Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Criminal Jurisdiction)
DATED : 23rd AUGUST, 2016
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------S.B. : HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Crl.M.C. No.02 of 2016
Petitioners
:
1.
Malayala Manorama,
Represented by its Chief Editor,
Shri Mammen Mathew
having its Office at
Manorama Building,
Post Box No.26,
Kottayam – 686 001,
Kerala.
2.
Shri Mammen Mathew,
Chief Editor,
Malayala Manorama,
Manorama Building,
Post Box No.26,
Kottayam – 686 001, Kerala.
3.
Shri Philip Mathew,
Managing Editor,
Malayala Manorama,
Manorama Building,
Post Box No.26,
Kottayam – 686 001, Kerala.
4.
Shri Jacob Mathew,
Executive Editor,
Malayala Manorama,
Manorama Building,
Post Box No.26,
Kottayam – 686 001, Kerala.
5.
Shri Thomas Jacob,
Editorial Director,
Malayala Manorama,
Manorama Building,
Post Box No.26,
Kottayam – 686 001, Kerala.
Crl.M.C. No.02 of 2016
Malayala Manorama represented by its Chief Editor and Others
vs.
M/s. Future Gaming and Hotel Services Pvt. Ltd.
6.
Shri G. Vinod,
Chief Reporter,
Malayala Manorama,
Manorama Building,
Post Box No.26,
Kottayam – 686 001, Kerala.
7.
Shri Jiji Paul,
Chief Reporter,
Malayala Manorama,
Manorama Building,
Post Box No.26,
Kottayam – 686 001, Kerala.
8.
Shri Prakash Mathew,
Chief Reporter,
Malayala Manorama,
Manorama Building,
Post Box No.26,
Kottayam – 686 001, Kerala.
The above named Petitioners are represented by
Shri Lal John, Chief General Manager,
Personnel and Administration.
versus
Respondent
:
M/s. Future Gaming and Hotel Services Pvt. Ltd.
with its Corporate Office at
Samdrupling Building, Kazi Road, Gangtok,
East Sikkim – 7371 01,
Represented by Shri P. Ravichandran,
authorised Agent for the said Company
Application under Section 482 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. R. Basant, Senior Advocate with Mr. Millu Dandapani and
Mr. Ajay Rathi, Advocates for the Petitioners.
Ms. Laxmi Chakraborty and Ms. Manju Rai, Advocates for the
Respondent.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Crl.M.C. No.02 of 2016
Malayala Manorama represented by its Chief Editor and Others
vs.
M/s. Future Gaming and Hotel Services Pvt. Ltd.
ORDER
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
This Application under Section 482 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short “Cr.P.C.”), filed by the Petitioners
seeks issuance of notice upon the Respondent to Show Cause as to
why the impugned Complaint filed before the Learned Chief Judicial
Magistrate, East and North Sikkim, at Gangtok, should not be
quashed and the Order taking cognizance be set aside, as also the
process of issuance of Summons.
Prayer was also made to stay
further proceedings in connection with the Complaint pending before
the Court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, East and North, at Gangtok
and to exempt the Petitioners from appearance before the Learned
Trial Court in terms of Section 205 of the Cr.P.C.
2.
The Petitioners’ case is that the Petitioner No.1 is a
Malayalam Vernacular Daily Newspaper, under the name and style
“Malayala Manorama”. The Petitioners No.2 to 8 are the Editors in
various capacities of the Newspaper, which has been in the business
for the last 125 years.
That, a Complaint was lodged by the
Respondent before the Court of the Learned Chief Judicial Magistrate,
East and North, at Gangtok, being Private Complaint Case No.59 of
2015, inter alia, on grounds that the news published on 22-04-2015 had
defamed the Respondent Company. That, in fact, it was learnt that
the Central Government had banned the sale of Sikkim Lottery in the
Crl.M.C. No.02 of 2016
Malayala Manorama represented by its Chief Editor and Others
vs.
M/s. Future Gaming and Hotel Services Pvt. Ltd.
State of Kerala for an indefinite period due to financial irregularities
and several cases of cheating were registered by the Central Bureau of
Investigation against the Respondent Firm and Mr. Santiago Martin
with respect to cheating in lotteries, conducted in the State of Kerala
and are matters of record in Kerala. This news was duly reported in
the “Malayala Manorama” naming the Respondent Firm as being
involved in the case. It is contended by Counsel for the Petitioners
that it is no one’s case that the Newspaper was published in Sikkim
neither it is circulated in the State. Secondly, that even if an online
publication exists, there must be proof that it was accessed and
downloaded to establish circulation in Sikkim, but this is absent.
