Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
RESERVED ON:
PRONOUNCED ON:
02.02.2026
12.02.2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE Ms. JUSTICE P.T. ASHA
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
and W.M.P.Nos.52834, 52833, 52827 and
52830 of 2025
M/s. URC Construction (P) Limited,
Represented by its Authorised Signatory,
Mr.K.Vijayakumar,
No.119, Powerhouse Road,
Erode – 638 001
-vs
1. Chennai Metro Rail Limited,
A Joint Venture of Government of India
and Government of Tamil Nadu
Represented by its Chief General Manager,
METROS, Nandanam, Anna Salai,
Chennai 600 035
1/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
...Petitioner in both W.Ps
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
2. Chennai Metro Asset Management Limited,
Represented by its Chairman,
Chennai Metro Rail Limited,
METROS, Nandanam, Anna Salai,
Chennai 600 035.
...Respondents in both W.Ps
Prayer inW.P.No.47323 of 2025: Writ Petition is filed under Article
226 of the Constitution of India to issue a Writ of Certiorarified
Mandamus, calling for the records of the 2nd respondent, relating to
the notification dated 04.11.2025 bearing No.NIT CMAML /CP/
TDR-50-CON/ 2025 discharging the tender related to “Design and
construction of Civil, Structural, Architecture, MEP, HVAC, Lifts,
Landscaping and all Associated Works for establishment of Integrated
Bus Terminal Cum Commercial / Office development at Vadapalani
Bus Depot and quash the same
and consequently direct the 2nd
respondent to accept the petitioner’s bid dated 30.07.2025 and award
the contract for the “Design and Construction of Civil, Structural
Architecture, MEP, HVAC, Lifts, Landscaping and all Associated
Woks for establishment of Integrated Bus Terminal cum Commercial /
office development at Vadapalani Bus Depot” to the petitioner herein.
2/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
Prayer inW.P.No.47327 of 2025: Writ Petition is filed under Article
226 of the Constitution of India to issue a Writ of Certiorari
Mandamus, calling for the records of the 2nd respondent relating to the
Tender Notice dated 05.11.2025 bearing no NIT No.CMAML/CP/
TDR- 10 -CS-DDC/ 2025 towards “Detailed Design of Integrated Bus
Terminal cum Commercial/Office Development at Vadapalani Bus
Depot” and quash the same.
For Petitioner
in both W.Ps
: Mr.A.L.Somayaji, Senior Advocate
for Mr.J.Rishikesh
For Respondents : Mr.Raghavendra Ross Divakar
1 and 2 in both W.Ps
COMMON ORDER
W.P.No.47323 of 2025 has been filed for the following relief:
“To issue a Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus,
calling for the records of the 2nd respondent, relating
to the notification dated 04.11.2025 bearing No.NIT
CMAML/CP/TDR-50-CON/2025
3/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
discharging
the
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
tender related to “Design and construction of Civil,
Structural,
Landscaping
Architecture,
and
all
MEP,
Associated
establishment of Integrated
HVAC,
Works
Lifts,
for
Bus Terminal Cum
Commercial / Office development at Vadapalani Bus
Depot and quash the same and consequently direct the
2nd respondent to accept the petitioner’s bid dated
30.07.2025 and award the contract for the “Design
and Construction of Civil, Structural Architecture,
MEP, HVAC, Lifts, Landscaping and all Associated
Woks for establishment of Integrated Bus Terminal cum
Commercial / office development at Vadapalani Bus
Depot” to the petitioner herein.
4/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
W.P.No.47327 of 2025 has been filed for the following relief:
“To issue a Writ of Certiorari Mandamus,
calling for the records of the 2nd respondent
relating to the Tender Notice dated 05.11.2025
bearing no NIT No.CMAML/CP/ TDR- 10 -CSDDC/
towards
“Detailed
Design
of
Integrated Bus Terminal cum Commercial/Office
Development at Vadapalani Bus Depot” and quash
the same.”
2. Considering the fact that the genesis for both the writ petitions
are one and the same, a common order is being pronounced.
