Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:504
Serial No. 03
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 238 of 2023
Date of Decision: 05.06.2024
1. M/s Reliance Infratel Limited
Having its registered office at
H Block, 1st Floor,
Dhirubhai Ambani Knowledge City,
Navi Mumbai, Maharashtra, 400710
2. Manish Nath, Authorised signatory of RITL
Having it office at RITL, H Block, 1st Floor,
Dhirubhai Ambani Knowledge City,
Navi Mumbai, Maharashtra, 400710.
…Petitioner(s)
- Versus –
1. State of Meghalaya represented by its
Chief Secretary to the Government of
Meghalaya, Shillong.
2. Meghalaya Power Distribution Corporation
Limited through its Chairman Cum Managing Director
Shri S. Goyal, Lumjingshai, Short Round Road
Shillong-793001.
… Respondent(s)
3. M/s Reliance Jio Infocomm Limited
Having its registered office at
Office 101, Saffron Nr. Centre Point,
Panchwati 5 Rasta, Ambawati,
Ahmedabad, Gujarat-380006.
4. M/s Summit Digitel Infrastructure Limited
Having its registered office at
Unit-2, 9th Floor, Tower-4, Equinow,
Business Park, LBS Marg, Kurla (W)
Mumbai City, Maharashtra-400070
…. Proforma Respondent(s)\
2024:MLHC:504
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. V.V.V. Sastry, Adv. with
Mr. H. Abraham, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. A. Kumar, AG with
Ms. R. Colney, GA (For R 1&2)
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The petitioner No. 1 namely; Reliance Infratel Limited
(formally Reliance Telecom Limited) a company that operates over
43,000 Mobile Towers in India of which 157 are situated in
Meghalaya, was admitted to insolvency with effect from 07.05.2019.
A resolution plan was then submitted by Reliance Projects and
Property Management Solutions Ltd. (RPPMSL), for takeover of the
petitioner, and on the same being approved by the National Company
2024:MLHC:504
Law Tribunal (NCLT) and thereafter by the Supreme Court,
RPPMSL took over the petitioner company on 22.12.2022.
2.
The respondent No. 2 namely; Meghalaya Power
Distribution Corporation Ltd. had vide letter dated 12.06.2023 sought
recovery of electricity dues from the petitioner for the periods prior
to the takeover under the Insolvency Code, and also from the
affiliates of the petitioner No. 1 (i.e. the respondents No. 3 & 4) by
threatening to disconnect the existing electricity connections for the
mobile towers, and further refused to provide new electricity
connections to the petitioner and its affiliates. Aggrieved thereby, the
writ petitioners by way of the instant writ petition have therefore put
a challenge to the impugned letter/Demand Notice dated 12.06.2023,
issued by the respondent No. 2 to the extent that it pertains to dues of
the petitioner No. 1, prior to 22.12.2022.
3.
Mr. V.V.V. Sastry, learned counsel for the petitioner has
submitted that the petitioner is highly aggrieved, inasmuch as, the
respondents Nos. 1 & 2, are seeking to recover and realize electricity
2024:MLHC:504
dues from the writ petitioners for the periods much prior to
22.12.2022, i.e. the effective date of takeover. Learned counsel
submits that the legal issues raised in the instant case are no longer
res integra, in view of the judgment rendered by the Supreme Court,
in the case of Tata Power Western Odisha Distribution Ltd.
(TPWODL) & Anr. vs. Jagannath Sponge Pvt. Ltd., wherein it was
held that a power distribution company, cannot insist on payment of
arrears which would negate the clean slate principle, if the successful
resolution applicant is asked to pay the arrears payable by the
corporate debtor. It is also submitted that by this decision, the
Supreme Court has clarified that in the event any statutory
authorities, or creditors have any claim, such person may approach
the NCLT, but that in the instant case the respondents are seeking to
recover the dues, without approaching the NCLT.
4.
The learned counsel submits that the admitted position is
that on the resolution plan being approved, the successful resolution
applicant had taken over the petitioner No. 1 on 22.12.2022, which is
the effective date, which also has been recorded in the order of the
2024:MLHC:504
NCLT Mumbai dated 11.05.2023. As such, he submits in view of the
approved resolution plan, which has provided that all claims, debts
and liabilities of the petitioners, including the Government and other
statutory authorities, in relation to the period upto the effective date
standing extinguished, the action of the respondent No. 2, in issuing
the impugned Demand Notice and further refusing to provide
electricity connections, is arbitrary and unreasonable.
