Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
7J
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
TUESDAY,THE SIXTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE RENUKA YARA
CIVIL M
OUS APPEAL NO: 543 0F 2024
Appeal Under Order 43, Rule 1 (r) of CPC against the order dated 29'
08-2024 passed in l.A.No. 1302 of 2024in LA.No. 151 of 2024 in A.S.No. 16 of
2016 on the file of the Court of the XXV Additional Chief Judge, City Civil
Court, Hyderabad.
Between:
1. M/s Vitlage lnn (lndia) Ltd, now known as M/s Vi!ryg. lnns (lndia) Pvt Ltd,
office at Door No.10-27-214, FACOR Layout,
having iIs opeiational
'Waltair Uplands,
Visakhpatnam, Rep. by its Authorised
Kaila#metta
Signatory, G.Ramakrishna Raju,' S/o.satyanarayana Faj.r, Aged about 45
ye-ars, No. 8-2-47211, Road No.S, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad.
2. Rajesh Tirumala Raju, S/o Rama Raju, {geO about 49 years,€cc. Service,
ny6. flat No.503, Blire Block, ttly Home Rainbow Apartment, Shaikpet Nala,
Hyderabad.
3. G.Satyanarayana Raju, S/o Late Venkata Rama.Raju,.Aged about 68 years,
resideht of B-Z-qt2l1, Road No.5, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad.
4. G.Ramakrishna Raju, S/ o.Satyanarayana Raju, Aged. about 45 years,
resident of B-2-472li, Road No.S, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad.
..APPELLANTS
AND
1. Syed Yousuf Hussain, S/o. Late_Syed_fi{alqq9q !u?sain, Aged about 62
y6ars, Occ. Retired Employee, R/d. 16-2-7381Cl18, Asmangadh, New
Malakpet, Hyderabad.
2. Syed Ahmed Hussar!, s./o. Late.syed ]vlgf'Iggo Hussain, 4g"9 about 59
y5ars, Occ. Retired Employee, R/o. 10-2-5101111, Asifnagar, [Mehadipatnam
Road, Hyderabad.
Both represented by their General Power of- Attorney^ Holder tMr.
p.Rama(rishnaiah, 516 Late P.Ramesh, aged about 81 years, Occ. Business,
R/o. Plot No.15, Saptagirinagar, Rethi Bowli, Hyderabad.
3. Syed Amjad Hussain, s/o. Late S^y9{Mahmood l.lus^sai1,4gg9 aboulT2
y6ars, Oic. RTAAgent, R/o. 17-2-318, Kurmaguda, Saidabad, Hyderabad.
4. Syed Sajjad Hussain, S/o. Late Syed.Mahqog.d Hussain, Aged about 66
y6ars, nyb. t 7-2'318, Kurmaguda, Saidabad, Hyderabad.
5. Syed Rasheed Hussain,.S/o. Late Syed Osman Hussain, Aged about 43
years, Oct;. Business, P./o. 1 -4-47 6, Gandhinagar, HyOerbOiA
-
6. Syed Zakir Hussain, S/ o. Lgte Syed Osman Hussain, Aged about 41 years,
Occ. Business, No. 1-4-476, Gandhinagar, Hyderabad. 7. Syed_Baq:ar Hqssain, S/o. Late Syed Osman Hussain, Aqed about 40 vears.
Occ. Busiress, No. 1-4-476, Gandhinagar, Hyderabad.
