe00oner is directed to reinstate the respondent in service, if not already
reinstated and pay the backwages at 25% as ordered by this court above
within a period of four weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order,
if not already paid.
19. The writ pe00on is disposed of with the aforesaid modi1ca0on and
direc0on. Consequently, connected miscellaneous pe00on is closed. There
shall be no order as to costs.
27.04.2026
Index : Yes / No
GLN
To
The Presiding O7cer
II Addl. Labour Court
Chennai.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.7807/2026
M.DHANDAPANI, J.
GLN
W.P. NO.7807 OF 2026
27.04.2026
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review