The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. Accordingly, the Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is allowed and the Judgment dated 06.11.2017 passed by the Railway Claims Tribunal, Amaravathi Bench, Guntur, in Case No.OA/II(u) 307 of 2011 is hereby set aside. The Respondent Railway shall pay the compensation amount of Rs.8,00,000/(Rupees eight lakhs only) to the appellants/claimants within a period of three (03) months from the date of receipt of copy of this Judgment, with interest at 6% p.a from the date of presentation of this Appeal. Out of the said compensation, the appellants/applicants 1 and 2 are entitled to half (1/2) share each.
16. Accordingly, Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is allowed. No costs. Dated 05.02.2026. CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 2/2023 DATED 05.02.2026
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010720432022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3333]
THURSDAY, THE FIFTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 2/2023
Between:
1.
M SAI PRASAD DIED, ( DIED ON 04-05-2022 )
2.
M. NALINI,, W/O. M. SAI PRASAD AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS YEARS,
OCC HOUSEWIFE R/O. D.NO.21-11-13/C NEAR GADDE BABURAO
STREET MADHURA NAGAR VIJAYAWADA-12
...APPELLANT(S)
AND
1.
UNION OF INDIA, rep. By its General Manager, South Central
Railway, Secunderbad
...RESPONDENT
Counsel for the Appellant(S):
1. GEETHA MADHURI N S
Counsel for the Respondent:
PASALA PONNA RAO (SC FOR CENT GOVT.)
JOSYULA BHASKARA RAO (SENIOR PANEL COUNSEL FOR CENTRAL
GOVT.)
The Court made the following:
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 2/2023
J U D G M E N T:
1.
The present Civil Miscellaneous Appeal (for short (CMA) has been
preferred by the Applicants/Claimants aggrieved by the Judgment in Case
No.OA/II(u) 307 of 2011 passed by the Railway Claims Tribunal, Amaravathi
bench, Guntur, wherein the Tribunal dismissed the claim of the Claimants.
For the sake of convenience, the parties herein after are arrayed as they
arrayed before the Tribunal i.e., Appellants as Claimants and Respondent as
Respondent
2.
Claimants being the parents of their unmarried son – Late M.Venkat
Sai Kiran (hereinafter called as the deceased), have filed a claim petition under
Section 16 of the Railway Claims Tribunal Act, 1987 against the Respondent –
Railway Administration, seeking compensation for his death, as a result of
untoward incident that occurred on 14.09.2011.
3.
The facts in nutshell are that – in the afternoon hours of 14.11.2011
the deceased went to Guntur Railway Station, purchased a passenger train
journey ticket bearing No.40256773 from Guntur to Dhone and boarded the train
No.57328 Guntur – Dhone passenger in a general compartment.
When
travelling, suddenly slipped and fell down accidentally from the said running train
at KM No.252/506 in between Nandyal and Panyam Railway Stations due to
speed and sudden jerks of the train, as a result of which, he sustained severe
injuries and died on the spot.
4.
Respondent – Railway administration filed the Written Statement
denying all the allegations made in the claim petition and contended that the
case was a case of suicidal death and not accidental fall from the train and as
such, the claim does not fall within the ambit of Section 123(c) read with Section
124A of the Railways Act, 1989 and hence, the claim application deserves to be
dismissed, with costs.
5.
On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, the Tribunal framed the
following issues –
1) Whether the Applicant(s) is/are dependant(s) of the deceased?
2) Whether the deceased was a bona-fide passenger of the train in question
and died as a result of an untoward incident?
3) Whether the applicant(s) is/are entitled to the compensation as claimed
and to what relief?
6.
During the course of enquiry, the 1st applicant got examined himself
as A.W.1 and also got marked Ex.A.1 – attested copy of FIR, Ex.A.2 – attested
copy of inquest report, Ex.A.3 – attested copy of postmortem examination report,
Ex.A.4 – original death certificate, Ex.A.5 – photocopy of ration card.
On behalf of Respondent, none was examined, but got marked Ex.R.1 –
Statutory Investigation report of DRM, Guntur.
7.
On considering the entire material on record, the Tribunal dismissed
the claim petition by coming to the conclusion that the deceased had committed
suicide. Therefore, the applicants are not entitled for any compensation. In view
of the finding on issue No.2, the Tribunal has concluded that there is no need to
deal with issues No.1 and 3.
8.
Heard both sides and perused the record.
9.
