Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/14
GAHC010236642023
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/6225/2023
MANABENDRA KR SARMA
SON OF SRI HARENDRA SHARMA,
R/O- SIMALUA,
P.O.- BALISATRA, GUWAHATI,
DIST.- KAMRUP, ASSAM,
PIN- 781350.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 4 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY,
DEPARTMENT OF SECONDARY EDUCATION,
DISPUR AT GUWAHATI- 781006.
2:THE DIRECTOR OF SECONDARY EDUCATION
KAHILIPARA AT GUWAHATI- 781019.
3:THE DISTRICT COMMISSIONER
KAMRUP
AS CHAIRMAN
DISTRICT SCRUTINY COMMITTEE
SECONDARY EDUCATION
AMINGAON
GUWAHATI- 781031.
4:THE INSPECTOR
KAMRUP DISTRICT CIRCLE
AMINGAON
GUWAHATI- 781031.
Page No.# 2/14
5:THE PRINCIPAL IN-CHARGE
MADHYA PANDURI H.S. SCHOOL
JAMTOLA
RANGIA
DISTRICT- KAMRUP(ASSAM)
Advocate for the Petitioner
BASU
: MR. N SARKAR, MR S BORTHAKUR,MR A BANERJEE,MR P K
Advocate for the Respondent : SC, SEC. EDU., GA, ASSAM
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SOUMITRA SAIKIA
ORDER
03.09.2026
Heard Mr. S. Borthakur, learned Senior Counsel, assisted by Mr. N. Sarkar
learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. U. Sharma learned Standing
Counsel appearing for the Secondary Education, Ms. K. Phukan, learned State
Counsel appears for the Respondent No. 3. In spite of notices being served,
none represents the Respondent No. 5.
2.
The petitioner before this Court is presently serving as the subject teacher
of English since 2009 in Madhya Panduri Higher Secondary School, located at
Jamtola, Rangia, Kamrup. The petitioner was initially appointed as the second
post of teacher in English by the Managing Committee of Madhya Panduri
Higher Secondary School in terms of the resolution adopted by the Managing
Committee dated 23.10.2009. The petitioner was thereafter issued the
appointment order on 24.12.2009, pursuant to which the petitioner joined his
service on 26.12.2009. It is the contention on behalf of the petitioner that he
has been rendering continuous service in the said school.
Page No.# 3/14
3.
In terms of the provisions of the Assam Venture Educational Institutions
(Provincialisation of Services) Act 2011, the services of the recommended
teachers were provincialised. In the said school, there were two teachers of
English, namely Shri Kishore Kumar Sarma, as the first teacher and the writ
petitioner as the second teacher. In terms of the provisions of the Act of 2011,
the School authorities sent the names of the teachers in their proposal for
provincialisation. Prior to the names being sent, the first teacher in English,
namely Shri Kishore Kumar Sarma had resigned and, pursuant to a decision
taken by the Managing Committee, the petitioner was appointed in his place as
the first English teacher of the said School.
4.
In the process undertaken for sending the names of the teachers for
provincialisation, for reasons beyond the control of the petitioner, the school
authorities inadvertently recommended the name of Shri Kishore Kumar Sarma
in place of the present writ petitioner for provincialisation, notwithstanding the
fact that Shri Kishore Kumar Sarma had already resigned on 22.06.2012 and the
petitioner
having
been
appointed
as
such.
As
a
consequence,
the
provincialisation of the services of the other teachers was granted by the
authorities, except that of the petitioner, whose name was inadvertently not put
up by the school authorities in place of Shri Kishore Kumar Sarma. Also in view
of his resignation, Shri Kishore Kumar Sarma, was also not provincialized.
Thereafter, the school authorities submitted a proposal before the District School
Committee for incorporation of the name of the petitioner against the first post
of subject teacher in English for provincialisation. The Scrutiny Committee, in its
meeting held on 04.06.2015, recommended that the name of the petitioner for
being put up for provincialisation against the first post of subject teacher
Page No.# 4/14
(English). The said recommendation was made as the petitioner has been found
to have been in service since the date of his joining on 26.12.2009, subsequent
resignation to Shri Kishore Kumar Sarma on 22.06.2012.
5.
The matter was examined by the Director of Secondary Education and, by
order dated 5th of December, 2015, the Director of Secondary Education
rejected the proposal for provincialisation of the writ petitioner. The said order
was challenged before this Court by the petitioner in WP(C) No. 3159/2016. By
order dated 27.05.2016, the Coordinate Bench of this Court disposed of the writ
petition, directing the matter to be considered afresh by the Director of
Secondary Education, by conducting an enquiry to ascertain whether the
petitioner was the first English teacher of the said school and also clear his
doubts by calling the principal of the said School.