5.
It is further submitted that the Resolution Professional
by a letter dated 25.07.2019, had duly informed the State Electricity
Board of the commencement of the proceedings and had also
requested submissions of any claims against the corporate debtor to
be made, but the respondent No. 2 did not file any claims at the
relevant point of time, which therefore, made the Demand Notice
untenable and unsustainable. The learned counsel contends that by
the operation of the approved resolution plan therefore, the petitioner
is not liable for any dues that were payable before the effective date.
It is further contended that Section 238 of the Insolvency Code would
override any other law which would include the provisions of the
2024:MLHC:504
Electricity Act and the Rules, and Regulations made thereunder. In
support of his submissions, the learned counsel has placed the
following decisions:
i)
Ghanshyam Mishra vs. Edelweiss Asset Reconstruction
Co. Ltd. reported in (2021) 9 SCC 657 (Para 95 to 149)
ii)
Committee of Creditors of Essar Steel India Ltd. vs. Satish
Kumar reported in (2019) SCC Online SC 1478
iii)
Ruchi Soya Industries vs. Union of India reported in
(2022) 6 SCC 343 (Paras 4-6, 10, 11)
iv)
Dimension Steel and Alloys Ltd. vs. Damodar Valley
Corporation reported in (2022) SCC Online Cal 995 (Paras
1, 7, 30, 32, 33)
v)
West Bengal State Electricity Distribution Company vs.
Sri Vasavi Industries reported in (2022) SCC OnLine Cal
1918 (Para 2, 6-9, 17 and 25)
vi)
Paschimanchal Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited vs. Raman
Ispat Pvt. Ltd passed in Civil Appeal No. 7976 of 2019
vii)
Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra
Pradesh Limited vs. Gavi Siddeswara Steels (India) Pvt.
Ltd. & Anr. arising out of Diary No. 9229 of 2013.
viii) Tata Power Western Odisha Distribution Limited
(TPWODL) & Anr. vs. Jagannath Sponge Private Limited
passed in Civil Appeal No. 5556 of 2023
2024:MLHC:504
6.
The learned counsel in closing his arguments, submits
that the writ petitioners are seeking a writ of mandamus, in view of
the arbitrary actions on the part of the respondents in not providing
electricity connections, which is interfering with their rights to carry
on trade and business, and also for not acting in terms of the approved
resolution. The plea that the respondents have not participated in the
resolution process, he submits cannot now be taken as a pretext to
take coercive measures against the petitioners as has been done. On
the question of alternative remedy, the learned counsel submits that
writ jurisdiction is being invoked, as the writ petitioners are seeking
the enforcement of their fundamental rights as the actions of the
respondents is wholly arbitrary and without jurisdiction.
7.
In reply to the submissions made by the counsel for the
petitioners, the learned Advocate General appearing for the
respondents has raised the following grounds: First, that a resolution
plan that ignores statutory dues is invalid and not binding, secondly,
the resolution plan does not provide for waiver of statutory dues,
thirdly, electricity dues are statutory in nature and the liability does
2024:MLHC:504
not cease and fourthly, that the writ petition is not maintainable due
to the presence of effective alternative remedy, and is based on the
disputed question of facts, as orders under challenge are against the
proforma respondents Nos. 3 & 4.
8.
With regard to the first submission, the learned
Advocate General contends that, a resolution plan ignoring any
statutory dues payable to any State Government or Legal authority,
would be in contravention of the provisions contained in the
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, and the electricity dues
being the statutory obligations of the petitioners, there is no
restriction placed on the appropriate authority to recover such dues.
Reliance has been placed in the case of State Tax Officer vs.
Rainbow Papers Limited reported in (2022) SCC OnLine SC 1162,
wherein he submits, it has been held that any resolution plan which
overrides statutory duties is invalid and not binding. It has been
further submitted that this decision has been upheld by the Supreme
Court in a subsequent decision namely; Sanjay Kumar Agarwal vs.
