Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
SWP No. 878/2006
Reserved on: 12.02.2026
Pronounced on : 20.02.2026
Uploaded on : 20.02.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced: Full
Madan Lal Parihar
Through:-
….Petitioners
Mr. Anuj Dewan Raina, Advocate.
V/s
State of J&K & anr
Through:-
…..Respondents
Mr. Vishal Bharti, Dy. AG with
Mr. Vivek Mattoo, Advocate.
\
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
(JUDGMENT)
01.
The petitioner, through the medium of the present
petition,
has
challenged
order
No.
of
dated
03.04.2006 issued by respondent No. 2 whereby his claim for
promotion to the next higher post of Field Assistant has been
rejected.
02.
As per case of the petitioner, he was engaged as a
Chowkidar on daily wage basis with respondent-Corporation
and he was regularized as such in the year 1996. It has been
submitted that the petitioner is having the qualification of B.Sc
SWP No. 878/2006
but the respondents promoted some of the employees, who
were appointed after the appointment of the petitioner, to the
post of Field Assistant, therefore, the petitioner and other
similarly situated persons approached this Court by filing a
writ petition bearing SWP No. 2534/1999, which was disposed
of by this Court vide order dated 25.05.2000 with a direction
to the respondents to examine the whole case and take a
decision within a period of four months of the receipt of the
copy of the said order.
03.
It has been contended that the respondents instead
of considering the case of the petitioner in its proper
perspective on the analogy of persons named in the writ
petition, who though were engaged against class-IV posts in
the respondent-Corporation on later dates, but were allowed
the benefit of promotion to the next higher post of Field
Assistant, rejected the claim of the petitioner vide SFC Order
No. 95/J of 2000 dated 15.12.2000. The stand taken by the
respondents was that because the petitioner was regularized
as Chowkidar in respondent-Corporation in terms of SRO 64,
as such he could not claim parity with persons who, though
junior to him, have been promoted to the next higher post of
Field Assistant prior to issuance of SRO 64 of 1994.
04.
The petitioner along with similarly situated persons
is stated to have filed another writ petition bearing SWP No.
2601/2000, challenging the aforesaid consideration order.
The said writ petition was again disposed of by this Court in
SWP No. 878/2006
terms of order dated 13.03.2003 directing the respondents to
consider the case of the petitioner for their promotion as
Junior Assistant and Field Assistant on their eligibility and
taking note of their experience, qualification and by giving
them same treatment as has been given to respondents No. 4
to 14.
05.
During the pendency of the contempt proceedings,
arising out of the aforesaid order, the respondents passed the
impugned consideration order thereby rejecting the claim of
the petitioner.
06.
The
petitioner
has
challenged
the
impugned
consideration order on the ground that the same is a glaring
example of discrimination and arbitrariness on the part of the
respondents. It has been contended that the respondents have
adopted different yardsticks in implementing the court orders
inasmuch as while implementing the consideration order in
SWP No. 415/1999, the petitioners therein have been allowed
the benefit of promotion but while implementing the judgment
of the Court in the case of the petitioner, a different stand has
been taken by the respondents. It has been contended that
the respondents cannot grant promotion to the persons, who
were engaged after the engagement of the petitioner on daily
rated basis, as such, the impugned order is liable to be set
aside.
07.
The respondents have contested the writ petition by
filing reply to the writ petition.
SWP No. 878/2006
In their reply, it has been
submitted that prior to the enforcement of SRO 64 of 1994, the
respondent-Corporation was appointing daily wagers against
the post of Field Assistant/Junior Assistant and Class-IV
employees but the inter se seniority of daily wagers was not a
criteria being followed at that point of time as no consolidated
seniority of the daily wagers was being maintained in the
Corporation.
It has been submitted that because a daily
wager’s service is not a service against any civil post so
seniority is not to be maintained.
08.
It has been further submitted that during the year
1993 the respondent-Corporation, keeping in view of the
availability of the posts, appointed some daily wagers as Field
Assistants/Junior Assistants and Class-IV employees. It has
also been submitted that respondent-Corporation had various
divisions throughout the State and the vacancies, prior to
coming into operation of SRO 64 of 1994, were distributed all
over the divisions whereafter eligible daily wagers working in
the divisions against such posts were adjusted.
