The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
9. Be that as it may, the present arbitration application is allowed. Mr. C. V. R. Rudra Prasad, Advocate, is appointed as an Arbitrator, who shall enter upon the reference and adjudicate upon the disputes arising out of and in connection with the auction notice, dated 12.02.2024, and render the Award within the statutory period. The parties shall be free to file detailed claims and counterclaims, before the learned Arbitrator. The learned Arbitrator shall also be entitled to claim the fee in consultation with the parties. No costs. Consequently, pending miscellaneous applications, if any, in this case, shall stand closed. A copy of this order be communicated to the learned Arbitrator on the address mentioned herein below: Mr. C.V.R. Rudra Prasad, #007, Anuraga Apartment, Vivekananda Street, Opp. Dairy Towers, Gurunanak Colony, Vijayawada, Andhra Pradesh. Ph: 98481 59643.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010571762025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
ARBITRATION APPLICATION NO: 37 of 2025
M/s. Sandhya Enviro Tech Systems
Bench
Sr.No:39
[3441]
...Applicant
Vs.
Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited
...Respondent
**********
Advocate for Applicant:
Ms. Jyothi Ratna Anumolu
Advocate for Respondent:
Mr. Sreekanth Reddy Ambati
CORAM :THE CHIEF JUSTICE DHIRAJ SINGH THAKUR
DATE
: 30th January, 2026.
PC:
This is an application filed under Section 11 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 (for short, “the Act of 1996”), seeking the appointment
of an arbitrator for adjudication of the disputes arising out of and in connection
with the auction notice, dated 12.02.2024.
2.
The applicant claims to be a partnership firm, involved in the business
of pre-processing of hazardous waste. It is stated that the applicant responded
to an auction notice, issued by the Hindustan Petroleum Corporation
Limited/respondent No. 1 herein, for the sale of “Pressed Scrap Mild Steel
(MS) Drums, Empty, de-shaped & Bundled” and was found successful in the
auction. The applicant, it is stated, duly paid an amount of Rs.18,17,614/towards the full material value, which also included applicable taxes.
3.
HCJ
ARBAPPL_37_2025
The case of the applicant is that it was not permitted to lift the material
on one pretext or the other.
4.
A notice, invoking the arbitration clause, dated 08.01.2025, is stated to
have been served, which is not denied by the respondent Corporation.
5.
The stand of the respondent Corporation is that it is not liable to make
any payment, as was being claimed by the applicant and further that no
dispute, in fact, existed, which was required to be referred for adjudication.
6.
According to the terms and conditions of the auction notice, disputes
between the parties were to be resolved through the mechanism of arbitration
in terms of Clause 23, which envisaged as under:
“23) ARBITRATION: a)All disputes and differences of whatsoever
nature, whether existing or which shall at any time arise between
the parties hereto touching or concerning the agreement, meaning,
operation or effect thereof or to the rights and liabilities of the
parties or arising out of or in relation thereto whether during or
after completion of the contract or whether before after
determination, foreclosure, termination or breach of the agreement
(other than those in respect of which the decision of any person is,
by the contract, expressed to be final and binding) shall, after
written notice by either party to the agreement to the other of them
and to the Appointing Authority hereinafter mentioned, be referred
for adjudication to the Sole Arbitrator to be appointed as
hereinafter provided.
b) The appointing authority shall either himself act as the Sole
Arbitrator or nominate some officer/retired officer of Hindustan
Petroleum Corporation Limited (referred to as owner or
PRINCIPAL) or a retired officer of any other Government
Company in the Oil Sector of the rank of Ch. Manager & above or
any retired officer of the Central Government not below the rank of
a Director, to act as the Sole Arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes
and differences between the parties. The contractor/vendor shall
not be entitled to raise any objection to the appointment of such
person as the Sole Arbitrator on the ground that the said person
is/was an officer and/or shareholder of the owner/PRINCIPAL,
another Govt. Company or the Central Government or that he/she
has to deal or had dealt with the matter to which the contract
HCJ
ARBAPPL_37_2025
relates or that in the course of his/her duties, he/she has/had
expressed views on all or any of the matters in dispute or
difference.
c) In the event of the Arbitrator to whom the matter is referred to,
does not accept the appointment, or is unable or unwilling to act or
resigns or vacates his office for any reasons whatsoever, the
Appointing Authority aforesaid, shall nominate another person as
aforesaid, to act as the Sole Arbitrator.
d) Such another person nominated as the Sole Arbitrator shall be
entitled to proceed with the arbitration from the stage at which it
was left by his predecessor. It is expressly agreed between the
parties that no person other than the Appointing Authority or a
person nominated by the Appointing Authority as aforesaid, shall
act as an Arbitrator. The failure on the part of the Appointing
Authority to make an appointment on time shall only give rise to a
right to a Contractor to get such an appointment made and not to
have any other person appointed as the Sole Arbitrator.
