Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/26
GAHC010008062015
2026:GAU-AS:3273
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/585/2015
MAHABIR PRASAD AGARWALLA
S/O LT. KIRORIMAL AGARWALLA R/O 1B, RYOAL SILVER TOWER, LACHIT
NAGAR, MAIN ROAD, NEAR BYE-LANE NO. 1, ULUBARI, P.O. GUWAHATI781007, DIST. KAMRUP M, ASSAM.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 3 ORS
REP. BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM,
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT, DISPUR, GUWAHATI-781006, DIST.
KAMRUP M, ASSAM.
2:THE COMMISSIONER AND SPECIAL SECRETARY
TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
DISPUR
GUWAHATI- 781006
DIST. KAMRUP M
ASSAM.
3:THE CHIEF ENGINEER
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT ROADS
ASSAM
CHANDMARI
GUWAHATI- 781003
DIST. KAMRUP M
ASSAM.
4:THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
Page No.# 2/26
GOALPARA RURAL ROADS DIVISION
GOALPARA
Linked Case : WP(C)/696/2015
MAHABIR PRASAD AGARWALLA
S/O- LT. KIRORIMAL AGARWALLA
R/O- 1B
RYOAL SILVER TOWER
LACHIT NAGAR
MAIN ROAD
NEAR BY-LANE 1
ULUBARI
P.O.- GUWAHATI- 781007
DIST.- KAMRUP M
ASSAM.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 4 ORS
REP. BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
PUBLIC WORKS DEPTT.
DISPUR
GHY- 6
DIST.- KAMRUP M
ASSAM.
2:THE COMMISSIONER AND SPECIAL SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
PUBLIC WORKS DEPTT.
DISPUR
GHY- 6
DIST.- KAMRUP M
ASSAM.
3:THE CHIEF ENGINEER
PUBLIC WORKS DEPTT. ROADS
ASSAM
CHANDMARI
GHY- 3
DIST.- KAMRUP M
ASSAM.
4:THE CHIEF ENGINEER
PUBLIC WORKS DEPTT. RIDF
ASSAM
CHANDMARI
Page No.# 3/26
GHY- 3
DIST.- KAMRUP M
ASSAM.
5:THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
PUBLIC WORKS DEPTT.
GOALPARA RURAL ROADS DIVISION
GOALPARA.
Linked Case : WP(C)/582/2015
MAHABIR PRASAD AGARWALLA
S/O LT. KIRORIMAL AGARWALLA
R/O 1B
RYOAL SILVER TOWER
LACHIT NAGAR
MAIN ROAD
NEAR BYE -LANE 1
ULUBARI
P.O. GUWAHATI- 781007
DIST. KAMRUP M
ASSAM.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 5 ORS
REP. BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-06.
2:THE COMMISSIONER AND SPECIAL SECRETARY
TO THE GOVT.OF ASSAM
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-6.
3:THE CHIEF ENGINEER
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT ROADS
ASSAM
CHANDMARI
GUWAHATI- 781003
DIST. KAMRUP M
ASSAM.
4:THE EMPOWERED OFFICER
Page No.# 4/26
PMGSY
ASRB
CHANDMARI
GUWAHATI- 781003
DIST.KAMRUP M
ASSAM.
5:THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
GOALPARA
RURAL ROADS DIVISION
P.O. and DIST. GOALPARA
ASSAM.
6:THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
DHUBRI RURAL ROADS DIVISION
P.O. and DIST. DHUBRI
ASSAM.
Linked Case : WP(C)/180/2015
MAHABIR PRASAD AGARWALLA
S/O- LT. KIRORIMAL AGARWALLA
R/O- 1B
ROYAL SILVER TOWER
LACHIT NAGAR
MAIN ROAD
NEAR BYE-LANE 1
ULUBARI
P.O.- GHY- 7
DIST.- KAMRUP M
ASSAM.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 5 ORS
REP. BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
PUBLIC WORKS DEPTT.
