Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:31327]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 18762/2025
CNR: RJHC021001872025 | URN: CW / 42276U / 2025
1.
M/s Rampratap Bhanwarlal Company, (A Partnership
Firm) Through Its Partner Smt. Vimla Devi W/o Surajmal
Goyal Purani Mandi, Ajmer
2.
Smt Vimla Devi W/o Surajmal Goyal, Partner, M/s
Rampratap Bhawarlal Company, Old Mandi, Ajmer
3.
Smt. Sulochna Devi W/o Chandraprakash, Partner, M/s
Rampratap Bhawarlal Company, Old Mandi, Ajmer
----Petitioners
Versus
Smt Neha Bindal W/o Lokesh Bindal, Aged About 36 Years, R/o
10/132 (149/16), Purani Mandi, Ajmer
----Respondent
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Akshay Singh for
Mr. Deepak Chauhan
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Veyankatesh Garg,
Ms. Pranjal Mundhra
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUDESH BANSAL
Order
10/08/2026
1.
Heard counsel for both parties and perused the record.
2.
Petitioners are tenant of respondent in the shop in question.
The application filed by respondent under Section 9 of the Rent
Control Act, 2001, pleading the necessity of the rented shop for
her husband to shift and use the shop for his business of readymade garments, was dismissed by the Rent Tribunal, Ajmer, vide
order dated 21.10.2022, whereagainst respondent preferred an
appeal. In the appeal, the Appellate Rent Tribunal, Ajmer, vide
judgment dated 03.10.2025, decided the issue of bona fide and
reasonable necessity in favour of respondent, and granted an
eviction certificate, directing petitioners to vacate and hand over
(2 of 10)
[2026:RJ-JP:31327]
the possession of the
[CW-18762/2025]
rented shop to respondent-landlord.
Aggrieved thereby, petitioners have preferred the present writ
petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
3.
The rented premises is situated in the building of respondent
at ground floor, which is a shop situated on the main road at
Purani Mandi, Ajmer, wherein petitioners are stated to be carrying
on the business of manufacturing and preparing photo frames.
The necessity of the said shop was pleaded for respondent's
husband to use the shop for continuing the business of readymade garments, which has to be started by respondent’s husband
in two rooms at ground floor, opening in chowk of the building.
4.
During the course of arguments, counsel appearing for
petitioners pointed out that, on previous occasion when the writ
petition came up on Board, an offer was given by respondent to
exchange the residential portion comprising two rooms, wherein
respondent's husband is presently carrying on his business, with
the
rented
shop
of
petitioners,
however,
subsequently,
respondents resiled from the said offer. In this regard, counsel
appearing for respondent drew the attention of this Court to the
order dated 26.02.2026 passed in the present writ petition,
wherein the alleged offer of exchange was noted by the Court in
presence of counsel for petitioners, but in the absence of the
arguing counsel for respondent.
However, counsel for respondent submits that respondent is
not agreeable to any such exchange of the residential portion of
two rooms of respondent with the rented shop of petitioners, and
she intends to contest the present writ petition on merits.
[2026:RJ-JP:31327]
5.
(3 of 10)
[CW-18762/2025]
Hence, with the consent of counsel for both parties, the writ
petition has been heard finally on merits.
6.
The submission of learned counsel for petitioners is that the
tenancy in the rented shop commenced in the year 1980 at a
monthly rent of Rs.400/-, which was enhanced to Rs.3,500/- per
month in the year 2015. Thereafter, respondent sought to enhance
the rent to Rs.5,000/- per month, but when petitioners declined to
accede to the said demand, the present eviction proceedings were
instituted, setting out the ground of bona fide and reasonable
necessity, and other grounds.
7.
Learned counsel for petitioners submits that the husband of
respondent is already carrying on his business of ready-made
garments from the premises situated on the ground floor of the
same building wherein rented shop is situated. The premises
wherein respondent’s husband is running his business of readymade garments is located just behind the rented shop in same
building and at the ground floor, which too is suitable and
sufficient for that business, hence, the alleged necessity of the
rented shop, as set out by respondent, is concocted, illusory and
unreasonable. He further submits that learned Rent Tribunal, after
appreciating the evidence on record, rightly declined to grant an
eviction certificate on this flimsy ground of the necessity. However,
the Appellate Rent Tribunal, without pondering over the factual
backdrop of the case, reversed the said finding and set aside the
order of the Rent Tribunal and committed perversity in issuing an
eviction certificate in favour of respondent-landlord on the ground
(4 of 10)
[2026:RJ-JP:31327]
[CW-18762/2025]
of alleged bona fide and reasonable necessity, which is indeed
neither genuine nor real.
His submission is that the reversal findings recorded by the
Appellate Rent Tribunal in respect of Issue No.1, which pertains to
the bona fide and reasonable necessity of the rented shop, are
perverse and contrary to the material available on record and,
therefore, liable to be quashed and set aside. Consequently, it has
been prayed that the judgment dated 03.10.2025 passed by the
Appellate Rent Tribunal be quashed and set aside, so as to uphold
the judgment dated 21.10.2022 passed by the Rent Tribunal.