B. Mrs..Asm;l Nizam, Wo. Mohd. Nizamuddin, D/ o. Late Syed Osman Hussain,
aged abor.rt 34 years, Occ. Home Maker, Rl/o 8_4-3691284, Swarajnagai, -tsorabanda, Hyderabad
(Respondent No.3 to 8 are not n_ecessary parties to this rA as they are shown
as proforrna parties and no rerief is soughi against them in A.s.N6.io J ioiol
...RESPONDENTS
lA NO: 1 OF 20i24
Petition r- nder Section 1s1 cpc praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, ine Hign court may ne pteaieJ to
suspend the op,:ration of order dated. 29-09-2024 passed in l.A. No. 13,02 o,f 2024
in l.A. No. 151 of 2024 in A.s. No. 16 ot 2016, by the Hon'bre xxv Addr. ahief
Judge, city civil court, Hyderabad, pending disposar of the cMA in the interest
of
justice
lA NO:2 OF 2024
Between:
I
Y:15rlX.r1ssgrl, S/o. Late Syed,Mahmood Hussain, Aged about 62
years,
-S.Ig-1 uoc. L<etrred Emoloyee, R/o. 16_2_Z3g1011g,
Asmangadh, New
Malakpel, Hyderabad.
2. Syed Ahmed Hussain, S/o. Late.Syed Mahmood Hussain, Aged about 59
Iears, Occ. Retired Employee, Rl/o.' 1 0_2_51 0/1/1, Asifnag;;, tffH;-p;i;;
Road, Hvderabad.
power
their Generat
Hotder Mr.
[{!_1qO.re-."n1gd
^9y.Late p.Ramesh, aq_ed aboutofgl Attorney
P.Ramatirishnaiah, s/o
guiinesl,
years,
bcc.
R/o. Plct No.15, Saptasirinasar, nethi -eowri,
[:1"rrri;#;i _"lirpf,
And
1. M/s. Villag^e lnn (rndia)
,Ltd, now known as M/s Viilage rnns (rndia) pvt Ltd,
n€vrng rrs operationar
office at Door No.10-22:z/+, FAco( Lavout.
Kailasanretta wartair Uprands, VisakhpatnJm,- n"p. 'oy 'iti-lirtnIiiI"l
.
Signatory, G.Ramakrishn'a.
eged aboui-is
years, R/o. 8-2-41211, Road f,ajg,,_Slo-Si'tyaniriyana'na1ul
No.5, Banyaraiiills, *yOeranaO.
'p-T_'fi i[,Tt13,t1lt3'f .['ffi [i#;t%?f ,tll[,,i?#Si[]s?iir,3,"ft iii:
Hyderabad.
3. G.Satyana rgryrlgsgjl S/9_Late Venkata Rama Raju, Aged about 68 years,
resident of 8-2-47211, Road No.S, Banjara Hills, HyddrabaE.
4. G.Ramakrishna R?ir., S/o_s.atyanarayana Raju, Aged about 45 years, resident
of 8-2-47211, Road No.S, Banjara Hills, Hydeiabad.
5. syed Amjadllussain, s/o. Late syed Mahmood Hussain, Aged aboutt2
years, Occ. RTA Agent, R/o. 17-2-31A, Kurmaguda, Saidabai, Hyderabad.
6. syed Sajjad Hussain, S/o. Late Syed tvahmood Hussain, Aged about 66
years, R/o. 17-2-318, Kurmaguda, Saidabad, Hyderabad.
7. Syed Rashe-ed Hussain, S/o. Late syed osman Hussain, Aged about 43
years, Occ. Business, Flio. 1-4-476, Gandhinagar, Hyderabid.
B. Qved Zakir Huss_ain, s/ o. Late syed osman Hussain, Aged about 41 years,
Occ. Business, R/o. 1-4-476, Gandhinagar, Hyderabad.-
9. Syedtlaquar Hussain, s/o. Late Syed osman Hussain, Aged about 40 years,
Occ. Business, R/o. 1-4-476, Gandhinagar, Hyderabad.
10.Mrs. Asma Nizam, w/o. tMohd. Nizamuddin, D/ o. Late Syed osman Hussain,
?ged about 34 years, Occ. Home [/aker, Rl/o 8-4-3691284, Swarajnagar,
Borabanda, Hyderabad
. Respondents / Respondent
Petition underSection 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
vacate the interim order dt. 08-1 1-2024 passed in lA No. 1 of 2024 in CIVIA No.