DISPUR
GHY- 6.
2:THE COMMISSIONER AND SPECIAL SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
Page No.# 5/26
PUBLIC WORKS DEPTT.
DISPUR
GHY - 6.
3:THE CHIEF ENGINEER
PUBLIC WORKS DEPTT. ROADS
ASSAM
CHANDMARI
GHY- 3
DIST.- KAMRUP M
ASSAM.
4:THE CHIEF ENGINEER
PUBLIC WORKS DEPTT.
ARISP AND RIDF
VASUNDHARA ENCLAVE
B.K. KAKOTI ROAD
ULUBARI
GHY- 7
DIST.- KAMRUP M
ASSAM.
5:THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
PUBLIC WORKS DEPTT.
GUWAHATI AACP DIVISION
GUWAHATI.
6:THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
PUBLIC WORKS DEPTT.
AACP DIVISION
DHUBRI
DIST.- DHUBRI
ASSAM.
Linked Case : WP(C)/732/2015
MAHABIR PRASAD AGARWALLA
S/O LT. KIRORIMAL AGARWALLA
R/O 1B
RYOAL SILVER TOWER
LACHIT NAGAR MAIN ROAD
NEAR BY LANE 1
ULUBARI
P.O. GUWAHATI- 781007
DIST.KAMRUP M
ASSAM.
Page No.# 6/26
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 4 ORS
REP. BY THE COMMISSINER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-6.
2:THE COMMISSIONER AND SPECIAL SECRETARY
TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-6.
3:THE CHIEF ENGINEER
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT ROADS ASSAM
CHANDMARI
GUWAHATI- 781003
DIST. KAMRUP M
ASSAM.
4:THE CHIEF ENGINEER
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT BOARDER ROADS AND NEC WORKS ASSAM
CHANDMARI
GUWAHATI- 781003
DIST. KAMRUP M
ASSAM.
5:THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
KARIMGANJ N.E.C. DIVISION
KARIMGNAJ.
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DEVASHIS BARUAH
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. O. P. Bhati, Advocate
Mr. P. K. Gupta, Advocate
For the Respondent(s) : Mr. P. Nayak, SC, PWD
Page No.# 7/26
Date on which judgment is reserved
: NA
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 27.02.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
Operative part of the judgment?
: NA
Whether the full judgment has been
Pronounced?
: Yes
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. O. P. Bhati, the learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the petitioner in the instant batch of writ petitions. Mr.
P. Nayak, the learned counsel appears on behalf of the PWD who
have been arrayed as respondents in the instant proceedings.
PREFACE
2.
All the writ petitions are filed by the same petitioner who
claims that he is a Class-I registered contractor with the Public
Works Department of the Government of Assam. Various
contract works were issued to the petitioner and the details of
which have been mentioned in the present writ petitions. It is
however very pertinent to take note of that these contract works
were awarded to the petitioner prior to 2015 and this aspect is
apparent from the fact that the writ petitions were filed in the
year 2015. The grievance of the petitioner in all the writ petitions
was that the Respondent Authorities have deducted huge
Page No.# 8/26
amounts of money against the bills of the petitioner on the
ground of payment of royalties which was not permissible as per
law.
CLAIMS OF THE PETITIONER IN THE FIVE WRIT PETITIONS
3.