State Tax Officer & Anr. (and other connected matters) reported in
2024:MLHC:504
2023 SCC OnLine SC 1406, wherein review was sought of the earlier
judgment i.e. State Tax Officer vs. Rainbow Papers Limited (supra).
9.
On the second submission, the learned Advocate General
has argued that the resolution plan relied upon by the petitioner does
not take away the right for the respondent No. 2 to realize the
statutory obligations from the petitioners. This he submits is because
the NCLT while approving the resolution plan vide order dated
03.12.2020, had observed that the approved resolution plan in no way
would amount to waiver of statutory dues. On his third submission,
it has been contended that electricity dues are statutory in nature and
subsequent owners are liable to pay the same. Reference on this point
has been made to the decision of the Supreme Court rendered in the
case of Telangana State Southern Power Distribution Company
Ltd. & Anr. vs. Srigdhaa Beverages reported in (2020) 6 SCC 404,
wherein it has been held that electricity dues where they are statutory
in character under the Electricity Act cannot be waived in view of the
provision of Section 56 of the Act itself. It is submitted that electricity
dues being statutory dues, the subsequent purchasers are therefore
2024:MLHC:504
liable for the same. The learned Advocate General on this point has
also referred to the case of K.C. Ninan vs. Kerala SEB, 2023 SCC
OnLine SC 663 in support of this argument.
10.
It is then contended that the writ petition is not
maintainable for implementation of the resolution plan, as the
petitioners have alternate remedy by virtue by Section 60 (5) (c) of
the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 and that further Section
63 thereof, provides that no civil court or authority, shall have
jurisdiction to entertain any suits or proceedings in respect of any
matter, in which the NCLT or NCLAT has jurisdiction under the said
Code. In support of this contention, the learned AG has cited the
following decisions: -
i)
ii)
11.
Thansingh vs. Superintendent of Tax, Dhubri, AIR 1964
SC 1419
City and Industrial Development Corpn. Vs. Dosu
Aardeshir Bhiwandiwala
Arguments have also been advanced that the writ is not
maintainable as there exists disputed question of facts, inasmuch as,
2024:MLHC:504
the orders under challenge are against proforma respondents Nos. 3
& 4. It is submitted that the petitioner has sought quashing of the
recovery notice to proforma respondents Nos. 3 & 4, and that these
respondents themselves, have not approached this Court to assail the
same, meaning thereby that they are not aggrieved, which would
make the instant petition on behalf of the respondents No. 3 & 4, not
maintainable in law. It has been further submitted that there are
disputed questions of facts, as the petitioner has not quantified the
amount payable by the respondents Nos. 3 & 4 before the alleged
cutoff date. It is also further submitted, that there is no clarity as to
the inter se relation, between the noticee i.e. respondent No. 3 and the
petitioner, which makes the writ petition vague and not maintainable.
On the point of disputed questions of facts, the learned AG has relied
on the following decisions:
i)
Sanjay Kumar Jha vs. Prakash Chandra Chaudhary
(2019) 2 SCC 499 (Para 10)
ii)
World Tel Inc. vs. Union of India (2001) 10 SCC 513
(Para 2-4)
2024:MLHC:504
12.
The learned Advocate General lastly submits that on
facts, there exists no legal right in favour of the writ petitioners to
institute the present writ petition, and as such the same is liable to be
dismissed.
13.
From the submissions and materials that have been
placed before this Court, the issue that arises for consideration is only
whether the respondent Corporation, is entitled to recover the
outstanding amounts from the petitioner No. 1 and its affiliates
respondents Nos. 3 & 4, for the periods prior to 22.12.2022 i.e. the
effective date when as per the resolution plan, the petitioner No. 1
was taken over. As discussed above, after the petitioner No. 1 was
admitted to insolvency, a resolution plan which had been submitted
was approved by the National Company Law Tribunal and by the
Supreme Court, and Reliance Projects and Property Management
Solutions Ltd. (RPPMSL) took over the petitioner No. 1 on
22.12.2022. Section 31 (1) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code,
2016 (I&B Code) which is relevant in this respect, provides that an
2024:MLHC:504
approved resolution plan is binding on all creditors. The same is
reproduced hereinbelow:“31: Approval of resolution plan. - (1) If the
Adjudicating Authority is satisfied that the resolution
plan as approved by the committee of creditors under
sub-section (4) of section 30 meets the requirements as
referred to in sub-section (2) of section 30, it shall by
order approve the resolution plan which shall be
binding on the corporate debtor and its employees,
members,
creditors,
[including the
Central
Government, any State Government or any local
authority to whom a debt in respect of the payment of
dues arising under any law for the time being in force,
such as authorities to whom statutory dues are
owed,] guarantors and other stakeholders involved in
the resolution plan:
Provided that the Adjudicating Authority shall, before
passing an order for approval of resolution plan under
this sub-section, satisfy that the resolution plan has
provisions for its effective implementation.”
