Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/31
GAHC010285292023
2026:GAU-AS:2427
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/7345/2023
M/S TINSUKIA DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION
A PUBLIC LIMITED COMPANY
INCORPORATED UNDER THE PROVISIONS OF THE COMPANIES ACT, 1913,
HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE AT A.T. ROAD,
TINSUKIA TOWN, P.O. AND P.S.- TINSUKIA,
DISTRICT- TINSUKIA, ASSAM,
REPRESENTED BY ITS AUTHORISED REPRESENTATIVE AND
CONSTITUTED ATTORNEY,
SRI SANJAY AGARWAL, AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS,
SON OF SRI BIJAY AGARWAL,
RESIDENT OF A.T. ROAD, P.O. AND DIST.- TINSUKIA,
ASSAM( 786125).
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 2 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM,
TOWN AND COUNTRY PLANNING DEPARTMENT,
DISPUR, GUWAHATI- 781006.
2:THE TINSUKIA MUNICIPAL BOARD
REPRESENTED BY ITS CHAIRMAN
GNB ROAD
P.O.
P.S. AND DIST.- TINSUKIA
ASSAM
PIN- 786125.
3:THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER
TINSUKIA MUNICIPAL BOARD
Page No.# 2/31
P.O.
P.S. AND DISTRICT- TINSUKIA
ASSAM
PIN- 786125.
4:SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM
DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND URBAN AFFAIRS
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-6
5:THE DIRECTOR
MUNICIPAL ADMINISTRATION
ASSAM
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DEVASHIS BARUAH
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. B. Dutta, Sr. Advocate
Mr. S. Deka, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. S.R. Baruah, Jr. Govt. Advocate
Mr. S.S. Roy, Standing Counsel
Date on which judgment was reserved : 20.01.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 18.02.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
Operative part of the judgment?
: NA
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
: Yes
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. B. Dutta, the learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr. S.
Page No.# 3/31
Deka, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner. Mr.
S.R. Baruah, the learned Junior Government Advocate appears on
behalf of the respondent No. 1 and Mr. S.S. Roy, the learned Standing
Counsel appears on behalf of the respondent Nos. 2 and 3.
2.
The petitioner herein has approached this Court challenging the
Notification bearing No. TMB/TD/TAX/2023-24/209 dated 03.05.2023
(hereinafter referred to as “the impugned Notification”) issued by the
respondent No. 3 as well as the reassessment and fixation of
municipal taxes on the basis of the impugned Notification and in the
interim has sought for a direction that the impugned Notification be
stayed and/or the respondents be directed not to take any coercive
measures against the petitioner.
BRIEF FACTS OF THE CASE
3.
The petitioner admittedly is the owner of various properties and
in that regard had obtained 136 holding numbers which were
assessed by the Tinsukia Municipal Board i.e. the respondent No. 2
(hereinafter referred to as, “the Respondent Board”).
4.
The grievance of the petitioner herein is that the respondent Nos.
2 and 3 have unreasonably and exorbitantly increased the annual
value of the holdings without following the mandate of the provisions
of the Assam Municipal Act, 1956 (for short, “the Act of 1956”). It is
Page No.# 4/31
also the grievance of the petitioner that the Respondent Board has
imposed the tax, namely the Urban tax at the rate of 3%, which was
not permissible in terms with the Act of 1956, more so, upon the
Assam Urban Immovable Property Tax Act, 1969 being repealed by
the Assam Repealing Act, 2022, which came into effect on
07.10.2022.
5.
It is alleged that in the month of February 2023, the respondent
No. 3 had issued a Notice dated 20.02.2023 whereby the citizens
were intimated that a draft reassessment list with new rates of the
Respondent Board has been published thereby inviting citizens to
submit their claims and objections, if any, w.e.f. 21.02.2023 to
20.03.2023. It was also mentioned in the said Notice that the claims
shall be heard by the designated officer of the Respondent Board and
the final assessment list shall be sent to the Government for review as
provided under Section 79-E of the Act of 1956.
6.
The petitioner alleges that the said Notification was not widely
published and it was only affixed to the Notice Board of the
Respondent
Board.
Resultantly,
the
petitioner
being
unaware
submitted a representation on 10.03.2023 requesting the Respondent
Board to increase the time limit to 90 days from 30 days for filing
claims/objections, and further to provide a copy of the draft
reassessment list for the Ward Nos. 3, 4, 10, 11, 12, 13, and 15 of the
Page No.# 5/31
Respondent Board for verification and to submit the claims and
objections. It is the case of the petitioner that the Respondent Board
did not consider the said request, for which, the petitioner again
made a request vide a communication dated 28.03.2023.
7.
