Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
WEDNESDAY, THE ELEVENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL Nos. 181 , 183, 202 & 252 of 2025 and
C.R.P.Nos.3559 and 3560 ot 2O24
C.M.A.No. 181 of 2025 :
Appeal Under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996
aggrreved by the Order dated 02-04-2025 in A.O.P.No 9 of 2022 on the file of the
Court of the XXVII Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Courts. Secunderabad.
Between:
tt/ahbub College (Multi-Purpose Higher Secondary School) Society, Mahbub College
(Multi-purpose Higher Secondary School) Society, rep by its President Sri P.L.
Srinivas, Regd No.56/1959 - 60 of AP, No.8-1-377 to 379, R P. Road, Secunderabad
- 5OOOO3
...APPELLANT
AND
t Venkat Narayana Educational Society, Plot No.1 02, High Court Colony,
z
Vanasthalipuram, Hyderabad - 500070 rep. by its President Dr. Rev K.V.K
Rao, s/o late Sri Venkaiah, aged 63 years
P L. Srinivas, s/o Sri P Laxman Rao, aged aged 65 years. 8 1-377 lo 379,
R.P. Road. Secunderabad - 500003
s. Konda and Konda Consultancy, rep. by its partner, 8-1-377 to 379, R.P.
Road, Secunderabad - 500003 (Respondents 2 and 3 are not necessary
parties)
...RESPONDENTS
l.A. NO: 1OF 2025
Petition under Section 1 51 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to suspend
the operation of the order dated 02-04-2025 passed in AOP 09/2022 on the file of
the XXVII Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Courts, Secunderabad, pending disposal
of the above appeal, in the interest of justice.
Counsel for the Appellant: Sri. Amith Kumar, Senior Counsel for
Sri D. Srinivas Prasad on record, assisted by
Ms. D. Shalini Shravanthi
Counsel for the Respondent No.1 :
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 183 t tF 2025
Appeal Under Section 37 of the Arbitratton and ) cnci atron Act. 1 g9e
aggrieved by the Order dated 02-04-2025 in A.O P No. 20 rt1 ltO24 on the file of the
Court of the XXVII Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Courts, ti :cunclerabad
Between:
Venkata Narayana Educational Society, Regd. No.4201201 j No.8-'l-377 to 379.
R.P. Road, Secunderabad - 500 003 Rep. by its President, tr iev K.V K. Rao, plot
No.102, High Court Colony, Vanasthalipuram, Hyderabad 501) j70
...1\ ,PELLANT / petitioner
AND
1. Mahbub College ([vlu lti-pu rpose Higher Secondary S :hool) Society, Regd
No 56 /1959 - 60 of AP, No.8-'1-377 to 379, R P Roac Secunderabad - 500
003 Represented by its President Sri P. L. Srinivas
2. Sri. P.L. Srinivas, President, lVlahbub (tVulti-purpcs: Higher Secondary
School) Society. Mahbub College Campus, No.8-'1-37 / to 379, R.p. Road,
Secunderabad 500 003
3. M/s. Konda and Konda Consultancy Services, Regd \ t. 1736 of 2015, g-1377 to 379 R.P Road, tr/ahbub College Car pus, Secunderabari
Represented by K. Anil Kumar
...RESPONDEI TS / RESPONDENTS
l.A. NO: 1OF 2025
Petition under order 39 Rule 1 & 2 of cPC praying that n the crrcumstances
stated in the affrdavit filed in support of the petition, the High ( ourt may be pleased
to grant an interrm order during the pendency of the r\ )peal restraining the
Respondent No 1 , members of the Respondent No.1 Society, t:luding their agents
Assignees represen tattves, employees, henchmen, etc f om addressing any
letters, representations, or otherwise approaching any Sta utory Authorities in
respect of 'Swami Vtvekananda lnstitute of Technology'(S\ I -tand 'Bolton School
being run in the Schedule Properties by the Appellant Society.
Petition Schedule Pro perties
Petition Schedule A Pro pertv
All the property approved in the building plan and sitr plan dated 30_06_
2006. Admeasuring 22,960 square meters situated at g-.1 I 77 to g_1_379, R.p.
Road and s.D. Road, Secunderabad where "Swami vivenk rnanda lnstitute of
Technology'( SVIT) is currently functioning and is bounde,J by
North: Road
South: S.D. Road
East: Neighbors land
West: R.P. Road
Petition Schedule B Pro ertv
All that piece and parcel fo land measuring 19-302 87 Sq meters, situated rn
plot No. 219t8, at GLR Sy No. 703 of Bolton Road, Secunderabad cantonment,
Telangana state where 'Bolton school' is currently functioning and bounded as
follows.
North. By Bolton Road
South By Nala
East. By Road and Bolton Road
West By Road
l.A. NO: 2OF 2025
.1
Petition under order 39 Rule & 2 ot cPC praying that in the circumstances
stated in the affidavit frled in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased
to grant an rnterim order during the pendency of the Appeal suspending/not giving
effect to the Notice of Termination dated 03.10.2024 \n any manner whatsoever.
Petition Schedu lep roperties
Petition Sched ule A Propertv
All that property approved in the building plan and site plan dated 30-06-2006,
admeasuring 22,960 square meters situated al8-1-377 to 8-1-379 . R P. Road and s.D
Road. Secunderabad where "swami vivenkananda lnstitute of Technology" ( SVIT) is
currently functioning and is bounded by:
Petition Schedule p rooerties
Petition Sc hedule B Property
Petition Schedule B Pro ertv
All that piece and parcel fo land measuring 19.302.87 Sq' meters, situated rn
plot No 21gtB, at GLR Sy.No 703 of Bolton Road, Secunderabad cantonment,
Telangana state where 'Bolton schoot' is currently functioning and bounded as
follows.
North. By Bolton Road
South. By Nala
East. By Road and Bolton Road
West: By Road
l.A. NO: 3 OF 2025
Petition under order XLI Rule 27 (1) (B) R/w Section 151 CPC praying that in the
crrcumstances stated rn the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court
may be pleased to receive the following documents as additional evidence in the
instant Civil tVliscellaneous Appeal
Counsel for the Appellant: Sri Sunil B. Ganu, Senior Cc unsel assisted by
Sri K.V.Rusheek Reddy
Counsel for the Respondent No.1 : Sra. Amith Kumar, St,r ior Counsel for
Sri D. Srinivas Prasarl rn record, assisted by
Ms. D. Shalini Shravan, ri
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 202 ( F 2025
Appeal Under Section 37 of the Arbitration and ( :(lnciliation Act, 1996
aggrieved by the Order daled 02-04-2025 in A.O P.No 20 cl 2:.024 on the file of the
Court of the XXVII Additional Chief Judge. City Crvil Courts, :; <;underabad.
Between:
Mahbub College (l\4 u lti-p urpose Higher Secondary Scho()l Society, rep by its
Presrdent Sri P.L. Srir-rivas, Regd No.56/1959 - 60 of AP, I.l, 8-1-377 to 379, R P
Road, Secunderabad - 500003
...APt, :LLANT / Respondent
AND
.1
. Venkat Narayana Educational Society, Plot No 101, High Court Colony,
Vanasthalipuram, Hyderabad - 500070 rep by its Prr: ident Dr. Rev K.V.K.
