Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/19
GAHC040005512025
2026:GAU-AP:517
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/163/2025
M/s T T Enterprises
having its registered office at Papu Nallah, PO Naharlagun, PS Papu Nallah, Papum
Pare District, Arunachal Pradesh (represented by its proprietor Shri Tadam Taku)
resident of Papu Nallah, PO Naharlagun, PS Papu Nallah, Papum Pare District,
Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
The Union of India and 5 Ors
represented by the Secretary, Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution, Govt
of India, New Delhi 110001
2:The Food Corporation of India
Age: 0
Occupation :
represented by its Chairman and Managing Director
16-20
Barakhamba Lane
New Delhi 110001
3:The Executive Director (NE)
Age: 0
Occupation :
Food Corporation of India
Zonal Office (NE)
Guwahati-7
Assam.
4:The Divisional Manager
Age: 0
Occupation :
FCI
Page No.# 2/19
DO
Banderdewa
Arunachal Pradesh
PO and PS Banderdewa
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
5:The General Manger (R)
Age: 0
Occupation :
FCI
RO
Itanagar
E Sector
JNK School Building
APPSC Road
Itanagar
PO and PS Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
6:The Tender Evaluation Committee
Age: 0
Occupation :
(Regional Office) Food Corporation of India
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh
Advocate for the Petitioner
Pada
: Dicky Panging, Sr. Adv, T Mingki,Likha Moriam,Daina Tamuk,Ojing
Advocate for the Respondent : Marto Kato, SC (FCI),B K Singh
Page No.# 3/19
:::BEFORE:::
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KARDAK ETE
Date on which judgment is reserved
: 20.05.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 26.05.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of
the operative of the judgment?
: No
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
: Yes
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. D. Panging, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Ms. D. Tamuk,
learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. B. K. Singh, learned Standing
Counsel, FCI, for respondent Nos. 2 to 6.
2.
By filing this writ petition, the petitioner has put to challenge the Notice
Inviting Tender (NIT) dated 25.03.2025, issued by the Assistant Manager
(Contract) for the General Manager (Region), Regional Office, Itanagar, for the
work of “Road Transport Contract Ex-RH Harmuty/FSD Banderdewa to FSD
Koloriang via weighbridge on regular basis for a period of 2 (two) years”, as well
as the communication dated 05.04.2025, whereby the respondent authorities
informed the petitioner that the rate quoted by the petitioner firm was very high
and awarding the contract in its favour would cause huge financial loss to the
Government exchequer. The petitioner has also prayed for issuance of
appropriate directions to the respondent authorities to award the contract
Page No.# 4/19
pursuant to the earlier NIT dated 08.01.2025 and to issue consequential work
order.
3.
The petitioner is a proprietorship firm under the name and style of M/s T T
Enterprises, having its office at Papu Nallah, Naharlagun, District-Papum Pare,
Arunachal Pradesh, and represented by its sole proprietor, Shri Tadum Taku.
4.
Briefly put, the case of the petitioner is that pursuant to the Notice Inviting
Tender (NIT) dated 08.01.2025, issued by the Assistant Manager (Contract) for
the General Manager (Region), Regional Office, Food Corporation of India,
Itanagar, for “Road Transport Contract Ex-RH Harmuty/FSD Banderdewa to FSD
Koloriang via weighbridge on regular basis for a period of 2 (two) years for an
estimated cost of Rs. 3,63,75,000/- (Rupees three crore sixty three lakhs
seventy five thousand) only”, the petitioner firm, participated in the tender
process along with four other bidders, namely, Agham Enterprises, M/s Itanagar
Traders, M/s Atu-Apa Developers and Lar Trading Agency, by submitting its bid
through the Government e-marketplace portal.
5.
It is the case of the petitioner that though initially its technical bid was not
accepted on the ground that the name of the petitioner firm was reflected as
“M/s TT Enterprise” instead of “M/s TT Enterprises”, the petitioner thereafter
submitted representation dated 14.02.2025 before the competent authorities
contending that the discrepancy was merely clerical in nature and also
submitted a self-declaration stating that both names pertain to the same firm.
Pursuant thereto, the petitioner was permitted to participate in the technical bid
evaluation process and eventually the technical bid of the petitioner along with
two other bidders was found qualified.
Page No.# 5/19
6.
