The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
25. 05.2026 is found to be one which is passed without any application of mind. For the afore-stated reasons, the impugned Rejection Order dated 25.05.2026 cannot stand the scrutiny of law and is, therefore, liable to be set aside. It is accordingly, set aside. Page No.# 16/16
31. As the order of rejection has been set aside, it is now the obligation of the Designated Public Servant to consider the application submitted by the petitioners for the notified public service,‘Composite Land Sale Transfer’ strictly in compliance of the provisions of Section 7[2] of the Assam Right to Public Services Act, 2012, as amended, the proviso to Section 21A of the Registration Act, 1908, as amended by the Registration [Assam Amendment] Act, 2009; and the Notification dated 11.11.2022; and to pass a speaking and reasoned order within the period of forty-five days from the date of submission of a copy of this order by the petitioner at the office of the Designated Public Servant.
32. With the observations made and directions given above, the writ petition stands allowed to the extent indicated above. There shall, however, be no order as to cost. Comparing Assistant Simanta Das DN: c=IN, o=Personal, postalCode=783384, l=Bongaigaon, st=Assam, street=TownAbhayapuri, Ward No4 Tengnamari , Bongaigaon, Bongaigaon Assam India 783384, title=8727,
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/16
GAHC010216152026
2026:GAU-AS:15511
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/5364/2026
MAJUMDAR RABHA AND ORS
SON OF LATE KAILASH RABHA,
2: RIPUNJOY RABHA
SON OF LATE KAILASH RABHA
3: NANDAN RABHA
SON OF LATE KAILASH RABHA
4: MANJOY RABHA
SON OF LATE KAILASH RABHA
ALL ARE RESIDENTS OF VILLAGEMALADHARA PART - I
POST OFFICEMALADHARA
POLICE STATIONLAKHIPUR
DISTRICT GOALPARA
ASSAM
PIN-783120.
5: DHANRAJ PANDIYA
SON OF BHANWAR LAL PANDIYA
PRESENTLY RESIDING AT GOALPARA TOWN
WARD NO. 8
POST OFFICE POLICE STATION GOALPARA
DISTRICT GOALPARA
ASSAM
PIN-783101 AND PERMANENT RESIDENT OF GANORA
POST OFFICE SUJANGARH
DISTRICT CHURU
RAJASTHAN
PIN- 33
VERSUS
Page No.# 2/16
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE
GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM, REVENUE AND DISASTER MANAGEMENT
DEPARTMENT, DISPUR, GUWAHATI-781006.
2:DISTRICT COMMISSIONER
GOALPARA DISTRICT
GOALPARA
ASSAM783101.
3:CIRCLE OFFICER
LAKHIPUR REVENUE CIRCLE
LAKHIPUR
DISTRICT GOALPARA
ASSAM-783129.
4:LAT MANDAL
NO. 15 LAT
LAKHIPUR REVENUE CIRCLE
LAKHIPUR
DISTRICT GOALPARA
ASSAM-783129
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. DITUL DAS, MR. B J TALUKDAR
Advocate for the Respondent : SC, REVENUE, GA, ASSAM
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE MANISH CHOUDHURY
JUDGMENT & ORDER
Date : 12-10-2026
1.
The petitioners, five in nos., have joined together to institute the present
writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India to assail an Order
dated 25.05.2026 passed by the Circle Officer, Lakhipur Revenue Circle, District Goalpara [the respondent no. 3]. By the Order dated 25.05.2026, the
respondent no. 3 has rejected an application submitted by the petitioners
seeking delivery of the notified public service, ‘Composite Land Sale Transfer’.
Page No.# 3/16
2.
The events leading to the Rejection Order dated 25.05.2026 can be
narrated, in brief, at first.
