Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010542222022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3333]
MONDAY, THE TWENTY THIRD DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 442/2022
Between:
1. M/S.THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE COMPANY LTD, REP BY IT'S
DIVISIONAL MANAGER, BHANUGUDI JUNCTION,
SUBHADRA
ACADE, KAKINADA.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. NADIGATLA NOOKA RAJU JAMINDHARU, S/O. SAMBASIVA RAO,
AGED ABOUT 39, R/O UDDANDA JAGANADHAPURAM VILLAGE,
PRATHIPADU MANDAL, EAST GODAVARI DISTRICT- 533446.
2. NADIGATLA SAI RUPA, D/O. NOOKA RAJU @ JAMINDHARU, AGED
ABOUT 14 YEARS. R/O UDDANDA JAGANADHAPURAM VILLAGE,
PRATHIPADU MANDAL, EAST GODAVARI DISTRICT- 533446.
3. NADIGATLA VENKATA SAI SIVA PAVAN TEJA, S/O. NOOKA RAJU
@ JAMINDHARU,
AGED ABOUT 12 YEARS. R/O UDDANDA
JAGANADHAPURAM VILLAGE. PRATHIPADU MANDAL, EAST
GODAVARI DISTRICT- 533446.
4. BATHULA SATYANARAYANA, ( DIED),
5. SATYANARAYANA, S/O. NARAYANA RAO, AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS
, VADISALERU VILLAGE,
RANGAMPETA MANDAL, EAST
GODAVARI DISTRICT-533294, (OWNER OF LORRY BEARING
NO.AIQ-2499).
6. BATHULA SURYA KUMARI, W/O. LATE SATYANARAYANA AGED
ABOUT 55 YEARS, R/O VADISALERU VILLAGE, RANGAMPETA
VS,J
MACMA No.442 of 2022
MANDAL, EAST GODAVARI DISTRICT.
7. UAPPALAPATI DURGA DEVI, W/O. SURIBABU, AGED ABOUT 34
YEARS, R/O VADISALERU VILLAGE, RANGAMPETA MANDAL, EAST
GODAVARI DISTRICT.
8. VEMULAPALLI ANANTHA LAKSMI, W/O. SIVA, AGED ABOUT 32
YEARS, R/O VADISALERU VILLAGE, RANGAMPETA MANDAL,
EAST GODAVARI DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC praying thet the Highcourt may be
pleased tobegs to submit this Memorandum of Motor Accident Civil
Miscellaneous Appeal being aggrieved by the Award and Decree dt. 21-062022 in M.V.O.P.No. 30 of 2018 on the file of Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal
cum Ill Additional District Court East Godavari, Kakinada
IA NO: 1 OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to grant stay of execution of the Award and Decree dt. 21-06-2022
passed in M.V.O.P.No. 30 of 2018 by The III Addl District Judge-CumChairman, M.A.C.T., Kakinada pending disposal of the main Appeal, in the
interest of justice.
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. T S RAYALU
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. CHANDRA SEKHAR ILAPAKURTI
2.
The Court made the following:
VS,J
MACMA No.442 of 2022
JUDGMENT:
The Insurance Company filed the present appeal challenging the order
and decree dated 21.06.2022 passed in M.V.O.P.No.30 of 2018 by the
Chairman, Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal – Cum – III Additional District
Judge,
Kakinada,
whereby
and
whereunder
the
Tribunal
granted
compensation of Rs.14,30,000/- (Rupees Fourteen Lakhs Thirty Thousand
only) to the petitioners therein/respondent Nos.1 to 3 herein, though the claim
petition was originally filed for Rs.6,00,000/-, on account of the death of the
deceased Nadigatla Vishnu Kumari alias Reddy Suryachakravathi in a motor
accident that occurred on 12.12.2012.
02.
For the purpose of convenience, the parties will be referred to as they
are arrayed before the Tribunal.
03.
The case of the petitioners/claimants is briefly as follows:
a) The 1st petitioner No.1 is the husband and petitioners No.2 and 3 are
children of the deceased.
b) The deceased was selected as Customer Service Provider in the
National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (NREGS). On 12.12.2012,
she along with the 1st petitioner went to Yeleswaram, received appointment
order and joined duty. Thereafter, they went to Annavaram and after having
darshan of Sri Satyanarayana Swamy, while returning and when they reached
near Santhi Ashramam cross road, the 1st respondent, who was driving the
lorry bearing No.AIQ-2499, came from behind the motorcycle of the 1st
VS,J
MACMA No.442 of 2022
petitioner at high speed and in a rash and negligent manner without blowing
horn. At first instance, he dashed against an auto bearing No.AP16TU-1685,
causing the auto to turn turtle, and thereafter, with the same speed, dashed
the motorcycle of the 1st petitioner and dragged it under the lorry. As a result,
the deceased died on the spot and the 1st petitioner sustained injuries. A case
was registered in Crime No.209 of 2012 under Sections 337 and 304-A of IPC
against the 1st respondent by the Annavaram Police Station.