Thereafter, upon opening of the financial bids, the petitioner firm was
declared as the lowest responsive bidder (L1). However, despite completion of
the tender process and despite the petitioner having emerged as the L1 bidder,
the respondent authorities cancelled the aforesaid NIT dated 08.01.2025
without assigning any reasons. Subsequently, the Divisional Manager, FCI, DO,
Banderdewa, Arunachal Pradesh, issued a fresh NIT dated 21.03.2025 on adhoc
basis for the same work for a period of 3 (three) months for an estimated cost
of Rs. 25,00,000/- (Rupees twenty five lakhs) only despite the fact that the said
Tender has already been floated and the petitioner has been declared as the
Lowest Bidder (L1). Aggrieved thereby, the petitioner instituted WP(C) No.
123/2025 challenging the adhoc NIT dated 21.03.2025, which was, however,
subsequently came to be withdrawn. Thereafter, the respondent authorities
issued a fresh NIT dated 25.03.2025 in respect of the same contract work.
7.
It is the further case of the petitioner that during pendency of the earlier
writ petition, the petitioner submitted a representation dated 18.03.2025 before
the General Manager, FCI, Regional Office, Itanagar, alleging arbitrariness in
cancellation of the earlier tender process and also alleging manipulation in the
matter. The respondent authorities, by communication dated 05.04.2025,
informed the petitioner that the rate quoted by the petitioner in the financial bid
was very high and awarding the contract at such rate would have caused huge
financial loss to the Government exchequer. It is the contention of the petitioner
that the said stand of the respondent authorities is wholly misconceived
inasmuch as the petitioner has quoted an amount of Rs. 3,20,96,520/- (Rupees
three crore twenty lakhs ninety six thousand five hundred twenty) only, which is
Page No.# 6/19
12.24% below the estimated tender value. Hence, this writ petition challenging
the fresh NIT dated 25.03.2025 as well as the communication dated 05.04.2025
and also seeking consequential directions upon the respondent authorities to
award the contract pursuant to the earlier NIT dated 08.01.2025 in favour of the
petitioner.
8.
Mr. D. Panging, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner, submits that the
impugned cancellation of the earlier tender process and issuance of the fresh
NIT dated 25.03.2025 after completion of the tender process is arbitrary and
unreasonable. The action of the respondent authorities lacks transparency and
fairness and has been undertaken with the intention of favouring some other
bidder. He submits that once the petitioner had been declared as the lowest
responsive bidder (L1), the respondent authorities could not have arbitrarily
cancelled the tender process without assigning any valid or cogent reasons. He
submits that the initial rejection of the technical bid of the petitioner on account
of discrepancy in the nomenclature of the firm itself demonstrates the arbitrary
approach adopted by the respondent authorities, inasmuch as the discrepancy
was merely clerical in nature. It is only after submission of representation and
self-declaration by the petitioner, the respondent authorities permitted the
petitioner to participate in the tender process and eventually declared qualified
in the technical bid.
9.
Mr. Panging, learned Senior Counsel, submits that the reason assigned by
the respondent authorities in the communication dated 05.04.2025 that the rate
quoted by the petitioner was “very high” and awarding the contract at such rate
would result in financial loss to the Government exchequer is wholly
Page No.# 7/19
misconceived and contrary to the records, inasmuch as the estimated tender
value is Rs. 3,65,75,000/-, whereas the petitioner has quoted Rs. 3,20,96,520/-,
which is 12.24% below the estimated cost put to tender. Therefore, he submits
that the impugned action of the respondent authorities amounts to changing the
rules of the game after completion of the tender process and the same is
impermissible in law. He submits that the cancellation of the earlier NIT and
issuance of the fresh NIT has been undertaken only to deny the contract to the
petitioner despite the petitioner having emerged as the L1 bidder.
10.
Learned Senior Counsel submits that though the Government may have
the power to reject or cancel a tender process, such power cannot be exercised
arbitrarily or unreasonably and must satisfy the requirements of fairness and
transparency as mandated under Article 14 of the Constitution of India. He
submits that the action of the respondent authorities is violative of the principles
of fairness, transparency and legitimate expectation. Therefore, Mr. Panging,
learned Senior Counsel, submits that the impugned action of the respondent
authorities in cancelling the earlier NIT dated 08.01.2025 and issuing the fresh
NIT dated 25.03.2025 for the very same work, despite the petitioner having
been declared as the lowest responsive bidder (L1), is arbitrary, unreasonable
and lacks transparency and as such, the same is liable to be interfered with by
this Court.