The petitioner further alleges that the Respondent Board, without
providing the draft reassessment list, issued several notices to the
petitioner in respect to the different holdings, including the notice
dated 21.04.2023, whereby it was intimated to the petitioner that the
Holding Taxes of the Respondent Board have been reassessed, and
the newly assessed Holding Tax would be effective from 01.04.2023,
and that from the financial year 2023-24, Holding Tax can be paid
digitally.
8.
The petitioner vide a communication dated 03.11.2023 requested
the
Respondent
Board
to
provide
the
detailed
calculation
method/formula along with other factors which have been considered
for calculation of the municipal tax. The petitioner thereupon received
an e-mail on 24.11.2023 from the Respondent Board whereby the
new tax calculation formula was provided to the petitioner. The
petitioner alleges that in spite of the communications submitted by
the petitioner, without providing the draft reassessment list and
conducting any proper verification by affording public hearing, the
impugned Notification was issued on 03.05.2023, notifying the final
Page No.# 6/31
assessment of the Holding Tax. The petitioner had denied that there
was any public meeting held on 29.04.2023 as mentioned in the
impugned Notification dated 03.05.2023. The petitioner was also
issued a demand notice on 11.12.2023.
9.
It is also alleged by the petitioner that the Holding Tax was
enhanced in the various Wards of the Respondent Board ranging from
197% to 6,349% which under no circumstances can be said to be
reasonable, rational, and acceptable by the public, including the
petitioner. The petitioner further has alleged that apart from revising
the annual value of the holding, the respondents have also imposed
an Urban Tax which the Respondent Board cannot realize in view of
the repealing of the Assam Urban Immovable Property Tax Act, 1969,
by the Assam Repealing Act, 2022.
10. On the basis of the above, the instant writ petition was filed, and
this Court vide an order dated 18.12.2023 issued notice, but was not
inclined to pass any interim order. However, vide an order dated
24.02.2025, this Court directed that no coercive steps be taken
against the petitioner. The said interim order has been extended from
time to time.
11.
It is also relevant to take note of that the petitioner had filed 2
(two) additional affidavits in the instant proceedings. In the additional
affidavit filed on 24.07.2024, the petitioner brought on record a
Page No.# 7/31
communication dated 10.03.2023 issued by the Joint Secretary to the
Government of Assam and i/c Municipal Reform Cell, Department of
Housing and Urban Affairs, wherein emphasis was placed upon Clause
5 of the said communication, wherein it was stipulated as under:
“5.
Rebate can be given to public so that the effective increase to the final property
tax rate shall not be more than 25% of the last property tax collected depending upon
the local conditions and requirements.”
12.
It was the contention of the petitioner on the basis of the said
communication dated 10.03.2023 that the determination of the annual
value of the holdings by the Respondent Board is not only contrary to
the said communication, but also unreasonable and exorbitant.
13.
The second additional affidavit was filed by the petitioner on
06.02.2025, wherein the petitioner raised the issue that the
respondent Nos. 2 and 3 had exceeded their jurisdiction and have
arbitrarily reassessed and fixed the municipal taxes without any
statutory authority or sanction in law, and that the impugned
Notification was contrary to the communication dated 10.03.2023.
The petitioner had also brought on record a bill dated 09.12.2024,
issued by the Chairman of the Respondent Board wherein an amount
of Rs. 18,93,738.86/- was demanded from the petitioner.
STAND TAKEN BY THE RESPONDENTS
14.
The record reveals that the respondent Nos. 2 and 3 filed an
Page No.# 8/31
affidavit-in-opposition through its Chairman. A perusal of the said
affidavit-in-opposition reveals that since 1975-76, the annual value of
the holdings have not been assessed. A Notification was issued by the
Commissioner and Secretary, Department of Housing and Urban
Affairs, Government of Assam, dated 28.06.2022, wherein taking into
consideration the 15th Finance Commission's recommendation in its
report for 2021-26, the urban local bodies were required to notify
floor rates of property taxes and collection has to be in tandem with
the growth rate of the State-owned GSDP growth and under such
circumstances, in terms with the said Notification dated 28.06.2022 all
Municipal Boards, (barring those whose last general assessment have
not yet completed 5 years) in Assam were directed to carry out the
exercise of revision of annual value of the holdings and prepare fresh
assessment lists as per the procedure prescribed under Section 79-A,
79-B, 79-C, 79-D, and 79-E of the Act of 1956. The operational part of
the said Notification being relevant is reproduced herein under:
“It is instructed that all the Municipal Boards (barring those whose last general
assessment has not yet completed five years) in Assam shall carry out the exercise of
revision of Annual Value of holdings and prepare fresh assessment lists as per
procedures prescribed under Section 79-A, 79-B, 79- C, 79-D and 79 E of the Assam
Municipal Act, 1956. While doing the exercise, the Municipal Boards will follow the
following steps namely:(1) Classification of holdings as per situation.