Rao, S/o late Sri Venkaiah, aged 63 years .Resporr ont/ Petitioner
2. P.L. Srinivas, s/o Sri P. Laxman Rao, aged aged 65 1:ars, 8-1-377 to 37g,
R.P Road, Secunderabad - 500003
3. Konda and Konda Consultancy, rep by its partner ( \.1-377 to 379, R.P.
Road, Secunderabad - 500003 (Respondents 2 artc 3 are not necessary
parties)
...RESPOND: \TS / Respondents
l.A. NO: 1OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circtrr- ;.ances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the Hrgh Court may I r pleased to suspend
the operation of the order dated 02.04.2025 passed in AoP 2ct t()24 on the file of the
XXVII Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Courts, Secunderba,l oendrng disposal of
the above appeal, in the interest of justice.
Counsel for the Appellant: Sri. Amith Kumar, Senior Counsel I >r
Sri D. Srinivas Prasad on record, a;sisted by
Ms. D. Shalini Shravanthi
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: Sri Sunil B. Ganu, Ser or Counsel
assisted by Sri K.V.Rtrr heek Reddy
Dr.K.V.K. Rao, appellant- p. rty-in person
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 252 OF 2025
Appeal Under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Concrliation Act, 1996
aggrieved by the Order dated 02-04-2025 in A.O.P.No. I of 2022 on the file of the
Court of the XXVII Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Courts, Secunderabad.
Between:
Venkata Narayana Educatronal Society, Regd. No.42012015, No B-1-377 lo 379,
R.P. Road, Secunderabad - 500 003 Rep. by its President, Dr. Rev. K.V.K. Rao, Plot
No.102, High Court Colony, Vanasthalipuram, Hyderabad 500 070 Email
rd.rev_kvkrao@yahoo.co. in
...APPELLANT / Petitioner
AND
1. I\ilahbub College (lvlulti-purpose Higher Secondary School) Socrety, Regd
No 56 /'1 959 60 of AP, No.8-1-377 to 379, R P. Road, Secunderabad - 500
003 Represented by its President Sri P. L. Srinivas
2 Sri P L. Srinivas, President, IVlahbub ([\4u lti-pu rpose Higher Secondary
School) Socrety,' ttrlahbub College Campus. No.B-1-377 to 379, R.P. Road
Secunderabad - 500 003
3. A//s. Konda and Konda Consultancy Services, Regd. No- .1736 of2015, B-1
377 lo 379, R.P. Road, lrlahbub College Campus, Secunderabad
Represented by K. Anil Kumar (Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 are not necessary
parties as Petitioner has not pressed the Arb OP No. 09 o'f 2022vide Memo Sr
No. o{ 2024 dated )
...RESPONDENTS/ Respondents
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Order 39 Rule 1 & 2 of C PC praying that in the circumstances
stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petrtion, the High Court may be pleased
to grant an interim order during the pendency of the Appeal restraining the
Respondent No. 1, members of the Respondent No. 'l Society, including their
agents, assignees, represen tatives, employees, henchmen, etc. from addressing any
letters, representations, or otherwise approaching any Statutory Authorities in
respect of 'Swami Vivekananda lnstitute of Technology'(Sv|T)and 'Bolton School'
being run in the Schedule Properties by the Appellant Society and pass
PETITION SCHEDULE PROPERTIES
PETITION SCHEDULE A PROPERTY
All that property approved in the building plan and site plan dated 30.06.2006,
admeasuring 22,960 square meters situated at 8-1-377 to 8-1-379, R.P. Road and
S.D, Road, Secunderabad where 'Swami Vivekananda lnstitute of
Technology'(SVIT)is currently functioning and is bounded by:
NORTH : Road
SOUTH S D. Road
EAST Neighbors Land
WEST R.P. Road
PETITION SCHEDULE 'B' PROPE f I
''l
All that piece and parcel of land measuriog 19 302.87 Sc nreters, situated in Plot
No 2.19/8, at GLR Sy. No 703 of Bolton Road, Ser;r r clerabad Cantonment,
Telangana State where 'Bolton School' is currently funct r r rng and bounded as;
follows.
NORTH By Bolton Road
SOUTH by Nala
EAST:by Road and Bolton Road
WEST : By Road
l.A. NO:2OF 2025
Petition under Order 39 Rule 1 & 2 of CPC praying the in the circumstances
stated in the affidavit filed rn support of the petition, the Higlr C;ourt may be pleased
to grant an interim order during the pendency of the Appeal : r- spending / not giving
effect to the Notice of Termination dated 03.1 0.2024 in any rr rnner whatsoever and
pass
PETITION SCHEDULE PROPERTIT], ;
PETITION SCHEDULE'A' PROPERI /
All that property approved in the building plan and site : an dated 30 06.2006,
admeasurrng 22,960 square meters situated at 8-1-377 to E- | 379, R.P. Road and
S.D. Road, Secunderabad where 'Swami Vivek,t r:rnda lnstitute of
Technology'(SVIT)is currently functioning and is bounded by
NORTH :Road
SOUTH : S.D. Road
EAST : Neighbors Land
WEST. R.P. Road
PETITION SCHEDULE B PROPERI\
All that piece and parcel of land measuring 19.302.87 Sq r erters, situated in Plot
No.219l8, at GLR Sy. No.703 of Bolton Road, Secun: rrabad Cantonment,
Telangana State where 'Bolton School' is currently functro- rrg and bounded as
follows:
NORTH
SOUTH
EAST-
WEST:
By Bolton Road
by Nala .
by Road and Bolton Road
By Road
Counsel for the Appellant: Dr. K.V.K. RAO, Party- in-person
Counsel for the Respondent No.1 : Sri Amith Kumar, Senior O runsel for
Sri D. Srinivas Prasad on record, a;sisted by
Ms. D. Shalini Shravanthi
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO:355 9 0F 2024
PetitionUnderArticle22TofConstitutionoflndiaagainsttheorderdated
195 of 2024 on the file of the Court of
28-10-2024 in l A.No lZOz of nni in O S No
m" if f i"niot Civil Judge' City Civil Courts, Secunderabad
Between
Society' rep by its
Mahbub College (l\/ u ltr-purpose Higher Secondary School)
of AP, No 8-1-377 to 379' R P
President Sri P.L Srinivas, RegO tto.SOllS5g - 60
Road, Secunderabad - 500003
,..PETITIONER / ResPondent
AND
High Court Colony'
Venkat Narayana Educational Society, Plot no"102'
Dr' Rev K V'K
Vanasthalipuram, Hyderabad - 500070 rep by its President
Rao, S/o late Sri Venkaiah' aged 63 years
a
Dr.Rev.K.V,K.Rao,S/olateSriVenkaiah,aged63years,R/oPlotNo.102'
- 500070
High Court Colony, Vanasthalipuram, Hyderabad
about 35 years' Plot
K Sriharsha Shashank, S/o Dr' Rev' K.V K' Rao' aged
Hyderabad - 500070
No.1 02, High Court Colony' Vanasthalipuram'
...RESPONDENTS
l.A. NO :1OF 2O24
PetitionunderSectionl5lCPCprayingthatinthecircumstancesstatedinthe
Court may be pleased to suspend
affidavit filed in support of the petition, int uign
'1302
of 2024 in O S' No 195 of 2024
the order dated 28..10 2024 passed in l A No
1O.2O24 passed in O S
and consequently suspend the docket order dated 28
Judge' secunderabad' pending
No,.195 of 2024 on the file of the lll Senror civil
Ji.porrt of the above revision petition, rn the interest of
cou nser for the Petitioner: sri
justice and pass
3$[[:Te?:::':l?:$,t'
j::isted by
Ms. D. Shalini Shravanthi
Senior Counsel
Counsel for the Respondent No'1 : Sri Sunil B' Ganu'
assisted bY Sri K'V'Rusheek ReddY
Counsel for the Respondent Nos' 2 &3: Sri' G' Vamshi
Krishna
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 3560 Ot- 2024
Petition Under Article 227 of Constitution of lndta . Jainst the order dated
28-10-2024 in O.S.No. 195 of 2024 on the file of the Cc,t r of the tll Senior Civil
Judge, City Civil Courts, Secunderabad.
