Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extra Ordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED : 29.11.2018
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (C) No. 50 of 2018
Petitioners
:
M/s Summit Online Trade Solutions (Pvt.)
Ltd., and Anr.
versus
Respondents
:
The State of Sikkim & Another
An application under Article 226
of the Constitution of India
----------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Surajit Dutta, Ms. Rachhitta Rai and Ms. Bhawana
Chettri, Advocates.
Mr. J.B. Pradhan, Additional Advocate General with Mr.
Karma Thinlay, Senior Government Advocate, Mr.
Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia, Government Advocate and Mr.
S.K. Chettri and Ms. Pollin Rai, Assistant Government
Advocates.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The Petitioners are before this Court praying that the
letter dated 27.10.2018 issued by the Respondent No. 2 as
well as the invitation for Expression of Interest/Tender dated
29.10.2018 be set aside and the Respondents be directed to
abide by the correspondence dated 18.08.2017 and the letter
W.P. (C) No. 50 of 2018
M/s Summit Online Trade Solution (Pvt.) Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
dated 24.09.2018 with the revised revenue. The Petitioners be
permitted to continue as Marketing Agents for the Sikkim
State Online Lotteries for 3 (three) years or till notification of
the
amended Lottery Rules by the Ministry of Home Affairs,
Government of India
(„MHA, GOI‟
for short hereinafter
respectively) whichever is earlier.
2.
On the prayers of learned Counsel for the Petitioners
that the matter be heard urgently in view of the date of
opening of three Invitations for Expression of Interest/Tender
for appointment of Marketing Agent for marketing and sale of
the following;
(i) 5 (five) Online Weekly Lotteries per day (Part A)
Technical Bid on 30.11.2018 and Financial Bid on
05.12.2018,
(ii) 6 (six) Online Weekly Lotteries per day (Part B)
Technical Bid on 03.12.2018 and Financial Bid on
05.12.2018,
(iii) 5 (five) Online Weekly Lotteries per day (Part C)
Technical Bid on 04.12.2018 and Financial Bid on
05.12.2018,
the instant matter was taken up for hearing along with I.A.
No. 01 of 2018 which is an application seeking stay of the
impugned letter dated 27.10.2018 and the invitation of
Expression of Interest/Tender issued by the Respondent No. 1
dated 29.10.2018.
W.P. (C) No. 50 of 2018
M/s Summit Online Trade Solution (Pvt.) Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
3.
The Petitioners’ case is that they are an existing
Marketing Agency for 8 (eight) Online Lottery draws being
conducted by the State of Sikkim pursuant to an Agreement
entered into in the year 2012. Prior to the expiry of the
contract on 27.08.2017 by virtue of letter dated 18.08.2017
(Annexure P-14) the Respondent No. 2 extended the contract
for
the
reasons
that
the
Expression
of
Interest
for
appointment of Marketing Agents/Distributors for the 8 (eight)
Online Lotteries could not fructify due to implementation of
the GST and the likelihood of amendments to the Lotteries
(Regulation) Act, 2016 by the MHA, GOI. The extension of the
contract was to be till such time that the MHA, GOI notified
the amendment in the Lotteries (Regulation) Act, 2016. The
terms in the letter was accepted by the Petitioners. During the
subsistence
of
the
contract
with
the
Petitioners,
the
Respondent No. 2 on 09.07.2018 floated Online Tenders for
appointment of Marketing Agents for 8 (eight) Weekly Online
Lotteries per day (Part A). On 17.07.2018 another Tender was
floated for appointment of Marketing Agents for 8 (eight)
Weekly Online Lotteries per day (Part B). The Petitioners vide
their letter dated 17.08.2018 while bringing it to the notice of
the Respondent No. 2 that they had come to learn of the
Tenders
floated
against
the
spirit
of
the
letter
dated
18.08.2017, requested the Respondent No. 2 to allow them to
continue the sale of 8 (eight) draws of Online Lotteries allotted
to them till the MHA, GOI notified the amendments in the
W.P. (C) No. 50 of 2018
