Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC App. No.7 of 2024
Magma HDI, General Insurance Company Ltd.,
Represented by its General Manager,
Magma House, 24 Park Street,
Kolkata-700016, West Bengal,
Local office at Netaji Chowmuhani,
Within the building of HDFC Bank,
P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala,
District: West Tripura, PIN-799001.
(Insurer of Truck bearing No.TR-03-B-1805)
---- Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Smt. Susmita Barman (Kar),
W/O Late Shyamal Kar
2. Miss. Sayantika Kar,
D/O. Late Shyamal Kar
Both are residents of Badurtali Lane,
Krishnanagar, P.O. Agartala, PIN-799001,
P.S. West Agartala, District-West Tripura.
----Claimant-Respondent(s)
3. Smt. Sajeda Begam
W/O Michil Miah,
Resident of Srimantpur, Shobhapur,
P.S.-Sonamura, P.O. Sonamura,
District-Sepahijala, Tripura. PIN-799181,
(Owner of Truck bearing No.TR-03-B-1805)
----Owner-Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Rajib Saha, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Kishor Kumar Pal, Adv.
Date of hearing
& delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
30.08.2025
Whether fit for
reporting
:
NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order(Oral)
This appeal is preferred challenging the judgment and
award dated 12.10.2023 delivered by Learned Member, MAC
Tribunal No.1, West Tripura, Agartala in connection with
T.S.(MAC)/314/2022. By the said judgment and award,
Learned Tribunal below has awarded a sum of Rs.58,05,700/with interest at the rate of 9% per annum with effect from
18.11.2022 i.e., from the date of filing of the claim petition to
till the date of actual realization/payment.
2.
Heard Learned Counsel Mr. Rajib Saha, appearing on
behalf of the appellant-Insurance Company and also heard
Learned Counsel, Mr. Kishor Kumar Pal, appearing on behalf
of the respondent-claimant petitioners. None appears on
behalf of the owner of the offending truck bearing No.TR-03B-1805 inspite of receipt of notice.
3.
Taking part in the hearing, Learned Counsel for the
appellant first of all drawn the attention of the Court regarding
the determination of monthly income of the deceased by the
Learned Tribunal below and submitted that based upon the
income tax return for the year 2022-23, supported by balance
sheet which was also not signed by the deceased(Exbt.-10
series in 4 sheets), Learned Tribunal below determined the total
gross annual income of the deceased at Rs.7,56,568/- and from
that, Rs.51,870/- was deducted towards tax and after that,
Learned Tribunal below divided Rs.7,04,698/- by 12 and
determined the monthly income of the deceased at Rs.58,725
which was too high as compared to the income tax return of
2021-22. Learned Counsel for the appellant-Insurance Company
further drawn the attention of the Court that in the income tax
return for the year 2021-22(Exbt.-9), the total income of the
deceased was shown at Rs.4,83,680/- when the deceased paid
Rs.1000/- as tax, but surprisingly within a short span of time
his yearly income has been shown as Rs.6,36,950/- which was
too high because the income tax return for the year 2022-23
was electronically generated on 13.11.2022 and the income tax
return for the assessment year 2021-22 was electronically
generated on 30.03.2022. Learned Counsel further submitted
that the alleged accident took place on 06.09.2022 and on
13.11.2022, the income tax return for the year 2022-23 was
submitted and the balance sheet of his firm was also submitted
and there is no scope to place any reliance upon that as the
same is not free from any embellishment rather it appears that
the same was a manufactured one. Learned Counsel for the
appellant again submitted that since the Learned Tribunal below
based upon the income tax return for the year 2022-23
supported by balance sheet as on 31.03.2022 determined the
monthly income of the deceased at Rs.58,725/-, so, the
calculation of amount cannot be relied upon. So, Learned
Counsel
for
the
appellant-Insurance
Company
urged
for
interference of judgment by this Court for the sake of justice.
It was further submitted by Learned Counsel for the
appellant that the Learned Tribunal below at the time of
delivery of judgment also awarded interest at the rate of 9%
p.a. which was also too high because in most of the nationalized
banks nowadays interest at the rate of 7% or 7.25% or 7.5%
only are being paid as being paid so the rate of interest also
should be modified/reduced in his case. Finally, Learned
Counsel for the appellant urged for allowing this appeal by
setting aside the judgment.
4.
On
the
other
hand,
Learned
Counsel
for
the
respondent-claimant petitioners submitted that on the alleged
date of accident not only the deceased succumbed to his
injuries but his wife also sustained injuries for which separate
claim petition has been filed by the wife of the deceased and
Learned Tribunal allowed the said claim petition filed by the
present
respondent-claimant
petitioners
and
awarded
compensation which is also pending for disposal before this
Court on being appeal filed by the present appellant-Insurance
Company. Regarding this appeal, Learned Counsel for the
respondent-claimant
petitioners
strongly
opposed
the
submission made by Learned Counsel for the appellantInsurance Company and submitted that Learned Tribunal below
based upon the oral/documentary evidence on record rightly
determined the monthly income of the deceased at Rs.58,725/-.