2.1. It is stated that the petitioner nos. 1-4 are the joint owners of a plot of
land measuring 1 Bigha & 1 Katha [‘the subject-plot’, for short] out of a larger
parcel of land measuring 2 Bighas, covered by Dag no. 587 of Khiraj Myadi Patta
no. 25, situate at Revenue Village – Maladhara Part-I, Lakhipur Revenue Circle,
District – Goalpara, Assam.
2.2. As there arose a necessity for the petitioner nos. 1-4 to sell the subjectplot, they entered into an agreement for sale of land with the petitioner no. 5.
To that effect, the petitioner nos. 1-4 sworn an affidavit on 16.02.2026 stating
inter-alia that the subject-plot was in their possession and they would not
become landless after the proposed sale.
2.3.
The petitioners had thereafter, submitted an application before the
respondent authorities for delivery of the notified public service, ‘Composite
Land Sale Transfer’ on 17.02.2026 and the receipt of the said application was
acknowledged by generating Application Reference no. NOC/03/ 37673/2026.
The application was submitted on-line in the comprehensive citizen platform,
SewaSetu.
2.4. The petitioners have further stated that while submitting the application all
the requisite documents were also submitted along with it. To the knowledge of
the petitioners, the respondent authorities had thereafter, commenced enquiry
Page No.# 4/16
for the purpose of deciding the application for delivery of the notified public
service, ‘Composite Land Sale Transfer’. While acknowledging the receipt of the
application submitted for the notified public service, ‘Composite Land Sale
Transfer’, it was stated that the notified public service would be provided within
forty-five days and the petitioners could file an appeal if the service was not
delivered within the stipulated delivery period.
2.5.
When
the
petitioners
tracked
their
Application
Reference
no.
NOC/03/37673/2026, in the comprehensive citizen platform, SewaSetu, the
status of their application is shown on 25.05.2026 as follows :- ‘The Application
is rejected by Circle Officer. [Insufficient documents (Pattadar fails to submit
documents even after follow-up by the CO). (As per LRA report case may be
rejected)]’.
3.
I have heard Mr. D. Das, learned counsel for the petitioners; Mr. J.
Handique, learned Standing Counsel, Revenue & Disaster Management
Department, Government of Assam for the respondent no. 1; and Mr. B.J.
Talukdar, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr. P.K. Medhi, learned Junior
Government Advocate, Assam for the respondent nos. 2, 3 & 4.
4.
Mr. Das, learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the service,
‘Composite Land Sale Transfer’ has been declared to be a notified public service
under the Assam Right to Public Services Act, 2012 [‘the ARTPS Act’, for short]
in all the districts vide a Notification bearing no. RDM-12011[17]/5/2022-LRREV-R&DM/95 [e-file no: 234314] dated 11.11.2022. As per the said
Notification, the Designated Public Servant [DPS] is the Deputy Commissioner
Page No.# 5/16
[presently, District Commissioner]/anyone to be nominated by the District
Commissioner. As per the said Notification and the Citizen Charter annexed
thereto as Annexure-I, the stipulated time limit for providing the service is fortyfive working days. Referring to the Rejection Order passed by the Designated
Public Servant, Mr. Das has submitted that the impugned Order is a nonspeaking and cryptic one. Considering the fact that the Rejection Order passed
by the Designated Public Servant under the provisions of the ARTPS Act is an
appealable order, the Designated Public Servant is obligated to record the
reasons while rejecting such an application. Non-recording of the reasons has
made the Rejection Order an arbitrary one and the same is liable to be set
aside. The learned counsel for the petitioners has referred to the provisions of
Section 21A of the Registration Act, 1908, as amended by the Registration
[Assam Amendment] Act, 2009, and Section 7[2] of the ARTPS Act, as
amended. Mr. Das, learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that a
similar issue regarding passing of non-speaking order in a matter of delivery of
notified public service has been dealt in a Judgment and Order dated
03.04.2025 passed in a writ petition, W.P.[C.] 1710/2025.
5.
The learned counsel for the official respondents have submitted that since
the Rejection Order is an appealable one, the petitioners instead of invoking the
extra-ordinary writ jurisdiction, ought to have approached the appellate
authority by preferring an appeal.
