Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/11
GAHC010246512025
2026:GAU-AS:419
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/6333/2025
M/S VERSHA TECHNOTRADE PVT. LTD.
REPRESENTED BY ONE OF ITS DIRECTOR SRI AAKASH SURANA, SON OF
BASANT SURANA, RESIDENT OF HOUSE NO. 42, 4TH BYELANE TARUN
NAGAR, PO DISPUR, GUWAHATI-781005, ASSAM
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 3 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE OFFICE OF THE CHIEF ENGINEER, PUBLIC WORKS
DEPARTMENT, BUILDINGS, ASSAM, CHANDMARI, GUWAHATI-781003.
2:THE OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER BPM BRANCH
PWD (BLDG) GUWAHATI ASSAM CHANDMARI GUWAHATI-781003.
3:M/S ALLIED CONSTRUCTION
3RD FLOOR BR TOWER 21 JANPATH LANE ULUBARI GUWAHATI-781007
4:POOJA ASSOCIATES (CONTRACT DIVISION)
PICK ME BUILDING
HB ROAD
KAMARPATTY
GUWAHATI-78100
Page No.# 2/11
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR MEDHI
Advocate for the petitioner
: Shri R. Choudhury
Advocates for the respondents :
Shri B. Choudhury, SC, APWD,
Shri T.J. Mahanta
Shri A. Borua for R. No. 3,
Shri S.K. Poddar for R.No. 4
Date on which judgment is reserved
: 07.01.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment : 09.01.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the operative part of the
judgment?
: NA
Whether the full judgment has been pronounced?
: Yes
JUDGMENT & ORDER
The validity and legality of a tender process in which the petitioner had
participated and emerged as the 3rd lowest bidder (L3) is the subject matter of
challenge in this petition instituted under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
2.
As per the facts projected, the Public Works Department had floated a
tender on 29.07.2025 for construction of a Circuit House at Udalguri on EPC
mode. The petitioner being interested and claiming to be eligible on all respects
had participated in the said tender process. Under Clause 6 (1) of the
“Information and Guidelines for Bidders”, there was a requirement for a
mandatory joint inspection of the site which the petitioner had done on
08.08.2025 and accordingly on 21.08.2025, the petitioner had submitted its bid.
On 22.08.2025, the respondent nos. 3 and 4 had also submitted their respective
bids. The technical bids were opened on 28.08.2025 when the bids of the
petitioner and the respondent nos. 3 and 4 were found to be responsive which
Page No.# 3/11
was followed by opening of the financial bids. In the financial evaluation, the
financial bid of the petitioner was found to be the 3 rd lowest (L3) whereas the
respondent no. 3 was declared to be L1 and respondent no. 4 as L2. The
grievance of the petitioner is with regard to the aspect that respondent nos. 3
and 4 had formed a cartel which is in violation of Article 2 (2) (b) of the NIT. It
is submitted that the bids by the said respondent nos. 3 and 4 were submitted
as a cartel and therefore, the entire tender process stands vitiated and is
required to be interfered with.
3.
I have heard Shri R. Choudhury, learned counsel for the petitioner. I have
also heard Shri B. Choudhury, learned Standing Counsel, APWD; Shri T.J.
Mahanta, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Shri A. Borua, learned counsel for
the respondent no.3 and Shri S.K. Poddar, learned counsel for the respondent
no. 4.
4.
Shri R. Choudhury, learned counsel for the petitioner, has drawn the
attention of this Court to the requirement of submitting an Integrity Agreement
to maintain the sanctity of a fair competition in the tender process. Article 2 is
with the aspect of the Commitment of the Bidder and under Article 2 (2) (b) of
the same, there was a requirement that the bidders would not enter into any
undisclosed agreement restricting competitiveness or to cartelize in the bidding
process. It is submitted that one of the mandatory condition was to make a joint
inspection of the site and from such joint inspection made by the respondent
nos. 3 and 4, it is clear that the aforesaid condition was violated. It is the case
of the petitioner that the representative of the respondent nos. 3 and 4 were
together while making the site inspection. The learned counsel, in this
connection has drawn the attention of this Court to the site inspection report of
the respondent no. 3 which is supported by a photograph. Similar site inspection
Page No.# 4/11
report of the same date i.e., 14.08.2025 is also submitted by the respondent no.
