Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC.APP.No.105 of 2024
Magma HDI General Insurance Co. Ltd.,
represented by its Regional Manager(Legal),
presently having office at ANUJ CHAMBER,
4th Floor, 24 Park Street, Kolkata-700016,
(Insurer of vehicle No.TR-06-A-1753 Truck)
---- Appellant(s)
1. Smti. Sarubala Debbarma,
wife of Late Khelan Debbarma
Versus
2. Smti. Tripurani Debbarma,
daughter of Late Khelan Debbarma
3. Smti. Raima Debbarma,
daughter of Late Khelan Debbarma
all are at present residing at
care of Sri Upendra Debbarma of
Rabicharan Thakur Para, P.S.Radhapur,
District-West Tripura
(Earlier they were residing at Bairagi Para,
P.S.Kalyanpur, District-Khowai, Tripura)
4. Sri Tapas Giri,
son of Sri Maran Giri of
Tutabari Purba Kalyanpur,
P.S.Kalyanpur, District-Khowai,
Tripura
(Owner of vehicle No.TR-06-A-1753 Truck)
----Claimant-Respondent(s)
----Owner-Respondent(s)
5. Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd.,
Sreeji Tower, 3rd Floor,
care of Guwahati Tea
Ware Housing Pvt. Ltd.,
Adjacent to Mahindra Show Room,
Near Ganesh Guri Fly Over, Christian Basti,
Guwahati-781005, Assam
(Insurer of vehicle bearing No.TR-06-5931 Scooty)
----Respondent-Insurer(s)
_____________________________________________________
For Appellant (s)
:
Mr. Samar Das, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Sankar Bhattacharjee, Adv.
Ms. Jeley Debbarma, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
28.04.2025
[---
Date of Judgment
& Order
:
30.04.2025
Whether fit for reporting :
NO
_________________________________________________________
(2)
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This appeal is preferred by the appellant-Insurance
Company for setting aside/modification of the award delivered by
Learned Member, MACT No.1, West Tripura, Agartala dated
04.07.2024 in connection with Case No.T.S.(MAC)63 of 2020.
[2]
Heard Mr. Samar Das, Learned counsel appearing
on behalf of the appellant-Insurance Company and also heard
Mr. Sankar Bhattacharjee, Learned counsel appearing on behalf
of the respondent Nos.1 to 3.
[3]
In course of hearing, Mr. S. Das, Learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the appellant-Insurance Company drawn
the attention of the Court that in this case, at the time of
determination of compensation, three issues were framed by the
Learned Tribunal below and accordingly, the Learned Tribunal
below discussed the issues and gave the findings. But in
determining the amount of compensation, Learned Tribunal
below
worked
out
the
compensation
amounting
to
Rs.49,69,500/- with 7% w.e.f.13.05.2020 to till the date of
actual payment. But the respondent-petitioner No.1 being a
government servant is not entitled to get any compensation
because she was not dependent upon the income of the
deceased but the Learned Tribunal below did not consider the
same.
[4]
It was further submitted by Learned counsel for
the appellant-Insurance Company that in this case, rate of
interest have been imposed by 7% which was in higher side and
needs to be modified. Furthermore, there was contributory
negligence on the part of the deceased which the Learned
Tribunal below has failed to appreciate and consider and thus
(3)
gave
an
erroneous
finding.
So,
Learned
counsel
for
the
appellant-Insurance Company at the end urged for interference
of the judgment/award by setting aside the same or to modify
the award.
[5]
On the other hand, Mr. Sankar Bhattacharjee,
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent-claimant
petitioners submitted that there was no illegality or infirmity in
the judgment/award delivered by the Learned Tribunal below
and the point regarding dependency of the claimant-petitioner
No.1 no such objection was raised by the appellant before the
Learned Tribunal below in course of trial and as such, the same
cannot be accepted at this stage. Furthermore, since the
respondent-claimant
petitioner
No.1
is/was
a
government
servant it does not mean that she was also not depending upon
the income of the deceased and as such, there is no scope to
interfere with the judgment delivered by the Learned Tribunal
below. In respect of rate of interest, Learned counsel for the
respondent-claimant petitioner submitted that Learned Tribunal
below imposed only 7% interest which is rightly been determined
by the Learned Tribunal below and as such, urged for dismissal
of this appeal with costs.
