Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
FRIDAY,THE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE RENUKA YARA
TRANS. CIVIL MISC.PETITION NO: 463 OF 2025
Betwee n:
1. N//s. Sandhya Hotels Pnvate Limited, a Private limited Company, having its
Registered office at Plot No. 22, HUDA Techno Enclave, Sector ll, l\,4adhapur
Hyderabad represented by its managing Director Sri S. Sreedhar Rao, S/o.
Sri S. Babu Rao, aged about 39 years, R/o. Hyderabad.
2. lv4/s. Dymes Engineers Private Limited, being represented by its Power of
Attorney Holder M/s Sandhya Hotels Private Ltd., Having office at Plot No.22,
HUDA Techno Enclave, Sector-ll, lvladhapur, Hyderabad., being Rep.by its
Director It4r. S. Sreedhar
...PETITIONERS
AND
1. Smt. Amritha Mishra, Wo. Rakesh lt/lishra, Aged about 44 years, Occ.
Business, R/o. A-11, Vikrampuri Colony, Kakaguda, Secunderabad
2. I\rlr. Rakesh Mishra, S/o. Satya Prakash tVlishra, Aged about 52 years, Occ
Business, R/o. A-11, Vikrampuri Colony, Ka[aguda, Secunderabad.
3. Mr. IVlayank Mishra, S/o. Rakesh Mishra, Aged about 27 years, Occ.'
Business, R/o. A-1'1, Vikrampuri Colony, Kakaguda, Secunderabad.
4. Smt. Dr. P. Rajini, Wo P. Swaroop Reddy, Aged about. 57 Years, Occ.
Doctor, R/o 50/3 RT, SR Nagar, Hyderabad. (lmpleaded Defendant in OS No.
12712016\
...RESP.NDENTS
Petition Under Section 24 ol the C.P.C. Praying that in the circumstances
stated in the affidavit filed therewith,the High Court may be pleased to transfer
and consolrdate O.S.No.127 of 2016 pending on the file of lll Addl. District Judge,
Ranga Reddy District, L.B. Nagar with O.S. No.947 of 2015 (Xl Addl. Chief
Judge, City Clvil Court, Hyderabad), O.S. No. 219 of 2016 (XlV Addl. Chief
Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad), and O.S. No. 12 of 2017 (lll Addl. District
Judge, Ranga Reddy Distrrct, L,B. NagaQ to any one competent learned Trial
Court where the suits are pending, for clubbing/consolid ation with directions to
frame common issues and render a common judgment with separate decrees as
warranted in law.
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying tnr,
,6e c:ir< rmstances stated rn
'n
the affidavit filed in sLrpport of the petition, the High Cour nay be p leased be
pleased to stay all further proceedings in O S. NO. 127 of 2C- i and 12 ttf 2017 on
the file of the Ill Additional District Judge, Ranga Reddy Drs
at L. B. Nagar and
O S No 947 of 2415 on the file of the XI Additional Chiei . rdge, Hyderabad at
City Civil Court and 0.S. No. 219 of 2016 on the file of the l
,
n'ble XIV Additional
Chief Judge, Hyderabad at Crty Civil Court pending dispcs: of the present "Tr.
C IVI,A"
Counsel for the Petitioners : SRl. SATHAKARNI.K
Counsel for the Resporrdent Nos.1 to 3 : M/s THOMAS LLC' D
Counsel forthe Respondent No.4 : SRI JULAKANTI VENU(; )PAL
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE RENUKA YARA
TRANSFER CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS PETITOIN NO.463 of 2O2S
9TH DAY OF JANUARY
Between:
M/s Sandhr a Hotels Private Limited and another
...Petitioners
and
Smt- Amritha Mishra arld 3 others
Respondents
ORDER:
1.
Heard Mr. Sathakarni. K, learned counsel for the
petitioners, Mr. Thomas Lloyd, learned counsel for respondent
Nos, I to 3 and Mr. Julakanti Venugopal, learned counsel for
the respondent No.4. Perused the record
2.