4 with the same photograph. It is submitted that the same demonstrates,
beyond all reasonable doubt that the respondent nos. 3 and 4 were in collusion
while submitting their respective bids as a result of which the sanctity of the
tender process was tarnished.
5.
The learned counsel for the petitioner has drawn the attention of this
Court to the inferences which have been enumerated in paragraph 10 of the
affidavit-in-reply filed on 22.12.2025. He has also drawn the attention of this
Court to certain other contracts in which both the respondent nos. 3 and 4 have
participated and has submitted that the same would demonstrate that the said
respondent nos. 3 and 4 are hand in gloves in submitting bids by forming a
cartel. He has also drawn the attention of this Court to the order dated
12.11.2025 passed by this Court wherein a prima facie view was expressed
regarding formation of such cartel. He has further submitted that under the
aforesaid facts and circumstances, the tender process is liable to be cancelled
with the direction to initiate a fresh process. He has also submitted that he has
instructions to submit that if a direction is given to debar the respondent nos. 3
and 4 from the tender process, his client is willing to do the work at the rate of
the L1.
6.
Per contra, Shri B. Choudhury, learned Standing Counsel, PWD has
disputed the projection made on behalf of the petitioner. He has submitted that
under Clause 6.0, there is a requirement of site visit and under Clause 6.1, such
site visit is mandatory. He has submitted that the said aspect is to be certified
by the concerned official and there is no requirement for attaching any
photograph. He has also added that there is no restriction or stipulation that
such visit has to be done by one bidder at a time. He has submitted that on the
Page No.# 5/11
aspect as to how a joint photograph was submitted, a letter was issued by the
Additional Chief Engineer on 07.10.2025 to the Executive Engineer which was
replied on the same date that the photograph was taken jointly.
7.
The learned Standing Counsel has submitted that the conditions of the
tender are authored by the Department and accordingly, the Department would
be the best Judge to give the best interpretation. He has submitted that the
Integrity Certificate has been duly executed and there is no material on record
to show that there is any exchange of information. In this regard, he has drawn
the attention of this Court to the affidavit-in-opposition, more particularly, the
contents made in paragraph 6 which reads as follows:
“6. That, with regard to the statements made in paragraph no 8 of the
writ petition; the deponent begs to state that the Integrity Agreement
dated 18.08.2025 and 22.08.2025 were executed separately by the
Respondent no. 3 and 4 respectively. Each agreement binds the respective
bidders independently. Tender Committee found all documents in
compliance of the conditions and there was no breach or irregularity
noted. There was no proof of exchange of confidential information,
coordination in bid pricing or restriction of competiveness.”
8.
He has submitted that the photograph cannot be a ground at all to draw
any inference and the record would show that the said photograph was not
taken into consideration. He has also submitted that the interim order was
obtained by misleading the Court. He has placed before this Court the original
records of the case.
9.
Supporting the stand of the Department, Shri T.J. Mahanta, learned Senior
Counsel appearing for the respondent no. 3, which is adjudged as the L1, has
submitted that the inference of violation of Article 2 is on mere presumption and
there is no material at all except from the photograph which is wholly irrelevant.
He has also submitted that the interim order was obtained from this Court by
Page No.# 6/11
making a misleading submission that the same person had represented the
respondent nos. 3 and 4. He has submitted that the picture was not actually
required to be enclosed to the certificate of site visit and the same would rather
show the bona fide of the competing parties. He has reiterated that there is no
violation of any clause of the tender document. He has submitted that the
respondent no. 3 was adjudged as the L1 in a duly conducted tender process.
He has also emphasized that the petitioner had participated in the tender
process and having emerged as the L3 in the financial bid has made the present
challenge.
10.
In support of his submission, the learned Senior Counsel for the
respondent no. 3 has relied upon the case of Central Coal Fields Limited vs.
