Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD.
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL No.524 of 2025
Date: 25 -08-2026
Between :
M/s.Santosh Dhaba Exclusive
.…Appellant.
And
M/s.The Santosh Original and
Six Others.
.…Respondents.
JUDGMENT:
Heard Sri Ashok Ram Kumar, learned Senior Counsel
assisted by Sri Agarwal Abhishek, learned counsel appearing for
the appellant, Sri Ashok Anand Kumar, learned Senior Counsel
assisted by Sri VenkataRamana P., learned counsel appearing for
respondent Nos.1 & 7, Sri Dr.Donti Reddy Venkat Reddy, learned
Senior Counsel representing M/s.R.V.R.Associates appearing for
respondent No.2, Sri Anand Kumar Kapoor, learned counsel
appearing for respondent Nos.3 & 6 and Sri R.A.Achuthanand,
learned counsel appearing on behalf of respondent Nos.4 and 5.
2.
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
The present Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is filed assailing the
docket proceedings dated 23.12.2025 passed in I.A.No.1681 of
2025 in O.S.No.486 of 2025 on the file of the XI Additional Chief
Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad.
3.
The appellant herein is the plaintiff in O.S.No.489 of 2025,
instituted seeking grant of permanent injunction restraining the
respondents/defendants and their men etc. from advertising or in
any manner using in respect of their Restaurant, hotel, Eatery a
deceptively similar Trade Mark ‘Santosh’ or any other deceptively
similar Trade Mark in any media, online platform etc. or in any
other manner of Services and thereby infringing the appellant’s
registered Trade Mark.
4.
Pending adjudication of the suit, the appellant filed
I.A.No.1681 of 2025 under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 CPC
seeking for grant of temporary injunction, and the same was
initially granted by the learned Trial Court vide its order dated
29.10.2025 and the same was extended from time to time.
5.
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
In the meantime, the question of jurisdiction of the Civil
Court arose. Respondent No.2 filed an application under Order VII
Rule 10 CPC seeking return of the plaint on the ground that the suit
involved a commercial dispute falling within the jurisdiction of the
Commercial Court. The said application was heard and, on
05.12.2025, after written arguments were filed by the parties, it
was reserved for orders and the matter was posted to 15.12.2025.
6.
On 15.12.2025, the order on the application under Order VII
Rule 10 CPC was not ready and the matter was adjourned to
17.12.2025 for orders. The proceedings sheet records: “Orders not
made ready, posted to 17.12.2025 for orders.” On 17.12.2025, the
matter was again adjourned and posted to 23.12.2025. The
appellant contends that, during this period, applications seeking
extension of the interim injunction were presented before the
learned Trial Court.
7.
Meanwhile, the learned Chief Judge, City Civil Court,
Hyderabad issued a Circular requiring cases relating to commercial
disputes falling within the specified pecuniary jurisdiction to be
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
transferred to the competent Commercial Court. The learned Trial
Court, referring to the said Circular and the judgment in
C.R.P.No.1932 of 2025, came to the conclusion that it lacked
jurisdiction to proceed with the suit and directed its transfer to the
competent Commercial Court.
8.
Accordingly, by docket order dated 23.12.2025, the learned
Trial Court recorded that it had no jurisdiction to try the suit and
the interlocutory application, directed transfer of the suit to the
Principal Special Court in the cadre of District Judge for Trial and
Disposal of Commercial Disputes, Hyderabad, and further recorded
that no extension petition had been filed by the petitioner. On that
basis, the ex parte injunction granted on 29.10.2025 was vacated.
9.
Aggrieved by the aforesaid order, insofar as it vacated the
interim injunction, the appellant preferred the present Civil
Miscellaneous Appeal. The suit was thereafter transferred to the
Commercial Court and renumbered as C.O.S.No.86 of 2025, while
I.A.No.1681 of 2025 was renumbered as I.A.No.1659 of 2025.
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
10. This Court, by judgment dated 23.06.2026, disposed of the
Appeal, inter alia observing that the material then available on
record did not disclose any order extending the temporary
injunction beyond 15.12.2025. This Court also proceeded on the
basis that, upon issuance of the Circular, the transferor Court
lacked authority to proceed further with the matter. The docket
order dated 23.12.2025 was accordingly set aside and the parties
were directed not to take adverse or coercive steps against each
other pending consideration of I.A.No.1659 of 2025 by the
Commercial Court.