Page No.# 9/31
(2) Calculation of Carpet area as per Section 79-C.
(3) Fixation of annual rental value and Annual value, while doing so the value
will be arrived with reference to latest zonal value of land and for value of
building the latest CPWD Schedule of Rates may be consulted in so far as
these relates to buildings. The Boards are at liberty to fix a justified percentage
over the PWD SOR
(4) Determination of rates of tax as per Section 79-D.
(5)
The exercise will be done as per approval of the Committee constituted
under Section 79-A(5) of the Act with Deputy Commissioner as Chairman.
(6) The Chairman of the committee can requisition staff, as may be required,
from other Departments for the purpose of this exercise.
The rate of Tax determined shall be published by respective Municipal Board by issuing
a public notice. A list of holdings shall be prepared based on the exercise which will
also be published for information of Tax Payers by December 3 2022,
The assessment so made shall be valid for a period of 5 years and shall be
revised every five years under Section 79.P. There would be continuous updating of
the holdings based on future revision of land value and value of holdings.”
15.
It further appears from the said affidavit-in-opposition that on
the basis of the said Notification dated 28.06.2022, certain operational
guidelines were also notified for revision of the property tax by the
Urban Local Bodies. Immediately thereafter, on 30.06.2022, the
Director, Municipal Administration, Assam had issued a communication
to all Chairperson/Executive Officer of the Municipal Boards informing
as regards the training program on assessment/reassessment of
Page No.# 10/31
property tax of Urban Local Boards to the Master Trainers of the
District Headquarter of the Urban Local Bodies which were completed
successfully on 27.06.2022 and 28.06.2022.
16.
On 16.07.2022, another Notification was issued by the
Commissioner
and
Secretary
to
the
Government
of
Assam,
Department of Housing and Urban Affairs stipulating the timelines for
implementation of the various stages for revision of the assessment of
property taxes in the Urban Local Body/Municipal Board areas and for
strict
adherence
by
the
concerned
District
Level
Committee
constituted and the Municipal Boards. The timeline so provided in the
said Notification is given in a chart which is reproduced herein under:
Sl. No
Action point
Timeline
Notification of one ADC as Nodal Officer 25th July, 2022
for Municipal Reforms related works.
1st meeting of District Level Committee 25th July, 2022
Notification of Principal Main Road, 5th August, 2022
Main Road and other Road
Notice for Self-Assessment by Municipal 10th August, 2022
Boards
Self-Assessment by public
10th
August
to
10th
September, 2022
Assessment/Re-assessment by Ward- 10th
September-15th
Page No.# 11/31
wise teams
November, 2022
Publication of Draft Assessment List
20th November, 2022
Notice for Claims and Objections on 20th November, 2022
Assessment of property tax
Disposal of claims and objections
20th November to 20th
December, 2022
Notice
of
publication
of
final 31st November, 2022
assessment list
17.
From the affidavit-in-opposition, it further reveals that pursuant
to the Government Notification dated 28.06.2022, as per Section 79A(5) of the Act of 1956, a District Level Committee was constituted in
respect to Tinsukia District under the Chairmanship of the Deputy
Commissioner, Tinsukia along with various members. This order was
passed by the Deputy Commissioner, Tinsukia on 06.07.2022 and the
compositions of the said District Level Committee were:
1.
The Deputy Commissioner, Tinsukia- Chairman.
2.
The Chairman, Tinsukia Municipal Board, Tinsukia-Member.
3.
The Circle Officer, Tinsukia Revenue Circle, TinsukiaMember.
4.
The Executive Engineer, PWD, Tinsukia/Doomdooma/Sadiya
Page No.# 12/31
Territorial Road Division, Tinsukia- Member
5.
The Executive Engineer, PWD (Building) Tinsukia Territorial
Division, Tinsukia- Member
6.
The Executive Engineer, Town & Country Planning, TinsukiaMember
7.
The Vice-Chairman, Tinsukia Municipal board, TinsukiaMember Secy.
18.
At this stage, this Court finds it very pertinent to take note of
Section 79-A(5) of the Act of 1956, which stipulates that subject to
the approval of the Committee, a Municipality may from time to time
publish the list of Principal Main Roads and the Main Roads and if
necessary modify the list as may be decided by the Committee.
19.
The Committee which was constituted by the Deputy
Commissioner, Tinsukia vide the order dated 06.07.2022 had issued a
Notice on 05.08.2022 informing all concerned that in terms with the
provisions of Section 79-A(5) of the Act of 1956, and with the due
approval from the Committee constituted under the said Section, the
various roads under the Respondent Board were classified as Principal
Main Roads and Main Roads for the purpose of classification of the
holdings under the provisions of Section 79A-(2) of the Act of 1956. It
was also mentioned that all other roads not listed in the two classes,
Page No.# 13/31
i.e., Principal Main Roads and Main Roads, shall be treated as other
roads.
