Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
VS,J
MACMA_512 of 2022
APHC010649262022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3333]
TUESDAY,THE TWENTY FOURTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 512/2022
Between:
1. M/S.SHRIRAM GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED,
REPRESENTED BY ITS LEGAL MANAGER, T.P. CLAIMS, E-8, EPIP,
RIICO, INDUSTRIAL AREA (NEAR MKM COLLEGE), SITAPURA,
JAIPUR - 302 022, RAJASTHAN STATE. (INSURER OF TRACTOR
BEARING NO. AP31 TX 3314, TRAILER BEARING NO . AP31 BB
6162) (POLICY NO . 10003/31/17/262488 VALID FROM 12-09-2016
TO 11-09-2017)
...APPELLANT
AND
1. SONGA GURU SEKHAR, S/ O GURAPPA, AGED 38 YEARS, HINDU,
AGED 38 YEARS,
2. SONGA LAKSHMI DEVI, W/O SONGA GURU SEKHAR, HINDU,
AGED 34 YEARS, HOUSEWIFE,
3. SONGA GURU SAI THARUN, S/ O SONGA GURU SEKHAR, HINDU,
STUDENT, AGED 8 YEARS, REP BY HIS MOTHER NATURAL
GUARDIAN I.E., S LAKSHMI DEVI. ALL ARE R/O D.NO. 1/39,
KANNELUR VILLAGE, JAMMALAMADUGU MANDAL, KADAPA
DISTRICT
4. GANTA PRATHAP, S/O G CHINNA PAMULETI, AGED 31 YEARS, R/O
VS,J
MACMA_512 of 2022
D.NO. 2/107, R.PAMPALLE VILLAGE, UYYALAWADA MANDAL,
KURNOOL DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC praying thet the Highcourt may be
pleased topleased to set aside the Judgment and Decree, dated.11-04-2022
in M.V.O.P.No. 98 of 2018 passed by the Chairman, Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal -Cum- II Addl., District Judge, Kadapa, Kadapa, at Proddatur and
pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to condone the delay of 136 days in filing the above MACMA against
the Judgment and Decree, dated. 11-04-2022 in M.V.O.P.No. 98 / 2018
passed by the Chairman, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal -Cum- II Addl.,
District Judge, Kadapa at Proddatur otherwise the petitioner will suffer
irreparable loss and hardships and pass
IA NO: 2 OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to suspend the Judgment and Decree passed in M.V.O.P.No. 98 of
2018, dated. 11-04-2022 on the file of the Chairman, Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal -Cum- II Addl., District Judge, Kadapa, pending disposal of the
MACMA and pass such other Order or Orders in the interest of justice,
pending disposal of the above appeal in the interest of justice and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to direct the Insurance Company to deposit Award amount of
Rs.12,82,600/- passed in M.V.O.P. No. 98 of 2018 dated 11.04.2022 on the
file of the Chairman, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal - Cum - II Additional
District Judge, Kadapa at Proddatur and pass
IA NO: 2 OF 2023
VS,J
MACMA_512 of 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to Vacate the Interim stay order granted I.A. No. 2 of 2022 in
MACMA. No. 512 of 2022, dated 07.12.2022 by permitting the
petitioners/claiments herein to withdraw the deposited amount of
Rs.12,82,600/- in M.V.O.P. No. 98 of 2018 on the file of the Chairman, Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal - Cum - II Additional District Judge, Kadapa at
Proddatur and pass
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. V HEMANTH KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. S ARIFULLAH
The Court made the following:
VS,J
MACMA_512 of 2022
JUDGMENT:This appeal is filed by the appellant – Insurance company challenging
the award dated 11.04.2022 passed by the Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal – cum- II Additional District Judge, Kadapa at Proddatur in
M.V.O.P.No.98 of 2018 filed by the respondent Nos.1 to 3/claimants
seeking compensation of Rs.9,00,000/- for the death of one Songa Ashok
Kumar (hereinafter referred to as ‘deceased’) in an accident that occurred
on
08.08.2017
near
Railway
gate,
Seshareddypalli
road,
Jammalamadugu mandal, Kadapa district, whereby, the Tribunal awarded
a sum of Rs.12,82,600/-.
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties are referred to as they
are arrayed before the Tribunal.
3.
The claimants are the parents and brother of the deceased.
