The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
5. We, thus, do not find any merit in the instant writ petition, the same is hereby dismissed. No order as to costs. (Harish Tandon) Chief Justice (M.S. Raman) Judge S.K. Jena/Secy. Designation: SECRETARY Reason: Authentication Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No.32445 of 2025
M/s. Rutuparna Construction,
Bhubaneswar
….
Petitioner
Represented by Adv.–
Mr. Achyutananda Pattanaik, Advocate
-Versus….
State of Odisha and Others
Opposite Parties
Represented by Adv.–
Ms. A. Dash, Addl. Standing Counsel
CORAM:
HON’ BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
AND
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MURAHARI SRI RAMAN
Order No.
ORDER
21.01.2026
01.
1. The instant writ petition is filed seeking a direction upon the
opposite parties to release the amount shown in the escalation bill
submitted to the authorities. It is averred in the instant wit petition that a
tender was floated for execution of Rural Piped Water Supply work
under the execution of a Rural Piped Water Supply Scheme to village
Badhimuhan wherein the petitioner was adjudged as the successful
bidder. The agreement was executed and the petitioner undertook the
work in terms of the said tender and it is not in dispute that the final bill
raised by the petitioner was duly paid by the authorities. Subsequent
thereto, the petitioner submitted the escalation bill annexed to the writ
petition and sensing that the same is kept pending by the authority, a
representation was made to take a decision thereupon. Since the
authorities have not taken any decision as of now, the instant writ
petition is filed in this regard.
2. Learned Additional Standing Counsel appearing for the Stateopposite parties submits that pursuant to the contract and the work
having done successfully, the entire amount has been paid to the
petitioner without any demur or deduction in this regard. It is further
submitted that the clause relating to escalation of price as relied upon
by the petitioner, is not applicable to the present contract, which is the
subject matter of the instant writ petition.
3. Our attention is drawn to clause 61.14 of the agreement which runs
thus:
“61.14
Price Variation/Escalation Clause : (Vide Works
Deptt. Office Memorandum No.12606/W dt. 24.12.2012) This
clause will be applicable to the contracts where original
stipulated period of completion is more than 18 months.
Contract price shall be adjusted for increase or decrease in rates
and price of Labour, Cement, Steel, Bitumen, Pipes, POL & other
material component in accordance with the following principles
and procedures as per formula given below:
(a) (i) REIMBURSEMENT/RECOVERY DUE TO VARIATION
IN PRICES OF MATERIALS OTHER THAN (STEEL,
CEMENT, BITUMEN, PIPES & P.O.L)
"If during the progress of the work the price of any materials
(excluding the cost of steel, cement, bitumen & POL) incorporated
in the work (not being materials supplied from the Engineer-incharge's store) in accordance with clause there of increases or
decreases as a result of increase or decrease in the Average
Wholesale Price Index (all commodities), and the Contractor
thereupon necessarily and properly pays in respect of that materials
incorporated in the work such increased or decreased price, then he
shall be entitled to reimbursement or liable to refund, quarterly as
the case may be, such an amount, as shall be equivalent to the plus
or minus difference of 85% in between the Average Wholesale
Price Index (all commodities) which is operating for the quarter
under consideration and that operated for the quarter in which the
bid was received (last date of receipt) as per the formula indicated
below provided that the work has been carried out within the
stipulated time or extension thereof as are not attributable to him.
If penalty is levied for delayed completion of the work, the
contractor shall not be eligible to get price escalation on the above
materials on the value of works executed during the extended
period.
This clause will be applicable to the contracts where original
stipulated period of completion is more than 18 months.
In the situation where the period of completion is initially
stipulated in the agreement as less than 18 (eighteen) months but
subsequently the completion period has been validly extended on
the ground that the delay in completion is not attributable to the
contractor and in the result the total period including the extended
period stands more than 18 (eighteen) months or more, price
escalation for other materials is admissible only for the remaining
period excluding 18 (eighteen) months there from.