Further
to
that,
the
Notice
also
stipulated
that
all
owners/occupiers of all the holdings within the Respondent Board to
furnish returns with all the details as required as per the format
available in the Office of the Respondent Board under the provisions
of Section 77 of the Act of 1956 and declare their holdings for the
purpose of determining the annual value of the holding not later than
10.09.2022. It was also mentioned that those owners who fail to
comply and file their returns shall attract the penalty and other
consequences as per the provisions of Section 77(3) and Section
77(4) of the Act of 1956.
20.
Annexure-9 to the affidavit-in-opposition shows that the District
Information and Public Relation Officer, Tinsukia was intimated vide a
communication dated 08.08.2022 by the respondent No. 3 for
publishing the Notification dated 05.08.2022 in two daily newspapers
i.e. the Assam Tribune, Dainik Janambhumi, and Dainik Purbudoy
(Hindi) at an early date. The said Notification dated 05.08.2022 was
accordingly published in the said newspapers.
21.
The record further reveals that the Commissioner and Secretary
to the Government of Assam, Housing and Urban Affairs Department
had issued an Office Memorandum dated 06.02.2023 wherein certain
points were directed to be considered by the Urban Local Bodies
Page No.# 14/31
during the exercise of fixation of the new rate of taxes of the
properties. Clauses 1 to 8 of the said Office Memorandum being
relevant are reproduced herein under:
“1.
The existing Zonal Value of Land and CPWD Schedule of Rates (DSR) are to be
considered for calculation of Annual Rental Value (ARV). The Boards are at
liberty to justify a fixed percentage of subsidy over the total value of land and
building.
2.
To determine the Annual Rental Value (ARV) of the property, the Boards will
follow the formula fixed in the earlier "Assam Urban Areas Rent Control Act,
1972 i.e. 7.5% of the total Value of Land and Building. The Board may however
fix ARV lower or higher than the value of 7.5% of the land and building value
on justified grounds. The Boards may determine the rental value for categories
of buildings u/s 79-C of the Assam Municipal Act, 1956.
3.
The new rate of taxes shall be determined by the concerned Municipal Board in
consultation with relevant stake holder/ local representative and the operational
guidelines issued vide UDD(M) 136/2022/18 Dtd. 28-06-2022. While fixing the
rate of taxes, the Municipal Boards shall consider the need for augmentation of
resources to bridge the deficit. The new rate of taxes shall be published by
respective Municipal Boards by issuing public notice u/s 79-F of the Assam
Municipal Act, 1956.
4.
The Municipal Boards shall publish the draft Assessment List with revised
valuation of properties for claims & objections. The list shall include details of
property captured during the assessment such as Name of Property Holder,
Name & Type of Road, Plot area, plinth area, number of floors, type of
construction, Use of the Building, Tax payable etc.
5.
The citizens shall be offered a period of one month to lodge their claims &
objections as provided u/s 83 of the Act. Claims so received shall be heard by
Page No.# 15/31
the officers as may be nominated by the respective Municipal Boards. After
disposal of claims & Objections the final assessment list shall be sent to Govt.
for review as provided u/s 79-E of Assam Municipal Act, 1956.
6.
After review of the Govt., in accordance with the provisions of the Assam
Municipal Act, 1956, the Municipal Board shall publish the final Assessment list
by issuing a public notice.
7.
The new rate of taxes shall come into force from 01-04-2023, which shall
remain valid for a period of five years, i.e. till 31-03-2028.
8.
22.
The entire exercise has to be completed within 20-03-2023.”
At this stage, it may be pertinent to take note of that in
pursuance to the communication dated 05.08.2022, the petitioner
submitted its self-declaration as would be seen from Annexure-R13 to
the affidavit-in-opposition. It is also very pertinent to take note of that
at paragraph No. 4 of the affidavit-in-opposition, the Respondent
Board had stated that the property tax has been calculated as per the
Proposed Tax Calculator from the dedicated portal under the
Directorate of Municipal Administration, Government of Assam and the
details have been given in Annexure-R2 to the said affidavit-inopposition.
23.
The records further reveals that the draft reassessment list was
published on 20.02.2023. It is also stated that the public meeting was
convened on 29.04.2023 and thereupon on 03.05.2023, the impugned
Notification was issued.
Page No.# 16/31
24.
No affidavit-in-reply was filed against the said affidavit-in-
opposition.
SUBMISSIONS
MADE
ON
BEHALF
OF
THE
LEARNED
COUNSELS FOR THE PARTIES.
25.
