Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No.34502 of 2025
(In the matter of an application under Articles 226
and 227 of the Constitution of India)
Maa Tarini SHG represented ….
by its Secretary Mamina
Pani and another
-versusState of Odisha, represented ….
by
its
Secretary-cumCommissioner, Housing and
Urban
Development
Department,
Bhubaneswar
and others
Petitioners
Opposite Parties
Appeared in this case:For Petitioners
:
Mr. D.K. Ray, Advocate
For Opposite Parties
:
Mr. G. Mohanty,
Learned Standing Counsel
(For O.P. Nos.1 and 2)
Mr. M. Mohanty, Sr. Advocate
assisted by Mr. D. Nayak,
Advocate
(For Opposite Party Nos.3 and
4)
Ms. S. Mohanty, Advocate
(For Opposite Party No.6)
CORAM:
JUSTICE A.C. BEHERA
JUDGMENT
Date of hearing : 23.02.2026 / date of judgment : 26.02.2026
A.C. Behera, J. This writ petition under Articles 226 and 227 of the
Constitution of India, 1950 has been filed by the petitioner
Women Self Help Group(WSHG) being a Mission Shakti
Group(MSG) along with another against the Opposite
Parties praying for quashing(setting aside) the assignment
of Operation and Management of Aahar Kendra at Jagatpur
to the Opposite Party No.6 WSHG and to issue the
Expression of Interest(EOI) in favour of the petitioner WSHG
for the Operation and Management of the said Aahar
Kendra at Jagatpur.
2.
The factual backgrounds of this writ petition, which
prompted the petitioner WSHG for filing of the same is that,
the Assistant Commissioner-cum-SIO, Cuttack Municipal
Corporation(Opposite
Party
No.4)
published
an
advertisement-cum-EoI on dated 14.10.2025(Annexure-4)
inviting applications of the WSHGs for the selection of one
SHG among them to operate and manage Aahar Kendra at
Jagatpur for the financial year 2025-2026 stating in the
Expression
of
Interest
interested
applicant
No.1465(Annexure-4)
WSHG
should
that,
submit
the
their
applications either through online or through off line on or
before 24.10.2025 by 5.00 P.M.
3.
In pursuance to such an advertisement and EOI dated
14.10.2025 (Annexure-4), the petitioner WSHG submitted
its application.
In that EOI vide Annexure-4, it was reflected that,
bids/applications of the applicants(WSHGs) shall be opened
on 28.10.2025 in Mini Conference Hall at Biju Bhawan,
Cuttack, but, due to some inconvenience, as per Letter
No.1569 dated 28.10.2025 vide Annexure-6, the opening of
the bids/applications on dated 28.10.2025 was postponed
and the date of opening of the bids/applications was fixed
to 01.11.2025.
Accordingly, on the aforesaid scheduled date and time
as
per
Annexure-6,
the
bids/applications
of
the
applicants(SHGs) were opened on 01.11.2025 at 11.00 A.M.
in Mini Conference Hall at Biju Bhawan, Cuttack in
presence of the petitioner WSHG along with other applicant
WSHGs and on the basis of the criterias indicated in EOI
dated 14.10.2025 vide Annexure-4, the petitioner WSHG
secured 95 marks out of 100 marks, but, the Opposite
Party No.6 WSHG secured 90 marks out of 100.
4.
Even though, the Opposite Party No.6 WSHG had
secured less marks, i.e., 90 marks than the petitioner
WSHG and the petitioner WSHG had secured 95 marks and
even though, the petitioner WSHG had the previous four
years experience in running the Aahar Kendra at Jagatpur,
still then, the Selection Committee Members illegally
selected to the Opposite Party No.6 WSHG on dated
28.11.2025 for the operation and management of Aahar
Kendra at Jagatpur for the year 2025-2026 moving beyond
the guidelines, parameters and criterias fixed for the
selection violating the principles of natural justice as well as
Article-14(1)(c) of the Constitution of India, 1950 debarring
the petitioner WSHG illegally from its selection as the
operator of Aahar Kendra at Jagatpur for the year 20252026.
For which, without getting any way, the petitioner
WSHG approached this Court by filing this writ petition
against the Opposite parties under Articles 226 and 227 of
the Constitution of India, 1950 praying for the cancellation
of the assignment to the Opposite Party No.6 WSHG in
respect of the operation and management of the Aahar
Kendra at Jagatpur and to issue the Expression of
Interest(EOI) in favour of the petitioner WSHG for the
operation and management of that Aahar Kendra.
5.
The Opposite Party Nos.3, 4 and 5 filed their counter
denying the allegations alleged by the petitioner WSHG
taking their stands that, as per the advertisement dated
14.10.2025, the petitioner WSHG and the Opposite Party
No.6 WSHG along with other WSHGs had made their
applications for their selection to operate and manage the
Aahar
Kendra
at
Jagatpur
knowing/accepting
the
conditions in the EOI vide Annexure-4 that, for entering
into the selection process, the qualifying mark is 60 out of
100. Accordingly, in the qualifying test, as per the criterias
indicated in Annexure-4, the petitioner WSHG had secured
95 marks and the Opposite Party No.6 WSHG had secured
90 marks. As the petitioner WSHG as well as Opposite Party
No.6 WSHG along with some others had secured more than
60 marks in the qualifying test, for which, they were taken
into the zone of selection process for consideration.