Formula to calculate the increase or decrease in the price of
material:Price adjustment for increase or decrease in cost of materials other
than cement, steel, bitumen, pipes and POL procured by the
contractor shall be paid in accordance with the comply with the
condition he shall be liable to pay as compensation an amount
equal to one-third percent on the said estimated cost of the whole
work for every day that the due quantity of work remains
incomplete. Provided that the entire amount of compensation to be
paid under the provision of this clause shall not exceed 10% (Ten
Percent) of the estimated cost of the work as shown in the tender.
(b) If there are possibilities of exceeding this compensation amount
as mentioned in clause (a) 10% of the estimated cost, or in any
case in which under any clause or clauses of this contract, the
contractor shall have rendered himself liable to pay compensation
amounting to the whole of his security deposit in the hands of
Government (whether paid in the sum or deducted by instalments)
the Executive Engineer on behalf of the Governor of Odisha, shall
have power to adopt any of the following courses, as he may deem
best suited to the interest of the Government.
i) To rescind the contract (of which recession notice in writing to
the contractor under the hand of the Executive Engineer shall be
conclusive evidence) 20% of the value of the left over work will be
realized from the contractor as penalty
ii) To employ labour paid by Deptt. of Water Resources and to
supply materials to carry out the work, or any part of the work,
debiting the contractor with the cost of the labour and the price of
the materials (of the amount of which the cost and price certificate
of the Executive Engineer shall be final and conclusive against the
contractor) and crediting him with the value of the work done, in
all respect in the same manner and at the same rates as if it had
been carried out by the contractor under the terms of his contract,
the certificate of the Executive Engineer as to the value of the work
done shall be final and conclusive against the contractor.
iii) To measure up the work of the contractor and to take such part
of the work of the contract, as shall be unexecuted out of his hands
and to give it to another contractor to complete, in which case any
expenses which may be incurred in excess of the sum which would
have been paid to the original contractor if the whole work had
been executed by him (of the amount of which excess the
certificate in writing of the Executive Engineer shall be final and
conclusive) shall be borne and paid by the original contractor and
may be deducted from any money due to him by Government
under the contract or otherwise or from his security deposit or the
proceeds of sale thereof or a sufficient part thereof.
In the event of any of the above courses being adopted by the
Executive Engineer the contractor shall have no claim to
compensation for any loss sustained by him by reason of his
having purchased or procured any materials, or entered into any
engagements, or made any advance on account of with a view to
the execution of the work or the performance of the contract. And
in case the contract shall be rescinded under the provision
aforesaid, the contractor shall not be entitled to recover or be paid
any sum for any work there to for actually performed under this
contract, unless and until the Executive Engineer shall have
certified in writing the performance of such work and the value
payable in-respect thereof and he shall only be entitled to be paid
the value so Certified.”
It is, thus, apparent from the aforesaid clause that the price
variation/escalation in the prices admissible to a contract stipulated the
period of completion more than 18 months. It is thus, restricted to a
contract where the work has to be completed and/or executed more than
18 months from the date of commencement, which ruled out its
applicability to a contract where the stipulated time of completion falls
short of 18 months.
4. From the escalation bill annexed to the instant writ petition, it
appears that the petitioner ensued the work on 28.03.2022 and the date
of completion was fixed at 22.01.2023 i.e. within 300 days. The
petitioner completed the work before the date of completion as
stipulated in the said agreement and precisely, for such reason, the
authorities have released all the amount due to the petitioner in relation
to the execution of the work awarded to it. As the clause of escalation in
price is restricted to specified contract and the contract which does not
come within the ambit thereof, neither it confers any right to claim the
escalation price nor are the authorities bound to pay the same. It would
be an ideal formality in directing the authorities to take a decision when
this Court finds from the clause as relied upon by the parties that the
instant contract is not engulfed into it.
5. We, thus, do not find any merit in the instant writ petition, the same
is hereby dismissed. No order as to costs.
(Harish Tandon)
Chief Justice
(M.S. Raman)
Judge
S.K. Jena/Secy.
Digitally Signed
Signed by: SANJAY KUMAR JENA
Designation: SECRETARY
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack.
Date: 27-Jan-2026 18:55:28
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review