This Court finds it relevant to take note of the claims of the
Petitioner in the five writ petitions and with specific reference to
the contracts detailed out in each of the writ petitions. The same
are given herein under:
(a)
In WP(C) No.585/2015, the Petitioner herein has sought
for direction for payment of Rs.4,23,762/- which the
petitioner claims that the same have been illegally deducted
from the running bills of the Petitioner. The details of the
claim along with the specific contracts are given herein
under:
SL No. Particulars
Forest
VAT on Total
Date
royalty
FR
final
payment
Construction
Gaurnagar
Road
of 351683
to
360606
63156
Tikrikilla
under
MNPA[Package No.MNPA39A]
for the Contract
Price of Rs.66,15,000.00
Execution of the 1/1 on 61083
Dwarka Bazar to Silsoke
Dhamal Road (L=30.00M)
of
Page No.# 9/26
with
approach
protection
work
and
under
Goalpara (East) LAC in
Goalpara District
412766
10996
423762
(b) In WP(C) No.180/2015, the Petitioner herein has sought
for direction for payment of Rs.26,75,421/- which the
petitioner claims that the same have been illegally deducted
from the running bills of the Petitioner. The details of the
claim along with the specific contracts are given herein
under:
SL No. Particulars
Forest
VAT on Total
Date
royalty
FR
final
of
payment
Upgradation
of 750151
101270
851421
23.08.2012
118836
1377604
01.06.2011
53096
446396
28.05.2012
Barpeta Jania Howly
Road-A(Chainage 1500
M to 4000 M) Contract
No.BR-7A in Barpeta
District of Assam State
under AACP @ a Bid
Price
of
Rs.4,09,55,147
Upgradation
of 1258768
Krishnai
to
Chariali
Resubelpara
Road,
Contract No.GLP-5
Rehabilitation of Road 393300
from Jewali Bangtimari
Road,
HM
Road
to
Page No.# 10/26
Dayarchar Road, Road
from
APS
Road
to
Kalapani Bazar, Road
from
Dharakoba
Bhurakata
via
to
Arat,
and Road from HM
Road to Moinbandha
via
Pecharkandi
Dhubri
in
District
[Contract No.DH®-9]
at
a
Bid
Price
of
Rs.79,95,460.00
2402219
(c)
273202
2675421
In WP(C) No.582/2015, the Petitioner herein has sought
for direction for payment of Rs.44,92,202/- which the
petitioner claims that the same have been illegally deducted
from the running bills of the Petitioner. The details of the
claim along with the specific contracts are given herein
under:
SL No. Particulars
Forest
VAT
royalty
FR
on Total
Date
final
payment
Construction of road 852098
from (i) Lakhipur to
Khalisabhita and (ii)
Lakhipur to Chunari
road
culverts,
including
monor
bridges and routine
maintenance of the
works for five years
Nil
852098
of
Page No.# 11/26
under Package No.AS
07-11PMGSY Ph-IV
Construction of road 301460
40697
342157
from Hatsingimari to
Kokradanga including
cross-drainage works
and
routine
maintenance of the
works for five years
under
PMGSY
(Regular),
Ph-VI.
Package
No.AS-05-
35(Balance Work)
Construction of Road 1378502
123679 1502181
from Gaurnagar to
Chatiamari
Road
including
cross-
drainage works and
routine maintenance
of the works for five
years
under
PMGSY(Regular) PhVI, Package No.AS07-30
Construction
of 1582173 213593 1795766
Road
from
1.Dabil
to
Borpathar,
2.
Dudhnoi
to
Thekasu III, 3.
Makhipara
to
Sialmari,
4.
Dudhunoi
to
Page No.# 12/26
Thekasu
II,
NH-37
5.
to
Kanyakuchi Pahar,
6.
Sidhabari
to
Karipara,
7.
Dolgoma
to
Basantapur 8. G.