That, the Complainant before the Learned Trial Court has not averred
that either he or the other Prosecution Witnesses saw the publication
in Sikkim and downloaded it in Sikkim. Thus, in both the above
circumstances, there is no publication of the article in Sikkim as
required under Section 499 of the Indian Penal Code (for short “IPC”).
It is alleged herein that the Complaint is vexatious and has been filed
for harassment. The second ground raised was that, the Complainant
ought to indicate that it is the Respondent Company who is
aggrieved, but the Complaint reveals that it is Mr. Santiago Martin,
the Managing Director of the Company who is aggrieved and since it
is inconvenient for him to appear in Sikkim, the Complaint has been
foisted on the Company, which is registered in Tamil Nadu,
Crl.M.C. No.02 of 2016
Malayala Manorama represented by its Chief Editor and Others
vs.
M/s. Future Gaming and Hotel Services Pvt. Ltd.
therefore, leading to an infraction of Section 199 of the Cr.P.C. The
next contention canvassed was that the portion which is defamatory
has to be specifically indicated by the party concerned, although there
are eight accused persons being employees of the Newspaper in
question, no averment reveals that they were responsible for the
publication.
Reliance on this aspect was placed on S.M.S.
Pharmaceuticals Ltd. vs. Neeta Bhalla and Another1. That, the Press
and Registration of Books Act, 1867, states that only the Chief Editor
is to be held liable, therefore, an omnibus statement of defamation is
insufficient for the purposes of the case. Reliance on this submission
was placed on K. M. Mathew vs. State of Kerala and Another2. That,
in fact, the contents of the alleged defamatory publication are based
on the Notification of the Government of India, issued on 19-06-2015
and is not the creation of the Petitioners.
It is pointed out that
incorrect procedure was adopted by the Learned Magistrate by not
complying with the Procedure mandated in Section 202 of the Cr.P.C.
which after amendment in 2015 specifies that there should be an
enquiry by the Magistrate, more especially, when the accused is
residing at a place beyond the area of the Magistrate’s jurisdiction,
which has been ignored while taking cognizance.
That the Apex
Court in Vijay Dhanuka and Others vs. Najima Mamtaj and Others3
and Udai Shankar Awasthi vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and Another4
1. (2005) 8 SCC 89
2. (1992) 1 SCC 217 (Paragraph 9)
3. (2014) 14 SCC 638
4. (2013) 2 SCC 435
Crl.M.C. No.02 of 2016
Malayala Manorama represented by its Chief Editor and Others
vs.
M/s. Future Gaming and Hotel Services Pvt. Ltd.
has laid down that the compliance of provisions of Section 202 of the
Cr.P.C. are mandatory for the Magistrate to issue process. It is also
further contended that although Sections 499 and 500 of the IPC are
constitutional, but at the same time it cannot be used vexatiously
against the Petitioners, on this count, reliance was placed on the
decision of Subramaniam Swamy vs. Union of India, Ministry of
Law and Others5.
That, under Section 205 of the Cr.P.C. the
Magistrate can dispense with the personal attendance of the
Petitioners at the stage of Summons, but the Summons clearly
indicate absence of an alternative to the Petitioners.
Hence, the
prayers enumerated hereinabove.
3.
Per contra, it was argued by Learned Counsel for the
Respondent that the specific Paragraphs of the Complaint indicate the
portions which are defamatory.
Allegations of the Respondent
having looted the State have been published in the newspaper while
the Gazette Notification of the Government of India is devoid of such
allegations. It is also submitted that since the Respondent is not privy
to the private work distribution at the publication house, therefore,
each of the Petitioners are equally liable for the defamatory articles
for which the Petitioners cannot now be heard to say that the Press
and Registration of Books Act, 1867, affords them shelter. That,
the Managing Director of the Respondent is part and parcel of the
5. 2016 (5) Scale 379
Crl.M.C. No.02 of 2016
Malayala Manorama represented by its Chief Editor and Others
vs.
M/s. Future Gaming and Hotel Services Pvt. Ltd.
Company and the Complainant is the authorised representative of the
Company, who in his statement before the Learned Chief Judicial
Magistrate, has categorically mentioned that he as well as the
Management of the Company were informed of the defamatory news
articles dated 22-08-2015 and 26-08-2015 by well-wishers, friends and
acquaintances residing in various parts of the country including
Sikkim. With regard to the lack of territorial jurisdiction, it was urged
that the Petitioner No.1 owns a Website in the name and style of
‘manoramaonline.com’ and the online version of the Newspaper can
be accessed World Wide including in Sikkim and loggers have wide
options for translation of the vernacular version of its online
subscription. That, the Petitioners’ argument is confined to lack of
proof of access and downloading of online articles but admittedly
there is an online version. Drawing strength from the decision of Dr.