04.
The petitioners contended that the deceased was hale and healthy,
working in NREGS and earning Rs.12,000/- per month and was maintaining
the family. Due to her sudden demise, the family was shattered. The
petitioners were completely dependent upon her earnings and suffered mental
agony. Therefore, the petitioner sought compensation of Rs.6,00,000/- from
the respondents.
05.
During the pendency of case, the 1st respondent/driver died intestate
leaving respondents No.4 to 6 as his legal representatives, and hence they
were impleaded as parties, and as the 1st respondent being driver of offending
vehicle, the 2nd respondent was the owner of the said vehicle and the 3rd
respondent was the insurer of the said vehicle at the time of the accident, the
petitioners prayed before the Tribunal that they are jointly and severally liable
to pay compensation.
06.
Before the Tribunal, the 2nd respondent/owner of the crime vehicle
remained exparte.
VS,J
MACMA No.442 of 2022
07.
The 3rd respondent/insurance company filed a counter denying the
averments made in the petition and contended that the lorry bearing No.AIQ2499 did not possess a valid permit, tax and fitness certificate at the time of
alleged accident. It was further contended that the accident occurred due to
the negligence of the 1st petitioner, and that there was no negligence on the
part of the driver of the lorry. It was also contended that the petition is bad for
non-joinder of necessary parties, i.e., the owner and insurer of the auto
bearing No. AP16TU-1685. The petitioners were put to strict proof regarding
the driving licence of the 1st respondent, the occurrence of the accident, the
involvement of the vehicle, and the age, occupation and income of the
deceased. It was further contended that the compensation claimed is
excessive and therefore prayed for dismissal of the petition.
08.
Based on the pleadings, the Tribunal framed the following issues for
trial:
“1. Whether the death of decased Nadigatla Vishnu Kumari alias Reddy
Suryachakravathi, W/o Nookaraju alias Jamindhar was died in the accident
occurred on 12.12.2012 at 11.30 p.m. near Santhi Ashramam Raod,
Nellipudi outskirts, Sankavaram Mandal due to rash and negligent driving
of lorry bearing registration No.AIQ-2499 by its driver i.e. 1st respondent?
2. Whether the petitioners are entitled for compensation? If so, to what
amount and against whom?
3. To what relief?”
09.
On behalf of the petitioners/claimants, the 1st petitioner examined
himself as P.W.1 and Exs.A1 to A4 were marked. On behalf of the 3rd
VS,J
MACMA No.442 of 2022
respondent, K.Leela Krishna, Assistant Manager of the insurance company
was examined as R.W.1 and Exs.B1 to B3 were marked. R.W.2/P.Vasavi
Priyanka, Senior Assistant from the RTA office, was also examined and
Ex.X1/Authorization letter and Ex.X2/permit extract of the vehicle bearing
No.AIQ-2499 were marked.
10.
After hearing both parties and after considering the oral and
documentary evidence on record, the Tribunal allowed the claim petition
against respondent Nos.2 to 6 and awarded compensation of Rs.14,30,000/with interest at 7.5% per annum. Respondent Nos.2 to 6 were jointly and
severally held liable to pay the said compensation and were directed to
deposit the same within one month from the date of the judgment. Out of the
said amount, the 1st petitioner was awarded an amount of Rs.4,30,000/-, out
of which, he was permitted to withdraw an amount of Rs.2,30,000/- with
accrued interest and the balance of Rs.2,00,000/- was directed to be kept in
deposit in his name in any Nationalized Bank for a period of three years. The
2nd and 3rd petitioners were awarded Rs.5,00,000/- each with accrued interest
and the said amounts were directed to be kept in any Nationalized Bank till
they attain majority. The petitioners were also directed to pay deficit Court fee
on the enhanced compensation. Accordingly, the petitioners paid the deficit
Court fee of Rs.8,300/- on 27.06.2022 and filed a memo before the Tribunal.
11.
Aggrieved by the said award, the 3rd respondent/insurance company
preferred the present appeal on the ground that Ex.B3/charge sheet clearly
VS,J
MACMA No.442 of 2022
shows that the driver of the lorry drove the vehicle in a rash and negligent
manner while under the influence of alcohol and caused the accident.
Therefore, the driver being in an intoxicated condition constitutes a gross
violation of the policy conditions. However, the Tribunal failed to properly
appreciate the said aspect. It was further contended that the rider of the
motorcycle has also contributed to the accident by driving in a rash and
negligent manner. Hence, the Tribunal erred in fastening liability on the
insurance company.
12.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the claimants/respondent Nos.1
to 3 herein has supported the impugned award and prayed to dismiss the
appeal.
13.
Now the point for consideration is:
Whether the order of the Tribunal needs any interference?
POINT:
14.
