Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
19.01.2026
Ct. No. 06
Item No.37
Cp
C.O. No. 4145 of 2025
M/s. Raasi Refractories Limited
Vs.
M/s. Steel Authority of India Limited
Mr. Saptanshu Basu, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Aniruddha Bhattacharya
Mr. Arnab Roy
…..for the petitioner.
Mr. Suddhasatwa Banerjee
Mr. Chayan Gupta
Mr. Sayantan banerjee
Mr. Dwip Raj Basu
……for the opposite party.
1. The revisional application arises out of an order
dated August 29, 2025, passed by the learned
arbitral
tribunal.
The
tribunal
allowed
an
application filed by the opposite party/counter
claimant, for production of additional evidence at
the stage of arguments.
2. Mr. Basu, learned senior advocate for the petitioner,
relies on the decisions of this court in the matters of
Cityscope Developers (P) Ltd. vs. Akla Builders
Pvt. Ltd. & Ors., reported in (2000) SCC Online
Cal 327 and Satyendra Nath Ray vs. VCK Share
& Stock Broking Services Limited, reported in
2021 SCC Online Cal 2096, in support of the
contention
that
the
arbitrator
functions
as
a
tribunal and is amenable to the superintending
power of this court under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India.
3. Thus, the preliminary objection raised by Mr.
Suddhasatwa Banerjee, learned advocate for the
opposite party, is being refuted by Mr. Basu on the
ground that interlocutory orders passed by the
learned arbitrator can be assailed by filing an
application under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India. He further submits that unless the order is
challenged at the first instance, the point cannot be
raised at any later stage. Moreover, participation in
the proceeding before the learned arbitrator without
challenging
the
order
impugned
may
raise
a
question of waiver, and the order will attain finality.
4. It is lastly submitted that the order suffers from
erroneous exercise of jurisdiction and perversity.
Upon recording an admission that the opposite
party/counter claimant wanted to fill up a lacuna
which was noticed at the stage of arguments, the
learned arbitrator allowed additional evidence to be
filed, thereby, enabling the opposite party/counter
claimant to fill up such gaps in the evidence. Recall
of witness and filing additional evidence at such a
belated stage is impermissible in the law. The fact
that Order 18 Rule 17A of the Code of Civil
Procedure was deleted upon an amendment being
made to the Code was completely ignored. The
learned arbitrator proceeded on the basis that the
documents which were left out were relevant and
vital, thereby, also making up his mind as to their
probative value, before those were filed before him.
5. Reliance has been placed on the decision of K.K.
Velusamy vs. N. Palanisamy, reported in (2011)
11 SCC 275, in support of the contention that the
Hon’ble Apex Court had deprecated the practice of
courts allowing production of evidence which could
have been produced by the party if due diligence
had been exercised. Documents shall not be allowed
to be produced at a later stage of the proceeding,
only to fill up any lacuna or gap in the evidence
already led.
6. Further reliance was placed in the decision of Bagai
Construction vs. Gupta Building Material Store,
reported in (2013) 14 SCC 1, in support of the
contention that recall of a witness and filing of
additional evidence may be allowed for clarification,
but if those documents were not placed on record
and brought before the court only at the belated
stage, much after the conclusion of the evidence, the
lacuna could not be filled up.
7. Mr. Banerjee, learned advocate for the opposite
party/counter claimant, raises the question of
maintainability of the application on the ground that
all orders passed by the learned tribunal may be
assailed at the final stage, i.e., when the award is
under challenge. The Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 1996 is a complete Code. Section 5 of the said
Act mandates that courts should adopt a hands off
approach. He relies on the decision of Deep
Industries Limited vs. Oil and Natural Gas
Corporation Limited & Anr., reported in (2020)
15 SCC 706.
8. The issue before this court is whether the order of
the learned arbitrator, permitting the opposite
party/counter claimant to file an additional affidavit
of evidence of its third witness upon imposition of
cost of Rs.50,000/-, is either perverse or without
jurisdiction.
9. An interlocutory order under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India can be challenged on very
limited grounds. In this case, the learned tribunal
exercised
jurisdiction,
inter
alia,
holding
that
substantial justice could not be defeated by strictly
applying
the
law
of
procedure.
The
opposite
party/counter claimant would suffer loss if the
evidence was not allowed to be brought on record.
That the delay caused by the opposite party/counter
claimant in filing the additional evidence could be
compensated by awarding cost to the claimant.
10. It was contended that the learned arbitrator not only
pre-decided the issue, but also allowed the opposite
party to fill up the lacuna in their evidence. The
liquidated damages was to be quantified in terms of
money, but such quantification could not have been
made as no evidence in that regard towards
payment of additional amount etc. was on record.
The
learned
arbitrator
allowed
the
opposite
party/counter-claimant to cover up such gap in the
evidence by passing the order impugned.
11. Considered the objections raised by the petitioner. It
is an admitted position that the application seeking
permission to file additional evidence upon recall of
the third witness was filed before the learned
arbitrator when the opposite party detected that
those were mistakenly not brought on record.
Although the learned advocate admitted that there
was a lacuna, it appears to this court that in
paragraphs 57 to 59 of the counter claim sufficient
pleadings and averments had been made with
regard to the
additional cost which was allegedly
incurred by the counter claimant in respect of the
subject purchase order. Tables 1, 2 and 3 of the
counter claim indicate the total claim and the heads
under which same had been made.