11.
In support of his submissions, Mr. Panging, learned Senior Counsel, has
placed reliance upon the following judgments:-
Page No.# 8/19
(i)
Food Corporation of India Vs. M/s Kamdhenu Cattle Feed
Industries, reported in (1993) 1 SCC 71
(ii)
Commissioner of Police, Bombay Vs. Gordhandas Bhanji,
reported in 1951 SCC OnLine SC 70
12.
On the other hand, B. K. Singh, learned Standing Counsel, FCI, for
respondent Nos. 2 to 6, submits that the writ petition is wholly misconceived
and not maintainable in law. He submits that the petitioner is estopped from
challenging the cancellation of the NIT dated 08.01.2025 inasmuch as the
petitioner has earlier instituted WP(C) No. 123/2025 challenging the very same
action of the respondent authorities and after having failed to obtain interim
relief therein and having subsequently participated in the adhoc tender process
dated 21.03.2025 and emerged successful therein, the petitioner withdrew the
said writ petition without obtaining any liberty to institute a fresh proceeding on
the same cause of action.
13.
He submits that the Food Corporation of India is entrusted with the
statutory obligation of ensuring food security throughout the country under the
provisions of the National Food Security Act, 2013 and the transportation and
handling of foodgrains, particularly in the North-Eastern Region and other farflung areas, constitute an essential public utility service. The uninterrupted
movement and supply of foodgrains is of paramount importance and therefore,
the respondent Corporation is duty bound to ensure that transportation
contracts are awarded at reasonable and competitive rates in public interest.
Page No.# 9/19
14.
Mr. Singh, learned Standing Counsel, FCI, submits that the route in
question, namely, Ex-RH Harmuty/FSD Banderdewa to FSD Koloriang, is a new
route for the Corporation and the NIT dated 08.01.2025 has been floated for
the first time in respect thereof. However, upon evaluation of the financial bids,
the rate quoted by the petitioner, i.e. Rs. 4520/- per MT, has been found to be
on the higher side after comparison with prevailing market rates and rates of
similar contracts as required under Clause 4.4 of the FCI Contract Manual. He
submits that the said clause specifically requires examination of the
reasonability of tendered rates in a transparent manner by comparing the rates
with prevailing market rates as well as rates of nearby FCI/CWC/SWC contracts.
15.
Learned Standing Counsel has further submitted that in an earlier
transaction audit report of the Zonal Office, exception has been taken by the
higher authorities in respect of acceptance of a transport contract at a rate
which is 19.5% higher than the previous contract without resorting to a second
tender attempt for obtaining lower rates. The said audit objection necessitated a
cautious approach in the present matter and accordingly, the competent
authority took a conscious decision to cancel the earlier tender process and
explore the possibility of obtaining more competitive rates.
16.
Learned Standing Counsel further submits that the Model Tender Form
itself, under Clause 11 of the “General Information to Tenderers”, stipulates that
the Food Corporation of India reserves the right to reject any or all the tenders
without assigning any reason and therefore, the petitioner cannot claim any
indefeasible right merely because the petitioner has emerged as the L1 bidder.
Page No.# 10/19
He submits that the subsequent events itself demonstrate the correctness of the
decision taken by the respondent authorities inasmuch as pursuant to the adhoc
NIT dated 21.03.2025, the petitioner himself participated and quoted a
substantially lower rate of Rs. 3990/- per MT, which is Rs. 530/- lower than the
rate quoted by the petitioner in the earlier NIT dated 08.01.2025, i.e. Rs. 4520/.
He submits that because of the lower rate discovered in the adhoc tender
process, the Corporation was able to save approximately Rs. 38 lakhs and
therefore, the allegation of arbitrariness or mala fide is wholly unfounded.
