Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:5357
WP No. 38592 of 2025
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 30TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR
WRIT PETITION NO. 38592 OF 2025 (GM-CPC)
BETWEEN:
1.
M/S S6 INFRA,
(A PARTNERSHIP FIRM)
HAVING ITS OFFICE AT NO. 202,
PRADHAM REGENCY, ANAND NAGAR
(BEHIND HEA POLYTECHNIC),
MARATHAHALLI,
BANGALORE - 560 037.
REPRESENTED BY ITS PARTNER, NAMELY,
PETITIONER NO. 2 AND 3 HEREUNDER
REGISTERED UNDER INDIAN PARTNERSHIP ACT.
2.
MRS. T. ANURADHA,
W/O SRI TV PRASAD
PARTNER M/S S6 INFRA
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
RESIDING AT NO. 202,
PRADHAM REGENCY, ANAND NAGAR
(BEHIND HEA POLYTECHNIC),
MARATHAHALLI, BANGALORE - 560 037.
3.
MR. N. RAMESH BABU
PARTNER, M/S S 6 INFRA
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS
RESIDING AT NO. 202,
PRADHAM REGENCY, ANAND NAGAR
(BEHIND HEA POLYTECHNIC),
Digitally signed
by CHANDANA
BM
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka
-2NC: 2026:KHC:5357
WP No. 38592 of 2025
HC-KAR
MARATHAHALLI,
BANGALORE - 560 037.
…PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. PRAMOD N. KATHAVI, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR
SMT. RACHANA BHARADWAJ R, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
SMT. R. NIRMALA
W/O SRI. RAVISEKHAR REDDY,
AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS
RESIDING AT MADAKAIRA,
ANANTAPURA DISTRICT,
ANDHRA PRADESH -515 301.
2.
SRI. S.S. BANTOSH
S/O SRI. S. J. SUBRAMANYAM,
AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS
RESIDING AT MADAKAIRA,
ANANTAPURA DISTRICT,
ANDHRA PRADESH - 515 301.
3.
MR. ROHAN SHIVKUMAR,
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS,
S/O SRI. N. SHIVA KUMAR
RESIDING AT NO. 181, ARMADALE,
WHITEFIELD MAIN ROAD, WHITEFIELD,
BANGALORE - 560 066.
4.
M/S. RITIKA PRIVATE LIMITED,
(A COMPANY REGISTERED UNDER
THE COMPANIES ACT, 1956)
SUNDARI ARMADALE PLOT NO. 33,
GROUND FLOOR, WHITE FIELD MAIN ROAD,
CHAITANYA ARMADALE
-3NC: 2026:KHC:5357
WP No. 38592 of 2025
HC-KAR
(ADJACENT TO FORUM VALUE MALL)
BANGALORE - 560 066.
REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGER/
AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE.
5.
M/S BEIJING HOTELS PVT. LTD
(A COMPANY REGISTERED UNDER
THE COMPANIES ACT, 1956)
SUNDARI ARMADALE PLOT NO. 33,
FIRST FLOOR, CHAITANYA ARMADALE
(ADJACENT TO FORUM VALUE MALL)
WHITE FIELD MAIN ROAD,
BANGALORE - 560 066
REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGER/
AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE.
6.
M/S ZONE MIND AND BODY STUDIO PVT. LTD.,
(A COMPANY REGISTERED UNDER
THE COMPANIES ACT, 1956)
SUNDARI ARMADALE, PLOT NO. 33,
SECOND FLOOR, CHAITANYA ARMADALE
(ADJACENT TO FORUM VALUE MALL)
WHITE FIELD MAIN ROAD,
BANGALORE - 560 066
REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGER/
AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE.
7.