D. Road to Khara
Pt.II 9. Lala to
Bandashree Road
including
cross-
drainage
works
and
routine
maintenance
of
the works for five
year
under
PMGSY (Regular)
Ph-VII,
Package
No.AS-07-51
(Balance work)
4114233
377969
4492202
(d) In WP(C) No.696/2015, the Petitioner herein has sought
for direction for payment of Rs.7,31,394/- which the
petitioner claims that the same have been illegally deducted
from the running bills of the Petitioner. The details of the
claim along with the specific contracts are given herein
under:
Page No.# 13/26
SL No. Particulars
Forest
VAT on Total
Date
royalty
FR
final
of
payment
Construction of RCC 294996
bridge
No.2/1
14445
309441
57989
421953
on
Lakhipur Chunari Road
including
approaches
and protection work
under
RIDE-IX
of
NABARD
under
Goalpara
roads
Division @ Bid Price of
Rs.2,88,20,104.00
Construction of RCC 363964
bridge/BUG
No.10/1
over river Jinari on
Goalpara Dodhnoi via
Soinik
School
Road
under
RIDF-XV
of
NABARD in Goalpara
District @ a Bid Price
of Rs.2,52,66,878.00
658960
72434
731394
(e) In WP(C) No.732/2015, the Petitioner herein has sought
for direction for payment of Rs.7,12,737/- which the
petitioner claims that the same have been illegally deducted
from the running bills of the Petitioner. The details of the
claim along with the specific contracts are given herein
under:
Page No.# 14/26
SL
Particulars
No.
Forest
VAT on Total
Date
royalty
FR
final
of
payment
Construction of RCC bridge 630741
81996
712737
9 Nos. approach 16 Nos.
on
Zamuang
Hripjow
Dullavcherra Road under
NEC
Programme
(Improvement/Repairs) to
damage
stretches
by
Metalling, Surfacing work
and Hard Shoulder with
GSB from 1st KM to 8th KM
and 9th KM to 12th KM on
Zamuang
Hriphow
Dullavcherra Road under
NEC Programme.
630741 81996
4.
712737
The records further reveal that during the pendency of the
writ petitions, the petitioner had amended the writ petitions
whereby appropriate directions sought for setting aside the
Notification dated 01.09.2009 issued by the Environment and
Forest Department, Government of Assam. It is however very
apposite to mention that while challenging this Notification
issued by the Forest Department of the Government of Assam,
the Forest Department of the Government of Assam was not
impleaded.
5.
Be that as it may, it is very pertinent to take note of from
Page No.# 15/26
the pleadings in the writ petitions that the challenge to the
Notification dated 01.09.2009 is on the question as to whether
the Notification dated 01.09.2009 is in violation to the provisions
of the Assam Forest Regulation, 1891.
6.
Taking into account that the Forest Department has not
been arrayed as a party, this Court would not like to decide on
the legality or validity of the Notification dated 01.09.2009.
ISSUE
7.
The question therefore arises in the present writ petitions is
as to whether the Respondent Authorities, i.e. the PWD could
deduct and/or withhold any amount on account of payment of
royalties?
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PARTIES
8.
Mr. O. P. Bhati, the learned counsel who appears on behalf
of the petitioner in the present batch of writ petitions submitted
that the petitioner at present is not in a position to produce the
agreements as the works in question were more than one or two
decades old. He further submitted that although there is a
challenge to the Notification dated 01.09.2009, but in the
present facts, the challenge to the Notification dated 01.09.2009
is not necessary taking into account the provisions of the Mines
and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 (for short,
Page No.# 16/26
'the Act of 1957') as well as the Assam Minor Mineral Concession
Rules, 2013 (for short, 'the Rules of 2013') in as much as the
question of payment of royalty would only arise if there is a
permit and/or license issued to the petitioner to extract minor
minerals. The learned counsel submitted that the incidence of
the royalty is not on purchasing a minor mineral, but is on
extraction of the minor mineral, and under such circumstances,
the Clauses 13.3 or 41.1 of the General Conditions of the
Contract or even Clause 4.6.1 of the Special Condition of
Contract would not permit the PWD to withhold the amount to
which the petitioner is entitled. Mr. O. P. Bhati, the learned
counsel or the petitioner further submitted that though in the
affidavit-in-opposition filed by the respondents, it is mentioned
that the petitioner had to collect the minor minerals from some
designated quarry, even the same, if accepted, then also there is
no requirement for the petitioner to pay any royalty to the
Government taking into account that the petitioner was not to
extract any minor minerals from these designated quarries. The
learned counsel further submitted that the statement made in
the affidavit filed by the respondents that the petitioner had to
obtain minor minerals from designated quarries was, however,
not a part of the tender documents or the agreement.