Between:
lVlahbub College (lt/ u ltr-pu rpose Higher Secondary Scho: ) Society rep by rts
President Sri P.L. Srinivas, Regd No.56/ 1959 60 of AP, t,t ) 8-1 377 ro 379, R p
Road. Secunderabad 500003
. PETIT|ONER / petitioner
AND
1. Venkat Narayana Educational Society, Plot No 102 High Court Colony.
Vanasthalipuram, Hyderabad 500070 rep by its Presrde -rt Dr Rev K.V.K. Rao,
sic. ) late Sri Venkaiah, aged 63 years
2 Dr. Rev. K.V.K Rao, S/o late Sri Venkaiah, aged 6:J y rars R/o plot No.102,
High Court Colony, Vanasthalipuram, Hyderabad 500C; l
3. K Sriharsha Shashank, S/o Dr. Rev. K.V.K. Rao, a(te( about 35 years. plot
No.102, High Court Colony, Vanasthalipuram, Hyder;rti c 500070
,
DEFEND! NTS , RESPONDENTS
l.A. NO: 1OF 2024
Petition under order XXXIX Rules '1 & 2 R/w. sec. 151 of I .c praying that in the
crrcumstances stated rn the affidavit filed in support of the 6 t t tron, the High courl
may be pleased to grant interim orders of injunction restrain r( -he Respondents, its
agents, employees, henchmen or anyone claiming through the, r from interfering with
the peaceful possession and enjoyment of the petitiorr j:hedule A AND B
Properties, and consequently from also interfering in its aff,r :; and runnrng of its
institutions, namely, Swami Vivekananda lnstitute of rechnol: ly (svlr) and Bolton
School being run from the petition schedule A and B propertr€s respectively pending
disposal of the above revisron petition, ln the interest of justice : rd pass
SCHEDULE'A' PROPERTY
All that property bearing premises no.8-1-377 to 379, s tr,ited at R p Road,
Secunderabad
acres 7-00 (appx) t,:1r:ther with buitdings
- 500003,ofadmeasuring
housing the institutrons
Swami Vivekananda lnstitute o' -rechnology (SVlr),
Swami Vivekananda PG coliege (svpc), High school, r t()rmedrate co ege,
Degree College, playground and SV Auditorium enclosed in a r crrnp6ltn6 wall on all
sides wrth primary gates on north and eastern sides, and bounr| cl on the
NORTH BY S.D. Road
SOUTH BY ltilunicipal Road
EAST BY: Neighbour's building, including hotel
WEST BY. R P. Road
SCHEDUL E'B
,PROPERTY
Survey No 703' situated at
together with buildings and
Bolton Road, Secunderabad Cantlnment' Secunderabad
and
Bolton School and enclosed by a compound wall'
All that property admeasuring acre 1 00' in GLR
open spaces thereon housing
bounded on the
NORTH BY. Bolton Road
SOUTH BY: Nala
EAST BY CentenarY School
WEST BY. Akshara Vagdevi lnternational School
Counsel for
Counsel for the Petitioner: Sri Amith Kumar' Senior
record, assisted by
on
Sri D. Srinivas Prasad
Ms. D. Shalini Shravanthi
Senior Counsel
Counsel for the ResPondent No'1 Sri Sunil B. Ganu,
assisted bY Sri K.V.Rusheek ReddY
Counsel for the Respondent Nos' 2 &3: Sri' G' Vamshi
The Court made the following COMMON JUDGMENT
:
Krishna
HIGTI COURT FOR THE STATE OFTELI. {GANA
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATI ACHARYA
AND
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN (UMAR
C.M.A.Nos.l8l 183 202 &252 of 2025 and C.R.P.Nos.3i L 9 & 3560 of2024
Dated : 1 1.02.2026
C MA No.l8l of 2025
Between:
Mahbub College (Multi-purpose Higher Secondary Schcr l)Society,
represented by its President
.Appellant
AND
Venkat Narayana Educational Society and two others.
...
Respondents
CO MMONJUDGMENT: Qter Hon'blc Justice Gadi Prav : ' Kunar)
l.
Since the 1is involved in these appeals and the rt" ision petitions is
common, they are being disposed olby this common judg lent.
2.
Heard Sri Arnith Kumar, leamed Senior Cour s :l appearing for
Sri D.Srinivas Prasad, leamed counsel on record for thc t ppellant, assisted
by Ms.D.Shalini Shravanthi, leamed counsel, in C-M-A. ros.202 and 181
of 2025 for the petitioner in C.R.P.Nos.3559 and 3560 cl 2024 and tbr the
respondents in C.M.A.Nos.252 and 183 of 2025, Sri Suni B Ganu, learned
Senior Counsel assisted by Sri Rusheek Reddy K.V., t: ttned counsel on
record appearing for the appellant in C.M.A.No.183 of 2025, for the
respondents in C.R.P.Nos.3559 and 3560 of 2024 as well as for the
respondents in C.M.A.No,202 of 2025 as well as Dr.K.V.K.Rao, appellant-
party-in-person in C.M.A.No.252 of 2025 and the respondent
tn
C.M.A.No.202 of 2025.
3.
CMA 181 of 2025 as well as CMA No.202 of 2025 is filed by
Mahbub Cotlege (Multi-purpose Higher Secondary Schoot) Society (for
short, 'Mahbub College'), who is the respondent in AOP No.9 of 2022,
and in AOP.No.2O of 2024 respectively, aggrieved by the order and decree
dated,02.04.2025 passed by the learned XII Additionat Chief Judge-FAC-
XXVII Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Court, Secunderabad (for shorr,
'the Trial Court') filed by Venkata Narayana Educational Society (for
short, 'VNES') wherein the leamed Trial Court allowed the said AOP
granting ad interim injunction restraining the respondenrMahbub Cotlege
from entering and interfering with functioning and administration of
VNES, until and unless the disputes between the parties are resolved by the
learned Arbitrator.
4.