11. The appellant challenged the said judgment before the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in S.L.P.(C) No.24442 of 2026. The Hon'ble
Supreme Court, by order dated 24.07.2026, observed that although
there was nothing in the material then placed before the High Court
indicating extension of the injunction beyond 15.12.2025, the
learned Senior Counsel for the appellant had brought to its notice
an endorsement of the word “Allowed” appearing on the
order/application dated 15.12.2025 with the signature of the
learned XI Additional Chief Judge. As the respondents disputed the
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
effect of the said endorsement, the Hon'ble Supreme Court found
that there was no clarity as to whether the application seeking
extension had in fact been allowed. The matter was therefore
remitted to this Court to examine that aspect after calling for the
records and proceedings from the transferee Court and obtaining an
appropriate report from the transferor Court.
12. Therefore, in compliance of the orders of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, this Court has heard the learned counsel appearing
for the parties and has perused the records and proceedings
received from the transferee Commercial Court, the report/records
of the transferor Court and the relevant S.R. Register placed before
this Court.
13. Sri Ashok Ram Kumar, learned Senior Counsel assisted by
Sri K.R.Sunil Kumar and Sri Agarwal Abhishek, learned counsel
appearing for the appellant, contended that the certified copies
obtained from the Hyderabad Civil Court’s Central Copying
Establishment conclusively establish that the appellant had
diligently filed applications under Section 151 CPC for extension
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
of the ad interim injunction (29.10.2025) on every date of hearing
without fail, whereas the respondent No.2 filed an application vide
I.A.No.1652 of 2025 under Order VII Rule 10 CPC seeking return
of the suit on the ground that valuation of the suit is beyond
Rs.3,00,000/- and hence, the subject matter falls within the purview
of ‘Commercial Dispute’ nature and sought for return of the suit so
as to present the same before the proper forum having jurisdiction
i.e. Commercial Court, that I.A.No.1652 of 2025 was reserved for
orders on 05.12.2025 and was directed to be listed on 15.12.2025
for orders by the learned XI Additional Chief Judge, City Civil
Court, Hyderabad.
14. Learned Senior Counsel further contended that as per the
practice of the Trial Courts, once any application or suit is reserved
for orders/judgment, regardless of specific net date given or not,
the entire record bundle is retained in the chambers of the learned
Presiding Officer; that even on 15.12.2025, the entire bundle was
in the Chamber of the learned Presiding Officer and the matter
was not called in the Court; as such, the appellant mentioned the
matter on the Bench and sought for extension by filing an
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
application across the Bench and thereafter the SR number will be
provided.
15. Learned Senior Counsel asserted that on 15.12.2025,
extension petition was filed across the Bench vide S.R.No.8936 of
2025, basing on the same, the learned Judge made a judicial
endorsement ‘Orders/Allowed’ along with signature/initials/date,
and the matter was adjourned to 17.12.2025 for orders in
I.A.No.1652 of 2025.
16. It is contended that on 17.12.2025, the matter was not called
on the Bench and the file was in Chambers of the learned Presiding
Officer by reason of orders in I.A.No.1652 of 2025 being reserved
for orders, and as such, the appellant once again mentioned the
matter on the Bench
by filing an extension petition vide SR
No.9004 of 2025, upon which, the said extension petition was
endorsed as ‘Allowed’ with signatures/initials/date, thereby
extending the ad interim injunction order, but the learned Trial
Court did not give any direction for next date till the impugned
order came to be passed on 23.12.2025. It is contended that since
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
there was no direction on 17.12.2025 with regard to the next date,
as a precautionary measure and abundant caution, the appellant had
filed an application for extension on 18.12.2025 vide SR No.9050
of 2025.
17. Learned Senior Counsel asserts that the learned Trial Court
took up the matter suo motu on 23.12.2025 without any notice to
either party and passed the matter vacating the interim injunction
erroneously noting that no extension applications were filed, and
the said order was challenged by the appellant on the ground that
the learned Presiding Officer had become functus Officio as on the
date of passing of the order as well from the date of the Circular
i.e. 04.12.2025 and 11.12.2025 issued by the learned Chief Judge,
City Civil Court, Hyderabad. He therefore contends that the order
passed on 23.12.2025 vacating the interim order is erroneous since
the learned Transferor Court, by virtue of the Circular of the
learned Chief Judge, ceased to hold the jurisdiction to entertain the
application and instead of transferring the matter by extending the
interim injunction, erroneously vacated the same, which action, it
is contended as arbitrary and liable to be set aside.