It is argued by the learned Counsel for the Appellants that the
Tribunal ought to have seen that the dead body of the deceased was reported to
the Railway Officials 12 hours after the incident on 15.09.2011. The Tribunal has
erroneously held that the deceased committed suicide, based on the statement
of Gateman which was annexed with the DRM’s report. It is also argued by the
learned Counsel for the Appellant that the Tribunal has grossly erred in holding
that the deceased committed suicide on the ground that the body of the
deceased was cut into two pieces. As per the Inquest Report – Ex.A.2, the
journey ticket was recovered from the dead body, issued on 14.09.2011 at 12.26
hours from ticketing Counter of Guntur. On a perusal of Ex.A.1, Ex.A.2 and as
well as Ex.R.1, it can be noticed that the Railway Police registered a case in
Crime No.59 of 2011 under Section 174 of Criminal Procedure Code (suspicious
death) on receiving message from the Railway Guard on 15.09.2011 at 8.10
hours. The F.I.R., discloses that on 15.09.2011 prior to 8.10 hours Key-man
found a male dead body, aged about 24 years at KM No.252/506 between
Nandhyal – Panyam Railway Stations. Even as per Ex.A.2 – inquest report it can
be observed - “that on 14.09.2011 the deceased in order to go to Dhone went to
ticketing Counter, Guntur and purchased a journey ticket, the same was
confirmed in the inquest report which discloses that there is a train journey ticket
from Guntur to Done vide ticket No.40256773 dated 14.09.2011 purchased at
12.l26 hours in Guntur ticketing center, ticket value Rs.44/-“. The statement of
A.W.1 was supported by inquest report with regard to availability of ticket.
10.
It can also be noticed that Ex.R.1 – DRM’s report was filed on
21.06.2012 after a span of nine (09) months from the date of incident. As per
Rule 6(iv) of Railway passenger (Manager of Investigation of Untoward Incidents
Rules) 2020 the Divisional Security Commissioner shall submit a report within 60
days from the date of untoward incident, for onward submission to the Divisional
Railway Station. However, for the reasons best known to them, in the present
case, they have submitted the DMR’s report after 60 days.
11.
Admittedly, there is no eye witness to the incident to support D.R.M’s
report that the deceased committed suicide. The statement given by one Sri
K.V.Sinivasa Rao, working as Head-Constable of R.P.F Post, Nandhyala which
is annexed to the DRM’s report also discloses that he has noticed one male dead
body lying at KM No.252/506, Nandhyal – Panyam Railway Stations and it was
found that the head of deceased was in the middle of the Track, whereas the
remaining body lying on the side of the track and on checking by Head
Constable, one journey ticket was also found in the possession of the deceased.
The report of untoward incident submitted by the Railway authorities also
disclose that Sri N.Chinna Venkateswarlu, on-duty Key-man informed that he
noticed one person, aged about 24 years, fell down under the train and died. It
can also be observed that there is no eyewitness to the incident to support the
report of the DRM that the deceased committed suicide. If at all the statement of
above persons are believed, there is no explanation as to why the Railway Police
filed F.I.R under Section 174 of Cr.P.C for the reasons best known to the
Railways. None of its officials, including the author of Ex.R.1 – report i.e., the
Divisional Railway Manager was examined before the Tribunal.
By placing
reliance on the report of the Divisional Railway Manager, the Tribunal has come
to an erroneous conclusion that the deceased has committed suicide and denied
the compensation to the applicants.
12.
In this connection, it is relevant to refer the Judgments of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Kalandi Charan Sahoo & another v. General Manager,
South-East Central Railway, 2018 ACJ 1460, Para 3 of the said Judgment
reads as under:
“3. Though role 7 of the Railway Passengers (Manner of Investigation of
untoward Incidents) Rules, 2003 (hereinafter referred to as "Rules)
mandates the railway authorities to investigate into such an untoward
Incident, admittedly, no such inquiry was conducted immediately after the
incident. It is only when the appellants filed the claim before the RCT on
27.2.2005 that investigation into the incident was ordered on 23.4.2009,
According to the Railways, the said investigation revealed that the
deceased detrained from the moving train of D Cabin without stoppage of
the rain and invited the accident. The claim was rejected on the aforesaid
basis and the aforesaid plea of the Railway was accepted by the RCT
resulting into the dismissal of the claim of the appellants. The appellants
filed the appeal, i.e., FAO No.535 of 2013 challenging the aforesaid order
of the RCT. The High Court has dismissed the same by cryptic and nonspeaking order with the only observations that findings of the Tribunal in
the impugned award and the reasons assigned in support of the same do
not warrant any interference."
