The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. As such, there is merit in this writ petition filed by the petitioner. The same is to be allowed.
14. In result, this writ petition filed by the petitioner is allowed. The impugned order dated 22.08.2025(Annexure-1) passed in Suo Motu Mutation Case No.7482 of 2025 by the Additional Tahasildar, Bhubanswar(Opposite Party No.5) and the correction of SATWA STATUS in the RoR vide Khata No.474/4108 are quashed. Due to the quashing of the Annexure-1 as well as the change of SATWA STATUS in the RoR of the case land vide Khata No.474/4108, the Additional Tahasildar, Bhubaneswar (Opposite Party No.5) is directed through issuance of writ of mandamus for preparation of the RoR of Khata No.474/4108, Plot No.516/1759 in Mouza-Patia in the name of the petitioner correcting the SATWA STATUS thereof from “PATTADAR” to “STHITIBAN” and to keep/maintain the same as it was prior to the passing of the impugned order dated 22.08.2025 (Annexure-1) as “STHITIBAN” and the Additional Tahasildar, Bhubaneswar(Opposite Party No.5) is also directed to correct the Satwa in the RoR of Khata No.474/4108 preparing the same reflecting its SATWA STATUS as “STHITIBAN” in the name of the petitioner within a period of one week positively from the date of production of the certified copy of this judgment before the Opposite Party No.5.
15. As such, this writ petition filed by the petitioner is disposed of finally. ( A.C. Behera ) Judge Orissa High Court, Cuttack The 22nd of January, 2026/ Jagabandhu, P.A. Designation: Personal Assistant Reason: Authentication Location: OHC, CUTTACK
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No.37178 of 2025
(In the matter of an application under Articles 226
and 227 of the Constitution of India)
M/s. Shyam Shree Residency ….
Pvt. Ltd., Khurda
Petitioner
-versusState of Odisha, represented ….
by
Principal
Secretary,
Revenue
and
Disaster
Management
Department,
Government
of
Odisha,
Bhubaneswar and others
Opposite Parties
Appeared in this case:For Petitioner
:
Mr. Abhishek Dash, Advocate
For Opposite Parties
:
Mr. G. Mohanty,
Learned Standing Counsel
CORAM:
JUSTICE A.C. BEHERA
JUDGMENT
Date of hearing : 24.12.2025 / date of judgment : 22.01.2026
A.C. Behera, J. This writ petition under Articles 226 and 227 of the
Constitution of India, 1950 has been filed by the petitioner
praying
for
quashing
22.08.2025(Annexure-1)
the
impugned
passed
by
order
the
dated
Additional
Tahasildar, Bhubaneswar(Opposite Party No.5) in Suo Motu
Mutation
Case
No.7482
of
and
to
direct
the
Tahasildar, Bhubaneswar(Opposite Party No.4) to keep the
SATWA
STATUS
in
the
RoR
of
the
case
land
as
“STHITIBAN”, which was prior to the passing of the
impugned order dated 22.08.2025(Annexure-1).
2.
As per the case of the petitioner, the case land was
settled in the name of one Sitabai Gupta for agricultural
purposes by the Government under a permanent lease in
W.L. Case No.2003/78. The said permanent lease of the
case land for agricultural purposes in favour of Sitabai
Gupta was confirmed as per order dated 09.11.2006 passed
in RC No.13/81 by the Additional District Magistrate,
Bhubaneswar(Opposite Party No.3).
When, the permanent lessee of the case land, i.e.,
Sitabai Gupta died leaving behind the vendors of the
petitioner as successors, for which, the vendors of the
petitioner inherited the case land from Sitabai Gupta as
successors of Sitabai Gupta. The successors of Sitabai
Gupta being the vendors sold the case land to the petitioner
through a registered sale deed dated 14.12.2010 vide
Annexure-3 and delivered possession thereof. Accordingly,
since the date of purchase, i.e., since 14.12.2010, the
petitioner possessed the case land exercising all rights
thereon like its vendors. Then, the petitioner converted the
case land from agricultural purpose to non-agricultural
purpose, i.e., to homestead(Gharabari) as per the final order
passed in a conversion proceeding vide OLR Case No.4993
of 2011 under Section 8-A of the OLR Act, 1960.
