Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No.36371 of 2025
M/s. Shree Bharat Motors Limited
….
Petitioner
Mr. Rudra Prasad Kar, Senior Advocate
assisted by Mr. Asit Kumar Dash, Advocate
-versusThe Chief Commissioner of CT &
….
Opposite Parties
GST, Odisha and others
Mr. Sunil Mishra, Standing Counsel for CT & GST
Department
CORAM:
THE HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
AND
THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MURAHARI SRI RAMAN
ORDER
02.02.2026
Order No.
01.
1.
Assailing the order dated 1st September, 2025 passed
under Section 161 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act,
2017/Odisha Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (collectively, “the
GST Act”) by the Assistant Commissioner of CT & GST,
Bhubaneswar-1 Circle, Bhubaneswar-opposite party no.3 for the tax
periods pertaining the Financial Year 2020-21 rejecting the
application for rectification ignoring to consider reconciliation
summary (statement) and also order dated 27th February, 2025
passed under Section 73 of the said Act, the petitioner beseeches to
set aside said orders and prays for a writ of mandamus to the
authority concerned to pass fresh orders by considering the
application for rectification on its merits by affording opportunity
of hearing.
2.
Pursuant to an audit undertaken under Section 65 of the
GST Act for the tax periods with respect to Financial Year 2020-21,
a proceeding under Section 73 of the GST Act was initiated on the
allegation that the petitioner has not reversed the corresponding the
Input Tax Credit (“ITC”, abbreviated) and its returns arising out of
credit notes. The sum and substance of the allegation was excess
ITC had been claimed by the petitioner in the GSTR-3B vis-à-vis
ITC available in GSTR-2A.
2.1.
The proceeding under Section 73 culminated in passing
of an order dated 27th February, 2025 raising a demand comprising
tax, interest and penalty with the observation that the taxpayer was
required to reverse the ITC on Non-Reversal of ITC on account of
credit notes from the suppliers. The petitioner on 29 th March, 2025
filed an application for rectification of adjudication order under
Section 161 of the GST Act on the following grounds:
“a. in response to the SCN dated 02.11.2024, the petitioner
in its reply submitted that the Petitioner while furnishing its
return in GSTR-3B claimed ITC as available in the GSTR-2A
during the period 2020-21. GST suppliers have issued Credit
Notes against which ITC to the tune of Rs.2,94,44,152.93
(Rs.2,86,38,277/- under IGST, Rs.90,787.28 each under
CGST & SGST, and Cess of Rs.6,24,301.70) have been
reversed being net off based on Table No.8A of GSTR-9. The
Purchaser Register, reconciliation statement along with
detail statement of Credit Notes ledger has also submitted
during Assessment proceeding which is part of the
Assessment Records.
b. On perusal of the impugned Order dated 27.02.2025,
which has been passed on the ground that the taxpayer has
not produced any supporting documents/evidences for
verification of the claim of the taxpayer is contrary to the
facts apparent on record that when the details are available
in the GST portal and also found placed in the Assessment
Record, allegation of non-submission of the same with preset mind to confirm the demand of tax is error apparent on
the face of the record needs to be revised on verification of
the detail record. The allegation as raised non submission of
Original Credit Notes has never confronted to the Noticee
during Assessment proceeding and also it is not relevant in
the present case as because the Credit Notes already
reflected in GSTR-2A of the Portal and its duly deducted in
the purchase Register and the Noticee not availed such ITC.
c. Since the taxpayer has already produced supporting
documents like Purchase Register and Credit Notes Ledger
regarding reversal of the aforesaid ITC much prior to
issuance of the present Order in Form-DRC-07 as passed in
the case of the Taxpayer on the self-same facts without
verification of the GST BO is an error apparent on the face
of records. Hence it is requested to take considered the
documents as available on the records and rectify the DRC07 under Section 161 of the OGST/CGST Act, 2017.”
3.
Sri Rudra Prasad Kar, Learned Senior Advocate submits
that the petitioner was instructed to appear on 7 th August, 2025, on
which date a reply was furnished stating therein that no excess ITC
was claimed in GSTR-3B in comparison to the ITC available in
GSTR-2A/2B. Therefore, it is emphatically submitted that there
was no requirement to reverse the ITC. Referring to Circular
No.105/24/2019-GST, dated 28th June, 2019, it is submitted that
when credit notes are issued as part of commercial understanding
for example, post-sale discount, incentive etc., there being no
separate supply of service, corresponding ITC could be adjusted in
the return from the eligible credit. Such adjustment does not require
a separate entry under GSTR-3B or DRC-3. Attention is drawn to
paragraph-5 of said Circular, which reads as follows:
“5. There may be cases where post-sales discount granted
by the supplier of goods is not permitted to be excluded
from the value of supply in the hands of the said supplier
not being in accordance with the provisions contained in
sub-section (3) of Section 15 of the CGST Act. It has
already been clarified vide Circular No.92/11/2019-GST
dated 7th March, 2019 that the supplier of goods can issue
financial/commercial credit notes in such cases but he will
not be eligible to reduce his original tax liability. Doubts
have been raised as to whether the dealer will be eligible to
take ITC of the original amount of tax paid by the supplier
of goods or only to the extent of tax payable on value net of
amount for which such financial/commercial credit notes
have been received by him. It is clarified that the dealer will
not be required to reverse ITC attributable to the tax
already paid on such post-sale discount received by him
through issuance of financial/commercial credit notes by
the supplier of goods in view of the provisions contained in
second proviso to sub-rule (1) of rule 37 of the CGST Rules
read with second proviso to sub-section (2) of Section 16 of
the CGST Act as long as the dealer pays the value of the
supply as reduced after adjusting the amount of post-sale
discount in terms of financial/commercial credit notes
received by him from the supplier of goods plus the amount
of original tax charged by the supplier.”
