Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No. 1/23
GAHC010245192025
2026:GAU-AS:4552
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
[THE HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM & ARUNACHAL PRADESH]
W.P.[C]. No. 6287/2025
M/s Travel Service represented by its
proprietor, Sri Mukul Medhi, 3-A Suriya
Enclave, Ajanta Path, Bye Lane No. 2,
Survey Beltola, Guwahati, Kamrup (M),
Assam, Pin-781028.
………………Petitioner
-VERSUS1. The Union of India, represented by
the Secretary to the Government of
India, Ministry of Roads, Transport
and Highways, New Delhi-110001.
2. National Highways & Infrastructure
Development
Corporation
Ltd
(NHIDCL), Regional Office, Guwahati,
Second Floor, Agni Shanti Business
Park, GNB Road, Opposite AGP Office,
Ambari, Guwahati-781001.
Page No. 2/23
3. Government
E-Marketplace
represented by its Chief Executive
Officer, Third Floor Tower II, Jeevan
Bharti Building, Connaught Place, New
Delhi-110001.
4. Kamakhya Travels, Panchmile, Tezpur,
District
–
Sonitpur,
Assam,
Pin-
784025.
……………….Respondents
BEFoRE
HoN’BLE MR. JUSTICE MANISH CHoUDHURY
Advocates :
For the Petitioner
: Mr. S.P. Bhattacharjee, Advocate
For the Respondent nos. 1 & 2
: Mr. C. Baruah, Standing Counsel,
NHIDCL
For the Respondent no. 3
: Mr. Y. Kothari, Advocate
For the Respondent no. 4
: Mr. B.D. Das, Senior Advocate,
: Ms. R. Deka, Advocate.
Date on which judgment is reserved
: Not applicable
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 24.03.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
Page No. 3/23
Operative part of the judgment ?
: No
Whether the full judgment has been
Pronounced ?
: Yes
JUDGMENT & oRDER
1.
The present writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is
preferred by the writ petitioner seeking cancellation of the bid of the
respondent no. 4, who has been declared as the lowest bidder [L-1] in a
tender process initiated by a Notice Inviting Tender [NIT] dated 23.08.2025
by the respondent National Highways & Infrastructure Development
Corporation Limited [NHIDCL]. A writ in the nature of mandamus has also
been sought for a direction to award the contract-work under reference to the
petitioner by declaring it as the L-1 bidder.
2.
The relevant and necessary facts leading to the institution of the writ petition
are required to be exposited at first. By a Notice Inviting Tender [NIT] dated
23.08.2025, the NHIDCL invited bids from companies, firms, agencies,
individuals having past experience in providing vehicles to Government
departments / public sector undertakings, etc. under a two-bid system
comprising of a technical bid and a financial bid. In the NIT, the subject of
the tender [hereinafter also referred as ‘the Contract-Work’, at places, for
easy reference] was mentioned as under:
‘Providing & supplying of 32 nos. vehicles [SUV such as Innova HyCross ZX / Toyota Fortuner] Innova Crysta, Scorpio, Bolero or
equivalent] on monthly basis for Regional Office, PMUs and its Site
Offices under RO - Guwahati, NHIDCL in the State of Assam.’
3.
It was mentioned that the vehicles, thirty two in nos., would be in need for
each Project Management Unit [PMU], Site Offices and Regional Office,
Page No. 4/23
Guwahati for the NHIDCL, a Public Sector Undertaking under the Ministry of
Road, Transport and Highways [MoRT&H], Government of India [GoI],
initially for a term of two years from the date of contract award, which might
be extended based on performance. The specifications of the thirty two
vehicles required for the Contract-Work was also mentioned in the NIT.
4.
It was mentioned that the technical bid and financial bid of the bidders would
be opened in the presence of authorized representatives. The time schedule
for the tender process was mentioned in detail in the NIT. In Clause 1.3 of
the Letter of Invitation [LoI], it was mentioned that the proposals were
invited through Government e-Market Place [GeM] [on-line bid submission]
for assignment. Clause 1.4 of the LoI provided that financial proposals would
be opened only for the firms found to be technically responsive. The selection
of the assignment would be done through Least Cost System i.e. the lowest
quoted bidder would be selected. Clause 2.1 and Clause 2.2 of the LoI had
outlined the documents required to be submitted in support of the technical
bid.
5.
It was mentioned in Clause 4 of the NIT that none of the staff of NHIDCL,
their relatives or any of the contractor / vendor / agencies assigned work /
contract in NHIDCL would be considered for bidding for hiring of vehicles. A
certificate in this regard should be furnished by the bidder along with
technical bid.
6.
Responding to the NIT, a total of thirteen nos. of bidders including the
petitioner and the respondent no. 4, submitted their bids on-line. After the
expiry of on-line bid submission time on the scheduled date, the technical
bids of the participant bidders were opened in the Government e-Market
Place [GeM] portal. Upon opening of the technical bids, the Bid Evaluation
Committee uploaded the results of technical bid scrutiny in the GeM portal in
two categories i.e. qualified and disqualified.
