Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/65
GAHC010109182025
2026:GAU-AS:8028
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/2922/2025
M/S TATA PROJECTS LIMITED, ASSAM
REPRESENTED BY RAJENDRA KUMAR SHARMA, DEPUTY GENERAL
MANAGER - FINANCE AND ACCOUNTS, HAVING OFFICE AT
JAGABANDHU APARTMENT, FLAT NO. F3 (4TH FLOOR), BHANGAGARH,
OPP. HUB MALL, G.S ROAD, GUWAHATI, ASSAM
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA AND 4 ORS
THROUGH THE SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE, MINISTRY OF
FINANCE, NORTH BLOCK, NEW DELHI-110001
2:STATE OF ASSAM
REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE
GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM
FINANCE DEPARTMENT
GROUND FLOOR
F BLOCK
JANATA BHAWAN
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-781006
3:ADDITIONAL COMMISSIONER
OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER (AUDIT)
CGST
SHILLONG
PLOT NO. 47
BISHOP COTTON ROAD
4TH FURLONG
SHILLONG-793001
4:JOINT COMMISSIONER
Page No.# 2/65
CGST AND CX
GUWAHATI
GST AND CENTRAL EXCISE COMMISSIONERATE
GUWAHATI GST BHAWAN
KEDAR ROAD
MACHKHOWA
GUWAHATI-781001
5:COMMISSIONER (APPEALS)
CGST
CENTRAL EXCISE AND CUSTOMS
3RD FLOOR
GST BHAVAN
KEDAR ROAD
MACHKHOWA
GUWAHATI-78100
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR G K DEKA, S RABHA,MR. A M BARUAH
Advocate for the Respondent : DY.S.G.I., SC, FINANCE,SC, GST
Linked Case : WP(C)/20/2026
M/S QUANTUM INFRATECH
ASSAM
REP. BY MR. MAYANK BANSAL ADDRESS HAVING OFFICE AT PARNIL
PALACE
2ND FLOOR
R.G.B. ROAD
GUWAHATI
KAMRUP (METROPOLITAN)
ASSAM-781024.
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 5 ORS.
THROUGH THE SECRETARY
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE
MINISTRY OF FINANCE
NORTH BLOCK
NEW DELHI - 110001
Page No.# 3/65
2:STATE OF ASSAM
REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT
OF ASSAM
FINANCE AND TAXATION DEPARTMENT
GROUND FLOOR
F BLOCK
JANATA BHAWAN
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-781006.
3:DEPUTY DIRECTOR
DGGI GUWAHATI ZONAL UNIT
H.N. 77
RUPKONWAR JYOTI PRASAD AGARWAL ROAD
OPP. SRIMANTA SANKARDEVA KALAKSHETRA
P.O. PANJABARI
GUWAHATI-781037.
4:ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER
CGST AND CENTRAL EXCISE
GUWAHATI DIVISION-II
GST BHAWAN
KEDAR ROAD
FANCY BAZAAR
GUWAHATI-781001.
5:ADDITIONAL COMMISSIONER (APPEALS)
CGST
CENTRAL EXCISE AND CUSTOMS
3RD FLOOR
GST BHAWNA
KEDAR ROAD
MACHKHOWA
GUWAHATI-781001.
6:COMMISSIONER (APPEALS)
CGST
CENTRAL EXCISE AND CUSTOMS
3RD FLOOR
GST BHAVAN
KEDAR ROAD
MACHKHOWA
GUWAHATI-781001.
------------
Page No.# 4/65
Advocate for : MR G K DEKA
Advocate for : DY.S.G.I. appearing for THE UNION OF INDIA AND 5 ORS.
Linked Case : WP(C)/1113/2026
BITCHEM ASPHALT TECHNOLOGIES LIMITED
REPRESENTED BY ITS AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE MR. RASHMI
RANJAN ROUT
HEAD FINANCE AND IT
HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE AT ANIL PLAZA
3RD FLOOR
NEAR IDBI BANK
G.S. ROAD
GUWAHATI
ASSAM781005.
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA AND 4 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY
MINISTRY OF FINANCE
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE
ROOM NO. 76
NEW DELHI -110001.
2:CENTRAL BOARD OF INDIRECT TAXES AND CUSTOMS
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE
MINISTRY OF FINANCE
DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS
4TH FLOOR
RAJENDRA BHAWAN
210 DEEN DAYAL UPADHAYAY MARG
NEW DELHI 110002
3:PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER
GST AND CENTRAL EXCISE COMMISSIONERATE
GUWAHATI
GST BHAVAN
KEDAR ROAD
MACHKHOWA
GUWAHATI-781001.
4:JOINT COMMISSIONER
GST AND CENTRAL EXCISE COMMISSIONERATE
Page No.# 5/65
GUWAHATI
GST BHAVAN
KEDAR ROAD
MACHKHOWA
GUWAHATI-781001.
5:OFFICE OF SUPERINTENDENT
CGST RANGE-IC
GUWAHATI
GST BHAVAN
KEDAR ROAD
MACHKHOWA
GUWAHATI781001.