Respondent No.1 is the owner and respondent No.2 is the insurer of the
tractor and trailer bearing Nos.AP21TX3314 and AP21BB6162. On
08.08.2017, while the deceased along with one Ganta Naresh Kumar was
proceeding to Seshareddypalli village on the aforementioned tractor and
trailer, after crossing the railway gate at about 06.30 p.m., the deceased,
being driver of the said tractor and trailer, was not able to control the
vehicle when buffaloes came across the road and as a result, the tractor
and trailer turned turtle towards right side; Ganta Naresh Kumar
sustained injuries in the incident whereas the deceased died on the spot.
The incident was reported to Jammalamadugu Police Station and a case
was registered in Crime No.274 of 2017 against the deceased under
Sections 337 and 304A of the Indian Penal Code, however, the case was
closed as abated. It is the case of the claimants that the deceased was
VS,J
MACMA_512 of 2022
aged about 21 years as on the date of the accident and that he used to
earn Rs.15,000/- per month from driving.
4.
Respondent No.1 remained exparte. The 2nd respondent
contested the claim petition by filing a detailed counter affidavit denying
the contentions of the claimants. It was contended that though the subject
tractor in question was registered for private purpose and the trailer for
agricultural purpose, it was used for commercial purpose as on the date
of accident which is a violation of the terms and conditions of the
insurance policy. It was also contended that the deceased had no valid
driving license to drive the subject vehicle.
5.
Basing on the above pleadings, the Tribunal framed the
following issues for trial:
1)
Whether the accident occurred on 8.8.2017 at about 6.30 P.M while
the defacto complainant by name GantaNaresh Kumar along with his
aunt’s son by name Songa Guru Ashok Kumar being the song of 1st and
2nd Claimants proceeding in a Tractor and Trailer bearing No.AP 21 TX
3314 and AP 21 BB 6162 at which time Songa Guru Ashok Kumar driving
the Tractor when the defecto complainant sat on the left side of the Engine
and when they are leading towards Seshareddypalle village at which time
the above said driver drove the same in a rash and negligent manner with
high speed and tried to save the buffaloes which time across the road due
to which he lost control over the tractor as a result of which the Tractor and
Trailer turned turtle consequent to which the defacto complainant
sustained injury and driver of the Tractor i.e., Songa Guru Ashok Kumar
died on the spot under the Trailer or not?
2)
Whether the 2nd Respondent is liable to pay compensation since the
Tractor and Trailer was driven by violating the terms of insurance policy or
not?
3)
not?
Whether the Petitioner/Claimant is entitled to any compensation or
VS,J
MACMA_512 of 2022
4)
To what relief?
6.
During the course of trial, P.Ws.1 and 2 were examined and
Exs.A1 to A10 were marked on behalf of the claimants. The 2nd
respondent got examined R.W.1 and relied on Exs.B1 and B2.
7.
The Tribunal, after considering all the facts and material
available before it, came to a conclusion that the accident occurred due to
the rash and negligent driving of the deceased himself, however, it
observed that the deceased was holding a valid driving license, thus, it
awarded a compensation of Rs.12,82,600/- to the claimants and made
respondent Nos.1 and 2 severally liable to pay the same. Challenging the
award dated 11.04.2022, the 2nd respondent/appellant filed this Motor
Accidents Civil Miscellaneous Appeal.
8.
Heard Sri. V. Hemanth Kumar, learned Standing Counsel for
the appellant and Sri. S. Arifullah, learned counsel for the respondents.
9.
During the course of arguments, learned counsel for the
appellant/respondent No.2 strenuously contended that the Tribunal has
awarded the compensation of Rs.12,82,600/- as against the claim of
Rs.9,00,000/- erroneously. He further contended that the tractor alone
was insured with the appellant/respondent No.2 and that no premium was
paid towards the insurance of the trailer which is registered only for
agricultural usage. He further contended that the accident occurred due to
the rash and negligent of the deceased himself and that the Tribunal
ought not to have considered the income of the deceased as Rs.8,000/per month without there being any documentary proof.
10.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondents
supported the award passed by the Tribunal in all aspects and contended
VS,J
MACMA_512 of 2022
that the Tribunal has rightly awarded the compensation of Rs.12,82,600/to the claimants and that the same need not be interfered with by this
Court.
11.
Perused the entire material available on record. Undisputedly, it
is clear from the evidence of P.W.2 – Ganta Naresh Kumar, who was
along with the deceased at the time of the accident, that after they have
crossed the railway gate while proceeding to Seshareddypalli, in order to
avoid the buffaloes which came across the road, the deceased lost
control of the subject vehicle, leading to turtle of the vehicle towards its
right side; though P.W.2 sustained injuries, the deceased died on the
spot. A perusal of the entire material available on record, including the
final report of the investigating officer (Ex.A.5), it is clear that the accident
occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of the deceased and the
same view was also taken by the Tribunal while answering the issue
No.1, which needs no interference.