Page No. 5/23
7.
It is the case of the petitioner that a list of technically qualified bidders was
published in the GeM portal and when the petitioner visited the GeM portal on
22.10.2025, he found that out of thirteen participant bidders, technical bids of
only two bidders were placed in the qualified category and the technical bids
of the remaining eleven bidders were declared disqualified. The petitioner was
one of the two bidders who was placed in the qualified category whereas the
name of the respondent no. 4 was found among eleven disqualified bidders.
8.
The petitioner’s further case is that on 30.10.2025, the financial bids were
opened. To the surprise of the petitioner, the respondent no. 4 whose
technical bid was earlier in the disqualified category, was declared to be the
lowest bidder [L-1] and the petitioner was shown as the L-2 bidder.
Aggrieved thereby and terming such action as arbitrary, non-transparent and
opposed to the principles of fairness and transparency required to be followed
in a public procurement process, the petitioner has approached this Court by
the writ petition seeking the reliefs, mentioned above.
9.
I have heard Mr. S.P. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel for the petitioner; Mr. C.
Baruah, learned Standing Counsel, NHIDCL for the respondent nos. 1 & 2; Mr.
Y. Kothari, learned counsel for the respondent no. 3; and Mr. B.D. Das,
learned Senior Counsel assisted by Ms. R. Deka, learned counsel for the
respondent no. 4.
10. Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has urged
that when a list of technically qualified bidders was duly published on
22.10.2025 there can be no occasion to add two more names in the list of
technically qualified bidders at a subsequent date. When the list of technically
qualified bidders was published on 22.10.2025, the name of the respondent
no. 4 was not enlisted there because the technical bid of the respondent no.
4 was placed in the disqualified category i.e. non-responsive. Once the
Page No. 6/23
technical bid of the respondent no. 4 was disqualified, the tendering authority
should not have opened its financial bid for consideration, much less for
acceptance, and such action is illegal, arbitrary and is not permissible in law.
The evaluation process of the financial bids ought to have been made limited
to the two bidders who were declared technically qualified on 22.10.2025.
Clause 2.1 of the LoI listed the documents which were to be uploaded along
with the technical bid. The bidders were required to upload a notarized
undertaking in a format prescribed by the NIT/Bid Document. As the
undertaking was an essential document and since the respondent no. 4 did
not upload it at the time of on-line submission of the bid, such defect being
incurable, could not have been rectified subsequently and the respondent
NHIDCL authorities were not permitted to shift the disqualified technical bid
of the respondent no. 4 to the qualified category subsequently.
In the
NIT/Tender Document, there was no mention that after opening of the
technical bids, the disqualified bidders would be allowed time to make
representation as regards non-responsiveness of their bids. Mr. Bhattacharjee
has, thus, contended that for the afore-stated reasons, the respondent no. 4
is to be declared disqualified and the petitioner is required to be declared as
the L-1 bidder. In support of his submissions, he has referred to the decisions
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in W.B. State Electricity Board vs. Patel
Engineering Company Limited and others, [2001] 2 SCC 451; Central
Coalfields Limited and another vs. SLL-SML [Joint Venture Consortium]
and others, [2016] 16 SCC 622; Afcons Infrastructure Limited vs. Nagpur
Metro Rail Corporation Limited and another, [2016] 16 SCC 818; and
Prakash Ashphatings and Toll Highways [India] Limited vs. Mandeepa
Enterprises and others, 2025 INSC 1108.
11. Mr. Baruah, learned Standing Counsel, NHIDCL has, at first, extensively
referred to the pleadings in counter affidavits filed by the respondent nos. 1
and 2 to project the case of tendering authority, NHIDCL. He has submitted
that in the Instruction to Bidders [ITB] part of the NIT, it was provided that
Page No. 7/23
the Evaluation Committee of the NHIDCL reserved right to seek confirmation /
clarification of any document from the bidder / issuing authority of such
document during the process of evaluation. He has submitted that the entire
tender process was conducted through the Government e-Marketplace [GeM].
On 22.10.2025, only the results after opening of the technical bids which
were provisional in nature, were uploaded. At that time, the technical bids of
only two bidders including the petitioner, were found responsive and the
technical bids of the remaining eleven bidders were shown as non-responsive.