Learned Counsel further submitted that the return was duly
accepted by the Income Tax Department and before the
Learned Tribunal below, the appellant-Insurance Company in
course
of
cross-examination
of
the
respondent-claimant
petitioner as PW-1 did not raise any ground to disbelieve Exbt.9 and Exbt.-10(four sheets). Furthermore from the side of the
appellant-Insurance Company, no evidence was adduced to
disbelieve the said documents. So at this stage of appeal, there
is scope to accept the contention made by Learned Counsel for
the appellant-Insurance Company. Furthermore according to
Learned Counsel for the respondent-claimant petitioners, before
the Learned Tribunal below also, the appellant-Insurance
Company save and except denial did not adduce any other
evidence on record to disallow the claim petition filed by the
respondent-claimant petitioners.
It was further submitted by Learned Counsel for the
respondent-claimant petitioners that even the Hon'ble Apex
Court in different cases awarded interest at the rate of 9% per
annum and in this case the Learned Tribunal below after
consideration of the evidence on record imposed interest at the
rate of 9% per annum which was rational and justified and at
this stage there is no scope to interfere with the same. So,
Learned Counsel urged for dismissal of this appeal filed by the
appellant-Insurance Company.
5.
In this case, the respondent-claimant petitioners filed
one claim petition before the Learned Tribunal, alleging inter
alia that on 06.09.2022 at about 11.45 am, the husband of the
respondent-claimant petitioner No.1, Shyamal Kar along with
the respondent-claimant petitioner No.1 were coming from
Chottokhala towards Agartala via Udaipur by boarding a vehicle
bearing registration No.TR-01-H-0405(Maruti Zen) and when
they reached at Patichari near Atkabazar under Shantirbazar
Police Station, that time, one truck bearing registration No.TR03-B-1805 came from the opposite direction with high speed
and due to rash and negligent driving of the said vehicle by its
driver. The driver took the vehicle in the wrong side and
suddenly dashed against the right frontal portion of the vehicle,
being boarded by the respondent-claimant petitioner No.1 and
her husband bearing registration No.TR-01-H-0405 (Maruti Zen)
and due to violent dashing, the right frontal portion of the
Maruti Zen was totally damaged and the victim Shyamal Kar
and his wife Susmita Barman(Kar) received fatal injuries and
the fire service immediately thereafter brought both of them at
Shantirbazar Hospital from where considering the gravity of the
injury both the victims were shifted to AGMC & GBP Hospital
and at GBP Hospital the attending doctor declared husband of
claimant petitioner No.1 as dead and the claimant petitioner
No.1 was shifted to ILS Hospital for better treatment. It was
further submitted that the accident took place due to rash and
negligent driving of the truck by its driver bearing No.TR-03-B1805 and for that accident, a specific police case vide
Shantirbazar
PS
case
no.24
of
under
Section
279/338/427/304(A) of IPC read with Section 184 of M.V Act
was registered. It was further submitted that the deceased was
a businessman of Hardware Wholesale at Agartala Town under
the name and style as M/S. Kar Agencies and from his shop he
used to earn Rs.70,000/- per month and at the time of death,
the deceased victim was 55 years old and due to untimely
death, the respondent-claimant petitioners have been suffering
a lot, so, they filed the claim petition.
The owner of the truck contested the claim petition by
filing
written
objection
denying
the
assertions
of
the
respondent-claimant petitioners and finally took the plea that
on the alleged day of accident the offending truck was duly
insured with the appellant-Insurance Company.
The appellant-Insurance Company also contested the
case by filing written statement denying the assertions of the
respondent-claimant petitioners and submitted that the claim
petition was subjected to strict proof.
6.
Upon the pleadings of the parties, Learned Tribunal
below determined the following points for decision of the claim
petition:
i) Did deceased Shyamal Kar die in a road traffic
accident occurred on 06.09.2022 at about 11.45
a.m. at Patichari near Athka Bazar on Agartala
Sabroom
Main Road under Santir Bazar Police
Station out of use of vehicles bearing registration
No. TR-01-H-0405 (Maruti Zen) and TR-03-B-1805
(Truck) due to rash and negligent driving by the
driver of the Truck?
ii) Are the petitioners entitled to get compensation as
prayed for and if so, to what amount and who is/are
liable to pay the same?
iii) To what other reliefs the parties are entitled?
7.
To substantiate the aforesaid points, the respondent-
claimant petitioner No.1 was examined herself as PW-1 and
relied upon some documents which were marked as Exbt.-1 to
Exbt -10 series.