[6]
I have heard both the sides at length and perused
the record of the Learned Tribunal below. It appears that the
respondent-claimant petitioner filed one claim petition before the
Learned Tribunal below alleging inter alia that on 11.02.2020
when the victim Khelan Debbarma was proceeding towards his
school at Utabari S.B. School from his residence by riding the
Scooty bearing registration No.TR-06-5931 and when he reached
near the gate of his School at about 7 a.m. suddenly, one truck
bearing registration No.TR-06-A-1753 came from the back side
(4)
with high speed rashly and negligently dashed against him from
his back side though there was no fault on the part of the victim
and the Truck was responsible for the said accident. As a result
of which the victim fell down and sustained fatal injuries. Soon
after the accident, the victim was shifted to the Kalyanpur
Hospital where from he was referred to AGMC & GBP Hospital at
Agartala wherein the Doctor declared him as dead. After that
postmortem examination was conducted over the dead body of
deceased and a police case was registered at Kalyanpur P.S. vide
Kalyanpur P.S. Case No.12 of 2020. It was further submitted
that the deceased was an under-graduate Teacher under the
Directorate of School Education, Government of Tripura having
his monthly salary of Rs.47,475/- and was 53 years old at the
time of death and the claimant-petitioner Nos.2 and 3 being the
daughters of the deceased were dependent upon the income of
the
deceased
but
the
claimant-petitioner
No.1
was/is
a
government servant and the father of the deceased was also not
dependent upon him. Hence, the claimant-petitioners filed the
claim petition.
[7]
The OP No.1 being the owner cum driver of the
Mini Truck appeared and submitted that he is the owner of
vehicle bearing No.TR-06-A-1753(Tata ACE Gold) which met with
an accident on 11.02.2020 at about 7 a.m. near Tutabari S.B.
School and as a result, one teacher Khelan Debbarma who was
riding the Scooty sustained fatal injuries. It was also submitted
that on the alleged day, the vehicle was duly insured with the
Magma HDI General Insurance Company Ltd. covering the period
from
30.05.2019
to
29.05.2020
and
as
such,
if
any
compensation is awarded that should be borne by the Insurance
Company.
(5)
[8]
The OP No.2 in the original claim petition i.e. the
Insurance Company appeared and submitted that the claim
petition is subjected to strict proof by the claimant petitioners
and denied the assertions of the claimant petitioners in their
claim petition.
[9]
Upon the pleadings of the parties, following issues
were framed :
“(1) Did deceased Khelan Debbarma die in a road
traffic accident occurred on 11.02.2020 at about 7
a.m. near the gate of Utabari S.B. School under
Kalyanpur P.S. out of use of vehicles bearing
registration No.TR-06-5931(Scooty) and TR-06-A1753(Truck) due to rash and negligent driving by
the driver of Truck vehicle ?
(2) Are the petitioners entitled to get compensation
as prayed for and if so, to what amount and who is
liable to pay the same ?
(3) To what other reliefs the parties are entitled ?”
To substantiate the issues, claimant-petitioner
No.2, Miss Tripurani Debbarma was examined as PW-1 and she
relied upon some documents which were marked as Exbt.1 to
Exbt.10. The OP No.1 also examined as OPW-1 and relied upon
some documents which were marked as Exbt.A and Exbt.B.
[10]
Finally, on conclusion of enquiry, Learned Tribunal
below vide judgment and award dated 04.07.2024 allowed the
claim petition. The operative portion of the said judgment and
award runs as under :
“It is therefore, held that the claimant petitioners
are entitled to get compensation of Rs.49,69,500/(Rupees Forty-nine Lakh Sixty nine Thousand Five
hundred only) with interest @ 7% per annum with
effect from 13.05.2020 i.e. the date of filing of the
claim petition till the date of actual payment. O.P
No.2 i.e.Magma HDI General Insurance Co. Ltd. shall
pay the amount of compensation with interest
within 30 days from today.
Out of the awarded amount of compensation
inclusive of interest, the petitioner no.1 will get
40% and the petitioners no.2 and 3 will get 30%
each. Out of the respective share of the petitioners
no.1, 2 and 3, 50% each of their shall be kept in
fixed deposit scheme in their respective name with
any Nationalized Bank of their locality for a period of
five years each and the remaining 50% shall be paid
to them through their respective bank accounts. No
loan or withdrawal shall be permitted from any of
the
fixed
deposit
certificates
without
prior
(6)
permission of this Tribunal. The petitioners no.1,2
and 3 shall, however, be at liberty to withdraw
monthly interest from their fixed deposit accounts
to meet up their day to day expenses.