In the GeM portal, there was a provision for a non-responsive bidder to
represent within four days from the time of uploading of the opening results
as regards the reason[s] shown for disqualification. The respondent no. 4 and
one M/s Sonu Enterprises submitted their representations on-line in the
window provided in the GeM portal within the stipulated time period provided
for such purpose and on receipt of the representations, the technical bids of
the said two bidders were scrutinized again. On scrutiny, their technical bids
were found responsive and thereafter, the final results of evaluation of
technical bids were uploaded on 30.10.2025 showing a total of four bidders
as technically responsive, an aspect on which the petitioner has maintained
silence. Thereafter on 30.10.2025 itself, the financial bids of those four
qualified [responsive] bidders were opened and evaluated. After evaluation,
the respondent no. 4 was declared as the lowest [L-1] bidder. On 22.10.2025,
while uploading the opening results of technical bids which were provisional in
nature, the reasons for which the technical bids of eleven bidders were placed
in the disqualified category were also uploaded. When the respondent no. 4
represented that it had uploaded the notarized undertaking along with its
technical bid, its technical bid was scrutinized again and it was found that the
notarized undertaking was part of the respondent no. 4’s technical bid
submitted only. Similarly, on receipt of a representation from M/s Sonu
Enterprises, its technical bid was checked again and on checking, its technical
bid was also found compliant. As the omission was attributable to the
tendering authority, due to oversight, it was corrected during the subsequent
Page No. 8/23
stage of technical bid evaluation. The learned Standing Counsel, NHIDCL has
contended that there was no infirmity in the procedure followed in declaring
the L-1 bidder and as the petitioner has not been able to make out a case,
the writ petition deserves to be dismissed.
12. Mr. Kothari, learned counsel for the respondent no. 3 has submitted that an
affidavit has been filed on behalf of the respondent no. 3 mentioning about
the manner in which a tender process is conducted through the Government
e-Marketplace [GeM] in deference to the Order dated 26.02.2026. In the
affidavit, the technical bids of the respondent no. 4 and M/s Sonu Enterprises
along with the documents, submitted on-line, have been annexed. He has
submitted that the GeM operates solely as an electronic public procurement
and facilitation portal, providing a neutral technological interface to enable
interaction and transactions between buyers and sellers registered on its
portal. The role of GeM is strictly limited to providing access to the platform
and facilitating electronic process of procurement, without any participation or
involvement of the GeM in the process underlying the contractual obligation
between the buyer and the seller. He has submitted that ordinarily, fortyeight hours time period is provided in the GeM portal for any bidder to
respond after opening of the bids and it is an in-built mechanism. But such
period can be altered at the instruction of the procuring authority. In the case
in hand, the time period provided for any bidder to respond was made ninetysix hours [four days] at the instruction of the buyer/procuring authority. He
has submitted that notarized undertaking was part of the technical bids
uploaded by the respondent no. 4 and M/s Sonu Enterprise.
13. Mr. Das, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondent no. 4 has
submitted in similar lines as the learned Standing Counsel, NHIDCL. He has
further submitted that when after the provisional results as regards technical
bids of the participant bidders were uploaded on 22.10.2025 the respondent
no. 4 came to know that purportedly for not uploading the notarized
Page No. 9/23
undertaking its technical bid was placed in the disqualified category. There
was a provision in the GeM portal for any bidder who had been disqualified
during the technical evaluation stage, to provide clarification as regards the
disqualified bid within four days from the time of uploading of the technical
bid opening results. In view of availability of such provision, the respondent
no. 4 submitted its representation within the stipulated time period in the
GeM portal on 24.10.2025 and also uploaded a certificate in abundant
caution. The representation was considered and the respondent no. 4 learnt
on 30.10.2025 that the respondent no. 4 had been removed from the
disqualified category to the qualified category during the technical bid
evaluation stage. Thereafter, the financial bids of the respondent no. 4 and
another similarly situated bidder were considered along with the two other
participant bidders, who were placed in the qualified category at the technical
bid opening stage. Upon evaluation of the financial bids, the respondent no. 4
was declared as the lowest [L-1] bidder. Mr. Das has submitted that as there
was no infirmity in the decision-making process and the respondent no. 4 had
quoted lower bid value than the petitioner, the assail made in the writ petition
has no substance.
14. The submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties have received
due consideration. The materials brought on record by the parties through
their pleadings have been thoroughly considered.
15. To understand the procedure followed by the respondent NHIDCL authorities
during evaluation process of the bids, it would be apposite to refer to the
counter affidavits filed on behalf of the respondent nos. 1 & 2 wherein the
procedure followed has been described.
15.1. In the affidavit filed on 21.11.2025, it has been averred that in Clause 5.1 of
the Bid Document under the head - 'Evaluation of Technical Bid', a two-stage
process in evaluation was contemplated. The Request for Proposal [RFP]
Page No. 10/23
mentioned that the financial bids of only those bidders who were declared
responsive in the technical bid evaluation stage by the Evaluation Committee,
would be opened and evaluated. After evaluation of the technical bids, the
Evaluation Committee uploaded the provisional results in the GeM portal in
two categories – ‘Qualified’ and ‘Disqualified’ - giving due reasons for
disqualification.