M/S CAFEZINHO
(A PARTNERSHIP FIRM)
OCCUPANT OF THE ENTIRE TERRACE FLOOR,
SUNDARI ARMADALE PLOT NO. 33,
CHAITANYA ARMADALE
(ADJACENT TO FORUM VALUE MALL)
WHITE FIELD MAIN ROAD,
BANGALORE - 560 066,
-4NC: 2026:KHC:5357
WP No. 38592 of 2025
HC-KAR
NO. 33, REPRESENTED BY ONE OF ITS
MANAGING PARTNER
MS. NISHITHA BARDHAN
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. N.G. SREEDHAR, ADVOCATE FOR R1 AND R2;
NOTICE TO R3 TO R7 IS DISPENSED WITH)
THIS WP IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227 OF
THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO I. CALL FOR
RECORDS PERTAINING TO THE ORDER DATED 19.09.2025,
PASSED IN O.S.NO.546 OF 2011 ON THE FILE OF THE
LEARNED IV ADDITIONAL SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE BANGALORE
RURAL, BANGALORE (ANNEXURE-A2) AND ETC.,
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY
HEARING, THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR
ORAL ORDER
Sri N G Sreedhar, learned counsel is directed to accept
notice for respondents 1 and 2.
2.
This petition by the defendants No.1 to 3 in OS
No.5646/2011 is directed against the impugned order dated
19.09.2025 whereby the application filed by the respondent
Nos.1 and 2 - plaintiffs under Order VI Rule 17 CPC seeking
amendment of the plaint by incorporating the additional relief
of refund and damages was allowed by the trial Court.
-5NC: 2026:KHC:5357
WP No. 38592 of 2025
HC-KAR
3.
A perusal of the material on record will indicate that
the respondents No.1 and 2 instituted the aforesaid suit against
petitioner Nos.1 to 3 - defendants No.1 to 3. and respondent
No. 3-defendant No. 4 and other defendants for specific
performance and other reliefs in relation to the suit schedule
immovable property.
The said suit having been contested by
the defendants, the matter was posted for trial and at the stage
of defendants' evidence, the respondents No.1 and 2 filed the
instant
application
seeking
amendment of
the
plaint by
incorporating the reliefs of refund of the advance amount and
damages in terms of Sections 21 and 22 of the Specific Reliefs
Act.
They said application having been opposed by the
petitioners, the trial Court proceeded to pass the impugned
order allowing the application by holding as under;
ORDER ON IA UNDER ORDER 6 RULE 17 OF CPC
DATED 04.12.2024 FILED BY plaintiff
Above application is filed by plaintiff seeking
for amendment of Plaint. In support of application,
plaintiff no.2 has filed affidavit and prayed to allow
the application.
2. On the other hand, defendants have filed
objection to the above application.
-6NC: 2026:KHC:5357
WP No. 38592 of 2025
HC-KAR
3. Based upon the above contentions of the
parties, the following points arise for consideration
of this court:
1. Whether the plaintiffs have made out
a grounds to allow the application?
2. What order?
4. Heard both side counsels. After hearing
and on due perusal of the records, the court's
findings on the above points are as under:
Point No.1: In the Affirmative..
Point No.2: As per the final Order
for the following:
REASONS
5. Point. No.1: Perused records. The suit is
filed by the plaintiffs against defendants seeking for
the relief Specific Performance of agreement sale in
respect of the suit schedule property When the case
was at the stage of further evidence of DW.1, the
plaintiffs have come up with present application
seeking for amendment of prayer in the plant. It is
submitted that, the plaintiff is entitled to seek
refund of advance amount under the agreement of
sale. Due to legal requirement, plaintiffs are
required to claim for compensation, in case the
court decides that the plaintiffs are not entitled for
the relief of Specific Performance of Contract, The
proposed amendment would not change the nature
of the suit., but it is necessary for effective
adjudication of all questions in controversy between
the parties. Hence, the plaintiffs prayed to allow the
above application.
6. On the other hand, the defendants in their
objection contended that, the above application is
-7NC: 2026:KHC:5357
WP No. 38592 of 2025
HC-KAR
filed by the plaintiffs by suppressing the material
facts. The plaintiffs have filed above application at
belated stage, after 13 years from the date of filing
the suit. The said prayer sought by the plaintiffs is
barred by limitation. The plaintiffs have not made
out any case for grant of the relief of Specific
Performance. Evidence has been completed by the
plaintiff. But at this stage, plaintiffs have filed the
present application to drag on the proceedings of
the above suit. Hence, the defendants have prayed
to dismiss the above application. Defendants have
relied upon the following citations:
1) (1996) 1 SCC 90 (Muni Lal Vs. Oriental Fire
and General Insurance Co. Ltd).