e) The Award of the Sole Arbitrator shall be final and binding on
the parties to the Agreement.
f) The work under the Contract shall, however, continue during the
Arbitration proceedings and no payment due or payable to the
concerned party shall be withheld (except to the extent disputed)
on account of initiation, commencement or pendency of such
proceedings.
g) The Arbitrator may give a composite or separate Award(s) in
respect of each dispute or difference referred to him and may also
make interim award(s) if necessary.
h) The fees of the Arbitrator and expenses of arbitration, if any,
shall be borne equally by the parties unless the Sole Arbitrator
otherwise directs in his award with reasons. The lump sum fees of
the Arbitrator shall be Rs. 40,000/- per case for transportation
contracts and Rs.60, 000/- for engineering contracts and if the sole
Arbitrator completes the arbitration including his award within 5
months of accepting his appointment, he shall be paid Rs.10, 000/additionally as bonus. Reasonable actual expenses for
stenographer, etc. will be reimbursed. Fees shall be paid stage
wise i.e. 25% on acceptance, 25% on completion of
pleadings/documentation, 25% on completion of arguments and
balance on receipt of award by the parties.
i) Subject to the aforesaid, the provisions of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 or any statutory modification or reenactment thereof and the rules made thereunder, shall apply to
the Arbitration proceedings under this Clause.
j) The Contract shall be governed by and construed according to
the laws in force in India. The parties hereby submit to the
exclusive jurisdiction of the Courts situated at Visakhapatnam for
HCJ
ARBAPPL_37_2025
all purposes. The Arbitration shall be held at Visakhapatnam and
conducted in English language.
k) The Appointing Authority is the Functional Director of Hindustan
Petroleum Corporation Limited.”
7.
It is no longer res integra that a person who has interest in the outcome
or decision of the dispute must not have the power to appoint a sole arbitrator.
In Perkins Eastman Architects DPC v. HSCC (India) Limited1, the Apex
Court held:
“21. … Naturally, the person who has an interest in the outcome or
decision of the dispute must not have the power to appoint a sole
arbitrator. That has to be taken as the essence of the amendments
brought in by the Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Act, 2015 (3
of 2016) and recognised by the decision of this Court in TRF Ltd.”
8.
This principle was subsequently affirmed by a judgment of the
Constitution Bench of the Apex Court in the case of Central Organisation for
Railway Electrification v. ECI SPIC SMO MCML (JV) A Joint Venture Co.2,
wherein it was held:
“129. Equal treatment of parties at the stage of appointment of an
arbitrator ensures impartiality during the arbitral proceedings. A clause
that allows one party to unilaterally appoint a sole arbitrator is exclusive
and hinders equal participation of the other party in the appointment
process of arbitrators. Further, arbitration is a quasi-judicial and
adjudicative process where both parties ought to be treated equally and
given an equal opportunity to persuade the decision-maker of the merits
of the case. An arbitral process where one party or its proxy has the
power to unilaterally decide who will adjudicate on a dispute is
fundamentally contrary to the adjudicatory function of arbitral tribunals.
…
169. c. A clause that allows one party to unilaterally appoint a sole
arbitrator gives rise to justifiable doubts as to the independence and
impartiality of the arbitrator. Further, such a unilateral clause is exclusive
(2020) 20 SCC 760
2024 SCC OnLine SC 3219
HCJ
ARBAPPL_37_2025
and hinders equal participation of the other party in the appointment
process of arbitrators;
d. In the appointment of a three-member panel, mandating the other
party to select its arbitrator from a curated panel of potential arbitrators is
against the principle of equal treatment of parties. In this situation, there
is no effective counterbalance because parties do not participate equally
in the process of appointing arbitrators.”
9.
Be that as it may, the present arbitration application is allowed.
Mr. C. V. R. Rudra Prasad, Advocate, is appointed as an Arbitrator, who shall
enter upon the reference and adjudicate upon the disputes arising out of and
in connection with the auction notice, dated 12.02.2024, and render the Award
within the statutory period. The parties shall be free to file detailed claims and
counterclaims, before the learned Arbitrator. The learned Arbitrator shall also
be entitled to claim the fee in consultation with the parties.
No costs. Consequently, pending miscellaneous applications, if any, in
this case, shall stand closed.
A copy of this order be communicated to the learned Arbitrator on the
address mentioned herein below:
Mr. C.V.R. Rudra Prasad,
#007, Anuraga Apartment, Vivekananda Street,
Opp. Dairy Towers, Gurunanak Colony,
Vijayawada, Andhra Pradesh.
Ph: 98481 59643.
DHIRAJ SINGH THAKUR, CJ.
SSN
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review