------------
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEVASHIS BARUAH
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. B. Raichandani, Advocate
: Mr. D. Das, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. S. C. Keyal, Senior Advocate, CGST
: Mr. K. Jain, Advocate
·
Date on which Judgment was reserved
: 12.05.2026
·
Date of Pronouncement of Judgment
: 08.06.2026
·
Whether the pronouncement is of
the Operative Part of the Judgment
: N/A
·
Whether the full Judgment has been
Pronounced
: Yes
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. B. Raichandani, the learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the Writ Petitioners in WP(C) No.2922/2025 and WP(C)
No.20/2026 and Mr. D. Das, the learned counsel appearing on
Page No.# 6/65
behalf of the Petitioner in WP(C) No.1113/2026. I have also heard
Mr. S. C. Keyal, the learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. K. Jain,
the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the Respondents.
2.
The writ petitioners in the three writ petitions have alternative
and efficacious remedy under the provisions of the Central goods
and Service Tax Act, 2017 (for short ‘the Act of 2017’). However,
the writ petitioners have approached this Court raising a common
jurisdictional issue on the maintainability of the proceedings
initiated against them. It is under such circumstances, the three
writ petitions are taken up for disposal by this common judgment
and order.
3.
The jurisdictional issue which has been raised in the batch of
writ petitions is as to whether the Proper Officer in exercise of the
powers conferred under Section 73 or Section 74 of the Act of
2017 would have the jurisdiction to issue a consolidated show
cause notice encompassing different financial years.
4.
It is the specific case of the Petitioners in the present batch of
writ petitions that if the jurisdictional issue is decided in their
favour, the entire proceedings which have been initiated against
them would be without jurisdiction and accordingly, the orders
Page No.# 7/65
which have been assailed in the present proceedings cannot
withstand the scrutiny of law.
5.
Per contra, Mr. S. C. Keyal, the learned Senior counsel for the
CGST submitted that the jurisdictional question which has been
raised is a completely misconceived one taking into account the
language employed in Sections 73 and 74 of the Act of 2017.
Under such circumstances, it is therefore the submission of the
learned Senior counsel for the Respondents that as the Petitioners
have alternative and efficacious remedies which are available under
the Act of 2017, this Court may not like to entertain the present
batch of writ petitions.
6.
In the backdrop of the above, it is the opinion of this Court
that the settled principles of law advocates the necessity of
deciding the jurisdictional issue and depending upon the outcome,
this Court may pass appropriate directions.
7.
A brief summary of the facts which led to the filing of the writ
petitions are required to be examined for deciding the jurisdictional
issue which are dealt herein under:
Page No.# 8/65
CONSPECTUS OF FACTS IN THE THREE WRIT PETITIONS:
WP(C) No.2922/2025:
8.
The Petitioner herein is a public limited company registered
under the provisions of the Act of 2017. The Petitioner is engaged
in the supply of works contract services. The Respondent
Department had conducted an audit of the records of the Petitioner
for the Financial Year 2017-18 (from July, 2017 onwards) to 202122 (till March, 2022). The Final Audit Report dated 13.12.2023 was
issued in FORM GST ADT-02. It is the case of the Petitioner that
during the course of the audit as well as subsequent thereto, the
Petitioner had paid various amounts.
9.
Be that as it may, on 27.12.2023, a Show Cause Notice was
issued under Section 74(1) of the Act of 2017 for the periods from
2018-19 to 2021-22. On the next date, i.e. on 28.12.2023, another
Show Cause Notice was issued under Section 73(1) of the Act of
2017 for the period from 2018-19. Pursuant thereto, the Petitioner
participated in the said proceedings and thereupon, an Order-inOriginal dated 30.04.2024 was passed. Being aggrieved, the
Petitioner preferred an appeal before the Respondent No.5. On
06.02.2025, the Respondent No.5 confirmed the demand as
proposed in the Show Cause Notices dated 27.12.2023 and
Page No.# 9/65
28.12.2023. It is under such circumstances, the Petitioner had
approached this Court by filing the present writ petition.
10. At this stage, it is pertinent to observe that in terms with
Section 112 of the Act of 2017, any person aggrieved by an order
passed against him under Section 107 or Section 108 of the Act of
2017 or the State Goods and Services Tax Act or the Union
Territory Goods and Services Tax Act may appeal to the Appellate
Tribunal against such order within a period of 3 (three) months
from the date on which the order sought to be appealed against
was communicated to the person preferring the appeal or the date
as may be notified by the Government, on the recommendation of
the GST Council, for filing the appeal before the Appellate Tribunal
under the Act of 2017 whichever is later.
11.
The records reveal that this Court vide an order dated
09.06.2025 issued notice and passed an interim order to the effect
that no coercive action shall be taken against the Petitioner in
terms with the Order-in-Appeal dated 06.02.2025. The interim
order thereupon had been extended from time to time.
12. The records reveal that an affidavit-in-opposition had been
filed by the Respondents on 04.02.2026 and a reply thereagainst
Page No.# 10/65
was filed by the Petitioner on 19.02.2026.
WP(C) No.20/2026:
13. The Petitioner herein is a partnership firm registered under the
Act of 2017. The Petitioner is engaged in construction of residential
buildings. The materials on record show that the Respondent
Department conducted search operations on 29.03.2023 at the
principal place of business as well as other business premises of
the Petitioner. In addition to that, searches were also carried out at
the residences of the partners and accountant of the Petitioner on
29.03.2023 and 03.04.2023.
14. Pursuant thereto, summons were issued on 29.03.2023 and
03.04.2023 to the partners as well as the accountant of the
Petitioner for the purpose of recording their statement on the said
dates. On the basis of the summons, the statements of the
partners as well as the accountant were recorded on 29.03.2023
and 03.04.2023.