M/s Summit Online Trade Solution (Pvt.) Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
Lotteries Rules apart from which they stated that considerable
amount had been incurred by them in creating infrastructure
and publicizing the Sikkim Lotteries. The matter was duly
examined by the Respondent No. 2 and the Tenders floated on
09.07.2018 and 17.07.2018 were cancelled vide Notification
dated 18.08.2018. On 24.09.2018 a letter was issued by the
Respondent No. 2 conveying to the Petitioners the decision to
allow them to continue the distributorship for 5 (five) draws
per day out of the 8 (eight) draws earlier allotted to the
Petitioners. This was with 5% incremental increase per annum
and the Minimum Assured Revenue was placed at Rs.52,000/(Rupees fifty two thousand) only, per draw. This was accepted
by the Petitioners vide letter dated 08.10.2018. However,
following this circumstance, the Respondent No. 2 issued
letter dated 27.10.2018 intimating the Petitioners that the
State Government had decided to invite Expression of Interest
through open tenders for selection of Marketing Agents for a
total of 16 (sixteen) Online Weekly Lotteries. Further the
distributorship of the Petitioners for 8 (eight) Online Lotteries
per day would be an interim arrangement till such time the
appointment of a new marketing agent would be finalized.
The Petitioners were required to send a confirmation letter if
the terms were accepted failing which the distributorship
would be terminated summarily. The Petitioners responded on
01.11.2018
accepting
the
conditions
laid
down
by
the
Respondent No. 2 in the impugned communication dated
W.P. (C) No. 50 of 2018
M/s Summit Online Trade Solution (Pvt.) Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
27.10.2018 but at the same time requested the Government
to review their decision and allow continuation of their
distributorship as per the letter of the Respondent No. 2 dated
24.09.2018. Subsequently on 12.11.2018, the Petitioners
submitted a representation to
the
Respondents seeking
continuation of Online Lotteries till the amendment in the
Lotteries (Regulation) Act/Rules in terms of the letters dated
18.08.2017 and 24.09.2018 to which no response was
received, hence the instant petition and I.A. with the prayers
as reflected hereinabove.
4.
Learned Counsel for the Petitioners, reiterating the facts
averred in the petition, drew the attention of this Court to the
correspondence that ensued between the Respondent No. 2
and
the
Petitioners.
That
vide
correspondence
dated
18.08.2017, Respondent No. 2 had extended the contract of
the Petitioners of the distributorship of 8 (eight) online
lotteries which was otherwise to expire on 27.08.2017. The
Petitioner Company accepted the terms duly endorsing it with
the signature of Naresh Mangal, a Director of the Company, on
the body of the letter. Attention of the Court was also drawn
to the correspondence addressed to the Respondent No. 2
dated 17.08.2018 by the Petitioners submitting therein that
despite the proposal made in the letter dated 18.08.2017 and
the acceptance of the Petitioners, the Respondent No. 2 had
invited tenders for the Lotteries being marketed by the
W.P. (C) No. 50 of 2018
M/s Summit Online Trade Solution (Pvt.) Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
Petitioners contrary to the spirit of the said letter. Learned
Counsel contended that pursuant to the extension of contract
considerable
amount
had
been
spent
on
creating
infrastructure and publicizing the Sikkim State Lotteries,
hence the principles of promissory estoppel would, therefore,
apply in the instant matter. To fortify this submission, learned
Counsel sought to garner strength from the decision in M/s
Motilal Padampat Sugar Mills Co. Ltd. v. State of Uttar Pradesh and
Others1.
5.
It was also exposited by learned Counsel for the
Petitioners
that
on
24.09.2018,
the
Respondent
No.
informed the Petitioners that the tenders floated in respect of
total 16 (sixteen) Online Lotteries dated 09.07.2018 and
17.07.2018 had been cancelled vide Notification of the
Department
dated
18.08.2018.
