Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:2031]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 17332/2023
M/s Shanker Steel Supplier, A Registered Partnership Firm
Having Its Office At Shop No. 17 And 18, Station Road, Near Polo
Victory Cinema, Jaipur Through Its Authorized Partner Shri Nand
Kumar Rathi S/o Late Shri Shreenath Rathi.
----Petitioner/Plaintiff
Versus
M/s
Rampur
Engineering
Company
Limited,
Having
Its
Registered Office At 20, Barakhamba Road, New Delhi- 110001
And Branch Office At Sp-150, Industrial Area, Bhiwadi. Shri
Sanjay Gupta Director, M/s Rampur Engineering Company
Limited 20, Barakhamba Road, New Delhi- 110001
----Respondent/Defendant
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. J.P. Goyal, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. Sarvesh Jain,
Ms. Yashika Vijayvergia
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Sanjay Rahar
Ms. Ronak Bansal
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE BIPIN GUPTA
Judgment
Reportable
Date of hearing and conclusion of arguments
07.01.2026
Date on which the judgment was reserved
07.01.2026
Whether the full judgment or only the operative
part is pronounced
Full Judgment
Date of pronouncement
20.01.2026
1.
The present writ petition has been filed assailing the order
dated 01.09.2023 passed by the learned Commercial Court No. 2,
Jaipur
Metropolitan-II
in
Civil
Suit
No.
94/2023
(CIS
No.
122/2020), whereby the application filed by the plaintiff-petitioner
(2 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JP:2031]
[CW-17332/2023]
under Order VI Rule 17 read with Section 151 CPC seeking
amendment of the plaint has been rejected.
2.
The controversy in a narrow compass is that the plaintiff-
petitioner instituted a summary suit on 22.01.2020 against the
defendant-respondent for recovery of a sum of Rs.1,16,99,746/-,
inclusive of interest at the rate of 24%, arising out of the supply of
goods.
3.
Upon service of summons, the defendant-respondent filed
his written statement, denying the averments made in the plaint
and contending, inter alia, that the goods supplied by the plaintiff
were not of the requisite quality, due to which the same were
returned and the payment was adjusted. Subsequently, the
plaintiff-petitioner filed a rejoinder, controverting the stand taken
by the defendant-respondent.
4.
On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, the learned Trial
Court framed the issues. The plaintiff-petitioner led his evidence
by
way
of
affidavit
and
the
cross-examination
of
PW-1
commenced. However, at this stage, the plaintiff-petitioner moved
an application under Order VI Rule 17 CPC, seeking amendment of
plaint
to
incorporate
pleadings
in
the
form
of
clarification/elaboration relating to jurisdiction of the Court,
limitation, valuation of the suit and cause of action stating that the
same were not elaborated due to inadvertent and bonafide
mistake on account of drafting.
5.
The
said
application
was
opposed
by
the
defendant-
respondent on the ground that the trial proceedings of the suit
(3 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JP:2031]
[CW-17332/2023]
had already commenced and that the application was merely a
tactic to delay the suit proceedings.
6.
The
learned
Trial
Court,
vide
impugned
order
dated
01.09.2023, rejected the application preferred by the plaintiffpetitioner, observing that in view of the provision to Order VI Rule
17 CPC, no amendment of the pleadings shall be allowed after the
commencement of the trial proceedings unless the Court comes to
a conclusion that despite due diligence the party could not raise
the issue.
7.
Hence, the present writ petition.
8.
Learned counsel for the petitioner contended that the
application seeking amendment of the plaint cannot be said to be
belated merely because the examination-in-chief of PW-1 had
been tendered and his cross-examination had commenced. He
submitted that the evidence of PW-1 had not even been
completed and, therefore, the trial could not be said to have
substantially progressed so as to non-suit the petitioner on the
ground of delay.
8.1. He further submitted that the amendment sought at this
stage is purely explanatory and clarificatory in nature, and merely
intends to bring on record certain material particulars in relation
to cause of action, valuation of the suit, jurisdiction of the Court
and limitation, which are foundational issues required to be
examined
for
proper
adjudication
of
the
suit.