Mr. B. Dutta, the learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of
the petitioner submitted that the manner in which the annual rental
value of the holdings has been assessed is unreasonable and
exorbitant. In that regard, the learned Senior Counsel drew the
attention of this Court to the chart at paragraph No. 14 of the writ
petition and submitted that the enhanced rate in the various Wards
under the Respondent Board has been enhanced by 197% to 6,349%.
The learned Senior Counsel submitted that there is no basis in that
regard. The learned Senior Counsel further submitted that the annual
value of the holding has not been arrived at in terms with Section 79
and 79A of the Act of 1956, inasmuch as the approval of the
Committee which was constituted in terms with the Notification dated
06.07.2022 was not taken. The learned Senior Counsel therefore
submitted that when the statute mandates that the procedure for
fixation of the annual value of the holding is to be carried out in a
particular manner, the same must be done in that manner or not at
all.
26.
The learned Senior Counsel further drawing the attention to
Page No.# 17/31
Section 68 of the Act of 1956 submitted that the Respondent Board is
empowered to impose within the limits of the said Board, the various
taxes, fees, and tolls. Drawing the attention of this Court to Clauses
(a) to (o) of Sub-Section 1 of Section 68 of the Act of 1956, the
learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner submitted that the Urban Tax
cannot be imposed upon under the provisions of the Act of 1956.
27. The learned Senior Counsel drawing the attention of this Court to
Section 79-F of the Act of 1956 submitted that the rate of tax
determined in accordance with the provisions of the Act has to be
published by issuance of a public notice within a period of 3 months
from the date of coming into effect of the Assam Municipal
(Amendment) Act, 2012. The learned Senior Counsel further
submitted that this determination shall be valid for a period of 5 years
and upon expiration of the said 5 years, new determination of rate of
taxes shall take place and shall be published in the same manner as
stipulated in Section 79-F of the Act of 1956.
28. The learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner also submitted that
steps have been taken for fixation of the rate of tax in the year 2022
without issuance of a public notice as is required under Section 79(ii)
of the Act of 1956, which stipulates that the publication of such notice
shall be in one vernacular and in one English daily newspaper
predominantly in circulation in the notified area of the Municipality.
Page No.# 18/31
The learned Senior Counsel therefore submitted that in absence of the
said being not done, the fixation of the Annual Value of the Holdings
is not permissible.
29. The learned Senior Counsel further submitted that though Urban
Tax was earlier realized, the same was realized in terms with the
Assam Urban Immovable Property Tax Act, 1969. The said Act was
repealed by the Assam Repealing Act, 2022, and under such
circumstances, the question of imposition of Urban Tax does not arise.
It is under such circumstances, the learned Senior Counsel submitted
that as the impugned Notification dated 03.05.2023 is contrary to the
Act of 1956 as well as the Assam Repealing Act, 2022, the same is
required to be interfered with.
30.
In addition to above, the learned Senior Counsel submitted that
the fixation of the annual value of the holding being unreasonable,
irrational, and exorbitant the same does not satisfy the mandate of
Article 14 of the Constitution of India, and as such, the same is
required to be interfered with.
31.
It is also the submission of the learned Senior Counsel that the
various demands so made by the Respondent Authorities, more
particularly, the demand notice dated 09.12.2024 is required to be
interfered with.
Page No.# 19/31
32.
Further to the above, the learned Senior Counsel also referring
to the communication dated 10.03.2023 issued by the Joint Secretary
to the Government of Assam, i/c Municipal Reform Cell, submitted
that the final property tax rate cannot exceed more than 25% of the
last property tax collected and it being a direction from the
Government of Assam, the Respondent Board is bound by the said
communication dated 10.03.2023.
33. Per contra, Mr. S.S. Roy, the learned Standing Counsel appearing
on behalf of the respondent Nos. 2 and 3 submitted that since 197576 there was no reassessment to the annual value of the holding,
though the value of the land as well as the buildings have increased
manifold. The learned Standing Counsel drawing the attention of this
Court to paragraph No. 16 of the affidavit-in-opposition submitted that
the enhancement of the annual value of the holdings of the petitioner
is quite obvious in consideration of the revised land values by the
State Revenue Department as well as the alteration and modification
in the nature of the construction of the petitioner’s property which the
petitioner had willfully concealed. The learned Standing Counsel
referred to the chart to paragraph No. 16 of the affidavit-in-opposition
and submitted that out of 136 holdings of the petitioner, 61 holdings
were assessed less than Rs. 50/- per quarter which is to say around
50% of their property were under Rs. 50/- per quarter, though those
properties are situated in the prime locations of Tinsukia.
Page No.# 20/31
34.