9.
Mr. P. Nayak, the learned Additional Advocate General
Page No.# 17/26
appearing on behalf of the respondents submitted that though
this Court has given various opportunities to the petitioner to
produce the copies of the agreements and the same was not
produced, but a perusal of the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the
respondents would show that the contracts which were entered
into with the petitioner contained various Clauses. He submitted
that in terms with Clause 13.3 as well as Clause 41.1 of the
General Conditions of the Contract stipulated that the rates
quoted by the bidder has to include all duties, taxes, royalties
and other levies payable by the contractor under the contract.
Referring to Clause 41.1 of the General Conditions of the
Contract, the learned Additional Advocate General submitted that
the rates quoted by the contractor shall be deemed to be
inclusive of sales and other levies, duties, royalties, cess, toll,
taxes of the Central and the State Governments, local bodies,
authorities that the contractor will have to pay for the
performance of the contract. He further submitted that Clause
41.1 of the General Conditions of the Contract further
empowered the employer, i.e. the PWD to perform such duties as
regard to deduction of such tax at source as per the applicable
law. Referring to Clause 4.6 of the Special Conditions of the
Contract, the learned Additional Advocate General submitted that
Clause 4.6.1 of the Special Conditions of the Contract is similarly
Page No.# 18/26
worded with Clause 41.1 of the General Conditions of the
Contract. He however submitted that in Clause 4.6.1 of the
Special Conditions of the Contract further mentioned that the
authority would grant the certificate for quantities used for the
work, but will not entertain any claim on the said amount on that
account. The learned Additional Advocate General, further
referring to Clause 4.6.2 of the Special Conditions of the Contract
submitted that the Respondent Authorities have withheld the
amount towards the payment of royalty on the ground that the
petitioner had failed to produce the No-Dues Certificate from the
Collector relating to the payment of royalty. The learned
Additional Advocate General therefore submitted that this is not
a case of deduction from the bills of the petitioner any amount
towards the royalty, but the amount is being withheld on account
of not furnishing the certificate as is required under Clause 4.6.2
of the Special Conditions of the Contract.
ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION
10.
While
deciding
the
issue
involved
in
the
present
proceedings, this Court finds it very pertinent to take note of
some of the Clauses to which the learned Additional Advocate
General appearing on behalf of the respondent PWD has referred
to in the General Conditions of the Contract as well as in the
Special Conditions of the Contract. Mr. P. Nayak,, the learned
Page No.# 19/26
Additional Advocate General referred to Clause 13.3 as well as
Clause 41.1 of the General Conditions of Contract which are
reproduced herein under:“13.3 All duties, taxes, royalties and other levies payable by the Contractor
under the Contract or for any other cause, shall be included in the rates, prices,
and total Bid price submitted by the Bidder.
41.1 The rates quoted by the Contractor shall be deemed to be inclusive of the
sales and other levis, duties, royalties, cess, toll, taxes of Central and State
Governments, local bodies and authorities that the Contractor will have to pay
for the performance of this Contract. The Employer will perform such duties in
regard to the deduction of such taxes at source as per applicable law.”
11. In addition to that, the learned Additional Advocate General
further referred to Clauses 4.6.1 and 4.6.2 of the Special
Conditions of the Contract which are reproduced herein under:“4.6.1 All dues regarding taxes including the sales tax, VAT, other duties,
royalty, 1% Cess on account of building and other construction workers' welfare
cess (Act 1996), etc., levied on the contractor's works by the central, state or
local government, private individual will be payable by the contractor. The
authority will grant a certificate for the quantities actually used on the work but
will not entertain any claim on this account.
4.6.2 Payment of contractor's final bill shall not be released till 'no dues'
certificate from collector relating to the payment of royalty is submitted by the
contractor.”