SLL-SML (Joint Venture Consortium & Ors.) reported in (2016) 8 SCC 622,
more particularly paragraphs 47 and 48 which reads as follows:
“47. The result of this discussion is that the issue of the acceptance or rejection
of a bid or a bidder should be looked at not only from the point of view of the
unsuccessful party but also from the point of view of the employer. As held in
Ramana Dayaram Shetty the terms of NIT cannot be ignored as being
redundant or superfluous. They must be given a meaning and the necessary
significance. As pointed out in Tata Cellular there must be judicial restraint in
interfering with administrative action. Ordinarily, the soundness of the decision
taken by the employer ought not to be questioned but the decision-making
process can certainly be subject to judicial review. The soundness of the
decision may be questioned if it is irrational or mala fide or intended to favour
someone or a decision “that no responsible authority acting reasonably and in
accordance with relevant law could have reached” as held in Jagdish Mandal
followed in Michigan Rubber.
48. Therefore, whether a term of NIT is essential or not is a decision taken by
the employer which should be respected. Even if the term is essential, the
employer has the inherent authority to deviate from it provided the deviation is
made applicable to all bidders and potential bidders as held in Ramana Dayaram
Shetty. However, if the term is held by the employer to be ancillary or
subsidiary, even that decision should be respected. The lawfulness of that
decision can be questioned on very limited grounds, as mentioned in the various
Page No.# 7/11
decisions discussed above, but the soundness of the decision cannot be
questioned, otherwise this Court would be taking over the function of the
tender issuing authority, which it cannot.”
11.
Shri Poddar, the learned counsel for the respondent no. 4 has endorsed
the submissions of both the learned Standing Counsel of the Department and
the learned Senior Counsel of the respondent no. 3. He has submitted that
there is a mandatory requirement regarding the site visit which was accordingly
done by his client. He further submits that on the same date, both the
representatives of the respondent nos. 3 and 4 had gone to the site and a
photograph was taken jointly to substantiate such visit which was not a
mandatory requirement. However, the Department has clarified that the
photograph was not even taken into consideration. He has also submitted that
the other tenders which are sought to be relied upon by the petitioner were
open tenders and would not, by any stretch of imagination, indicate that there is
any collusion between the respondent nos. 3 and 4. He has submitted that the
same would rather show that there is stiff competition between the respondent
nos. 3 and 4 while bidding for various works.
12.
Shri R. Choudhury, the learned counsel for the petitioner in his rejoinder
has admitted that while submissions were made on 07.11.2025, it was projected
that the same person had represented the respondent nos. 3 and 4 as the
photograph reflected two persons and one was bona fide assumed to be an
official of the Department. He has, however, submitted that after exchange of
the affidavits, it transpires that the two persons are the representatives of the
respondent nos. 3 and 4. He has hastened to add that by such projection, the
formation of cartel becomes more pronounced.
13.
The rival submissions have been duly considered and the materials on
Page No.# 8/11
record including the original documents placed before this Court have been
carefully perused.
14.
The entire challenge projected by the petitioner is based on the ground
that the respondent nos. 3 and 4 had formed a cartel which is in violation of
Article 2 (2) (b) of the NIT. To substantiate the same, reliance has been placed
on a common photograph enclosed by the respondent nos. 3 and 4 while
submitting their bids regarding the site visit.
15.
The aspect of site visit is a mandatory requirement as contained in Clause
6 (1) “Information and Guidelines for Bidders”. For ready reference, the said
Clause is extracted herein below:
“6.0 SITE VISIT
6.1 The bidder is advised to visit the site of work mandatory, at his own cost,
and examined it and its surroundings to collect all information that he considers
necessary for proper assessment of the prospective assignment. Site visit by the
bidder is mandatory as the site is full of number of existing structures .”
16.
It transpires that site visit which is mandatory in nature is required to be
established which has been done by the respective parties by submission of a
certificate. There is no requirement at all for enclosing any photographs to
substantiate the same. Nonetheless, it appears that the respondent nos. 3 and 4
in support of such site visit had enclosed a photograph which however is a
common one containing the respective representatives of both the respondent
nos. 3 and 4.
17.
While the writ petition was presented, it clearly appears that the writ
petitioner had understood that there was a common representative of the
respondent nos. 3 and 4 as the second person in the photograph was presumed
Page No.# 9/11
to be an official of the Department. The same is fortified by the submissions of
the learned counsel for the petitioner recorded by this Court in its order dated
07.11.2025, the relevant part of which is extracted herein below:
“07.11.2025
...