8.
Per
contra,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
respondent
submits that the premises wherein respondent's husband is
carrying on his business of ready-made garments, are situated in
the residential portion of the house, having an opening in the
chowk, whereas the rented shop is situated on the main road at
Purani Mandi, Ajmer, therefore, the rented shop is more suitable
and advantageous for carrying on and to flourish the business of
ready-made garments by respondent's husband. It has been
submitted that the true factual aspect could not be properly
appreciated by the Rent Tribunal, but has duly been considered by
the Appellate Rent Tribunal in true sense, hence, the eviction
certificate
passed
in
favour
of
respondent,
is
based
on
appreciation of evidence and after considering the entirety of facts
and circumstances of the case, which is not required to be
interfered with by this Court in exercise of its writ jurisdiction
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
9.
Heard. Considered.
(5 of 10)
[2026:RJ-JP:31327]
10.
[CW-18762/2025]
The present writ petition involves a dispute between the
landlord and tenant, in respect of eviction of petitioners from the
shop in question on the ground of bona fide and reasonable
necessity of respondent. The question of bona fide and reasonable
necessity is essentially a mixed question of fact and law, which
requires adjudication on the basis of the evidence brought on
record. Unless and until, the fact findings recorded by the courts
below, or by the Appellate Rent Tribunal in the present case, on
the issue of bona fide and reasonable necessity, are shown to be
perverse, without evidence or contrary to the material available on
record, or otherwise suffering from a patent illegality or beyond
the settled principles of law on the subject, such findings ordinarily
do not warrant interference by the High Court in exercise of its
writ jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
In support of the aforesaid proposition, instead of multiplying
the case law, reference of few judgments delivered by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court, would be suffice:(i)
Shamshad Ahmad v. Tilak Raj Bajaj [(2008) 9 SCC 1];
(ii)
Shalini
Shyam
Shetty
v.
Rajendra
Shankar
Patil
[(2010) 8 SCC 329];
(iii)
Jacky v. Tiny Alias Antony [(2014) 6 SCC 508];
(iv) B. K. Muniraju v. State of Karnataka [(2008) 4 SCC
451]; &
(v)
Mohammed Yusuf v. Faji Mohammad [(2009) 3 SCC
513].
11.
In case of Shamshad Ahmad (Supra), the Hon’ble Supreme
Court held that the fact findings recorded by the Appellate Court in
(6 of 10)
[2026:RJ-JP:31327]
[CW-18762/2025]
respect of the ground of bona fide and reasonable necessity, could
not have been interfered with and set aside by the High Court in
exercise of writ jurisdiction.
12.
In case of Shalini Shyam Shetty (Supra), after pondering
over
the
previous
judgments,
the
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
observed, in respect of exercising jurisdiction by the High Court
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, that while exercising
its powers of superintendence, the High Court cannot interfere to
correct mere errors of law or fact or just because another view
than the one taken by the tribunals or courts subordinate to it, is
a possible view. In other words, the jurisdiction has to be very
sparingly exercised.
13.
In case of Jacky (Supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court, in
Para No.15, held and observed as under:“15. A petition under Article 226 or Article 227 of the Constitution
of India can neither be entertained to decide the landlord-tenant
dispute nor is it maintainable against a private individual to
determine an intense dispute including the question whether one
party is harassing the other party. The High Court under Article
227 has the jurisdiction to ensure that all subordinate courts as
well as statutory or quasi-judicial tribunals, exercise the powers
vested in them within the bounds of their authority but it was not
the case of the 1st respondent that the order passed by the
Munsif Court was without any jurisdiction or was so exercised
exceeding its jurisdiction. If a suit is not maintainable it was well
within the jurisdiction of the High Court to decide the same in
appropriate proceedings but in no case power under Articles 226
and 227 of the Constitution of India can be exercised to question
a plaint.”
14.
Keeping in mind the proposition of law as expounded by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the afore-referred judgments, this Court
finds that the Appellate Rent Tribunal, in the impugned judgment
dated 03.10.2025, has categorically recorded a fact finding that
the rented shop, which has opening on main road, comparing to
[2026:RJ-JP:31327]
(7 of 10)
[CW-18762/2025]
the residential portions of two rooms having opening in the
common chowk, is more suitable for carrying on the business of
ready-made garments by respondent's husband, and that he
cannot be compelled to continue his business from the residential
rooms situated in the chowk, which has a narrow opening. The
factum that respondent’s husband has started his business of
ready-made garments in his residential two rooms, due to nonavailability of vacant shop is an undisputed fact. Such findings
have been recorded on the basis of appreciation of evidence led by
parties as well as considering the location of the rented shop and
premises, wherein respondent’s husband is carrying on business of
ready-made garments so also the suitability of the rented shop for
respondent’s husband. Such fact findings, being based on the
material available on record, cannot be considered to be perverse,
much less have been recorded within the jurisdiction and
parameters of law.
