Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/19
GAHC010226392025
2026:GAU-AS:12168
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/6517/2025
M/S VISHNU ENGINEERING CORPORATION
PREMISES NO. 19
BIPLABI ANUKUL CHANDRA STREET
KOLKATA - 700072
REPRESENTED BY ITS AUTHORISED REPRESENTATIVE SRI DEV GUPTA
AGED ABOUT 20 YEARS
SON OF SRI VISHAL KUMAR GUPTA
RESIDING AT 19
BIPLABI ANUKUL CHANDRA STREET
KOLKATA - 700072
WEST BENGAL.
VERSUS
THE ASSAM INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LIMITED AND
ANR
AIDC LTD.
HAVING OFFICE AT R. G. BARUAH ROAD GUWAHATI 781024 REPRESENTED
BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR.
2:MSTC LIMITED
A GOVERNMENT OF INDIA ENTERPRISE
HAVING ITS BRANCH OFFICE AT BSNL EXCHANGE BUILDING
BELTOLA - BAISISTHA ROAD
WIRELESS
RANI BAGAN
GUWAHATI - 781028 REPRESENTED BY ITS BRANCH MANAGER.
-----------Advocate for the Petitioner
: Mr. R. Karnani, Adv.
Advocate for the respondents
: Mr. D. Saikia, Advocate General,
Mr. D. Deka, Standing Counsel, AIDC.
Mr. P. S. Bhattacharya, CGC.
Page No.# 2/19
Date on which judgment was reserved : 02.06.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 25.08.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the : NA
operative part of the judgment?
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
:Yes
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANJAN MONI KALITA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. R. Karnani, learned counsel for the Petitioner. Also
heard Mr. D. Saikia, learned Advocate General assisted by Mr. D. Deka,
learned Standing Counsel, AIDC/ Respondent No. 1 as well as Mr. P. S.
Bhattacharya, learned CGC for Respondent No. 2.
2.
By filing the instant writ petition, the Petitioner is seeking to
invoke the jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India,
challenging the tender process corresponding to Auction No.
MSTC/GHY/Assam
Industrial
Development
Corporation
Limited/5/Guwahati/25-26/25321 dated 07.08.2025.
3.
The summary of the facts leading to filing of the instant writ
petition are provided hereinbelow:
3.1. The Petitioner is a partnership firm under the name and
style of M/s. Vishnu Engineering Corporation, having its place of
business in Kolkata, West Bengal. The Petitioner has been in the
Page No.# 3/19
business of dismantling large ocean-going vessels, cargo and
tanker ships within docks of Kolkata Port Trust and its business
revolves around purchase and sale of scrap materials auctioned
by the government undertakings, public sector enterprises and
other statutory bodies.
3.2. The Petitioner’s case is that the Petitioner was completely
unaware of any tender or auction floated by the Respondents
on 07.08.2025 concerning the demolition and disposal of the
plant and machinery and other structures of the defunct Cachar
Paper Mill in Panchgram in the State of Assam.
3.3. It is contended that during its interactions with certain
other bidders, the Petitioner came to learn about the issuance
of a detailed Auction Catalogue dated 07.08.2025 for the
demolition and disposal works involving Cachar Paper Mill. After
getting the information, the Petitioner obtained a copy of the
catalogue.The Petitioner came to learn that the e-auction had
already been conducted on 13.10.2025, but the sale has not yet
been finalized or awarded due to interim orders passed by this
Court in connected writ petition, namely, WP(C) 5975/2025
(SPS Steels Rolling Mills Limited). It is contended by the
Petitioner that having learnt that such a highvalue auction had
escaped its notice, upon investigation about the mode of
publication, it learnt that the aforesaid Auction Catalogue was
published only on MSTC e-auction portal and nowhere else. It is
contended that the Auction Catalogue was neither published on
Page No.# 4/19
any government portal nor it was published on State Public
Procurement Portal (SPPP).It is contended that the Petitioner
was taken by surprise due to the fact that the Auction
Catalogue was not published in any national newspapers. It is,
therefore, contended by the Petitioner that due to such nonpublication and/or very limited publicity, the Petitioner has been
deprived of an opportunity to participate in the aforesaid
Auction. It is contended that MSTC website is accessible only to
a limited circle of registered users and therefore, there was no
sufficient publicity about the tender process.
3.4. Faced with the aforesaid situation and being deprived of
its inability to participate in the aforesaid auction, the Petitioner
submitted a detailed written representation on 30.10.2025 to
the Respondent Authorities calling upon them to explain the
inadequate publicity, stringent pre-qualification criteria and
apparent
exclusion
of
competition.