Subramanian Swamy (Accused) vs. Prabhakar S. Pai and Another6, it
was argued that Section 179 of the Cr.P.C. applies to the instant case,
which provides that the offence is triable where the act is done or
consequence ensues, hence in view of the circulation of the online
version the consequences have ensued within the local jurisdiction of
the Magistrate in Sikkim. That, it is not the Petitioners’ case that their
matter falls under any of the exceptions provided under Section 499
of the IPC, but even assuming so the matter has to be taken to trial
6. 1984 CRI.L.J.1329 (Bombay)
Crl.M.C. No.02 of 2016
Malayala Manorama represented by its Chief Editor and Others
vs.
M/s. Future Gaming and Hotel Services Pvt. Ltd.
and cannot be quashed at the threshold. The subject-matter being
publication in a Newspaper and its online version, the Petitioners
cannot now take a stand that it was not meant to be read. Assistance
in this regard was taken of two decisions of the Hon’ble Madras High
Court in Thirumurthi and Another vs. Muthusamy7 and Chellappan
Pillai vs. Karanjia8. It was also contended that the Notification of the
Government of India does not contain the name of Mr. Santiago
Martin or any of the Members of its Management or employees
except the person representing the Respondent, contrary to which the
news item commences with the caption “Santiago Martin duped Sikkim
of about Rs.22 crores in 5 years”. Vouching for the correctness of the
Order of the Learned Magistrate and compliance of Section 202 of the
Cr.P.C. it was put forth that the Complainant was examined, the
Complaint and the documents placed on record perused and after
application of judicial mind cognizance taken which, therefore,
cannot be faulted. That, Section 205 of the Cr.P.C. is the discretion of
the Learned Magistrate,
and
the
filing
of the Complaint is not
vexatious but has been filed within the jurisdiction of the concerned
Court. No Complaint in any other Court of Law has been filed with
regard to the news articles in question herein. Hence, the Petition be
dismissed.
7. MANU/TN/0637/1971
8. 1962 (2) CRI.L.J. 142 (Kerala)
Crl.M.C. No.02 of 2016
Malayala Manorama represented by its Chief Editor and Others
vs.
M/s. Future Gaming and Hotel Services Pvt. Ltd.
4.
I have heard Learned Counsel for both parties at length
and given anxious consideration to the submissions.
I have also
carefully perused the Judgments cited at the bar by Learned Counsel
for both parties.
5.
First, coming to the question of jurisdiction. Section 177
of the Cr.P.C. has been invoked by Learned Counsel for the
Petitioners to contend that the Court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate
at Gangtok has no jurisdiction in the matter, the publication and
circulation not having been made in Sikkim. Section 177 reads as
follows;
“177. Ordinary place of inquiry and
trial.−Every offence shall ordinarily be inquired into
and tried by a Court within whose local jurisdiction it
was committed.”
The Section needs no further elucidation.
6.
Per contra the Learned Counsel for the Respondent has
placed reliance on Section 179 of the Cr.P.C. which is extracted
hereinbelow for convenience;
“179. Offence triable where act is done or
consequence ensues.−When an act is an offence by
reason of anything which has been done and of a
consequence which has ensued, the offence may be
inquired into or tried by a Court within whose
local jurisdiction such thing has been done or such
consequence has ensued.”
To elucidate briefly, it transpires that, the consequences must
form an integral part of the offence and should not be a mere
Crl.M.C. No.02 of 2016
Malayala Manorama represented by its Chief Editor and Others
vs.
M/s. Future Gaming and Hotel Services Pvt. Ltd.
consequence
arising
therefrom,
thereby
meaning
that
the
consequence must be such as has to be proved, to establish the
offence. If the primary consequence completes the offence the mere
fact that there is a more remote consequence will not make Section
179 of the Cr.P.C. applicable. In the light of the above provisions,
what requires examination is as to whether the offence was
committed at all in the State of Sikkim as per the requirement under
Section 499 of the IPC which reads as follows;
“499. Defamation.−Whoever, by words either
spoken or intended to be read, or by signs or by visible
representations, makes or publishes any imputation
concerning any person intending to harm, or knowing
or having reason to believe that such imputation will
harm, the reputation of such person, is said, except in
the cases hereinafter expected, to defame that person.”
There are four Explanations and ten Exceptions to the Section.
