Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
\
[ 3444 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
FRIDAY, THE TWENTY THIRD DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE TIRUMALA DEVI EADA
CRIMINAL PETITION NO: 8882 OF 2025
Between:
1. It,4ahesh lvlatam, S/o Buchaiah [\4atam, aged about 55yrs, Occ. Principal
Engineer, o H.no 3547, Sorrel Ln Duluth, GA 30096-1457, USA Rep by its
Power of Attorney P2
2. Buchaiah Matam, S/o Late Chen ltrlallaiah aged about 77 years, Rlo Flat 414,
Block A, Concrete Avasa, Nagole, Hyderabad, Telangana 500 068.
3. Smt. Haimavathi Devi [/atam,, Wo Sri Buchaiah A,4atam, aged aboul 72
years, Rio same as above Flat 414, Block A, Concrete Avasa, Nagole,
Hyderabad, Telangana 500 068..
4. Smt. Sailaja Kumari A/atam,, Wo Dr. Upender A/latam, Age 53 Years Occ.
Professor, NIT Warangal, R/o Hanamkonda, Telangana
5 Dr. Upender lVlatam,, S/o lr,4allaiah aged about 58 Years, Doctor, Blue Line
Plastic Surgery Hospital, Hanamkonda, Telangana.
...PETITIONERiACCUSED No.1 to 5
AND
1. State of Telangana, Through its Public Prosecutor. High court of Telangana,
at Hyderabad.
.,.RESPONDENT No.1
2. Lav anya Kakarlamatham,, Wo Sri Mahesh Matam, Aged about 49yrs, R/o
H .No .16-2-7 42lFi B It/alakpet, Hyderabad.
..RESPONDENT No.2/COMPLAINANT
Petition under Section 528 of BNSS praying that in the circumstances
stated in the lt/emorandum of Grounds of Crrminal Petition, the High Court may be
pleased to call for the records rn DVC.No. 55 OF 2025 Dtd. 31 .O1 .2025 On The
File Of The lV Judicial Magistrate Of First Class At Hyderabad City and quash the
same.
l.A. NO: 2 OF 2025
Petition under Section 528 of BNSS praying that in the ctrcumstances
stated in the Memorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition, the High Court may be
pleased to a stay of all further proceedings in DVC.No 55 OF 2025 Dtd.
31 .01 .2025 On The File Of The IV Judicial N4agistrate Of Fi-st Class At Hyderabad
City City, pending the disposal of the above Criminal Petitioe
This Petition comrng on for hearing, upon perusinr; re lVlemorandum of
Grounds of Cnminal Petition and upon hearing the argumert of Sri Kondaparthy
Kiran Kumar, Advocate for the Petitioner and the Public F'r:;ecLrtor on behalf of
the Respondent No.1 and None appeared for Respondent Nr il
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE TIRUMALA DEVIEADA
CRIMINAL PETITION No.8882 ot 2025
Date:23.01.2026
Between:
lVahesh Matam and 4 others
Petitioners/Accu sed Nos.1 to 5
And
State of Telangana,
Rep. by the Public Prosecutor,
High Court for the State of Telangana,
Hyderabad and another.
Respondents
ORDER:
This Criminal Petition is filed seeking to quash the proceedings
against the petitioners-accused Nos.l to 5 in DVC No.55 of 2025 on
the file of lV Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Hyderabad
2. Heard Sri K. Kiran Kumar, learned counsel for the
petitioners, Sri Jithender Rao Veeramalla, learned Additional Public
Prosecutor appearing for respondent No.1 and Sri S. Nageswara
Reddy, learned counsel for the respondent No.2
3. The learned counsel for the petitioners has submitted that
the petition is filed seeking to quash the proceedings in the pending
ETD,J
c P. No.88E2 012025
DVC No.55 of 2O25 He further has submitterl lhat there is no
domestic relationship as such between the petititl rer No.1 and the
respondent No 2 and that the couple got divorcec ong ago and the
present petition is filed as an afterthought, iLtr t to harass the
petitioners. He further submitted that the matrimc,l i,al disputes were
amicably settled vrde orders dated 18.04.2023 of t re Superior Court
of Forsyth County, State of Georgia. He furtl't r submitted that
subsequent to the decree of divorce, the petition: No.1 received a
derogatory mail from the respondent No.2 herein rrr 16 '10.2023, to
which the petitioner No.1 issued reply and thal in the said mail
respondent No.2 has threatened him of initiating ,:ti n inal proceedings
against him. He further submitted that with an atti de of vengeance,
t
the respondent No.2 has lodged the present contlr rint and that their
children have filed affidavits to the effect that the,' a re getting vexed
with the attitude of their mother and that she
is raising false
allegations against the petitioners herein. He furt rer has submitted
that the DVC proceedings have been initiated aft: an extraordinary
delay and that continuing the DVC proceedings tvt trd be re-agitating
the already settled issues, which also amounts to rr ruse of process of
law. He further argued that it is not the case of the retitioners that the
DVC is not maintainable after a decree of divorce,
I
Lrt the respondent
No.2 being a foreign citizen and having effectively c vorced in US and
)
EIO,J
c -P. N,.EEE2 0f 2025
having derived the benefit of decree of divorce by way of
funds/monies and division of assets, cannot turn around and filed
DVC proceedings claiming that the divorce in US is not conclusive
and hence, prayed to quash the proceedings against the petitioner
herein