12. The
additional
expenses
which
were
allegedly
incurred on account of the failure of the petitioner to
fulfil its obligations under the purchase order have
been enumerated. Thus, it cannot be said that the
counter-claimant was trying to
develop a case or
create a new case or a better case after closure of
evidence, upon discovering that the evidence was
deficient or inadequate.
13. This is not a situation which is covered by the ratio
of the decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Bagai
Constructions (supra). The learned arbitrator was
of
the
conclusion
that,
although
somewhat
negligent, the counter-claimant had missed out
relevant documents, and if those documents were
not produced in evidence, the counter-claimant
would suffer irreparable loss and injury and will not
be able to prove its case.
14. Thus, the learned arbitrator rightly decided to
permit the counter-claimant to substantiate its
claim by documentary evidence. The probative value
of those documents shall be decided by the learned
arbitrator at the final stage. The order impugned
only permitted an opportunity to the counterclaimant to substantiate and prove its claim.
Otherwise, procedural stringency could result in
injustice. It was an omission on the part of the
opposite party. Such omission was rectified by the
order.
On
account
of
arbitrator
imposed
cost.
the
delay,
the
learned
Omission
to
file
the
documents is not relatable to gross negligence. A
mistake was corrected by the tribunal.
15. It is not a fact that this order was passed in a
routine manner. The learned arbitrator applied his
judicial mind to the issue and came to the
conclusion that al beit somewhat negligent,
the
documents sought to be relied upon should be
before the tribunal for proper adjudication of the
dispute and a chance should be given to the
counter-claimant to prove its claim. Strict adherence
to the rules of procedure will prevent ultimate
justice.
16. In Bagai Construction (supra), the original bills
were sought to be placed on record after the trial
was concluded and judgment was reserved. At that
stage, the Hon’ble Apex Court held that the plaintiff
could not be permitted to file an application to fill
up lacuna in the pleadings and the evidence led by
him. In this case, there are sufficient averments in
the counter-claim indicating that the counterclaimant had incurred additional costs.
Whether
such counter claim will be allowed on the basis of
the documents sought to be disclosed in evidence, is
a matter of adjudication. It is for the arbitrator to
decide. The probative value has not been decided.
Only
a
last
opportunity
to
rely
on
certain
documents, which has been mentioned in the
counter-claim, but missed out, has been permitted.
Thus, the ratio of Bagai Construction (supra) will
not apply.
17. With regard to K. K. Velusamy (supra), this Court
finds that the Hon’ble Apex Court was of the clear
view that an application under Section 151 of the
Code of Civil Procedure could be filed despite
deletion of Order 18 Rule 17A of the Code of Civil
Procedure, if a witness is needed to be recalled and
additional evidence is to be adduced. It was further
held by the Hon’ble Apex Court that it was the duty
of the Court before which an application of such
nature was placed, to exercise discretion and
consider whether the
documents sought to be
brought on record in evidence would lead to a just
and effective adjudication or not. In this case, the
learned Arbitrator held that an opportunity should
be given in order to allow the counter-claimant to
substantiate its claim. This is not a case where the
opposite party wanted to protract the litigation by
filing frivolous applications. It cannot be held at this
stage that the opposite party was acting in a
mischievous
manner
or
had
filed
a
frivolous
application to cover up negligence and lacuna.
A
mistake on the part of the learned Advocate was
noticed by the learned Tribunal and it was held that
the counter-claimant should not suffer on account
of the mistake committed by the learned Advocate,
but must be allowed to plead and prove its case to
the fullest, for the ends of justice. Ultimately, if the
learned Tribunal finds that the evidence was not
genuine or relevant or lacked probative value, the
learned Tribunal will deny the claims based on
those documents. Such stage has not yet arrived.
Secondly, the satisfaction of the learned Tribunal as
recorded in the order impugned with regard to the
relevance of the materials sought to be brought in
by evidence by the opposite party, in my view, are
tentative findings. To arrive at a conclusion as to
why
such
evidence
should
be
filed,
such
observations were made. Those cannot be taken to
be the final decision of the learned Tribunal with
regard to acceptance of these documents as proof of
the counter-claim. The evidence will be weighed at
the time of trial and the claimant/petitioner shall
have the liberty to argue on those issues and also
cross-examine the witness on the documents to be
filed pursuant to the order impugned.
Lastly, the
award can also be challenged on the ground of
patent illegality which includes perversity, and
procedural irregularity.
learned
Arbitrator
had
The
objection
committed
that the
procedural
irregularity by allowing belated filing of the evidence,
can be also taken at the stage of challenge to the
award.
18. Under such circumstances, the order impugned is
upheld.
19. However, on account of the delay, this Court
imposes an additional cost of Rs.20,000/- to be paid
to the petitioner by the opposite party within four
weeks from date.
20. Mr. Basu submits that his client may not be in a
position to proceed before the learned Arbitrator on
20th January, 2026. Parties are at liberty to pray for
adjournment.
21. Accordingly, the revisional application is disposed
of. There shall be no order as to costs.
22. Parties are to act on the server copy of this order.
(Shampa Sarkar, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review