Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010697382018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA
PRADESH AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3596]
TUESDAY, THE 6th DAY OF OCTOBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
CRIMINAL APPEAL No: 2572/2018
Between:
1. THUMULA
KRISHNA,
R/O.KURAKULA
VEEDHI,
PACHIPENTA VILLAGE AND MANDAL, VIZIANAGARAM
DISTRICT.
2. MAMIDI
APPANNA,
R/O.KURAKULA
VEEDHI,
PACHIPENTA VILLAGE AND MANDAL, VIZIANAGARAM
DISTRICT.
3. MAMIDI
MUSALAYYA,
R/O.KURAKULA
VEEDHI,
PACHIPENTA VILLAGE AND MANDAL, VIZIANAGARAM
DISTRICT.
4. MAMIDI
APPANNA,
R/O.KURAKULA
VEEDHI,
PACHIPENTA VILLAGE AND MANDAL, VIZIANAGARAM
DISTRICT.
5. MAMIDI NOOKA RAJU, R/O.KURAKULA VEEDHI,
PACHIPENTA VILLAGE AND MANDAL, VIZIANAGARAM
DISTRICT.
6. MAMIDI SIMHACHALAM, R/O.KURAKULA VEEDHI,
PACHIPENTA VILLAGE AND MANDAL, VIZIANAGARAM
DISTRICT.
...APPELLANTS
AND
1. THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, REP. BY ITS
PUBLIC PROSECUTOR, HIGH COURT AT HYDERABAD.
2. MR TUMULA SIMHACHALAM, OCC . FARMER,
R/O.KURAKULA VEEDHI, PACHIPENTA VILLAGE AND
MANDAL, VIZIANAGARAM DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENTS
KSR,J & JS,J
CRL.A.No.2572 & 2684 OF 2018
Appeal under Section 372/374(2)/378(4) of Cr.P.C praying
that the High Court may be pleased to set aside the Judgement
dated 06-09-2018 in S.C.No. 4 of 2017 on the file of the Court of
the II Additional District and Sessions Judge, Parvathipuram in so
far as the Appellants / Accused No. 2, 4, 5, 7 to 9 is concerned
and dismiss the SC No. 4 of 2017, and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC
praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition,
the High Court may be pleased to suspend the operation of the
Judgment dated 06-09-2018 passed in S.C.No. 4 of 2017 on the
file of the Court of the II Additional District and Sessions Judge,
Parvathipuram, and release the petitioners / Accused No. 2, 4, 5,
7 to 9 on bail, pending final disposal of the main criminal appeal,
and pass
Counsel for the Appellant(S):
1. POSANI AKASH
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
The Court made the following:
KSR,J & JS,J
CRL.A.No.2572 & 2684 OF 2018
APHC010758432018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA
PRADESH AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3596]
TUESDAY, THE 6th DAY OF OCTOBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
CRIMINAL APPEAL No: 2684/2018
Between:
1. MAMIDI SANKARA RAO, OCC-CULTIVATION, R/O.
KURAKULA VEEDHI, PACHIPENTA VILLAGE AND
MANDAL, VIZIANAGARAM DISTRICT
...APPELLANT
AND
1. STATEOF ANDHRA PRADESH, Rep., by its Public
Prosecutor, High Court at Hyderabad
...RESPONDENT
Appeal under Section 372/374(2)/378(4) of Cr.P.C praying
that the High Court may be pleased to set aside the Judgment
dated 06.09.2018 in S.C No.4/2017 on the file of the Court of the
II Additional District and Sessions Judge, Paravathipuram in so far
as the Appellant and Accused No.1 is concerned and dismiss the
SC No.4 of 2017
IA NO: 1 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC
praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition,
the High Court may be pleased to suspend the operation of the
Judgment dated 06.09.2018 in S.C No.4/2017 on the file of the
Court of the
II Additional District and Sessions Judge,
Paravathipuram in so far as the Appellant and Accused No.1 is
concerned and release the Petitioner and Accused No.1 on bail
pending final disposal of the main Criminal Appeal
KSR,J & JS,J
CRL.A.No.2572 & 2684 OF 2018
IA NO: 1 OF 2019
Petition under Section 151 CPC
praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition,
the High Court may be pleased to grant temporary bail to the
Petitioner/Accused No.1 in SC No. 4 of 2017 on the file of the
Court of the II Additional District and Sessions Judge,
Parvathipuram, for a period of ten (10) days i.e., from 03.12.2019
to 13.12.2019 to perform Pedda Karma of his deceased father,
pending final disposal of the main appeal, and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2024
Petition under Section 151 CPC
praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition,
the High Court may be pleased to enlarge the Petitioner Accused
No. 1 on bail after suspending the sentence of imprisonment
dated. 06-09-2018 passed in SC No. 4 of 2017 on the file of the II
Addl. District and Sessions judge, Parvathipuram pending
disposal of the Criminal Appeal No. 2684 of 2018 and to pass
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. POSANI AKASH
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
The Court made the following:
KSR,J & JS,J
CRL.A.No.2572 & 2684 OF 2018
COMMON JUDGMENT: (Per Hon'ble Sri Justice K. Suresh Reddy)
As both the appeals arise out of the same Sessions Case
i.e., S.C.No.4 of 2017 on the file of the Judge, Family Court-cumIII Additional Sessions Judge, FAC.II Additional District &
Sessions Judge, Parvathipuram, they are taken up together and
being disposed of by way of this common judgment.