Therefore,
incorporation of such facts at the present stage would not cause
any prejudice to the respondent, as no vested right would be
(4 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JP:2031]
[CW-17332/2023]
taken away and the respondent would have full opportunity to
cross examine the plaintiff.
8.2. Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the
proposed amendment is corollary and incidental to the original
pleadings and does not alter the nature or character of the suit.
He further contended that the amendment in fact would assist the
Court below in rendering a well-reasoned adjudication and would
also prevent multiplicity of proceedings, which is one of the
primary objects underlying Order VI Rule 17 CPC.
8.3. Learned counsel for the petitioner also contended that the
omission to incorporate certain legal details in the original plaint
occurred due to inadvertence and oversight on the part of the
counsel, and it is a settled position of law that a litigant should not
be penalized for the mistake of his advocate, particularly when the
amendment
sought
is
bonafide
and
necessary
for
the
counsel
for
determination of the real questions in controversy.
8.4. In
support
of
these
submissions,
learned
petitioner relied upon the following judgments:
(i) Life Insurance Corporation of India vs Sanjeev
Builders Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.; 2022 (16) SCC 1.
(ii) Chakreshwari Construction Pvt. Ltd. vs Manohar
Lal; 2017 (5) SCC 212.
(iii) Abdul Rehman vs Mohd. Ruldu & Ors.; 2012 (11)
SCC 341.
(iv) Vidyabai vs Padmalatha; AIR 2009 SC 1433.
(v) Varun Pahwa vs Mrs. Renu Choudhary; AIR 2019 SC
1186.
(5 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JP:2031]
9.
[CW-17332/2023]
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent vehemently
opposed
the
petition
and
submitted
that
the
amendment
application has admittedly been filed after the commencement of
trial, and therefore, the proviso to Order VI Rule 17 CPC squarely
applies.
9.1. It was argued that the petitioner failed to demonstrate due
diligence, as required under the proviso, since all the facts now
sought to be incorporated were well within the knowledge of the
petitioner at the time of filing of the suit.
9.2. Learned counsel for the respondent contended that during
the cross-examination of PW-1, certain questions put to the
witness, exposed deficiencies in the plaint relating to jurisdiction,
valuation of the suit and limitation, and only thereafter the
present amendment application was filed in an attempt to fill up
lacunae
in
the
pleadings,
Hence,
such
an
exercise,
is
impermissible keeping in view the fact that the trial has already
commenced.
9.3. Learned counsel further highlighted that the suit was
instituted in the year 2020, whereas the amendment application
was preferred in the year 2023, which clearly reflect gross delay
and lack of due diligence.
9.4. Learned counsel for the respondent thus while supporting the
impugned order submitted that no error, not to speak of any error
of law, could be said to have been committed by the learned Trial
Court while passing the impugned order.
(6 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JP:2031]
[CW-17332/2023]
9.5. Learned counsel for the respondent placed reliance upon the
judgment passed by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of
Ajendraprasadji
N.
Pandey
&
Anr.
Vs
Swami
Keshavprakeshdasji N. & Ors.; 2006 (12) SCC 1 to buttress his
arguments.
10. Heard learned counsel for parties and perused the material
available on record.
11.
This Court, on perusal of the application filed by the
petitioner under Order VI Rule 17 CPC, finds it appropriate to
reproduce the original pleadings as well as the amendments
sought therein by the petitioner.
11.1 Paragraph No. 20 of the original plaint, which relates to the
aspect of jurisdiction, reads as under:
"That the present case is filed within the jurisdiction of
this Hon'ble Court since the petitioner and respondent
company offices are situated in Bhiwandi-Alwar-Jaipur."
11.2 By way of the present application, the petitioner seeks to
amend the aforesaid paragraph. The amended Paragraph No. 20,
as proposed, reads as under:
"20. That the present case is filed within the jurisdiction
of this Hon'ble Court since the booking of goods were
made at Jaipur registered office of the petitioner then
same were sent by the petitioner from Jaipur to its
Bhiwandi and then to the respondent. Hence, part of
cause of action arises at the jurisdiction of this Hon'ble
Court."
