Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WP No. 15850 of 2018 etc. batch
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
RESERVED ON: 23-06-2026
PRONOUNCED ON: 27-07-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE DR.JUSTICE ANITA SUMANTH
AND
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE SUNDER MOHAN
WP No. 15850 of 2018 and WP(MD) Nos. 16976, 15031,
14381 & 14382 of 2018
AND WMP No. 18853 of 2018 and WMP (MD) Nos.14957, 13569,
13014 and 13015 of 2018
WP No.15850 of 2018
S.Kandakumar,
S/o.K.Subbanna, Inspector of Police, (C.B.C.I.D.
Virudhunagar at the relevant point of time)
..Petitioner(s)
Vs
1.The Principal Secretary to
Government, Home Department,
Fort St. George, Chennai-09.
2.The Registrar
State Human Rights Commission,
No.143, P.S.Kumarasamy Raja Salai, Greenways
Rd, Chennai-28
3.R.Jaishankar,
4.R.Ponmuthuraj
..Respondent(s)
__________
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 15850 of 2018 etc. batch
WP(MD) No. 16976 of 2018
Sangiliraj
Head Constable, PEW,
Srivilliputhur, F1, Police Quarters, North
Malaiadipatti, Rajapalayam Virudhunagar District.
..Petitioner(s)
Vs
1.The State Human Rights Commission
Rep. by its Registrar,
143 - P.S. Kumarasamy Raja Salai,
Greenways Road, Chennai - 600 028.
2.Jaishankar
3.Ponmuthuraj
4.S. Kandhakumar
Inspector Of Police, CBCID,
Virudhunagar District.
5.E. Irinthangabala
Women Sub-Inspector of Police,
CBCID, Virudhunagar District.
6.Gurusamy
Sub-Inspector Of Police,
CBCID, Virudhunagar District.
7.B. Alagupandi
Police Constable,
CBCID, Virudhunagar District.
8.V. Vanaveerapandian
Police Constable,
CBCID, Virudhunagar District.
… Respondents
__________
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 15850 of 2018 etc. batch
WP(MD) No. 15031 of 2018
E. Irin Thangabala
..Petitioner(s)
Vs
1.The Registrar (LAW)
The State Human Rights Commission,
Tamil Nadu, Thiruvarangam, No.143, P.S.
Kumarasamy Raja Salai (Greenways Road),
Chennai-600 028.
2.R. Jaishankar
3.R. Ponmuthuraj
..Respondent(s)
WP(MD) No. 14381 of 2018
Thiru. Gurusamy
Sub Inspector of Police, S/o. Rengasamy, 2/598-3,
Bharathi Nagar, Reserve Line, Sivakasi.
..Petitioner(s)
Vs
1.The State Human Rights Commission
Rep. by its Registrar,
143-P.S.Kumarasamy Raja Salai,
Greenways Road, Chennai-600 028.
2.Jaishankar
3.R.Ponmuthuraj
4.Thiru. S. Kandakumar
Inspector of Police, CBCID Virudhunagar
5.Tmt. E. Irin Thangabala
Women Sub-Inspector of Police, CBCID
Virudhunagar
__________
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 15850 of 2018 etc. batch
6.Thiru. Sangiliraj
Police Constable, CBCID Virudhunagar
7.Thiru. B. Alagupandi
Police Constable, CBCID Virudhunagar
8.Thiru. V. Vanaveerapandian
Police Constable, CBCID Virudhunagar.
(R4 to R8 are deleted vide order dated 15.10.2019
made in WP(MD).No.14381 and 14382 of 2018 by
TSSJ and KRJ)
..Respondent(s)
WP(MD) No. 14382 of 2018
Thiru B. Alagupandi
..Petitioner(s)
Vs
1.The State Human Rights Commission
Rep. by its Registrar, 143-P.S.Kumarasamy Raja
Salai, Greenways Road, Chennai-600028.
2.Jaishankar
3.R.Ponmuthuraj
4.Thiru. S. Kandakumar
Inspector of Police, CBCID Virudhunagar
5.Tmt. E. Irin Thangabala
Women Sub-Inspector of Police, CBCID
Virudhunagar
6.Thiru. Sangiliraj
Police Constable, CBCID Virudhunagar
__________
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 15850 of 2018 etc. batch
7.Thiru. Gurusamy
Sub Inspector of Police, CBCID Virudhunagar
8.Thiru. V. Vanaveerapandian
Police constable, CBCID Virudhunagar. (R4 to R8
are deleted vide order dated 15.10.2019 made in
WP(MD).No.14381 and 14382 of 2018 by TSSJ
and KRJ)
..Respondent(s)
Prayer in WP No.15850 of 2018: Writ Petition filed under Articles 226
of the Constitution of India, for issuance of a writ of certiorari, calling for
records relating to the 2nd respondent’s order made in S.H.R.C. No.810/
2009 dated 21.05.2018 to quash the same.