4. Learned counsel for the respondent No.2 has submitted that
the DVC is filed with regard to harassment meted out by the
respondent No.2 during her stay with the petitioners herein and while
there was domestic relationship existing between the parties. The
petitioners are raising all false grounds and that the respondent No.2
has raised her objections before the Superior Court of Forsyth
County, State of Georgia, which were not considered and that she
has not filed any amendment consenting for the divorce. He further
contended that in the judgment of Superior Court of Forsyth County,
State of Georgia dated 18.04.2023, it is mentioned that the
respondent No.2 herein had filed an amendment wherein she agreed
that the marriage had been broken irrevocably, but the said
settlement is false that she never filed any amendment. He further
submitted that the decree of divorce granted by the Superior Court is
not enforceable in lndia as the same is obtained by means of fraud
and that the petitioner No.1-husband has not filed any application
ETD.J
ctl.P. No.a882 0t 2025
under Section 44-A C.P.C. in lndia for execution of li e decree passed
by the Courts in reciprocating territory and that the t r/C is very much
maintainable and the proceedings cannot be quir hed against the
petitioners.
5 Perused the record
6 The allegations against the petitioners
r
that they have
harassed the respondent No. 2-de facfo complainarr {rom the date of
her marriage with petitioner No.'l . The responden. No.2 specifically
stated that on25.02.2023 at about 14.30 hours whe
she went to the
house of her in-laws to plead them to setfle the c sputes between
herself and her husband, she was thrown out of tht house and was
abused by the petitioners. The said incident was; r tr-tch prior to the
divorce. The respondent No.2 got married to the 1r rlitioner No. 1 on
22.05.1997 and in the initial days itself, her motn:
in law used to
make abusive comments on her saying that ,.no foc cl for new aunt,
thus she eats grass". But, anticipating the vr ,ll being of the
respondent No.2, her parental family has consoled r.er in a hope of
peaceful marital life. Equally, all the other family rr embers used to
insult and never treated her with any respect. lt is frr ther alleged that
both the father-in-law and mother_in_law i.e. petiticr er Nos.2 and 3
never used to give any privacy to the newly werl led couple.
ln
ETD,J
Crl.P- No.8882 of 2025
February 1998, the de facto complainant was 6th months pregnant
and she was taken to hospital by her mother-in-law for checking the
fetus health, but under that pretext, the mother-in-law performed sex
determination test of fetus, due to which gender of the fetus was
found as female and then her mother-in-law requested the doctor to
abort the 6th month pregnancy, but the gynecologist had refused to do
so and shouted back at the petitioner No.3/mother-in-law. lt is further
alleged that on 24.04.1998 when she gave birth to twin baby girls, the
situation worsened and the in-laws, more particularly, the father-in-
law and mother-in-law used to comment that those who have
committed sins will give birth to baby girls. ln February 2000, when
her husband was about to leave for Canada, her father-in-law was not
happy if the de facto complainant accompanied him to Canada and
instigated her husband agalnst her. They went even to the extent that
when the de facto complainant was in lndia during the year 2000 for
Visa processing of the minor baby girls for which she was
accompanied by her father, the petitioner-No.1 got furious and
abused the de facto complainant questioning her "whether the twin
baby girls were conceived with him or with her own father."
7. On 12.12.2000, the de faclo complainant received a hate
mail from an unknown person in filthy abusive words targeting the
EfD,J
Crl P No-EAE2 ol2025
character of her parents and herself. Again c,r 04.01.200'1 , she
received a mail from her husband in which he staler ':hat he received
a hate mail from an unknown person and though
I
the abusive words, he supported the allegatic
r
: drsagrees with
; made on the
respondent No 2 and he also mentioned that s: rreone enquired
about the mail-lD of the respondent No.2. Durrr r July 2005, the
respondent No.2 went along with her parents anJ ,r'other lo the in-
laws house to put an end to the harassment, the I other-in-law and
sister-in-law reported that they were not paid the exp :cted dowry and
that would be the only solution for stopping the rarassment and
demanded Rs 5 00 lakhs, which was paid by
I
er parents. On
24.08.2007 her father-in-law wrote an e-mail to petitioner No l
suggesting that he should switch over to software ir,: J, otherwise, the
respondent No.2 may earn more and may dor - nate him. On
22.10.2007 another mail was sent by the petitioner lo. 1 to petitioner
I
No.4 stating that the petitioner Nos.2 and 3, his : rrents, hate the
respondent No.2 and for that reason they have not, isited the house
of petitioner No.'1 for 7 years and when they visited li :ir house after 7
years, they never spoke to the grand children.
