The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
7. 5. Therefore, in view of the aforesaid analysis, this Court is inclined to quash order dated 06.02.2023 so issued under Annexure-6, wherein benefit of regularization of promotion was treated to have been issued prospectively and quash the same accordingly. While quashing order dated 06.02.2023, this Court in the alternate upheld the order issued under Annexure-4 dated04.10.2019, and direct the Opp. Parties to continue with such order with extension of the benefits as due and admissible in favour of the petitioners.
8. Both the Writ Petition stand disposed of accordingly. (Biraja Prasanna Satapathy) Judge Basudev Reason: Authentication Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) Nos.38132 & 38135 of 2023
Arun Kumar Mohapatra
….
Petitioner
Mr. M.K. Mishra, Sr. Advocate
with Mr. S. Senapati, Advocate
-versusState of Odisha and Ors.
….
Opposite Parties
Mr. S.P. Das, ASC
Mr. B.K. Dash, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. S.R. Dash, Advocate for O.P. No.3
CORAM:
JUSTICE BIRAJA PRASANNA SATAPATHY
Order No.
17. 1.
This
matter
ORDER
24.06.2026
is taken up
through
Hybrid
Arrangement (Virtual/Physical) Mode.
2.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
3.
The present Writ Petition has been filed inter alia
with the following prayer:“It is, therefore, humbly prayed that this Hon’ble
Court: may graciously be pleased to issue rule nisi
calling upon the 0pp. Parties to show cause as to why
writ/writs shall not be issued quashing the impugned
Minutes of the Meeting (resolution) dtd.30.12.2021
under Annexure -.6(A), the Minutes of 43rd Meeting
(resolution) dtd. 19.11.2022 under Annexure-6(B),
Resolution of DPC dtd.21.12.2020 under Annexure-10
and the consequential dtd.06.02.2023 Annexure-6 and
as to why the promotion of the petitioner to the post of
Asst. Director (Technical) shall not be regularised w.e.f
dtd.27.04.1998 as per order dtd.04.10.2019 and
further be pleased to direct the authorities/Opp. Parties
to give promotion to the petitioner to the post of Deputy
// 2 //
Director(Technical) within a stipulated time and perusal
of causes shown if any or insufficient causes shown,
make the said rule absolute and may pass such other
order/orders as deemed just and proper.”
4.
It is contended that while continuing as a Jr. Project
Engineer in the establishment of Opp. Party Nos.2 and 3,
both the petitioners were appointed as Asst. Director
(Technical) on adhoc basis vide order dated 27.04.1998
and 24.04.1998 under Annexure-3.
4.1. It is further contended that on such appointment as
Asst. Director (Technical) on adhoc basis, both the
petitioners were extended with the scale of pay as due
and admissible as against the said post. Not only that all
further service benefits as due and admissible as against
the post of Asst. Director (Technical), were also extended
in favour of both the petitioners from time to time.
4.2. It is contended that while so continuing as Asst.
Director (Technical) on adhoc basis pursuant to order
dated 27.04.1998 and 24.04.1998 under Annexure-3 in
both
the
Writ
Petitions,
basing
on
the
DPC
recommendation dated 17.09.2019 under Annexure-8,
both the petitioners got the benefit of regularization as
against the post of Asst. Director (Technical) from the
date they were so appointed on adhoc basis vide order
dated-04.10.2019 under Annexure-4. Recommendation of
the DPC dated 17.09.2019 reads as follow:“As per restructured cadre and it’s rule, the sanctioned post
of Asst. Director (Tech.) is 20 which shall be filled up by way
of direct recruitment. Total vacancy is 20. Seven Nos. Jr.
// 3 //
Project Engineer'/ Junior Engineers have been allowed to
hold the posts of Asst. Director (Technical) in the scale of pay
Rs. 2000 /- - 3500 /- (pre-revised) vide office order No. 1231
Dt. 24.03.2005, office order No.1875 Dt. 24.04.1998 & office
order No. 1844 Dt. 24.04.1998 on officiating / adhoc basis.
