Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
‘APHC010595462008
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA
PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3459]
FRIDAY, THE THIRTEENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 1143/2008
Between:
1. MAJJI DEVUDU, S/O.APPANNA R/O.NEAR MANIPURAM
RAILWAY GATE, MANGALAGIR ROAD, GUNTUR DISTRICT.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. SRI
B
SRINIVAASA
REDDY,
M/S.B.V.SUBBA
REDDY
CONSTRUCTIONS OWNER OF TIPPER NO.AP 09 X 5529
R/O.D.NO.5-8-51/1,
FATHE
SULTHAN
LINE,
NAMPALLI,
HYDERABAD.
2. THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER, UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO LTD
THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER, UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO
LTD., 15/1, ARUNDELPEET, GUNTUR.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal Under Section 30 of Act against orders
IA NO: 1 OF 2006(CMAMP 1440 OF 2006
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be
pleased condone the delay of 30 days in filing the CMA
JS,J
C.M.A.No.1143 of 2008
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. A RAJENDRA BABU
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. 2. NARESH BYRAPANENI
This Court made the following:
JS,J
C.M.A.No.1143 of 2008
JUDGMENT:
This appeal is filed against the order dated 25-01-2006 in
W.C. No. 61 of 2004, on the file of the Commissioner for Workmen's
Compensation and the Assistant Commissioner of Labour-I Circle at
Guntur (for short “the Commissioner”), by raising the following substantial
question of law for consideration:
(i) Whether the court below is right in assessing the loss of earning
capacity to an extent of percentage of permanent partial disability
sustained in an accident arising out of and in the course of
employment?
(ii) Whether the court below has materially erred in assessing the
compensation, taking the 30% loss of earning capacity?
(iii) Whether the court below is justified in not awarding interest on
the compensation amount?
(iv) Whether the court below is justified in taking only the minimum
wages fixed by the Government for assessing the compensation?
2.
The appellant has raised various grounds in the present appeal, and
they are as follows:
(a) The court below erred in awarding Rs.72,159/- towards
compensation against the claim of Rs.3,00,000/- .
(b) The court below erred in taking only minimum wages fixed by the
Government for a cleaner while assessing the compensation and
JS,J
C.M.A.No.1143 of 2008
minimum wages fixed by the Government is only a guiding factor
and necessarily the same for assessing the compensation.
(c) The court below erred in fixing the loss of earning capacity at
25% through the doctor who treated the appellant and categorically
stated in his evidence that the physical disability suffered by the
appellant is to an extent of 20% to 25% and it is permanent in nature
and he is totally unfit to work as a cleaner and ought to have taken
the loss of earning capacity of the appellant as 100% and awarded
the compensation on the basis of earning capacity by applying
Section 2(1) of the Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923 (for short
“the W.C. Act”).
(d) The claim of the appellant is that he was earning Rs.3,000/- per
month which was just and reasonable and the same does not
warrant any reduction.
3.
The learned Commissioner has thoroughly examined the matter
before him. After reviewing the documents submitted by the appellant,
namely, the FIR (Ex.A-1), Charge Sheet (Ex.A-2), Wound Certificate
(Ex.A-3), Doctor Certificate (Ex.A-4), Medical Prescriptions (Ex.A-5),
Insurance Policy (Ex.A-6=Ex.R-1), Registration Certificate (Ex.A-7), Driving
Licence (Ex.A-8=Exs.R-2&3), and Goods Carriage Permit (Ex.A-9)—as
well as the evidence provided by the parties, the Commissioner concluded
that the applicant was a workman and sustained personal injuries in an
accident arising out of and during the course of employment with the
opposite party-I. The applicant's age at the time of the accident was
determined to be 30 years. In determining the compensation, the minimum
JS,J
C.M.A.No.1143 of 2008
wages applicable to a cleaner in public motor transport, as specified in
G.O.Ms.No.390 dated 27.07.2000, were taken into account. Accordingly,
the wages of the applicant amounting to Rs.2313/- per month were fixed in
accordance
with
the
provisions
of
the
Worker’s
Compensation
(Amendment) Act, 2000.
4.