It has been
submitted that senior most daily wagers in their respective
divisions thus got the benefit of the aforesaid policy of the
Corporation and their adjustment was made against the posts
of Field Assistant/Junior Assistant in the year 1993.
09.
It has been submitted that after coming into
operation of SRO 64 of 1994, the conditions laid down in the
said SRO were to be strictly adhered to.
Accordingly, the
services of the petitioner as Class-IV employee were regularized
SWP No. 878/2006
after completion of seven years as daily wager.
It has been
contended that no person junior to the petitioner has been
adjusted/promoted after the enforcement of SRO 64 of 1994.
It has been further submitted that in terms of SRO 64 of 1994,
there is no provision of regularizing the daily wagers on higher
posts on the basis of higher qualification other than Class –IV
posts and prior to enforcement of SRO 64 of 1994, there was
no prescribed method/consistent policy for regularization of
service of daily wagers in the respondent –Corporation. It has
been submitted that the petitioner is seeking seniority over
and above certain other employees who were promoted before
the enforcement of SRO 64 of 1994 in their respective divisions
and as such case of the petitioner is not similar to the case of
such employees.
10.
The respondents have submitted that case of the
petitioner for his promotion to the post of Field Assistant shall
be considered as per the seniority maintained by the
respondents. It has been further contended that the petitioner
has not challenged the regularization or engagement of
employees as Field Assistant appointed prior to 1994 and he is
estopped from doing so at this stage.
11.
During the pendency of the writ petition, the
petitioner filed a supplementary affidavit on 08.02.2011 in
which he has submitted that Sh. Ram Dayal, Sh. Hem Raj and
Smt. Radha Krishan were appointed on daily wage basis after
his appointment as Daily Wager and all these persons have
SWP No. 878/2006
been promoted as Field Assistants pursuant to order No. 42 of
1999 dated 13.08.1999 in terms of direction dated 18.07.1995
passed by this Court in SWP No. 415/1994.
It has been
submitted that in the said writ petition, Smt. Meera Devi,
Sh. Rajan Kotwal and Sh. Majid Rashid were impleaded as
private respondents and they have also been promoted as Field
Assistants.
Besides this, one Ms. Vijay Laxmi who was
engaged on 09.04.1999 in the Corporation has also been
promoted and placed in the pay scale of Rs. 3050-4820 vide
SFC Order No. 67 of 2002 dated 08.03.2002. The petitioner
further contends that Sh. Arjun Singh and Sh. Surinder Singh
who were engaged as Daily Wagers after him, have been
promoted as Field Assistants on 15.04.1994.
12.
The respondents in their reply to the supplementary
affidavit have submitted that Smt. Vijay Laxmi was engaged on
consolidated wages of Rs. 4000/- per month as Computer
Operator on the basis of her qualification as postgraduate
diploma in Systems Management.
Subsequently, keeping in
view her performance, she was adjusted in regular pay scale
vide SFC Order No. 67 of 2002 dated 08.03.2002. It has been
submitted that because Smt. Vijay Laxmi was appointed on
the basis of her computer skills which the petitioner does not
possess, as such, his claim is not maintainable.
13.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and
perused record of the case.
SWP No. 878/2006
14.
The main ground that has been urged by the
petitioner for assailing the impugned consideration order is
that some of the employees, who were engaged on daily rated
basis after his engagement on daily wage basis, have been
adjusted/promoted to the higher post of Field Assistant. So
far as date of engagement of the petitioenr on daily wage basis
is concerned, the same is not in dispute and even the date of
engagement of the persons as daily rated employees with the
respondent-Corporation in respect of whom the petitioner is
claiming parity is concerned, the same is also not in dispute.
Admittedly, all those persons to whom the petitioner has
referred in his supplementary affidavit as also in the writ
petition have been engaged on daily rated basis after the
engagement of the petitioner as Chowkidar on daily wage basis
in the year 1988.
15.
The stand taken by the respondent-Corporation is
that while the persons who have been adjusted/promoted
against the higher post of Field Assistant were engaged on
daily rated basis after the engagement of the petitioner yet
their services were regularized prior to the coming into
operation of SRO 64 of 1994 but the services of the petitioners
came to be regularized after coming into force of SRO 64 of
1994 vide SFC Order No. 59 of 1997 dated 10.06.1997 after
the petitioner had completed seven years of service as daily
rated employee.