2) (2004) 3 SCC 392 (T.N. Alloy Foundry Co.
Ltd. Vs. T.N. Electricity Board & Ors).
3) (2010) 14 SCC 596 (Van Vibhag
Karmachari Griha Nirman Sahakari Sanstha
Maryadit (Registered) Vs. Ramesh Chander and
Ors)
4) (2001) 3 KLJ 336-(T.S. Raju Vs. S. Anil
Kumar & Anr)
5) (1997) 1 OLJR 674 (Bhagawati Prasad
Jalan Vs. Prem Lata Devi Kedia & Ors).
7. Admittedly, the suit is filed by the plaintiffs
for the relief of Specific Performance of Agreement
of sale. The case is at the stage of evidence by the
defendants. The plaintiffs contend that, due to legal
requirement, he requires to seek for claim of
compensation under the agreement of sale, if at all
the court decides that plaintiffs are not entitled for,
Specific Performance of Agreement. Except, said
reason the plaintiffs hance not stated anything
about the delay in seeking for the rellef of earnest
money. Whereas the defendants contends that, the
-8NC: 2026:KHC:5357
WP No. 38592 of 2025
HC-KAR
relief of earnest money is prayed by the plaintiffs is
barred by limitation. At this belated stage, the
plaintiffs cannot seek for amendment of plaint.
However, it is pertinent to note that, the plaintiffs
stated that, due to the legal requirement he has
sought To amending the prayer seeking for earnest
money. The question whether the relief sought for
amendment is barred by limitation or not has to e
determined only after completion of the trial. It
appears that, after commencement of trial, the
plaintiffs doubts about the relief of Specific
Performance of Agreement. Hence, the plaintiffs
have sought for amending the plaint to include the
relief of earnest money. However, the plaintiffs
have to prove whether he is entitled for earnest
money or not during trial. Hence, in order to give
an opportunity for the plaintiffs to prove his case,
the amendment requires to be allowed. Moreover,
the defendants have got all opportunity to deny the
case of plaintiffs by filing addl. Written statement.
Hence, no prejudice would cause to the defendants,
if above application is considered. Hence, the
following:
ORDER
IA Under Order 6 Rule 17 of CPC dated
04.12.2024 filed by plaintiffs is hereby allowed
on cost of Rs.2000/-.
For amendment of plaint within 14 days
and to file amended plaint.
Call on 30.10.2025.
4.
Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners submits
that the proposed amendment was ex-facie barred by limitation
since the cause of action for seeking the said reliefs arose at
-9NC: 2026:KHC:5357
WP No. 38592 of 2025
HC-KAR
the time of institution of the suit on 25.05.2011 and the
present application filed on 04.12.2024 was hopelessly barred
by limitation and the trial Court fell in error in allowing the
application without imposing any conditions and as such the
impugned order passed by the trial Court deserves to be set
aside.
5.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents
No.1 and 2 submits that apart from the fact that the proposed
amendment has been statutorily permitted under Section 21(2)
and 22 (2) of the specific relief Act ., in the light of the
principles laid down by the Apex Court in the case of Sampath
Kumar vs. Ayyakannu and Others (AIR 2002 SC 3369)
and L C Hanumanthappa vs. H B Shivakumar ((2016) 1
SCC 332), the trial Court was fully justified in allowing the
amendment application by passing the impugned order which
does not warrant interference by this Court in the present
petition.
6.
A perusal of the material on record including the
impugned order will indicate that the trial Court has come to
the correct conclusion that proposed amendment being in the
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:5357
WP No. 38592 of 2025
HC-KAR
nature of a statutory amendment which is permitted under
proviso to Section 21(5) as well as proviso to Section 21(2) of
the Specific Relief Act, the alternative reliefs of refund and
recovery of damages sought for by the respondent No. 1 plaintiff is permissible in law. The trial Court has also taken
care to ensure that the right of the petitioner to put forth the
plea of limitation is adequately safeguarded by directing that
the question of limitation is to be decided only after a fullfledged trial. It is an undisputed fact that the alternative relief
of refund of advance amount and damages relate to the sale
agreement
dated
20.10.2010,
in
respect
of
which
the
respondents No. 1 and 2 have sought for specific performance.