6.
Pursuant to the directions issued by the Court, although the Director, by
order dated 04.10.2016, reconsidered the matter again, he reiterated his earlier
stand and rejected the claim made by the petitioner on the ground that the
Principal of the school could not produce the Attendance Register from January
2011 to April 2011, and also that from May 2011 the petitioner had put his
signature after Grade-IV employee and only in the year 2013 he had put his
signature in the Attendance Register before the Grade-IV employee. The
Director rejected the proposal on the ground that there was clear case of
manipulation of the records. The said order was therefore again assailed by the
petitioner by filing WP(C) No. 1056/2017. However, the writ petition had to be
withdrawn in view of the fact that the Act of 2011 was held to be ultra vires by
the Division Bench of this Court. Although, the writ petition was withdrawn,
Page No.# 5/14
liberty was granted to the petitioner to challenge the order dated 04.10.2016 at
a future date. Subsequent to the enactment of the Act of 2017, the present writ
petition has been filed assailing the impugned order dated 04.10.2016 passed
by the Director.
7.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the conclusion arrived at
by the Director is not borne out of the records and that the petitioner has not
been serving against the first post of Subject teacher of English. From a perusal
of the impugned order, it is seen that the rejection of the proposal of the writ
petitioner is only on the ground that the petitioner had signed the Attendance
Register after a Grade-IV employee, without any reasons being shown by the
Director as to why the petitioner’s signature appeared after being Grade-IV
employee. There is no provision under the Act of 2011 or 2017 restraining
subject teachers from putting signatures after Grade-IV employees. It is
submitted that the School maintains the Attendance Register on the basis of the
seniority of employment and, as the Grade-IV employee had been appointed at
an earlier date, the name of the petitioner came to be placed below the GradeIV employee in the Attendance Register.
8.
The further contention of the petitioner is that the conclusion arrived at by
the Director that the School Authorities did not produce the Attendance Register
from January 2011 to April 2011 cannot be attributed to the writ petitioner, as
the said registers were not within his custody. It was open for the Director to
compel or issue further directions to the School Authorities to produce all
relevant records and, in the absence thereof, to take appropriate action against
the erring officials for their failure to produce the Attendance Registers.
Page No.# 6/14
9.
The learned Senior Counsel has referred to the additional affidavit filed by
the petitioner in the present proceedings and the annexure enclosing the copies
of the Attendance Register obtained by the petitioner from Madhya Pandhuri
Higher Secondary School, Jamtola. The copies of the Attendance Registers were
received from the School under the cover letter dated 17.07.2026 issued by the
Principal-In-Charge of the said School. Referring to the photocopies of the
Attendance Registers enclosed with the additional affidavit filed by the
petitioner, the learned Senior Counsel submits that the said registers are for the
period January 2010 to December 2011. He submits that the signature of the
writ petitioner is available for all the months in the registers and that these are
the photocopies as is reflected in the order dated 04.10.2016. The learned
Senior Counsel submits that the non production of the Teacher Attendance
Register by the School authorities before the Director at the time of hearing are
beyond the comprehension of the writ petitioner and no fault can be attributed
to him for non-production of these registers, as they were not within his
custody. Referring to Section 3(1)(vi) and (vii) Act of 2017, it is submitted that
the Act provides for provincialization of venture high school or venture high
secondary school and that the conditions prescribed therein are fulfilled by the
said School. He further refers to Section 2 (t) to submit that the expression
“teacher” under the provisions of the Act, would mean any teacher or any
teaching faculty working in a venture educational school having the requisite
educational and professional qualifications in the norms and standards fixed
under the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009, the
NCTE Act, 1993, the UGC Act, 1956 and the relevant rules and regulations, and
whose services are provincialised under any other Act, as may be applicable on
the date of provincialisation, and whose services are provincialised under the
Page No.# 7/14
Act. It is submitted that, on a date when the proposal was put up for
consideration of the claim for provincialisation, the petitioner satisfied all the
norms prescribed and his name ought to have been provincialised, but for the
error committed by the School Authorities in recommending the name of the
former teacher, namely Kishore Kumar Sarma for provincialisation as the first
subject teacher in English instead of the present writ petitioner. He, therefore,
submits that the impugned order dated 04.10.2016 be interfered with and the
respondents be directed to take into account the verification undertaken by the
District Scrutiny Committee and pass appropriate orders for provincialisation of
the services of the petitioner with effect from the date on which the other
teachers of the same school were provincialised.