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
18. Learned Senior Counsel further drawn the attention of this
Court to the docket proceedings dated 15.12.2025, wherein on the
first page of the petition filed by the learned counsel for the
appellant in I.A.__of 2025 in I.A.No.1681 of 2025 in O.S.No.489
of 2025 filed under Section 151 CPC, the word “Orders” as well as
“Allowed” was reflected on 15.12.2025, and contends that
admittedly the order was extended and vacation of the order passed
by the learned Trial Court erroneously without jurisdiction, and
thereby sought to allow the Appeal.
19. On the other hand, Sri Ashok Anand Kumar, learned Senior
Counsel appearing for respondent Nos.1 and 7 contended that the
appellant filed SLP before the Hon’ble Supreme Court on
16.07.2026, whereas on 09.07.2026, a docket order was passed by
the learned Commercial Court in I.A.No.939 of 2026 in
I.A.No.1659 of 2025 in C.O.S.No.86 of 2025 upon petition filed
under Section 151 CPC praying the Court to extend the interim
orders dated 29.10.2025 wherein at second page, it was recorded
that it is relevant to refer to the observations of this Court made in
para-20 of the order dated 23.06.2026 to the effect that ‘the
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
material available on record does not disclose any order extending
the temporary injunction beyond 15.12.2025. Consequently, prima
facie, the interim order of temporary injunction ceased to operate
after 15.12.2025’.
20. It is also contended that upon perusal of the docket order
dated 17.12.2025 and 23.12.2025 in I.A.No.1681 of 2025 of the XI
Additional Chief Judge, it is found that there was no extension of
ad interim ex parte interim orders, and after 15.12.2025 interim
orders are not extended and there was no extension of interim order
as on 17.12.2025 or 23.12.2025 even to restore the position as it
stood after setting aside the docket order dated 23.12.2025 by the
Hon’ble High Court. The learned Commercial Court also referred
to the order of this Court dated 23.06.2026 to the effect that
pending consideration of I.A.No.1659 of 2025 in C.O.S.No.86 of
2026 by the Commercial Court, both parties are directed not to take
any adverse or coercive steps against each other. In view of the
above direction, the learned Commercial Court held that both
parties are directed to obey the orders of the Hon’ble High Court
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
and to cooperate with the Court in expeditious disposal of
I.A.No.1659 of 2026.
21.
Learned Senior Counsel appearing for respondent Nos.1 and
7 contended that even though the SLP is filed before the Hon’ble
Supreme Court on 16.07.2026, the order dated 09.07.2026
disposing of I.A.No.939 of 2026 filed seeking extension of ad
interim ex parte order dated 29.10.2025 was not placed on record
before the Hon’ble Supreme Court and the order dated 09.07.2026
has been assailed by way of appropriate proceedings, and that the
appellant preferred the SLP without challenging the order dated
09.07.2026 passed in I.A.No.939 of 2026 in I.A.No.1659 of 2025
in C.O.S.No.86 of 2026, which clearly establish that the appellant
is resorting to forum hunting ignoring the judicial hierarchy, and it
amounts to gross misuse of the legal process.
22. Learned Senior Counsel also submitted that the attitude of the
appellant is glaringly clear that he wants to get the orders dated
09.07.2026 passed by the learned Trial Court in I.A.No.939 of
2026 nullified without challenging it directly, which amounts to
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
playing fraud upon this Court so also upon the Hon’ble Supreme
Court.
23. Learned Senior Counsel urged that the docket proceedings
dated 15.12.2025 indicates that the petition for extension of the
interim order was placed on record of the learned Transferor Court
only on 16.12.2025 under the SR.
24. It is further contended that the impugned order indicates that it
is a comprehensive order passed in the suit, in I.A.Nos.1748 and
1681 of 2025 and the reasoning given for passing the orders in all
the above matters is one and the same, and that the entire order has
to be read in whole and not in piece meal manner. He therefore
seeks to dismiss the Appeal.
25. In support of his contentions, he relied upon the decisions in
Raja Soap Factory and others Vs. S.P. Shantharaj and others1,
M/s.EXL Careers Vs. Frankfinn Aviation Services (P) Ltd2,
Chairman-cum-Managing Director, Coal India Ltd. and others
1AIR 1965 SC 1449
2(2020) 12 SCC 667
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
Vs. Ananta Saha and others3and IEEE Mumbai Section Welfare
Association Vs. Global IEEE Institute for Engineers4.