6.
I have duly considered the submissions of the learned counsel for the
parties and have also gone through the materials brought on record by the
petitioners. I have also gone through the provisions of the Assam Right to Public
Page No.# 6/16
Services Act, 2012, as amended, and Section 21A of the Registration Act, 1908
as amended by the Registration [Assam Amendment] Act, 2009.
7.
The Assam Right to Public Services [ARPTS] Act, 2012 has been enacted
by the Assam Legislative Assembly in order to provide for delivery of notified
public services to the people of the State of Assam within the stipulated time
limit and for matters connected therewith and incidental thereto. The ARTPS Act
received the assent of the Governor of Assam on 27.04.2012 and was notified
by a notification dated 02.05.2012. The ARTPS Act has been published in the
Assam Gazette in its issue dated 02.05.2012.
8.
As per Section 2[h], ‘Right to Public Service’ means right to obtain the
notified service under the ARTPS Act from time to time within the stipulated
time limit as prescribed under Section 5. Section 5 of the ARTPS Act has laid
down that every eligible person shall have the right to obtain the services in
accordance with the ARTPS Act within the time bound period as notified under
Section 4. It is the liability of the Designated Government Servant to deliver
services, under Section 6 of the ARTPS Act, within the stipulated period. The
stipulated time limit, as per Section 7[1], starts from the date when the
application for obtaining a required notified service is submitted to the
Designated Public Servant or to a person subordinate to him authorized to
receive the application. It is further mentioned that such application shall be
duly acknowledged.
9.
As per Section 7[2], the Designated Public Servant on receipt of an
application under sub-section [1] shall, within the stipulated time limit, provide
Page No.# 7/16
the notified service or reject the application and in case of rejection of
application, he shall record the reasons in writing and communicate to the
person making the application, [i] the reasons for such rejection; [ii] the period
within which an appeal against such rejection may be preferred; and [iii] the
particulars of the Appellate Authority.
10. Section 8 of the ARTPS Act has provided for an appeal before the Appellate
Authority and also for a review before the Reviewing Authority. As per subsection [1] of Section 8 any person, whose application is rejected under
subsection [2] of section 7 or who has not been provided the notified service
within the stipulated time limit, may file an appeal to the Appellate Authority
within thirty days from the date of rejection of application or the expiry of the
stipulated time limit.
11.
The first proviso to sub-section [1] of Section 8 has provided that
theAppellate Authority may admit the appeal after the expiry of the period of
thirty days but in no case beyond sixty days or the expiry of the stipulated time
limit for delivery of that particular notified service, if he is satisfied that the
appellant was prevented by sufficient cause from filing the appeal in time. The
second proviso to sub-section [1] of Section 8 has provided further that in case
of rejection of an application for a notified service for which any other law for
the time being in force prescribes remedy, the applicant shall follow the process
under such law for the time being in force.
12.
It may also be apposite to refer to the relevant provisions of the
Registration Act.
Page No.# 8/16
13. Entry 6 of List III [Concurrent List] of Seventh Schedule to the Constitution
of India has provided for 'Registration of Deeds and Documents'. The
Registration Act, 1908 is a Central Act and the States are empowered, because
of Entry 6 of List III, to make amendments in the Registration Act, 1908. A nos.
of States have made a number of amendments in the Registration Act, 1908.
The State of Assam has also made a number of amendments in the Registration
Act, 1908.
14.
The Registration Act, 1908 came to be amended by the Registration
[Assam Amendment] Act, 2009 with the insertion of Section 21A and again by
the Registration [Assam Amendment] Act, 2021. After those amendments,
Section 21A of the Registration Act, 2009 reads as under :21A. No registration of non-testamentary instruments with no objection
certificate.