They are also getting regular scale & annual increment in the
post of Asst. Director (Tech.). On careful consideration of the
individual cases with reference to the service history,required experience, disciplinary proceedings, vigilance cases
and ORV Act / Rules, the committee recommended the
following officers suitable for promotion to the post of Asst.
Director (Tech.) from the date they have been allowed to hold
such posts on officiating'/adhoc basis.”
Sl. No.
Name
Date of joining as Asst. Director
on officiating/adhoc basis
1.
Kishore Kumar Das
24.04.1998
2.
Maheswar Badajena
24.04.1998
3.
Arun Kumar Mohapatra 27.04.1998
4.3. It is contended that after getting the benefit of
promotion as Asst. Director (Technical) from the date
petitioners were so appointed on adhoc basis w.e.f.
27.04.1998 and 24.04.1998 vide order dated 04.10.2019
under Annexure-4 and while continuing as such, the
impugned order was communicated vide order dated
06.02.2023 under Annexure-6. Vide the said order, such
promotion of the petitioners as Asst. Director (Technical)
was treated to have been made prospectively.
4.4. It is contended that order under Annexure-6 was
issued basing on the decision taken by the Governing
Body of OREDA on 19.11.2022 under Annexure-6(B).
// 4 //
Decision taken in Agenda No.11 of the Proceeding of the
meeting dated 19.11.2022 reads as follows:“Regularisation of service of existing six Assistant
Directors(Technical), OREDA on promotion (Officiating/
ad-hoc basis)
The GB considered the regularisation of services of
the six Assistant Directors(Technicians) who were
promoted on officiating/adhoc basis without obserrving
the prescribed procedures for such promotion. It was
decided that their services will be regularized
prospectively, but there will be no recovery of the
financial benefits they have already received due to their
officiating/ad-hoc promotion.”
4.5. While assailing the impugned order so far as
regularization as against the post of Asst. Director
(Technical) prospectively is concerned, learned Senior
Counsel vehemently contended that since petitioners
were extended with the benefit on adhoc promotion in the
rank of Asst. Director (Technical) w.e.f. 27.04.1998 and
24.04.1998 in terms of the order issued under Annexure3
and
DPC
dtd.17.09.2019
recommended
for
regularization as against the said post from the date
petitioners were so appointed on adhoc basis, after
extension
of
the
benefit
basing
on
the
DPC
recommendation dated 17.09.2019, vide order dated
04.10.2019 under Annexure-4, such benefit could not
have
been
withdrawn
unilaterally,
basing
on
a
subsequent decision taken by the Board in its Proceeding
dated 19.11.2022 under Annexure-6(B).
4.6. It
is
also
contended
that
in
the
proceeding
dtd.19.11.2022 while treating the regularization of the
// 5 //
petitioners
as
against
the
post
of
Asst.
Director
(Technical) prospectively, it was however decided not to
recover the financial benefit already received by the
petitioner while continuing on adhoc basis.
4.7. It is contended that since petitioners basing on
Annexure-3 order, were allowed to continue in the
promotional post on adhoc basis and were extended with
the benefit of promotion vide order dated 04.10.2019
under Annexure-4, from the date they are continuing on
adhoc basis with all service benefits and it was also
decided not to recover the benefits in terms of DPC
recommendation dtd.17.09.2019, regularization of the
services of the petitioners as against the post of Asst.
Director (Technical) on promotion w.e.f. 27.04.1998 and
24.04.1998 could not have been treated to have issued
prospectively
vide
the
impugned
order
issued
on
06.02.2023 under Annexure-6, in terms of the decision
taken in the proceeding of the meeting dtd.30.12.2021
and 19.11.2022 under Annexure-6(A) & 6(B).
4.8. It is further contended that as provided under
Orissa Renewable Energy Development Agency Service
Rules, 1997, more particularly Rule-6 of the said Rules,
1/3rd of the post in the rank of Asst. Director (Technical)
is required to be filled up by way of promotion. Rule-6(2)
of the Rules reads as follows:-
// 6 //
“6.