In
the
aforesaid
Representation, the Petitioner clearly stated its readiness and
willingness to participate even at that stage and indicated a
standing bid of Rs.120 Crores for the tendered assets, which
are yet to be finally awarded in the said auction. It is contended
that no reply to the aforesaid Representation was received by
the Petitioner. The Petitioner contended that the Notice Inviting
Tender was neither uploaded on the State Public Procurement
Portal (SPPP), nor was any abridged notice published in
newspapers as required under the Assam Public Procurement
Rules, 2020, which mandated such publication to ensure wide
Page No.# 5/19
participation.
Therefore,
it
is
contended
that
confining
publication solely to the MSTC portal, the Respondents
breached statutory obligations and deprived the public of equal
opportunity to compete.The Petitioner also contended that the
Pre-Qualification Criteria (PQC) demanded an average annual
turnover of Rs.30 Crores and completion of one single work of
Rs.100 Crores within 10 years. It is contended that such
thresholds have no rational nexus to the nature of work being
simple demolition and clearance. It is contended that the said
criteria have been solely designed to exclude competent
medium-scale competitors, thus eliminating competition and
favouring selected few. The Petitioner also contended that PreQualification Criteria stipulated the possession of OHSAS 18001
certificate, which, in fact, had become obsolete in 2021 and the
same has been replaced globally by ISO 45001:2018 certificate.
Therefore, such an obsolete condition shows the nonapplication of mind on the part of the Respondent Authorities
and the same is tailor-made to suit arbitrary interest of the
Respondents.
3.5. In view of the aforesaid grievances, mainly due to the fact
of its inability to take part in the auction process as there was
no sufficient publication of the tender or auction floated by the
Respondents, the Petitioner has approached this Court by filing
the instant writ petition.
4.
An Additional Affidavit has been filed by the Petitioner with due
Page No.# 6/19
permission from this Court, whereby the Petitioner has brought
certain certificates and documents showing its credentials and
experience in similar kind of works.
5.
An Affidavit-in-Opposition has been filed by the Respondent No.
1, wherein, the Respondent No. 1 has denied that there was no
sufficient publication of the concerned auction and therefore, the
Petitioner was deprived of its participation in the auction process. It is
the stand of the Respondent No. 1 that Respondent No. 2, i.e. the
MSTC Limitedis a Government of India Enterprise under the Ministry
of Steel, having its e-auction portal, which provides maximum
publicity of any bid issuedby governments. The Respondent No. 1
stated that the NIT dated 07.08.2025 regarding the auction was
published in the portal of Respondent No.2. It is stated that the NIT
got wide publicity and viewership which can be seen from the fact
that altogether 20 (Twenty) bidders from all over the country, have
participated in the tender process. It is stated that the Petitioner
being a business organization handling similar worksshould have been
vigilant enough to not have missed the instant NIT for the auction.
6.
It is also the stand of the Respondent No. 1 that after a Cabinet
decision, it was decided that the NIT should be published in the
Respondent No. 2’s e-portal who has wide publicity. It was decided
due to the fact that MSTC Limited is a Government of India
Undertaking having wide publicity and viewership. It is also
contended that the Assam Public Procurement Rules, 2020 is not
applicable in the instant case, as the Government has already decided
Page No.# 7/19
to put the NIT in the e-portal of MSTC portal, which has larger
publicity and viewership and also due to the fact that the portal
belongs to the Ministry of Steel which is a Central Government
functionary. Therefore, there is no wrong committed by Respondent
No. 1 by putting the NIT of the auction in the aforesaid e-portal.It is
stated that the Cabinet decision of the Government regarding
publishing of the NIT of the auction in the MSTC portal is purely due
to the intention to increase its reach and include wider participation
from all parts of the country.
7.
The Respondent No. 1 contended that tender conditions were
just and reasonable and have been formulated on the basis of
required expertise, safety and experience in handling such disposal. It
is stated that the Respondent No. 1, being the issuer of the contract,
had all the rights to put the conditions as it deems fit to meet the
requirements to get the contract work done taking into account
various factors, including public policy.Therefore, it is denied by
Respondent No. 1 that the pre-qualifications included in the tender
for the auction do not have any rational nexus to the scope of work
mentioned in the Auction Document.
8.