Accordingly, the RoR of the case land vide Khata
No.474/4108, Plot No.516/1759(Annexure-4) was prepared
under „sthitiban status‟ having its kisam as „gharabari‟ in
the name of the petitioner. That RoR vide Annexure-4 in the
name of the petitioner was not challenged by anybody
including the State. Accordingly, the petitioner had been
paying rent of the case land in its name through valid rent
receipts.
Surprisingly, the Additional Tahasildar, Bhubaneswar
(Opposite Party No.5) initiated a Suo Motu Mutation Case
No.7482 of 2025 on the basis of a letter of Revenue and
Disaster Management Department vide Letter No.RDMCHS-PGOT-0303-2020-23868/R&DM
dated
02.07.2025
(Annexure-5) and corrected/changed the SATWA STATUS in
the RoR of the case land vide Khata No.474/4108, Plot
No.516/1759 (Annexure-4) as per impugned order dated
22.08.2025(Annexure-1) passed in Suo Motu Mutation Case
No.7482 of 2025 from “STHITIBAN” to “PATTADAR” and on
the
basis
of
such
impugned
order
dated
22.08.2025(Annexure-1), the SATWA Column in the RoR of
the
case
land
was
changed
from
“STHITIBAN”
to
“PATTADAR”. The changed/corrected impugned RoR is
Annexure-2.
3.
For which, the petitioner filed this writ petition
challenging
the
22.08.2025(Anenxure-1)
impugned
passed
order
by
the
dated
Additional
Tahasildar, Bhubaneswar(Opposite Party No.5) in Suo Motu
Mutation Case No.7482 of 2025 as well as challenging to
the changed/corrected impugned RoR vide Annexure-2 by
filing this writ petition under Articles 226 and 227 of the
Constitution of India, 1950 praying for quashing the
Annexures-1 and 2 on the ground that, the Annexures-1
and 2 are not legally sustainable.
4.
I have already heard from the learned counsel for the
petitioner and the learned Standing Counsel for the State.
5.
It is the undisputed case of the parties that, prior to
the passing of the impugned order dated 22.08.2025
(Annexure-1) in Suo Motu Mutation Case No.7482 of 2025
by the Additional Tahasilar, Bhubaneswar(Opposite Party
No.5), the SATWA STATUS in the RoR of the case land vide
Khata No.474/4108, Plot No.516/1759 as per Annexure-4
was “STHITIBAN”, to which, the Additional Tahasildar,
Bhubaneswar(Opposite Party No.5) changed/corrected on
the basis of the impugned order dated 22.08.2025 passed
in Suo Motu Mutation Case No.7482 of 2025 from
“STHITIBAN” to “PATTADAR” as per the notification issued
by the Revenue and Disaster Management Department,
Government of Odisha vide Letter No.RDM-CHS-PGOT0303-2020-23868/R&DM dated 02.07.2025 (Annexure-5).
6.
The law concerning the legal effect of the resolutions
and notification of the Government has already been
clarified in the ratio of the following decisions:(i)
In a case between Ex-Capt. K.C. Arora and
another vrs. State of Haryana and others passed in
Writ Petition Nos.6436-37 of 1980 and Civil appeal
Nos.3095-96 of 1980 decided on 26th April, 1984 that,
accrued rights cannot be taken away by Government by
making amendment of the rules with retrospective
effect.
(ii)
In a case between State of Gujarat and another
vrs. Raman Lal Keshav Lal Soni and others :
reported in (1983) 2 SCC-33 that,
Government cannot take away the accrued rights of the
petitioner and the appellant by making amendment of
the Rules with retrospective effect.
(iii)
In a case between State of Madhya Pradesh vrs.
Yogendra Srivastava : reported in (2010) 12 SCC-538
that,
rights and benefits which have already been earned or
acquired under the existing Rules cannot be taken away
by amending the Rules with retrospective effect.
(iv)
In a case between Baisnab Charan Panda and
others vrs. State of Orissa and others : reported in
130(2020) CLT-564 that,
the resolution should have been prospective and could
not have been taken away the benefit already accrued to
the party without involving the person likely to be
affected in such process.
(v)
In a case between Kamal Kishore vrs. State and
others ; reported in (1995) 02 J&K CK 0008 that,
the accrued rights and the benefits vested cannot be
taken away be amendment to rules retrospectively.