The learned Standing Counsel for the respondent Nos. 2 and 3
submitted that the annual value of the holdings have been assessed in
terms with the Office Memorandum dated 06.02.2023 which stipulates
that the existing zonal value of the land and the CPWD Schedule of
Rates are to be considered for calculation of the Annual Rental Value
(ARV). In addition to that, the learned Standing Counsel has also
referred to Annexure-R-2, wherein the calculation is provided in the
dedicated portal under the Directorate of Municipal Administration. He
therefore submitted that taking into account that for the last 48 years
there has been no reassessment of the annual value of the holdings,
it cannot be said that the enhancement which has been made is
unreasonable, irrational or exorbitant.
35.
The learned Standing Counsel for the respondent Nos. 2 and 3
submitted that the revision of the annual rental value of the holdings
was recommended by the 15th Finance Commission as well as the
directions issued by the Government of Assam vide the Notification
dated 28.06.2022. The learned Standing Counsel further referring to
the Notification dated 28.06.2022 as well as the operational guidelines
enclosed therein submitted that each of the steps as given in the
operational guidelines have been adhered to. Further to that, the
learned Standing Counsel also referred to the Notification dated
16.07.2022 and the timeline prescribed therein. In addition to that,
Page No.# 21/31
the learned Standing Counsel further referring to the order dated
06.07.2022 submitted that the District Level Committee was
constituted in terms with Section 79-A(5) of the Act of 1956 and the
said Committee duly approved the various roads under the
Respondent Board by classifying them as Principal Main Roads and
Main Roads as well as other roads. He therefore submitted that the
submissions so made by the learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner
that there was no approval of the Committee so constituted in terms
of Section 79-A(5) of the Act of 1956 does not hold water in view of
the Notice dated 05.08.2022. He further submitted that the draft
reassessment lists of the holdings were prepared and the same were
duly published calling for objections and upon conducting a public
hearing on 29.04.2023, the Assessment list was published vide the
impugned Notification dated 03.05.2023.
36.
The learned Standing Counsel for the respondent Nos. 2 and 3
also submitted that prior to the revision being carried out vide the
impugned Notification dated 03.05.2023, the rate of property tax was
14% on the annual value which included house tax at 6% on annual
value, latrine tax at 3% on annual value, light tax at 2% on annual
value and Urban Tax at 3% on the annual value. He further submitted
that pursuant to the 4th Board's General Meeting held on 01.03.2023,
the tax has been simplified inasmuch as the Respondent Board
Page No.# 22/31
abolished the house tax at 6%, latrine tax at 3%, and light tax at 2%,
and in total imposed a total property tax of 6% on the annual value
which consists of Holding Tax at 3% on annual value and Urban Tax at
3% on the annual value. The learned Standing Counsel therefore
submitted that it is not for the first time that the Urban Tax has been
imposed, and the Urban Tax was earlier also imposed, and the
petitioner had duly paid the same, and therefore the petitioner now
cannot raise an objection as regards the imposition of the Urban Tax.
37.
The learned Standing Counsel further submitted that the instant
writ petition is an abuse of the process of the Court and in order to
not make payment of the dues to which the petitioner is liable to, the
instant writ petition has been filed. It is under such circumstances, the
learned Standing Counsel submitted that the instant writ petition
should be dismissed with exemplary costs.
ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION.
38. The Court has heard the learned counsels appearing on behalf of
the parties and has given an anxious consideration to the materials on
record including the records which were produced before this Court.
39. At the outset, it is very pertinent to take note of that during the
course of the hearing, an instruction was placed by Mr. S.R. Baruah,
the learned Junior Government Advocate, which was issued by the
Page No.# 23/31
Secretary to the Government of Assam, Department of Housing and
Urban Affairs. This instruction is kept on record and marked with the
letter “X”. The instruction which kept on record and marked with the
letter “X” is of importance as it encloses the Minutes of the Meeting
held on 21.08.2025 at 1:30 PM in the office chamber of the Secretary
to the Government of Assam, Department of Housing and Urban
Affairs. In these Minutes, a discussion took place as regards
communication dated 10.03.2023 upon which the petitioner places
reliance by way of the additional affidavits. The Minutes of the
Meeting, more particularly, the contents of the Minutes of the Meeting
are relevant, and as such, the same is reproduced herein under:
“Minutes of the meeting held on 21/08/2025 at 1:30 PM in the office chamber of Shri
Richand Ahmed, Secretary to the Government of Assam, DoHUA regarding Order No.
DMA.162/2022/143 dated 10th March, 2023.
Members present: As per Annexure-A
The meeting was chaired by Secretary to the Govt. of Assam, DoHUA. He
welcomed the members present, Director, Municipal Administration, Assam explained
the purpose of the meeting.
The agenda of the meeting was to clarify the matter regarding the aforesaid
Order, in pursuance of the order dated 16 th July, 2025, passed in WP(C) 7345/2023
(M/S Tinsukia Development Corporation Ltd. vs. The State of Assam & Ors) in
continuation of the previous meeting held on 7th August, 2025.