The Tr.C.M.P is filed with a prayer to transfer and
consolidate O. S. No. 127 of 2O 16 pending on the file of the
III Addl. District Judge, Ranga Reddy District at L.B.Nagar with
O.S.No.947 r-rf 2015 pending on the file of the XI Addl. Chief
Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad, O.S.No.219 of 2O16
pending on the file of the XIV Addl. Chief Judge, City Civil
Court, I{l.derabad and O.S.No.12 of 2Ol7 pendi- l on the file of
thc III Addl. District Jr-Ldge, Ranga Reddy Distrr: at L.B.l'Jagar,
to any one of the competent Courts ulherc .hc suits are
pcnding. lor clubbing or consolidation rvith a di.- ction to frame
common rssues ancl render a common judgmcr t u,ith separate
decrees as warranted in lau'
3.
The respondents have hlcd counter oppos r g transfer
4.
The petitioners herein arc plaintiffs in l.S.No.l27 of
2O16 and defendants in O.S.Nos.947 of 2015. 2 ') of 2016 and
12 of 2Ol7
5.
During arguments, the iearned colr sel lor the
petitioners referred to the suits stating that O.S . los.12 oI' 2017
(oid O.S No.1803 ol 2015), 127 of 2016,947 of 2( 15 and'.219 of
are at the stage of defendants eviclence u,herea; O.S.No.143 of
2Ol7 flled by respondent No. i herein against r: .;pondent No.4
has been rejected on filing of a petition under Or', er VIT Rule 11
of CPC. An appeal is preferred against said rejec ion before this
Court by way of First Appeal. The learned col r sel submitted
that all the suits are at advanced stage of rompletion of
recording of delendants evidence and therefore, clubbing said
I
\
j-
I
/:.
suits at this stage rs not possible. However, the parties, the
subject matter involved in all the suits are common and
therefore, for anv Presiding Officer to have u'holistic view of the
lis betrveen the parties, there is a need for disposal of all the
suits by one court. In that context, reliance is placed on the
judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in the case of
Chitivalasa Jute Mills v. Jaypee Rewa Cementt, Atomberg
Technologies Private Ltd. v. Eureka Forbes Limited and
othersr and order ol the High Court of Andhra Pradesh at
Hyderabad in the case of Gandodi Reddeppa v
Ayyala
Krishnaveni3 for impressing upon transfelr,r'hen there is
substantial and sufficient similarity of issues arising in
connected suits and common arguments need to be addressed-
Further, refercnce is made to cross examination of the plaintiff
(Pw1)
1.e
respondent No.1 herein in O.S.No.219 of 2016,
r.r,herein, it is admitted that there is no specific transaction
betu,een the plaintifl in O.S.No.219 of 2076 and the defendants
i.e. petitioners herein, lrrith respect to any particular property
' AIR 2oo4 sc 1687
) MANU
lscl1446lzoz5
r Mar{u/ap/ r tsolzoo+
','._l':
but it '"r,as girren in bulk and the defendants dentifie<l four
properties thal car-i be sold in lieu of thc amounrs foru,arded
6.
On thc basis of aforemcntioncd citatrons, - t<l admissions
made bv plaintilT i.e. respondent herein in O.S. r t.219 ol '2O16,
transfer is sought
7.
The learncd counsel for the respondeni opposed the
petition alleging that the transactions involvecl :r a1l the surts
are different and distrnct. that alreadi. evirl: Lcc has been
recorded in all the suits and that the prescnt -1' C.NI.P is filed
only to protract the proceedings. It is alleged that in the gr-rise of
disposal of all the suits by one Court, an attemf r,r,ill be made
to stall the disposal of cases s,here the eviden,: is completed
and the matters are at the stage of argumen r The learned
counsel raised one objection to the transfer a.I ging thzrt the
rejection of O.S.No.143 of 2Ol7 has rendere: the suits in
O.S.Nos.12 of 2O).7 and 727 ol 2016 infructuous
B.
Having regard to the arguments of both tl : counsel, the
learned counsel for the respondents was qu: ;tioned as to
l
)
lvhether or not the monev transactions listed ir -).S.No.219 of
2016 before the XIV Addl. Chief Judge, City Civil .ourt reflected
I
l
I
I
at page Nos.60 and 61 of matcrial papers in the Tr'C'M'P cover
the money transactions involved in the remaining sutts'
g.