Consequent
thereto
the
Government offered continuation of distributorship of 5 (five)
out of the 8 (eight) Online Lotteries for a period of 3 (three)
years or till notification of the amended Lottery Rules by the
MHA, GOI, whichever was earlier. This was duly accepted by
the Petitioners on 08.10.2018. In contra thereto, during the
period
of
such
subsistence,
the
Respondent
No.
on
27.10.2018 issued the impugned letter wherein the Petitioners
were informed that the Government had now decided to invite
Expression of Interest for selection of Marketing Agents for 16
(1979) 2 Supreme Court Cases 409
W.P. (C) No. 50 of 2018
M/s Summit Online Trade Solution (Pvt.) Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
(sixteen) Online Lotteries. However, in the interim till such
time the appointment of a new Marketing Agent was finalized,
the Petitioners were to continue distributorship of the Online
Lotteries allotted to them. Due to apprehension that they
would lose their distributorship, under duress the Petitioners
vide their letter dated 12.11.2018 accepted the terms set out
in the impugned letter dated 27.10.2018. That the contract
between the parties can be rescinded only if all the terms as
detailed in Clause 19.4 of the agreement dated 09.11.2012
between the Petitioners and the Respondents are fulfilled viz.;
“(a) Fraudulent conduct in sale of lottery tickets
by the Marketing Agent;
(b) Any act of misconduct or malfeasance on the
part of Marketing Agent;
(c) Erratic running of lottery without any
sufficient cause;
(d) The conviction of the Marketing Agent.”
That none of the above conditions have ensued to rescind the
contract. In any event, even if such conditions are fulfilled
which is not so in the instant matter, 15 (fifteen) days notice
are to be issued to the concerned party by the Respondents.
6.
It
is
urged
that
there
is
no
revocation
of
the
communication dated 18.08.2017 and the offer letter dated
24.09.2018 or termination of the agreement entered into
between the Petitioners and the Governor of Sikkim, hence,
the impugned Tenders could not have been floated. That in
the absence of amendment of the Lotteries (Regulation)
Act/Rules, the invitation for bids during the subsistence of
W.P. (C) No. 50 of 2018
M/s Summit Online Trade Solution (Pvt.) Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
Agreement between the Petitioners and the Respondents is
irrational, arbitrary and violates the fundamental rights of the
Petitioners. Moreover, the extension letter dated 18.08.2017
and offer for continuation of distributorship of lotteries with
revised rates dated 24.09.2018 is in the nature of an
agreement
between
the
parties
and
binding
on
the
Respondents and the sudden floating of tenders have seriously
prejudiced the rights and interests of the Petitioners. That the
facts and circumstances establish that the Petitioners are
entitled to the reliefs claimed.
7.
The Respondents No. 1 and 2 appeared on advance
notice and waived formal notice.
8.
Mr. J.B. Pradhan, Additional Advocate General, making
submissions for the Respondents No. 1 and 2 argued that in
the first instance, the question of promissory estoppel would
not apply as the Petitioners had been distributors and
Marketing Agents of lotteries since the year 2005 and have all
required infrastructure in place and would thereby not have
incurred any added expenditure. That an earlier agreement
between the parties dated 09.05.2005 was extended on
09.11.2012 vide which the term was extended for a further
period of 5 (five) years and 110 (one hundred and ten) days
w.e.f. 09.05.2012 to 26.08.2017 for marketing and sale of 8
(eight)
Online
Lottery
Schemes
as
approved
by
the
Government from time to time. Admittedly, the letter dated
W.P. (C) No. 50 of 2018
M/s Summit Online Trade Solution (Pvt.) Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
18.08.2017 was issued by the Respondent No. 2 extending the
contract of the Petitioners till the MHA notified amendment in
the Lotteries Act, however pursuant to this letter, the letter
dated 27.10.2018 came to be issued to the Petitioners by the
Respondent No. 2. The letter specified that the Petitioners
were to continue distributorship of 8 (eight) Online Lotteries
as an “interim arrangement” till such time the appointment of
a new Marketing Agent was finalized. The letter also specified
that in the event of acceptance of the terms, a confirmation
letter was to be sent by the Petitioners on or before
01.11.2018
(4
distributorship
p.m.)
failing
would
be
which
continuation
terminated
of
the
summarily.