2.
A-1 in the above Sessions Case, filed Criminal Appeal
No.2684 of 2018, whereas A-2, A-4, A-5, A-7, A-8 and A-9 filed
Criminal Appeal No.2572 of 2018.
3.
The appellants along with A-3, A-6 and A-10 were tried by
the learned Additional Sessions Judge under the following
charges:
1st charge was under Section 148 IPC against A-1 to A-10.
2nd charge was under Section 302 r/w.149 IPC against A-1 to A-10
3rd charge was under Section 324 r/w.149 IPC against A-1 to A-10.
and the last charge was under Section 326 r/w.149 IPC against
A-9.
4.
Substance of the charge is that on 01.08.2016 at about
06.00 a.m., A-1 to A-10 formed into an unlawful assembly, armed
with axes and sticks, attacked one Mamidi Simhachalam
(hereinafter referred to as “deceased”), and also attacked P.W-1,
KSR,J & JS,J
CRL.A.No.2572 & 2684 OF 2018
P.W-2 and P.Ws-6 to 8 at Kurakula Street, Pachipenta Village,
Vijayanagaram District, causing death of the deceased and also
causing injuries to P.W-1, P.W-2 and P.Ws-6 to 8 and thereby
committed offences punishable under Sections 148, 302, 324, 326
r/w.149 IPC.
5.
After completion of trial, the learned Additional Sessions
Judge convicted A-1 under Section 302 IPC and sentenced him to
suffer imprisonment for life, and also to pay a fine of Rs.50,000/-,
in default, to suffer simple imprisonment for six months.
The
learned Additional Sessions Judge further convicted A-2, A-4, A-5,
A-7 and A-8 under Section 324 IPC and sentenced them to suffer
simple imprisonment for a period of one year and also to pay a
fine of Rs.10,000/-, in default, to suffer simple imprisonment for six
(06) months. The learned Additional Sessions Judge convicted
A-9 under Section 326 IPC and sentenced him to suffer simple
imprisonment for a period of one year and six months, and also to
pay a fine of Rs.5,000/-, in default, to suffer simple imprisonment
for three months. Aggrieved by the same, the appellants filed the
present appeals.
6.
Case of the prosecution as emanated from the evidence of
prosecution witnesses, briefly, is as follows:
KSR,J & JS,J
CRL.A.No.2572 & 2684 OF 2018
i)
All the accused and the material prosecution witnesses are
residents of Kurakula Street, Pachipenta Village, Vijayanagaram
District.
The deceased was also resident of the same village.
P.W-1 is the elder brother and P.W-3 is the wife of the deceased
respectively. P.W-2, P.Ws-4 to 8 are the close relatives of the
deceased.
ii)
On 30.07.2016, P.W-4 was cleaning the vacant site situated
near his house, as there was a function in his house. On the
same day, one Mamidi Narayanamma, who is close relative of
A-10 threw debris in the said cleaned vacant site. Then, P.W-4
questioned her about throwing debris in the vacant site.
Thereafter, the said Narayanamma went and informed A-10 about
P.W-4 questioning her.
iii)
On the next day, there was a commotion between A-1 to
A-10 and the prosecution party on the other side. Both the groups
formed into an unlawful assembly armed with sticks and other
weapons. P.W-4 was questioning the said Narayanamma about
throwing debris in the vacant site.