3. Factual Matrix
The factual matrix giving rise to the above writ petitions are as
follows:-
5/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
(i) On 29.05.2025, the 2nd respondent had invited tenders for a
project which is titled “Design and Construction of Civil, Structural,
Architecture, MEP, HVAC, Lifts, Landscaping and all Associated
Works for the establishment of Integrated Bus Terminal Cum
Commercial / Office development at Vadapalani Bus Depot”. The last
date for submission of the bids was 30.07.2025.
The contract in
question was a “Turn-key” or in other words a “design and build”
contract, placing the entire responsibility on the tenderer starting from
the detailed investigation and design up to the construction and
commissioning. Since this was a “lump-sum” tender, persons bidding
were required to possess significant resources.
(ii) It is the case of the petitioner that they had submitted a bid on
30.07.2025. The petitioner qualified for the technical bid and after the
opening of the price bid, they were declared the lowest bidder at a sum
6/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
of Rs.5.18 crores, which was 6.95% lower than lowest bidder(L2).
Thereafter, a series of four meetings were held between the petitioner
and the respondents. On 14.10.2025 and 17.10.2025, the 1 st respondent
had called the petitioner for negotiations and to submit their important
credentials. In the first of these meetings held on 16.10.2025, the
respondents had requested the petitioner to offer discounts and the
petitioner had offered a discount of 1.50% in total subject to the
condition that a discount of 0.75% would be granted if land is provided
for the workers’ inside the campus and the remaining 0.75% if land for
a batching plant was provided within the campus. The 2nd negotiation
was held on 22.10.2025, during which further reductions were
discussed and the petitioner had informed the respondents that the
contract value quoted by them was lower than the value based on
CPWD DPAR and the petitioner's original estimate.
7/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
(iii) It is the case of the petitioner that during these negotiations,
the respondents had repeatedly requested the petitioner to share
commercially sensitive and proprietary data.
Though these details
were the petitioner’s exclusive Intellectual Property, the petitioner, on
the belief that the work order would be issued to them, forwarded
confidential pricing details and technical data vide e-mail dated
21.10.2025. It is thereafter that the 2 nd negotiation meeting had taken
place on 22.10.2025.
(iv) Since the details requested had been handed over, the
petitioner, vide their detailed letters dated 24.10.2025 and 27.10.2025,
after setting out the factual details of the bid and the negotiations, had
requested for grant of work order. However, to their shock and surprise
they received a notification via respondents’ portal on 04.11.2025
stating that the subject tender had been discharged. No reasons were
8/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
given for the said decision and the same was a unilateral decision. This
notification is the subject matter of W.P.No.47323 of 2025.
(v) On the very next day, i.e 05.11.2025, the respondents had
issued a fresh tender for the very same project but limiting the scope to
“Detailed Design only”. Thereafter, on 12.11.2025. the 1 st respondent
called upon the petitioner to collect the original EMD for which also
there was no explanation. On receipt of the said communication, the
petitioner had sent a detailed representation dated 14.11.2025 to the 1 st
respondent highlighting the arbitrary and unilateral cancellation made
by the respondents. Challenging the fresh tender dated 05.11.2025,
W.P.No.47327 of 2025 was filed by the petitioner.
4. Grounds raised by the petitioner:
(i). The petitioners have challenged the tender by contending that
the Discharge Order dated 04.11.2025 was patently arbitrary and
9/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
legally perverse, as the respondents were duty bound to act fairly and
reasonably. The respondents, having effectively induced the petitioner
to disclose their commercially sensitive details under the guise of
negotiations, proceeded to discharge the tender after surreptitiously
obtaining the technical details from the petitioner.
(ii). The discharge of the tender was totally unreasonable,
inasmuch as the petitioner's bid was 6.95% lower than L2 and by once
again resorting to the tender process, the respondents were incurring
higher costs which is contrary to the public interest. The respondents
have not satisfactorily explained as to how the “Design and Build”
model was converted to “Detailed Design only”.