10. Mr. U. Sharma, learned Standing Counsel, on the other hand, submits that
the affidavit filed by the Department clearly indicates that, in the impugned
order dated 04.10.2016, there is a categorical finding by the Director that there
was manipulation of the records and that the School was provincialized in the
year 2013. He further submits that, as per Section 4(2)(iii) of the Act of 2017,
the teachers to be provincialised must have rendered at least six years of
continuous service as on 01.01.2017 from the date of joining in the concerned
Venture Educational School, and that the date of joining must be on 31.12.2010
or prior to that date. It is submitted that the petitioner was appointed in the
year 2009 and that he does not satisfy the required period of service as on the
date when the names were put up for provincialisation. He therefore, submits
that there is no merit in the writ petition and that the claim made by the writ
petitioner is not maintainable. He, therefore, submits that this writ petition be
dismissed.
Page No.# 8/14
11. The learned counsel for the parties have been heard, pleadings available
on record have been carefully perused.
12. At the outset it is necessary to refer to the relevant provisions of the Act of
2017. Under Section 3 (1)(vi) & (vii), the provisions of the Act are as under:
“Eligibility criteria for selection of educational
institution
for
provincialisation
of
services
of
teachers/tutors.
3. (1)
Subject to the provisions of Article 30 of the
Constitution of India, the following categories of Venture
Educational
Institutions
shall
be
eligible
for
being
considered for provincialisation of the services of their
teachers and tutors:vi)
In case of a Venture High School or a Venture Higher
Secondary School or a Venture Junior College or a Venture
Degree
College,
Institution
must
the
concerned
have
a
Venture
consistent
Educational
good
academic
performance which would mean that at least 30% of the
candidates appearing for the final examination as a whole
must
have
passed
in
the
last
three
consecutive
examinations held during previous three consecutive years
prior to the date of coming into force of this Act.
(vii) In addition to the provision under clause (v) above,
at least 10 students must have appeared in the last final
examination in any subject in case of Venture High School,
Page No.# 9/14
Venture High Madrassa, or Venture Higher Secondary
School or Venture Junior College. At least 15 students in
any subject must have appeared in case of Venture Degree
College in the last final examination.”
Under Section 4 (2) (iii), the provisions of the Act are as under:
“Teachers and/or tutors to be government
servants
4. (2) The teachers and/or tutors to be provincialised
under this Act,(iii)
must have rendered at least six years continuous
service as on 1.1.2017 from the date of joining in the
concerned Venture Educational Institution which must be
on 31.12.2010 or prior to that date.
Under Section 13 (6), (7), (8) & (9), the provisions of the Act are as
under:
”13. District Scrutiny Committee and State
Level Scrutiny Committee.
(6) The District Scrutiny Committee shall first
scrutinize and prepare a list of all Venture Educational
Institutions within the district, which are eligible in terms of
the provisions of this Act and shall thereafter proceed to
scrutinize and verify the service records of all the serving
Page No.# 10/14
teachers, who are eligible or would become eligible for
being considered for provincialisation of their services. The
District Committee shall identify a Base School for each
category of school and recommend the name of teacher/
tutor to be associated against each Base School.
(7) The District Scrutiny Committee shall forward
the verified list of eligible teachers Base school-wise in
accordance with this Act, to the concerned Director who
shall place the matter before the State Level Scrutiny
Committee to be constituted under sub-section (10) of this
section and after making such further scrutiny as may be
required, shall forward the same to the concerned
Department of the State Government for consideration and
for issuing Notification in respect of the eligible institutions
and
teachers
eligible
for
getting
their
services
provincialised.
(8) The District Scrutiny Committee shall have the
powers to inspect physical existence of school and to
inspect all documents and records produced before it and
call for such further records and documents as may be
required for the purpose of causing verification and scrutiny
and examine witnesses for the purpose, if considered
necessary and while doing so it shall have the powers of a
Civil Court for the purpose of compelling attendance of
persons and production of documents.
(9) The State Government may, for reasons to be
recorded in writing, by an order re-constitute the District
Page No.# 11/14
Scrutiny Committee or may change in its composition, if the
circumstances so warrant, from time to time.”
