Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Digitally
signed by
ANURADHA
ANURADHA TIWARI
TIWARI
Date:
2026.01.16
17:08:58
+0530
2026:CGHC:2625-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
REVP No. 1 of 2026
M/s Tirupati Minerals Private Limited, Through Its Authorised Signatory,
N.H. 200, Raigarh Road, Champa, District - Janjgir-Champa (C.G.)
... Petitioner
versus
1 - State of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary, Department of Mines And
Minerals, Mahanadi Bhawan, Mantralaya, Naya Raipur, Chhattisgarh
2 - Secretary Department of Housing And Environment, Mahanadi
Bhawan, Mantralaya, Naya Raipur, Chhattisgarh
3 - Member Secretary Chhattisgarh Environment Conservation Board,
Paryavas Bhawan, North Block, Sector - 19, Naya Raipur, Chhattisgarh
4 - Director Directorate of Geology And Mining, Indravati Bhawan,
Mantralaya, Naya Raipur, Chhattisgarh
5 - The Collector And District Magistrate Collectorate Office, Rampur,
District - Korba, Chhattisgarh
6 - Regional Office - Korba, Chhattisgarh Environment Conservation
Board H.I.G. 21 And 22, Near Tehsil Office, Rampur, District - Korba,
Chhattisgarh
7 - Deputy Director (Mining) Department Of Geology And Mining,
Collectorate Office, Rampur, District - Korba, Chhattisgarh (Original
Respondents)
8 - Govind Gour Alias Govind Sharma S/o Late Shri R.N. Gour R/o Flat 402, B-Block, Indrasen Nagar, Mangala, Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh.
(Original Petitioner)
... Respondents
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
For Petitioner
: Mr. Amit Soni, Advocate
For Respondents No.1, : Mr. Shashank Thakur, Additional Advocate
2, 4, 5 and 7
General
For Respondents No.3 : Mr. Animesh Tiwari, Advocate
and 6
For Respondent No.8
: Mr. Kishore Bhaduri, Senior Advocate
assisted by Mr. Harsh Dave, Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Shri Bibhu Datta Guru, Judge
Order on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
16.01.2026
1.
Heard Mr. Amit Soni, learned counsel for the review petitioner.
Also heard Mr. Shashank Thakur, learned Additional Advocate
General, appearing for the State/respondents No.1, 2, 4, 5 & 7,
Mr. Animesh Tiwari, learned counsel appearing for respondents
No.3 & 6 as well as Mr. Kishore Bhaduri, learned Senior Counsel
assisted by Mr. Harsh Dave, learned counsel appearing for
respondent No.8/original writ petitioner.
2.
The present review petition has been filed by the review-petitioner
seeking review/recall of the order dated 31.10.2025 passed by
this Court in Writ Petition (PIL) No. 85 of 2025, with following
prayer :“It is therefore prayed that this Hon'ble Court may
kindly be pleased to allow the instant review
application and order dated 31.10.2025 passed in
WPPIL No. 85/2025 particularly the directions
contained in Paragraph 16 thereof may kindly be
reviewed in larger interest of Justice.”
3.
By the said order, the writ petition was disposed of with the
observation that the respondent authorities shall not permit any
industry to fill the pit with fly ash and that the water body so
formed shall not be disturbed.
4.
Mr. Amit Soni, learned counsel for the review petitioner, submits
that the impugned order dated 31.10.2025 has been passed
under a patent misconception of both facts and the applicable
statutory framework. It is contended that the foundational premise
of the order that a “water body so formed” exists at the Konkona
Ordinary Stone Mine, is demonstrably erroneous. The material
placed on record, including the affidavits filed by respondent No.6,
clearly establishes that mining operations were carried out
pursuant to valid permissions till the period 2023–2024 and that
no permanent or natural water body ever came into existence. At
best, the pit had accumulated rainwater on account of cessation
of operations, which cannot, in law or in fact, be equated with a
protected water body.
5.
Mr. Soni further submits that the operative and binding Quarry
Closure Plan of 2024, approved by the competent statutory
authority, namely the State Environment Impact Assessment
Authority (‘SEIAA’), Chhattisgarh, mandates reclamation of the
mined area by filling the mine pit with fly ash, thereafter covering it
with top soil and undertaking plantation. This statutory obligation
has overriding force and supersedes the earlier closure plan of
2016, which stood exhausted and rendered otiose after the grant
of subsequent mining permissions. Therefore, the direction
restraining fly ash filling is in direct conflict with the approved
closure plan and frustrates the object of scientifically reclaiming
the abandoned mine in accordance with environmental norms.