There ensued a wordy
altercation between both the groups. Suddenly, A-10 proclaimed
to kill the prosecution party. Immediately, A-4 beat the deceased
with a stick on his legs and the deceased fell down. Immediately,
A-1 hacked the deceased on his head with an axe. A-2 and A-3
said to have kicked the deceased with hands and legs. When
KSR,J & JS,J
CRL.A.No.2572 & 2684 OF 2018
P.W-1, P.W-2 and P.Ws-6 to 8 intervened, they were also beaten
by the accused. The deceased, P.W-1, P.W-2 and P.Ws-6 to 8
were shifted to hospital.
iv)
At about 09.00 a.m. on 01.08.2016, P.W-17 Sub Inspector
of Police, Pachipenta Police Station, received information from the
hospital. Immediately, he deputed Head Constable by name Srinu
to visit the Community Health Center, Saluru.
The said Head
Constable recorded statement from P.W-2, marked as Ex.P-2. On
the basis of Ex.P-2, P.W-17 registered a case in Cr.No.82/2016
under Sections 148, 323, 324 r/w.149 IPC. FIR was marked as
Ex.P-12. Immediately, P.W-17 rushed to the scene of offence and
prepared an observation report/Ex.P-3. He also seized M.Os-1 to
3 at the scene of offence.
He has also prepared a rough
sketch/Ex.P-13 at the scene of offence. He went to Community
Health Center, Saluru, and recorded statements of P.W-1, P.W-2
and P.Ws-6 to 8. He shifted the injured/Mamidi Simhachalam to
Government Hospital, Vijayanagaram, and from there to KGH,
Visakhapatnam.
v)
On the next day at about 08.30 a.m., P.W-1 went to police
station and informed P.W-17 that the deceased succumbed to
injuries. He received Ex.P-1 report from P.W-1 and altered the
section of law to sections 148, 302, 324, 323 r/w.149 IPC and
KSR,J & JS,J
CRL.A.No.2572 & 2684 OF 2018
issued alteration memo/Ex.P-14. Further investigation was taken
over by the Inspector of Police/P.W-18.
vi)
P.W-18/Inspector of Police, received altered FIR and also
verified the investigation conducted by P.W-17. Immediately, he
rushed to King George Hospital, Visakhapatnam, and examined
P.Ws-1 to 5 at mortuary. He secured the presence of mediators
P.W-11 and another and held inquest over dead body. Inquest
report was marked as Ex.P-4. He forwarded the dead body for
post mortem examination.
vii)
P.W-15 Assistant Professor, Andhra Medical College,
conducted autopsy over dead body. He opined the cause of death
was due to head injury.
He issued post mortem certificate
Ex.P-11.
viii)
On 03.08.2016, P.W-18 visited scene of offence and
recorded statements of P.Ws-9 and 10.
On 10.08.2016, he
apprehended A-1 in the presence of P.Ws-12 and 13. A-1 said to
have confessed about commission of offence. On the confession
made by A-1, P.W-18, seized M.Os-4 and 5 weapons from the
house of A-1 under a panchanama/Ex.P-5 in the presence of
P.Ws-12 and 13. On the same day at about 10.45 a.m., P.W-18
arrested A-2 to A-10.
All the accused were produced before
Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Saluru, who were remanded to
judicial custody. On 12.08.2016, P.W-18 forwarded M.Os-4 and 5
KSR,J & JS,J
CRL.A.No.2572 & 2684 OF 2018
to RFSL, Visakhapatnam, under a letter of advice/Ex.P-15. RFSL
report was marked as Ex.P-16. After receiving all the documents
and after completion of investigation, P.W-18 filed charge sheet.
7.
In support of its case, the prosecution examined P.Ws-1 to
18, marked Exs.P-1 to P-16 and exhibited M.Os-1 to 5. On behalf
of defence, Exs.D-1 to D-16 were marked.
8.
When the accused were examined under Section 313
Cr.P.C., they denied the incriminating evidence appearing against
them.
9.
Accepting the evidence of P.Ws-1 to 10, the learned
Additional Sessions Judge convicted the accused as aforesaid.
10.
Heard Sri Posani Venkateswarlu, learned Senior Counsel
appearing for Sri Posani Akash, learned counsel for the
appellants/accused, and Sri Marri Venkata Ramana, learned
Additional Public Prosecutor appearing for the respondent/State.
11.
Learned
Senior
Counsel
strenuously
contends
that
admittedly, both groups formed into an unlawful assembly and
quarreled with each other. He also contends that even according
to the allegations made in the charge sheet, both groups with
common intention formed themselves into an unlawful assembly,
KSR,J & JS,J
CRL.A.No.2572 & 2684 OF 2018
armed with deadly weapons like sticks and axes and fought with
each other. He further contends that the motive for the clash by
both groups is trivial in nature.
