Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 21
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
WP(C) No.920/2023
Pronounced on : 12.05.2026
Uploaded on : 13.05.2026
Mahant Subash Shah, Age 73 years
Chela of Mahant Harikrishan Shah, Mahant
Suthrashahi, Pakka Danga, Jammu
….Petitioner(s)
Through :- Ms. Shivani Jalali, Sr. Advocate with
Ms. Isha Razdan, Advocate
V/s
1. Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir
Through its Principle Secretary,
Housing & Urban Development
Department, Civil Secretariat, J&K,
Jammu
2. Chairman, Municipal Council, Kathua.
3. Tajual Tareef, Tehsildar,
Tehsil and District Kathua.
4. Neetu Devi,
W/o Late Satish Kumar,
R/o Shiv Mandir, Ward No.6, Teshil and
District Kathua.
Through :CORAM:
….Respondent(s)
Mr. Suneel Malhotra, GA
Mr. Vikas Mangotra, Advocate
HON’BLE MS.JUSTICE MOKSHA KHAJURIA KAZMI, JUDGE
ORDER
12.05.2026
1.
By this petition, the petitioner herein inter alia seeks to quash all the
proceedings holding respondent No.4 as beneficiary including the
permission granted by the Municipal Council on a land owned by the
petitioner with a further directions to the official respondents to restrain
the private respondent from raising construction under PMAY Scheme on
the temple land at Dharamshalla, Suthrian, Ward No.7, Kathua.
WP(C) No.920/2023
2.
It is submitted that the petitioner is successor-in-interest of Suthrashahi
Sect, which has its properties in Jammu & Kashmir, one such property is
Dharamshala and appurtenant situated at Ward No.7, Tehsil and District
Kathua with a Shiv Temple inside it. Respondent No.4 is stated to be the
wife of late One Satish Kumar, who was pujari of the Shiv Temple
situated in the premises of Suthrashahi property, belonging to the
petitioner. According to the petitioner, respondent No.4, sought benefit
under the Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojna (PMAY), a Central Government
Scheme, aimed at providing affordable houses to the poor. She also
sought declaration from Tehsildar, Kathua in order to take benefit of the
scheme besides seeking permission from the Chairman, Municipal
Council, Kathua for raising construction. It is stated that the Tehsildar,
Kathua clandestinely without confirming the title of the land allowed the
late husband of respondent No.4 to go ahead with the construction and
accepted him as a beneficiary under the PMAY scheme.
3.
On coming to know about the permission granted in favour of respondent
No.4, petitioner vide communication dated 11th November, 2022
requested the Chairman, Municipal Council, Kathua to restrain the private
respondent from raising any illegal construction over the property owned
and possessed by the petitioner. When representation filed by the
petitioner did not yield any result, a legal notice was issued to respondent
Nos. 2 and 3 but the same also in vain, which constrained the petitioner to
file the instant petition.
4.
Per contra, in the objections filed by the official respondents, it is stated
that the petitioner has raised disputed question of facts, which cannot be
adjudicated by this Court in exercise of extraordinary writ jurisdiction. It
WP(C) No.920/2023
is stated that the Government of India launched Pradhan Mantri Awas
Yojana (Urban Mission) Scheme for all over India including that of J&K,
in the UT of J&K, Housing Board is the nodal agency for implementation
of the same. It is further stated that respondent No.4 was one of the
beneficiaries of the scheme and pursuant to the report and
recommendations of the revenue authorities, her dwelling unit has been
sanctioned for construction under the supervision of nodal agency.
5.
The claim of the petitioner is also resisted by respondent No.4, who in her
objections has stated that she is a widow of late Sh. Satish Kumar and is
permanent resident of Ward No.7, Kathua. It is further stated that family
of her deceased husband is residing in Shiv Mandir near Sabzi Mandi
Main Bazar, kathua for the last more than hundred years. According to
her, the temple under reference is the ancestral property of forefathers of
her husband, whose samadhis are in the temple. It has further been stated
that respondent No.4 along with her in-laws has been in settled possession
of the subject property and it is only after proper verification, benefit
under PMAY scheme has been granted in her favour.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner would argue that after his succession to
the Sutrashahi Gaddi, ownership rights with respect to all the temples,
Dharamshala including the one at Ward No.7, Kathua devolved upon the
petitioner, as such, it is not understandable as to how the respondents
without affirming the ownership as well as title of the land have granted
permission to the private respondent to raise construction and to render
her eligible under PMAY scheme.