15.
Subsequent thereto, during investigation, the Department
issued further summons dated 30.08.2023 and 01.11.2023 to the
Petitioner. The Petitioner neither appeared for recording of the
statements nor furnished the records/documents as sought for.
Page No.# 11/65
Rather, the Petitioner vide letters dated 11.09.2023 and 09.11.2023
raised objections by referring to Section 67(2) read with Section
160(2) of the Act of 2017. Pursuant thereto, a Show Cause Notice
was collectively issued under Section 74(1) read with Section
122(1A) and Section 122(3)(a) of the Act of 2017 on 03.08.2024
against the Petitioner, its partners and Accountant. The said Show
Cause Notice pertained to the period from July, 2017 to March,
2023.
16. The Petitioner on receipt of the said Show Cause Notice
submitted a letter on 14.08.2024 to the Respondent No.3
requesting issuance of separate Show Cause Notices under Section
74 of the Act of 2017 to the Noticee Nos. 2, 3 and 4 i.e. the
partners and the accountant of the Petitioner. However, no reply
was filed by the Petitioner or its partners as well as the
Accountant.
17. Hearings were conducted on 13.01.2025 and 20.01.2025. The
Order-in-Original dated 04.02.2025 was passed by the Respondent
No.4. The Petitioner filed six Appeals and its partners filed two
separate appeals against the Order-in-Original dated 04.02.2025.
The
Respondent
No.5
passed
the
Order-in-Appeal
dated
26.08.2025 thereby confirming the demand as was passed in the
Page No.# 12/65
Order-in-Original dated 04.02.2025. Being aggrieved, the Petitioner
had filed the instant writ petition.
18. It may not be out of place to mention that the two partners of
the Petitioner who have been imposed penalty under Section
122(1A) of the Act of 2017 have filed separate writ petitions before
this Court which are registered and numbered as WP(C)
No.24/2026 and WP(C) No.25/2026 wherein separate jurisdictional
issues have been raised and as such, the said writ petitions are
separately dealt with by a separate judgment and order. It may not
be out of place to mention that if the jurisdictional issue raised by
the Petitioner herein is adjudicated in favour of the Petitioner, the
jurisdictional issues raised in the writ petitions filed by the partners
need not be gone into.
19. This Court vide an order dated 07.01.2026 issued notice and
directed that no coercive action in pursuance to order passed by
the Respondent Authorities be initiated against the writ petitioner.
The interim order thereupon had been extended from time to time.
The Respondents in the instant proceedings have not filed any
affidavit-in-opposition.
Page No.# 13/65
WP(C) No.1113/2026:
20. The Petitioner herein is a company incorporated under the
provisions of the Companies Act, 1956 and is also registered under
the Act of 2017.
21. The Petitioner is engaged in the business of supply of road
building materials and operates under its brand name “Bitchem”,
offering a wide range of products, including Bitumen Emulsion,
patented Bitchem Tailor-Made Cold Binder, Bitumen, Modified
Bitumen, Ready Mix for Pothole Repair, LDO, Anti-Stripping Agents
and Soil Stabilization solutions.
22. The Petitioner was issued a Show Cause Notice under Section
74 of the Act of 2017 on 25.06.2025 along with the summary of
the Show Cause Notice under FORM GST DRC-01 clubbing together
Financial Years 2018-19 to 2020-2021 alleging inter alia that the
Petitioner misstated/ underreported its taxable turnover for the
Financial Years 2018-19 to 2020-21 and thereby evaded payment
of GST. The Petitioner was called upon to show cause as to why
GST amounting to Rs.12,34,73,490/- along with applicable interest
under Section 50 and penalty should not be demanded and
recovered from the Petitioner.
Page No.# 14/65
23. The Petitioner submitted replies on 25.07.2025 separately for
the Financial Year 2018-19, 2019-20 and 2020-21. Thereupon,
hearings were conducted on 20.08.2025, 18.09.2025, 08.10.2025
and 24.10.2025. Subsequent thereto, the Respondent No.4 passed
the Order-in-Original dated 28.11.2025. The Petitioner instead of
availing remedies under Section 107 of the Act of 2017, had
approached this Court by filing the present writ petition.
24. The records reveals that this Court vide an order dated
27.02.2026 issued notice and further directed that no coercive
action be taken against the Petitioner. The interim order thereupon
had been extended from time to time.
25. In the backdrop of the aforementioned facts, let this Court
consider the respective submissions of the learned counsels for the
parties in respect to the jurisdictional issue raised on the
competence of the Proper Officer to issue a consolidated Show
Cause Notice encompassing various financial years.