The
Petitioners, vide response dated 01.11.2018 categorically
accepted the terms by stating inter alia that they accept the
offer of the Respondents for continuation of 8 (eight) Weekly
Online Lotteries as an interim arrangement till such time the
appointment of a new Marketing Agent is finalized. This fact is
also evident from the contents of the letter dated 12.11.2018
addressed to the Respondents where the Petitioners have
stated that they have given their acceptance for continuation
of distributorship of draws in protest with a request to review
the same for continuation of distributorship in terms of the
letters dated 18.08.2017 and 24.09.2018. In light of such
awareness and acceptance of terms of the Respondent No. 2,
the Petitioners cannot now turn back and state that the
decision of the Respondents was arbitrary or irrational. That
W.P. (C) No. 50 of 2018
M/s Summit Online Trade Solution (Pvt.) Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
despite the Petitioners’ awareness of Tenders being floated on
09.07.2018 and 17.07.2018, no protest was put forth by them
at the relevant time or at any subsequent time. The
Respondent No. 2 was constrained to withdraw the said
Tenders when certain contingencies arose and offered the
Petitioners continuity of distributorship but this in no manner
tantamounts
to
allowing
the
Petitioners
to
continue
in
perpetuity.
9.
Learned Additional Advocate General would further
canvass
that
nothing
prevented
the
Petitioners
from
participating in the bids dated 09.07.2018 and 17.07.2018
when the Tenders were floated as admittedly they had
purchased Tender Forms thereby indicating intention to
participate in the said bids. That the Tenders have been
floated in larger public interest as there cannot be a loss of
public revenue. Hence, in view of the facts and circumstances
brought to the notice of this Court, it is apparent that the
petition is a chance petition. Moreover as the Petitioners
contend that the contract between the parties have been
violated no remedy obtains to them under Article 226 of the
Constitution. It is prayed that the petition deserves no
consideration and be dismissed with exemplary costs.
10.
I have heard at length and considered carefully the
submissions put forth by the parties. Documents relied on by
the Petitioners have been meticulously examined by me.
W.P. (C) No. 50 of 2018
M/s Summit Online Trade Solution (Pvt.) Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
11.
Admittedly,
the
contract
of
the
Petitioners
for
distributing/marketing 8 (eight) Online Lotteries pursuant to
an Agreement entered into in the year 2012 was extended by
the Respondent No. 2 by virtue of letter dated 18.08.2017
(Annexure
P-14)
till
such
time
the
MHA
notified
the
amendment in the Lotteries (Regulation) Act, 2016. It is urged
that communication dated 18.08.2017 was not revoked. On
this aspect, it is pertinent to notice that the last but one
paragraph of the letter reads as follows;
“...Further, Govt. of Sikkim will invite fresh
Expression of Interest as soon as MHA notifies
the amendment in the Lotteries (Regulation) Act.
The State Govt. also reserve (sic) to discontinue
this Agreement at any time without assigning
any reason thereof.”
In other words, the Respondent No. 2 has unequivocally by
the
correspondence
stated
with
clarity
that
the
State
Government reserves its right to discontinue the existing
agreement with the Petitioners at any time without assigning
any reason thereof, thereby indicating to the Petitioners the
stand of the Respondents to which evidently no attention was
afforded by the Petitioners. During the subsistence of the
agreement supra admittedly Online Tenders were invited for
appointment of Marketing Agents for the Weekly Online
Lotteries as detailed in the Tender bids dated 09.07.2018 and
17.07.2018. It is not the case of the Petitioners that they were
unaware of the aforestated invitation for bids put forth by the
Respondent No. 2. Although letter dated 17.08.2018 came to
W.P. (C) No. 50 of 2018
M/s Summit Online Trade Solution (Pvt.) Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
be issued by the Petitioners the contents thereof appear to be
a whimper and does not voice the alleged protest of the
Petitioners. The relevant portion reads as follows;
“...Recently, it has come to our notice that
the Directorate of State lotteries has invited
tenders for online lotteries which is against the
spirit of the above said letter. Kindly note that
we have spent a considerable amount in creating
infrastructure and publicizing the Sikkim State
lotteries and sudden announcement of inviting
tenders has come to us as a shock. Therefore,
you are requested to kindly continue to allow
eight draws of online lotteries allotted to us till
the MHA notifies the amendment in the Lotteries
(Regulation) Rules so there will be no loss of
revenue to the State exchequer.”