The Petitioner has filed an Affidavit-in-Reply to the Affidavit-in-
Opposition filed by the Respondent No. 1, wherein, the Petitioner has,
mostly, reiterated its statements made in the writ petition. The
Petitioner reiterated that by non-publication of the NIT in the State
portal, i.e. SPPP and in other national newspapers, has curtailed
competition in the instant case and bidders like the Petitioner, who
Page No.# 8/19
could have easily participated in the auction, have been deprived of
such participation.It further reiterated that the pre-qualification
criteria set out in the Auction Document do not have any rational
nexus to the objects sought to be achieved and the same have been
included only to favour certain favoured bidders by the Respondent
No. 1.
9.
The learned counsel appearing for the Petitioner submits that the
Petitioner is a firm which is into the business of dismantling and
purchasing of scrap goods in a large scale and having an experience
of 50 years in such business. He submits that only due to the very
limited publication of the NIT, which was published only in the eportal of MSTC Limited, the Petitioner has been deprived of the
participation in the auction process.He submits that by such action of
the Respondent No. 1, the competition in the bid has been curtailed,
which should not have been the purpose and object of a State
authority like the Respondent No. 1. He submits that by not
publishing in national newspapers and the State Public Procurement
Portal in terms of the Assam Public Procurement Rules, 2020, the
Respondent No. 1 has violated the terms of the aforesaid Assam
Public Procurement Rules, 2020.He submits that since the finalization
of the contract is yet to happen and the Petitioner is willing to submit
a bid of Rs.120 crores for the scope of work mentioned in the Auction
Document, the Petitioner should be allowed to participate in the
auction process.
10. On the other hand, Mr. D. Saikia, the learned Advocate General
Page No.# 9/19
representing the Respondent No. 1 submits that the instant writ
petition is totally misconceived and should be summarily dismissed.
He submits that there was wide circulation of the NIT due to its
publication in the e-portal of MSTC Limited (Respondent No. 2), which
fact can be ascertained by the participation of as many as 20
(Twenty) bidders from all over the country.Therefore, the contention
of the Petitioner that there was no wide publicity of the NIT for the
auction is totally invalid andfalse.He further submits that the auction
process has already come to a conclusion and only the work has to be
awarded to the highest bidder and the Petitioner has approached the
Court more than a month after the conclusion of the auction process,
the instant writ petition is liable to be dismissed. He submits that the
tendering authority, i.e. the Respondent No. 1 is at liberty to put its
own terms and conditions to meet the requirements of the scope of
work and the same cannot be challenged by a person who has not
participated in the bid itself. Therefore, he submits that the instant
writ petition does not have any merit for consideration and the same
should be dismissed at once.
11. It is seen that the Petitioner is not a participant in the bid and it
has approached this Court more than a month after the conclusion of
the auction process.
12. Though it has been contended by the Petitioner that due to non
publication of the NIT of the auction in national newspapers and the
State Public Procurement Portal, there is limited publicity of the NIT
and therefore, the Petitioner missed the NIT and has been deprived
Page No.# 10/19
of his right to participate in the tender process, the Petitioner has also
contended that it is willingto participate even at this stage and
indicated a standing bid of Rs.120 crores for the tendered assets,
which are yet to be finally awarded in the auction.
13. It is also seen that the Petitioner has challenged the thresholds,
i.e.the pre-qualification criteria set for the auction. It is seen that the
Petitioner has contended that there is no rational nexus of fixing such
thresholds simply because the work relates to demolition and
clearance.The Petitioner has also contended that the pre-qualification
of possessing OHSAS 18001 certification is also not required as it has
already become obsolete and the same has been replaced by ISO
45001:2018. From the above, it is seen that the main challenge of the
Petitioner in the instant case is that the Petitioner is deprived of its
right to participate in a public tender floated by the Respondent No. 1
due to the fact of limited publicity of the NIT for the auction. Along
with the aforesaid main contention, the Petitioner has also challenged
the terms and conditions of the Auction Document and the threshold
fixed in the Auction Document for the auction.
14. From the materials and pleadings, it is seen that MSTC Limited
(Respondent No. 2) is a Government of India entity under the
Ministry of Steel, Government of India. MSTC Limited has an e-portal
which is being widely used by government entities for publication of
their NITs or Auction Documents. This e-portal can be accessed by
any one or entity who has registered itself in the aforesaid e-portal.
Since it is a Government of India portal having national reach, it
Page No.# 11/19
seems, it has wide publicity and viewership. In the instant case, the
Petitioner has contended that it has missed out the NIT of the
concerned auction as the same was not published in national
newspapers as well as in the State Public Procurement Portal.