11.3 Paragraph No. 23 of the original plaint, dealing with the issue
of valuation of suit and amount of Court fees, reads as under:
(7 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JP:2031]
[CW-17332/2023]
"Valuation of the subject matter: The valuation of this
application for the purpose of Court fees and jurisdiction
is thus fixed court fee of Rs....... is affixed thereon. That
present petition is filed by paying proper duty as
required under law."
11.4 The
petitioner
now
seeks
to
substitute
the
aforesaid
paragraph with the following amended paragraph:
"23. Valuation of the subject matter: That present
petition is filed by paying proper duty as required under
law. That as on date, the valuation of the suit for the
purpose
of
Court
Rs.1,16,99,746.00/-
fees
and
jurisdiction
(Rupees
One
Crore
is
Sixteen
Thousand Ninety Nine Thousand Seven Hundred and
Forty Six Only), on which proper ad-valorem Court fee
of 3,61,130/- stands paid. The petitioner undertakes to
pay the requisite Court fees on the decree amount at
the time of the final adjudication."
11.5 Paragraph 19 of the original plaint, which related to the
cause of action, reads as under:
"The petitioner claim is admitted and is within the
period of limitation and not barred by law of limitation.
It is deemed that the respondent in unable to pay its
debts and has therefore rendered itself liable to be
liable for payment of dues."
11.6 The amendment sought for in Paragraph No. 19 reads as
under:
"19. The petitioner claim is admitted and is within the
period of limitation and not barred by law of limitation.
It is deemed that the respondent in unable to pay its
debts and has therefore rendered itself liable to be liable
for payment of dues. That the cause of action for filing
of the present suit, first arose on 24.02.2014 when the
(8 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JP:2031]
[CW-17332/2023]
legal notice was sent by petitioner for recovery of
amount. That the cause of action further arose on
06.12.2018 when Hon'ble Delhi High Court allowed the
petitioner to filed civil suit. That the cause of action
further
arose
on
07.06.2019
when
the
petitioner
company issued legal notice to the respondent to repay
the outstanding dues. The cause of action further arose
on 18.02.2020 when the Non-Starter Report was issued
by the Rajasthan State Legal Services Authority, Jaipur.
That the cause of action is still a continuing one. Hence,
the present suit is therefore, well within the limitation
period."
11.7 The petitioner also sought to incorporate the verification
clause after the prayer portion of the plaint.
12.
The scope and ambit of Order VI Rule 17 is well settled. The
provision empowers the Court to allow amendment of pleadings at
any stage of the proceedings if such amendment is necessary for
determining the real questions in controversy. The proviso,
introduced thereafter vide Amendment Act of 2002, restricts such
power after commencement of trial unless the Court concludes
that despite due diligence, the party could not have raised the
matter earlier.
For ready reference, Order VI Rule 17 CPC is reproduced herein
below:
"17. Amendment of pleadings.—The Court may at
any stage of the proceedings allow either party to alter
or amend his pleadings in such manner and on such
terms as may be just, and all such amendments shall
be made as may be necessary for the purpose of
determining the real questions in controversy between
the parties:
[2026:RJ-JP:2031]
(9 of 15)
[CW-17332/2023]
Provided that no application for amendment shall be
allowed after the trial has commenced, unless the Court
comes to the conclusion that in spite of due diligence,
the party could not have raised the matter before the
commencement of trial."
13.
The law in this regard is quite clear and consistently
reiterated that the Courts should adopt a liberal approach while
considering the applications for amendment of pleadings and the
same should be rejected only in those cases where the other party
would be placed in a disadvantageous position, and where the
resulting prejudice cannot be adequately compensated by costs.
In Pirgonda Hongonda Patil vs Kalgonda Shidgonda Patil;
AIR 1957 SC 363, a decision which continues to hold the field, the
Hon'ble Apex Court authoritatively laid down that all amendments
ought to be allowed which satisfy the two conditions: (a) of not
working injustice to the other side, and (b) of being necessary for
the purpose of determining the real questions in controversy
between the parties.
14.