A further reference can be made to the judgment of Kerala High Court in the case of
Union of India v. A. Geetha & others, 2018 ACJ 941 Paras 12 and 13 of the said
judgment read as under:
"12. The pleadings of the applicants in the original application disclose that
Smt. Sandhya was travelling alone in the train. Her bag containing
material things including the ticket taken by her for travelling purpose was
lost. Her body was found lying in the railway track. It is pertinent to note
that even though disclosure of the facts is made in the original application,
the respondent has not ventured to controvert those. The respondent has
also no case that any enquiry in the matter was conducted by them and
the contrary was revealed to them. The only objection raised was
regarding the non-pulling of the chain by co-passengers and nonproduction of the ticket by the claimants. The lady being a passenger not
in accompaniment with any of the original applicants, it is difficult for the
latter to state specifically about the incident. The attending circumstances
being so, the authorities of the Railway, being in reachable space to the
place of incident, are the appropriate person to conduct an enquiry and to
get convinced themselves about the untoward Incident rather than the
original applicants, who were in a remote place at the relevant time. The
authorities of the railway cannot take advantage of their inaction to
conduct an enquiry and the incapacity of the original applicants to place
on record evidence supporting their claim. In the case on hand, the
attending circumstances drawn out from the pleadings of the original
applicants are leaning in favour of the original applicants rather than those
advanced by the respondent.
14. The dictum in the decision supra rendered by a Division Bench of this
Court, of which one among us, was a constituent member, is also relevant
in the context and is extracted herein below:"B. We have considered all the relevant inputs. To us it appears that Chap
13 of the Railways Act reflects the vibrant compassion of the legislature in
favour of the victims of untoward Incidents that take place during the
operation of the Railways Even though there is no specific liability known
to law on established led principles obliging the railways to compensate
the victim of such untoward incidents, Law declares that Railways shall
compensate the victims. More than enforcement of a legal right, the
statutory provision recognizes compassion and concern which the Railway
administration must show to the unfortunate victims of the untoward
incidents. An anxious perusal of the relevant statutory provisions and the
rules must convince that the framers of the statute and the rules did not
reckon the proceedings as an adversarial litigative process at all. If there
be any semblance of doubt on this aspect it will be appropriate to frequent
oneself with the stipulations of the Railway Passengers (Manner of
Investigation of Untoward Incidents) Rules, 2003 (as amended in 2007),
R.7 to 10 clearly show that the burden is on the local police and the
officers of the force to conduct an enquiry/investigation Into the cause of
the incident and come to appropriate conclusion. To us it appears that the
provisions clearly reveal due recognition and acceptance of the
helplessness of the claimants who may be far far away from the
scene/venue of the incident and consequentially incapable of adducing
very compelling evidence in support of their claim. The realistic
acceptance of the plight of the victims is perfectly clear from the
mechanism stipulated for enquiry/investigation under the Railway
Passengers (Manner of Investigation of Untoward Incidents) Rules, 2003.
The burden really is not placed entirely on the shoulders of the victims or
claimants. But, the burden is placed on the shoulders of the Railway and
its officials to conduct a proper enquiry to ascertain whether claimants are
really entitled to amounts or not."
13.
In support of contention of learned Counsel for Appellants, also
relied upon a Judgment of the Hon’ble High Court of Calcutta in Suchitra as
(ash) vs Union of India dt.11.04.2019 wherein it was held as hereunder –
“There may be a number of hypothetical theories as to how the deceased
suffered death, but the theory which is in consequence with the evidence
on record has to be accepted. Court is not concerned with the academic
exercise and theoretical possibilities, but with practical relation derived
from evidence adduced in a particular case during trial.
When a person falls down from a speeding train, he sustained multiple
injuries in consequence of repetitive impacts and rolling depending upon
the surface on which the body falls together with the relative velocity of
falling body and that aspects not having been adequately taken care of by
the learned Tribunal Judge, it cannot be concluded with all certainty that
the finding reached by the Tribunal making out the case of run over upon
considering the recovery of the body of the deceased from inside the
railway track was the one and only probability, reasonably drawable from
a given set of facts and thereby leaving aside the other probabilities to go
away at the same time”.
In view of the above observations made by the Court and the Judgments referred
above, this Court is of the opinion that the Claimants are entitled for payment of
compensation.
14.
As per the schedule given by the Ministry of Railways vide
notification dated 02.12.2016, the Railways are liable to pay compensation of
Rs.8,00,000/- (Rupees eight lakhs) for the death arising in railway accident.
Therefore, the applicants are entitled to compensation of Rs.8,00,000/- for the
death of their son – Sri M.Venkat Sai Kiran.
15.
Accordingly, the Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is allowed and the
Judgment dated 06.11.2017 passed by the Railway Claims Tribunal, Amaravathi
Bench, Guntur, in Case No.OA/II(u) 307 of 2011 is hereby set aside. The
Respondent Railway shall pay the compensation amount of Rs.8,00,000/(Rupees eight lakhs only) to the appellants/claimants within a period of three (03)
months from the date of receipt of copy of this Judgment, with interest at 6% p.a
from the date of presentation of this Appeal. Out of the said compensation, the
appellants/applicants 1 and 2 are entitled to half (1/2) share each.
16.
Accordingly, Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is allowed. No costs.
_______________________
SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
KS
Dated 05.02.2026.
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 2/2023
DATED 05.02.2026
KS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review