15.
In addition, the Appellate Rent Tribunal has also noticed that
another shop, adjoining to the rented shop, came to be vacated
during the course of present proceedings, has been used by
respondent herself, for doing her separate business of sarees.
16.
Having gone through the findings recorded by the Rent
Tribunal on Issue No.1, and the reversal findings recorded by the
Appellate Rent Tribunal, particularly with regard to the necessity of
the rented shop for shifting the business of ready-made garments
being carried on by respondent's husband, this Court arrives at a
conclusion that the findings recorded by the Appellate Rent
Tribunal are just, proper and reasonable, which do not warrant
(8 of 10)
[2026:RJ-JP:31327]
[CW-18762/2025]
interference in exercise of the writ jurisdiction of this Court under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
17.
This Court further finds that the Appellate Rent Tribunal
acted well within its jurisdiction so also in consonance with the
settled principles of law while holding that the necessity, pleaded
by respondent for obtaining vacant possession of the rented shop
to shift and carrying on the business of ready-made garments by
her husband therein, is bona fide and reasonable, and accordingly,
the Appellate Rent Tribunal passed the eviction certificate, well
within its jurisdiction.
18.
The supervisory jurisdiction of the High Court under Article
227 of the Constitution of India is not akin to appellate or
revisional jurisdiction and is limited to examine the perversity in
the order or jurisdictional error or the order suffers from patent
illegality or vice of arbitrariness, which leads to injustice. The
fundamental
object
and
purpose
of
exercising
supervisory
jurisdiction by the High Court is to keep the subordinate Courts
within the bounds and parameters of law.
It would not be out of place to refer the oft-quoted and
landmark judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of
Estralla Rubber Vs. Dass Estate (P) Ltd. [2001 (8) SCC 97],
wherein the scope and ambit of the jurisdiction of the High Court
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India have been explained
as under:-
“The scope and ambit of exercise of power and jurisdiction by a
High Court under Article 227 of the Constitution of India is
examined and explained in number of decisions of this Court. The
exercise of power under this Article involves a duty on the High
Court to keep inferior courts and tribunals within the bounds of
[2026:RJ-JP:31327]
(9 of 10)
[CW-18762/2025]
their authority and to see that they do duty expected or required
of them in a legal manner. The High Court is not vested with any
unlimited prerogative to correct all kinds of hardship or wrong
decisions made within the limits of the jurisdiction of the courts
subordinate or tribunals. Exercise of this power and interfering
with the orders of the courts or tribunal is restricted to cases of
serious dereliction of duty and flagrant violation of fundamental
principles of law or justice, where if High Court does not interfere,
a grave injustice remains uncorrected. It is also well settled that
the High Court while acting under this Article cannot exercise its
power as an appellate court or substitute its own judgment in
place of that of the subordinate court to correct an error, which is
not apparent on the face of the record. The High Court can set
aside or ignore the findings of facts of inferior court or tribunal, if
there is no evidence at all to justify or the finding is so perverse,
that no reasonable person can possibly come to such a
conclusion, which the court or Tribunal has come to.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
The ratio decidendi expounded by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in case of Estralla Rubber (Supra), has been affirmed and
reiterated recently by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Nandi
Infrastructure Corridor Enterprises Ltd. v. B. Gurappa Naidu
[2026 SCC OnLine (SC) 745], and in Para No.31, following
observations have been made:“31. The scope and ambit of the power of the High Court under
Article 227 of the Constitution has been the subject matter of
consideration before this Court in several judgments, and the law
governing of its supervisory jurisdiction, the High Court cannot act
as an appellate court, nor can it sit in appeal over the correctness
of the orders passed by courts and tribunals over which it exercise
the power of superintendence under Article 227.”
19.
In the considered opinion of this Court, the findings of fact
recorded by the Appellate Rent Tribunal in the impugned judgment
with regard to Issue No.1, pertaining to the bona fide and
reasonable necessity of the rented shop for respondent's husband
to carry on his business of ready-made garments, cannot be said
to suffer from any perversity, jurisdictional error, or transgression
of the parameters of law. Therefore, in exercise of its jurisdiction
[2026:RJ-JP:31327]
(10 of 10)
[CW-18762/2025]
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, this Court is not
inclined to interfere with the impugned judgment.
20.
As a final result, the writ petition, being devoid of substance,
is hereby dismissed.
However, since petitioners have been stated to be using the
rented shop for manufacturing photo frames since 1980, four
months’ time is granted to them to vacate and hand over the
possession of the rented shop to respondent, subject to payment
of arrears of rent/ mesne profits in terms of the order of the
Appellate Rent Tribunal dated 03.10.2025.
21.
Stay application and pending application(s), if any, stand
disposed of.
(SUDESH BANSAL),J
Sachin Sharma/ 14
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review