26. On the other hand, Sri Dr.Donti Reddy Venkat Reddy, learned
Senior Counsel appearing for respondent No.2, initially submits
that the contemporaneous judicial record, when it is read as a
whole, unequivocally establishes that the ex parte ad interim
injunction was operative only upto 15.12.2025 and was not
extended thereafter, that the docket orders in I.A.No.1681 of 2025
contain no order of extension of ex parte ad interim injunction
from 15.12.2025 onwards; that the SR register disclose that the
alleged extension application was received and registered only on
16.12.2025 and not on 15.12.2025; and that the learned
Commercial Court, upon examining the relevant docket orders, has
also categorically recoded that there was no extension of interim
order after 15.12.2025; and thus, there is no contemporaneous
judicial order evidencing any extension of the injunction on
15.12.2025.
3(2011) 5 SCC 142
42025 SCC OnLine SC 1756
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
27. It is further contended that the docket proceedings records no
extension of the ex parte ad interim order from 15.12.2025 until
23.12.2025 and that the certified copies of the docket proceedings
annexed to I.A.No1659 of 2025 filed by respondent No.2 do not
disclose any such extension.
28. Learned Senior Counsel further submits that as per the
Register containing the S.R. Details, there is no extension
application filed by the appellant on 15.12.2025.
29. Learned Senior Counsel further drawn the attention of this
Court to the documents filed by the appellant and contends that
every petition filed under Section 151 CPC reflects the word
‘Allowed’ along with relevant documents, whereas the left side, the
SR number also reflects showing the dates on which the
applications have been entertained.
Similarly, learned Senior
Counsel drawn the attention of this Court to the docket proceedings
dated
14.11.2025,
17.11.2025,
18.11.2025,
21.11.2025,
24.11.2025, 28.11.2025, 01.11.2025 and 05.12.2025, and contends
that upon perusal of the petition filed on 15.12.2025 at the right
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
hand column, the words ‘Orders” and “Allowed” are reflecting
and on the left side, the SR number as ‘8936 dated 16.12.2015’ has
been entered.
30. It is contended that the appellant’s attempt to rely upon the
date mentioned in the application despite the S.R. record showing
its receipt and registration on 16.12.2025, creates a misleading
impression as to the actual date on which the application was
presented before the Court and as such, the appellant cannot,
merely mentioning 15.12.2025 as the date of application, treat an
application which was actually received and registered on
16.12.2025 as having been filed on 15.12.2025.
31. In support of his contentions, learned Senior Counsel
appearing for respondent No.2 relied upon the decision in Madupu
Enterprises
Pvt.
Ltd.,
Hyderabad
and
others
Vs.
B.Suryanarayana Murthy and others5 and sought for dismissal of
the Appeal.
2023 (2) ALD 144 (TS)S
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
32. The learned transferee Court passed orders on 09.07.2026
disposing of I.A.No.939 of 2026, which is filed seeking extension
of the ad interim ex parte orders dated 29.10.2025
33. Sri Anand Kumar Kapoor, learned counsel appearing for
respondent Nos.3 and 6 contended that the appeal itself is not
maintainable; that no suit is pending before the Court while Appeal
is against vacating of interim order.
It is contended that
interlocutory injunction orders are in aid of the main suit
proceeding and they are not independent of suit proceedings, and
hence, when there is no suit, nothing remains to be adjudicated as
held in Bharat Aluminium Company Vs. Kaiser Aluminium
Technical Services Inc.6
34. Learned counsel further contended that Section 107(2) CPC
stipulate that the appellate Court shall have the same powers as that
of the original Court, that when original court has held it lacks
jurisdiction and said order remained unchallenged by way of
appeal, then the appellate Court lacks jurisdiction and needless to
say that when court lacks jurisdiction, it cannot decide anything
(2012) 9 SCC 552
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
and if it decides, it is a nullity, needs no elaboration. It is also
contended that for an appeal to lie under Order 43 Rule 1(r) CPC,
there has to be an order in the eye of law, as by termination of suit
vide O.S.No.489 of 2025 before the XI Additional Chief Judge,
City Civil Court, all interlocutory orders stood automatically
nullified by operation of law, once there is no order subsisting in
the eye of law, for it to be challenged by way of appeal.