The floating of
subsequent tender not only creates further delay but would also result
in price escalation thereby causing revenue loss. Therefore, the
petitioner had filed these writ petitions.
10/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
5. Counter affidavit of the respondents:
(i) The 2nd respondent had filed identical counters in both the writ
petitions. The main plank of the defence of the respondents is that the
petitioner's bid amount was 18.78% higher than the respondents’
approved estimate of Rs.436.10 crores. The petitioner, in the course of
negotiations, had contended that the estimate for the works under the
tender did not include certain items and that therefore, the bid amount
was justified. The 2nd respondent thereupon requested the petitioner to
share the detailed estimate to understand the alleged missing
components in the approved estimate of the 2 nd respondent.
In
response, the petitioner had submitted an abstract of quantities of
various items along with their rates. The information did not include
the detailed quantity break-up, rate analysis, construction methodology,
drawings and the materials that was submitted did not justify the bid
amount.
11/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
(ii) On 24.10.2025, the petitioner had once again reiterated that
their bid amount was justifiable and offered a rebate of 1.50%,
however, with conditions. The conditions were that, out of the rebate
of 1.50%, 0.75% would be granted if the respondents were to provide
space for setting up workmen’s quarters within the work area and the
remaining 0.75% if space for setting up a batching plant was provided
within the respondents' land.
Since the rebate offered was totally
insignificant, the Tender Evaluation Committee recommended for
discharge of the tender and to work out an alternate procurement
strategy. Therefore, in terms of Clause 39.1 of the Instructions to
Bidders, the tender was discharged on 04.11.2025 and on 05.11.2025, a
fresh tender was notified only for detailed design. The respondents,
therefore, sought for dismissal of the writ petitions, stating that the
decision to discharge the tender was on account of the inability on the
part of the petitioner's to provide a viable rate.
12/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
6. Rejoinder to the counter:
In the rejoinder, the petitioner has sought to counter the
allegations contained in the counter affidavit by stating that it was only
during the negotiations that the respondents contended that the
petitioner's quoted price was higher than the estimated cost.
The
estimated cost was never made known to the bidders. Therefore, the
petitioner would pray that the writs be allowed, the discharge be set
aside and the subsequent tender be quashed.
7. Submissions made on behalf the petitioner
(i) Mr.A.LSomayaji, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf
of the petitioner would submit that on 09.09.2025, the petitioner was
declared the lowest bidder(L1) at Rs.5.18 Crores while the next
bidder(L2) had quoted Rs.5.54 Crores. Thereafter, the petitioner was
invited for negotiations on 16.10.2025 vide the respondents' letter dated
14.10.2025. After the negotiations held on 16.10.2025, the petitioner
13/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
was once again called for discussions on 22.10.2025 which was
communicated to the petitioner vide the 1st respondent's letter dated
17.10.2025.
During the course of negotiations, the petitioner was
asked to share the detailed itemised break-up of costs, the methodology
adopted for submitting the quotations and the confidential technical
drawings and underlying price assumptions. These details were made
available to the respondents through an email dated 21.10.2025.
Thereafter, since there was no further follow up, the petitioner had sent
a letter dated 24.10.2025 wherein they had explained that their quoted
price was 8.29% less when compared to CPWD PAR 2023 plus the
updated Cost Index for the year 2025, 11.43% less than the CPWD
PAR 2025 and 6.22% less than the petitioner's BOQ with price breakup. In the said communication, the petitioner once again reiterated
their offer of a rebate of 0.75% on total quoted amount, excluding the
provisional sum, GST and Labour cess if space is provided within the
site for workmen’s camp and 0.75% if space is provided for setting up
14/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
a batching plant facilities within the site. The letter also highlighted
the fact that the petitioner had completed a number of projects in
Phase-I of the CMRL, which included the metro headquarters building
at Nandanam and was also currently engaged in ongoing projects.