Prayer in WP(MD) No. 16976 of 2018: Writ Petition filed under
Articles 226 of the Constitution of India, for issuance of a writ of
certiorari, calling for the records relating to order passed by the 1st
respondent in his proceedings in S.H.R.C.No. 810 of 2009 dated
21.05.2018 and Quash the same as illegal.
Prayer in WP(MD) No. 15031 of 2018:
Writ Petition filed under
Articles 226 of the Constitution of India, for issuance of a writ of
certiorari, calling for the entire records pertaining to the order passed by
the 1st respondent in S.H.R.C. No.810 of 2009 vide order dated
21.05.2018 and quash the same in so far as the petitioner is concerned.
Prayer in WP(MD) No. 14381 of 2018:
Writ Petition filed under
Articles 226 of the Constitution of India, for issuance of a writ of
__________
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 15850 of 2018 etc. batch
certiorari, calling for the records relating to order passed by the 1st
respondent State Human Rights Commission in S.H.R.C. No.810 of 2009
dated 21.05.2018 in so far as petitioner is concerned and quash the same.
Prayer in WP(MD) No. 14382 of 2018: Writ Petition filed under
Articles 226 of the Constitution of India, for issuance of the writ of
certiorari, calling for the records relating to order passed by the 1st
respondent State Human Rights Commission in S.H.R.C. No.810 of 2009
dated 21.05.2018 in so far as petitioner is concerned and quash the same.
WP No.15850 of 2018
For Petitioner(s):
Mr.P.G.Santhoshkumar
For Respondent(s):
No Appearance (for R1)
Mr.S.Karthikeyan (for R2)
Mr.S.Venkatesh (for R3 & R4)
WP (MD) No.16796 of 2018
For Petitioner(s):
No Appearance
For Respondent(s):
Mr.S.Karthikeyan (for R1)
Mr.S.Venkatesh (for R2 & R3)
No Appearance (for R4 to R8)
WP (MD) No.15031 of 2018
For Petitioner(s):
Mr.D.Senthur Kugan
for Mr.R.Anand
For Respondent(s):
Mr.S.Karthikeyan (for R1)
Mr.S.Venkatesh (for R2 & R3)
__________
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 15850 of 2018 etc. batch
WP (MD) No. 14381 of 2018
For Petitioner(s):
Mr.K.Balasubramaniam
for Mr.A.Sivasubramanian
For Respondent(s):
Mr.S.Karthikeyan (for R1)
Mr.S.Venkatesh (for R2 & R3)
R4 to R8 deleted vide Court order dated
15.10.2019.
WP (MD) No. 14382 of 2018
For Petitioner(s):
Mr.K.Balasubramaniam
for Mr.A.Sivasubramanian
For Respondent(s):
Mr.S.Karthikeyan (for R1)
Mr.S.Venkatesh (for R2 & R3)
R4 to R8 deleted vide Court order dated
15.10.2019.
Common Order
(Order of the Court was delivered by Sunder Mohan J.)
The captioned writ petitions have been filed by the police officers
working in various positions challenging the order dated 21.05.2018
passed by the State Human Rights Commission [hereinafter referred to
as, ‘the Commission’] in S.H.R.C.No.810 of 2009 holding them guilty of
human rights violations.
(2) The facts leading to the filing of the above writ petitions are as
follows:
__________
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 15850 of 2018 etc. batch
(a) A case was registered for offences under Sections 302 and 380
of the IPC by the Rajapalayam South Police Station in Cr.No.637 of 2006
for the murder of one Ganesan, his wife viz., Kala and their two children.
Thereafter, the case was transferred to CBCID for further investigation.
(b) It is the case of the complainants viz., R.Jaishankar [hereinafter
referred to, as ‘the 1st complainant’] and R.Ponmuthuraj [hereinafter
referred to, as ‘the 2nd complainant’], who are respondents 3 and 4 in
W.P.No.15850 of 2018 and respondents 2 and 3 in other four Writ
Petitions filed before the Madurai Bench of this Court that the petitioner
in WP No.15850 of 2018, the Inspector of Police, CBCID, along with his
team came to the office of the 2 nd complainant and forcibly took him and
went to the room where the 1st complainant stayed and took both of them
first to E3-Teynampet Police Station, thereafter to Zam Bazaar Police
Station; that they took both the complainants in a car from the said Police
Station to Koyambedu Bus Stand and from there to Madurai CBCID
office, ostensibly for the purpose of investigation in the murder case.