6. The learned counsel for the petitioner therefore submitted that it is the same
person who has represented on behalf of the respondent Nos.3 & 4 who had
carried out the site verification for each other.
...”
18.
It becomes apparent that on such incorrect submission the interim order of stay
was passed.
19.
However, on exchange of affidavits, when it was clarified that the photograph in
question which was common to the bids of the respondent nos. 3 and 4 had featured
the two representatives of the said respondent nos. 3 and 4. On such disclosure, there
has been a marked shift in the basis of the challenge. While the challenge remains to
be hinged upon violation of Article 2 (2) (b), the accompanying facts have undergone
a shift that a common visit was made by the representatives of the respondent nos. 3
and 4.
20.
The issue which therefore arise for determination after such shift of stand is
whether a visit on the same date by the two representatives of the respondent nos. 3
and 4 can be construed to be a violation of the Article 2 (2)( b) which pertains to
Commitment of the Bidder. To appreciate the challenge even after the shift
instant, it would be necessary to examine the aforesaid Article which reads as
follows:
“Article 2: Commitment of the Bidder(s)/Contractor (s)
...
2) b) The Bidder(s)/Contractor (s) will not enter with other Bidder(s) into any
Page No.# 10/11
undisclosed agreement or undertaking, whether formal or informal. This applies
in particular to prices, specifications, certifications, subsidiary contracts,
submission or non-submission of bids or any other actions to restrict
competitiveness or to cartelize in the bidding process.”
21.
There is no dispute to the fact that the respective integrity Agreements
have been duly executed by the respondent nos. 3 and 4. In this connection, it
would be required to examine the stand of the Department in its affidavit dated
05.12.2025, more particularly, the averments made in paragraph 6 thereof
which reads as follows:
“6. That with regard to the statements made in Paragraph no. 8 of
the writ petition, the deponent begs to state the Integrity
Agreement dated 18.08.25 and 22.08.25 were executed separately
by the Respondent no. 3 and 4 respectively. Each agreement binds
the respective bidder independently. Tender Committee found all
documents in compliance of the conditions and there was no breach
or irregularity noted. There was no proof of exchange of confidential
information, coordination in bid pricing or restriction of
competitiveness.”
22.
Though the petitioner has filed an affidavit in reply on 22.12.2025 to the
aforesaid affidavit of the Department, there is no specific response, not to talk
of any denial of the said stand of the Department. This Court has also noted
that in paragraph 10 of the said affidavit, all the five nos. of inferences are
based on the photograph only.
23.
Even if the altered argument is taken into consideration that the two
representatives of the respondent nos. 3 and 4 were found to have featured in
the common photograph, the same, in the considered opinion of this Court
cannot be construed to be any violation of the Integrity Commitment. To accept
such submission would be far-fetched and would be in the realm of imagination.
Page No.# 11/11
Unless, any concrete materials can be demonstrated, this Court would be loath
in interfering with matters pertaining to allotment of contracts. This Court has
also taken into consideration that site visit by the prospective bidders was a
mandatory requirement and there is no stipulation that such visit cannot be
made on the same date or time by different bidders. This Court is also unable to
accept the submission that only because the respondent nos. 3 and 4 were
found to be bidders in various other contracts, a cartel can be presumed.
Rather, a contrary view would also be possible that there is competition between
the respondent nos. 3 and 4.
24.
In the conspectus of the aforesaid discussion, this Court is of the opinion
that no case for interference is made out and accordingly the writ petition is
dismissed.
25.
The interim order stands vacated which otherwise also appears to have
been passed on an incorrect submission made on behalf of the petitioner.
26.
At this stage, this Court is reminded of the law laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Raunaq International Ltd vs I.V R.
Construction Ltd. And Ors reported in (1999) 1 SCC 492 wherein a strong
view was expressed in cases where stay orders pertaining to public works were
obtained by unscrupulous litigant where exception was taken and cost was also
prescribed to be imposed. However, this Court has restrained itself from taking
recourse towards such direction.
27.
The records are handed over back to the learned Standing Counsel, PWD.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review