14.
As such, by operation of the above quoted provision,
even in cases where the creditors include Central Government and
such other authorities to whom statutory dues are owed, they shall be
bound by the said resolution. It is seen in the instant case that in
accordance with the provisions of the I&B Code, public
announcements had been made inviting all creditors of the petitioner
No. 1, to submit proof of claims on or before 01.06.2016, and the
2024:MLHC:504
same was also published by the Interim Resolution Professional as
evidenced by Annexures 3 to 5 of the writ petition. Thereafter, what
is more telling, is that by a letter dated 25.07.2019, (Annexure 6 to
the writ petition) the Resolution Professional, had addressed a letter
to all the State Electricity Boards informing them of the Corporate
Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) and further, had invited any
claims which had not yet been submitted against the Corporate
Debtor. The respondent No. 2 it appears, did not submit any claims
in respect of their dues as was done by the other creditors. The
approval order then on the resolution coming to a close, was passed
on 03.12.2020 by the NCLT, wherein as per the approved Resolution
Plan the claims, demands and liabilities as the case may be were to
stand fulfilled on the deposit of the resolution amount. Though
against the approval order, appeals were filed by various persons, the
NCLT on an application by the petitioner No. 1 allowed the deposit
of the total value of the Restoration Plan into an Escrow account,
which would go towards distribution of the said amount to the
creditors, which enabled the acquisition and control of the petitioner
2024:MLHC:504
No. 1 on a clean slate, as also on all the claims which were lying
before the effective date i.e. 22.12.2022.
15.
In this backdrop, what unfolded thereafter, was on the
application of the petitioner No. 1, for a permanent power connection
before the respondent No. 2, the same was declined vide letter dated
29.03.2023, on account of pending dues of the petitioner No. 1, i.e.
formally Reliance Telecom, and the petitioner was called upon to
clear all dues in order to acquire any new connection. At this juncture,
it would be useful to refer to Section 238 of the I&B Code, which
provides that this Code shall override other laws. The same is
reproduced hereinbelow:“238. Provisions of this Code to override other laws.The provisions of this Code shall have effect,
notwithstanding anything inconsistent therewith
contained in any other law for the time being in force
or any instrument having effect by virtue of any such
law.”
16.
This provision is crucial, as a ground had been set up by
the respondent No. 2 that electricity dues being statutory in character
under the Electricity Act 2003, the same cannot be waived in view of
2024:MLHC:504
Section 56 of the said Act. However, though electricity dues
admittedly, and as held by the Supreme Court in the case Telangana
State Southern Power Distribution Company Ltd. & Anr. vs.
Srigdhaa Beverages (supra) are statutory in character and cannot be
waived, the interplay of Sections 31 and 238 of the I&B Code and
the circumstances surrounding the case, have to be given due
consideration. This observation has been made in view of the fact that
the respondent No. 2, did not participate in the resolution process and
as such, as per Section 31 is bound by the same. The dues claimed by
the respondent No. 1, are for the periods prior to the effective date
i.e. 22.12.2022, which on the approval of the Resolution Plan, on no
claim being made by the respondent No. 2, would therefore stand
extinguished. In the considered view of this Court, Section 56 of the
Electricity Act will not be attracted, as it is not a case where the
petitioner No. 1, after the effective date, has neglected to pay any
charge of electricity, or that any amount is due. For easy reference
Section 56 of the Electricity Act, 2003 is reproduced hereinbelow:“56. Disconnection of supply in default of payment: -(1) Where any person neglects to pay any charge for
electricity or any sum other than a charge for electricity
due from him to a licensee or the generating company
2024:MLHC:504
in respect of supply, transmission or distribution or
wheeling of electricity to him, the licensee or the
generating company may, after giving not less than
fifteen clear days’ notice in writing, to such person and
without prejudice to his rights to recover such charge
or other sum by suit, cut off the supply of electricity and
for that purpose cut or disconnect any electric supply
line or other works being the property of such licensee
or the generating company through which electricity
may have been supplied, transmitted, distributed or
wheeled and may discontinue the supply until such
charge or other sum, together with any expenses
incurred by him in cutting off and reconnecting the
supply, are paid, but no longer:
Provided that the supply of electricity shall not be cut
off if such person deposits, under protest,(a) an amount equal to the sum claimed from him, or
(b) the electricity charges due from him for each month
calculated on the basis of average charge for electricity
paid by him during the preceding six months,
whichever is less, pending disposal of any dispute
between him and the licensee.