The Petitioners have only expressed shock at the floating of
the tenders and thereafter requested continuation of their
distributorship. Evidently no protest has been voiced. The
Petitioners, as pointed out by the learned Additional Advocate
General, failed to lodge a protest with the Respondent No. 2
although at the relevant time, the agreement between the
Petitioners and the Respondents was subsisting. On the
inability of the Respondent No. 2 to carry out the Tender bids
to its logical end, the said Tenders floated came to be
cancelled vide notification dated 18.08.2018. It is evident that
till 18.08.2018 or for that matter even till 24.09.2018 when
another letter came to be issued by the Respondent No. 2
offering the Petitioners continuance of the distributorship by
setting out new terms and conditions, no protest was lodged
by the Petitioners before the Respondent No. 2. The letter
dated 24.09.2018 offered the Petitioners continuation of
W.P. (C) No. 50 of 2018
M/s Summit Online Trade Solution (Pvt.) Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
distributorship of 5 (five) instead of the 8 (eight) Online
Lotteries per day setting out new terms and conditions viz. the
Minimum Assured Revenue was to be Rs.52,000/- (Rupees
fifty two thousand) only per draw with 5% incremental
increase per annum.
12.
The impugned letter dated 27.10.2018 specifically states
as follows;
“... In regard to this, it is to inform you
that the State Government has now decided to
invite Expression of Interest through Open
tenders for selection of Marketing Agents for a
total of 16 (Sixteen) Online Weekly Lotteries per
day in the ratio of 6:5:5 in view of the
observation made by the State Law Commission.
Further, the State Government has also
approved for continuation of distributorship of
the 08 (Eight) weekly Online Lotteries per day at
the revised rate of ₹52,000/- per draw and draw
expenses of ₹3,000/- per draw, as an interim
arrangement, till such time the appointment of a
new Marketing Agent is finalized.
In view of this, you are directed to
continue marketing and sale 08 (Eight) weekly
online lotteries of the Sikkim State at the
revised rate of ₹52,000/- per draw and
₹3,000/- per draw which will deem to have
come into effect from 11.10.2018 till such time
the appointment of a new Marketing Agent is
finalised.
In the event of acceptance, a confirmation
letter may be sent on or before 01.11.2018
(4.00 PM) failing which continuation of the
distributorship shall be terminated summarily.
...”
13.
In response thereto, the Petitioners submitted the letter
dated 01.11.2018 wherein they have inter alia stated;
“We are in receipt of your letter
No.789/FIN/DSSL/III/2018-19/358
dated
27.10.2018
regarding
continuation
of
distributorship of the 08 (eight) weekly online
lotteries per day at the revised rate of
W.P. (C) No. 50 of 2018
M/s Summit Online Trade Solution (Pvt.) Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
Rs.52,000/- per draw and draw expenses of
Rs.3,000/- per draw, as an interim arrangement
till such time the appointment of a new
Marketing Agent is finalized and the Government
has further decided to come out with the
Expression of Interest for 16 online weekly
lotteries in the ratio of 6:5:5.
We
hereby
accept
your
offer
for
continuation of distributorship for 08 (eight)
weekly online lotteries.
We further would like to state that we are
associated with the Government of Sikkim since
2005 and successfully marketing Sikkim State
lotteries and request you to kindly review your
decision and continue our distributorship as per
your letter No.789/FIN/DSSL/III/2018-19/325
dated 24.09.2018.”