12.
With regard to issue No.2, the Tribunal relied on the evidence
of the legal executive of the 2nd respondent’s insurance company –
R.W.1, who filed a true copy of the insurance policy which is marked as
Ex.B.2. The insurance policy – Ex.B.2 discloses that the 1st respondent is
the insurer of the vehicle bearing No.AP21TX3314 for a period of one
year i.e. from 12.09.2016 to the midnight of 11.09.2017. As the accident
occurred on 08.08.2017, it can be said that the policy is in force as on that
date. Furthermore, the deceased was holding a valid driving license as
on the date of accident as can be seen from Ex.A6. As such, the Tribunal
is right in holding that there is no violation of terms and conditions of the
insurance policy by the 1st respondent and in fixing the liability on the 2nd
respondent to pay the compensation to the claimants, considering the
VS,J
MACMA_512 of 2022
deceased as third party to the accident. Thus, the Tribunal has answered
issue Nos.1 and 2 in favour of the claimants and the same needs no
interference.
13.
Now, admittedly, as on the date of accident, the deceased was
holding a valid driving license and the vehicle bearing No.AP21TX3314
was insured with the 2nd respondent/appellant. It is the contention of
respondent No.2/appellant that the respondent No.1 had not paid any
premium towards the insurance of the trailer bearing No.AP21BB6162.
Time and again, the Apex Court, in catena of judgments held that no
separate insurance is contemplated for a trailer and when the trailer is
attached to the tractor that is insured, it becomes the part of the tractor.
The principle of claim for compensation in accidents arising out of the use
of the motor vehicle is based on tortuous liability and the negligence of
the driver of the motor vehicle is sine quo non for maintaining a claim
under the provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act. Inasmuch as the trailer by
itself cannot be driven and it has to be carried or towed with a tractor, the
question of insuring the trailer would not arise. It is only the prime mover
or the motor vehicle which controls movement of the trailer and in case of
negligence driving of the tractor, the owner of the vehicle and its insurer
alone will be made liable for payment of compensation.
14.
Coming to the quantum, it appears that the claimants
contended that the deceased was earning Rs.15,000/- as on the date of
his death, but the same was not substantiated by any documentary
evidence. Thus, the Tribunal relying on a judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India delivered in the year 2004 whereby the Apex
Court fixed the income of the driver therein as Rs.6,000/-, the Tribunal
fixed the income of the deceased as Rs.8,000/-. This Court is of the
VS,J
MACMA_512 of 2022
opinion that a driver in the year 2017 would have earned way more than
Rs.8,000/-, however, as the claimants failed to put forward any reliable
evidence, the same is not altered. As per the documents filed by the
claimants, the deceased was born on 10.06.1996, as such, the age of the
deceased as on the date of accident was taken by the Tribunal as 20.
The Tribunal, added 40% of the monthly income of the deceased towards
future prospects and computed the income of the deceased as
Rs.11,200/- per month and after deducting 50% of the income towards
personal expenses, the deceased being a bachelor, the annual income of
the deceased would become Rs.67,200/- [Rs.5,600/- X 12]. As per the
age of the deceased, the relevant multiplier as per SarlaVerma and Ors.
Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and another 1 is ‘18’. Thus,
Rs.12,09,600/- was fixed as compensation under the head of loss of
dependency [Rs.67,200 X 18]; in addition, Rs.16,500/- was awarded
towards
loss
of
estate,
Rs.16,500/-
towards
funeral
expenses,
Rs.40,000/- towards loss of consortium. In total, the Tribunal has awarded
Rs.12,82,600/- to the claimants, which is on reasonable basis and is
neither excessive nor deficient as per the considered opinion of this
Court.
15.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the award passed by the
Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal – cum- II Additional District Judge,
Kadapa at Proddatur in M.V.O.P.No.98 of 2018 is on reasonable basis
and the same need not be intervened by this Court. Accordingly, this
Motor Accidents Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is dismissed. There shall be
no order as to costs.
AIR 2009 SCC3104
VS,J
MACMA_512 of 2022
Consequently, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
___________________
JUSTICE V. SUJATHA
Date:24.02.2026.
Gss
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review