15. However, from the facts of the instant case, it is seen that as
many as 20 (Twenty) participants from all over the country have
participated in the Bid. Therefore, the Petitionerbeing a business
entity who claims to have been in the business for the last 50 years, it
is surprising that the Petitioner was not vigilant enough to have
missed the NIT for the present auction.From the pleadings of the
Petitioner, the Petitioner has itself admitted that the Petitioner has
been using or accessing the MSTC e-portal for various kinds of
government contracts. In its Additional Affidavit at Para 6, the
Petitioner has itself stated that the Petitioner firm is registered in
Respondent No. 2's portal. To support the aforesaid fact, the
Petitioner has provided its registered ID of the MSTC portal, being
Registration No. 28203. The Petitioner has also provided a profile
downloaded from the website of MSTC, which is annexed as
Annexure-C to the Additional Affidavit.The aforesaid facts make it
clear that since the MSTC portal is accessible only to registered users
and the Petitioner being a registered user, has not been sufficiently
vigilant and thereby missed the NIT for the instant auction.
Therefore, if anybody has to be blamed for missing out on the NIT of
this auction, that person can be only the Petitioner and none else.
Therefore, this Court, in its considered opinion, does not find any
Page No.# 12/19
merit in the argument of the Petitioner that due to non-publication of
the NIT in national newspapers and the State Public Procurement
Portal, the Petitioner has missed out the NIT, and thereby, it has been
deprived of its right to participate in a public tender like the instant
auction.
16. As far as the contentions of the Petitioner regarding the fixing of
threshold and pre-qualification criteria and other terms and conditions
are concerned, this Court does not find much merit in those
submissions. It is also a fact that the Petitioner is not a participant in
the whole tender process and it has approached this Court by filing
the instant writ petition only after the conclusion of the auction
process.
17.
It is a settled law that in a judicial review under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India, a Constitutional Court has limited
jurisdiction of review of a commercial contract. The terms and
conditions of a contract being created and written by the issuer of the
contract or the employer as per its requirements to meet the scope of
work, the same are the prerogative of the issuer of the contract or
the employer, a Constitutional Court should refrain from interfering
unless any arbitrary or mala fide or biasness is alleged in awarding
the contract or the terms and conditions are such which do not have
any reasonable or rational nexus with the object to be achieved.
18. The power of judicial review in contractual and tender/auction
matters have been laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in a catena
Page No.# 13/19
of cases.
19. As regards the scope of judicial review of government contracts
and auctions,in the case of M/s Michigan Rubber (India)
Limited-vs- State of Karnataka & Ors. , reported in (2012)8 SCC
216, the Hon’ble Apex Court, held as follows:
"23. From the above decisions, the following principles
emerge:
(a) The basic requirement of Article 14 is fairness in
action by the State, and non-arbitrariness in essence and
substance is the heartbeat of fair play. These actions are
amenable to the judicial review only to the extent that the
State must act validly for a discernible reason and not
whimsically for any ulterior purpose. If the State acts
within the bounds of reasonableness, it would be
legitimate
to take
into consideration
the
national
priorities;
(b) Fixation of a value of the tender is entirely within the
purview of the executive and the courts hardly have any
role to play in this process except for striking down such
action of the executive as is proved to be arbitrary or
unreasonable. If the Government acts in conformity with
certain healthy standards and norms such as awarding of
contracts by inviting tenders, in those circumstances, the
interference by courts is very limited;
(c) In the matter of formulating conditions of a tender
Page No.# 14/19
document and awarding a contract, greater latitude is
required to be conceded to the State authorities unless
the action of the tendering authority is found to be
malicious and a misuse
of its statutory powers,
interference by courts is not warranted;
(d) Certain preconditions or qualifications for tenders
have to be laid down to ensure that the contractor has
the capacity and the resources to successfully execute the
work; and
(e) If the State or its instrumentalities act reasonably,
fairly and in public interest in awarding contract, here
again, interference by court is very restrictive since no
person can claim a fundamental right to carry on business
with the Government”.
20.
Similarly, in the case of Tata Cellular v. Union of India,
reported in (1994) 6SCC 651, the Hon’ble Apex Court, while
discussing the issue of judicial review viz-a-viz administrative
discretion in deciding matters relating to contracts and auctions, held
as follows:
“94.(1) The modern trend points to judicial restraint in
administrative action.
(2) The court does not sit as a court of appeal but merely
reviews the manner in which the decision was made.