543 of 2024 and to pass
Counsel for the Appellant(s):SRl. S. MALLA RAO
Counselfor the Respondents: SRI S. VENKAT RAMANA
The Court delivered the following: Judgment
i
I
t
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
,
,
'l'
r,,;1.
. -. ,, ,':"1i
i'i
IN THE HI(]H COUR'I FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
HYDBRABAD
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE RENUKA YARA
CIVIL MISCEI.LAN EOtIS APPEAL No.543 of 2O24
o6'h DAY 0F JANUARY, 2026
Bet*'een:
M/s. Village lnn. (lndia) 1.td., and 3 others
...Appellants
AND
Sri S1,'ecl Yotrsut'l Iussairr attd 7 others.
...Respondents
JUDGMENT;
Heard liri S. Matla Rao, leanred counsel for the appellants and Sri S.
Venkat Rarnana, learned cclunsc-l for respondent Nos.l and 2. Perused the
entire record.
2.
The Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is preferred by the appellants
herein/resp<rndent Nos.l to 4 aggrieved by the order dated 29.08.2024
passed in I.A No. I 302 of 2O24 in I.A.No.l51 of 2024 in A.S.No.16 of 2016
passed by rtre learned XXV Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Court at
I{yderabad, grantirlg ir{unction in favour of respondent Nos.l and 2
herein/petitirtners, restraining the appellants/respondent Nos.l to 4 from
alienating the suit schedule property till disposal of the condone delay
petition (l.A.No.l5l of 2024)
\
\
RY,J
cMA s43 2024
3.
The background facts of the case are that respondent Nos. I and 2
herein filed suit in O.S.No.2024 of 2009 on the file of Additional Judge-
cum-Vl Senior Civil Judge, City Small Causes Couft, Hyderabad, seeking
perpetual injunction to restrain the appellants herein from interfering rvith
the possession and enjoyment over the suit schedule land consisting of
Ac.2-00 guntas in Sy.No.ll5l2 and Ac.|,.25 guntas in Sy.No.1l5/3
altogether adrneasuring Ac.3.25 guntas together with three roolns
conesponding to Town Survey No.l l2lpart, Block-L, Ward ttg of
Khairtabad Village and Mandal, Hyderabad.
'[he said suit has been
dismissed vide judgment and decree dated 26.06.2015. Dr-rring pendency of
the suit, respondent Nos.l and 2 were not granted any ternporary
injunction. Aggrieved by the judgment and decree in O.S.No.2024 of
200b, respondent Nos.l and 2 herein pref'erred A.S.No.l6 of 2016 on the
file of the XXV Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Court at Hyderabad.
The said appeal was dismissed for default on 06.06.2023. During pendency
of the appeal also there was no temporary injunction in favour of the
respondent Nos. t and 2. After disrnissal of the appeal, respondent Nos- l
and 2 filed I.A.(SR)No. 157 of 2024 for restoration of the appeal with a
condone delay petition in I.A.No. l5 1 of 2024 to condone delay of I 86 days
in filing the I.A. for restoration of the appeal. Along with the t.A. to
cdndone delay, I.A.No.l302 of 2024 was filed alongwith affidavits of third
RY,J
cMA 543 2024
.i. )
parties seeking ad interim injunction. In the said interlocutory application
i.e., [.A.No.1302 ot- 2024, respondent Nos.l and 2 herein sought ad interim
injunction to rr,strain the appellants herein ltorn alienating the suit schedule
property till d'sposal of the condone delay application i.e. t.A.No.l5l of
2024. An ex ptrte tenrporary injLrnction order was granted in I.A.No.l302
of 2024 vide inpugned order dated 29.08.2024. Aggrieved by the same, the
present Clivil It4isccllaneous Appeal has been prefered.