SUBMISSIONS MADE ON BEHALF OF THE LEARNED COUNSELS FOR
THE PARTIES:
26. Mr. B. Raichandani, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of
the Petitioners in WP(C) No.2922/2025 and WP(C) No.20/2026 and
Page No.# 15/65
Mr. D. Das, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the writ
petitioner in WP(C) No.1113/2026 submitted as under:
(A) The entire statutory architecture of the Goods and Service Tax
regime is built around distinct tax period and independent financial
years. Returns are filed tax period wise under Section 39 of the Act
of 2017. Annual returns are filed financial year wise under Section
44. Limitation under Sections 73(10) and 74(10) of the Act of 2017
is computed separately for each financial year. Maintenance of
books and records is also financial year specific. It is therefore the
submission of the learned counsels for the Petitioners that the Act
of 2017 itself recognizes every financial year as an independent
unit for determination of tax liability. The learned counsels further
submitted that Section 2(11) of the Act of 2017 defines
“assessment” to mean determination of tax liability under the Act
of 2017 and specifically include self-assessment, re-assessment,
provisional assessment, summary assessment and best judgment
assessment. A proceeding under Section 73 and 74 of the Act of
2017 is nothing but determination of tax liability and therefore
squarely fall within the definition of assessment. It was further
submitted that Section 73 or Section 74 of the Act of 2017 are only
substantive provisions through which a self-assess return filed
under Section 39 of the Act of 2017 can be reopened and
Page No.# 16/65
reassessed by the Department. Therefore, a proceedings under
Section 73 or 74 of the Act of 2017 are not separate from
assessment but a part of the overall statutory assessment
mechanism.
(B)
The learned counsels appearing on behalf of the Petitioners
further submitted that the statutory framework as envisaged in the
Act of 2017 stipulates as to how the various forms of assessment
are to be carried out. Referring to Section 59 of the Act of 2017,
the learned counsels submitted that the said Section deals with
“self-assessment”. Likewise, Section 61 of the Act of 2017
stipulates about “scrutiny of returns”. Section 62 of the Act of 2017
is in respect to “best judgment assessment”. Section 63 mentions
about assessment of unregistered persons. Section 64 of the Act of
2017 mentions about “summary assessment” and Sections 73 and
74 of the Act of 2017 determines tax liabilities arising from alleged
short payment or wrongful availment. It is therefore the
submission of the learned counsels for the Petitioners that the
proceedings under Section 73 or 74 of the Act of 2017 is a part of
determination of the tax liability and as such, has to be construed
as falling within the ambit of Section 2(11) of the Act of 2017.
(C)
The learned counsels for the Petitioners further submitted
Page No.# 17/65
that there is no scope for consolidating multiple financial years/tax
periods while issuing of notice under Section 74 of the Act of 2017,
as it goes against the very statutory scheme under the Act of 2017.
The learned counsels further submitted that inserting Section
73(10) and Section 74(10) of the Act of 2017 by the Legislature,
the legislative intent is very clear that proceedings under Sections
73 and 74 of the Act of 2017 had to be initiated financial years
wise and not consolidated financial years wise. The legislative
intent is based upon the prejudice which would be caused upon
the assessee inasmuch as, distinct years may have distinct
defences, distinct limitation periods and even different statutory
provisions. In this regard, the learned counsels appearing on behalf
of the Petitioners submitted that there are various judgments of
the High Courts supporting the point in issue in favour of the
Petitioners that there cannot be initiation of consolidated Show
Cause proceedings under Section 73 or 74 of the Act of 2017 for
multiple financial years. In that regard, the learned counsels
referred to the following judgments:
(i)
M/S Tharayil Medicals Vs. The Deputy Commissioner
[2025-TIOL-828-HC-KERALA-GST];
(ii) Dhanlaxmi Bank Limited & Another Vs. Union of India &
Page No.# 18/65
Others [2026-TIOL-353-HC-KERALA-GST];
(iii) M/S Oriental Lotus Hotel Supplies Private Limited Vs.
The Joint Commissioner,
Chennai GST Audit II,
Commissionerate [2025-TIOL-1869-HC-MAD-GST];
(iv) Titan Company Ltd. Vs. Joint Commissioner of GST & C.
Ex. & Another [2024 (1) TMI 619];
(v)
Milroc Good Earth Developers Vs. Union of India [WP
2203/2025];
(vi) Marfani Steel Impex Vs. Principal Commissioner, CGST
& Central Excise, Nagpur, [(2026) 39 Centax 300
(Bom.);
(vii) Aasawa Brother Corporate Avenue Vs. Union of India &
Others., [WP No.11644 of 2025]; and
(viii) Uber India Systems Private Limited Vs. Deputy
Commissioner of Central Tax Superintendent [WP
No.19740/2024].
(D) In addition to that, the learned counsels for the Petitioners
also submitted that a perusal of Section 73(10) and Section 74(10)
Page No.# 19/65
of the Act of 2017 would show that the Proper Officer shall issue
the order under Section 73(9) or Section 74(9) of the Act of 2017
within 3 years or 5 years respectively from the due date for
furnishing of annual return for the financial year to which the tax
not paid or short paid or input tax credit wrongly availed or utilized
relates to or within 3 years or 5 years from the date of erroneous
refund. The learned counsels submitted that the phrase “the
financial year to which .…. relates” as appearing in Section 73(10)
and Section 74(10) of the Act of 2017 is a term of jurisdictional
significance inasmuch as limitation runs independently for each
financial year calculated from the financial year due date for annual
return. It was submitted that 3 (three) or 5 (five) financial years
means 3 (three) or 5 (five) independent windows of limitation
which would be 3 (three) or 5 (five) separate causes of action and
3 (three) or 5 (five) separate basis of jurisdiction respectively. This
limitation periods so mentioned in Section 73(10) and 74(10) of
the Act of 2017 cannot be carried over cumulatively as they are
structurally isolated. In that regard, Paragraph Nos. 8.4 – 8.6 of
the judgment in the case of Pramur Homes and Shelters Vs. Union
of India and Others reported in MANU/KA/4378/2025 have been
relied upon.