Nowhere in the advertisement dated 14.10.2025 vide
Anenxure-4, it was reflected that, the selection will be
made, only on the basis of the marks secured in the
qualifying test or which WSHG will secure highest marks in
qualifying test, that WSHG will be selected as the operator
of the Aahar Kendra. For which, securing of highest marks
in the qualifying test was not the only criteria for selection.
The Selection Committee Members selected Opposite Party
No.6 SHG as per Annexure-I/3 for the operation and
management of Aahar Kendra assigning he reasons that,
“as inferred from table above, among same word SHGs
and new SHGs, the Opposite Party No.6 SHG has secured
the highest marks, hence the Opposite Party No.6 is selected
for operation and management(O&M) of Jagatpur Aahar
Kendra.”
It
was
specifically
reflected/indicated
in
the
EOI(Annexure-4) that, the Cuttack Municipal Corporation
in its sole discretion and for any reason whatsoever decides
to terminate the contract for the operation and management
of Aahar Kendras under its Municipal areas.
The intended applicants including the petitioner
WSHG had submitted undertakings in this regard and
knowing the criterias indicated/reflected in the EOI vide
Annexure-4, all the applicants WSHGs including the
petitioner WSHG had participated in the selection process
and after being unsuccessful in the said selection, the
petitioner WSHG has challenged to the process of selection
by filing this writ petition. For which, the petitioner WSHG
is estopped under law to challenge such process of
selection. Therefore, the writ petition filed by the petitioner
WSHG is liable to be dismissed.
6.
I have already heard from the learned counsel for the
petitioner WSHG, learned counsel for the Opposite Party
No.6, learned Standing Counsel for the State and the
learned senior counsel for the Opposite Party Nos.3 and 4.
7.
Learned counsel for the Opposite Party Nos.3 and 4
relied upon the following decision:(i)
In a case between M.P. Public Service Commission,
vrs. Navnit Kumar Potdar and another : reported in 1994
Supreme(SC)-923.
8.
It is the undisputed case of the parties that, the
Selection Committee Members have selected to the Opposite
Party No.6 WSHG for the operation and management of
Aahar Kendra at Jagatpur assigning the specific reasons in
Annexure-I/3 that,
“Among same word SHGs and new SHGs, the Opposite
Party No.6 has secured the highest marks, hence the
Opposite Party No.6 WSHG is selected for O&M of Jagatpur
Aahar Kendra.”
9.
When, as per the EOI(Annexure-4), securing of 60
marks was the qualifying mark for entering into the
selection process and when, the prime object for selecting a
WSHG to operate and manage an Aahar Kendra like
Jagatpur Aahar Kendra is for the up-liftment of the downtrodden lady members of the said WSHG in order to make
them financially independent, socially strengthen and
when, the members of the selection committee have selected
to Opposite Party No.6 WSHG for the operation and
management of Aahar Kendra at Jagatpur as per AnnexureI/3 assigning the specific reasons that, among the new
SHGs of same ward, the Opposite Party No.6 SHG has
secured the highest marks and when, as per the resolution
dated 06.09.2025 vide Annexure-H/3 of the Cuttack
Municipal Corporation(CMC), it was resolved unanimously
that, instead of old SHGs, the new SHGs will be selected for
the operation and management of the Aahar Kendra and
when, after knowing/accepting the criterias indicated
in
the Annexure-4, the petitioner WSHG had participated in
the selection process and when, after selection of the
Opposite
Party
No.6
WSHG
for
the
operation
and
management of Jagatpur Aahar Kendra, a memorandum of
understanding vide Ext.J/3 has already been executed on
dated 01.12.2025 in favour of the Opposite Party No.6 to
manage and operate the Aahar Kendra at Jagatpur and
when, after being unsuccessful in the selection process, the
petitioner WSHG has challenged the process of selection,
then at this juncture, the petitioner WSHG is estopped
under law to challenge the process of selection through this
writ petition.
On this aspect, the propositions of law has already
been clarified in the ratio of the following decisions:(i)
In a case between D. Saroja Kumari vrs. R.
Helen Thilakom : reported in 2017(3) Apex Court
Judgments-458(S.C.)
participating in selection process and after being
unsuccessful, the said unsuccessful candidate is
estopped from challenging the process of selection.
(ii)
In a case between Dhanjay Malik and others
vrs. State of Uttranchal and others : reported in
2008(2) Apex Court Judgments-196(S.C.)
once a candidate appears at the interview, he cannot
subsequently contend that, the process of interview was
unfair.
10. When, as per the discussions and observations made
above, it has already been held that, the petitioner WSGH is
estopped under law, to challenge the process of selection,
then at this juncture, the question of interfering with the
said process of selection and to disengage the Opposite
Party No.6 SHG from the operation and management of
Aahar Kendra at Jagatpur does not arise.
11. Therefore, there is no merit in this writ petition filed by
the petitioners. The same must fail.
12. In result, this writ petition filed by the petitioners is
dismissed on contest.
13. As such, this writ petition filed by the petitioners is
disposed of finally.
( A.C. Behera )
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack
26 of January, 2026/ Jagabandhu, P.A.
Signature NotTheVerified
th
Digitally Signed
Signed by: JAGABANDHU BEHERA
Designation: Personal Assistant
Reason: Authentication
Location: OHC, CUTTACK
Date: 27-Feb-2026 13:40:27
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review