(ii) The learned senior counsel would submit that the difference
in price between the petitioner and L2 was nearly 6.95% and that the
petitioner had also furnished the details as to how their estimated price
was 8.29 % less than CPWD PAR 2023 plus the applicable cost index,
as set out in Annexure-I, that their estimate cost was 11.43% less than
CPWD PAR 2025 in Annexure-II and that their quoted price was
6.22% less when compared with their BOQ with price breakup in
Annexure -III to the letter dated 24.10.2025. Since the letter of award
was not issued to them, the petitioner had addressed a letter dated
27.10.2025 to the respondents. In the said letter, the petitioner had
informed the respondents that any attempt to cancel the lump-sum
15/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
tender and invite a fresh tender was not only a bad industry practice but
was also against business ethics more particularly if such action were
to be taken after the respondents had obtained the highly proprietary
and confidential data, which would be prejudicial and detrimental to
the
petitioner's
commercial
interest
and
would
amount
to
misappropriation of their intellectual properties. It was after receipt of
the said letter that the discharge order dated 04.11.2025 had been
issued.
(iii) The learned senior counsel would draw the attention of this
Court to the fact that this communication does not disclose any reason
whatsoever for arriving at the decision for discharge. Further, the fresh
tender issued on 05.11.2025 was only with reference to design and was
not a “design and construct” as contemplated in the earlier bid. The
learned senior counsel would submit that the reason for the huge
difference between the estimate of the respondents and the price quoted
16/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
by the petitioner was on account of the fact that the respondents had
adopted the plinth area cost of the year 2023 for the tender floated in
May 2025. He would further argue that the respondents are duty bound
to assign reasons for cancelling the contract and issuing a fresh tender.
In this regard, he would place reliance on Section 12(2) of the Tamil
Nadu Transparency in Tenders Act (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”)
which provides that where the tender accepting authority decides to
cancel the tender, it shall record the reasons for the same. That apart,
he would submit that the respondents cannot be permitted to improve
their case during the course of proceedings before this Court. In this
regard, he would rely upon the judgment reported in (1978) 1 SCC 405
[Mohinder Singh Gill and another Vs The Chief Election
Commissioner, New Delhi and Others] and in particular, paragraph 8
therein.
17/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
(iv) In support of his argument that the tender cannot be
cancelled in an arbitrary fashion, the learned senior counsel would rely
upon the judgment reported in (2024) 15 SCC 461 [Subodh Kumar
Singh Rathour Vs. Chief Executive Officer and Others) with
particular reference to paragraphs 45, 46, 57.2, 57.5, 62, 67, 130 and
134. Likewise, he would rely upon the judgment reported in 2026
SCC Online 24 (Golden Food Products India Vs. State of U.P and
Others) with reference to paragraph 32.
He would therefore submit
that the cancellation of the earlier tender was bad in law and that the
new tender dated 05.11.2025 ought to be set aside.
8. Submissions made on behalf of the respondents:
(i) Per contra, Mr.Raghavendra Ross Divakar, learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the respondents would draw the attention of this
Court to the minutes dated 16.10.2025 and 22.10.2025 wherein even in
the 1st meeting held on 16.10.2025, the Tender Evaluation committee
18/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
has observed that the petitioner's quoted amount of Rs.5.18 crores was
18.78% (Rs.81.390 crores) higher than the estimated cost of Rs.436.10
crores and therefore, the petitioner was asked to provide a detailed
price break-up of the quoted amount.
(ii) The learned counsel would further submit that the reasons for
the difference in price were also discussed in the said minutes and that
the petitioner had made it clear that they were willing to offer a rebate
of 1.50% on the quoted amount subject to permission being granted to
establish the batching plant and labour camp within the work area.
Thereafter, since the price quoted was found to be substantially higher
than the estimated cost, the Tender Evaluation Committee had
recommended the discharge of the tender and to proceed with the
re-tendering after reviewing the technical requirements and revising the
cost estimate accordingly.
19/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
(iii) The Tender Evaluation committee had decided to adopt an
item-rate tendering process for the building works in order to arrive at a
more realistic estimate. The minutes further indicates that the very
negotiations were convened only on account of the fact that the quoted
amount was higher than the estimated cost.