(E)
The learned counsels further submitted that the insertion of
Page No.# 20/65
Section 74A by the Finance Act, 2024 w.e.f. 01.11.2024 and
applying the same to financial year 2024-25 onwards as well as the
insertion of Section 73(12) and Section 74(12) by the Finance Act,
2024 w.e.f. 01.11.2024 clearly signifies the legislative scheme and
intent that the proceedings which are to be initiated under Section
73 as well as Section 74 of the Act of 2017 have to be financial
year specific.
27. Per contra, Mr. S. C. Keyal, the learned Senior counsel for the
Respondents submitted that a combined reading of Sections 73(1),
73(3), 74(1) and 74(3) of the Act of 2017 clearly demonstrates
that the statute permits issuance of notice and statements for any
period and such period without restricting the same to a single
financial year. Referring to Sub-Sections (3) and (4) of Sections 73
and 74 of the Act of 2017 respectively, the learned Senior counsel
submitted
that these Sub-Sections contemplate issuance of
statement for period other than those covered under Sub-Section
(1) of Sections 73 and 74 of the Act of 2017 which are deemed to
be notices for the purpose of adjudication. The use of the
expression “for any period” and “for such periods” unmistakably
indicates that the legislature consciously permitted consolidated
proceedings in respect of multiple years. The said aspect is in clear
contrast with Section 73(10) and 74(10) of the Act of 2017 where
Page No.# 21/65
the expression “financial year” has been specifically employed only
for the purpose of computation of limitation for passing
adjudication orders. Consequently, while limitation is to be
reckoned independently for each financial year, there exists no
statutory embargo against issuance of consolidated Show Cause
Notice for multiple years.
28. The learned Senior counsel therefore submitted that clubbing
of multiple financial years in one Show Cause Notice is merely
procedural in nature and does not extend, override or dilute the
statutory timelines prescribed under the Act of 2017. It was further
submitted that the issuance of the consolidated Show Cause
Notices also served upon object of administrative efficiency by
avoiding multiplicity of proceedings, repeated adjudication and
conflicting findings. Such consolidation is equally beneficial to the
tax payer as it reduces repetitive litigations and permit holistic
adjudication of transactions spread across several years particularly
in cases involving fraudulent availment or utilization of input tax
credit. The learned Senior counsel further submitted that the issue
as to whether it is permissible to issue a consolidated Show Cause
Notice thereby encompassing various financial years is no longer
res-integra in view of the authoritative pronouncement of various
Courts. In that regard, the learned Senior counsel referred to the
Page No.# 22/65
judgment of the Delhi High Court in the case of Ambika Traders
through Proprietor Vs. Additional Commissioner, Adjudication,
DGGSTI, CGST, Delhi North reported in 2025 SCC OnLine Del 6913.
29.
The learned Senior counsel appearing on behalf of the
Respondents further submitted that a Special Leave Petition was
filed against the judgment of the Delhi High Court in the case of
Ambika Traders (supra) before the Supreme Court. However, the
said Special Leave Petition was withdrawn on 01.09.2025.
30. The learned Senior counsel further referred to the judgment of
the Delhi High Court in the case of M/S Mathur Polymers Vs. Union
of India and Others reported in 2025 SCC OnLine Del 6892 wherein
the judgment in the case of Ambika Traders (supra) was followed.
The learned Senior counsel for the Respondents further submitted
that a Special Leave Petition was filed against the judgment in the
case of M/S Mathur Polymers (supra). However, the Special Leave
Petition was also dismissed but with a categorical observation by
the Supreme Court in its order dated 07.11.2025 that the Supreme
Court did not find any good ground and reason to interfere with
the judgment passed by the Delhi High Court in the case of M/S
Mathur Polymers (supra).
31. The learned Senior counsel further referred to the judgment of
Page No.# 23/65
the Supreme Court in the case of Kunhayammed Vs. State of
Kerala reported in (2000) 6 SCC 359 and submitted that as the
Supreme Court had made an observation in the order dated
07.11.2025 that there was no good ground and reason to interfere
with the impugned order passed by the Delhi High Court in the
case of M/S Mathur Polymers (supra), the principles of law as laid
down in M/S Mathur Polymers (supra) were upheld. The learned
Senior counsel further submitted referring to Paragraph No.44(v) of
the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Kunhayammed
(supra) that the statement of law contained in M/S Mathur
Polymers (supra) therefore had attained the status of declaration of
law by the Supreme Court within the meaning of Article 141 of the
Constitution and hence binding.
32. The learned Senior counsel further submitted that the learned
Division Bench of the Allahabad High Court in the case of S.A.
Aromatics Private Limited and Another Vs. Union of India and
Others reported in 2026 SCC OnLine All 191 was of the clear view
that it was permissible for the Proper Officer to issue a
consolidated Show Cause Notice for different years. In that regard,
he referred to paragraph Nos. 65 to 82 of the said judgment. The
learned Senior counsel for the Respondents further referred to a
recent judgment of the learned Division Bench of the Karnataka
Page No.# 24/65
High Court in the case of Commissioner of Central Tax, Bengaluru
and Another Vs. Chimney Hills Education Society reported in 2026
SCC OnLine Kar 3836 and submitted that the judgment passed by
the learned Single Judge in the case of Pramur Homes and
Shelters (supra) was interfered with. The learned Senior counsel
submitted that the learned Division Bench of the Karnataka High
Court had held that there was no statutory bar for issuance of a
common Show Cause Notice covering multiple tax periods or
financial years. In that regard, reference was made to Paragraph
No.57 of the said judgment.