CMA No.l83 of 2025 as well as CMA No.252 of 2025 is filed by
VNES aggrieved by the order dated 02.04.2025 passed in AOP No.20 of
2024 andin AOP No.9 of 2022 respectively on the
file o .he leamed Trial
Court wherein only acl interim injunction was grante(
respondents-Mahbub College from entering and
functioning but refused to suspend the letter of
restraining the
I rterlering with
ternr lation and also
refused to restrain the respondents-Mahbub College
fron addressing any
letters or otherwise approaching any statutory authori i:s
Swami Vivekananda Institute of Technology (SVIT) and
5.
in respect ol
t olton School'
On the other hand, both CRP Nos'3559 and 3560 f 2024
by Mahbub Cotlege being aggrieved by the order dated
are filed
ll i l0'2024 passed
in t.A.No.l302 of 2024 in O'S. No' 195 of 2024 on the f te
of the learned
III Senior Civil Judge, City Civit Court, Secunderabad nd docket order
Ie I.A., relerred
dated 28.10.2014 in o.S.No.195 of 2024,while allowini;
the parlies to arbitration, in view of the arbitration c [r ttses
I
I and I 2
contained in the Agreement dated 27 '08'2015'
I
I
6.
The brief facts of the case are that the Mahbub
(l,r l':ge is a Society
originalty formed in the year 1862 over an extent of 'Ar ; 5'00
of land in
Rashtrapati Road, Secunderabad, consisting of four rrstitutions'
Mahbub Coltege High Schoot, Junior College, Degree
v2 '
O rLlege and SVIT'
which were having approximately 3,000 students' I he appellant
f,
in
C.M.A.Nos.1 8
I and 202 of 2025, Mahbub College' is having an extent of
Acs.4.77 guntas of land in Bolton Road, Secundet:abad'
lease from the Ministry of Defence, Union of India'
which is taken on
and running Centenary
School, Vaghdevi Intemational School and Bolton
School' The Mahbub
College appears to be in existence since 1862, the Degree College
was
estabtishedinlgg3whitethesVlTwasestablishedin2004andBolton
School was established in the year 2009' Initially'
the SVIT was run on a
joint licence basis with Secunderabad Busiuess School under Agreements
dated 17.02.2025, 26.02.2006 and 04'07'2006' Subsequently' these
agreements were terminated in the year 20 15 '
T.Later,VNESwasformedonlg.06.2015trndertheAndhraPradesh
Societies Registration Act, 2001' Mahbub College and
a licence agreement dated 2T '08 '201 5 to
VNES entered into
jointty manage the affairs of SVIT
and Bolton School through a governing body, comprising
of five members
from Mahbub College and five members fi'om VNES under
the directions
ofMahbubCottege.Intheyear2olg,thepresentPresidentofMahbub
Coltege and his family members became members
membership lrom some of the erstwhile members'
of VNES by purchasing
8.
However, disputes arose among the present merl ers of M'JES, the
erstwhile members and also Mahbub College with res I )ct to the various
financial transactions culminating into filing ol O.S.No. ti ol 202 I on the
file of the Trial Court seeking permanent injunction as v e:ll as declaration
of lefters revoking membership as illegal and arbitrar y Subsequently, a
compromise was entered into between the parties there i r and the term of
compromise is to the effect that the amount in question rv ts treated as loan,
which need not be repaid and a decree to that effect was rassed in the said
surt
9.
Thereafter, again on account of disputes that itt cse between the
parties with regard to the various financial transaction; as well as gross
material breaches that attacked the fundamental I Li ture of licence
agreement dated 27.08.2015, the licence was terminat: I under a notice
dated 03.10.2024 by the Mahbub College, which led to iting of multiple
proceedings before various forums such as W.P.N<'. ',7867 of 2021,
W.P.No.35229 of 2022, W.P.No.28459 of 2024, R&-l' ' No.2 of 2024,
W.A.No.463 and 464 of 2023 and so on.
10. As referred above, AOP No.9 of 2022 as well ,r AOP No.20 of
2024 was filed by VNES under Section 9(ii) of thr: .A,rbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 (for short 'the Act') against Mahbub College
seeking to suspend the Letter of Termination dated 03.10.2024 and an
order to restrain the Mahbub College fi'om entering the Petition schedule
properties or interfering in the functioning and administration of SVIT and
Bolton School and also restraining them from addressing any letters or
otherwise approaching any Statutory authorities in respect of SVIT and
Bolton School.
11. The learned Trial Court passed an order dated 02'05.2025, while
considering the petition recorded that the licence agreement dated
27.08.2015, was admitted by both parties, and contained a valid arbitration
clause reflecting their mutual intention to resolve disputes through
arbitration. The fact that both parties had approached the learned Trial
Court by lrting OS.No.l 6 of 2021 was the prima facie indication that there
exists disputes between the parties which requires resolution through
arbitration in terms of the agreement
12. The learned Trial Court further noted that, although voluminous
documents had been produced by both sides in support of their respective
contentions relating to the validity of the termination notice, interpretation
of contractual terms, alleged misappropriation of funds, and alleged
contravention of the agreement, it was not within the trrisdiction of the
leamed Triat court to analyse such material or adjudic rte upon disputed
issues as these were matters squarely falling within tht: urisdiction of the
arbitrator and contemplating them in the said AOP coul,l cause pre.iudice to
the parties in the arbitral proceedings. The leamed T'ri; I Court also took
note of the petitioner's contention that absence of inteli
I protection would
result in interference with the administration of the educ nional institution,
potentialty teading to disruption and affecting the intereri ; of children.
13. On the aforesaid reasoning, the leamed Trial C'r rft partly allowed
the petition and granted interim injunction restraining the respondents from
entering the petition schedule property and from ir t rrfering with the
functioning and administration of the petitioner societ" until the disputes
were resolved by the arbitrator', while declining othe prayers sought,
giving rise to the present CMA.
14. The leamed Senior Counsel for the appellant - vlahbub College,
Sri Amith Kumar as well as Sri D.Srinivas Prasad, cc rtended in CMA
No. l8l and202 of 2025 that the impugned order o-the learned Trial
Court is illegal, contrary to law, contrary to the pleadin. ,s and documents
on record and violative of the fundamental principles -: rverning grant of
t
interim measures under Section 9 of the Act. It was contended that the
order granting interim injunction is in conflict with the most basic notions
of morality and justice.
15. The leamed Senior Counsel further contended that all documents
placed on record clearly establish that Mahbub College is the absolute
owner and possessor of the entire campus at R.P. Road, Secunderabad,
admeasuring about Ac.7.00, along with all buildings and movable
properties therein, and that it has been in possession of the said campus
since 1862. It was further contended that the Bolton Road campus
admeasuring Acs.4.77 guntas has been in its possession since I 962 as a
lessee from the Ministry of Defence, and that these crucial and undisputed
facts were completely ignored by the learned Trial Court. The leamed
counsel further contended that the learned Trial Court committed grave
iltegatity in ignoring the well-settled principle that there cannot be an
injunction against a true owner in possession, the parent body in whose
favour all statutory approvals and affiliations have been granted by
AICTE, JNTLIH and the State Govemment and failed to consider VNES's
own admission, contained in its letter dated 24.04.2024, acknowledging
Mahbub College's possession of the R.P. Road campus and directing
vacating and shifting of the institutions to the Bolton Road campus.