The evidence of the Doctor and Exs.A-3 to A-6 were duly
considered, leading to the conclusion that the appellant is unable to squat
or sit like a normal person and is consequently unfit for the occupation
undertaken prior to his injury. Accordingly, the applicant's physical
disability is 20% to 25%. The Commissioner has concluded that 25% of
earning capacity has been lost and has arrived at a compensation amount
of Rs.72,304/- to be paid by the respondents within 30 days of receipt of a
copy of the order. Aggrieved against the same, the appellant is before this
Court.
5.
The case of the appellant is that he was a cleaner employed by the
1st respondent/Opposite Party-1 in a tipper bearing registration No. AP09X-5529. On 22.06.2004, an accident occurred at Patchalatadiparru
village of Ponnur in Guntur District, and a case was registered as Crime
No.71/2004 on the file of the SHO, Ponnur. As a result, he sustained
grievous injuries to the left leg. He received treatment from Doctor, AW-2.
The appellant was 30 years old at the time of the accident and was earning
Rs.3,000/- per month. The Respondent No.1, who had insured the said
tipper with the 2nd Respondent/Opposite Party-2, is liable to compensate
the appellant for the injuries sustained in an accident arising out of and in
the course of his employment. The insurance policy is valid from
JS,J
C.M.A.No.1143 of 2008
05.12.2003 to 04.12.2004. The appellant, who has sustained 100%
disability and cannot work as he did earlier, therefore, prays for
compensation of Rs.3,00,000/-.
6.
The learned counsel for the appellant would rely on various
judgments in support of his contentions, and the same are extracted
hereunder:
(i). The judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in Indira Bai Vs.
Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. &Anr. {Civil Appeal No. 4492
(SLP (Civil) No.138/2023)} - wherein the total disablement has been
defined and same runs as under:
25. “Total disablement” is defined by section 2(1)(l) as
follows:"Total disablement" means such disablement, whether of a
temporary or permanent nature, as incapacitates a workman
for all work which he was capable of performing at the time of
the accident resulting in such disablement:
Provided that permanent total disablement shall be deemed to
result from every injury specified in Part I of Schedule I or from
any combination of injuries specified in Part II thereof where
the aggregate percentage of the loss of earning capacity,
earning capacity, as specified in the said Part II against those
injuries, amounts to one hundred percent or more;”
26. In Pratap Narain Singh Deo v. Srinivas Sabata and
another, decided by a four-Judge Bench of the Apex
Court, the injured workman was a carpenter by profession
and by loss of left hand above the elbow, he was evidently
rendered unfit for the work of carpentry and, therefore, the
Commissioner awarded compensation by considering
JS,J
C.M.A.No.1143 of 2008
permanent disability as total, i.e., 100%. The employer raised
an argument that the injury did not result in permanent total
disablement of the workman and therefore, the Commissioner
committed a gross error of law in taking a view that there was
total disablement. In that context, the Apex Court held: “5. The expression "total disablement" has been defined in
section 2(1)(l) of the Act as follows:
"total disablement" means such disablement, whether of a
temporary or permanent nature, as incapacitates a workman
for all work which he was capable of performing at the time of
the accident resulting in such disablement."
It has not been disputed before us that the injury was of such
a nature as to cause permanent disablement to the
respondent, and the question for consideration is whether the
disablement incapacitated the respondent for all work which
he was capable of performing at the time of the accident. The
Commissioner has examined the question and recorded his
finding as follows:
"The injured workman in this case is a carpenter by
profession.... By loss of the left hand above the elbow, he has
evidently been rendered unfit for the work of carpenter, as the
work of carpentry cannot be done by one hand only."
This is obviously a reasonable and correct finding. Counsel for
the appellant has not been able to assail it on any ground and
it does not require tobe corrected in this appeal.”
(ii). The judgment of the High Court of Judicature for the
States of Andhra Pradesh and Tamilnadu in N. Sree Ramulu
@ Sree Rama Murthy Vs. B. Lakshmi Naryana and another
reported in 2013 (5) ALD 249 - wherein the extent of
permanent disability and effect of permanent disability on
earning capacity of injured and percentage of loss of earning
JS,J
C.M.A.No.1143 of 2008
and relevancy of opinion of medical practitioner are dealt with
as under:
“28. C.M.A.No.2197 of 2003:
In this case, the Appellant suffered an accident on
10.6.2001 when he was driving a Lorry of the 1st Respondent
resulting in the crushing of his right leg and fracture of his left
leg. AW-II, the Medical Practitioner stated that the Claimant
suffered injuries to the right lower limb and fracture to both
bones of left leg above knee; amputation was done for the
right thigh and fixation was done for fracture of left leg; he is
not fit for driving the vehicle; that Partial Permanent Disability
is 80%; and Loss of Earning Capacity is 100%. He also issued
Ex. A2-Medical Certificate. The Commissioner however held
that Loss of Earning Capacity is only 80% and awarded
Compensation on the said basis.