13. A perusal of the aforesaid provisions reveal that it is the District Scrutiny
Committee who has been given the responsibility of making the necessary
scrutiny and enquiry into the proposal received from the Venture Educational
Institution seeking provincialisation of the service of teachers. The procedure
prescribed under Section 13 (6), (7), (8) and (9) are very clear.
14. Coming to the facts of the present writ petition, the District Scrutiny
Committee, in the subsequent proposal, had undertaken a detailed scrutiny and
recommended the name of the writ petitioner for provincialisation, as recorded
in the Minutes of the Meeting held on 04.06.2015. The discrepancy reflected in
the impugned order dated 04.10.2016 by the Director of Secondary Education,
to the effect that the Attendance Registers from January 2011 to April 2011
were not available or produced by the Principal of the School, is also sought to
be dispelled by the copies of the Attendance Registers for the concerned period
obtained from the School Authorities, which are enclosed in the additional
affidavit filed by the petitioner on 24.07.2026. No such finding regarding nonavailability of attendance registers is also seen in the Minutes of the District
Scrutiny Committee.
15. From the pleadings, it is also seen that there is no dispute with regard to
the fact that the first subject teacher (English), Shri Kishore Kumar Sarma had
already resigned on 22.06.2012, prior to the proposal for provincialisation being
submitted by the School Authorities. It is also clear from the earlier order
passed by the Director dated 5th of December, 2015, wherein it was
Page No.# 12/14
categorically mentioned that, the earlier incumbent Shri Kishore Kumar Sarma
having resigned on 22.06.2012, it was not understood why the Principal
submitted the name of the said teacher for provincialisation after a period of
three months, on 29.09.2012. Accordingly, it is not in dispute that Shri Kishore
Kumar Sarma had tendered his resignation well prior to the proposal for
provincialisation being sent or put up by the School Authorities. The fact that
the School Authorities had thereafter sent the subsequent proposal for including
the name of the petitioner for provincialisation is also supported by the scrutiny
undertaken by the District Scrutiny Committee, as is evident from the Minutes of
the Meeting dated 04.06.2015.
16. The question with regard to the availability of the Attendance Registers of
the said School for the period January 2011 to April 2011, is sought to be
answered by the photocopies and extracts of the said Registers furnished before
this Court by filing additional affidavit under the cover letter of the School
Authorities dated 17.07.2026. No affidavit has been filed by the State disputing
the materials which are brought on record by the additional affidavit filed by the
writ petitioner on 24.07.2026. There is also no reference found in the impugned
order passed by the Director of Secondary Education with regard to scrutiny
undertaken by the District Scrutiny Committee, which is mandatorily required to
be done under Section 12 of the Act of 2016, which committee had duly
recommended the provincialisation of the writ petitioner.
17. Under such circumstances, this Court is of the view that, in the face of the
materials placed before this Court with regard to the availability of the
Attendance Registers for January 2011 to April 2011, and the materials
Page No.# 13/14
indicating the availability of the writ petitioner and his rendition of services in
said School, the matter will require re-examination by the Director of Secondary
Education.
18. Accordingly, the matter is remanded back to the Director to re-examine the
claims and the proposal put up by the School Authorities for provincialisation of
the writ petitioner by taking into consideration the fact that the scrutiny having
already been undertaken by the District Scrutiny Committee, as is evident from
the Minutes of the Meeting dated 04.06.2015, and also to either call for the
originals of the School Attendance Registers, the extract of which are placed
before this Court by way of the additional affidavit dated 24.07.2026, filed by
the petitioner, or to personally verify the correctness of the information stated to
be available in the Attendance Registers.
19. The Director is also given liberty to undertake any verification with regard
to the employment status of the petitioners as also his eligibility under the Act
of 2017. Upon such detailed verification being undertaken, the claim of the writ
petitioner will be considered and a detailed speaking order will be passed by the
Director.
20.
In the event, the Director finds that the petitioner is eligible for
provincialisation, then his name should be put up immediately, without further
delay, for provisialisation with effect from the appropriate date, as would be
evident from the proposal put up by the School Authorities for provincialisation
and consequential orders thereon be passed provincialising the services of the
petitioner. In the event, the Director is of the considered view that the claim of
Page No.# 14/14
the petitioner is not found to be admissible, then also an appropriate speaking
order shall be passed to that effect.
21. Let this entire exercise be undertaken within the period of 60 (sixty) days
from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order.
22. In view of the order passed today, the impugned order dated 04.10.2016 is
hereby set aside.
23. Accordingly, this writ petition stands disposed of in terms of the direction
stated hereinabove.
24. No order as to cost.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review