16. lt was further averred that the learned Trial Court a.iled to apply the
basic requirements for grant ol interim protection und':
Section 9 of the
Act, as the respondent neither failed to estabtish an! pi't na facie
proved possession, balance of convenience or irreparat'l : loss'
erroneous finding was recorded that "admittedly the
case nor
and yet an
resl ondent is running
the institutions", contrary to the pleadings and materi' I on record'
learned counsel also assailed the order on the ground lrat no
The
issue was
framedordecidedrelatingtopossession,whichisfbt-rdationaltosuch
relief despite clear pleadings and documents showil I the appellant's
exclusive possession and administration of the institutio r ;'
17. It is also submitted that the leamed Trial Court rr ongly declined to
examine the documents filed by the Mahbub College or the
ground that it
cannot step into the shoes of the arbitrator' Such rt'i soning is
wholly
erroneous, as a Court exercising jurisdiction under Se :tion 9 of Act
required to examine pleadings and documents to assess .'rima facie
is
rights'
It is also contended that the learned Trial court failed tr, ropreciate that the
agreement dated 27.08.2015 is only a licence agreemer ' governed by
the
provisions of the lndian Easements Act, 1882 and that rossession always
remained with the licensor.
i
18. The leamed Senior counsel for Mahbub College further contended
that the licence agreement stood terminated by notice dated 03.10.2024
and that granting injunction permitting the VNES to continue thereafter
amounts to granting specific performance of a determinable contract, in
contravention of Section 14 of the Specific Retief Act, 1963. It is
contended that having hetd that disputes relating to termination, breaches
and financial issues are matters for arbitration, the learned Trial Court had
no
jurisdiction to grant interim injunction despite the respondent
approaching the Court with unclean hands, having indulged ln
impersonation, abuse ofprocess and suppression of material facts and that,
at best, the VNES could seek compensation.
19. The present President of VNES, Dr.Rao appearing as party-inperson, while adopting the arguments of the leamed Senior Counsel
appearing for VNES, contended that that the Agreement dated 27.08.2015
is not a mere licence, as repeatedly portrayed by Mahbub College, but
constitutes a joint sponsorship or co-sponsorship arrangement embodying
an equal partnership between the parties. It is contented that the Agreement
comprehensively structures the govemance, administration, operation and
development of the institutions through carefully delineated rights and
obtigations, under which exclusiQE -and effective managerial, financial,
l1-
operational and functional control stood vested in VNI 'S in accordance
withtheexpresstermsoftheAgreement'Theper:'i;l.entattemptby
Mahbub College to tabet the instrument as a "[icenc: rlgreemetlt" was
contended to be a deliberate mischaracterization, part i :ularly when the
Agreement itself does not describe the arrangement a I it licence at any
place.
20. It was further contended that the Agreement presr:r ibes a mandatory
and staged mechanism for termination, cancellation or , issolution of the
association, commencing with a unanimous decision of 1 re offrce bearers,
followed by consideration by the Goveming Body, pas;rng of a special
resolution therein, and culminating in independent a<< eptance by both
sponsors. According to VNES, Mahbub College nert rer initiated nor
completed this contractual process and therefore cannot ely upon its own
non-compliance to contend absence ol liabitity or dues' In such
circumstances, the termination notice dated 03.10.2024 r zs asserted to be
void, non-est and in complete defiance of the contractual ramework'
21. The VNES contended that the Clauses 10, ll and 12 of the
agreement is ,consent-locked insofar as termination is :rlncemed which
mandates arbitration in the event of disputes and ensures c'ontinuity of the
T
t2
arrangement until quantification and full and final settlement of
claims.
The unilateral termination notice, which proceeded on the assertion
that the
Agreement had
,.worked itself out" and directed vNES to vacate the
premises within hours, was contended to be an archetypal act of
impermissibteself-helptakeover,whollyalientothecontractualscheme.
22. It was further averred that the relief sought by VNES under Section
9 of the Act is purely protective in nature and does not amount to seeking
specific performance of the Agreement' According to VNES, the
interim
protection is intended only to preserve the last admitted contractual srQrls
quore|atingtomanagementandadministrationoftheinstitutionspending
arbitration, so as to prevent the arbitral proceedings from being rendered
nugatory by unilateral disruption. It is contended that the validiry
and legal
effect of the termination notice is an arbitrable issue and that, on a
prima
facie consideration, the notice is ineffective for non-compliance with
the
mandatory procedure under Clauses l0 to l2'
23. The vNES contended that the bar under Sections l4(d) and 4l(e) of
the Specific Relief Act, 1963 has no application, as the Agreement iS not
inherently determinable. Section l4(d) applies only to contracts terminable
at will or by unilateral notice, rvhereas the present Agreement expressly
t3
excludes unilateral termination through three inter < cking contractual
safeguards, namely, the consent-lock under Clause 1(), t re arbitration-lock
under Clause I i, and the continuity-lock till settlemcrt under Clause 12.
Consequently, the contention that compensation alone s the remedy was
argued to be misconceived and incapable of defl: ting the Court's
jurisdiction under Section 9 to preserve the subject matte 'of arbitration.
24. It was also pleaded that the Agreement cannot )e construed as a
licence within the meaning of Section 52 of the lndiz I Easements Act,
1882. On a true construction, the instrument creates rei) Drocal contractual
rights, a detailed govemance architecture and e :onomic sharing
arrangements consistent with a joint sponsorshilr
lr .,olnt venture
arrangement, and not a mere personal permission. The nr Ltrner in vvhich the
document was registered and stamped, the absence <, any schedule of
immovable property or rent consideration, and the I resence of equal
representation, managerial control mechanisms ar I surplus-linked
economics were relied upon to negate the licence tt t ory advanced by
Mahbub College.
25. The VNES further contended that even assuminl, -he Agreement to
be a licence, the same is irrevocable in law under Sectio L 60 of the Indian
t4
Easements Act, 1882. According to VNES, the arrangement is a licence
coupled with interest within the meaning of Section 60(a), as VNES has
executed and caused permanent and endurirg institutional works,
infrastructure, systems and value additions, thereby attracting Section
60(b), rendering unilateral revocation legally impermissible.
26. The leamed Senior counsel for the Appettant-VNES, Sri Sunil B
Ganu as well as Sri Rusheek Reddy KV, in CMA No. 183 and 252 of 2025
contended that the impugned order, to the extent of non-grant of the reliefs
prayed for by the appellant, is contrary to law, settled principles of law and
the evidence on record, and therefore liabte to be set aside. It was
contended that the learned Court below ought to have granted all the reliefs
as prayed for, having regard to the facts and circumstances ofthe case.