6.
It is contended by Mr. Soni that the review petitioner is a
necessary and proper party to the proceedings, being the primary
executing agency engaged for transportation and filling of fly ash
under valid work orders and permissions issued by the concerned
authorities.
The
impugned
directions
have
the
effect
of
permanently stalling the lawful business operations of the review
petitioner and imposing serious financial and commercial
prejudice, despite the petitioner not having been impleaded in the
writ petition nor afforded any opportunity of being heard. Such an
order, having grave civil consequences, is in clear violation of the
principles of natural justice, particularly audi alteram partem.
7.
It is further contended by Mr. Soni that the direction issued by this
Court effectively operates as a blanket and perpetual injunction
against the respondent authorities, compelling them to act
contrary to the statutory mining and environmental regime, without
there being a full and final adjudication on the inter se validity of
the competing quarry closure plans. The failure to consider the
rationale and legal effect of the subsequent closure plan,
prepared
and
approved
after
fresh
mining
permissions,
constitutes an error apparent on the face of the record. It is,
therefore, urged that the impugned order, to the extent it restrains
fly ash filling by proceeding on an incorrect factual premise and by
overlooking binding statutory material already on record, warrants
review and recall in the interest of justice, equity, and to prevent
manifest injustice to the review petitioner.
8.
On the other hand, Mr. Animesh Tiwari, learned counsel appearing
for respondents No. 3 and 6, fairly submits that pursuant to
paragraph 16 of the impugned order dated 31.10.2025 passed by
this Court, the work order granted in favour of the review
petitioner has been cancelled by the competent authorities in
obedience to and in compliance with the directions contained
therein. He further submits that, in view of the said judicial
direction, the respondent authorities had no discretion but to
discontinue the work relating to fly ash filling at the mine site.
9.
Mr. Tiwari contends that at this stage he is not in a position to
justify or continue the said work order contrary to the directions of
this Court. However, it is fairly conceded that the petitioner may
be permitted to submit a fresh and comprehensive representation
before the competent authorities, particularly before respondent
No. 6, raising all permissible grounds in support of its claim. It is
submitted that, in the event such a representation is filed, the
same may be considered and decided independently by the
concerned authority in accordance with law, strictly keeping in
view the applicable environmental statutes, rules, and regulatory
guidelines, as well as the environmental impact of the proposed
activity.
10.
Mr. Tiwari assures the Court that such representation, if filed, shall
be examined objectively and expeditiously, without being
influenced by any earlier order, and a reasoned decision shall be
taken on its own merits, balancing environmental considerations
with the statutory framework governing mine reclamation and fly
ash utilization.
11.
Mr. Shashank Thakur, learned Additional Advocate General,
appearing on behalf of the State as well as Mr. Kishore Bhaduri,
learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr. Harsh Dave, learned
counsel appearing for the original writ petitioner/respondent No.8
jointly submit that they have no objection in case the impugned
order dated 31.10.2025 is suitably modified, clarified, or reviewed
to the limited extent of the present review petitioner alone. It is
fairly stated that such modification may be confined to protecting
and adjudicating the rights of the review petitioner without
affecting the operation of the order vis-à-vis other parties or the
general issues raised in the public interest litigation.
12.
It is further submitted that the State and the original writ petitioner
would not oppose a limited interference by this Court, if deemed
appropriate, so as to enable the review petitioner to pursue its
remedy in accordance with law, subject to environmental
safeguards, statutory rules, and applicable guidelines, and without
diluting the environmental concerns underlying the original writ
proceedings.
13.
We have heard learned counsel appearing for the parties and
perused the impugned order under review.
14.
This Court while deciding the public interest litigation being Writ
Petition (PIL) No.85/2025, has passed the following order, by
observing as follows :“13. The primary grievance of the petitioner was
that the pit formed by mining of the stones should
not be used for filling up the fly ash but since
there existed a huge water body since 2019, the
same should be left as a water body only. From
the above affidavit filed by the Regional Officer,
CECB, it appears that at this stage, the grievance
raised by the petitioner has been redressed as no
dumping of fly ash is being done by any of the
industries.