4.
ln grounds of appeal. the appellants have pleaded that no ad interim
injunction cotLld have been granted when an application for condone delay
was filed ancl pending. lrurther, an arppeal is a continuation of a suit and the
procedure apprlicable in the suit has to be adhered to, more so when the suit
has been disnrissed and the appeal also was dismissed for default. Further,
the relief of injunction granted in the I.A. that is restraining the respondents
from alienating the suit schedule property during pendency after the
application to condone delay is beyond the scope of relief of perpetual
injunction sought in the rnain suit and said suit has been dismissed and is
challenged vide A.S.No.16 of 2016, which was dismissed for default.
Further, there is misinterpretation of the judgment of the High Court of
Calcutta in M/s. Vinayak Conclave Pvt. Ltd. v. Life fnsurance
\
\
,!>
RY,.I
cMA 543 2024
Corporationl relied upon by respondent Nos.1 and 2. The relief granted is
beyond the porvers vested by law that too when the appeal has been
dismissed for def-ault. Emphasis is made on the fact that no injrrnction was
granted in favour of respondent Nos. I and 2 during pendency of the suit or
during pendency of the appeal. It is emphasized that once the suit has been
dismissed denying relief of grant of perpetual injunction with a finding that
respondent Nos.l and 2 have failed to prove their possession, it is
erroneous that ad interim injunction was granted in favour of respondent
Nos.l and 2 restraining the appellants from alienating the suit schedule
property during pendency of interlocutory application filed to condone
detay. As such, it is contended that the impugned order passed is
unsustainable and is liable to be set aside.
5.
Leamed counsel for the appellants relied upon the judgment of the
High Coun of Judicature at Hyderabad in the case of A. Balaiah v.
Aravindanagar Co-operative Housing Society Ltd.2, wherein it is held
that an appeal lies under Order XLIII Rute I (r) of CPC against an acl
interim injunction passed under Order XXXIX Rule 1 of CPC. The same
principle is held by Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of A.
t
AlR 1995 Calcutta 1L3
' rggo (t) ALT 90 (D.8.)
RY,J
cMA s43 2024
venkatasubbi:rh Naidu v. S. Challappan3, wherein it is held that a party
who has suffered ex partc injunction order has rernedy available under
Order XLlll Rrrle I ol'CI)C.
.fhe
chocie available is for the party to move
the Appellate (jourt ot' Lo approach the same Court tbr any other retief. tn
this regarcl, it is to be r-roted that there is no challenge as to maintainability
of a C.M.A. filed against an ad-interirn order passed by the learned XXV
Additional Chiel' .ludge, City Civil Cotrrt at t-Iyderabad, t,icle impusned
order. Responclent Nos.l and 2 did not challenge the rnaintainability of the
C.M.A. and therefore, the albrernentioned citations are relevant only to the
extent of suppor:ting the case of the appellants with respect to
rnaintainabilitl, of the C.lvl.A.
6.
Learned counsel tbr the appellants relied uporl judgment of Madras
High Court in the case of P.N. Aboobucker v. K. Kunhamooa, wherein it
is held that arr interim reliel'granted during pendency of a suit should not
be of greater licope than that would be granted if in the suit itself after the
party has esteblished his right in the suit to that relief. The judgment of
orissa High Court in the case of Haraparbati Thakurani Bije v.
Ramakanta rGuptat, it i. held that an application before trial Court for
grant of injunction restrainirrg the defendant from alienating the property,
\zooo 1s1 ALr 44 (sc)
o
ryn rssa Madras 287
'AIR 2oo2 orissa 8l
I
H
RY,J
cMA 543 2024
the scope of appeal would be confined to the question of alienation and it
cannot be expanded so as to pass order of injunction restraining the
defendant from demolishing the building standing on the suit land. Further,
the High Coum of Judicature at }{yderabad, in the case of Kolli Butchi
Koteswara Rao v. District Level Committee, Vijayawad6, held that issue
of temporary injunction which runs beyond the relief sought in the rnain
suit is illegal. In the case of Kagitala Venkata Chalapathi Rao v.