On the other hand, the owner of the truck was
examined as OPW-1 and relied upon some documents of the
truck
bearing
registration
No.
TR-03-B-1805
which
were
marked as Exbt.-A to Exbt.-C. For convenience, the names of
the
witnesses
as
well
as
the
exhibited
documents
are
mentioned herein below:
Name of the witness of the claimant:
1. PW-1: Smt. Susmita Barman (Kar)
Exhibits of the claimant:
1. Exbt.1(i)-1(xi): FIR along with Ejahar, in lieu of
seizure memo, Mechanical Inspection Reports.
2. Exbt.2(i)-2(xiii): Post Mortem Examination
Report, Final Report.
3. Exbt.3: Death Certificate.
4. Exbt.4: Survival Certificate.
5. Exbt.5: Pan Card of Shyamal Kar.
6. Exbt.6: Aadhar Card.
7. Exbt.7: Insurance policy Certificate.
8. Exbt.8: Trade Licence.
9. Exbt.9: Income tax return acknowledgment.
10.Exbt.10
series:
Income
tax
return
acknowledgment, Balance sheet, Profit and loss
account, Computation of tax.
Name of the witness of the opposite party No.1:
1. OPW-1: Smt. Sajeda Begam
Exhibits of the Opposite Party No.1:
1. Exbt.A: Policy certificate.
2. Exbt.B: Registration Certificate.
3. Exbt.C: Driving Licence.
Finally on conclusion of enquiry, Learned Tribunal below
allowed the claim petition by the judgment and award dated
12.10.2023. The operative portion of the judgment runs as
follows:
ORDER
“It is, therefore, held that the claimant petitioners
are entitled to get compensation of Rs.58,05,700/(Rupees Fiftyeight Lakh Five Thousand Seven
Hundred only) with interest @ 9% per annum with
effect from 18.11.2022 i.e. the date of filing of the
claim petition till the date of actual payment as per
Judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India
passed on 17.10.2022 in CA No.7593 of 2022. The
Opposite Party No.2 namely, MAGMA HDI General
Insurance Company Ltd. will pay the amount of
compensation with interest within 30 days from
today in terms of Section 168(3) of M.V. Act, 1988.
Out of the total awarded amount of compensation
inclusive of interest, the claimant petitioner no.1
will get 70% and the claimant petitioner no.2 will
get 30%. Out of the respective share of claimant
petitioners no.1 and 2, 50% each of their respective
share shall be kept in fixed deposit scheme in their
respective name in any Nationalized Bank of their
locality for a period of five years each and the
remaining 50% of their respective share shall be
paid to them through their respective bank account.
The claimant petitioners no.1 and 2 shall however
be at liberty to withdraw monthly interest from their
fixed deposit to meet their day today expenses. No
loan or premature withdrawal shall be permitted
from/against any of the fixed deposit certificates
without prior permission of this Tribunal.
Supply copy of this award free of cost to the parties.
The claim petition stands disposed of on contest.”
And challenging that judgment, the appellant-Insurance
company has preferred this appeal.
8.
I have heard argument of both the sides and gone
through the judgment and award delivered by Learned Tribunal
below, and also the evidence on record adduced by the parties
before the Learned Tribunal below. It is the admitted position
that before the Learned Tribunal, the present appellant did not
adduce oral/documentary evidence on record save and except
filing of written statement. The respondent-claimant petitioner
No.1 in her examination-in-chief in affidavit supported her
version in the claim petition but during cross-examination by
the present appellant-Insurance Company, she stated that on
the alleged day the deceased Shyamal Kar was driving the
vehicle bearing No.TR-01-H-0405(Maruti Zen) and she took her
seat besides her husband in the front of the vehicle and she
clarified that the truck in question was running on the wrong
track at that relevant point of time. But regarding income tax
returns as relied upon by the respondent-claimant petitioners
which were marked as Exbt.-9 and Exbt.-10 series, it appears
that not a single question was raised by the appellant-Insurance
Company to the respondent-claimant petitioner No.1 during her
cross-examination by the appellant- Insurance Company before
the Learned Tribunal below. Thus, it appears to this Court that
this plea was firstly taken before this Court at the time of
hearing of appeal.
However, at the time of hearing Learned Counsel for
the appellant tried to draw the attention of the Court referring
the income tax return for the period of 2021-22 and 2022-23
and submitted that in both the returns there was huge variation
of income of the deceased. Furthermore, in the balance sheet of
the firm belonging to the deceased, the total gross income of
the deceased was shown as Rs.7,56,568/- which includes
income from business as Rs.7,21,830/- and income from other
sources as Rs.34,738/- i.e. accrued interest on fixed deposit
and referring the same Learned Counsel for the appellant
submitted that the said amount of income from other sources
amounting to Rs.34,738/- could not be taken into consideration
for determination of annual income of the deceased and urged
for interference of this Court. But after going through these
documents and also after going through the oral evidence on
record, I do not find any scope to disbelieve Exbt.-10 series(4
sheets) relied upon by the respondent-claimant petitioners
before the Learned Tribunal below. There is also no contrary
evidence on record from the side of the appellant-Insurance
Company to disbelieve said Exbt.-10 series as relied upon by
the claimant petitioners. So, it appears to this Court Learned
Tribunal below at the time of delivery of judgment rightly
determined the monthly income of the deceased at Rs.58,725/and as such, I do not find any scope to interfere with the same.