14 Mr. Bhaduri, learned Senior Advocate for the
petitioner contends that though the dumping of fly
ash has been stopped, but when dumping may
start again, cannot be ruled out and as such, the
respondent authorities may be directed to restrain
any of the industries to dump fly ash in the area in
question and the mining pit should remain a water
body for ever.
15 On the above submission, Mr. Tiwari submits
that the mine has been closed long ago and as
per the earlier closure plan, the same was to be
filled by the fly ash but if any changes has to be
made in the mine closure plan with respect to the
use of the pit, that can be done only by the State
Environmental Impact Assessment Authority (for
short, the SEIAA) and not the CECB.
16 In view of the above submission, we hereby
dispose of this petition with a hope and trust that
the respondent authorities would not permit any
industries to fill the pit with fly ash and the water
body so formed shall not be disturbed. In case,
the petitioner has still any grievance, he may take
recourse
to
the
appropriate
authority
in
accordance with law.”
15.
Having given our thoughtful consideration to the rival submissions
and upon a careful perusal of the impugned order sought to be
reviewed, the pleadings on record, and the affidavits filed by the
respondent authorities, we are of the considered opinion that the
present review petition deserves to be partly allowed to a limited
extent, strictly confining the relief to the review petitioner alone.
16.
It is evident from the record that while disposing of Writ Petition
(PIL) No.85/2025, this Court proceeded on the premise that a
“water body so formed” existed in the mining pit and, on such
premise, issued the observation contained in paragraph 16 of the
order dated 31.10.2025. However, the material subsequently
brought to the notice of this Court, particularly the affidavits filed
by respondent No.6, prima facie indicate that the mining
operations at Konkona Ordinary Stone Mine continued pursuant
to valid permissions till the year 2023–2024 and that the pit had
merely accumulated rainwater after cessation of mining activity.
Whether such accumulation of water constitutes a permanent
water body and whether the mine pit is required to be reclaimed
by fly ash filling, as mandated under the approved Quarry Closure
Plan of 2024, are issues which necessarily require consideration
by the competent statutory authority under the applicable
environmental and mining regulations.
17.
This Court also takes note of the fact that the review petitioner,
though directly affected by the directions contained in paragraph
16 of the order dated 31.10.2025, was not a party to the original
writ proceedings. The impugned observation has resulted in
cancellation of the work order issued in favour of the review
petitioner and has serious civil and commercial ramifications. In
such circumstances, the ends of justice would be subserved if the
review petitioner is afforded an effective opportunity to place its
case before the competent authority for an appropriate decision in
accordance with law.
18.
It is equally significant that the learned State counsel as well as
the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the original writ
petitioner have fairly stated before this Court that they have no
objection if the impugned order is suitably modified or clarified to
the limited extent of the present review petitioner, without
disturbing the order in its application to other parties or the
broader issues involved in the public interest litigation.
19.
In view of the above, and without expressing any opinion on the
merits of the rival claims, this Court is inclined to clarify and
modify the order dated 31.10.2025 to the extent that the
observation contained in paragraph 16 thereof shall not come in
the way of the review petitioner from submitting a fresh, detailed,
and comprehensive representation before respondent No.6. The
said representation may raise all permissible grounds available to
the review petitioner under law, including reliance upon the
approved Quarry Closure Plan of 2024, the environmental
clearances granted, and the guidelines governing reclamation of
abandoned mines and utilization of fly ash.
20.
In turn, respondent No.6 is accordingly directed that, in the event
such a representation is filed by the review petitioner within a
reasonable time, the same shall be considered and decided
independently, objectively, and expeditiously, in accordance with
law, keeping in view the applicable environmental statutes, rules,
notifications, and guidelines, as well as the environmental impact
of the proposed activity. While deciding the representation,
respondent No.6 shall not be influenced by the observations
made in paragraph 16 of the order dated 31.10.2025 and shall
pass a reasoned order after due application of mind.
21.
It is clarified that this limited modification/clarification is granted
only in favour of the present review petitioner and shall not affect
the operation of the order dated 31.10.2025 in respect of other
parties or the general issues raised in Writ Petition (PIL)
No.85/2025, nor shall it be construed as a dilution of the
environmental concerns underlying the public interest litigation.
22.
With the aforesaid observations and directions, the instant review
petition stands disposed of to the limited extent indicated above.
Sd/(Bibhu Datta Guru)
Judge
Anu
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review