(vi)
In a case between Prestige Estates Projects
Limited, through its Vice President, The Falcon
House, No.1 Main Guard Cross Road, Bangalore vrs.
State of Tamilnadu and another(Madras) passed in
W.P. Nos.25677 and 25678 of 2012 decided on
13.12.2012 that,
accrued rights cannot be taken away by subsequent
amendment/orders of the authorities.
(vii) In a case between Chandra Prakash Rath vrs.
State of Odisha and others decided on 14.11.2025
in W.P.(C) No.31150 of 2025 Para No.7 that,
rights which has accrued to a person much prior to the
notification made by the Government, such right cannot
be taken away through any subsequent notification of
the Government.
7.
In view of the propositions of law settled in the ratio of
the aforesaid decisions, the operation of all notifications
and resolutions of the Government are prospective in
nature, but, the same will have no retrospective effect.
8.
It is the judicial coronary that, when initial order is
held to be illegal, then, the documents/orders prepared on
the basis of the said initial orders shall be deemed to be
non-est in the eye of law.
On this aspect, the propositions of law has already
been clarified in the ratio of the following decisions :(i)
In a case between Badrinath vrs. Government of
Tamilnadu and others : reported in (2000) 8 SCC-395
that,
once the basis of a proceeding is gone, may be at a later
point of time by order of a superior authority, any
intermediate action taken in the meantime would fall to
the ground. This principle of consequential orders which
is applicable to judicial and quashi-judicial proceedings
is equally applicable to administrative orders.
(ii)
In a case between State of Kerala vrs.
Puthenkavu N.S.S. Karayuogam and another :
reported in (2001) 10 SCC-191 that,
once the main impugned order is set aside any other
consequential order made pursuant to the same would
automatically become ineffective.(Para 9)
(iii)
In a case between Mangal Prasad Tamoli(dead)
by LRs. vrs. Narvadeshwar Mishra(dead) by LRs. :
reported in (2005) 3 SCC-422 that,
if remand order was bad under law, then all further
proceedings consequent thereto would be non-est and
have to be necessarily set aside.
(iv)
In a case between State of Punjab vrs. Davinder
Pal Singh Bhullar and others etc. : reported in
2012(51) OCR (SC)-220 that,
if initial action is not consonance with law, all
subsequent and consequential proceedings would fall
through for the reasons that illegality strikes at the root
of the order.
9.
In addition to the above argument of the learned
counsel
for
the
petitioner
relating
to
the
lack
of
retrospective effect of the Notification No.23868/R&DM
dated 02.07.2025 of the Government, his second limb of
argument was that, even otherwise the Notification dated
02.07.2025 can have no applicability to the given facts
relating to the lease lands granted for agricultural purpose
in W. L. Cases under the OGLS Act as per the prevailing
lease principles then holding the field like the W.L. Case
No.2003/78 in this matter at hand in respect of the case
land, it was pointed out by him that,
Section 4(f) of the
OLR Act, 1960 confers heritable right upon the settlee of
the case land and also confers alienable right in favour of
the settlee after the lock period of ten years for its nonalienation. The Para No.26 of the Letter No.22206 dated
19.06.2025 of the Government also in support of conversion
of agricultural lease hold land like the case land from
agricultural purposes to non-agricultural purposes as per
Section 8-A of the OLR Act. According to him, when, the
alienation of the case land has been made much after ten
years of the settlement of the case land in favour of the
predecessor of the vendors of the petitioner in W.L. Case
No.2003/78 and when, the conversion of the case land from
agriculture purpose to homestead purpose has been made
by the order of the Tahasildar, Bhubaneswar in OLR Case
No.4993 of 2011 under Section 8-A of the OLR Act and
when, the aforesaid conversion and alienation of the case
land and preparation of the RoR of the case land vide
Annexure-4 in favour of the petitioner were inconformity
with
law,
for
which,
the
impugned
order
dated
22.08.2025(Annexure-1) passed by the Opposite Party No.5
in Suo Motu Mutation Case No.7482 of 2025 and the
consequential change in the RoR of the case on the basis of
the said Annexure-1 cannot be sustainable under law.