Notwithstanding anything contained in any other provision of this Act, no non
testamentary instrument relating to immovable property. except for house, flat,
residential apartment, commercial building or any construction or structure
erected on a plot of land, shall be accepted for registration, unless the Deputy
Commissioner of the concerned district issues a No Objection Certificate
containing the description of such immovable property to be transferred and also
such other No objection Certificates, which are required to be issued by the
Deputy Commissioner or any other Authority under any law for the time being in
force or under any Executive Instruction, Order etc. issued by the State
Government from time to time;
Page No.# 9/16
Provided that all such No Objection Certificates shall be issued within a period of
thirty days from the date of the receipt of application and in case No Objection
Certificate is not issued within the stipulated period of thirty days, a speaking
order with reasons thereof shall be issued to the applicant within the said
stipulated period.
15.
The main enacting part of Section 21A, quoted above, is with a non-
obstante clause. It has provided that no non-testamentary instrument relating
to immovable property shall be accepted for registration unless the Deputy
Commissioner of the concerned district issues a No Objection Certificate
containing the description of such immovable property to be transferred and
also such No Objection Certificates, which are required to be issued by the
Deputy Commissioner or any other Authority under any law for the time being in
force or under any Executive Instruction, Order, etc. issued by the State
Government from time to time.
16.
In the proviso to Section 21A of the Registration Act, 1908, it is provided
that all such No Objection Certificates shall be issued within a period of thirty
days from the date of receipt of application and in case No Objection Certificate
is not issued within the stipulated period of thirty days, a speaking order with
reasons thereof shall be issued to the applicant within the said stipulated
period.
17.
The provisions of Section 7[2] of the Assam Right to Public Services Act,
2012, as amended, and the proviso to Section 21A of the Registration Act, 1908,
as amended by the Registration [Assam Amendment] Act, 2009, have cast
obligation respectively on the District Commissioner and the Designated Public
Page No.# 10/16
Servant to record the reasons in the event it decides he does not issue the No
Objection Certificate with a period of thirty days or he rejects an application for
a notified public service.
18.
In the case in hand, the application submitted by the petitioners for the
notified public service, ‘Composite Land Sale Transfer’ has been rejected by the
respondent no. 3 citing the following reason : ‘The Application is rejected by
Circle Officer. [Insufficient documents (Pattadar fails to submit documents
even after follow-up by the CO). (As per LRA report case may be rejected)]’.
19.
The Notification dated 11.11.2022 is on the subject :- ‘Declaration of
Service under Revenue & DM Department as per provision of the Assam Right to
Public Services Act, 2012 in all Districts [except sixth scheduled Districts] of
Assam. The notification has been issued with a view to provide delivery of public
service to eligible citizens within the stipulated time limit and others as under :Subject: Declaration of Service under Revenue & DM Department as per
provision of the Assam Right to Public Services Act, 2012 in all
Districts [except sixth scheduled Districts] of Assam
With a view to provide the delivery to Public Service to eligible citizens within
stipulated time limit, Revenue & DM Department in continuation of earlier
Notification No. RSS.203/2022/1 dated 6th May 2022 has notified the below
service under the Assam Right to Public Services Act, 2012.
Service Name : Composite Land Service Transfer
An important service provided by the Deputy Commissioner regarding Land Sale
permission is ‘NoC for Transfer of Immovable Property’ under section 21[A] of the
Indian Registration Act, 1908. However once NoC is issued by the O/o the
Page No.# 11/16
Deputy Commissioner, applicant has to apply for Registration of the Scheduled
land in Sub Registrar Office following separate applications for Mutation,
Partition, Jamabandi etc. in the concerned Circle Office.
‘Composite Land Sale Transfer’ intends for issuing No Objection Certificate for
the Transfer of Immovable property at O/o Deputy Commissioner followed by
Registration of Property at the Sub Registrar Office followed by auto mutation
and auto Composite Land Sale Transfer Service with ‘Auto Mutation’ or ‘Auto
Mutation along with Partition’ at the time of submitting the Application form.