__________
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 15850 of 2018 etc. batch
(c) It is the further case of the complainants that at the CBCID
Office at Madurai and at Theni, the complainants were kept in illegal
custody and subjected to custodial torture, made to confess about their
guilt in the murder case wherein the complainants' aunt, uncle and their
two children were murdered.
(d) The father of the complainants, who was examined as PW3
before the Commission, sent a telegram to CBCID on 12.12.2008
alleging that his two sons were forcibly taken by the police.
On
13.12.2008, a relative of the complainants, viz., PW4 lodged a complaint
before the Inspector of Police, E3 Teynampet Police Station stating that a
few persons claiming themselves to be police officials had abducted the
complainants.
(e) On 16.12.2008, a Habeas Corpus Petition was filed by the
father [PW3] before this Court alleging illegal detention by the Inspector
of Police, CBCID, who is the petitioner in WP No.15850 of 2018, and his
team. On 12.01.2009, this Court had closed the Habeas Corpus Petition
by recording the submission of the learned Additional Public Prosecutor
that the complainants were called for enquiry and sent away; and by
__________
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 15850 of 2018 etc. batch
further observing that the petitioner’s counsel had not disputed the said
fact.
(f) On 27.01.2009, the complaint which gave rise to the impugned
order was lodged by the complainants before the Commission praying for
compensation due to the illegal custody and custodial violence.
(g) Before the Commission, the complainants were examined as
PW1 and PW2; their father was examined as PW3; and the cousin of the
complainants, was examined as PW4. They had marked six documents
including the telegram and the CSR Receipt issued by E3 Teynampet
Police Station. The other documents filed were summons issued by the
CBCID office to the complainants' father and mother. The petitioners,
who are the respondents before the Commission, filed their counter and
also examined themselves as witnesses.
(h) It was the case of the petitioners before the Commission that
they had never taken the complainants for enquiry and that the allegations
have been invented only to shield the complainants and thwart any action
__________
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 15850 of 2018 etc. batch
against them in the murder case that was being investigated. They also
pointed out to certain contradictions in the evidence of the complainants
on certain vital facts.
(i) During the course of enquiry, the Commission also directed the
production of general diary relating to the station, viz., CBCID,
Thallakulam from 01.12.2008 to 01.01.2009, register of train warrant
details, register of work allotted to the police officials and few other
documents.
(j) The Commission, after considering the evidence, by the
impugned order dated 21.05.2018, had recommended payment of
compensation of Rs.3 Lakhs each to the complainants to be recovered
from the petitioners herein, who were arrayed as respondents 2 to 6
before the Commission.
3. The learned counsels for the petitioners would submit that the
allegations are vague; that the Commission had no authority to direct
payment of compensation and their findings can only be recommendatory
__________
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 15850 of 2018 etc. batch
in nature; and that in any case, the Commission had recorded that there
was no direct evidence to establish illegal custody and violence during
custody and therefore, ought to have disbelieved the case of the
complainants, even as regards abduction.
4.
Mr.S.Venkatesh,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
complainants, however, would submit that the Commission had
considered the evidence in the right perspective and found a part of the
complaint to be true, viz., illegal abduction and rightly awarded
compensation, and in the absence of any procedural irregularity, this
Court may not interfere in the writ proceedings, as scope of judicial
review is limited.
5. We have carefully considered the rival submissions and perused
the records.
6. A Full Bench decision of this Court in Abdul Sathar v. Principal
Secretary and others, reported in 2021 SCC OnLine Mad 16611, was
brought to our notice, wherein it was held that the recommendation of the
__________
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 15850 of 2018 etc. batch
Commission is binding and the officers who have been found guilty of
violation of human rights can challenge the orders by invoking Article
226 of the Constitution of India.
7. It is the specific case of the complainants that they were taken
into custody on 12.12.2008 and kept under illegal custody till 26.12.2008.
A telegram was sent by the complainants' father to the CBCID on
12.12.2008. It is their case that this telegram was not received by the
CBCID and it was returned. It is also not in dispute that a writ petition
was filed in HCP No.2056 of 2008, before this Court. In the said writ
petition, this Court had recorded the fact that the 2 nd respondent therein
viz., the Inspector of Police, CBCID, had admitted taking the petitioners
therein/complainants for enquiry and sending them after the enquiry. The
complainants have not alleged before the Division Bench either illegal
custody or custodial violence.