8. ln February 2022, the petitioner No.1 botrr ht a property in
Shamshabad, Hyderabad, without any information 1c the respondent
ETD,J
C .P- No-8A82 012025
No.2 and concealed the same to deceive her economically. lt is the
I
I
I
allegation of the respondent No.2 because of that continuous ongolng
I
harassment and emotional abuse for over 23 years, she got broken
I
i
down psychologically and emotionally and on 27.02.2022, she has
opted for counsellor services from McConaghie Counselling. lnspite
of the mental harassment, the respondent No.2 continued to live wrth
the petitioner No.1. ln 0303.2022, the petitioner No.1 has bought
another property at Shamshabad without her knowledge and on
11.05.2022 he filed a divorce petition at Superior Court of Forsyth
County in the State of Georgia on the ground that the marriage is
irretrievably broken and it is filed only under the influence of his
parents. The respondent No,2 has filed her response denying the
allegations in the said petition. ln February, 2023, respondent No.2
was in lndia primarily to save her marriage by involving their elders for
resolving differences between them and on 25 02.2023, she went to
her in-laws house to settle the rssue amicably, but her father-in-law
and mother-in-law and her niece dragged her out of the house while
the sister-in-law thrown out her belongings and shouted on her in a
loud voice. lt is further alleged that in the divorce petition she has not
filed any amendment agreeing that the marriage has broken down
irrevocably and that the said statement is false and it is further alleged
that the divorce of decree is not maintainable in lndia as the petitioner
\
\
ETD,J
Ctl.P N0-8882 o12025
No.'1-husband had not filed petition under Secticr 44_A Cr.p.C. for
execution of the divorce decree passed by thr: ljuperior Curt of
Forsyth County in the State of Georgia. lt is furt. :r alleged that on
16 102023, the petitioner No.1 wrote an e-mail : the respondent
No.2 accepting to have abused her.
9. Thus, there are specific allegations ar : the dates with
regard to the incidents of harassment meted orr by the de faclo
complainant. The contention of the learned counse fr:r the petitioners
I
is that since the divorce decree is already pa s ;ed between the
parties, there is no domestic relationship betweerr them and further
even if the DVC proceedings are maintainable s rosequent to the
decree of divorce, since the respondent No.2 is a f rreign citizen and
having effectively contested the divorce petition in |..lSA and having
derived the benefits under the decree of divor: : with regard to
division of assets, she cannot turn around and file )VC proceedings
claiming that divorce in USA is not conclusive. - l- us, the learned
counsel for the petitioner contends that since shr: is bound by the
decree of divorce and in the said decree then; 'ruas drvision of
properties also and having accepted the same, she ,lannot question
the validity of the decree in the present petition
While it is the
contention of the learned counsel for the de facto ccr rplainant
that the
Crl.P- No-8882 ol 2U5
W:
decree of divorce is not enforceable in lndia as no application under
Section 44-A Cr.P.C. has been filed by the petitioner No.'l herein
before the courts in lndia. Fu(her, the contentions with regard to
shared household, forum shopping, litigation tourism and with regard
to division of properties, they are all triable issues Admittedly, there
is no application under Section 44-A Cr.P.C filed by the petitroner
No.1 before any competent court in lndia for enforcement of the said
decree. Thus, in view of the allegations leveled against the
petitioners, it is opined that the truth or otherwise in the allegations
can be culled out only after a full-fledged trial. Therefore, the
proceedings against the petitioners cannot be quashed. However, it
is deemed appropriate to dispose of the petition by dispensing with
the attendance of the petitioners before the trial court.
10. Accordingly, the Criminal Petition is disposed of dispensing
with the attendance of the petitioners before the trial court provided
they are represented by a counsel before the trial court on every date
of hearing and shall appear before the trial court as and when their
presence is required during the course of trial
Miscellaneous Petitions pending, if any, shall stand closed
Sd/- P. PONNA KRISHN
ASSISTANT REGI
R
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1 The lV Judicial l\ilagistrate of First Class at Hyderabad.
2. One CC to SRl. KONDAPARTHY KIRAN KUMAR, Advocare [OPUC]
e 3. Two CCs to the Public Prosecutor, High Court of Telangana at Hydeiabad
louTl
4. Two CD Copies
'T
t
I
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2310112026
-/
C
()
ORDER
CRLP.No.8882 ot 2025
l4
a(
rlrlC 1.
i 0 ,.,,1 ,,|]]
r),,
i. .'
"Srr,'..1""t-)'-/
:'\::--_J:---
DISPOSING OF THE CRIMINAL PETITIoN
!
i
I
I
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review