It is undisputed that the publication of the offending articles was
made in the “Malayala Manorama” on 22-08-2015 and another similar
article went online on 26-08-2015. It is clear that in the instant matter
neither the publication of the Newspaper took place in Sikkim nor has
it been established that hard copies of the same were circulated in the
State. What remains the moot point now is since the publication went
online in the internet, therefore, would the Courts in Sikkim have
jurisdiction?
7.
In Rekhabai vs. Dattatraya and Another9 the Bombay
9. 1986 CRI.L.J. 1797 (Bombay)
Crl.M.C. No.02 of 2016
Malayala Manorama represented by its Chief Editor and Others
vs.
M/s. Future Gaming and Hotel Services Pvt. Ltd.
High Court held that the posting of a defamatory letter being
publication, in cases where the letter reaches its destination, the
offence itself is complied with the posting of the letter and gives
jurisdiction to the Court where the letter is posted and the
consequences which consisted in gaining publicity at the opening of
the letter at the other end and also gives jurisdiction where the
addressee resides. Therefore, in a defamation case, the venue of trial
could also be at the place where the letter was received and read. The
Allahabad High Court in Ashok Singhal vs. State of U.P. and
Another10 held that in case of defamation both Courts at the place
where the defamatory statement is made and also at the place where
the Newspaper in which defamation statement is published, is
circulated and read. Therefore, making it accessible to any person
who would access the internet and be able to understand the contents
thereof.
In Dr. Subramaniam Swamy6 (supra) the Bombay High
Court held that when an assailed statement was made at Chandigarh
and the Indian Express carried the impugned news item which was
published, circulated and read in the city of Bombay where the
Complainant resides, it was held that the consequence of the
statement made at Chandigarh was completed at Bombay by
circulation of the said papers and, therefore, the offence of
defamation is complete in the city of Bombay.
10. 2005 CRI.L.J. 2324 (Allahabad)
Crl.M.C. No.02 of 2016
Malayala Manorama represented by its Chief Editor and Others
vs.
M/s. Future Gaming and Hotel Services Pvt. Ltd.
8.
Here in the instant matter, it is not denied that the
offending article dated 26-08-2015 went online thereby making it
accessible to any person who would access the internet and be able to
understand the contents thereof.
The Respondent in his statement
before the Magistrate has stated that the Respondent has a Corporate
Office and business of the Company within the jurisdiction of this
Court. It has also been stated, inter alia, as follows;
“……………………………………………
I along with thousands of residents of Sikkim
who had known about the company and its operation
in Sikkim and other Indian states have been severely
disturbed and subject (sic, subjected) to a lot of ridicule
and mental agony owing to the slanderous and libelous
articles published by Accused Persons who had
conspired to defame our company and management.
…………………………………………………….”
Despite the above statement, no person who has read the online
version of the article in Sikkim was produced before the Court of the
Magistrate.
9.
In the Judgments of the various High Courts discussed
hereinabove, it is apparent that the cause of action arose on both sides
as it was established that the statement and publication was made in
one place whereas circulation was made in another place and duly
read by the public. By filing the Complaint the Respondent has failed
to point to any person who has in fact read the online version or
downloaded the same to make the offence under Section 499 of the
IPC complete and thereby extend jurisdiction to the Courts in Sikkim.
Crl.M.C. No.02 of 2016
Malayala Manorama represented by its Chief Editor and Others
vs.
M/s. Future Gaming and Hotel Services Pvt. Ltd.
Merely because there is an online circulation of the article the offence
will not be established until and unless it is proved that it was read in
Sikkim as well. In the circumstances, I cannot agree with Counsel for
the Respondent that Section 179 of the Cr.P.C. would apply to the
instant case.
In the facts and circumstances since it has not been
established that the consequence had ensued in Sikkim, merely
because the Corporate Office and Business of the Company is within
the jurisdiction of the Courts in Sikkim, does not necessarily mean
that jurisdiction for Section 499 of the IPC would also be extended.
Consequently, it is found that Learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, East
and North at Gangtok, has no jurisdiction to try the offences.
10.
With regard to the question of taking cognizance, a
careful perusal of Section 202 of the Cr.P.C. would indicate that the
provisions thereof have not been flouted. For convenience, the said
Section is reproduced hereinbelow;
“202. Postponement of issue of process.−(1)
Any Magistrate, on receipt of a complaint of an offence
of which he is authorised to take cognizance or which
has been made over to hi m under section 192 , may, if
he thinks fit, and shall, in a case where the accused is
residing at a place beyond the area in which he
exercises his jurisdiction postpone the issue of process
against the accused, and either inquire into the case
himself or direct an investigation to be made by a
police officer or by such other person as he thinks fit,
for the purpose of deciding whether or not there is
sufficient ground for proceeding:
Provided that no such direction for investigation
shall be made−
Crl.M.C. No.02 of 2016
Malayala Manorama represented by its Chief Editor and Others
vs.