The Executive Officer, Dr. Nayan Jyoti Nath, attended the meeting in
representation of Tinsukia Municipal Board, since the petitioner is a Tinsukia-based
Page No.# 24/31
company and the dispute is connected therewith. Dr Nayan Jyoti Nath explained that
the petitioner has filed the instant Writ Petition regarding the property tax
reassessment by the Tinsukia Municipal Board in 2023. The petitioner assailed in their
petition that the tax enhancement by reassessment is exorbitant and arbitrary and
enhanced contrary to the provisions of the above order dated 10.03.2023 on point 5 of
the order provides which slates that "Rebate can be given to the public so that the
effective increase to the final property tax rate shall not be than 25% of the last
property collected, depending upon the local conditions and requirements."
The matter was discussed at length and after a threadbare discussion, it was
observed that the reading of the impugned order is ambiguous in relation to the rest
of the contents of the said order.
1. The ambiguity in the impugned Notification shall be dealt with by repeal/revocation
or by issuing a corrigendum in this regard.
2. Point 5 in the order No. DMA.162/2022/143 dated 10th March 2023, may be
rephrased and aligned with the preceding four points, along with the office
memorandum issued on 6th February, 2023. Point 5 may be read as: "Rebate can be
given to the public, not exceeding 25%, so that the effective increase to the final
property tax is not less than the last property tax collected, depending upon the local
conditions and requirements."
The meeting ended with a vote of thanks from the chair.”
40. From the above, it is apparent that it was decided that Point 5 of
the communication dated 10.03.2023, upon which the petitioner had
emphasized be read as “rebate can be given to the public, not
exceeding 25%, so that the effective increase to the final property tax
is not less than the last property tax collected, depending upon the
local conditions and requirements”. Therefore, the communication
Page No.# 25/31
dated 10.03.2023, in view of the Minutes of the Meeting dated
21.08.2025 completely changes the complexion of the contention so
made by the petitioner that the increase in the final property tax
cannot exceed 25% of the last property tax collected. This therefore
settles the said issue.
41.
The materials on record clearly show that since 1975-76, there
had been no determination of the annual value of the holdings which
were assessed to the Respondent Board. During this period of 48
years, there is no iota of any doubt which the learned Senior Counsel
for the petitioner also accepts that the values of the properties have
increased manifold. In the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the
respondent Nos. 2 and 3, it is categorically mentioned that the State
of Assam in the Revenue Department have also increased the land
value on various occasions. There is no denial to the said aspect. This
Court can also take judicial notice of the fact that the value of the
property have increased. It is also pertinent to mention that the
petitioner has not challenged the Notification and the Office
Memorandum dated 28.06.2022 and 06.02.2023 respectively which
stipulated that the existing zonal value of the land and the CPWD
schedule of rates are to be considered for calculation of the annual
rental value. It is also seen that the Directorate of Municipal
Administration, Assam has a proposed tax calculator in its dedicated
portal which provides as to how the annual rental value is to be
Page No.# 26/31
assessed. It is the opinion of this Court that taking into account the
Notification and the Office Memorandum dated 28.06.2022 and
06.02.2023 respectively read with the proposed tax calculator as
provided in the dedicated portal under the Directorate of Municipal
Administration, Assam and the fact that since the last 48 years there
has been no redetermination of the annual value of the holding, the
enhancement of the annual value of the holding cannot be said to be
exorbitant, irrational or unreasonable.
42.
This Court has also taken into consideration the Notice dated
05.08.2022 which also clearly mentions that with the approval of the
Committee so constituted in terms with Section 79-A(5), the
Respondent Board had published the list of Principal Main Roads and
Main Roads. Therefore, there is no infraction to Section 79-A(5) as
alleged by the learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner.
43.
Section 68 of the Act of 1956 empowers the Respondent Board
to impose within its limits the various taxes. It includes taxes such as
Holding Tax, Water Tax, Lighting Tax, Latrine Tax, Drainage Tax.
Holding tax, Water tax, Lighting Tax and Latrine Tax have a correlation
with the annual value of the holdings, whereas the drainage tax is in
respect when a system of drainage has been introduced. Section 68 of
the Act of 1956, however, does not confer any power upon the
Respondent Board to impose Urban Tax.
Page No.# 27/31
44.
At this stage, if this Court takes note of the Assam Urban
Immovable Property Tax Act, 1969 it would show that in terms with
Section 3 of the said Act of 1969, the Municipal Board or the Town
Committee are empowered to collect urban immovable property tax
on all lands and buildings situated within the area of such Municipal
Board or Town Committee, at the rate of 3% of the annual value of
the land and building. The Assam Urban Immovable Property Tax Act,
1969, however, was repealed by the Assam Repealing Act, 2022,
which came into effect on 07.10.2022. Therefore, w.e.f. 07.10.2022,
the Town Committee as well as the Municipal Bodies cannot impose
Urban Tax.