When the Medical evidence is clear that the Loss of
Earning Capacity is 100%, the fact that the Claimant who was
employed as a Lorry Driver at the time of the accident is not fit
for driving the vehicle in view of amputation on the right side
above knee and malunion of the left leg, it has to be held that
the Loss of Earning Capacity is 100%. In my opinion, the
Commissioner erred in granting Compensation on the basis
that Loss of Earning Capacity of the Claimant is only 80%.
Therefore, the Appeal is allowed and the order dated 1.4.2003
in W.C. No. 51 of 2002 of the Commissioner for Workmen's
Compensation and Asst. Commissioner of Labour-I, Guntur is
set aside. Compensation shall be assessed and paid to the
Appellant on the basis that his Loss of Earning Capacity is
100%. The Appeal is accordingly allowed. No costs.”
(iii). The judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in Saberabibi
Yakubbahai Shaikh and others Vs. National Insurance Co.
Ltd. and others reported in 2014 ACJ 467 and the judgment
JS,J
C.M.A.No.1143 of 2008
of this Court in Konukola Vemulaiah Vs. S. Haribabu (CMA
No.1045/2009) - wherein claimants are entitled to interest at
the rate of 12% from the date of accident.
It is observed in Para 10 of the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex
Court in Saberabibi Yakubbahai Shaikh case, as under:
“10. We have perused the aforesaid judgment. We are of the
considered opinion that the aforesaid judgment relied upon by
the learned counsel for the appellants is fully applicable to the
facts and circumstances of this case. This Court considered
the earlier judgment relied upon by the High Court and
observed that the judgments in the case of National Insurance
Co. Ltd. v. Mubasir Ahmed [(2007) 2 SCC 349] and Oriental
Insurance Co. Ltd.v. Mohd. Nasir [(2009) 6 SCC 280] were per
incuriam having been rendered without considering the earlier
decision in Pratap Narain Singh Deov. Srinivas Sabata [(1976)
1 SCC 289]. In the aforesaid judgment, upon consideration of
the entire matter, a four-judge Bench of this Court had held
that the compensation has to be paid from the date of the
accident.”
7.
The 1st respondent/Opposite Party-I remained unrepresented. The
appellant's claim was contested by Respondent No. 2/Opposite Party-II. It
was argued that the appellant failed to produce the authenticated
documents, such as proof of age, wages, employment, and treatment. The
policy excludes liability towards the cleaner, and the appellant's claim is
exorbitant and not entertainable, as the assessment of the appellant's loss
of earning capacity at 100% conflicts with the provisions of the Act.
Respondent No. 2 cited a judgment, in support of this contention, in
National Insurance Company Limited v. D. Sivasankar reported in 2006
(4) ALD 398, wherein it is held thus:
JS,J
C.M.A.No.1143 of 2008
“14. The Commissioner, however, proceeded to take the
disability as well as L.E.C., at 100%. The reason furnished by
the Commissioner is that, on account of the injury to his leg,
the 1st respondent is not able to walk freely, and in that view
of the matter, he cannot drive the vehicle. He referred to
certain judgments rendered by various Courts, which are to
the effect that, even if the disablement is not total, the L.E.C.
can be assessed at 100%, depending on the facts.
15. Schedule-I of the W.C. Act enlists different categories of
injuries, in two parts, and indicates the extent of L.E.C.,
resulting out of such injuries. All the injuries specified in Part-I
are deemed to have resulted in 100% L.E.C. The injury
sustained by the 1st respondent is not the one, that occurs in
Part-I of Schedule-I.”
8.