(iv) The learned counsel would thereafter draw the attention of
the Court to the disclaimer contained in the tender documents with
particular reference to Disclaimer-1e, which clearly states that the 2 nd
respondent reserves the right to accept or reject any tender without
informing the affected bidder of the grounds for the said action. The
very same disclaimer is reiterated in the General Instructions to
Bidders, Clause 39.1 wherein it is clearly stipulated that the employer
namely the 2nd respondent reserves their right to accept or reject any
bid and to annul the bidding process and reject all bids at any time
prior to the award of contract without assigning any reasons and
20/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
without incurring any liability to the bidders. In case of discharge of
the tender, the bid securities were to be promptly returned to the
bidders.
(v) He would submit that the rejection has taken place even prior
to the discharge of the contract and that intimation was also promptly
given to the petitioner to collect the bid securities. That apart, he
would submit that, by their letter dated 30.07.2025, the petitioner had
clearly acknowledged that they understood that the respondents were
not bound to accept the lowest evaluated bid or any other bid. He
would submit that in the light of the above, the petitioner cannot now
seek to question the cancellation.
(vi) He would rely upon Section 10(3) of the Act, which provides
that if the tender accepting authority decides that the price of the lowest
tender is higher with reference to the prevailing market rate, it may
21/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
negotiate for reduction of price with the tenderer, notwithstanding the
provisions of Section 10(2) of the Act. Further Section 12(1) of the Act
empowers the authority to reject the tender where the price quoted is
higher than the percentage prescribed over the schedule of rates or the
prevailing market rates. In the case on hand, the price quoted was
18.87% more than the estimated price. Therefore, the respondents are
well within their right to reject the tender and proceed with a fresh
tender.
(vii)
The learned counsel would rely upon the unreported
judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in IJM Corporation Berhad
Vs National Highways Authority of India and Another in SLP(C)
No.10811 of 2022 which was a case where the Successful bidder, who
had fulfilled the eligibility criteria under the RFB (Required for
Proposal) and had quoted a high premium, found that the tender was
suddenly annulled by the National Highways Authority of India
22/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
without assigning any reasons, against which writ proceedings were
initiated.
In the Special Leave Petition, it was contended by the
petitioner therein that the expectations of the National Highways
Authority of India had not been disclosed in the tender documents, and
that an expected premium of 10.77% was sought to be relied upon only
at a later stage. The challenge by the tenderer was dismissed against
which, the SLP had been filed. The learned Judges, taking note of the
fact that the bid document clearly provides for the authority to reject or
annul bids without giving , proceeded to dismiss the SLP.
(viii) The learned counsel would rely upon another unreported
judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in S.L.P(C) Nos.12353-12355
of 2011[The Principal Chief Conservator of Forest and Others Vs.
Suresh Mathew and Others] which was also a case of cancellation of
an earlier tender and re-tendering. The learned Judges, relying upon
the tender notice wherein the bidding authority had reserved its right to
23/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
modify / cancel any or all bids without assigning any reason, upheld
the decision of the tender notifying authority and set aside the order
passed by the High Court. He would, therefore, submit that the facts of
said case would apply to the facts of the case on hand.
9. In reply to the argument of the learned counsel for the
respondents, the learned senior for the petitioner would submit that the
basis on which the estimated cost had been arrived at was on the 2023
price and not on the 2025 price index.
Therefore, the entire
proceedings are flawed.
10.
Heard the learned counsels on either side and perused the
materials available on record.
24/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
11.
Discussions:
(i) On a perusal of the documents and the rival submissions, the
crux of the matter is whether the respondents had the right to cancel /
anull / discharge the tender without assigning details and whether the
reasons now put forth are sustainable.
(ii) Admittedly, the petitioner was L1, having quoted a sum of
Rs.5.18 Crores, which was 6.92% less than the price quoted by L2. A
perusal of the terms of the tender, particularly the Disclaimer Clause F
of the tender document and the General Instructions issued to tenderers
under Clause 39 clearly indicate that it is well open to the tender
inviting authority to cancel the tender process and reject all tenders at
any time prior to the award of contract, without informing the affected
bidder of the grounds of such action.