10. The aforesaid arguments of the learned counsel for the
petitioner on the basis of the aforesaid decisions, provisions
of law envisaged in Section 4 of the OLR Act, 1960 and
Letter
No.22206
Department,
dated
Government
19.06.2025
of
the
of
for
making
Odisha
R&DM
the
impugned order dated 22.08.2025(Annexure-1) passed in
Suo Motu Mutation Case No.7482 of 2025 by the Additional
Tahasildar, Bhubaneswar (Opposite Party No.5) as well as
the impugned correction of the SATWA STATUS in the RoR
of the case land in Khata No.474/4108 from “STHITIBAN”
to “PATTADAR” as unsustainable under law cannot be held
as inacceptable under law.
11. Here in this matter at hand, when much prior to the
passing
of
the
impugned
order
dated
22.08.2025
(Annexure-1) in Suo Motu Mutation Case No.7482 of 2025
and when, much prior to the correction of SATWA status in
the RoR vide Khata No.474/4108 from “STHITIBAN” to
“PATTADAR”, the RoR of the Khata No.474/4108 was
continuing in the name of the petitioner under “STHITIBAN
SATWA STATUS” on being prepared by the Tahasildar,
Bhubaneswar(Opposite Party No.4) since the year 2011,
then
at
this
juncture,
as
per
the
order
dated
22.08.2025(Annexure-1) passed in Suo Motu Mutation Case
No.7482 of 2025(Annexure-1), the Additional Tahasildar,
Bhubaneswar(Opposite
Party
No.5)
should
not
have
changed the SATWA STATUS of Khata No.474/4108 from
“STHITIBAN” to “PATTADAR” on the basis of the subsequent
notification dated 02.07.2025(Annexure-5).
For
which,
the
impugned
order
dated
22.08.2025(Annexure-1) passed in Suo Motu Mutation Case
No.7482 of 2025 as well as correction of SATWA STATUS in
the RoR of the case land vide Khata No.474/4108 from
“STHITIBAN” to “PATTADAR” cannot be sustainable under
law.
12. Therefore, there is justification under law for making
interference
with
the
impugned
order
dated
22.08.2025(Annexure-1) passed in Suo Motu Mutation Case
No.7482
of
by
the
Additional
Tahasildar,
Bhubaneswar(Opposite Party No.5) as well as with the
correction of SATWA STATUS in the RoR vide Khata
No.474/4108 from
“STHITIBAN” to “PATTADAR” through
this writ petition filed by the petitioner.
13. As such, there is merit in this writ petition filed by the
petitioner. The same is to be allowed.
14. In result, this writ petition filed by the petitioner is
allowed.
The impugned order dated 22.08.2025(Annexure-1)
passed in Suo Motu Mutation Case No.7482 of 2025 by the
Additional Tahasildar, Bhubanswar(Opposite Party No.5)
and the correction of SATWA STATUS in the RoR vide Khata
No.474/4108 are quashed.
Due to the quashing of the Annexure-1 as well as the
change of SATWA STATUS in the RoR of the case land vide
Khata
No.474/4108,
the
Additional
Tahasildar,
Bhubaneswar (Opposite Party No.5) is directed through
issuance of writ of mandamus for preparation of the RoR of
Khata No.474/4108, Plot No.516/1759 in Mouza-Patia in
the name of the petitioner correcting the SATWA STATUS
thereof
from
“PATTADAR”
to
“STHITIBAN”
and
to
keep/maintain the same as it was prior to the passing of
the impugned order dated 22.08.2025 (Annexure-1) as
“STHITIBAN”
and
the
Additional
Tahasildar,
Bhubaneswar(Opposite Party No.5) is also directed to
correct
the
Satwa
STATUS
in
the
RoR
of
Khata
No.474/4108 preparing the same reflecting its SATWA
STATUS as “STHITIBAN” in the name of the petitioner
within a period of one week positively from the date of
production of the certified copy of this judgment before the
Opposite Party No.5.
15. As such, this writ petition filed by the petitioner is
disposed of finally.
( A.C. Behera )
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack
The 22nd of January, 2026/ Jagabandhu, P.A.
Digitally Signed
Signed by: JAGABANDHU BEHERA
Designation: Personal Assistant
Reason: Authentication
Location: OHC, CUTTACK
Date: 27-Jan-2026 07:56:00
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review