(3) The court does not have the expertise to correct the
administrative decision. If a review of the administrative
Page No.# 15/19
decision is permitted it will be substituting its own
decision, without the necessary expertise, which itself
may be fallible.
(4) The terms of the invitation to tender cannot be open
to judicial scrutiny because the invitation to tender is in
the realm of contract.
(5) The Government must have freedom of contract. In
other words, a fair play in the joints is a necessary
concomitant for an administrative body functioning in an
administrative sphere or quasi-administrative sphere.
However, the decision must not only be tested by the
application of Wednesbury principle of reasonableness
(including its other facts pointed out above) but must be
free from arbitrariness not affected by bias or actuated by
mala fides.
(6) Quashing decisions may impose heavy administrative
burden on the administration and lead to increased and
unbudgeted expenditure."
21. It is also a settled law that a party which has not participated in
the tender process has an extremely limited right to challenge the
tender process. In this connection, reference may be made to the
decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in National Highways
Authority of India-vs-Gwalior-Jhansi Expressway Limited,
reported in (2018) 8 SCC 243, wherein at paragraph 20, it was
observed as under:
Page No.# 16/19
“20
While
considering
the
relief
claimed
by
the
respondent (claimant), the same should have been tested
on the touchstone of the principle governing the tender
process, especially when the validity of the tender
document has not been put in issue or challenged before
any competent forum. Going by the terms and conditions
in the tender documents, as already alluded to in para 10
above, there is no tittle of doubt that the right of the
claimant (respondent) to match the bid of L-1 or to
exercise ROFR would come into play only if the
respondent was to participate in the tender process
pursuant to the notice inviting tenders from the interested
parties. The objective of tender process is not only to
adhere to a transparent mechanism but to encourage
competition and give equal opportunity to all tenderers
with the end result of getting a fair offer or value for
money. The plain wording of the eligibility clause in the
tender documents and the incidental stipulations make it
explicit that the respondent was required to participate in
the tender process by submitting its sealed bid (technical
and financial). The fact that a deeming clause has been
provided in the tender document that if the respondent
was to participate in the bidding process, it shall be
deemed to fulfil all the requirements of the tender
Clauses 3 to 6 of RFP, being the existing concessionaire of
the project, does not exempt the respondent from
Page No.# 17/19
participating in the tender process; rather the tenor of the
terms of the documents made it obligatory for the
respondent to participate in the tender process to be
considered as a responsive bidder, along with others.
Having failed to participate in the tender process and,
more so, despite the express terms in the tender
documents, validity whereof has not been challenged, the
respondent cannot be heard to contend that it had
acquired any right whatsoever. Only the entities who
participate in the tender process pursuant to a tender
notice can be allowed to make grievances about the nonfulfilment or breach of any of the terms and conditions of
the tender documents concerned. The respondent who
chose to stay away from the tender process, cannot be
heard to whittle down, in any manner, the rights of the
eligible bidders who had participated in the tender
process on the basis of the written and express terms and
conditions. At the culmination of the tender process, if the
respondent had not participated, in law, the offer
submitted by the eligible bidders is required to be
considered on the basis of the stated terms and
conditions. Thus, if the claim of the respondent was to be
strictly adjudged on the basis of the terms and conditions
specified in the subject tender document, the respondent
has no case whatsoever”.
Page No.# 18/19
22. In the instant case in hand, it is seen that the auction process
has already progressed to an advanced stage and the only thing
remaining is the award of the contract. It is also observed that the
tender process has been completed without any challenge to the
terms and conditions thereof, although the instant writ petition along
with certain other petitions have been filed after the process has
come to an end. Since the evaluations of Technical Bids as well as
Financial Bids have already been completed, third-party rights have
already been created. Therefore, it is the opinion of this Court that, at
this stage, it is not permissible for any partyespecially a party that has
not participated in the tender processto disrupt or derail the auction
process that has been concluded except award of the contract.
23.
In the instant case for whatever reason, the Petitioner was not
a participant in the tender process of the Auction in hand. Although
the Petitioner has alleged that due to non-publicity of the Notice
Inviting Tender (NIT) by the Respondent No. 1 in a sufficient manner,
the Petitioner has missed out the NIT and thereby, deprived of
participating in the tender process, the same contention cannot be
accepted, reasons for which, have already been discussed above and
the same may not be reiterated here.
24.
Taking into account the entire facts of the case and the
principles of law settled by the Hon’ble Apex Court, this Court is of
the considered opinion that the instant writ petition does not have
any merit and therefore, the same stands dismissed .
Page No.# 19/19
25. Parties to bear their own costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review