According to the prosecution, P.W-4 cleaned the vacant site
for the purpose of a function in his house. Thereafter, one
M.Narayanamma, who is close relative to A-10 threw debris in the
said vacant site. That was the reason for both groups to clash
with each other. Of course, the said M.Narayanamma was not
examined by the prosecution, as such, the learned Senior Counsel
contends that there is a free fight between both groups and the
accused are responsible for their individual acts.
He further contended that there was a counter case, which
was registered against the prosecution party in Cr.No.83/2016 of
the same police station. The said counter case i.e., C.C.669/2016
on the file of Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Saluru, is still
pending for trial. The learned Senior Counsel further contends
that as there are case and counter case, both of them ought to
have been tried simultaneously one after the other. But, the said
procedure was not followed by the learned Additional Sessions
Judge. Of course, neither the prosecution party, nor the accused
brought to the notice of the learned Additional Sessions Judge
about the counter case pending against the prosecution party.
KSR,J & JS,J
CRL.A.No.2572 & 2684 OF 2018
He further contends that A-1, A-4, A-5, A-7 to A-9 and two
others received injuries in the hands of prosecution party, which is
subject matter of C.C.669/2016.
He further contends that the
prosecution has not explained the injuries on the accused. He
also contends that the wound certificates pertaining to A-1, A-4,
A-5, A-7 to A-9 were marked as Exs.D-8 to D-14.
He further
contends that Exs.D-8 to D-14 were marked through Civil
Assistant Surgeon, Saluru, who was examined as P.W-14.
P.W-14 has specifically admitted in the cross-examination that
Exs.D-8 to D-14 are the wound certificates pertaining to some of
the accused.
He further contended that all the prosecution witnesses i.e.,
P.Ws-1 to 10 have stated that A-1 hacked the deceased on his
head with an axe/M.O-4.
But, the medical evidence adduced
through P.W-15 coupled with Ex.P-11 does not corroborate the
version of P.Ws-1 to 10, as such, he requested this Court to allow
both the criminal appeals, by setting aside the conviction recorded
by the learned Additional Sessions Judge.
12.
On the other hand, the learned Additional Public Prosecutor
opposed both the appeals, contending that P.W-1, P.W-2, P.Ws-6
to 8 are the injured witnesses and their presence cannot be ruled
out. He further contends that the evidence of P.Ws-1 to 10 is
KSR,J & JS,J
CRL.A.No.2572 & 2684 OF 2018
consistent with regard to the attack on deceased.
All the
witnesses stated that it is A-1, who hacked the deceased on his
head with axe/M.O-4, as such, he requested this Court to dismiss
both the appeals, by confirming the conviction and sentence
recorded by the learned Additional Sessions Judge.
13.
We have carefully scrutinized the entire evidence on record.
14.
Admittedly, P.Ws-1 to 8 are closely related to the deceased.
P.Ws-9 and 10 are the villagers, who were also shown as eye
witnesses to the incident. P.Ws-1 to 10 in their evidence have
categorically stated that A-4 hacked the deceased on his legs and
A-1 hacked the deceased on his head. But, as seen from the
medical evidence adduced through P.W-15, there was no injury on
the legs of the deceased. P.W-15, who conducted post mortem
examination over dead body, found only one injury on the head of
deceased, except the said injury, there is no other injury on the
body of deceased. So far as attack on P.W-1, P.W-2, P.Ws-6 to 8
is concerned, they were beaten by some of the accused. But,
there was no corroboration from the medical evidence adduced
through P.W-14.
The injuries attributed by P.W-1, P.W-2 and
P.Ws-6 to 8 were not tallying with the medical evidence adduced
through P.W-14.
KSR,J & JS,J
CRL.A.No.2572 & 2684 OF 2018
15.
P.W-6 in his evidence has stated that A-9 beat him with a
long handled spade on the head. But, the Medical Officer/P.W-14
found the said injury as simple injury.
P.W-14 has also found
another injury on left ring finger, which is grievous in nature. But,
P.W-6 did not attribute this injury to anyone.
16.
Even according to the prosecution, both groups formed into
an unlawful assembly, armed with deadly weapons and attacked
each other, as such, it can be safely concluded that it is a case of
free fight between the prosecution party on one side and the
accused on the other side.
17.
It is well settled by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case
of Vadivelu Thevar Vs. State of Madras1, that “in a case of free
fight, question of unlawful assembly and common object does not
arise and each accused were responsible for their individual acts.”
In the case on hand also, even according to the allegations in the
charge sheet, both groups formed into an unlawful assembly,
armed with deadly weapons and fought with each other, as such,
accused are liable for their individual acts.
18.