Under these circumstances, I am of the considered opinion that
the impugned order passed by the trial Court permitting
amendment does not warrant interference by this Court in the
present petition in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 227
as held by the Apex Court in the cases of Radhey Shyam Vs.
Chhabi Nath - (2015) 5 SCC 423, K.P. Natarajan Vs.
Muthalammal – AIR 2021 SC 3443 and Mohamed Ali Vs.
V. Jaya & others – (2022) 10 SCC 477.
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:5357
WP No. 38592 of 2025
HC-KAR
7.
Insofar as the contention urged by the learned
Senior counsel for the petitioner that no useful purpose would
be served if by permitting the amendment since the same is
ex-facie barred by limitation is concerned, in view of the
judgments of the Apex Court in Sampathkumar’s case and
L.C.Hanumanthappa’s case supra, when an amendment to a
pleading is opposed on the ground of limitation, the proper
course of action to be adopted by Courts is to permit the
amendment and direct that the amendment shall not relate
back to the date of the suit but shall be considered/reckoned
from the date of filing of the amendment application and by
leaving open the question of limitation to be decided along with
other issues in the suit.
8. In the case of K.R.Suresh vs. R.Poornima & others
– 2025 INSC 617, the Apex Court held as under:53. The High Court denied the relief of refund of
advance money to the appellant herein, having regard of
the fact that the appellant had not sought for an
alternative
prayer
for
refund
of
the
advance
sale
consideration in the suit as mandated by Section 22(2) of
the 1963 Act.
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:5357
WP No. 38592 of 2025
HC-KAR
54. Before we proceed to answer the question
formulated by us in para 27, we deem it necessary to
examine Section 22 of the 1963 Act. It reads thus:
“22. Power to grant relief for possession,
partition, refund of earnest money, etc.— (1)
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained
in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908),
any person suing for the specific performance of a
contract for the transfer of immovable property
may, in an appropriate case, ask for—
(a) possession, or partition and separate
possession, of the property, in addition to such
performance; or
(b) any other relief to which he may be entitled,
including the refund of any earnest money or
deposit paid or [made by] him, in case his claim
for specific performance is refused.
(2) No relief under clause (a) or clause (b) of subsection (1) shall be granted by the court unless it
has been specifically claimed:
Provident that where the plaintiff has not claimed
any such relief in the plaint, the court shall, at any
stage of the proceeding, allow him to amend the
plaint on such terms as may be just for including a
claim for such relief.
(3) The power of the court to grant relief under
clause (b) of subsection (1) shall be without
prejudice to its powers to award compensation
under section 21.”
55. Sir Frederick Pollock, 3rd Baronet, in Pollock &
Mulla: The Indian Contract and Specific Relief Acts, 16th
Edn., has discussed the object and scope of Section 22 of
the 1963 Act and the alternative relief of refund of
earnest money deposit, as follows:
“[s 22.6.2]
Deposit
Refund
of
Earnest
Money
or
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC:5357
WP No. 38592 of 2025
HC-KAR
[…] The relief of refunding of earnest money or
deposit cannot be granted unless specifically
claimed. Further such a plea cannot be considered
in a second appeal, particularly when the issue of
execution of the agreement has been held as not
having been proved.
Refund of amounts paid may also be ordered when
specific performance has been refused on the
ground of unexplained delay by the plaintiff in
approaching the Court. It is also open to a plaintiff
to give up his prayer for specific performance at the
hearing, or before the hearing, and ask for return of
the earnest money or deposit.