33.
The learned Senior counsel appearing on behalf of the
Respondents also submitted that the statement of law laid down by
the Bombay High Court in the case of Milroc Good Earth
Developers (supra), Marfani Steel Impex (supra), Aasawa Brother
Corporate Avenue (supra) have been referred by another learned
Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in the case of Rollmet
LLP Vs. Union of India reported in 2026 SCC OnLine Bom 2613 to a
larger Bench by formulating 5 (five) questions.
34. The learned Senior counsel for the Respondents therefore
submitted that the jurisdictional issue which have been raised in
the instant proceedings is no longer res-integra in view of the
Page No.# 25/65
various judgments passed by the various High Courts as well as the
statement of law in the case of M/S Mathur Polymers (supra)
having been accepted by the Supreme Court in the order dated
07.11.2025 which would be a declaration of law in terms with
Article 141 of the Constitution. The learned Senior counsel for the
Respondents therefore submitted that the instant batch of writ
petitions therefore ought not to be entertained as the Petitioners
have alternative and efficacious remedy.
ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION:
35. The Act of 2017 is an enactment to make provisions for levy
and collection of tax on intra-state supply of goods or services or
both by the Central Government and the matters connected
therewith or incidental thereto. Section 2 of the Act of 2017
contains the various definitions.
Section 2(4) of the Act of 2017 defines the term “Adjudicating
Authority” to mean any authority, appointed or authorized to pass
any order or decision under the Act of 2017 but does not include
the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs, the Revisional
Authority, the Authority for Advance Ruling, the Appellate Authority
for Advance Ruling, the National Appellate Authority for Advance
Ruling, the Appellate Authority, the Appellate Tribunal as well as
Page No.# 26/65
the Authority referred to in Sub-Section (2) of Section 171 of the
Act of 2017. In other words, the Proper Officer who would be
required to pass an order under Sections 73(9) or Section 74(9) of
the Act of 2017 has to be construed as the Adjudicating Authority.
Section 2(8) of the Act of 2017 specifically defines the term
“Appellate
Authority”
to
mean
the
authority
appointed
or
authorized to hear appeals as referred to in Section 107 of the Act
of 2017.
Section 2(9) defines the term “Appellate Tribunal” to mean the
Goods and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal constituted under Section
109 of the Act of 2017.
Section 2(11) of the Act of 2017 defines the term “Assessment”
to mean determination of the tax liability under the Act of 2017
and
includes
self-assessment,
reassessment,
provisional
assessment, summary assessment and best judgment assessment.
Section 2(91) of the Act of 2017 defines the term “Proper
Officer” to mean an Officer in relation to any function to be
performed under the Act of 2017 and means the Commissioner or
the Officer of the Central Tax who is assigned that function by the
Commissioner in the Board.
Page No.# 27/65
Section 2(106) of the Act of 2017 defines the term “Tax Period”
to mean period for which the return is required to be furnished.
Section 2(117) of the Act of 2017 defines the term “Valid
Return” to mean a return furnished under Sub-Section (1) of
Section 39 of the Act of 2017 on which self-assessed tax have been
paid in full.
It is also apposite herein to observe that Section 2(97) of the
Act of 2017 defines the term “Return” to mean any return
prescribed or otherwise required to be furnished by or under the
Act of 2017 or the Rules made therein under.
From the definitions so provided in Section 2 of the Act of
2017, there is no definition for the term “financial year” or the
phrase “for any period” or “for such periods”.
36. Chapter IX of the Act of 2017 is with the heading “Returns”.
Section 39 of the Act of 2017 which is included in Chapter IX
stipulates the requirement of furnishing returns electronically.
Section 39(2) of the Act of 2017 is of relevance inasmuch as it
stipulates that the registered person paying tax under the
provisions of Section 10 of the Act of 2017 shall for each financial
year or part thereof furnish a return electronically of the turnover
Page No.# 28/65
in the State or Union Territory, inward supplies of goods or services
or both, tax payable, tax paid and such other particulars in such
form and manner and within such time as may be prescribed. The
corresponding Rule in respect to Section 39(2) is Rule 62 of the
Central Goods and Service Tax Rules, 2017 (for short ‘the Rules of
2017’).
Section 44 of the Act of 2017 deals with “Annual Return”. The
said annual return is to be filed for every financial year
electronically within such time and in such form and in such
manner as prescribed under the Rules of 2017. Rule 80 of the
Rules of 2017 stipulates as to within what time, the annual return
is to be submitted. The said annual return is to be submitted
electronically in FORM GSTR-9 on or before 31 st day of December
following the end of such financial year through the common portal
either directly or through a Facilitation Centre notified by the
Commissioner. At this stage, it is relevant to observe that vide
various notifications, amendments were carried out to Rule 80 of
the Rules of 2017 by insertion of Sub-Rules (1A), (1B), (3A) and
(3B) whereby the period for filing annual returns were extended for
the financial year 2020-21 for all registered persons mentioned in
Sub-Rule (1) and (3) of Rule 80 of the Rules of 2017 and for the
financial year 2022-23, for those registered persons who has their
Page No.# 29/65
principal place of business at certain locations.