Coming to the overt acts attributed to accused, only
consistency in the evidence of P.Ws-1 to 10 is attack on the
1957(1) SCC 700
KSR,J & JS,J
CRL.A.No.2572 & 2684 OF 2018
deceased. All the ten witnesses in their evidence have stated that
initially A-4 hacked the deceased on his legs and when the
deceased fell down, A-1 hacked the deceased on his head with
M.O-4/axe. So far as attack on the prosecution witnesses i.e.,
P.W-1, P.W-2, P.Ws-6 to 8 is concerned, absolutely there is no
consistency in their evidence. Independent witnesses P.Ws-9 and
10 did not spoke about the attack on the prosecution witnesses by
the accused. They only say the attack on the deceased, as such,
we are not inclined to place any reliance on the so-called attack by
the accused on P.W-1, P.W-2 and P.Ws-6 to 8. But, the attack
made by A-1 on the deceased is concerned, though all the
witnesses have stated that A-1 hacked the deceased on his head
with an axe, but there is no corroboration from the medical
evidence adduced through P.W-15. P.W-15 in his evidence has
stated that the injury received by the deceased was possible by a
blunt object.
19.
At this stage, it is elicited by the defence in the cross-
examination of P.W-9 that A-1 used the stick portion of the axe,
and dealt a blow on the head of the deceased, as such, A-1 has
not used the sharp portion of the axe in attacking the deceased.
Except the head injury, there are no other injuries on the body of
deceased, as such, even if the case of the prosecution is accepted
KSR,J & JS,J
CRL.A.No.2572 & 2684 OF 2018
in entirety, the only injury established by the prosecution is injury
on the head of the deceased, which is attributed to A-1.
20.
As already pointed out, A-1 never used the sharp edge
portion of the axe in beating the deceased.
Further, A-1 also
received injuries at the hands of prosecution party, which is the
subject matter of C.C.669/2016 on the file of Judicial Magistrate of
First Class, Saluru, as such, it cannot by any stretch of
imagination be said that A-1 is guilty of the offence U/s.302 IPC.
If really A-1 is intended to kill the deceased, he ought not to have
stopped with one blow, and ought to have inflicted few more blows
on the deceased, as such, the conviction U/s.302 IPC passed
against
21.
A-1 is liable to be interfered with.
In the result, the Criminal Appeal No.2572 of 2018 is
allowed. The conviction and sentence recorded by the learned II
Additional District and Sessions Judge, Parvathipuram, against
the appellants/A-2, A-4, A-5, A-7, A-8 and A-9 in Sessions Case
No.4 of 2017 dated 06.09.2018 for the offences under Sections
324, 326 IPC is hereby set aside. The appellants/A-2, A-4, A-5,
A-7, A-8 and A-9 are acquitted for the offence under Sections 324,
326 IPC and the fine amount if any paid by the appellants/A-2,
A-4, A-5, A-7, A-8 and A-9, shall be refunded to them.
KSR,J & JS,J
CRL.A.No.2572 & 2684 OF 2018
22.
The Criminal Appeal No.2684 of 2018 is partly allowed. The
conviction and sentence recorded by the learned II Additional
District
and
Sessions
Judge,
Parvathipuram,
against
the
appellant/A-1 in Sessions Case No.4 of 2017 dated 06.09.2018 for
the offence under Section 302 IPC is hereby set aside. Instead,
the appellant/A-1 is convicted Section 304 Part-II of IPC. As the
appellant/A-1 has already served nearly six (06) years of
imprisonment, the period already undergone by him, shall meet
the ends of justice, while maintaining the fine amount.
23.
As the appellant/A-1 in Criminal Appeal No.2684 of 2018
was released on bail by order dated 18.03.2024 vide I.A.No.1 of
2024 in terms of orders passed by the Combined High Court in
Batchu Rangarao and others Vs. The State of Andhra
Pradesh (Crl.A.M.P.No.1687 of 2016 in Crl.A.No.607 of 2011), his
bail bonds shall stand cancelled.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, in both the
Criminal Appeals, shall stand closed in consequence.
_________________________
JUSTICE K. SURESH REDDY
__________________________
JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
KSR,J & JS,J
CRL.A.No.2572 & 2684 OF 2018
6th October, 2026
PSK
Whether the judgment is:
Speaking
Reportable
---
Reasoned
Non-Reportable
√
√
KSR,J & JS,J
CRL.A.No.2572 & 2684 OF 2018
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
32 & 33
CRIMINAL APPEAL No.2572 & 2684 OF 2018
6th October, 2026
W
PSK
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review