The main contention of the learned counsel for the appellant is that the
driver of the offending vehicle was in a drunken condition at the time of
accident, which amounts to violation of the policy conditions, and, as such, no
liability can be fastened on the appellant/insurance company. To substantiate
the said contention, the insurance company relied upon Ex.B3/copy of the
charge sheet filed against the 1st respondent/driver. As can be seen from
Ex.B3, the driver was arrested at the accident spot on 12.12.2012 and was
VS,J
MACMA No.442 of 2022
found to be in a drunken condition. He was sent for medical examination for
issuance of a drunkenness certificate. LW14/Dr.P.Nanda Kishore examined
the accused and issued a certificate stating that the driver had consumed
alcohol and was under the influence of alcohol at the time of the accident. The
charge sheet further states that the accident occurred due to the rash and
negligent driving of the lorry by the driver while in a drunken condition,
resulting in the instantaneous death of the deceased and simple injuries to the
1st petitioner. Though the Tribunal, upon considering the said evidence, held
respondent Nos.2 to 6 are jointly and severally liable to pay the compensation.
But, however, as per Ex.B3/copy of the charge sheet relied upon by the
insurance company, it is an admitted fact that respondent No.1/driver of the
offending vehicle was in an intoxicated condition at the time of the accident. In
such a case, this Court is of the opinion that there is a clear violation of the
policy conditions, since the driver contributed to the said accident by driving
the vehicle in a drunken state.
15.
It is to be noted that under similar circumstances, where there is
violation of the policy conditions, the Hon’ble Apex Court in National
Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh & Ors., 1 held that if the insurer
successfully proves a breach of policy condition, the insurance company may
still be directed to pay compensation to the claimants and then recover the
amount from the insured (owner of the vehicle). This ensures that the rights of
the third-party victim are protected and it was emphasized that insurance
(2004) 3 SCC 297
VS,J
MACMA No.442 of 2022
policies are statutorily required to protect third parties, and even in cases of
breach by the insured, the insurer's liability towards third-party victims does
not vanish immediately.
16.
In view of the above legal position and following the settled principles of
law as held by the Hon’ble Apex Court, this Court is of the opinion that the
compensation awarded by the Tribunal in the instant case has to be first paid
by the insurance company, and thereafter the insurance company can recover
the same from the owner of the offending vehicle i.e., owner of the lorry
bearing No.AIQ-2499 i.e., respondent No.2.
17.
So far as the quantum of compensation is concerned, though the
petitioners contended that the deceased was earning Rs.12,000/- per month
by working in NREGS, no documentary evidence was produced to prove the
earnings of the deceased. In this regard, the Tribunal placed reliance on the
judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Arun Kumar Agrawal & anothers vs.
National Insurance Co., Ltd., and others2 wherein it was held at para 32
that the gratuitous services rendered by a wife/mother to the husband and
children cannot be equated with the services of an employee and no evidence
or data can be produced for estimating the valid of such services. It is virtually
impossible to measure in terms of money for the loss of personal care and
attention suffered by the husband and children on the demise of the
housewife….”. In the present case, considering the fact that the deceased was
AIR 2010 SC 3426
VS,J
MACMA No.442 of 2022
a housewife and was also working under NREGS, the Tribunal assessed her
notional income at Rs.10,000/- per month i.e., Rs.1,20,000/- (Rs.10,000/- X
12) per annum, which in the opinion of this Court, is just and proper and
requires no interference. Since there were three dependants i.e., husband
and two minor children, the Tribunal rightly deducted 1/3rd of the income of the
deceased towards personal expenses and arrived at Rs.80,000/- per annum
(Rs.1,20,000/- - 1/3rd ) towards her contribution to the family. By applying the
relevant multiplier of ‘17’ applicable to the age of the deceased i.e., 29 years,
as recorded in Ex.A2 -Post Mortem Report, the Tribunal has arrived at
Rs.13,60,000/- (Rs.80,000/- X 17) towards the loss of dependency, which is
just and proper and in accordance with the guidelines laid down by the
Hon’ble Apex Court in Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation.
Further, the Tribunal awarded Rs.15,000/- towards loss of estate, Rs.15,000/towards funeral expenses and Rs.40,000/- towards loss of consortium. Thus,
the total compensation awarded by the Tribunal comes to Rs.14,30,000/-,
which cannot be said to be excessive or on higher side. The order passed by
the Tribunal does not suffer from any infirmity and requires no interference in
this civil miscellaneous appeal. The point is answered accordingly.
18.
In view of the above discussion, while confirming the quantum of
compensation awarded by the Tribunal, this Court deems it appropriate to
partly allow this appeal by modifying the award to the extent that the insurance
company shall first pay the compensation to the petitioners/claimants and
VS,J
MACMA No.442 of 2022
thereafter recover the same from the owner of the offending vehicle i.e., lorry
bearing registration No.AIQ-2499/respondent No.2.
19.
With the above direction, this appeal is allowed in part. No costs.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand closed.
___________________
JUSTICE V. SUJATHA
Date: 23.02.2026
KGR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review