Therefore, admittedly, the services of the
petitioner have been regularized well after the date the services
SWP No. 878/2006
of those persons with whom the petitioner is claiming parity
were regularized.
16.
As per method of recruitment/promotion to the post
of Field Assistant as contained in the Jammu and Kashmir
State Forest Corporation Employees (Condition of Services)
Regulations,
(hereinafter
to
be
referred
to
as
“Regulations of 1993”) is 80% by direct recruitment and 20%
by promotion from Class-M of administrative cadre employees
having
prescribed
standards.
minimum
qualifications
and
physical
The post of Chowkidar falls in Class-M of the
Schedule-II of the aforesaid regulations, therefore, for being
eligible to the promotion to the post of Field Assistant, an
employee has to hold the post of Chowkidar etc on substantive
basis, only then he can be promoted to the post of Field
Assistant.
17.
The stand of the respondents is that prior to 1994,
there were no service regulations in operation and daily rated
employees were being adjusted/promoted to the post of Field
Assistant/Junior Assistant subject to the availability of
vacancies in a particular division.
It appears that all the
persons with whom the petitioner is claiming parity excepting,
Smt. Vijay Laxmi, were either regularized as Class IV employee
or adjusted against the post of Field Assistant/Junior
Assistant prior to coming into force of Regulations of 1993.
None of them has been adjusted/promoted after the coming
into force of Regulations of 1993.
SWP No. 878/2006
18.
As per the directions of the writ court passed in
earlier writ petition filed by the petitioner and other persons,
the respondents were directed to consider the case of the
petitioner for their promotion as Junior Assistant and Field
Assistant
on
their
eligibility
and
taking
note
of
their
experience, qualification and by giving them same treatment as
has been given to respondents No. 4 to 14 to the said writ
petition.
The said order was made on the concession of
learned counsel for the respondents that the respondents
would consider the case under the rules and the Court did not
render any finding on merits of the claim of the petitioner. As
already stated as per the Regulations of 1993, the case of the
petitioner had to be considered along with other eligible
employees.
19.
In the consideration order, it has been clearly
indicated that there are at least 308 Chowkidars, who were
senior to the petitioner and who are also eligible for promotion
to the post of Field Assistant. In the face of the Regulations of
1993, the petitioner cannot claim promotion over and above
these 308 Chowkidars. Any action taken by the respondents
prior to coming into force of Regulations of 1993 would not
give a right to the petitioner to claim parity with those who
have
been
promoted/adjusted/regularized
prior
to
the
enforcement of the said Regulations which came into force on
06.01.1994 upon their publication in the Government Gazette.
SWP No. 878/2006
20.
So far as case of Smt. Vijay Laxmi is concerned, it
has been explained by the respondents in their affidavit that
she was having special skills and was holding post-graduate
diploma in Systems Management as a result whereof even
though she was appointed on consolidated basis after the
regularization of the petitioner, she was granted regular pay
scale in terms of the SFC Order No. 67 of 2002 dated
08.03.2002 keeping in view the specialized qualification
needed for the post of Computer Operator. The petitioner
admittedly does not hold any qualification in operating
computers, as such, he cannot claim parity with her.
21.
Apart from the above despite the petitioner having
been appointed on daily wage basis prior to the persons with
whom he is claiming parity, he cannot be given preference in
matter of grant of promotion to higher post because his
services have been regularized with effect from the year 1996
whereas, those with whom he is claiming parity were
regularized/adjusted prior to the year 1994. The crucial date
for determining inter se seniority between the petitioner and
those with whom he is claiming parity is not the date of their
initial engagement as daily wagers but it is the date on which
their services were regularized.
On this count also, the
petitioner cannot claim promotion to higher post from the date
when those who were regularized ahead of him, were
promoted, particularly when the petitioner has not challenged
their regularization or adjustment.
SWP No. 878/2006
22.
For what has been stated hereinbefore, I do not find
any merit in this petition.
The same is, accordingly,
dismissed.
(SANJAY DHAR)
JUDGE
JAMMU
20.02.2026
Naresh/Secy.
Whether the judgment is speaking: Yes
Whether the judgment is reportable: No
Naresh Kumar
2026.02.05 05:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
SWP No. 878/2006
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review