7.
On the other hand, learned counsel for private respondents as well as for
the official respondents would argue that the issue sought to be raised in
WP(C) No.920/2023
this writ petition are disputed and factual in nature, which cannot be gone
into in the exercise of extraordinary writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India. It is stated that petitioner has no right, title or
interest in the subject property and that the private respondent and her inlaws are in settled possession of the subject property.
8.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material available
on record.
9.
From the pleadings of the parties, it becomes evident that the ownership
and possession of the petitioner over the temple, which is subject matter
of this writ petition has been specifically denied by the private respondent.
Even, as per the official respondents, benefit of PMAY scheme has been
granted in favour of the private respondent pursuant to the report and
recommendations of the revenue authorities.
10.
The petitioner is relying upon order dated 21.01.1983 passed by the
District Judge, Kathua, in an appeal titled Uttam Chand v. Subash and
others, wherein, as per the petitioner, it has been decided that the property
in dispute is owned and possessed by the petitioner, whereas perusal of
the same clearly reflects that the Court of learned District Judge, Kathua
has not given any finding with respect to the ownership and possession of
the petitioner with respect to the property in question. Moreover, the
petitioner has failed to show his entitlement or locus to file the present
petition.
11.
In the present petition, the dispute between the parties is relating to
property rights with regard to the Shiv Temple situated at Ward No.7
Kathua for which the appropriate remedy is before the civil courts because
the questions of fact can be answered on the basis of the evidence adduced
WP(C) No.920/2023
by the parties but not in a writ petition filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution.
12.
In Dwarka Prasad Agrawal v. B.D.Agrawal, (2003) 6 SCC 230, the
Supreme Court has observed that a writ remedy is not available for
resolution of a property or a title dispute. Relevant extract of the judgment
is reproduced hereunder:
“The High Court derives its jurisdiction in terms of Article
226 of the Constitution of India, if an occasion arises therefor, to
make judicial review of the order passed by a statutory
authority. It is beyond any cavil that no writ can be issued if the
disputes involve private law character. The writ court has also
no jurisdiction to determine an issue on private dispute over a
property or right under a partnership.”
13.
The Supreme Court in Roshina T v. Abdul Azeez K.T. and others,
(2019) 2 SCC 329 observed thus:
“It has been consistently held by this Court that a regular suit is
the appropriate remedy for settlement of the disputes relating to
property rights between the private persons. The remedy under
Article 226 of the Constitution shall not be available except
where violation of some statutory duty on the part of statutory
authority is alleged. In such cases, the Court has jurisdiction to
issue appropriate directions to the authority concerned. It is
held that the High Court cannot allow its constitutional
jurisdiction to be used for deciding disputes, for which remedies
under the general law, civil or criminal are available. This
court has held that it is not intended to replace the ordinary
remedies by way of a civil suit or application available to an
aggrieved person. The jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution being special and extraordinary, it should not be
exercised casually or lightly on mere asking by the litigant. (See
Mohan Pande. Usha Rani, 1992 (4) SCC 61 and Dwarka
Prasad Agrawal v. B.D. Agrawal (2003) 6 SCC 230).
WP(C) No.920/2023
14.
From the aforementioned judicial pronouncement of the Supreme Court it
becomes crustal clear that a regular suit is the appropriate remedy for
settlement of property disputes between the private parties and no writ can
be issued in such a matter.
15.
In the instant case, there is a property dispute between the petitioner and
respondent No.4 with regard to the ownership and possession over a
Temple situated at Ward No.7, Kathua, which indeed is a disputed
question of facts, cannot be determined in these proceedings as the
appropriate remedy for seeking settlement of property dispute between the
private persons is before the Civil Court.
16.
In view of the above, the writ petition is dismissed as not maintainable
with liberty to avail the remedy before the civil court, if so desires.
Jammu:
12.05.2026
) (Moksha Khajuria Kazmi)
Judge
Vinod.
Whether the order is reportable: Yes/No
Vinod Kumar
2026.05.13 17:27
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review