15.2. It was on 22.10.2025 the provisional technical bid evaluation results were
uploaded in the GeM portal with the reasons of disqualification, apart from
placing the bidders in two categories [qualified and disqualified]. In a Table,
the reasons for disqualification of the technical bids of eleven participant
bidders were mentioned. The reason cited for disqualifying the bid of the
respondent no. 4 was shown as ‘want of the certificate that none of the staff
of NHIDCL, their relatives, etc. are participating in the bid’. The reasons for
disqualification of the technical bid of M/s Sonu Enterprises were shown as
'want of the certificate that none of the staff of NHIDCL, their relatives, etc.
are participating in the bid' and 'want of notarized contract with the owner in
case vehicle is not owned by the bidder'.
15.3. There was a provision in the GeM portal for any disqualified bidder to
represent within four days from the time of uploading the results to respond
to any clarification or discrepancy for being disqualified brought out during
technical bid evaluation stage. The facility in the GeM portal was for the
bidder to know the reasons for disqualification of the bids by clicking the
'view' icon in the GeM portal and to submit a representation, if one chooses to
do so. Such representation was to be submitted within four days from the
time and date of uploading of the provisional technical bid evaluation results
in the GeM portal. Post-uploading of the results of evaluation of the technical
bids in GeM portal on 22.10.2025, two bidders, namely, [i] M/s Kamakhya
Travels [the respondent no. 4] and [ii] M/s Sonu Enterprises represented
Page No. 11/23
within ninety-six hours [four days] with their responses with regard to their
disqualification during the technical bid evaluation stage.
15.4. On consideration of the representations submitted by the afore-stated two
bidders, namely, [i] M/s Kamakhya Travels [the respondent no. 4] and [ii]
M/s Sonu Enterprises [non-party], the Evaluation Committee decided to make
a scrutiny of their technical bids and on scrutiny, found both the bidders to be
qualified. Other than the said two bidders, no other bidder from the
disqualified category represented during the stipulated time-frame of four
days. Inadvertently, M/s Kamakhya Travels [the respondent no. 4] was
placed in the disqualified category for non-submission of the certificate that
none of the staff of the NHIDCL, their relatives, etc. was participating in the
bidding process. But on re-scrutiny of the tender document of M/s Kamakya
Travels [the respondent no. 4] by the Evaluation Committee in the GeM
portal, it was found that the same had been uploaded in the form of a
notarized undertaking by the bidder in GeM portal at the time of bid
submission itself. Similarly after re-scrutiny, the technical bid of the bidder,
M/s Sonu Enterprises had to be declared qualified.
15.5. Consequently, only four bidders, namely, [i] M/s Cozy Tour & Travels; [ii] M/s
Kamakhya Travels [the respondent no. 4]; [iii] M/s Sonu Enterprises; and [iv]
M/s Travel Services [the petitioner]; were declared qualified by the Evaluation
Committee and the final results of technical bid evaluation were uploaded in
the GeM portal on 30.10.2025.
15.6. On the basis of the final results of technical bid evaluation by the Evaluation
Committee, the financial bids of all the four technically qualified bidders were
opened on 30.10.2025 and among them, the respondent no. 4 was found to
be lowest bidder [L-1]. It was prepared using the in-built process of GeM
portal in ascertaining the L-1 bidder through GeM portal. The respondent no.
Page No. 12/23
4 quoted a bid value at Rs. 5,80,87,008/- to emerge as the lowest [L-1]
bidder.
16. An assertion is made by the petitioner to the effect that the final results were
uploaded in the GeM portal on 22.10.2025 after evaluation of the technical
bids, declaring only two bidders including the petitioner, as qualified and the
said fact has been admitted by the respondent NHIDCL authorities as well as
by the respondent no. 4. What the respondent NHIDCL authorities have
asserted is that the results of technical bid evaluation which were uploaded
on 22.10.2025, were only provisional in nature and it was at an earlier stage
of the technical bid evaluation stage after opening of the technical bids. At
that stage, the reasons for disqualification against each disqualified bidder
were also provided for fairness and transparency. Such reasons for
disqualification could be viewed by the concerned bidder by clicking the 'view'
icon on the same page of the GeM portal and the purpose was to enable a
disqualified bidder to represent against disqualification within the stipulated
time period of four days, if he had valid reason to agitate that his technical
bid ought not have been placed in the disqualified category.
17. The petitioner itself has annexed a screenshot of the results of technical bid
evaluation uploaded on 22.10.2025 at Annexure-2 of the writ petition. From
Annexure-2, it can be seen that out of thirteen participant bidders, technical
bids of only two bidders were placed in the qualified category and the bids of
the remaining eleven bidders were placed in the disqualified category. In the
extreme right column, there was a ‘view’ icon.