25/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
(iii) This right has been acknowledged by the petitioner in their
letter dated 30.07.2025 wherein they have clearly stated that they
understood that the respondents were not bound to accept the lowest
evaluated bid or any other bid that they may receive. These clauses are
in sync with Section 12(1) of the Act. Section 12(1) of the Act reads as
follows:
12. Acceptance of tender
(1) The tender accepting authority shall accept the
tender which is the lowest tender in accordance with the
evaluation criteria prescribed:
(iv) A perusal of the minutes of the meeting held on 16.10.2022
and 22.10.2022 clearly indicates that the first negotiation meeting held
on 16.10.2025, the Tender Evaluation Committee had observed that
the petitioner's quoted amount was 18.87% higher than the estimated
cost of Rs.436.10 crores.
Therefore, on the very 1st day of the
negotiation the petitioner was well aware that their quoted price was
26/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
higher than the estimates cost and it is not a reason that has been put
forward in the defence to the writ petition. The very negotiation
meeting was convened only on the account of quoted price being over
and above the estimated price. The petitioner was directed to give a
detailed breakup of the quoted amount, which, according to the
minutes, was shared with the respondents on 22.10.2025. The minutes
would further show that the reasons for the difference in costing as
against the respondents’ estimate was on account of the following:
The respondents has adopted a top-down construction
method, whereas and the bidder had adopted a bottom-up
construction
methodology
with
soil
anchoring
for
diaphragm wall/basement construction.
Further, the respondents’ estimate included waterproofing only for
podium slab whereas the respondents had considered water proofing
for the entire ground floor slab. During the negotiation, the petitioner
27/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
had informed the respondents that the amount quoted was justifiable in
the light of the risk associated with design and construction of a two
basement + ground + 12 structure and they had offered a rebate of only
1.50% that too subject to the condition that the respondents permit the
petitioner to establish a batching plant and labour quarters inside the
work area.
(v) In the light of the above stand taken by the petitioner, the
respondents being the tender inviting authority had decided that the
price was neither competitive nor viable.
Therefore, the Tender
Evaluation Committee had decided to discharge the tender and proceed
with a fresh tender.
This decision cannot be found fault with,
inasmuch as the petitioner namely the bidder had clearly expressed its
final stand with reference to price and the respondents had found the
quoted price to be higher. Section 12(1) of the Act expressly empowers
the tender accepting authority to reject the tender where the quoted
28/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
price is higher. The respondents have only exercised the statutory right
vested in them under the Act.
(vi) Further, even in the judgments relied upon by the
respondents, namely (2024) 15 SCC 461 and 2026 SCC Online 24,
the cancellation had taken place post the award of work. In fact, in
(2024) 15 SCC 461, the Hon'ble Supreme Court had elaborately
discussed the scope of judicial review in contractual matters in
paragraphs 45 and 46 which read as follows:
“45. Over a period of time the courts recognised the
crucial role of judicial oversight in preventing the abuse of
power
and
maintaining
public
confidence
in
the
administrative process. Courts developed various doctrines
and principles to guide their review, such as the principles of
natural justice, reasonableness and proportionality. These
principles ensured that the administrative actions are not
arbitrary, discriminatory or capricious. By enforcing such
standards, the courts also ensured that the rule of law was
maintained and the individual rights were protected.
29/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
46. The interplay between judicial review and
administrative discretion has been a dynamic process. As
new challenges and complexities kept on arising before the
courts as regards the State's actions and governance, it
continued to refine its approach. This ongoing dialogue
between the courts and the executive branch contributed to
the development of a more accountable and transparent
administrative framework, paving the way for the exercise of
judicial review even in the realm of contractual disputes to
achieve a fine balance between efficiency and fairness in
policy decisions on the one hand and the rights of
individuals and overall public interest on the other.”