12. From a perusal of Clause 13.3 of the General Conditions of
the Contract, it is apparently clear that the rate, price and the
total bid so submitted by the bidder should be inclusive of all
Page No.# 20/26
duties, taxes, royalties and other levies payable by the contractor
under the contract. The use of the words “payable by the
contractor under the contract” has to be interpreted to mean
when the contractor is liable to pay the duties, taxes, royalties
and other levies under the contract and not otherwise.
13.
Clause 41.1 of the General Conditions of the Contract as
quoted above also stipulates that the rates quoted by the
contractor shall be deemed to be inclusive of sales tax and other
levies, duties, royalties, cess, toll, taxes of Central and State
Government, local bodies and authorities that the contractor will
have to pay to perform for the performance of the contract. In
other words, the rates so quoted by the contractor are inclusive
of all levies payable by the contractor for the performance of the
contract. Further to that, it is also mentioned in Clause 41.1 of
the General Conditions of the Contract that the employer will
perform such duties as regard to the deduction of such taxes at
source as per applicable law. In other words, the employer would
have the power to deduct taxes provided the same is permissible
under law for the employer to do so. It is no longer res integra
that the power to deduct tax has to be conferred by the statute
and cannot be based upon an agreement entered into by and
between the parties.
14.
This Court further finds it relevant to take note of Clause
Page No.# 21/26
4.6.1 of the Special Conditions of the Contract which stipulates
that all dues regarding taxes including sales tax, VAT and other
duties, royalties, 1% cess on account of building and other
construction workers welfare cess, etc. levied on the contractor's
work by the Central, State, or the local Government, private
individual will be payable by the contractor. In other words, the
contractor is liable to pay those taxes, royalties, cess, etc. which
are levied on the contractor's works by the Central, State, or
local Government, private individual. It also stipulates that for
the purpose of making due assessment, the PWD authority
would grant a certificate for the quantities actually used on the
work, but would not entertain any claim on that account. It may
be pertinent to take note of that in the affidavit so filed, certain
certificates have been enclosed by the PWD authorities as
regards the use of the materials.
15.
Clause 4.6.2 of the Special Conditions of the Contract is
important in as much as the payment of the final bill of the
contractor would be released only upon the No-Dues Certificate
from the Collector relating to payment of royalty is submitted by
the contractor. It is very pertinent to take note of that though
Clause 4.6.2 of the Special Conditions of the Contract stipulates
that the contractor has to produce a No-Dues Certificate from
the Collector relating to payment of royalty, but the question
Page No.# 22/26
arises that if the contractor is not liable to make any payment as
per the Act of 1957 or the Rules of 2013, can the respondents
insist upon a No-Dues Certificate to be issued from the Collector
for the release of the final bill to the petitioners?
16. For deciding aforestated aspect, this Court finds it pertinent
to take note of Rule 5, Rule 8 and Rule 27 of the Rules of 2013.
A perusal of Rule 5 of the Rules of 2013 would show that the
said Rule applies when a temporary mining lease is granted to
the contractor which is connected to a specific work/project of
the Government, its agencies as well as the urban local bodies.
Rule 8 of the Rules of 2013 pertains to issuance of a mining
lease to any bidder through a competitive bidding for a period
ordinarily not less than 10 years but not exceeding 20 years.
Rule 27 of the Rules of 2013 relates to permits for extraction of
ordinary clay/earth.
It is also very pertinent to take note of that by virtue of Rule 5
of the Rules of 2013, a contractor becomes a temporary lessee
of a mining area; by virtue of Rule 8 of the Rules of 2013, the
lessee who is issued the mining lease has the only power to
extract the minor minerals and in terms with Rule 27 of the Rules
of 2013, it is the permit holder who can only extract ordinary
clay/earth.
Page No.# 23/26
Rule 5(3), Rule 8(6) and Rule 27(4) of the Rules of 2013 only
imposes the payment of royalty upon the temporary lessee
(contractor), the leaseholder and the permit holder respectively.