18. The facts which have emerged are that after opening of the technical bids on
22.10.2025, the results found after opening of the technical bids were
uploaded in the GeM portal on 22.10.2025, with reasons of disqualification
mentioned, as found out by the Evaluation Committee upon scrutiny of the
technical bids and the documents in support, uploaded on-line. Each bidder
Page No. 13/23
including a bidder from the disqualified category, could view the reasons by
clicking the ‘view’ icon. The reasons for declaring the technical bids of the
respondent no. 4 and M/s Sonu Enterprises as disqualified were made known
to them. Post-uploading of the results after opening of the technical bids in
the GeM portal, only two bidders, namely, M/s Kamakhya Travels [the
respondent no. 4] and M/s Sonu Enterprises represented within four days
with the responses with regard to their disqualification during the stage the
evaluation of the technical bids was being undertaken.
19. The issues which have, therefore, arisen are, firstly, whether after uploading
of the results of technical bid opening on 22.10.2025 in the manner above, it
was open for the tendering authority, that is, the NHIDCL to scrutinize the
technical bids again; and secondly, whether the participant bidders whose
technical bids were placed in the disqualified category, could be permitted to
submit any representation or any additional document qua the reasons shown
for declaring their technical bids disqualified.
20. For the issue whether the results of technical bid opening uploaded on
22.10.2025 should be treated as final, a further look at the Tender Document
is necessary. In Clause 5.1 of the LoI which was part of the tender document,
the manner in which the technical bid proposals would be evaluated was
mentioned. As per Clause 5.1, the proposals would be evaluated by an
Evaluation Committee and to evaluate the proposals, a two-stage procedure
would be adopted. In the first stage, the technical bids would be opened by
the Evaluation Committee and the Evaluation Committee would examine on
the four aspects specifically mentioned therein. In case the answer to any of
the four aspects was found to be in negative, then the bid would be declared
as non-responsive and shall not be evaluated further. After examining the
proposal of the above grounds, the Evaluation Committee would shortlist the
bidders on the basis of information provided in their technical bids
Page No. 14/23
corresponding to their requirements set forth. All the conditions set forth in
Clause 2.1 were to be met by the bidders at the stage of technical evaluation.
21. In the Tender Document, it was mentioned that the time allowed for technical
qualifications during technical evaluation would be four days. From the above
clauses, it is discernible that the details uploaded on 22.10.2025 were at an
interim stage in the process of technical bid evaluation. The reasons
mentioned to place the bidders in the qualified category and the disqualified
category did not attain finality at that stage. As a time period of four days
was kept for technical clarifications during technical evaluation and an
window was kept open during that period to enable the participant bidders to
submit representations, it cannot be said that the process of evaluation of the
technical bids came to a culmination on 22.10.2025 itself. By uploading the
reasons found after opening and evaluation of the technical bids in the GeM
portal, the Evaluation Committee had disclosed the reasons it had found to
disqualify the technical bids of some of the bidders and the reasons were for
knowledge of the participant bidders. By keeping the window open for a
period of four days thereafter, the Evaluation Committee facilitated the
bidders to submit representations as against the reasons for disqualification.
If by submitting representation a bidder placed in the disqualified category
could show sufficient cause as to why he should not be placed in that
category and should be placed in the qualified category in so far as the
technical bid evaluation is concerned, the final view in the matter after
consideration of the reasons shown in the representation could altogether be
different. A tentative view taken during the early stage of the technical bid
evaluation process cannot be deemed to be the final view in the matter and
the final view would be dependent on the responses received from the
bidders through representations and their consideration by the Evaluation
Committee. Therefore, it was within the authority of the tendering authority
to scrutinize the technical bids of the bidders after uploading of the results it
uploaded upon opening of the technical bids.
Page No. 15/23
22. When the two disqualified bidders submitted their representations showing
reasons as to why their technical bids should be placed in the qualified
category, the Evaluation Committee made scrutiny of the technical bids and
the documents submitted in support of the technical bids. In so far as the
respondent no. 4 is concerned, the respondent no. 4 had asserted that it had
complied with the condition of uploading the notarized undertaking with the
technical bid. It was for such reason, the respondent NHIDCL authorities
stated to have made the scrutiny of the technical bid of the respondent no. 4
again.
23. In the affidavit-in-opposition, the respondent NHIDCL authorities had taken a
stand to the effect that on rechecking of the submitted documents by the
Evaluation Committee in the GeM portal it was found that the certificate in
the form of notarized undertaking was uploaded by the respondent no. 4 in
the GeM portal at the time of bid submission itself. As the notarized
undertaking was uploaded at the time of bid submission by the respondent
no. 4 and it was the sole reason for placing the respondent no. 4 in
disqualified category after opening of the technical bids on 22.10.2025, due
to inadvertence, the respondent no. 4 was subsequently placed in the
qualified category.