Assistant Director (Technical): The posts of
Assistant Director (Technical) shall be filled up in the
following manner, namely:
(1) Not less than two-thirds of the said posts shall be filled
up by direct recruitment from among persons having First
Class B.E./B. Tech degree in Electrical Engineering or
Mechanical Engineering or Agricultural Engineering, as may
be specified.
(2) Not more than one-third of the said posts shall be filled
up by selection from amount the Junior Project Engineers
who have (i) worked in that rank for at least ten years in
OREDA service and (ii) achieved the targets in respect of
Biogas, Improved Chullahs, Solar Lantern, Cooker during
the last three years of their posting in the District
Renewable Energy Cell/IREP.
4.9. It is accordingly contended that the impugned order
dtd.06.02.2023
so
issued
under
Annexure-6
needs
interference of this Court.
5.
Mr. B.K. Dash, learned Senior Counsel appearing for
the Opp. Party Nos.2 and 3-OREDA, on the other hand
made his submission basing on the stand taken in the
counter affidavit so filed. It is contended that even though
basing on the recommendation of the DPC dated
17.09.2019, petitioners were extended with the benefit of
regularization as against the post of Asst. Director
(Technical) vide order dated 04.10.2019 under Annexure4, from their initial date of promotion on adhoc basis so
issued vide order dated 27.04.1998 and 24.04.1998
under Annexure-3, but subsequently when it came to the
knowledge of the Opp. Party Nos.2 and 3 that such
benefit has been extended wrongly, basing on the
decision taken in the minutes of the meeting held on
// 7 //
30.12.2021 under Annexure-A/2, the matter was placed
before the Board.
5.1. The Board in its proceeding of the meeting dated
19.11.2022 under Annexure-B/2, decided to regularize
the services of the petitioners as against the post in
question prospectively and basing on such decision of the
Board, the impugned order dated 06.02.2023 under
Annexure-6 was issued.
5.2. It is contended that the DPC in its proceeding dated
17.09.2019 without following due procedure and without
proper appreciation, recommended to extend the benefit
of regularization on promotion from the date petitioners
were so promoted on adhoc basis
vide order dated
27.04.1998 and 24.04.1998 and the same was acted
upon with issuance of order dated 04.10.2019 under
Annexure-4. But since it was found that such benefit has
been extended wrongly in favour of the petitioners, the
Board in its wisdom, resolved to extend such benefit of
promotion
prospectively
in
its
proceeding
dated
28.11.2022 under Annexure-B/2, basing on the decision
taken by the Committee on 30.12.2021 under AnnexureA/2.
5.3. It is also contended that in the meeting held on
30.12.2021 under Annexure-A/2, the Chief Executive,
OREDA as the Chairman of the meeting, came to a
finding that the prescribed procedures were not followed
// 8 //
at the time of giving officiating/adhoc promotion in favour
of the present petitioners and accordingly recommended
for placement of the matter before the Board.
5.4. It is accordingly contended that since the promotion
of the petitioners w.e.f. the date they were continuing on
adhoc basis vide order under Annexure-4 was issued
basing
on
a
wrong
recommendation
of
DPC
dtd.17.09.2019, benefit of regularization extended from
the date petitioners were so promoted on adhoc basis,
was modified with issuance of the order dated 06.02.2023
under Annexure-6.
5.5. It is accordingly contended that no illegality or
irregularity can be found with such action of the Opp.
Parties.
6.
To the submission made by the learned Sr. Counsel
appearing for Opp. Party Nos.2 and 3, learned Sr.