The learned counsel for the respondents fairlv conceded
that the moneJi transactions in O.S.No.219 of 20 1.6 do relate to
the transactions involving the propertv in the remaining four (4)
suits. Further, the issue about the suits in O S'Nos 12 of 2Ol7
and. I27 of 20 16 being rendcred infructuous is found to be
baseless a-fter assessing pleadings and prayers of respective
suits.
10. At this juncture, the only objection that was raised by
the learned counsel for the respondents is that there is every
scope lor protracting the proceedings in all the suits' To such
an allegation, the learned counsel for the petitioners submitted
that r'vhile transferring the suits, time frame may be fixed for
expeditious disposal.
The very admission by the learned counsel for the
respondent No. 1 (PW 1) about money transfers w'hich are
subject matter of O.S.No.219 of 2016 being part and parcel of
the propertY transactlons ln the remaining suits Proves that
transacLions rll all tlrc suits are related. Therefore, for the
purpose of havirrg a ',vholistic understanding a r i for rendering
complete justice, there is a need for disposal o, il the suits bv
one court, farling rvhich. Lherc is likctihood ll Llte respcctirre
courts reaching different conclusions resultinr in conl'licting
decisions. To avoid delivering of conflicting 1r:cislons and
multiplicity of proceedings, there is a nced for rial of all the
suiLs by one court_
12. In vierv of the fact that all the suils are i the stage of
recording of defenclants evidence, there can bc ro question of
clubbing the suits. As such, the relief sought is rodilied to the
extent of transfer of all the suits i.e. O.S.No 127 ol 2016
pendir-rg on the filc of the III Addl. District Judqr Ranga iteddl,
District at L.B.Nagar, O.S.No.947 ol 2015 pendi r i o n the file of
the XI Add1. Chiel Judge, Citl. Civil Court. t: 'd er abacl and
O.S.No.12 of 2Ol7 pending on the file of the Ill Addl. District
Judge, Ranga Reddy District at L.B.Nagar to tht: llc of tl'rc XIV
Addl. Chief Judge, City Civil Courr, Hyderabad i. d Judge, City
Civil Court, Hl,derabad 1r,here O.S.No.219 of 2( 5 is perLding,
for separate but simultaneous disposal.
t'I
.\(r
q
I
\
13. In the rcsult, O.S.Nos. 127 of 2016 pendrng on the file of
the III Addl. District Judge, Ranga R<:ddy District at L.B.Nagar,
O.S.No.947 ol 2015 pending on thc file of the XI Addl. Chiel
Judge, City Crvil Court, H-vderabad and O.S.No.12 of 2Ol7
pending on the lile of the III Addl. District Judge, Ranga Redd,v
District at L.B.Nagar, are r.r'ithdraun and transferred to the file
r>f XIV Addl. Chief Judge, Citl' Crvil Court, Hyderabad for
clisposal of all the suiLs se paratel,\ but simultaneously. The
Courts concerned are dirccted to Lratrsfer the enLire bundle duly
indcxed within a pertod of one (1) mortth lrom the date of
receipt of copl' oI this order.
14.
Accordingly, this Tr.C.M.P. is disposed of. There shall be
no order as to costs.
Pending Miscellaneous applicalions, if any, shail stand
clo sed
SD/- N. CHANDRA SEKHAR RAO
DEPUTY REGISTRA
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
L. B. Nagar
The lll Addrtional District Judge, Ranga ReddY Dist
ad
Hyde
2 The Xl Additional Chief Judge, CttY Civil Court,
bad
HYde
Court,
Civil
City
Judge,
Chief
3 The XIV Additional
4 One CC to Sri Sathakarni.K , Advoc ate (OPUC)
(OPUC)
5 One CC to Sri Thomas LloYd, Advoc ate
(OPUC)
Advocate
VenugoPal,
Julakanti
Sri
6 One CC to
7 Two CD Copies
Ks/PSL
I
HIGH COURT
DATED:0910112026
-.4-.i <d\{:
(.1
ORDER
S.. 16rB2o26
,l/
TR.C.M.P.No.463 of 2025
Disposing of the Tr.C.M.P
Without costs.
L
3" I
\
,.\
'd..'.)
'r ,.\
., ,1
) tt
ti
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review