. It is contended that the leamed Trial Court erred in refusing to
restrain the respondent-Mahbub College, its members, agents and
representatives from interfering in the enjoyment, functioning and
administration of SVIT and Bolton School and from addressing letters,
representations or otherwise approaching statutory authorities. Such
refusal, according to the appellant, is contrary to the principles of
preponderance of probabilities and well-established principles of law.
l5
28. The VNES stated that the learned Trial Court : red in re lerring to
the agreement dated 27.08.2015 as a licence agreemerr' and in proceeding
on the basis that the same is a admitted fact. Ever lssurning the said
agreement to be a licence agreement, it was contendec hat the same is an
irrevocable and permanent agreement in perpetuity an( VNIIS is protected
under Section 60 of the Indian Easements Act, 1882.
29. It is contended that the termination notice datec 13.10.2024 is null
and void and that on the basis of the said notice, IVi hbub College has
illegatty interfered with the management of the inst tutions, including
attempting to change the operation of bank accounts. iuspension of the
termination notice is essential to protect the subje rt matter ol the
arbitration.
30. The Leamed Senior counsel for the VNES t r ntended that the
leamed Court below erred in holding that passing an ir.t:rim order under
Section 9 of the Act on the validity of the termination r rtice would cause
prejudice belore the arbitrator. Having held, that primo. { r:ie disputes exist
between the parties and that until resolution of such di ; rutes the Mahbub
College could not have terminated the agreement dati:, 27.08.2015, the
leamed Court below ought to have suspended the termination notice dated
03.10.2024 as prayed for.
31. It is further slated that the VNES has been managing the institutions
since inception, that the agreement is still in force and the termination
notice is inoperative, thereby establishing a prima facie case. It is
contended that the balance of convenience lies entirely in favour of the
vNE,S and that non-grant of interim relief would result in irreparable loss
and injury incapable of compensation.
32. The leamed counsel for Mahbub College filed reply denying the
averments made by the respondent in CMA No. 202 of 2025 and appellant
in CMA 252 of 2025 and contending that the argument of \NES regarding
non-compliance with the procedure lor termination under Clauses 10 and
I 2 of the licence agreement dated 27 .08.2015 is wholly misconceived.
It is
contended that the termination was not without cause, as VNES was in
complete breach of its financial obligations under the agreement.
33. It is pleaded that, in any event, the procedure contemplated under
Clauses 10 and 12 stood fully satisfied in view of the Joint Resolution
dated 05.04.2019 passed and signed by members of both societies, wherein
it was agreed that the licence agreement hotld stand terminated forthwith
t7
in the event ol non-payment of dues or disputes am I rg members of the
VNES. The said resolution remains undisputed, and tf ) contention that it
does not amount to an amendment of the agreement is vholly irrelevant at
the interlocutory stage
34. [t is contended that even assuming, without r dmitting, that the
termination procedure was not strictly followed, settle J law mandates that
the only remedy available to the appellant is corr r, ,t:nsation and not
enforcement of the licence agreement by way of injunct (,n. The allegation
of irnproper termination itself presupposes that the contract is
determinable, and no injunction can be granted to enfor: such a contract.
35. [t is averred that every private contract is de r:rminable unless
expressly made irrevocable, and there is no clause in tll: icence agreement
rendering it irrevocable. In view of Section l4(d) read .iith Section 4l(e)
of the Specific l{elief Act, 1963, no injunction can be gr rnted to enforce a
determinable contract. Reliance was placed on Cox & . ings v. IRCTCT,
Overnite Express Ltd. v. DMRC, IOCL v. Amri,l tr Gas Service,
' (2012) 7 scc 5E7
'] 2022 SCC Online t)el2488
l8
Rajasthan Breweries Lld. and Adhunik Steels Ltd. to substantiate the
said legal position
36. It is further contended that the agreement dated27.08.2015 is purely
a licence agreement granting limited participation in management and
squarely attracts Section 52 of the Indian Easements Act, 1882. Upon
termination of such licence, the statutory remedy available to the licensee
is compensation under Section 64 of the Indian Easements Act, 1882 and
not injunction. The use of the rvord "cancel" in Clause 12 instead of
"terminate" does not alter the legal effect, as cancellation includes
termination of contractual obligations, and Clauses l0 and 12 apply only to
termination without cause, whereas the present termination was for
multiple material breaches.
17. It is stated that the tetmination notice dated 03.10.2024 clearty
enumerates over twenty serious breaches committed by the appellant,
including illegal admissions to unapproved courses, impersonation of the
\NES before this Court by fraudulently filing writ petitions, breach of
financial obligations, misuse of institutional premises, issuance of notices
seeking eviction of long-established educational institutions, and falsely
'lrostyrsccs33
t9
claiming ownership over land and buildings conlra
1/ to the licence
agreement.
38. tt is further averred all statutory approvals fior AICTE' JNTUH
and the State Govemment stand exclusively in its rame as the sole
promotersocietysince2004,muchpriortothefirstliccrc:eagreement'and
that restraining the respondent from managing its owtt institutions would
result in loss ol statutory approvals, causing irreparab
( harm to students'
stalf and third-pan-v i nstitutions.
39. It is finalty contended that the appellant aband'r red the arbitration
clause by filing and prosecuting o.S. No. l6 of 2021 be i re the Trial court,
having invoked civil jurisdiction and obtained partial rr: ir:fs, and therefore
cannot approbate and reprobate by selectively revertinr to arbitration at a
later stage.
40.WithrespecttotheCRPS,onl0.l0.2024,MahbrlCollegeflledOS
No.195 of 2024 befbre the [eamed III Senior cjr il Judge seeking
permanent injunction to restrain vNES from interfering
\l,rith the peaceful
possession and enjoyment of the petition schedule F 1)perty and from
interfering in its affairs and running of SVIT and I llton school. on
16.lO.2024,IA No. 1302 of 2024 was filed by VNES st: ing that they have
entered into an agreement dated 27.08.2015 with Ir{ illbub college to
manage SVIT, Swami Vivekananda PG College (SVPG) and Bolton
School and that in the said agreement, in Clause I l, both parties have
agreed that any dispute arising out of the Agreement shall be relerred to
arbitration, which reads as under:
'"that lhe Disputes or Slalemale, if ony, to lhis agreemenl, shall be refeted to a
sole qrbilrator, v'ho shctll be appointed jointly by both the pqrties and resolved in
occordance with the prowsions of the Arbitration ond Conciliation Act, 1996. "
4\. The learned III Senior Civil Judge, upon consideration of the
pteadings and submissions of both sides, passed a docket order dated
28.10.2024 and an order in I.A.No.1302 of 2024, noting that though the
ptaintiffs had instituted O.S. No.16 of 2021 against third parties atleging
breach of a Memorandum of Understanding, Mahbub College was also
arrayed as a defendant and reliefs were sought against it on the premise of
unilateral termination of the licence and waiver of the arbitration clause.
42. Upon perusal of the said agreement daled' 27.08-2015, the learned III
Senior Civit Judge found no provision enabling unilateral termination by
Mahbub Coltege for violation of Clause 11. Referring to Clause 12, it held
that cancellation of the agreement by Mahbub College was contingent
upon settlement of the approved claims of VNES, and in the absence of
any material to show such settlement, the leamed III Senior Civil Judge
concluded that the agreement had not been validly terrl nated and that the
arbitration clause continued to subsist.