35. It is further contended that the Hon’ble Supreme Court
directed to get the record, get the report, hear the parties and decide
afresh, and as such, the additional record is not merely for
answering an isolated factual question and it is intended to enable
the High Court to correctly adjudicate the matter that was before it.
He therefore pleaded that the present Appeal is not maintainable
and is liable to be dismissed.
36. Sri
R.A.Achuthanand,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
respondent Nos.4 and 5, while reiterating the submissions made on
behalf of other respondents, contended that the present proceeding
is nothing but to extract the valuable time of the Hon’ble Court.
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
37. I have given my earnest consideration to the submissions
made as above and perused the record thoroughly.
38. On being mentioned by the learned counsel for the appellant
by way of memo, the matter was listed before this Court on
12.08.2026; in compliance with the directions of the Hon’ble Apex
Court, vide order dated 24.07.2026, in SLP(C) No.24442 of 2026,
records as well as reports from the respective Courts are called for
and directed the matter to be listed on 17.08.2025. However, since
the records were not received, the matter was directed to be posted
to 18.08.2026. On 18.08.2026, since the SR Register along with the
report of the Transferor Court was received and the record of
Transferee Court was not received, the matter was directed to be
listed on 20.08.2026. On 20.08.2026, the record as well as report
from the Transferee Court was also received and placed on record.
39. Upon perusal of the report submitted by the Transferor Court
i.e. XI Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad, dated
14.08.2026, it is seen that upon verification of the SR Register
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
2025, the following petitions/Memos under Section 151 CPC in
I.A.No.1681 of 2025 in O.S.No.489 of 2025 were filed as under:
SL.
No
SR.NO
Date
Remarks
1.
8936/2025
16.12.2025
Petition filed U/s. 151 CPC
2.
9004/2025
17.12.2025
Petition filed U/s. 151 CPC
3.
9019/2025
17.12.2025
Memo in O.S. No. 489/2025
4.
9050/2025
18.12.2025
Petition filed U/s. 151 CPC
5.
9085/2025
19.12.2025
Petition filed U/s. 151 CPC
6.
9202/2025
24.12.2025
Out of order U/s. 57 CPC
7.
9203/2025
24.12.2025
Petition filed U/s. 151 CPC
40. The report was duly verified with the SR Register, where
under on 15.12.2025, there was no reference of O.S.No.489 of
2025. However, on 16.12.2025, vide SR No.8936 annexure to
O.S.No.489 of 2025, reflecting I.A.No.1681 of 2025 is registered.
The same was continued on 17.12.2025, 18.12.2025 and
19.12.2025.
41. The report submitted by the transferee court, Principal Special
Judge in the cadre of District Judge for trial and disposal of
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
Commercial Disputes, Hyderabad, dated 19.08.2025 reads as
under:
“I further submit that this Court has received the file in
OS.No. 489/2025 from the file of XI Addl.Chief Judge,
City Civil Court, Hyderabad by transfer on 27.12.2026
and in this Court it was re-numbered as COS.No.
86/2025 on 29.12.2026. On verification of the docket
proceedings in IA.No. 1681/2025 in OS.No. 489/2025 on
the file of XI Addl. Chief Judge, City Civil Cour
Hyderabad from 29.10.2025 onwards, it shows that on
29.10.2025 the Presiding Officer in the transferor Court
has granted ad-interim injunction till 14.11 2025.
Subsequently, as per docket proceedings, the interim
order was extended from 14.11.2025 to 17.11.2025, from
17.11.2025 to 18.11.2025, 18.11.2025 to 21.11.2025,
and from 21.11.2025 to 24.11.2025.
I further submit that on 24.11.2025 the counsel for the
petitioner has filed a petition extension of interim
injunction orders till next date of hearing and the same
was allowed but it is not reflecting on the docket
proceedings. The petition was posted to 28.11.2025 for
hearing. On 28.11.2025 the interim order was extended
to 01.12.2025. On 01.12.2025 the counsel for the
petitioner has filed a petition for extension of interim
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
injunction order but no order was passed by the
Presiding Officer of the transferor Court on the
extension petition vide SR No. 8525/2025, dt.01.01.2025
and the matter was posted to 5.12.2025 for further
hearing.