Sabarunnissa Begum', it ir held by the l-ligh Court of Judicature at
Hyderabad that grant of interim relief which runs beyond the scope of a suit
or relief claimed in the suit is impermissible. When the relief claimed in the
plaint is limited to defendants in the suit but not against the proposed party,
order granting temporary injunction restraining the Sub Registrar from
registering any document pertaining to schedule property cannot be
sustained.
.
In the instant case, the relief sought by respondent Nos.1 and 2 in the
main suit is that of perpetual injunction i.e., respondent Nos.l and 2 claim
to be in possession of the suit schedule property and allege interference by
the appellants herein and therefore, have sought perpetual injunction.
During pendency of the suit in O.S.No.2024 of 2009, there was no interim
irw{aALD6s2
'
(51
2OL7
ALD 174
I
[TY,J
cMA 543 2024
injunction in frrvour of respondent Nos.l and 2, restraining the appellants
fiom alienatinp, the suit schedule property. Likewise, after dismissal of the
suit, vvhen A.S.No.l6 of l0l6 u,as filed before the XXV Additional Chief
Judge, Civil C,)uft at l-lyderabad, there was no interim order restraining the
appellants frorn alienating the suit schedule property. Only alter dismissal
of the appeal, when interlocutory application was filed to condone delay of
186 days in filing the petition to restore the appeal, the ad interim
injunction wai passed against the appellants herein restraining them from
alienating the suit schedule propeft)'.
8.
The crtrx of the issue raised by the appellants is that the scope of the
rnain suit war; for grant ol perpetual injunction. Likelvise, the scope of the
appeal was also to grant perpetual injr-rnction. There was no issue about the
alienation of suit schedule propefty either in the suit or the appeal i.e., the
relief seekinll restraint on the appellants from alienating the suit schedule
property was never a subject matter of the suit or the appeal. That being the
case, seeking relief against the appellants to prevent them from alienating
the suit sche'dule property, that too when the appeal has been dismissed.
During the interim of pendency of interlocutory application to condone
delay, the re:lief sought far exceeds and is beyond the scope of the relief
souglrt in tht: main suit and the appeal. [n those circumstances, according to
\
\
RY,J
cMA 543 2024
the learned counsel for appellants, the order passed is unsustainable and is
liable to be set aside.
9.
Respondent Nos.l and 2 have tiled I.A.No.2 of 2024 in I.A.No.l of
2024 in the present C.M.A with a prayer to vacate .the interim order granted
by this Court vide order dated 08.1 I .2024, wherein the operation of the
impugned order was suspended. Aggrieved by the same, the application is
filed to vacate the stay, alleging that the appellants are bypassing the due
process of law that interirn injunction can always be granted during
pendency of the petition under Section 5 of Lirnitation Act as per judgment
of the Hon'ble High Court of Calcutta, in the case of M/s. Vinayak
Conclave P. Ltd. (cited supra) and that ex parte injunction can be granted
even in the presence or absence of the opposite parties. Lastly, it is claimed
that the appellants have filed a C.M.A. with unclean hands as in the
interlocutory application filed to condone delay vrde [.A.No.l5l of 2024in
A.S.No.16 of 2016, notices were ordered several times, but the appellants
have intentionally avoided to receive the notices. The intention of the
appellants is to drag the proceedings and anticipating the same,
I.A.No.1302 of 2024 is filed seeking injunction to restrain the appellants
from alienating the suit schedule property. In the guise of the suspensron
order granted in the C.M.A., the appellants are rnaking attempts to alienate
f',
RY,J
cMA 543 2024
the scheduled property to persons by name Neelanchal Projects and Sattava
Developers. In the circumstances, even in case of respondent Nos.I and 2
succeed in the appeal, thel may not enjoy the fi'uits of the decree
10. [t is a point to be noted that the appellants herein did not raise any
issue about nraintainability of a petition seeking ad interim injunction
during pendency of the irrterlocutory application filed seeking to condone
delay in fitin;3 the appeal. Therefbre, the judgment relied upon by the
respondent Nos.l and 2 in the case of M/s. Vinayak Conclave Pvt. Ltd.