45. In the backdrop of the above, if this Court duly takes note of the
affidavit-in-opposition filed, it would be show that prior to the exercise
of reassessment of the holdings being carried out which was initiated
vide the Notification dated 28.06.2022, the total property tax was
14% of the annual value of the holdings which included house tax,
latrine tax, light tax, and Urban Tax. The Respondent Board in its 4 th
Board's General Meeting held on 01.03.2023 unanimously resolved
that they would abolish the house tax at the rate of 6%, latrine tax at
the rate of 3%, and light tax at the rate of 2%, and instead impose
Holding Tax at 3% on the annual value of the holdings and Urban Tax
at 3% on the annual value of the holdings.
Page No.# 28/31
46. It is on the basis thereof, it is seen in the impugned Notification
dated 03.05.2023, at Clause No. 5, it is mentioned that for both
residential and commercial establishment, rate of Holding Tax is 3%
and Urban Tax is 3% and hence total property tax shall be fixed at
6% (Holding Tax 3% + Urban Tax 3%). It is the opinion of this Court
that though the Respondent Board has the power to impose the
Holding Tax at the rate of 3% in terms with Section 68, but in view of
the repealing of the Assam Urban Immovable Property Tax Act, 1969
by the Assam Repealing Act, 2022, the Respondent Board cannot
impose Urban Tax at the rate of 3%. Therefore, the imposition of the
Urban Tax vide the Notification dated 03.05.2023 is required to be
interfered with to that extent.
47.
Let this Court now deal with the contention raised by the
petitioner as regards violation to Section 79-F of the Act of 1956. The
learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner submitted that the said
provision stipulates that determination of rates of taxes shall take
place and shall be published in the same manner as stipulated in the
said Section. For the purpose of deciding the said contention, this
Court finds it relevant to take note of Section 79-F of the Act of 1956.
The said provision is reproduced herein below:
“79-F. Determination of taxes.- The rate of taxes determined in accordance with
the provisions of this Act, shall be published by the respective Municipal Board/Town
Committee by issuing a public notice within a period of three months from the date of
Page No.# 29/31
coming into force of the Assam Municipal (Amendment) Act, 2012. This determination
shall remain valid for a period of five years. At the expiration of very five years. At the
expiration of very five years new determination of rate of taxes shall take place and
shall be published in the same manner as stipulated in this Section.
Explanation.- For the purposes of this Section the word “publish” shall have the same
meaning as assigned to it under Section 79(ii).”
48.
It is of importance to take note of that the above quoted
provision was brought within the Act of 1956 vide the Assam
Municipal (Amendment) Act, 2011 w.e.f. 25.05.2011. It is pertinent to
observe that the said provision relates to the rate of taxes which shall
remain valid for a period of 5 (five) years and thereupon a fresh
exercise would be carried out. It is of importance that vide the
impugned Notification the rate of taxes were determined. The said
aspect has been duly published as per Section 79(ii) of the Act of
1956. The said determination would be prospective w.e.f. 01.04.2023.
Under such circumstances, the contention so made appears to be
misconceived.
49. Accordingly, the instant writ petition therefore stands disposed of
with the following observations and directions:
(i)
The reassessment of the annual value of the holdings by
the Respondent Board is not unreasonable, irrational or
exorbitant. It is in consonance with the present value of the land
and the buildings and in terms with the Office Memorandum
Page No.# 30/31
dated 06.02.2023. Under such circumstances, the question of
interference with the reassessment of the annual value of the
holdings by the Respondent Board does not arise.
(ii) The Respondent Board in view of the repealing of the Assam
Urban Immovable Property Tax Act, 1969 by the Assam
Repealing Act, 2022, cannot impose Urban Tax. Accordingly, the
impugned Notification dated 03.05.2023, insofar as imposition of
the Urban Tax at the rate of 3% on the annual value of the
holdings is interfered with.
It is however clarified that the impugned Notification dated
03.05.2023 imposing Holding Tax at the rate of 3% is not
interfered with.
(iii) This Court further observes that in view of the above
declaration that the Respondent Board cannot impose Urban Tax
which is fixed at the rate of 3%, the Respondent Board shall now
be required to re-compute the liability of the petitioner. The
Demand Notice dated 09.12.2024 shall have to be either
modified or a fresh Demand Notice be issued as per the
observations and findings made herein above. The said be
carried out forthwith.
(iv) Interim order stands vacated.
Page No.# 31/31
(v)
The records so produced be returned to Mr. S.S. Roy, the
learned Standing Counsel by the Court Master of this Court.
(vi) No costs.
JUDGE
Date: 2026.02.18 06:58:29 +05'30'
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review