17. Mr. Singh, learned Standing Counsel, FCI, submits that the petitioner has
not approached this Court with clean hands inasmuch as contradictory
statements have been made in the writ petition regarding non-receipt of reply
to the representation despite the petitioner himself having annexed the
communication dated 05.04.2025 issued by the respondent authorities. He
further submits that the allegations regarding favouritism, pick and choose
policy and mala fide exercise of power are bald, vague and unsupported by any
material particulars. He submits that the adhoc tender dated 21.03.2025 has
been floated only as a temporary measure for a period of 3 (three) months in
view of operational exigencies and the impending rainy season, whereas the
fresh NIT dated 25.03.2025 was issued to obtain more competitive rates for the
regular contract period. The decision making process has been undertaken
strictly in accordance with the provisions of the Contract Manual, the Model
Tender Form and prevailing guidelines and does not suffer from arbitrariness,
mala fide or unreasonableness warranting interference of this Court. Therefore,
he submits that no legal or fundamental right of the petitioner has been
infringed and the petitioner having participated in the subsequent adhoc tender
Page No.# 11/19
process and benefited therefrom cannot now turn around and challenge the
cancellation of the earlier NIT dated 08.01.2025 and as such, the writ petition
being devoid of merit is liable to be dismissed.
18.
In support of his submissions, Mr. Singh, learned Standing Counsel, FCI,
has placed reliance upon the following judgments:-
(i)
Air India Ltd. Vs. Cochin International Airport Ltd. & Ors.,
reported in (2000) 2 SCC 617
(ii)
Jagdish Mandal Vs. State of Orissa & Ors., reported in (2007)
14 SCC 517
(iii)
M/S N. G. Projects Limited Vs. M/S Vinod Kumar Jain & Ors.,
reported in (2022) 6 SCC 127
19.
Mr. D. Panging, learned Senior Counsel, while rejoining his submissions,
submits that the present writ petition is maintainable inasmuch as the earlier
writ petition, being WP(C) No. 123/2025, was filed challenging the Ad-hoc NIT
dated 21.03.2025, whereas the instant writ petition challenges the fresh regular
NIT dated 25.03.2025. He submits that the cause of action in both the writ
petitions is distinct and different and therefore, the plea of estoppel raised by
the respondents is misconceived.
20.
He further submits that though the petitioner was declared as the L1
bidder pursuant to the NIT dated 08.01.2025, the said tender process was
Page No.# 12/19
cancelled on the purported ground that the quoted rate was on the higher side
despite the admitted position that the petitioner’s bid was 12.24% below the
estimated tender value. More so, the subsequent issuance of the fresh regular
NIT dated 25.03.2025, merely 4 (four) days after the Adhoc NIT dated
21.03.2025, completely contradicts the stand of the respondents that issuance
of a regular tender would have taken considerable time.
21.
Learned Senior Counsel further submits that the reliance placed by the
respondents upon Clause 4.4 of the FCI Contract Manual is misconceived
inasmuch as every tender has to be evaluated on its own merits and rates
quoted in different tenders or routes cannot be mechanically compared.
Therefore, the cancellation of the NIT dated 08.01.2025 and issuance of the
fresh NIT dated 25.03.2025 for the same work is wholly arbitrary,
discriminatory, mala fide and unsustainable in law.
22. Mr. Panging, learned Senior Counsel, further submitted that the stand of
the respondents that the petitioner’s quoted rate was unreasonably high is
inconsistent with the Corporation’s own past conduct. In this regard, learned
Senior Counsel has referred to several earlier tenders wherein bids either above
or below the estimated cost were accepted by the respondents. He submits that
once the petitioner has been adjudged as the lowest responsive bidder and the
quoted rate is within the sanctioned estimate, a legitimate expectation accrued
in favour of the petitioner which could not have been defeated by cancellation
of the tender process merely on the anticipation that a lower rate might be
received in a future tender. Although the respondents may possess the authority
to cancel a tender process, such power has to be exercised fairly, transparently
Page No.# 13/19
and in conformity with Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
23. Due consideration has been extended to the submissions advanced by the
learned counsel for the parties and also perused the materials available on
record.
24. The petitioner is aggrieved by the action of the respondent authorities in
cancelling the earlier NIT dated 08.01.2025, despite the petitioner having been
declared as the lowest responsive bidder (L1), and thereafter issuing the fresh
NIT dated 25.03.2025 for the very same contract work. The petitioner has also
challenged the communication dated 05.04.2025, whereby the respondent
authorities informed the petitioner that the rate quoted by the petitioner has
been found to be on the higher side and awarding the contract at such rate
would have caused financial loss to the Government exchequer.
25. From the submissions advanced by the learned counsel for the parties and
upon perusal of the materials available on record, it appears that there is no
dispute with regard to the fact that pursuant to the NIT dated 08.01.2025, the
petitioner was initially disqualified in the technical bid evaluation process on
account of discrepancy in the nomenclature of the petitioner firm. However,
after submission of representations and self-declaration by the petitioner, the
respondent authorities permitted the petitioner to participate in the tender
process and eventually declared the petitioner technically qualified. It also
appears to be undisputed that upon opening of the financial bids, the petitioner
emerged as the lowest responsive bidder (L1).