This letter speaks for itself, lucidly indicating the willingness of
the Petitioners to continue distributorship of 8 (eight) Weekly
Online Lotteries as an interim arrangement. A request follows
for review of the decision.
14.
The averments of the Petitioners as also the submissions
put forth by learned Counsel for the Petitioners would also
indicate that although the Petitioners were
appalled to
discover that the Respondents had vide the impugned letter
dated 27.10.2018 sought the response of the Petitioners on or
before
01.11.2018, the Respondents made an interim
arrangement with the Petitioners viz. that the Petitioners
would
continue
time
the
appointment of a new Marketing Agent was finalized.
The
Petitioners
their
admittedly
distributorship
apprehending
till
such
discontinuation
of
lotteries and termination of the agreement submitted their
acceptance vide letter dated 01.11.2018 although requesting
W.P. (C) No. 50 of 2018
M/s Summit Online Trade Solution (Pvt.) Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
the Government to review the decision allowing them to
continue as
distributors in terms of the letter dated
24.09.2018.
15.
What emerges, therefore, from the entire gamut of the
facts and circumstances placed before this Court is that
although the
contract between the
Petitioners and
the
Respondents was renewed up to 26.08.2017, in the interim
Tenders were floated for 16 (sixteen) Online Lotteries on
09.07.2018 and 17.07.2018 of which distributorship of 8
(eight) had earlier been given to the Petitioners and was
subsequently reduced to 5 (five) vide letter dated 24.09.2018.
When these Tenders were floated, no protest was made. Vide
letter dated 18.08.2018, the Tenders so floated were cancelled
on
account
of
the
contingencies
enumerated
in
the
correspondence. This afforded the Petitioners sufficient time to
protest against the actions of the Respondents but they were
evidently rendered immobile for reasons best to them. In any
event, the understatement is that admittedly the conditions
mentioned in the impugned letter dated 27.10.2018 allowing
the Petitioners to operate as distributors as an interim
arrangement
till
finalization
of
a
Marketing
Agent
was
accepted by the Petitioners. They cannot therefore having
accepted the condition once now claim that it was on
apprehension of losing their distributorship. In New Bihar Biri
W.P. (C) No. 50 of 2018
M/s Summit Online Trade Solution (Pvt.) Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
Leaves Co. and Others v. State of Bihar and others2, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held that;
“48. It is a fundamental principle of general
application that if a person of his own accord,
accepts a contract on certain terms and works
out the contract, he cannot be allowed to adhere
to and abide by some of the terms of the
contract which proved advantageous to him and
repudiate the other terms of the same contract
which might be disadvantageous to him. The
maxim is qui approbat non reprobate (one who
approbates cannot reprobate). This principle,
though originally borrowed from Scots Law, is
now firmly embodied in English Common Law.
According to it, a party to an instrument or
transaction cannot take advantage of one part of
a document or transaction and reject the rest.
That is to say, no party can accept and reject
the same instrument or transaction. ...”
16.
In
Cauvery
Coffee
Traders
v.
Hornor
Resources
(International) Co. Ltd.3, the Hon’ble Supreme Court would hold
that;
“...”34. A party cannot be permitted to „blow hot
and cold‟, „fast and loose‟ or „approbate and
reprobate‟. Where one knowingly accepts the
benefits of a contract or conveyance or an order,
is estopped to deny the validity or binding effect
on him of such contract or conveyance or order.
This rule is applied to do equity, however, it
must not be applied in a manner as to violate
the principles of right and good conscience. ...
35. ... The doctrine of estoppels by election
is one of the species of estoppels in pais (or
equitable estoppels), which is a rule in equity. By
that law, a person may be precluded by his
actions or conduct or silence when it is his duty
to speak, from asserting a right which he
otherwise would have had.”...”