M/s. Future Gaming and Hotel Services Pvt. Ltd.
(a) where it appears to the Magistrate that
the offence complained of is triable
exclusively by the Court of Sessions; or
(b) where the complaint has not been made
by a Court, unless the complainant and
the witnesses present (if any) have been
examined on oath under section 200.
(2) In an inquiry under sub-section (1), the
Magistrate may, if he thinks fit, take evidence of
witness on oath:
Provided that if it appears to the Magistrate that
the offence complained of is triable exclusively by the
Court of Session, he shall call upon the complainant to
produce all his witnesses and examine them on oath.
(3) If an investigation under sub-section (1) is
made by a person not being a police officer, he shall
have for that investigation all the powers conferred by
this Code on an officer in charge of a police station
except the power to arrest without warrant.”
11.
A perusal of the Orders of the Learned Magistrate dated
19-10-2015, 05-11-2015 and 04-12-2015 would clearly indicate that he
has taken all necessary steps as contemplated in the above Section.
The accused in the said Complaint are alleged to be residing beyond
the area in which the Magistrate exercises jurisdiction. In such an
event, the Section mandates that he shall postpone the issue of
process against an enquiry into the case himself or direct an
investigation.
In Vijay Dhanuka3 (supra) the Hon’ble Apex Court
has succinctly laid down that an inquiry under Section 202 of the
Cr.P.C. would mean in Paragraph 14 which reads as follows;
“14. In view of our answer to the aforesaid
question, the next question which falls for our
determination is whether the learned Magistrate before
issuing summons has held the inquiry as mandated
under Section 202 of the Code. The word "inquiry" has
Crl.M.C. No.02 of 2016
Malayala Manorama represented by its Chief Editor and Others
vs.
M/s. Future Gaming and Hotel Services Pvt. Ltd.
been defined under Section 2(g) of the Code, the same
reads as follows:
“2.
(g)
‘inquiry’
means
every
inquiry, other than a trial, conducted under this
Code by a Magistrate or court;”
It is evident from the aforesaid provision, every
inquiry other than a trial conducted by the Magistrate
or court is an inquiry. No specific mode or manner of
inquiry is provided under Section 202 of the Code. In
the inquiry envisaged under Section 202 of the Code,
the witnesses are examined whereas under
Section 200 of the Code, examination of the
complainant only is necessary with the option of
examining the witnesses present, if any. This exercise
by the Magistrate, for the purpose of deciding whether
or not there is sufficient ground for proceeding against
the accused, is nothing but an inquiry envisaged under
Section 202 of the Code.”
12.
From the Order dated 19-10-2015 on the date of filing of
the Complaint, it is seen that the matter was listed on 05-11-2015 on
which date the Complainant was examined.
An enquiry under
Section 202(1) of the Cr.P.C. requires the Magistrate if he thinks fit to
take evidence of witness on oath. This has also been duly complied
with as he has examined Complainant on oath and thereafter taken
cognizance and then only resorted to issuing Summons to the accused
persons.
Therefore, the Orders of the Learned Magistrate under
Section 202 of the Cr.P.C. cannot be faulted.
13.
While addressing the arguments pertaining to Section
205 of the Cr.P.C., this Section clothes the Magistrate with
discretionary powers if he sees reason to do so to dispense with the
personal attendance of the accused and permit him to appear by his
Crl.M.C. No.02 of 2016
Malayala Manorama represented by its Chief Editor and Others
vs.
M/s. Future Gaming and Hotel Services Pvt. Ltd.
pleader. The provisions thereof are not mandatory and in any event
on the first date the personal attendance of the accused persons are
required for the purposes of complying with formalities of bail.
Therefore, there appears to be no error on the part of the Magistrate
in this regard.
14.
In conclusion, although the Orders of the Learned Chief
Judicial Magistrate, East and North Sikkim, at Gangtok, under
Sections 202 and 205 of the Cr.P.C. cannot be faulted for the reasons
set out hereinabove, however, on account of lack of jurisdiction of the
said Court, the Order taking cognizance as also the process of
issuance of summons and Order for appearance of the Petitioners in
the Court are hereby set aside. No observations are, however, being
made on the other arguments forwarded, as it would tantamount to
foreclosing the issue on merits.
15.
Crl.M.C. is disposed of accordingly.
16.
No order as to costs.
Sd/-
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
23 -08-2016
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review