Thus, an amendment to the pleadings ought to be allowed
when it is intended to rectify the absence of material particulars in
the plaint and when such amendment is necessary for determining
the real questions in controversy between the parties. The said
position of law has been reiterated in the case of Life Insurance
Corporation of India vs Sanjeev Builders Private Limited &
Anr.; 2022 (16) SCC 1 wherein the Hon'ble Apex Court while
discussing the said position of law held as under:
“70. Our final conclusions may be summed up thus:
(10 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JP:2031]
[CW-17332/2023]
(i) Order II Rule 2 CPC operates as a bar against a
subsequent suit if the requisite conditions for application
thereof are satisfied and the field of amendment of
pleadings
falls
far
beyond
its
purview.
The
plea
of
amendment being barred under Order II Rule 2 CPC is,
thus, misconceived and hence negatived.
(ii) All amendments are to be allowed which are necessary
for determining the real question in controversy provided it
does not cause injustice or prejudice to the other side. This
is mandatory, as is apparent from the use of the word
“shall”, in the latter part of Order 6 Rule 17 CPC.
(iii) The prayer for amendment is to be allowed:
(i) If the amendment is required for effective and
proper adjudication of the controversy between the
parties.
(ii) To avoid multiplicity of proceedings, provided:
(a) the amendment does not result in
injustice to the other side,
(b) by the amendment, the parties seeking
amendment do not seek to withdraw any
clear admission made by the party which
confers a right on the other side, and
(c) the amendment does not raise a timebarred claim, resulting in divesting of the
other side of a valuable accrued right (in
certain situations).
(iv) A prayer for amendment is generally required to be
allowed unless:
(i) By the amendment, a time-barred claim is
sought to be introduced, in which case the fact
that the claim would be time-barred becomes a
relevant factor for consideration.
(ii) The amendment changes the nature of the
suit.
(iii) The prayer for amendment is mala fide, or
(iv) By the amendment, the other side loses a
valid defence.
(v)
In dealing with a prayer for amendment of pleadings,
the court should avoid a hyper technical approach, and is
[2026:RJ-JP:2031]
(11 of 15)
[CW-17332/2023]
ordinarily required to be liberal especially where the opposite
party can be compensated by costs.
(vi) Where the amendment would enable the court to pinpointedly consider the dispute and would aid in rendering a
more satisfactory decision, the prayer for amendment should
be allowed.
(vii) Where the amendment merely sought to introduce an
additional or a new approach without introducing a timebarred cause of action, the amendment is liable to be
allowed even after expiry of limitation.
(viii) Amendment may be justifiably allowed where it is
intended to rectify the absence of material particulars in the
plaint.
(ix) Delay in applying for amendment alone is not a ground
to disallow the prayer. Where the aspect of delay is arguable,
the prayer for amendment could be allowed and the issue of
limitation framed separately for decision.
(x) Where the amendment changes the nature of the suit or
the cause of action, so as to set up an entirely new case,
foreign to the case set up in the plaint, the amendment must
be disallowed. Where, however, the amendment sought is
only with respect to the relief in the plaint, and is predicated
on facts which are already pleaded in the plaint, ordinarily
the amendment is required to be allowed.”
15.
In the present case, the amendments sought by the
petitioner pertain to jurisdiction of the Court, valuation of the suit,
limitation and elaboration of cause of action, which are not foreign
to the original pleadings but are foundational and statutory
requirements. Since in the present case, the examination-in-chief
of PW-1 has been filed and only the cross-examination had
commenced, and the evidence has not yet concluded. Therefore,
the Court is duty bound to allow such amendments at this stage
itself as the amendment sought are fundamental for the proper
adjudication of the matter.
[2026:RJ-JP:2031]
16.
(12 of 15)
[CW-17332/2023]
Moreover, on a careful perusal of the proposed amendments,
this Court finds that the amendment does not introduce a new
cause of action nor does it alter the nature or character of the suit
rather it merely elucidates the original pleadings. The claim
continues to arise out of the same transaction relating to supply of
goods and recovery of the outstanding amount and also the relief
sought remains unchanged. Thus, it is clear that the amendments
proposed only seek to elaborate the pleadings and it neither
enlarges the scope of the suit nor takes the respondent by
surprise.
17.
Furthermore, Order VII Rule 1 CPC specifically enumerates
the particulars which a plaint must contain, including the facts
constituting the cause of action, the valuation of the suit for
purposes of jurisdiction and court fees, and statements relating to
limitation. Moreover, drafting a plaint in conformity with these
statutory requirements is primarily the responsibility of the
counsel, who is expected to possess the requisite legal expertise
to incorporate such particulars appropriately.