The Petitioners cannot therefore approbate and reprobate on
this issue. That apart, the impugned letter was issued on
(1981) 1 SCC 537
50 (2011) 10 SCC 420
W.P. (C) No. 50 of 2018
M/s Summit Online Trade Solution (Pvt.) Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
27.10.2018 affording the Petitioners sufficient time thereby to
take steps. They have filed a response to the impugned letter
of the Respondent No. 2 on 01.11.2018 and another letter on
12.11.2018 besides which they were well aware of the dates
when the tender bids were to be opened and cannot claim
urgency belatedly. Added to this is the admission that tender
forms were purchased by them and nothing prevented the
Petitioners from competing in the bids.
17.
So far as the question of rescinding the contract
between the parties is concerned, in State of U.P. and Others v.
Bridge & Roof Company (India) Ltd. 4, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
pronounced as follows;
“16. Firstly, the contract between the
parties is a contract in the realm of private law.
It is not a statutory contract. It is governed by
the provisions of the Contract Act or, maybe,
also by certain provisions of the Sale of Goods
Act. Any dispute relating to interpretation of the
terms and conditions of such a contract cannot
be agitated, and could not have been agitated,
in a writ petition. That is a matter either for
arbitration as provided by the contract or for the
civil court, as the case may be. Whether any
amount is due to the respondent from the
appellant-Government under the contract and, if
so, how much and the further question whether
retention or refusal to pay any amount by the
Government is justified, or not, are all matters
which cannot be agitated in or adjudicated upon
in a writ petition. The prayer in the writ petition,
viz., to restrain the Government from deducting
a particular amount from the writ petitioner‟s
bill(s) was not a prayer which could be granted
by the high Court under Article 226. Indeed, the
High Court has not granted the said prayer.
....................................................................
(1996) 6 SCC 22
W.P. (C) No. 50 of 2018
M/s Summit Online Trade Solution (Pvt.) Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
18. Accordingly, it must be held that the writ
petition filed by the respondent for the issuance
of a writ of mandamus restraining the
Government from deducting or withholding a
particular sum, which according to the
respondent is payable to it under the contract,
was
wholly
misconceived
and
was not
maintainable in law. ...”
The ratio is self-explanatory.
18.
On the question of promissory estoppel raised by the
Petitioners, the doctrine is an equitable doctrine evolved by
equity in order to prevent injustice when a promise is made by
a person knowing that it would be acted on by the person to
whom it was made and in fact has so acted on it. It would in
such a circumstance be inequitable to allow the party making
the promise to go back upon it. As earlier pointed out, the
Government has set out unequivocally in its letter dated
18.08.2017 that it could discontinue the agreement at any
time without assigning any reason. It is asserted
that the
Petitioners have been in the business since 2005 hence it can
safely be assumed that logistics were in place and
any
additional
be
expenditure
incurred
subsequently
cannot
termed as loss making or inequitable. What looms large of
course is the fact of acceptance of conditions by the
Petitioners as laid down by the Respondent No. 2 in the
impugned letter dated 27.10.2018.
19.
In view of the aforestated facts and circumstances that
have emerged and also bearing in mind the well-established
principles of law governing the grant of stay, I am of the
W.P. (C) No. 50 of 2018
M/s Summit Online Trade Solution (Pvt.) Ltd. and Anr.
Vs. The State of Sikkim and Anr.
opinion that no case is made out for stay of the impugned
letter dated 27.10.2018. No grounds also emanate for setting
aside the letter dated 27.10.2018 and the invitation for
Expression of Interest/Tender dated 29.10.2018 and in view of
the acceptance of the terms and conditions set forth in the
impugned letter dated 27.10.2018, the question of directing
the Respondents to abide by the correspondence dated
18.08.2017 and letter dated 24.09.2018 does not arise.
Hence, the Petitioners are not entitled to any of the reliefs
claimed.
20.
The petition hereby stands rejected and W.P. (C) No. 50
of 2018 disposed of accordingly as also the I.A. No. 01 of
2018.
21.
Certified copies be made available to the parties, as per
Rules.
(Meenakshi Madan Rai)
Judge
29.11.2018
Approved for reporting: Yes
Internet: Yes
ml
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review