24. Similarly, the other bidder, M/s Sonu Enterprises who also represented during
the permitted period of four days after 22.10.2025, was also placed in the
qualified category after scrutiny. M/s Sonu Enterprises has not been
impleaded as a party-respondent in the present proceeding and nothing has
been pleaded against the said bidder in the writ petition. Consequently, the
respondents also did not traverse on the aspect as to why M/s Sonu
Enterprises was brought into the qualified category after placing it in the
disqualified category, at first, after opening of the technical bids on
Page No. 16/23
22.10.2025. Therefore, this Court is not in a position to dilate further on this
subject-matter due to want of sufficient materials.
25. On bringing the said two bidders in the qualified category, the total number
of bidders placed in the qualified category at the end of evaluation process of
the technical bids of all the thirteen participant bidders became four. After
completion of the process of technical bid evaluation, the final results were
uploaded on 30.10.2025. In the writ petition, the petitioner is found to have
maintained silence as regards uploading of the final results of technical bid
evaluation on 30.10.2025 while challenging the financial bid evaluation results
of 30.10.2025. After uploading the final results of technical bid evaluation, the
financial bids of the four technically qualified bids were opened on
30.10.2025. The results of final evaluation were also uploaded on 30.10.2025.
As upon financial bid evaluation, the respondent no. 4 with an offered bid
value of Rs. 5,80,87,008/- emerged as the lowest bidder [L-1], its rank was
shown as L-1 in the GeM portal. The petitioner who had offered its bid value
at Rs. 6,17,25,600/- emerged as the L-2 bidder and M/s Sonu Enterprises
with an offered bid value of Rs. 6,17,52,000/- was adjudged as L-3. The
fourth bidder [L-4] offered a bid value of Rs. 7,17,84,000/-.
26. As already mentioned above, a contention was raised on behalf of the
petitioner that the notarized undertaking was not submitted by the
respondent no. 4 at the time of on-line bid submission and in the counter
affidavit filed by the respondent no. 4, it did not traverse specifically on the
said aspect. In the counter affidavit, the respondent no. 4 had mentioned that
while submitting its response on 24.10.2025, he also uploaded a declaration
certificate. In view of the controversy arose on the issue in a such manner,
the respondent no. 3 was directed, on 26.02.2026, to file an affidavit to bring
the entire technical bids submitted on-line by the two bidders, M/s Kamakhya
Travels [the respondent no. 4] and M/s Sonu Enterprises before the bid
submission closing date. In deference to the Order dated 26.02.2026, the
Page No. 17/23
respondent no. 3 filed the affidavit on 12.03.2026, to bring therewith the
technical bids of the petitioner and M/s Sonu Enterprise on record.
27. In the affidavit of the respondent no. 3, it is averred that the notarized
undertaking bearing e-stamp dated 02.09.2025 was uploaded by the
petitioner in the GeM portal at 06-40 a.m. on 08.09.2025, that is, before the
bid submission closing date of 12.09.2025. The notarized undertaking bearing
e-stamp dated 02.09.2025 is found available at Page nos. 429 to 431 of the
affidavit. The notarized undertaking dated 12.09.2025 of M/s Sonu
Enterprises is found available at Page nos. 567 to 568 of the same affidavit.
28. In W.B. State Electricity Board [supra], the respondent nos. 1 to 4, which
was a consortium of four companies, was one of the three bidders in the fray.
After opening of the bids, the bid of the respondent consortium was found to
be the lowest and when the appellant made further scrutiny, a good number
of arithmetical errors were discovered in the bid. The respondent consortium
attributed
the
mistakes
to
repetitive
systematic
typographical
data
transmission failure. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that the appellant
Board was justified in not permitting the respondent consortium to correct the
errors which had occurred in a highly competitive bidding process. It has
been observed that the mistakes might be intentional but it was not beyond
the control of the respondent consortium to correct the same before the
submission of the bid and had the respondent consortium been vigilant in
checking the Tender Documents before their submission, the mistakes could
have been avoided.
29. The subject-matter in the tender process involved in Central Coalfields
Limited [supra] was for a work, ‘Outsourcing for Overburden Removal
[1050.00 L. CuM] and Coal Extraction [975.00 L. Te] and transportation by
deploying surface miner at Ashok OPC, Piparwar Area for a period of 8 years’.
The NIT / Bid Document prescribed for submission of the earnest money
Page No. 18/23
deposit [EMD] either in the form of demand draft [DD] / banker’s cheque
[BC] / banker’s pay order [BPO] or irrevocable bank guarantee [BG] from any
schedule bank ‘in the format given in the Bid Document’. On scrutiny, the
respondent joint venture consortium [JVC], SLL – SML’s BG submitted for the
EMD was found in a format, other than the prescribed format, and the JVC’s
bid was rejected on that ground. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that
since the employer Coal India Limited had not relaxed or deviated from the
requirement of furnishing the BG in the prescribed format, every bidder was
obliged to adhere to the prescribed format and therefore, the failure on the
respondent JVC to furnish the BG in the prescribed format was a sufficient
reason for the employer to reject its bid.