43. In view of the existence of a subsisting arb t ation clause, the
leamed III Senior Civil Judge rejected the contention trat the agreement
stood terminated or that the arbitration clause had been 'araived, and held
that the III Senior Civil Judge tacked jurisdiction to :ntertain the suit
Accordingly, I.A. No. ll02 oi2024 filed under Sectior U olthe Act was
allowed, the parties were referred to arbitration, and t te proceedings in
O.S, No.l95 of 2024 were ordered to be closed, givinp 'ise to the present
CRP
44. The leamed counsel for the petitioner-Mahbub ( ollege contended
that the leamed III Senior Civil Judge did not touch th,: disputes on merit
between the parties to the suit in an application filed un<t, r Section 8 of the
Act and that the III Senior Civit Judge committed grarr irregularity even
by holding that the termination of the agreement datec 17.08.2015 is not
valid according to rts own finding in the previous sentence, and it
completely failed to apply its mind to hnd out as t,r 'whether a valid
arbitration agreement exists between the petitioner and t re respondents in
spite of clear pleas by the petitioner
45. It is also contended that the III Senior Civil Judge committed
material irregularity by relying on the generic recital of definition of the
second party, which includes its administrators, etc., and committed gross
error by holding that the respondent Nos.2 and 3 are the nominees and
hence, it cannot be said that the agreement is already terminated and
arbitration clause has been waived offby respondentNo.1.
46. It is further contended that the III Senior Civil Judge also committed
an error by allowing the application despite a specific plea that the acts of
the Mahbub College in breach of the licnece agreement amounted to fraud
being committed against public at large as it defrauded the income tax
department by claiming tax exemption by merging the accounts of the
institutions with that of the petitioner and caused a loss of over l3 crores to
the exchequer of the State which resulted in both the petitioner and the
respondent No.l receiving demand notices from the income tax department
and that the III Senior Civil Judge committed irregularity in dealing with
the said issue by maintaining complete silence as to the arbitrability of the
dispute itself. Therefore, prays to allow the CRP by setting aside the order
dated 28.10.2024 passed in I.A.No.1302 of 2024 in O.S.No. 195 of 2024
and also docket order passed in O.S.No.195 of 2024 dated28.10.2024.
47. We have given our eamest cOnsideration to the I rrious contentions
urged by the parties and also perused the substantial ma t rial on record.
48. From the pleadings, submissions and the order-s 'mpugned in the
connected civit Miscetlaneous Appeals and civil Rer i rion Petitions, the
following issues arise for consideration:
l. Whether the arbitration clause in the Agreement 't ed 27-08'2015
stood abandoned or waived b1t the conduct of the par ies'?
2. ll/hether the Civil Court lacked jurisdiction to trr the disputes on
the ground tfutt they are commercial disputes?
3. Whether the termination notice dated 03- 10.2(-):' is liable to be
suspended at the interlocutory stage?
4. Whether the interim iniunction granted against t lehbub College
w arr ant s i n t e rfer e n c e?
5. Whether Mahbub College could be restrained Jnt n addressing or
approaching statutoty and regulatory authorities ;, respect of the
institutions?
Issue No.l: Whether the a rbitration clause stood aba ! doned or waived
49. The principal contention of Mahbub College is t rat the arbitration
clause contained in the Agreement dated 27.08.201j; stood waived or
abandoned by reason of the institution O.S. No.16 rf 2021 and the
participation of both parties in the civil proceedings aris r 6; therefrom.
50. There is no dispute that the Agreement dated 27.08.2015 contains a
specif,rc arbitration clause, namely Clause I 1, which expressly provides
that all disputes ol stalemates arising out of the agreement shall be referred
to arbitration. Further, it is a settled principle of law that an arbitration
clause constitutes a separate and independent agreement, distinct from the
substantive terms of the contract in which it is embedded. This doctrine of
separability stands statutorily lecognized under Section 16 of the Act
which states that an arbitration agreernent survives notwithstanding
allegations of breach or termination of the underlying contract.
51. Therefore, when this very issue arose for consideration before the
learned III Senior Civil Judge in I.A. No.l302 of 2024 in O.S. No.t95 of
2024, a clear finding was recorded that the arbitration clause is severable,
independent and continues to bind the parties.
52. A perusal ol the record reveals that O.S. No. 16 of 2021 was
instituted before the Trial Court in the context of disputes inter se members
and erstwhile members of the society, though Mahbub College was arrayed
as one of the parties. Waiver of an arbitration agreement cannot be lightly
inferred as such waiver must be clear, conscious and on unequivocal terms.
Mere participation in civil proceedings, in the absence of a demonstrable
intention to relinquish arbitration as the agreed , ispute resolution
mechanism, does not amount to waiver.
53. This Court, therefore, holds that the arbitration : zLuse contained in
the Agreement dated 27.08.2015 is an
indepenckr
t and subsisting
arbitration agreement, and that the institution and pr rsecution ol O.S
No.l6 of2021 does not amount to waiver or abandonnror t of the same.
Issue No.2: Whether the C ivil Court lacked iuris d iction to try thr
disputes
54. The Mahbub College contended that the disputc: tre commercial in
nature and therefore fall within the exclusive irr isdiction of the
Commercial Court, rendering the proceedings before tr I Civil Court and
Trial Court without jurisdiction
55. It is inherent that once parties have entered I to an arbitration
agreement, the jurisdiction of civil courts, including co I mercia[ courts, is
govemed by the Act. Proceedings under Sections 8 and') c,f the Act are not
trials of commercial disputes but are ancillary procer: lings intended to
facilitate arbitration. The mere fact that the transactic r has comtnercial
attributes does not, by itself, confer exclusive jur sdiction on the
Commercial Court so as to override the agreed arbitral nt, c,hanism.
56. More importantly, this Court has already held that
the arbitration
clausecontainedintheAgreementdated2T.0820t5isindependent'valid
and subsisting. In the face of a continuing
arbitration agreement' it would
be neither appropriate nor efhcacious for
parallel proceedings to be
pursued before civit or commercial courts
on the same contractual
relationship. The legislative policy underlying
resolution of disputes through arbitration'
the Act clearly favours
once and for all' in the forum
chosen bY the Parties themselves'
57. In such circumstances, the prarties approaching arbitration
twin purposes of respecting party autonomy
and finat adjudication o[all disputes
serves the
and ensuring a comprehensive
arising out of the agreement' without
multiplicitY of Proceedings'
Issue No. 3: Whethe r the te rminati on
notice dated 0 3.10.2024sh ould be
susDe nded
58. The VNES sought suspension of the termination notice
03.10.2024, contending that the termination
dated
is void for non-compliance
with Clauses 10, 11 and 12 of the Agreement and
that continuity of the
arrangement is contractually mandated till settlement
of claims'
59. This Court ltnds no merit in the said contention : the interlocutory
stage as the validity and legal effect of the terminatio notice lie at the
heart of the arbitral dispute. Whether the Agreement is e tnere licence or a
joint sponsorship arrangement, whether termination rvrr pennissible, and
whether the contractual procedure for termination stood , omplied with, are
all matters requiring detailed evidence and contractual in' :rpretation.