3.1.
It is submitted that since no excess ITC was claimed by
the petitioner, for convenience sake the petitioner furnished
reconciliation summary by which it is demonstrated that no reversal
of ITC was necessitated under the GST Act or the Rules framed
thereunder.
3.2.
It is submitted that the orders impugned are liable to be
set aside and the application for rectification under Section 161
deserves to be considered as there has been flagrant violation of
principles of natural justice. The authority could not have rejected
such application by without taking into consideration the
reconciliation summary and without verifying the figures available
in the portal in its proper perspective. The rejection of application
for rectification, therefore, suffers from error apparent on the face
of record which warrants indulgence of this Court in the present
writ petition.
4.
Opposing vehemently, Mr. Sunil Mishra, learned
Standing Counsel for the CT & GST Department urged that the
authority concerned was justified in rejecting the claim of the
petitioner inasmuch as the petitioner failed to reverse the ineligible
ITC and the finding of fact is recorded by the authority to the effect
that there was excess ITC claimed in GSTR-3B in comparison to
GSTR-2A. He would submit that the writ petition is liable to be
dismissed in limine as the petitioner cannot be given scope to
circumvent remedy provided under the GST Act.
5.
Heard learned Senior counsel for the petitioner and
learned Standing Counsel for the CT and GST Department.
6.
Perused the record.
7.
On perusal of record, it is manifest that to the notice
seeking additional information by the concerned authority, a reply
dated 7th August, 2025 was filed enumerating exhaustively with
respect to the requirement of reversal of ITC as suggested by the
authority concerned. The petitioner during the course of hearing
drew attention to such reply where it is categorically stated that
“ITC reconciliation statement along with input tax credit and
corresponding credit note reversal statement incorporated in
consolidated GSTR-3B”. Such reply also depicts that point-wise
enumeration with respect to each alleged transaction was submitted.
Vide Annexure-8 series, it seems the petitioner furnished the ITC
reconciliation summary. It is revealed from Assessment Order that
such reply was discarded as there was absence of original credit
notes along with purchase invoices and issuance of credit notes by
the suppliers. It is stated by the counsel that the petitioner had
uploaded in the portal along with returns and the details was
available for the Assessing Officer to verify. It is emphatically
submitted that the application filed under Section 161 of the GST
Act could not have been rejected without affording opportunity of
hearing. This aspect remained uncontroverted by the opposite
parties. The order dated 1st September, 2025 rejecting application
for rectification could not have been passed merely quoting the
provisions under Section 161 of the OGST Act. Without assigning
reasons for not accepting the documents stated to have been
submitted and declining to verify the evidence available on the
portal the rejection of application suffers from infirmity in law. It
does not emanate from said order dated 01.09.2025 rejecting the
application for rectification that the aforesaid documents as
produced by the petitioner have been given due consideration by
the Assistant Commissioner of CT & GST, Bhubaneswar-1 Circle,
Bhubaneswar nor does it reveal before rejection any opportunity of
personal hearing was given.
8.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court perceives
that the Order dated 1st September, 2025 (Annexure-9) passed by
the Assistant Commissioner of CT & GST, Bhubaneswar-1 Circle,
Bhubaneswar rejecting the application for rectification dated 29th
March, 2025 is bereft of reason and hence, the same is liable to be
set aside.
8.1.
Having set aside the Order dated 1st September, 2025, the
case is remanded to the aforesaid authority with the direction that
the application for rectification dated 29th March, 2025 be disposed
of having regard to the ground taken therein along with supporting
documents/records available on the portal as stated to have been
uploaded and/or to be produced, as it had not been afforded
adequate opportunity to present its case during the course of the
proceeding under Section 73 of the GST Act. To avail such
opportunity of hearing and proffering explanation before the said
Authority by producing records and documents to support fact and
figures which have already been uploaded, the petitioner is directed
to appear before the Assistant Commissioner of CT & GST,
Bhuabneswar-1 Circle, Bhubaneswar within fifteen working days
from date. On receipt of copy of this order, the said Authority
concerned shall proceed to hear the petitioner on such dates(s) as he
may deem fit and proper. Needless to say that the petitioner shall
cooperate with the Authority concerned and it shall not be granted
unnecessary adjournments.
8.2.
The
Assistant
Commissioner
of
CT
&
GST,
Bhuabneswar-1 Circle, Bhubaneswar shall consider the explanation
of the petitioner along with records/documents sought to be
produced to support the fact and figures as discussed above and
pass an appropriate reasoned order rectifying the Order dated 1st
September, 2025, if need be, in terms of provisions of Section 161
of the GST Act and communicate the same to the petitioner
forthwith.
9.
With the above observations and directions, the writ
petition stands disposed of. As a result of disposal of the writ
petition, pending Interlocutory Application(s), if any, shall stand
disposed of.
(Harish Tandon)
Chief Justice
(M.S. Raman)
Judge
MRS/Laxmikant
Digitally Signed
Signed by: LAXMIKANT MOHAPATRA
Designation: Senior Stenographer
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 03-Feb-2026 10:56:41
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review