In other words, the temporary leaseholder as per Rule 5 of the
Rules of 2013, the mining leaseholder as per Rule 8 of the Rules
of 2013 and the permit holder as per Rule 27 of the Rules of
2013 are liable to pay the royalty.
It is apposite to mention herein that Rule 5(3) of the Rules of
2013 was inserted only on 11.10.2021, and as such, Rule 5(3) of
the Rules of 2013 shall not be applicable. Apart from that, it is no
one’s case that the petitioner was granted any mining permit.
Under such circumstances, let this Court take into consideration
whether by virtue of Rules 8 and 27 of the Rules of 2013, there
is liability of the petitioner to pay royalty.
17.
The royalty paid by the mining lease holder as well as the
permit holder can very well be passed on to the consumers, but
under no circumstances, the consumers can be imposed the
liability to pay the royalty by the State or other Authorities as per
the mandate of the Rules of 2013. It is also seen from a perusal
of Rule 8 and Rule 27 of the Rules of 2013 that the incidence of
payment of royalty is upon the extraction of the minor minerals
and clay/earth respectively and not on sale of the minor
minerals. Under such circumstances, it is the opinion of this
Page No.# 24/26
Court that if the royalty has already been paid by the mining
lease holder and/or the permit holder there cannot be a double
payment of the royalty by deducting any amount from the bills of
the petitioner.
18.
It is also important to note that the certificate which is
being mentioned in Clause 4.6.2 of the Special Conditions of
Contract is only to keep a check that the State is getting the
royalties for the extracted minor minerals and minor minerals are
not used from illegal source. The said certificate that royalties
have been paid can be given to those persons by the Competent
Authority who is liable to pay the royalties and not to others who
have no liability to pay royalty.
19. Under such circumstances, this Court therefore is of opinion
that the certificate produced by the petitioner from the vendor
from whom the petitioner had purchased the minor minerals
which was used in the contractual works stating therein that the
due royalties were paid on those minor minerals would suffice for
the purpose of releasing the final bill of the petitioner.
CONCLUSION
20.
Accordingly, the writ petitions stand disposed of with the
following observations and directions:(i) This Court directs the Respondent Authorities to release
Page No.# 25/26
the final bill of the petitioner upon production of certificate
issued by the vendor of the petitioner who had sold the
minor minerals to the petitioner for execution of the
contract to the effect that the said minor minerals sold to
the petitioner were royalty paid minor minerals. The vendor
in the said certificate shall also provide the source from
where the minor minerals were extracted.
(ii) The Respondent Authorities, upon receipt of such
certificate, shall cause an enquiry with the concerned
Divisional Forest Officer under whose jurisdiction the minor
minerals were extracted as the source of the minor minerals
would be provided in the certificate submitted by the
petitioner from his vendor.
(iii) This Court further observes and directs that when a
request is made by the PWD to the concerned Divisional
Forest Officer seeking verification, the verification be
conducted by the concerned Divisional Forest Officer within
a period of 30 (thirty) days and due information be given to
the PWD Authorities. Based upon such verification made,
the Respondent Authorities shall release the final bill to the
petitioner.
(iv) It is observed that if the Divisional Forest Officer does
Page No.# 26/26
not provide the verification upon being requested within 30
(thirty) days, it shall be deemed that the Office of the
Divisional Forest Officer had carried out the verification.
(v)
It is further observed that in the circumstance, upon
verification it is found that the minor minerals were used
from illegal and unauthorized sources without payment of
royalty, the PWD Authorities shall deduct amount(s) towards
the royalty payable.
(vi) The said exercise to be completed within a period of
4(four) months from the date on which the copy of the
judgment along with the certificate(s) are placed before the
concerned Chief Engineer, PWD.
JUDGE
Pradip Kumar Kalita
Comparing Assistant
Date: 2026.03.09 18:02:55 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review