60. Therefore, the issue regarding the refusal to susp,: Lti the termination
notice calls for no interference.
Issue No.4: Whether the interim ini unction asainsl l[ahbub Collese
warrants interference
61. Mahbub Cotlege contended that the injunction I,r rnted amounts to
an impermissible restraint against a true owner in ; rssession and
IS
contrary to settled principles of law
62. 'I he injunction in question is purely interim and pr rtective in nature.
It does not confer title, declare ownership, or finally dett:r ntine the legality,
validity or effect of the termination notice dated 03.1 ).2024. All such
questions are consciously and expressly left open for a< irrdication by the
arbitrator
63. The interim protection granted is inte nded only to maintain the
existing state of affairs and to erlsure continuity in the functioning of the
educational institutions pending arbitral adjudication. The object is to
prevent unilateral disruption that may irreversibly preiudice the arbitral
process itself, particularly in matters involving running educational
institutions where students, staff and statutory compliances are directly
impacted.
64. Section 9 of the Act empowers the Court to grant interim measures
to preserve the subject matter of arbitration and to ensure that the arbitral
proceedings are not reudered null. The injunction granted squarely falls
within the said limited protective jurisdiction. Any attempt by this Court to
examine the legality of the terrnination or to adj udicate competing
contractual rights at this stage u,ould not only be contrary to the legislative
intent underlying the Act but u'ould also trench upon the autonomy of the
arbitral process.
65. Therefore, the interim injunction neither amounts to a final
adjudication nor warrants interf'erence at this stage until further orders are
passed by the leamed Arbitrator. However, in view of large pending
titigation, both parties are at liberty to raise respective ontentions before
the Iearned Arbitrator
Issue No.5: Whether Mahbub Collese could be restrained from
ADD roachins statutory authorities
66. VNES sought a restraint against Mahbub Collell from addressing
letters, representations or otherwise approaching statut(:/ and regulatory
authorities such as AICTE, JNTUH and the State Gover t nent
67. This Court is of the considered view that such r relief is legatly
impermissible. Statutory and regulatory authorities discharge public
functions under goveming enactments. A private c < rLtractual dispute
cannot be made the basis to restrain a party from compll ng with statutory
obligations or from communicating with regulatory authc rties.
68. lt is not in dispute that statutory approvals and i I iliations stand in
the name of Mahbub College. Any intervention pr ''renting it from
approaching regulatory authorities may jeopardize :ompliances and
adversely affect students, staff and third parties. Such a r :straint w'ould go
far beyond the scope of Section 9 of the Act and ' rould amount to
enforcing disputed contractual rights at an interlocutor5' ; lge.
69.
Therefore, the refusal ofsuch
relief calls for no interference.
70. The Constitution of India, through
directive principles, guarantees
them as essential pillars lor
access to hearth and education,
human digrrity. and in today,s
effective realization is vital for
development of the Nation'
Therefore, ecrucation should
Educational institutions exist
ultimately affects the welfare
the constitutional mandate
by managernent interests alone.
and contr.r creare uncertainty
not to be carried on at the
and future shourd not surfer
that
which obrigates the State and
cost of
due to conflicts
position gains added significance
ensure that access to education
society, and
of the students, teachers and academic
functioning. Such disputes ought
between managements' This
the overall
not be treated as a
for the benefit of students and
prolonged disputes ove. administration
recognizing
society their
social progress, equality, and
mere commercial activity driven
students' whose education
its fundamental rights and
in view of
a, stakehorders to
rs not impeded by administrative
or
managerial conflicts
71. Further, in the agreement dared 27.Og.20t5,Mahbub
as MIES have noted the importance
it in the objects as hereunder:
College as well
of promoting education by including
3.1
,,4,
OBJECTS:-
The objects of lhe .school ores-
(i) lo impqrt und promole educalion, and
(ii) lo underldke oll legitimale activities which will help lo a't 'in our aim
72. In light ol' the above discussion, it is clear that educational
institutions occupy a central position in the process of I lrrtion-building by
shaping future leaders, innovators, and responsible citiz t ns who contribute
to the social, economic, and democratic development o the country. The
growing tendency to view education through a purely commercial lens
dilutes this core purpose and detracts from the role ol s rch instittrtions as
instruments ofsocial advancement and equal opportunjt,,
73. For the foregoing reasons and upon considerati(,r of the facts and
pleadings, this Court holds that the arbitration claus,: contained in the
agreement dated 27.08.2015 continues to subsist anc has neither been
abandoned nor waived by the conduct of the parties. Tha the issues raised
are contractual and arbitrable in nature and are requirr d to be resolved
comprehensively through arbitration. All other issues re expressly left
open to be urged before the leamed Arbitrator, who s r ril adjudicate the
same independently and on their own merits, unirr luenced by any
observations made in this judgment.
4. We, therefbre, hold that the parties are relesated to arbitration and
Hon'ble Sri Justice L.Nageswara llao. ijormer Judge, Supreme Court of
India, R/o 304, Scctol l5,A, Noida- 201301, [.tttar Pradesh, India, ls
appointed as the sole Arbitrator, rvho u'ill ad.iudicate the disputes between
the parties, as may be raised before hirn. I'he leamed Arbitrator shall make
appropriate disclosure of all the contentions in terms of the provisions of
the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, and shall be entitled to charge
fees according to the provisions of the .Act. l'he interiru injunction shall
remain in force until further orders passed by the leamed Arbitrator.
75. In the result, the Civil Miscellaneor,'s Appeals and Civil Revision
Petitions stand dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs. Pending
miscellaneous applications. if any, shall stand closed.
SD/- K.SRINIVASA RAO
JOINT REGISTRAR
,TRUE COPY//
ECTION OFFICER
To
Sri Justice L.Nageswara Rao, Former Judge, Sup.reme Court of lndia'
io+, s"cto. 15 A; Noida - 2o13o1, Uttar Pridesh' lndia ( By Speed Post )
( along with a copy of affidavit and material papers)
itr" Xivtt Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Courts, Secunderabad
The Ill Senior Civil Judge, City Civil Courts, Secunderabad'
One CC to SRl. D. SRINaVAS PRASAD, Advocate [OPUC]
One CC to Sri K.V.Rusheek Reddy, Advocate (OPUC)
One CC to Sri. G. Vamshi Krishna, Advocate (OPUC)
RJo'
7. Two CD Copies
8. One CC to Dr.K.V.K.Rao, Party-in-person President Venkat Narayana
Educational Society,Plot No.102, High Court
Colony,Van astha lip u ra m, Hyde ra bad-500070
Kul/ps I
Vr'
\
HIGH COURT
DATED: 1110212026
COMMON JUDGMENT
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL Nos. 181 183 202 & 252 of 2025
and C.R.P.Nos.3559 and 3560 ot 2024
I HE S
,i
( :\
)
)
Cr
a-
I t{ fl 206
]1
)-
\ .l
DISMISSIN(; TIll, CIYIL NIISCELL:\NEOUS I\PPEALS
AND CIVII, T{EVISIoN PEI'ITIONS
WITIIOLII' COSl'S
\o
-eA
YA-
#(eret
o
*
\C)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review