Where a clause entitling forfeiture of earnest money
is contained in the agreement, it would not be
refundable to the plaintiff who has failed to perform
his part of the contract. Forfeiture of earnest money
should not be allowed where the vendor has not
suffered any loss, but has actually gained, viz., on
account of frustration of contract. Where the value
of land had considerably increased after the sale
agreement, the Court, while refusing a decree for
specific performance, ordered a refund of the
earnest amount on the ground that the plaintiff did
not suffer any loss, but had gained due to the
default of the plaintiff.
xx xx xx
[s 22.7]
Pleadings
Pleadings
and
Amendment
to
Section 22 enacts a rule of pleading. It enables
the plaintiff to ask for possession in the suit for
specific performance and empowers the Court to
provide, in the decree itself, that upon payment by
the plaintiff of the consideration money within the
given time, the defendant should execute the deed
and put the plaintiff in possession. If the said relief
is not claimed in the plaint, the Court shall permit
the plaintiff at any stage of the proceedings,
including execution proceedings, to amend the
plaint on such terms as it deems proper. The
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC:5357
WP No. 38592 of 2025
HC-KAR
purpose is to avoid multiplicity of suits. This
provision overrides the provisions of Order VI, rule
17 of CPC, 1908. Omission to seek alternative relief
is not a ground to reject the plaint.
A plaintiff may amend the plaint to include a
claim for refund to advance money paid to the
defendant. The amendment may be made at any
stage of the proceeding, including the appellate
stage. The option vests with the plaintiff to claim
alternative relief, and unless he claims such a relief,
the Court is not empowered to grant it.”
(Emphasis supplied)
56. The expression “at any stage of the proceeding”
has been judicially interpreted to include the appellate
stage as well, as affirmed by a catena of High Court
decisions.
This
interpretation
entails
that
that
an
amendment of the plaint to incorporate a prayer for the
alternative relief of refund of earnest money may be
sought even during the first appeal from the original
decree passed in a suit for specific performance. The nonobstante clause attached to Section 22(1) of the 1963 Act
grants it an overriding effect, thereby excluding the
operation of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. Further,
the use of the word “shall” in the proviso to Section 22(2)
imposes
a
mandate
upon
the
court
to
allow
the
amendment of plaint, as sought by the party, at any
stage. [See: Sahida Bibi v. Sk. Golam Muhammad,
1982 SCC OnLine Cal 59; Tarit Bhowmik v Mukul
Day, 2014 SCC Cal 5361]
57. In Manickam v. Vasantha, reported in 2022
SCC OnLine SC 2096, this Court was dealing with the
question of whether the executing court could deliver
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC:5357
WP No. 38592 of 2025
HC-KAR
possession in execution of a decree where no specific
prayer for possession had been made in a suit for specific
performance. It held that the proviso appended to Subsection (2) of Section 22 of the 1963, which mandates the
Court to allow an amendment of the plaint at any stage of
the proceeding to include a claim for such relief under
Clause (a) or (b) of Section 22(1), renders the provision
directory in nature. The Court opined that Section 22(2) is
qualified by the phrase “in an appropriate case”, referring
to situations where such relief does not necessarily flow
from
a
decree
for
specific
performance
of
a
sale
agreement. Accordingly, if such relief under Clause (a) or
(b) of Section 22(1) appears as a necessary implication of
the decree for specific performance, a specific prayer for
claiming such relief would not be required. In light of
these principles, this Court held that the relief of
possession was inherently included in a decree for specific
performance
and
need
not
be
specifically
pleaded.
Furthermore, it reiterated that the words “at any stage of
the proceeding” have a wide amplitude, encompassing
both the appellate stage and execution proceedings. The
relevant observations are reproduced hereinbelow:
“22. The Bombay High Court in a judgment
reported as Lotu Bandu Sonavane v. Pundalik
Nimba Koli held that relief of possession is to be
claimed “in an appropriate case”. It means a case
in which the relief does not necessarily flow from
the decree for specific performance of the
agreement of sale. If such a relief is ancillary to and
necessarily flows from a decree for specific
performance, then it is not necessary to specifically
seek such a relief and the bar of S. 22(2) would not
be attracted. If the defendant is in possession of
the property agreed to be sold and the decree
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC:5357
WP No. 38592 of 2025
HC-KAR
directs a specific performance of the agreement of
sale, the defendant is bound to execute the sale
deed as per the decree and to put the plaintiff in
possession of the property as contemplated by S.