Eligibility criteria :
Anyone in whose name figures in Jamabandi/Record of Rights or his/her legal
heir/successor or his/her registered power of attorney holder is eligible to avail
the service online.
Designated Public Servant [DPS]:
Deputy Commissioner/to the nominated by Deputy Commissioner.
20.
The Notification has also provided for procedural steps to be followed by
the authorities involved in providing the notified public services. As per the
Citizen Charter annexed to the Notification as Annexure-I, for the notified public
service ‘Composite Land Sale Transfer’, the Deputy Commissioner or the
authority to be nominated by the Deputy Commissioner is the Designated Public
Servant and the stipulated time limit for providing the service is mentioned as
forty-five days. In the Citizen Charter, the Commissioner of Divisions has been
mentioned as the appellate authority.
21.
It is submitted by Mr. Handique, learned Standing Counsel, Revenue &
Disaster Management Department that the office of the Commissioner of
Page No.# 12/16
Divisions has been abolished in the meantime and presently, by another
notification dated 16.11.2023, the Revenue & Disaster Management Department
has been made the appellate authority.
22.
On perusal of the impugned Rejection Order, it is evidently clear that the
impugned order is not in conformity with Section 7[2] of the ARTPS Act and
Section 21A of the Registration Act, 1908 as amended by the Registration
[Assam Amendment] Act, 2009.
23.
A speaking order is one which expressly states the reasons for the
decision. In other words, a speaking order speaks for itself by assigning the
reasons behind the conclusion. If an order is passed without giving a reason by
the concerned authority, more particularly, when the authority is statutory
authority then the order is a non-speaking one. Non-speaking order is one
which does not provide a clear reason for its decision. The authority exercising
the statutory power must record reasons for its decision, unless such obligation
is not expressly or impliedly dispensed with. It is implicit in the principles of
natural justice and fair play that an authority which has been vested with the
power to decide the matter should record reasons as it is part of fair procedure,
more particularly, when the decision is likely to affect the person concerned. In
the case in hand, the right of the applicant is also traceable to Article 300A of
the Constitution. Though the right provided in Article 300A is not fundamental
right, but it is still a constitutional and human right. Recording of reasons is also
prima facie suggestive of conscious application of mind on the part of the
authority. The obligation to record reasons is a possible check against arbitrary
action on the part of the authority invested with the statutory power to take a
Page No.# 13/16
decision which is likely to affect the right of the person concerned. When the
statute itself contains a prescription to record reasons in the decision, absence
of reasons in the decision falls short of prescription and would be in violation of
the prescription and thus, illegal.
24.
It has been canvassed on behalf of the official respondents that the
petitioners have approached this Court by filing the instant writ petition in order
to invoke the extra ordinary remedy instead of availing an alternative statutory
remedy which is adequate and efficacious. It is settled law that even in
presence of an alternative, efficacious and statutory remedy of appeal, a writ
petition under article 226 of the Constitution of India is maintainable on the
ground :- [i] where the writ petitioner seeks enforcement of any of the
fundamental rights; or [ii] where there is failure of principles of natural justice;
or [iii] where the orders or proceedings are wholly without jurisdiction; or [iv]
where the vires of an Act is challenged. In these circumstances, an alternative
remedy does not operate as a bar.
25.
The recording of reasons in the order passed by the Designated Public
Servant who deals with the matter at the first stage, is necessary. The
responsibility to record reasons is higher when the order to be passed by the
original authority at the first stage by the Designated Public Servant is an
appealable order. An order which affects the right of a citizen or a person,
requires recording of reasons as the reasons recorded would aid the appellate
authority to see whether the original authority concerned has acted fairly and
reasonably to the aggrieved person. The recording of reasons in the order, more
particularly, when the adverse order has the possibility of impacting a citizen or
Page No.# 14/16
a person adversely is necessary as then only the person aggrieved can have the
knowledge of the reasons as to why the order has been passed and he can have
a proper opportunity to demonstrate before the appellate authority that the
reasons which impelled the Designated Public Servant to pass the adverse order
against him, are erroneous, arbitrary, untenable or unjust.