The learned counsel for the appellant argued that the main issue in
this appeal is whether the doctor's statement, which states that the injured
person has a physical disability between 20% to 25% and is permanently
unfit to work as a cleaner, should be interpreted as a complete loss of
earning capacity. If so, this would justify compensation for a 100% loss of
earning capacity under Section 2(1) of the W.C.Act. The learned counsel
also pointed out that when an injury does not fall under Part I or Part II of
Schedule 1 of the Act, the correct legal provision is Section 4(1)(c)(ii) of the
W.C. Act, which permits estimating 100% loss under earning capacity. It
was highlighted that the doctor’s description relates only to impairment, not
to the person’s ability to earn. As noted earlier, the disability has been
considered as a total loss of earning capacity.
9.
It is an undisputed fact that the appellant/claimant was employed as
a vehicle cleaner. Ex.A3 is the wound certificate and Ex.A4 is the doctor’s
certificate. The injuries were certified by a qualified doctor, AW2, who
examined the claimant. He estimated the disability at 20% to 25% and
JS,J
C.M.A.No.1143 of 2008
opined that the injuries were grievous in nature, comprising a soft tissue
injury to the left leg and foot, with restricted movement of the left knee joint,
ankle and foot. The claimant is unable to squat or sit normally and is not fit
for the occupation.
10.
In the judgment of the Delhi High Court in NEW INDIA
ASSURANCE CO. LTD Vs. MOHARMAN & Anr., reported in 2024 ACJ
1511, it is clarified that the worker such as a cleaner or driver sustains 20%
to 25% physical injury that impairs their ability to perform their prior work, it
amounts to a 100% loss of earning capacity. The Court emphasized that
functional disability—the inability to perform the same work—is more
significant for compensation than the percentage of physical impairment.
11.
It is to be treated as total disablement. For example, if a professional
driver or a carpenter loses a limb, the Court may rule that the loss of
earning capacity is 100%, even if Schedule-I or a medical report suggests
a lower percentage for the physical injury. Further, if the injury is not listed
in Schedule-I, the percentage of earning capacity is estimated via a
medical certificate from a qualified Medical Practitioner under Section 4 (c)
(2). The Court has the authority to consider the disability as 100% and
grant full compensation if the injury causes a total loss of the employee’s
liability to perform the specific job they were employed for at the time of the
accident, regardless of whether the injury is scheduled or not.
12.
The Commissioner determined that the disability was 25%. After
evaluating the available evidence, the Commissioner concluded that the
appellant is permanently unfit for cleaner work. It is also noted that the
appellant was 30 years old at the time of the accident and that his monthly
wages were Rs.3,000/- and the Commissioner held that the compensation
JS,J
C.M.A.No.1143 of 2008
amount should be calculated according to Section 4(1)(b) of the Act, with
the monthly salary multiplied as per G.O. Ms. No.390 dated 27.07.2000.
13.
The disability, as determined by the statute, is a specific loss of soft
tissue in the left leg and restriction of movement of the left knee. In the
event of more than one such loss, it cannot be said that a mere
aggregation would determine the actual loss. A true medical certificate had
been produced, which would have aided the Court in assessing the
functional disability. However, the fact remains that the appellant, a
cleaner, on account of injury to his left leg, could neither stand for a long
time nor fold his leg, and was required to use a walking aid. He could not
lift heavy objects and would be entitled to compensation, taking the
disability as 100% or less, as per medical opinion. Notably, in this case,
the doctor had certified that the workman had suffered 25% permanent
partial disability with relevant factor 207.98. Though the 100% liability
cannot
be
assessed,
insofar
as
the
appellant
injury
is
concerned. Therefore, for permanent partial disability, the compensation is
calculated as a percentage of the compensation payable for total
disablement, based on the loss of earning capacity.
14.
The loss would be assessed and it comes to Rs.93,591/- (Rs.3,000/-
x 60% x 207.98 x 0.25%). The appellant shall also be entitled to 12%
interest from the date of the accident, and the appeal stands allowed with
the above direction.
15.
As a result, the Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is allowed. No costs.
JS,J
C.M.A.No.1143 of 2008
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, if any pending, shall stand
closed.
_________________________
JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
13th February, 2026
cbs
JS,J
C.M.A.No.1143 of 2008
THE HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
C.M.A.No.1143 of 2008
13th February, 2026
cbs
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review