37.
Chapter XII of the Act of 2017 is with the heading
“Assessment”. The said chapter contains Sections 59 to 64 of the
Act of 2017.
38. Section 59 of the Act of 2017 relates to “self-assessment”
whereby a registered person self-assess the taxes payable under
the Act of 2017 and furnishes a return for each tax period as
specified under Section 39 of the Act of 2017.
39. Section 60 of the Act of 2017 is in relation to “provisional
assessment”. Provisional assessment is made where the taxable
person is unable to determine the value of the goods or services or
both or determine the rate of tax applicable and in such
circumstances, the taxable person request the Proper Officer in
writing giving reasons for the payment of tax on provisional basis
and the Proper Officer shall pass an order within a period not later
than 90 days from the date of receipt of such request allowing the
payment of tax on provisional basis at such rate or on such value
as may be specified by him.
40. Section 61 of the Act of 2017 deals with “scrutiny of returns”
whereby the Proper Officer scrutinizes the return and the related
Page No.# 30/65
particulars furnished by the registered person to verify the
correctness of the return and inform the registered person of the
discrepancies noticed, if any, in such manner as may be prescribed
and seek his explanation. If the explanation is not satisfactory,
within 30 days of being informed by the Proper Officer or such
period as may be permitted by the Proper Officer, or where the
registered person after accepting the discrepancies fails to take
corrective measures on his return for the month in which the
discrepancies are accepted, the Proper Officer may initiate
appropriate action including those under Section 65 or 66 or 67 of
the Act of 2017 or proceed to determine the tax and other dues
under Section 73 or Section 74 or Section 74A as the case may be.
41. Section 62 of the Act of 2017 is in respect to “assessment of
non-filers of returns”. This type of assessment is being carried out
where a registered person fails to furnish the return under Section
39 or Section 45 of the Act of 2017 even after service of notice
under Section 46 and in that circumstances, the Proper Officer may
proceed to assess the tax liability of the said person to the best of
his judgment taking into account that all the relevant materials
which are available or which the Proper Officer had gathered and
issue an assessment order within a period of 5 (five) years from
the date specified under Section 44 of the Act of 2017 for
Page No.# 31/65
furnishing of the annual return for the financial year to which the
tax not paid relate. However, if the registered person furnishes a
valid return within 60 (sixty) days of the service of the assessment
order, the said order shall be deemed to be withdrawn but the
liability for payment of interest under Sub-Section (1) of Section 50
of the Act of 2017 or for payment of late fee under Section 47 shall
continue. The period of 60 days which have been mandated in
Section 62(2) of the Act of 2017 can be enlarged on payment of
further late fee.
42. Section 63 of the Act of 2017 pertains to “assessment of
unregistered persons” meaning thereby, where a taxable person
fails to obtain registration even though liable to do so, or whose
registration has been cancelled under Sub-Section (2) of Section 29
but who is liable to pay tax, the Proper Officer may proceed to
assess the tax liability of such taxable person to the best of his
judgment for the relevant tax period and issue an assessment
order within a period of 5 (five) years from the date specified
under Section 44 for furnishing of the annual return for the
financial year to which the tax not paid relates.
43. Section 64 of the Act of 2017 relates to “Summary assessment
in certain special cases”. In the circumstance, the Proper Officer
Page No.# 32/65
may on any evidence showing a tax liability of a person coming to
his notice, with the previous permission of the Additional
Commissioner or the Joint Commissioner, proceed to assess the tax
liability of such person to protect the interest of revenue and issue
an assessment order, if he has sufficient grounds to believe that
any delay in doing so may adversely affect the interest of revenue.
It is however relevant to mention that in such circumstances, the
taxable person may file an application within 30 (thirty) days from
the date of receipt of the order passed under Sub-Section (1) of
Section 64 of the Act of 2017 before the Additional Commissioner
or the Joint Commissioner or the said Authorities suo moto may
withdraw the order passed under Section 64(1) of the Act of 2017
if the said Authorities consider such order to be erroneous and
follow the proceedings laid down under Section 73 or Section 74 or
Section 74A.
44. Chapter XV of the Act of 2017 which is the pivotal Chapter for
the purpose of the present discussion is with the heading “Demand
and Recovery”. The said Chapter contains various Sections from
Section 73 to Section 84. Sections 73 and 74 of the Act of 2017
being relevant for the purpose of the present analysis are
reproduced herein under:
Page No.# 33/65
“73.
Determination of tax [pertaining to the period up to Financial
Year 2023-24] not paid or short paid or erroneously refunded or
input tax credit wrongly availed or utilised for any reason other
than fraud or any willful-misstatement or suppression of facts.—
(1)
Where it appears to the proper officer that any tax has not been
paid or short paid or erroneously refunded, or where input tax
credit has been wrongly availed or utilised for any reason, other
than the reason of fraud or any wilful-misstatement or suppression
of facts to evade tax, he shall serve notice on the person
chargeable with tax which has not been so paid or which has been
so short paid or to whom the refund has erroneously been made,
or who has wrongly availed or utilised input tax credit, requiring
him to show cause as to why he should not pay the amount
specified in the notice along with interest payable thereon under
section 50 and a penalty leviable under the provisions of this Act
or the rules made thereunder.