(vii) In paragraph 67, the Hon'ble Supreme Court had laid down
that the test to be applied is to assess as to whether there is any
discernible principle emerging from such action and if so, whether the
same satisfies the test of reasonableness. Once this test is satisfied, it
cannot be stated that the action is arbitrary. The learned Judges have
30/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
further set out the yardsticks that can be applied to find out whether an
administrative action is arbitrary in paragraph Nos.71 and 73 of the
judgment.
“71. To ascertain whether an act is arbitrary or not,
the court must carefully attend to the facts and the
circumstances of the case. It should find out whether the
impugned decision is based on any principle. If not, it may
unerringly point to arbitrariness. If the act betrays caprice
or the mere exhibition of the whim of the authority it
would sufficiently bear the insignia of arbitrariness. In
this regard supporting an order with a rationale which in
the circumstances is found to be reasonable will go a long
way to repel a challenge to State action. No doubt the
reasons need not in every case be part of the order as
such. If there is absence of good faith and the action is
actuated with an oblique motive, it could be characterised
as being arbitrary. A total non-application of mind without
due regard to the rights of the parties and public interest
may be a clear indicator of arbitrary action.
31/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
73. Thus, the question to be answered in such
situations is whether the decision was based on valid
considerations. This is undertaken to ensure that the
reasons assigned were the true motivations behind the
action and it involves checking for the presence of any
ulterior motives or irrelevant considerations that might
have influenced the decision. The approach of the court
must be to respect the expertise and discretion of
administrative authorities while still protecting against
arbitrary and capricious actions. Thus, now the only
question that remains to be considered is: whether the
action of the respondent to cancel the tender could be
termed as arbitrary?
(viii) In the case on hand, the minutes of the negotiation meetings
held on 16.10.2025 and 22.10.2025 clearly indicate that the only basis
for the negotiations was the higher cost that had been quoted by the
bidder namely the petitioner. The petitioner, who had quoted a price
18.76% higher than the estimated cost, after negotiations agreed to
offer only a rebate of 1.50%, which was not acceptable to the
32/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
respondents. Considering the final and unequivocal stand taken by the
petitioner to restrict the rebate to 1.50%, the tender-notifying authority,
namely, the 2nd respondent, was well within its right not to proceed
further with the contract, as there was no meeting point between the
parties with reference to the cost.
(ix) Further as stated supra, the tender documents had conferred
upon the respondents to cancel the bid prior to the issuance of the work
order without assigning the reasons. Here, the respondents, even on
the 1st day of negotiation, had clearly stated that the price quoted by
the petitioner was higher.
Therefore, it cannot be stated that the
cancellation was effected without assigning reasons. Viewed from any
angle, the action of the respondents cannot be found fault with.
The
filing of the present writ petition by the petitioner appears to be an
attempt to compel the respondents to accept the quoted price.
Accordingly, W.P.No.47323 of 2025 is dismissed.
33/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
(x) Since this Court finds that no arbitrariness in the action of the
respondents in discharging /annulling the tender, the decision to call for
a fresh tender by adopting an item rate tender system cannot be found
fault with, particularly when the Tender Evaluation Committee had
decided that such a tendering approach was in order to arrive at a more
realistic estimate. Accordingly, W.P.No.47327 of 2025 is dismissed.
No costs. Consequently connected miscellaneous petitions are closed.
12.02.2026
Index : Yes/No
Internet :Yes/No
srn
34/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
To:
1. The Chief General Manager,
Chennai Metro Rail Limited,
A Joint Venture of Government of India
and Government of Tamil Nadu
METROS, Nandanam, Anna Salai,
Chennai 600 035
2. The Chairman,
Chennai Metro Asset Management Limited,
Chennai Metro Rail Limited,
METROS, Nandanam, Anna Salai,
Chennai 600 035.
35/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
P.T.ASHA, J.,
srn
W.P.Nos.47323 and 47327 of 2025
and W.M.P.Nos.52834, 52833, 52827 and
52830 of 2025
12.02.2026
36/36
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review