30. The appeals in Afcons Infrastructure Limited [supra] were preferred before
the Hon’ble Supreme Court against the decision of a Division Bench of the
High Court wherein it was held that the respondent joint venture, GYT – TPL
JV was eligible to bid for a tender invited by the Nagpur Metro Rail
Corporation Limited [NMRCL] for the work of design and construction of a
viaduct between Jhansi Rani Square and Lukamanya Nagar Station on the
East-West Corridor of Nagpur Metro Rail Project. After opening of the
technical bids, the bid of the respondent GYT – TPL JV was disqualified due to
not meeting the eligibility conditions as stipulated in Clause 4.2[a] of Section
III. Clause 4.2[a] prescribed for the bidder’s experience of undertaking one
metro civil construction work for minimum INR 3200 million and in the said
contract-work, the bidder should have completed viaduct length of not less
than 5 km. The respondent GYT – TPL JV claimed such experience in respect
of an Inter-City High Speed Railway Project. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has
observed that there is a qualitative difference between an inter-city railway
project and a metro railway project and also a qualitative difference in the
construction of a viaduct for an inter-city railway project and a metro rail
project which is intra-city. Observing so, the Hon’ble Court did not interfere
Page No. 19/23
with the decision of the NMRCL to disqualify the bid of the respondent GYT –
TPL JV.
31. The decisions in W.B. State Electricity Board [supra]; Central Coalfields
Limited [supra]; and Afcons Infrastructure Limited [supra] have been
considered in Prakash Asphaltings and Toll Highways [India] Limited
[supra]. The legal proposition which has emerged is that a competitive
bidding process offers a fair opportunity to all the bidders to compete for a
project and it affords the authority a choice to select the best of competitors
in a competitive price without prejudice to the quality of the work. While
benefit to the public exchequer is an important criterion in award of contract,
it is also in public interest, a requirement to adhere to the rules and
conditions subject to which bids are invited. The words used in the tender
document cannot be ignored or treated as redundant or superfluous and they
should be given their due meaning and necessary significance. The sanctity of
public tenders and contract is a fundamental principle and there must be
stability, transparency and predictability at all the stages of a competitive
bidding process.
32. The lis in Prakash Asphaltings and Toll Highways [India] Limited [supra]
arose on a challenge made by the respondent no. 1 after the respondent
employer, the State of West Bengal refused to treat the respondent no. 1 as
the highest bidder by permitting it to rectify its financial bid after the bidding
process was over. After the dismissal of the writ petition by the learned Single
Judge, the respondent no. 1 preferred a writ appeal wherein the Division
Bench observed that the error in quoting the figure by the respondent no. 1
was inadvertent. Observing that since the respondent no. 1 had promptly
sought correction of the error immediately after reopening of the price bids,
the Division Bench directed the employer State to evaluate the Bil of Quantity
[BoQ] rate by treating the amount offered by the respondent no. 1 as the per
day amount and then, on that basis to compute the total amount for the
Page No. 20/23
entire contract period of 1095 days. In the price bid, the respondent no. 1
instead of quoting the price for the entire contract period of 1095 days, had
uploaded per day amount of the BoQ. The Hon’ble Supreme Court had set
aside and quashed the Judgment and Order of the Division Bench and
allowed the employer State to proceed with the tender process for finalization
of the award of contract in terms of the notice inviting tender. One of the
legal propositions emerging from the afore-noted decisions is that after the
stage of bid submission, a participant bidder whose technical bid had been
adjudged non-responsive at the stage of technical bid evaluation, cannot be
permitted to plead that its technical bid should be declared responsive on the
basis of any additional documents submitted after the bid submission.
33. Clause 2.1 and Clause 2.2 of the LoI had enumerated the documents which
must be uploaded along with the technical bid. Sub-clause [g] of Clause 2.2
mentioned about an undertaking on stamp paper for providing vehicles in
case of Award of Work. A format for notarized undertaking by the bidder was
prescribed in the Technical Bid of the Bid Document. In Para 4 of the
prescribed format, the bidder had to state and swear that he was neither staff
of NHIDCL nor related to any staff of NHIDCL [Staff such as deputation / on
contractual basis / outsource agencies]. It is not a case of any of the parties
that there was a prescribed form in which the certificate, as indicated in
Clause 2.1 of the NIT, was to be submitted by the bidder along with the
Technical Bid.
34. In the present case, the reason to place the technical bid of the respondent
no. 4 in the disqualified category after opening was cited as ‘want of
certificate that none of the staff of NHIDCL, their relatives, etc. are
participating in the bid’. In Clause 4 of the NIT, it was mentioned that ‘none
of the staff of NHIDCL, their relatives or any of the contractor / vendor /
agencies assigned work / contract in NHIDCL will be considered for bidding
Page No. 21/23
for hiring of vehicles. A certificate in this regard should be furnished by the
bidder along with Technical Bid’.