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in any other
law for the time being in force, no sum due from any
consumer, under this section shall be recoverable after
the period of two years from the date when such sum
became first due unless such sum has been shown
continuously as recoverable as arrear of charges for
electricity supplied and the licensee shall not cut off the
supply of the electricity.”
2024:MLHC:504
As such, the dues not attributable to the petitioner No. 1
after the effective date, and no claim having been made against the
Corporate Debtor, and further Section 238 having an overriding
effect on all other laws, the stand of the respondent No. 1 that the
petitioners are liable to pay in terms of Section 56 of the Electricity
Act is therefore, unsustainable.
17.
As held in the case of Ghanshyam Mishra vs. Edelweiss
Asset Reconstruction Co. Ltd (supra), the legislative intent of
making the resolution plan binding after approval, was that the
successful resolution applicant, should start with a fresh slate on the
basis of the said approved resolution plan, and that it not be faced
with surprise claims. Para 102.1, which is very relevant is quoted
hereinbelow:“102.1. That once a resolution plan is duly approved
by the adjudicating authority under sub-section (1) of
Section 31, the claims as provided in the resolution
plan shall stand frozen and will be binding on the
corporate debtor and its employees, members, creditors
including the Central Government, any State
Government or any local authority, guarantors and
other stakeholders. On the date of approval of
resolution plan by the adjudicating authority, all such
claims, which are not a part of resolution plan, shall
2024:MLHC:504
stand extinguished and no person will be entitled to
initiate or continue any proceedings in respect to a
claim, which is not part of the resolution plan.”
18.
Further, the above proposition that is applicable to the
instant case, has also been dealt with in the case of Southern Power
Distribution Company of Andhra Pradesh Limited vs. Gavi
Siddeswara Steels (India) Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. and Tata Power Western
Odisha Distribution Limited (TPWODL) & Anr. vs. Jagannath
Sponge Private Limited (supra) wherein the Supreme Court has held
that the clean slate principle will stand negated if the successful
resolution applicant is asked to pay the arrears payable by the
Corporate Debtor for the grant of an electricity connection in his/her
name. The argument put by the respondent No. 1, by placing reliance
on the case of State Tax Officer vs. Rainbow Papers Ltd. (supra) that
any resolution plan which overrides statutory dues, is invalid and not
binding to the mind of the Court, will have no application in the
instant case, as firstly, the respondent No. 2 never filed any claim in
accordance with law, and further the said decision was rendered in
regular appeals which were preferred under Section 62 of the I&B
Code.
2024:MLHC:504
19.
On the other challenge that the writ petition is not
maintainable, due to the availability of alternative efficacious
remedy, by virtue of Section 60 (5) (c) of the I&B Code, 2016, this
argument is not accepted, as the writ petitioner is clearly seeking a
mandamus in view of the actions of the respondents Nos. 1 & 2,
where in spite of the binding nature of Section 31 of the I&B Code,
are denying the writ petitioners electricity connections by making the
same contingent upon the recovery of pending dues not attributable
to it. The judgments referred to by the learned Advocate General
standing on a different footing are of no assistance and are not
discussed herein.
20.
Accordingly, as discussed above and in the facts and
circumstances of the case, the instant writ petition stands allowed and
is disposed of.
21.
No order as to costs.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
05.06.2024
VALENTINO
LYNDEM
VALENTINO LYNDEM
Date: 2024.06.06 16:44:18
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review