Page No.# 14/19
26.
The first issue which falls for consideration is with regard to the
maintainability of the present writ petition in view of the earlier writ petition,
being WP(C) No. 123/2025, instituted by the petitioner in connection with the
adhoc NIT dated 21.03.2025. While the respondents contend that the petitioner
is estopped from raising the present challenge after withdrawal of the earlier
writ petition without liberty, the stand of the petitioner is that the earlier writ
petition pertained to the adhoc NIT dated 21.03.2025, whereas the present writ
petition challenges the subsequent regular NIT dated 25.03.2025 and therefore,
the cause of action in both proceedings is distinct.
27.
It is seen that the earlier writ petition, being WP(C) No. 123/2025, was
instituted challenging the adhoc NIT dated 21.03.2025 floated for a limited
period, whereas the present writ petition challenges the subsequent regular NIT
dated 25.03.2025 as well as the consequential communication dated
05.04.2025. Therefore, the cause of action in the present proceeding cannot be
said to be identical to the earlier writ petition and as such, this Court is of the
considered view that the present writ petition is maintainable.
28.
Now, it is to be considered as to whether the action of the respondent
authorities in cancelling the earlier NIT dated 08.01.2025 and issuing the fresh
NIT dated 25.03.2025 for the very same contract work is justified in law and
whether the same suffers from arbitrariness, mala fide, unreasonableness or
lack of transparency warranting interference by this Court.
29.
The specific stand of the respondent authorities is that though the
petitioner had emerged as the lowest responsive bidder (L1) pursuant to the
Page No.# 15/19
earlier NIT dated 08.01.2025, the quoted rate of the petitioner, i.e. Rs. 4520/per MT, has been found to be on the higher side upon examination of the
reasonability of rates in terms of Clause 4.4 of the FCI Contract Manual and
therefore, the competent authority had taken a conscious decision to cancel the
earlier tender process and issue a fresh tender in public interest. The
respondent authorities have also relied upon Clause 11 of the “General
Information to Tenderers” contained in the Model Tender Form, whereby the
Corporation reserves the right to reject any or all tenders without assigning any
reason.
30. On the other hand, the petitioner has contended that the quoted amount
of Rs. 3,20,96,520/- (Rupees three crore twenty lakhs ninety six thousand five
hundred twenty) only was admittedly 12.24% below the estimated tender value
of Rs. 3,63,75,000/- (Rupees three crore sixty three lakhs seventy five
thousand) only and therefore, the subsequent stand of the respondent
authorities that the quoted rate of the petitioner was “very high” is wholly
arbitrary and contrary to the records. The petitioner has further contended that
after completion of the tender process and after having declared the petitioner
as the lowest responsive bidder (L1), the respondent authorities could not have
arbitrarily cancelled the tender process merely on the possibility of obtaining
lower rates in a future tender process.
31.
Having considered the submissions advanced by the learned counsel for
the parties and upon perusal of the materials available on record, it appears that
there is no dispute with regard to the fact that pursuant to the NIT dated
08.01.2025, the petitioner participated in the tender process and was eventually
Page No.# 16/19
declared as the lowest responsive bidder (L1). It also appears to be undisputed
that the quoted amount of the petitioner was admittedly below the estimated
tender value.
32.
It is well settled that though the State and its instrumentalities possess
considerable freedom in contractual matters and award of tenders, such
freedom is not absolute or unfettered. In Food Corporation of India Vs. M/s
Kamdhenu Cattle Feed Industries, reported in (1993) 1 SCC 71, as relied
by the learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
held that in contractual sphere also, the State and its instrumentalities are
required to act fairly, transparently and in a non-arbitrary manner and that every
State action must satisfy the mandate of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
It has further been held that due observance of fairness in decision making
gives rise to a legitimate expectation in favour of persons participating in a State
action.