35. As already found above from the affidavit of the respondent no. 3 that a
notarized undertaking bearing e-stamp dated 02.09.2025 was part of the
Technical Bid of the respondent no. 4 which was uploaded in the GeM portal
on 08.09.2025. The said notarized undertaking dated 02.09.2025 is found to
be in conformity with the format of undertaking prescribed in the Technical
Bid of the Bid Document. The stand of the respondent NHIDCL is to the effect
that the respondent no. 4 was initially placed in the disqualified category for
non-submission of the certificate that none of the staff of the NHIDCL, their
relatives, etc. was participating in the bidding process and on scrutiny of the
Bid Document of the respondent no. 4 by the Evaluation Committee in the
GeM portal and after receipt of the representation, it was found that the
notarized undertaking was uploaded in the form of a notarized undertaking by
the respondent no. 4 in the GeM portal at the time of bid submission itself, a
fact which has also been vouched by the respondent no. 3 in its affidavit.
36. The propositions are settled, as also referred to in the afore-mentioned
decisions, that the decision-making process of the tendering authority in
accepting or rejecting the bid of a tenderer should ordinarily be respected and
interference is permissible only if the decision-making process is mala fide or
is intended to favour someone. A decision of accepting or rejecting a bid of a
tenderer, taken by the tendering authority, is not to be interfered with unless
the decision is found to be of such arbitrary or irrational nature which no
responsible authority acting reasonably and in accordance with law could
have reached. For interference, the decision-making process or the decision
should be perverse and not merely faulty or incorrect or erroneous. A mere
disagreement with the decision-making process of the decision of the
administrative authority is no reason for a constitutional court to interfere.
The constitutional courts are expected to exercise restraint in interfering with
Page No. 22/23
the decision of the tendering authority and ought not to substitute its view as
if it is sitting on it as an appellate authority. The tendering authority having
authored the tender document is the best person to understand and
appreciate its requirements and interpret its documents. The constitutional
courts must defer to the understanding and appreciation of the tender
documents of the tendering authority, unless there is mala fide or perversity
in the understanding or appreciation or in the application of the terms and
conditions of the tender documents. It has been held that it is possible that
the tendering authority may give an interpretation to the tender documents
that is not acceptable to the constitutional courts but that by itself is not a
reason for interfering with the interpretation given.
37. From the stand taken by the tendering authority in the case in hand, it is
found that the tendering authority has accepted that submission of the
notarized undertaking in the prescribed format would fulfill the condition as
regards the certificate mentioned in Clause 2.1 of the NIT. In the absence of
any prescribed format in which the certificate was required to be submitted
and in view of presence of a sworn statement in the notarized undertaking to
the effect that the bidder was neither a staff of NHIDCL nor related to any
staff of NHIDCL, if the tendering authority had accepted that the submission
of the notarized certificate along with the technical bid by the bidder was
sufficient to fulfill the condition then this Court is not to make any endeavour
to reach at a different conclusion and has to defer to such interpretation.
38. From the materials brought on record, as discussed above, it has emerged
that the notarized undertaking bearing e-stamp dated 02.09.2025 was part of
the technical bid uploaded by the respondent no. 4 on 08.09.2025 at the time
of bid submission. Therefore, this Court is of the considered view that the
decision of the tendering authority to transfer the respondent no. 4 from the
disqualified category in which he was placed originally after opening of the
technical bids on 22.10.2025, to the qualified category after completion of the
Page No. 23/23
process of evaluation of the technical bids on 30.10.2025 a decision which
does not for any interference. It is not found that in the process of decisionmaking, the tendering authority had taken into consideration any additional
document received from the respondent no. 4, submitted after the last date
of submission of the bids to arrive at the decision.
39. After the final results of technical bid evaluation were uploaded on
30.10.2025, the financial bids of the four technically responsive bidders were
opened on 30.10.2025. The criteria for financial bid evaluation was through
Least Cost System, that is, the lowest quoted bidder was to be selected. The
respondent no. 4 quoted a bid value of Rs. 5,80,87,008/- to emerge as the
lowest [L-1] bidder as against the bid value quoted by the petitioner at Rs.
6,17,25,600/- to emerge as the L-2 bidder. There is, therefore, no reason for
this Court to accede to the prayer of the petitioner to declare it as the lowest
bidder [L-1] for the finding reached that there is no reason to cancel the bid
of the respondent no. 4.
40. In view of the observations made and the reasons recorded, in the
discussions made above, this Court is of the view that the writ petition is not
merited and the same is liable to be dismissed. It is accordingly ordered. The
interim order stands recalled. The records, if any, placed before the court are
to be returned. There shall, however, be no order as to cost.
Konwar
Date: 2026.03.30 17:21:57 +05'30'
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review