55(1)(f) of the Transfer of Property Act. In such a
case it is not necessary to specifically claim the
relief of possession in the suit.
xx xx xx
9. The term “proceeding” is a very wide and
comprehensive term and it includes execution
proceeding also. The expression “at any stage of
the proceeding” gives widest permission to the
Court to allow amendment at any stage of the
proceeding including execution of the decree. The
amendment can be allowed even in an appeal
arising out of the order passed by the executing
Court rejecting the prayer for permission. The
proviso recognises the well settled position that the
Court passing a decree for specific performance
retains control over the subject matter as long as
anything remains to be done in the case.”
xx xx xx
26. The matter can be examined from another
angle as well. Section 22(2) of the Act, though is
worded in negative language, “no relief under
clause (a) or clause (b) of sub-section (1) shall be
granted by the court unless it has been specifically
claimed”, but the proviso takes out the mandatory
nature from the substantive provision of subsection (2) when the plaintiff is allowed to amend
the plaint on such terms as may be just for
including the plaint for such relief “at any stage of
the proceeding”. “At any stage of the proceeding”
would include the proceeding in suit or in appeal
and also in execution. The proviso to sub-section
(2) of Section 22 of the Act contemplates that the
Court shall, at any stage of the proceedings, allow
the plaintiff to amend the plaint on such terms as
may be just for including a claim for such relief. The
said proviso makes the provision directory as no
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC:5357
WP No. 38592 of 2025
HC-KAR
penal consequences follow under subsection (2) of
Section 22. […]
xx xx xx
29. To examine whether a provision is directory or
mandatory, one of the tests is that the court is
required to ascertain the real intention of the
legislature by carefully attending to the whole
scheme of the statute. Keeping in view the scheme
of the statute, we find that Section 22(2) of the Act
is only directory and thus, the decree-holder cannot
be non-suited for the reason that such relief was
not granted in the decree for specific relief.
30. The defendant in terms of the agreement is
bound to handover possession of the land agreed to
be sold. The expression “at any stage of
proceeding” is wide enough to allow the plaintiffs to
seek relief of possession even at the appellate stage
or in execution even if such prayer was required to
be claimed. This Court in Babu Lal has explained
the circumstances where relief of possession may
be necessary such as in a suit for partition or in a
case of separate possession where the property
conveyed is a joint property. In the suit for specific
performance, the possession is inherent in such
suit, therefore, we find that the decree-holders are
in fact entitled to possession in pursuance of the
sale deed executed in their favor.”
(Emphasis supplied)
58. It is thus a settled position of law that the plaint
may be amended at any stage of the proceedings to
enable the plaintiff to seek an alternative relief, including
that of refund of earnest money, and the courts have
been vested with wide judicial discretion to permit such
amendments. However, under Section 22 of the 1963 Act,
the courts cannot grant such relief suo moto, since the
inclusion of the prayer clause remains a sine qua non for
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC:5357
WP No. 38592 of 2025
HC-KAR
the grant of such a relief. In other words, when an
“appropriate case” exists for seeking the said relief under
this provision, it must be specifically sought either in the
original plaint or by way of an amendment. This has been
emphatically held by this Court in Desh Raj v. Rohtash
Singh, reported in (2023) 3 SCC 714. The relevant
observations are reproduced hereunder:
“35. On a plain reading of the above-reproduced
provision, we have no reason to doubt that the
plaintiff in his suit for specific performance of a
contact is not only entitled to seek specific
performance of the contract for the transfer of
immovable property but he can also seek
alternative relief(s) including the refund of any
earnest money, provided that such a relief has been
specifically incorporated in the plaint. The court,
however, has been vested with wide judicial
discretion to permit the plaintiff to amend the plaint
even at a later stage of the proceedings and seek
the alternative relief of refund of the earnest
money. The litmus test appears to be that unless a
plaintiff specifically seeks the refund of the earnest
money at the time of filing of the suit or by way of
amendment, no such relief can be granted to him.
The prayer clause is a sine qua non for grant of
decree of refund of earnest money.
36. Applying these principles to the facts of the
case in hand, we find that the respondent has
neither prayed for the relief of refund of earnest
money in the original plaint nor he sought any
amendment at a subsequent stage. In the absence
of such a prayer, it is difficult to accept that the
courts would suo motu grant the refund of earnest
money irrespective of the fact as to whether
Section 22(2) of the SRA Act is to be construed
directory or mandatory in nature.”