Supply copy of this award free of cost to the
parties.
The claim petition stands disposed of on
contest.
Make necessary entry in the T.R and in CIS.”
Challenging that award, this appeal is preferred.
[11]
I have heard detailed arguments of both the sides
and gone through the record of the Learned Tribunal below
including the judgment/award. There is no dispute on record in
respect of fact of accident on the alleged day. It is also the
admitted position that the claimant-petitioner No.1 is the wife of
the deceased and the claimant-petitioner Nos.2 and 3 are the
daughters of the deceased. There is no contrary evidence on
record from the side of the contesting OPs that the claimant
petitioners
were
not
depending
upon
the
income
of
the
deceased. Furthermore, the Insurance Company in course of
enquiry before the Learned Tribunal below did not raise this point
nor submitted any contrary evidence on record to substantiate
their
contention
and
furthermore,
by
not
adducing
oral/documentary evidence on record they failed to satisfy the
tribunal below that the claimant-petitioner No.1 was not entitled
to get any compensation. As per the principle of claim case the
dependents are to be duly compensated by the MACT but here in
the case at hand nowhere I find that the claimant-petitioner No.1
was not depending upon the income of the deceased being the
legally married wife and as such, the Learned Tribunal below
rightly allowed the claim petition and also apportioned the
compensation among the claimant-petitioner No.1 and other two
claimants.
(7)
[12]
Further, on perusal of the records it appears that
Learned Tribunal below determined the monthly income of the
deceased at Rs.47,475/- since he was a government servant and
relying upon the judgment of National Insurance Co. Ltd. v.
Pranay Sethi & Ors. [Special Leave to Petition(Civil) no.25590
of 2014] added 15% with that amount as future income and
determined the monthly income of the deceased at (Rs.47,475 +
Rs.7,121/-)=Rs.54,596/- and assessed the loss of dependency at
(Rs.54,596 x 12 x 11)=Rs.72,06,672/- and deducted 1/3rd
amount on account of personal expenditure of the deceased and
calculated the income of the deceased at (Rs.72,06,672 –
Rs.24,02,224/-)=Rs.48,04,448/-
towards
net
income.
Thereafter, relying upon the judgment of Pranay Sethi(supra)
awarded Rs.15,000/- toward loss of estate, further awarded
Rs.15,000/- towards funeral expenses and towards loss of
consortium allowed Rs.1,30,000/- i.e.@ Rs.40,000/- each for
three claimants. With that amount he further added more 10%
based upon the judgment of Pranay Sethi(supra) and thus
calculated
total
Rs.49,69,500/-
amount
and
of
fastened
compensation
the
liability
amounting
of
payment
to
of
compensation upon the Insurance Company for making payment
of
compensation
to
the
respondent-claimant
petitioners.
However, at the time of awarding compensation awarded rate of
interest @ 7% p.a. w.e.f.13.05.2020 to till the date of actual
payment which in my considered view the rate of interest should
be 6% p.a. in place of 7% w.e.f.13.05.2020 to till the date of
actual payment. Regarding apportionment of amount there was
no dispute, so, the same is not interfered with.
[13]
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant is
partly allowed with modification that the respondent-claimant
(8)
petitioners shall be entitled to get Rs.49,69,500/- with 6%
interest p.a. in place of 7% interest p.a. w.e.f.13.05.2020 to till
the date of actual payment. The appellant-Insurance Company
shall deposit the amount to the Tribunal below within a period of
6(six) weeks from the date of passing of the judgment for
making payment to the respondent-claimant petitioners. If any
amount by this time is paid that amount also shall be deducted
from the total amount of compensation to be paid by the
appellant-Insurance Company. The disbursal of amount would be
made as per observation of the Learned Tribunal below.
A copy of this judgment/award be furnished free of
cost to Learned counsel for the appellant-Insurance Company
and a copy of this judgment also be supplied to Learned counsel
for the respondent-claimants free of cost.
Send down the LCR along with a copy of this
judgment/award.
JUDGE
signed by
SABYASACHI Digitally
SABYASACHI
BHATTACHA BHATTACHARJEE
Date: 2025.05.03
RJEE
22:28:58 +05'30'
Sabyasachi B
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review