(cited supra) i;; not relevant
Il.
The rnain issue raised by the appellants in this appeal i.e., whether
the impugned order passed by the leamed XXV Additional Chief Judge,
City Civi[ Q6,urt at Hyderabad, in I.A.No.l302 of 2024 in LA.No.15l of
2024 in A.S.I{o.16 of 2016 is beyond the scope of the relief sought in the
appeal and the main suit i.e., O.S.No.2024 of 2009. For that purpose, there
is a need to examine the relief sought in the main suit. The relief sought in
the main suit is as follows:
a) restraining the defendants I to 4, their men, agents or anybody
claiming through them from interfering with the possession and
enjoyment of the plaintiff over the suit schedule land namely land
admeasuring Ac.2-00 guntas in Sy.No.llsl2 and Ac.l.25 guntas in
Sy.No.ll5l3 altogether admeasuring Ac.3.25 guntas corresponding to
Town Srrrvel, No.l/2/part, Block-L, Ward 89 of Khairtabad Village and
Mandal, Hyderabad, bounded on North - 30 feet wide road, South - 30
I
I
\
RY,J
cMA 543 2024
feet wide road and house of Shaik Wahid Ali bearing No.8-2-467/AlA,
East - Banjara Hills Road No. 1 and West - 30 t-eet wide road.
b) costs of the suit.
c) to grant such a reliet'or reliefs as this Court has deerns fit and proper
in the circumstances ol'the case.
12. The above relief sought is only with respect to protection of the
alleged possession of respondent Nos.l and 2 over the suit schedule
property. The nature of relief sought is perpetual injunction. The said suit
was filed and prosecuted without any ad interim injunction with respect to
alienation until dismissal of the sr-rit. Similarly, after the appeal
1n
A.S.No.l6 of 2016 was filed till the dismissal of said appeal for default on
06.06.2023 there was no interim injunction in the nature of preventing the
appellants from alienating the suit schedule property. Only while filing the
interlocutory application to condone delay, the impugned interlocutory
application under appeal was filed seeking ad interim injunction i.e., to
prevent the appellants from alienating the suit schedule property. As per,
the judgments reported in the case of P.N. Aboobucker, Haraparbati
Thakurani Bije and Kolli Butchi Koteswara Rao (all cited supra) issue
of temporary injunction which runs beyond the relief of the suit is illegal
13. In the instant case, grant of relief of restraining the appellants from
alienating the suit schedule property which is beyond and distinct from the
/
/
i
r..
RY,J
clMA 543 2024
relief of perpe:ual injunction sought in the main suit is illegal as such said
in-rpugned ordt:r is liable tt-r be set aside.
14. In the rt:sult, the Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is allowed setting aside
the inrprrgnerl order dated 29.08.2024 in I.A.No.l302 of, 2024 in
I.A.No.l5l ol 2024 in A.S.No.16 of 2016 passed by the learned XXV
Additional Ctrief Judge, City Civil Court at Hyderabad. There shall be no
order as Lo c<lsts. Misccllaneous applications, if any, pending shall stand
closed
SD/. T. KRISHNA KUMAR
JOINT REGISTRAR
/ffRUE COPY/
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The )(XV Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad (with records)
2. Ohe CC to SRl. S MALLA RAO Advocate [OPUC]
3. One CC to SRl. S VENKAT RAMANAAdvocate [OPUCI
4. Two CCt Copies
kul/Sa
&
L1,
/
I
I
t
t
HIGH COURT
DATED:0610112026
f
( oR
lHE S
o
U
JUDGMENl'
1 2 [i,qn lfrifr
c)
CMA.No.543 of 2024
ALLOWING'I'TIE APPEAL WITIIOUT
(c
?b
w
*
t
't
G
,
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review