(Emphasis supplied)
59. The judgment in Desh Raj (supra) has been relied
upon by the learned counsel appearing for the appellant
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC:5357
WP No. 38592 of 2025
HC-KAR
herein. However, it is difficult to understand how this
judgment furthers their case. On the contrary, this
judgment clearly contradicts their position, stating in
unequivocal terms that, in the absence of a prayer for the
relief of refund of earnest money, such relief cannot be
granted by this Court.
60. Another judgment which has been relied upon by
the learned counsel for the appellant in reference to the
issue of refund of earnest money, is the case of Kamal
Kumar v. Premlata Joshi, reported in (2019) 3 SCC
704. Notably, the ruling in this case also stands contrary
to the arguments advanced by the appellant on account of
the fact that the relief of refund of earnest money was
denied therein. The relevant observations are extracted
hereunder:
“9. In the case at hand, we find that the two
courts below have gone into these questions in the
light of pleadings and evidence and recorded a
categorical finding against the plaintiff holding that
the plaintiff was neither ready nor willing to
perform his part of the contract and, therefore, he
was not entitled to claim the relief of specific
performance
of
the
contract
against
the
defendants in relation to the suit land. It was also
held that the plaintiff was not entitled to claim any
relief of refund of earnest money because it was
liable to be adjusted as agreed between them.”
(Emphasis supplied)
61. Applying these principles to the facts of the case at
hand, we find ourselves unable to accept the submissions
of the appellant that, in the absence of a specific prayer
for the refund of advance money paid by them, Prayer (c)
of the plaint which specifies the grant of “such other
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC:5357
WP No. 38592 of 2025
HC-KAR
relief(s) as the Hon’ble Court deems fit in the facts and
circumstances of the case in the interest of justice”, can
be construed to include a prayer for such an alternative
relief.
62. The reasoning set forth in the case of Manickam
(supra) as regards the relief of possession under Section
22(1)(a) of the 1963 Act, can be appropriately imported
in the present case to say that the relief of refund of
earnest money under Section 2 2(1)(b) is not a relief that
automatically flows from a decree for specific performance
of a sale agreement and must, therefore, be explicitly
sought.
63. In our considered opinion, the law contained under
Section 22(2) of the 1963 Act is adequately broad and
flexible to allow the appellant to seek an amendment of
the plaint for the said relief, even at the appellate stage.
However, no such application for an amendment of the
plaint was moved either before the trial court or during
the course of the first appeal before the High Court. That
is to say, the appellant never prayed for the refund of the
advance money. Here, it would be redundant to state that
the law aids the vigilant, not those who sleep over their
rights.
9.
In the instant case, the suit having been filed on
25.05.2011 and the amendment application having been filed
on 04.12.2024, I deem it just and appropriate to modify the
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC:5357
WP No. 38592 of 2025
HC-KAR
impugned
order
and
permit
the
amendment
subject
to
imposition of certain conditions in this regard.
10. In the result, I pass the following:ORDER
(i) Petition is hereby disposed of.
(ii) The impugned order dated 19.09.2025 passed in O.S.
No.546/2011 by the IV Additional Senior Civil Judge, Bangalore
Rural District, Bangalore, is hereby modified.
(iii)
The
application
for
amendment
filed
by
the
respondents No.1 and 2 - plaintiffs dated 04.12.2024 is allowed
by directing that the said amendment shall not relate back to
the date of the suit filed on 25.05.2011, but the proposed
amendment shall be reckoned/considered from 04.12.2024
when the amendment application was filed by leaving open the
question of limitation to be decided by the trial Court in
accordance with law.
(iv) Liberty is reserved in favour of the petitioners and
other defendants to file their additional written statement to
the amended plaint and take up all contentions including the
contentions regarding maintainability, jurisdiction, limitation
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC:5357
WP No. 38592 of 2025
HC-KAR
etc., which shall be decided by the trial Court in accordance
with law.
(v) All rival contentions and all aspects of the matter
including limitation are kept open and no opinion is expressed
on the merits/demerits of the rival contentions.
Sd/(S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR)
JUDGE
YKL/SRL
List No.: 2 Sl No.: 11
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review