26.
In the case in hand, the Designated Public Servant has only mentioned
that the application has been rejected on the ground of non-submission of
sufficient documents without mentioning anything about the documents, which
were not submitted with the application to enable the petitioner to meet the
deficiencies, if there is any, and to submit a fresh application or to prefer an
appeal.
27.
The petitioners have alleged violation of the principles of natural justice.
The Designated Public Servant while deciding their applications for the notified
public service, by not passing a reasoned and speaking order has violated the
principles of natural justice.
28.
In view of the above fact situation, this Court is of the considered view
that when the incident of vulnerability of the Rejection Order on the touchstone
of not meeting the statutory prescription of recording reasons and violation of
principles of natural justice is considered against the point canvassed by the
official respondents regarding non-filing of appeal it is the vulnerability of the
Rejection Order passed in the application which would far outweigh the other
reason regarding the petitioners not approaching the appellate forum.
Page No.# 15/16
29. In the above obtaining fact situation, the Court finds it apposite to refer to
the following observations made in the decision in Mohinder Singh Gill and
another vs. Chief Election Commissioner, New Delhi and others, [1978] 1 SCC
405 :“8. The second equally relevant matter is that when a statutory functionary
makes an order based on certain grounds, its validity must be judged by the
reasons so mentioned and cannot be supplemented by fresh reasons in the
shape of affidavit or otherwise. Otherwise, an order bad in the beginning may, by
the time it comes to court on account of a challenge, get validated by additional
grounds later brought out. We may here draw attention to the observations of
Bose J. in GordhandasBhanji :
Public orders, publicly made, in exercise of a statutory authority cannot be
construed in the light of explanations subsequently given by the officer
making the order of what he meant, or of what was in his mind, or what
he intended to do. Public orders made by public authorities are meant to
have public effect and are intended to effect the actings and conduct of
those to whom they are addressed and must be construed objectively
with reference to the language used in the order itself.
Orders are not like old wine becoming better as they grow older.”
30.
Thus, from every stand point, the impugned Rejection Order dated
25.05.2026 is not a speaking order as such, the impugned order dated
25.05.2026 is found to be one which is passed without any application of mind.
For the afore-stated reasons, the impugned Rejection Order dated 25.05.2026
cannot stand the scrutiny of law and is, therefore, liable to be set aside. It is
accordingly, set aside.
Page No.# 16/16
31. As the order of rejection has been set aside, it is now the obligation of the
Designated Public Servant to consider the application submitted by the
petitioners for the notified public service,‘Composite Land Sale Transfer’ strictly
in compliance of the provisions of Section 7[2] of the Assam Right to Public
Services Act, 2012, as amended, the proviso to Section 21A of the Registration
Act, 1908, as amended by the Registration [Assam Amendment] Act, 2009; and
the Notification dated 11.11.2022; and to pass a speaking and reasoned order
within the period of forty-five days from the date of submission of a copy of this
order by the petitioner at the office of the Designated Public Servant.
32.
With the observations made and directions given above, the writ petition
stands allowed to the extent indicated above. There shall, however, be no order
as to cost.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
Simanta
Das
DN: c=IN, o=Personal, postalCode=783384, l=Bongaigaon,
st=Assam, street=TownAbhayapuri, Ward No4 Tengnamari ,
Bongaigaon, Bongaigaon Assam India 783384, title=8727,
2.5.4.20=caa9a1c0be943e0740ca5dfbbfb8695db6814b4620
2926df0aea3036caed4e3c,
serialNumber=d950a33227bd4a5ce185958e9d34bdfd7c09a
2ca0a1f463628d94fa581ffcb03,
email=simnds08@gmail.com, cn=Simanta Das
Date: 2026.10.13 17:21:32 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review