18.
This Court thus finds merit in the contention that a litigant
ought not to suffer for the omission or inadvertence of his counsel
in not elaborately stating the aforesaid particulars, particularly
when the proposed amendment neither changes the nature and
character of the suit nor introduces a new cause of action. The
amendments are explanatory and clarificatory in nature and
merely supply material particulars which were otherwise implicit in
the original pleadings.
(13 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JP:2031]
[CW-17332/2023]
19.
As regards the proviso to Order VI Rule 17 CPC, though the
trial
has
technically
commenced,
the
requirement
of
“due
diligence” has to be appreciated in a pragmatic manner. Due
diligence is to be observed by the advocate while drafting
pleadings, and any lapse on that count should not, in the facts of
the present case, operate to the prejudice of the client.
20.
Further, a bare reading of Order XXIII Rule 1(3) CPC clarifies
that, if the Court finds that the suit will fail for some formal defect
then the same can be permitted to be withdrawn with liberty to
file fresh on same cause of action. The particulars in a suit, as are
required to be pleaded in terms of Order VII Rule 1 CPC, if are not
correctly pleaded and for formal defect a suit may fail, then the
power is vested with the Court to permit the plaintiff to withdraw
the suit. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of V. Rajendran and
Ors. vs Annasamy Pandian (D) thr. L.Rs. Karthyayani
Natchiar; 2017 (5) SCC 63 defined the formal defects and
observed as under:
10. In K.S. Bhoopathy and Ors. v. Kokila and Ors.;
(2000) 5 SCC 458, it has been held that it is the duty of
the Court to be satisfied about the existence of "formal
defect"
or
"sufficient
grounds"
before
granting
permission to withdraw the suit with liberty to file a
fresh suit under the same cause of action. Though,
liberty may lie with the Plaintiff in a suit to withdraw the
suit at any time after the institution of suit on
establishing the "formal defect" or "sufficient grounds",
such right cannot be considered to be so absolute as to
permit or encourage abuse of process of Court. The fact
that the Plaintiff is entitled to abandon or withdraw the
suit or part of the claim by itself, is no licence to the
(14 of 15)
[2026:RJ-JP:2031]
[CW-17332/2023]
Plaintiff to claim or to do so to the detriment of
legitimate right of the Defendant. When an application is
filed
under
Order
XXIII
Rule
1(3)
Code
of
Civil
Procedure, the Court must be satisfied about the "formal
defect" or "sufficient grounds". "Formal defect" is a
defect of form prescribed by the Rules of procedure such
as, want of notice Under Section 80 Code of Civil
Procedure, improper valuation of the suit, insufficient
court fee, confusion regarding identification of the suit
property, mis-joinder of parties, failure to disclose a
cause of action etc. "Formal defect" must be given a
liberal meaning which connotes various kinds of defects
not affecting the merits of the plea raised by either of
the parties."
21.
This Court finds that if such powers are vested with the
Courts that a suit may be permitted to be withdrawn with liberty
to file fresh, if the suit is liable to be dismissed for some formal
defects, then why not amendment can be permitted to cure the
formal defects by allowing the elaboration of material particulars
as to valuation for the purpose of jurisdiction, cause of action and
limitation, so as to avoid multiplicity of proceedings.
22.
In view of the above observation, the writ petition is allowed.
The impugned order dated 01.09.2023 passed by the learned
Commercial Court No. 2, Jaipur Metropolitan-II in Civil Suit No.
94/2023 is hereby set aside. The application filed by the plaintiffpetitioner under Order VI Rule 17 read with Section 151 CPC
stands allowed, subject to payment of costs of Rs. 25,000/- to the
defendant-respondent.
23.
After filing of the amended plaint, the respondent shall be at
liberty to file an additional written statement, if so advised, and
[2026:RJ-JP:2031]
(15 of 15)
[CW-17332/2023]
the learned Trial Court shall thereafter proceed with the suit in
accordance with law.
24.
Pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.
(BIPIN GUPTA),J
Sudha/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review