I further submit that on 5.12.2025 the interim injunction
was extended and posted to 15.12.2025. On 15.12.2025
the counsel for the petitioner has filed a petition for
extension of interim injunction order till next date of
hearing and the same was endorsed as "allowed" by the
presiding Officer of the transferor Court but the same is
not reflecting on the docket proceedings the matter was
posted to 17.12.2025 for orders. On 17.12.2025 the
petition was filed by the counsel for the petitioner for
extension of interim injunction orders and the same was
endorsed as allowed" and but the same is not reflected in
docket proceedings of IA and the mater was posted
23.12.2025.”
42. It is necessary to observe here that the appellant's relied upon
the application bearing S.R.No.8936 and, more particularly, upon
the
endorsement
“Allowed”
appearing
thereon
with
the
initials/signature of the learned Presiding Officer. The report
submitted by the Transferor Court also states that the said
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
endorsement and records that the application dated 15.12.2025 was
endorsed as “Allowed”, though the same was not reflected in the
docket proceedings of the interlocutory application.
43. The record placed before this Court shows that the learned
Trial Court had initially granted the ex parte ad interim injunction
on 29.10.2025 and thereafter extended the same from time to time.
On 05.12.2025, the interim order was extended by posting the
matter to 15.12.2025. Thus, the interim order was undoubtedly
operative up to 15.12.2025. The controversy is only with regard to
its continuation beyond 15.12.2025.
44. Upon perusal of the docket proceedings dated 15.12.2025, it is
seen that the “orders were not made ready and the matter was
posted to 17.12.2025 for orders”. Significantly, the main docket
proceedings do not record any extension of the interim injunction
on that date. Similarly, on 17.12.2025, the matter was posted to
23.12.2025, but there is again no corresponding docket entry
recording extension of the interim injunction.
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
45. The appellant seeks to overcome the absence of such an entry
by relying upon the application dated 15.12.2025 bearing
S.R.No.8936 and the endorsement “Allowed” thereon. It is
contended that the application was presented across the Bench
when the main file was in the Chambers of the learned Presiding
Officer and that the endorsement made thereon constituted a
judicial order extending the injunction.
46. However, the said contention has to be considered along with
the contemporaneous official record. The S.R. Register does not
contain an entry relatable to the said application on 15.12.2025 and
records its registration only on 16.12.2025. Further, the
endorsement “Allowed”, though appearing on the application, is
not reflected in the proceedings of I.A.No.1681 of 2025. The
subsequent proceedings also do not indicate the period for which
the alleged extension was granted or contain any direction that the
injunction would continue until the next date of hearing or until
further orders.
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
47. This assumes significance because the interim injunction had
earlier been extended from time to time by specific orders of the
learned Trial Court. However, after 15.12.2025, there is no
corresponding order in the main proceedings recording its further
extension or specifying the period for which it was to continue.
The endorsement “Allowed” on the application, therefore, has to be
considered along with the contemporaneous proceedings and
cannot be read in isolation.
48. The subsequent applications relied upon by the appellant also
does not show any extension of the ad interim order. The fact that
further applications for extension were presented on 17.12.2025
and 18.12.2025, even according to the appellant, was by way of
abundant caution.
49. However, there is no corresponding operative order in the
main docket extending the injunction. Thus, the subsequent
applications, by themselves, cannot establish that the injunction
had already been extended on 15.12.2025.
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
50. Therefore, it is deemed that the orders are not extended. The
only mistake committed by the Trial Court is that instead of using
the word ‘vacated’, it ought to have written ‘interim order not
extended’ or ‘expired’.
51. After careful perusal of the Register and reports of both the
Courts below, this Court is of the firm opinion that there is no
existing ad interim ex parte injunction order on 15.12.2025, as
apparent on the face of record, there was no extension application
on that particular day and there was no endorsement on the docket
as regards extension.
52. It is also pertinent to observe that the order dated 09.07.2026
passed by the learned Transferee Court, wherein the very issue of
continuation of the interim injunction was considered and it was
observed that the injunction was not extended beyond 15.12.2025.
This aspect was not brought to the notice of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court.
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
53. This Court has not expressed any opinion on the merits of the
suit or on the merits of the pending application for interim relief,
which shall be considered independently by the competent Court.
54. It is clarified as noted above and the CMA is accordingly is
disposed of. No order as to costs.
Pending miscellaneous petition, if any, shall stand closed.
__________________________
GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR, J
Date: 25.08.2026
VSV/GJ
GPK,J
CMA No.524 of 2025
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL No.524 of 2025
Date: -08-2026
VSV/GJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review