8. Further, admittedly, no medical evidence was produced by the
complainants to substantiate the assaults said to have been made by the
police officials. In fact, PW2, the 2nd complainant had admitted in the
__________
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 15850 of 2018 etc. batch
cross-examination that he and PW1, the 1st complainant made a statement
on 26.12.2008 before the Inspector of Police, E3 Teynampet Police
Station that they had voluntarily gone to various places, implying that
they were not kept under illegal custody. But PW2 would add that the
police officials had forced him to make such a statement.
9. However, neither the complainants nor their father had
mentioned about this fact to the Division Bench which heard the Habeas
Corpus Petition or in their complaint and proof affidavit before the
Commission.
The fact that they were threatened to withdraw the
complaint was stated for the first time in the cross-examination when the
statement made by PW2 to the Inspector of Police, was pointed out to
him.
10. In the complaint, a general allegation has been made as against
seven respondents.
In the proof affidavit, a reference is made to
respondents 2 to 5 who are petitioners in the above writ petitions, that on
12.12.2008, they took both the complainants i.e., the 2 nd complainant
from his office and the 1st complainant from his room, to their office, but
__________
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 15850 of 2018 etc. batch
there is no reference to the presence of the 6 th respondent-Irin
Thangabala, who was shown as 3rd respondent in the final order.
11. The array of the respondents are different in the complaint as
well as in the order. It is not as if the complainants had identified the
respondents/petitioners herein before the Commission. They just refer to
them by their array in the proof affidavit and in the cross-examination.
There is no specific allegation against any particular officer. Further,
there is also reference to respondents 8 and 9, when there are no persons
arraigned so.
12. Admittedly, no independent witnesses who could have been
examined by the complainants, viz., at the office of the 2nd complainant or
the room-mates of the 1st complainant, had been examined.
13. The Commission also found that there is no evidence except for
illegal abduction. We find that there is no evidence for abduction also.
That apart, as stated earlier, the complainants themselves had made a
statement to the Inspector of Police, E3 Teynampet Police Station
suggesting that they were not in illegal custody or subjected to custodial
__________
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 15850 of 2018 etc. batch
violence. The Commission itself had only believed a portion of the
evidence of the complainants. However, on considering the evidence
before the Commission, we are of the view that it is difficult to separate
the chaff from the grain and accept only a part of the evidence of the
complainants.
14. We may also point out here that in the Habeas Corpus Petition,
the learned Additional Public Prosecutor had stated before the Division
Bench that the complainants were taken for enquiry and then sent back.
But, the 2nd respondent in the complaint before the Commission (the
petitioner in WP No.15850 of 2018) had denied taking the complainants
for enquiry. However, we find that there is nothing to show that the 2nd
respondent had filed an affidavit before the Division Bench. Hence, we
cannot hold the 2nd respondent guilty of any human rights violation only
for this reason.
15. We also find contradictions in the evidence of the complainants
as regards whether uniformed persons or plain clothesman had taken
them on 12.12.2008. Considering the overall evidence on record, we find
__________
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 15850 of 2018 etc. batch
the allegations that the complainants were illegally taken to custody and
were detained for 14 days and subjected to violence, have not been
proved.
16. In such circumstances, since the findings of the Commission,
are not based on the evidence and are hence perverse, we are inclined to
set aside the same.
17. Accordingly, the impugned order dated 21.05.2018 passed by
the State Human Rights Commission in S.H.R.C.No.810 of 2009, is set
aside and the Writ Petitions are allowed. Consequently, the connected
Writ Miscellaneous Petitions are closed.
(A.S.M.,J.) (S.M.,J.)
27-07-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
ars
__________
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
WP No. 15850 of 2018 etc. batch
DR.ANITA SUMANTH J.
AND
SUNDER MOHAN J.
ars
To
1.The Principal Secretary to Government,
Home Department, Fort St. George, Chennai-09.
2.The Registrar,
State Human Rights Commission,
No.143, P.S.Kumarasamy Raja Salai,
Greenways Rd, Chennai-28.
3.The Public Prosecutor,
High Court, Madras.
Pre-delivery common order in
WP No. 15850 of 2018 and WP(MD) Nos. 16976,
15031, 14381 & 14382 of 2018
AND WMP No. 18853 of 2018 and
WMP (MD) Nos.14957, 13569, 13014
and 13015 of 2018
27-07-2026
__________
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review