Counsel appearing for the petitioners made further
submission contending inter alia that after extending the
benefit of promotion, from the date of adhoc promotion
vide order dated 04.10.2019, the same could not have
been treated as prospective promotion vide the impugned
order dated 06.02.2023 under Annexure-6, without
following the principle of natural justice. Not only that
since both the petitioners continued in the promotional
post of Asst. Director (Technical) w.e.f. 27.04.1998 and
24.04.1998 as per Order issued under Annexure-3 on
// 9 //
adhoc basis and such promotion was regularised vide
order issued under Annexure-4, they will be seriously
prejudiced if such order of promotion is taken as
prospective
promotion
so
issued
vide
order
dated
06.02.2023 under Annexure-6.
6.1. It is also contended that since it is not disputed that
petitioners have received all the financial benefit as due
and admissible to the promotional post w.e.f. 27.04.1998
and 24.04.1998 and in the proceeding of the meeting
dtd.19.11.2022 under Annexure-6(B), it has also been
decided not to recover the benefit, there was no occasion
to treat the promotion as a prospective one. Such an
action has been taken only to deprive the petitioners to
get the benefit of further promotion to the next higher
rank.
7.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and
considering the submission made, this Court finds that
both the petitioners while continuing under Opp. Party
Nos.2 and 3 as against the post of Jr. Project Engineers,
they were promoted as against the post of Asst. Director
(Technical) on adhoc basis vide order dated 27.04.1998
and 24.04.1998 under Annexure-3. It is not disputed that
on such promotion on adhoc basis w.e.f. 27.04.1998 and
24.04.1998, both the petitioners were extended with the
benefit of the scale of pay as due and admissible to the
post in question.
// 10 //
7.1. It is also not disputed that both the petitioners were
extended with all service benefits as due and admissible
as against the post of Asst. Director (Technical) all
through w.e.f. 27.04.1998 and 24.04.1998 till the DPC in
its Proceeding dated 17.09.2019, recommended to extend
the benefit of promotion on regular basis in favour of the
petitioners, from the date they were initially promoted on
adhoc basis vide orders issued under Annexure-3.
7.2. Basing on such recommendation of the DPC dated
17.09.2019 under Annexure-8, both the petitioners were
regularized
as
against
the
post
of
Asst.
Director
(Technical) from their initial date of promotion on adhoc
basis, vide order dated 04.10.2019 under Annexure-4.
7.3. However, it is found that subsequent to extension of
such benefit, basing on the decision taken in the meeting
held on 30.12.2021 under Annexure-A/2, the Board in its
Proceeding
datd
19.11.2022
under
Annexure-B/2,
resolved to extend the benefit of promotion in favour of
the
petitioners
prospectively.
However
in
the
said
proceeding, the Board resolved that no recovery be made
so far as extension of financial benefit is concerned.
7.4. Considering the fact that petitioners were given the
benefit of promotion on adhoc basis w.e.f. 27.04.1998
and 24.04.1998 and were regularised in the promotional
post from the date they were initially promoted on adhoc
basis, basing on the recommendation of the DPC dated
// 11 //
17.09.2019
under
Annexure-8,
vide
order
dated
04.10.2019 under Annexure-4 and in view of the fact that
petitioners all through were extended with the benefit of
the scale of pay as due and admissible as against the post
of Asst. Director (Technical), this Court is of the view that
the decision taken by the Board in its proceeding dated
19.11.2022 under Annexure-B/2 to extend the benefit of
promotion prospectively under Annexure-A/2, is not legal
and justified.
7.5. Therefore, in view of the aforesaid analysis, this
Court is inclined to quash order dated 06.02.2023 so
issued
under
Annexure-6,
wherein
benefit
of
regularization of promotion was treated to have been
issued prospectively and quash the same accordingly.
While quashing order dated 06.02.2023, this Court in the
alternate upheld the order issued under Annexure-4
dated04.10.2019, and direct the Opp. Parties to continue
with such order with extension of the benefits as due and
admissible in favour of the petitioners.
8.
Both the Writ Petition stand disposed of accordingly.
(Biraja Prasanna Satapathy)
Judge
Basudev
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BASUDEV SWAIN
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 30-Jun-2026 10:41:19
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review