33. At the same time, the principles laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in Air India Ltd. Vs. Cochin International Airport Ltd., reported in (2000)
2 SCC 617, Jagdish Mandal Vs. State of Orissa, reported in (2007) 14
SCC 517 and M/S N.G. Projects Ltd. Vs. M/S Vinod Kumar Jain, reported
in (2022) 6 SCC 127, clearly indicate that though the scope of judicial review
in tender matters is limited, the Court can certainly interfere where the decision
making process is found to be arbitrary, irrational, mala fide or violative of
Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
34. In the present case, as noted above, it is not in dispute that pursuant to
Page No.# 17/19
the NIT dated 08.01.2025, the petitioner participated in the tender process and
eventually emerged as the lowest responsive bidder (L1). It is also not in
dispute that the estimated value of the tender was Rs. 3,63,75,000/- (Rupees
three crore sixty three lakhs seventy five thousand) only whereas the bid quoted
by the petitioner was Rs. 3,20,96,520/- (Rupees three crore twenty lakhs ninety
six thousand five hundred twenty) only, which admittedly is 12.24% below the
estimated tender value.
35. The justification sought to be advanced by the respondent authorities for
cancellation of the earlier NIT dated 08.01.2025 is that the rate quoted by the
petitioner has been found to be on the higher side and the Corporation intended
to obtain more competitive rates in public interest. In this regard, reliance has
been placed upon Clause 4.4 of the FCI Contract Manual pertaining to
examination of reasonability of tendered rates as well as Clause 11 of the
“General Information to Tenderers”, which reserves liberty upon the Corporation
to reject any or all tenders without assigning any reason.
36. Clause 11 of the Model Tender Form undoubtedly reserves power upon the
respondent Corporation to reject or cancel any tender process. However, such
power cannot be construed to mean that the respondent authorities are at
liberty to act arbitrarily or dehors the principles of fairness and transparency.
The discretion vested upon a public authority necessarily has to be exercised
reasonably, fairly and on the basis of discernible and justifiable reasons.
37.
In the case in hand, this Court finds that though the respondents have
subsequently attempted to justify the cancellation of the earlier tender process
Page No.# 18/19
by contending that the quoted rate was “high”, no such reason was disclosed at
the time of cancellation of the earlier NIT dated 08.01.2025. Even the
communication dated 05.04.2025 merely states that the quoted rate was “very
high” and awarding the contract at such rate would have caused financial loss to
the Government exchequer. However, the respondents have failed to
demonstrate as to how a bid admittedly 12.24% below the estimated tender
value could be treated as exorbitant or unreasonable.
38.
This Court also finds force in the submission advanced on behalf of the
petitioner that the stand of the respondent authorities appears to be selfcontradictory. While the respondent authorities sought to justify the adhoc NIT
dated 21.03.2025 on the ground that issuance of a regular tender would take
considerable time, the fresh regular NIT dated 25.03.2025 came to be issued
within merely 4 (four) days thereafter. The aforesaid sequence of events creates
doubt with regard to the transparency and fairness of the decision making
process adopted by the respondent authorities.
39.
Having considered that the petitioner emerged as the lowest responsive
bidder (L1) pursuant to the earlier NIT dated 08.01.2025 and considering that
the quoted amount of the petitioner was admittedly below the estimated tender
value, ordinarily the respondent authorities may have been justified in
proceeding with the tender process. Though Clause 11 of the Model Tender
Form reserves power upon the Corporation to reject any tender, such power
necessarily has to be exercised reasonably, fairly and in a transparent manner
consistent with the mandate of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
Page No.# 19/19
40. The materials available on record do not disclose any cogent or justifiable
reason for cancellation of the earlier tender process initiated pursuant to the
NIT dated 08.01.2025. The subsequent explanation sought to be furnished by
the respondent authorities appears to be an afterthought and lacks adequate
factual foundation. Merely because the petitioner subsequently quoted a lower
amount in the adhoc tender process, the same by itself cannot retrospectively
validate the earlier decision of cancellation.
41.
In view of what has been discussed herein above, this Court is of the
considered view that the impugned action of the respondent authorities in
cancelling the earlier NIT dated 08.01.2025 and issuing the fresh NIT dated
25.03.2025 for the same work suffers from arbitrariness and lack of
transparency and therefore is violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
In the result, the impugned NIT dated 25.03.2025 as well as the communication
dated 05.04.2025 are hereby set aside and quashed. The respondent authorities
are directed to take consequential steps in respect of the earlier NIT dated
08.01.2025 in accordance with law and complete the process expeditiously,
preferably within a period of 6 (six) weeks from the date of receipt of a certified
copy of this order.
42. The writ petition accordingly stands allowed and disposed of. No order as
to cost(s).
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review