Although the appellant took the plea that the accident
took place on 06.09.2022 and the income tax return i.e. Exbt.10 series was electronically generated on 13.12.2022. And from
the evidence on record it appears that there was no infirmity in
the
judgment
of
the
Learned
Tribunal
below
regarding
determination of monthly income of the deceased as a
businessman of hardware. So, the submission of the Learned
Counsel for the appellant cannot be accepted as a genuine and
valid one to take a reverse view about determination of monthly
income of the deceased by the Learned Tribunal.
9.
However at the time of hearing, Learned Counsel for
the appellant-Insurance Company drawn the attention of the
Court that Learned Tribunal at the time of delivery of judgment
imposed rate of interest at 9% per annum with effect from the
date of filing the claim petition to till the date of actual
payment. In this regard, this High Court in several judgments
considering the rate of interest in the nationalized banks of the
country determined the interest at the rate of 7.5% and it
appears to this Court that the Learned Tribunal below at the
time of delivery of judgment determined interest at the rate of
9% which appears to be in higher side. So considering all, after
hearing the submission of Learned Counsel for the appellant it
appears to this Court that only on this point the appellant is
entitled to get some relief from this Court.
So, after hearing both the sides it appears that the
percentage of rate of interest imposed by Learned Tribunal
below should be interfered with. Accordingly, the rate of
interest be awarded in favour of the respondent-claimant
petitioners at the rate of 7.5% in place of 9%. Since Learned
Counsel for the appellant in course of hearing of argument did
not raise any other points to decide this appeal so this Court
also does not find any illegality or perversity in the judgment
delivered by the Learned Tribunal below.
10.
Further on perusal of the judgment of the Learned
Tribunal below it appears that based on the evidence on record
Learned Tribunal came to the observation that the deceased
was a businessman of hardware items who was running his
establishment under the name and style as M/S. Kar Agencies
and he had valid trade licence on that relevant point of time and
relying upon the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in
Sarla Verma & Ors. Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation
reported in (2009) 6 SCC 121, Learned Tribunal below applied
multiplier of 11 and relying upon another judgment of Hon’ble
Supreme Court in National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Pranay
Sethi & Ors., (Spl. Leave Petition(civil) No.25590 of
2014)
further
added
10%
of
the
monthly
income
and
determined the loss of dependency at Rs.85,26,936/- and
thereafter from that amount, deducted 1/3rd of the amount on
account of personal expenditure and determined the net
amount at Rs.56,84,624/- and after that, with that amount
added Rs.16,500/- as loss of estate and Rs.16,500/- towards
funeral expenses and towards loss of consortium, Rs.80,000/(i.e. Rs.40,000 x 2) along with 10% in addition after expiry of 3
years and after final calculation, determined the total amount of
compensation amounting to Rs.58,05,624/- (Rs.56,84,624/- +
Rs.16,500/- +Rs.16,500/- + Rs.88,000/-. Since from the side
of the appellant no further argument was raised in respect of
other conventional heads save and except the rate of interest,
so, it appears to this Court there was no illegality or perversity
in the judgment delivered by Learned Tribunal below.
11.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant-
Insurance Company is partly allowed. The judgment and award
dated 12.10.2023 delivered by Learned MAC Tribunal No.1,
West Tripura, Agartala is hereby modified to the extent that the
respondent-claimant petitioners shall be entitled to get the
compensation of Rs.58,05,700/- along with interest at the rate
of 7.5% per annum with effect from 18.11.2022 i.e. from the
date of filing the claim petition to till the date of actual
payment. The aforesaid amount be deposited by the appellantInsurance Company to the Learned Tribunal below within a
period of 6(six) weeks from the date of delivery of judgment by
this Court and the disbursal of amount shall remain the same as
ordered by Learned Tribunal below by the aforesaid judgment
and award dated 12.10.2023.
12.
With this observation, this present appeal stands
disposed of.
A copy of this judgment be furnished free of cost to the
Learned Counsel for the appellant-Insurance Company and also
a copy of this order be furnished free of cost to the Learned
Counsel for the respondent-claimant petitioners.
Send
down
the
LCR
along
with
a
copy
of
this
judgment/award.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA DATTA DATTA
Date: 2025.09.01 18:06:11 -07'00'
Deepshikha
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review