(2)
The proper officer shall issue the notice under sub-section (1) at
least three months prior to the time limit specified in sub-section
(10) for issuance of order.
(3)
Where a notice has been issued for any period under sub-section
(1), the proper officer may serve a statement, containing the
details of tax not paid or short paid or erroneously refunded or
input tax credit wrongly availed or utilised for such periods other
than those covered under sub-section (1), on the person
chargeable with tax.
(4)
The service of such statement shall be deemed to be service of
Page No.# 34/65
notice on such person under sub-section (1), subject to the
condition that the grounds relied upon for such tax periods other
than those covered under sub-section (1) are the same as are
mentioned in the earlier notice.
(5)
The person chargeable with tax may, before service of notice
under sub-section (1) or, as the case may be, the statement under
sub-section (3), pay the amount of tax along with interest payable
thereon under section 50 on the basis of his own ascertainment of
such tax or the tax as ascertained by the proper officer and inform
the proper officer in writing of such payment.
(6)
The proper officer, on receipt of such information, shall not serve
any notice under sub-section (1) or, as the case may be, the
statement under sub-section (3), in respect of the tax so paid or
any penalty payable under the provisions of this Act or the rules
made thereunder.
(7)
Where the proper officer is of the opinion that the amount paid
under sub-section (5) falls short of the amount actually payable,
he shall proceed to issue the notice as provided for in sub-section
(1) in respect of such amount which falls short of the amount
actually payable.
(8)
Where any person chargeable with tax under sub-section (1) or
sub-section (3) pays the said tax along with interest payable under
section 50 within thirty days of issue of show cause notice, no
penalty shall be payable and all proceedings in respect of the said
notice shall be deemed to be concluded.
Page No.# 35/65
(9)
The proper officer shall, after considering the representation, if
any, made by person chargeable with tax, determine the amount
of tax, interest and a penalty equivalent to ten per cent of tax or
ten thousand rupees, whichever is higher, due from such person
and issue an order.
(10) The proper officer shall issue the order under sub-section (9)
within three years from the due date for furnishing of annual
return for the financial year to which the tax not paid or short paid
or input tax credit wrongly availed or utilised relates to or within
three years from the date of erroneous refund.
(11) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (6) or subsection (8), penalty under sub-section (9) shall be payable where
any amount of self-assessed tax or any amount collected as tax
has not been paid within a period of thirty days from the due date
of payment of such tax.
(12) [The provisions of this section shall be applicable for determination
of tax pertaining to the period up to Financial Year 2023-24.]
74.
Determination of tax [pertaining to the period up to Financial
Year 2023-24] not paid or short paid or erroneously refunded or
input tax credit wrongly availed or utilised by reason of fraud or
any willful-misstatement or suppression of facts.—
(1)
Where it appears to the proper officer that any tax has not been
paid or short paid or erroneously refunded or where input tax
credit has been wrongly availed or utilised by reason of fraud, or
any wilful-misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax, he
Page No.# 36/65
shall serve notice on the person chargeable with tax which has
not been so paid or which has been so short paid or to whom the
refund has erroneously been made, or who has wrongly availed or
utilised input tax credit, requiring him to show cause as to why he
should not pay the amount specified in the notice along with
interest payable thereon under section 50 and a penalty
equivalent to the tax specified in the notice.
(2)
The proper officer shall issue the notice under sub-section (1) at
least six months prior to the time limit specified in sub-section
(10) for issuance of order.
(3)
Where a notice has been issued for any period under sub-section
(1), the proper officer may serve a statement, containing the
details of tax not paid or short paid or erroneously refunded or
input tax credit wrongly availed or utilised for such periods other
than those covered under sub-section (1), on the person
chargeable with tax.
(4)
The service of statement under sub-section (3) shall be deemed to
be service of notice under sub-section (1) of section 73, subject
to the condition that the grounds relied upon in the said
statement, except the ground of fraud, or any wilful-misstatement
or suppression of facts to evade tax, for periods other than those
covered under sub-section (1) are the same as are mentioned in
the earlier notice.
(5)
The person chargeable with tax may, before service of notice
under sub-section (1), pay the amount of tax along with interest
payable under section 50 and a penalty equivalent to fifteen per
Page No.# 37/65
cent of such tax on the basis of his own ascertainment of such
tax or the tax as ascertained by the proper officer and inform the
proper officer in writing of such payment.
(6)
The proper officer, on receipt of such information, shall not serve
any notice under sub-section (1), in respect of the tax so paid or
any penalty payable under the provisions of this Act or the rules
made thereunder.
(7)
Where the proper officer is of the opinion that the amount paid
under sub-section (5) falls short of the amount actually payable,
he shall proceed to issue the notice as provided for in sub-section
(1) in respect of such amount which falls short of the amount
actually payable.
(8)
Where any person chargeable with tax under sub-section (1) pays
the said tax along with interest payable under section 50 and a
penalty equivalent to twenty-five per cent of such tax within thirty
days of issue of the notice, all proceedings in respect of the said
notice shall be deemed to be concluded.
(9)
The proper officer shall, after considering the representation, if
any, made by the person chargeable with tax, determine the
amount of tax, interest and penalty due from such person and
issue an order.
(10) The proper officer shall issue the order under sub-section (9)
within a period of five years from the due date for furnishing of
annual return for the financial year to which the tax not paid or
short paid or input tax credit wrongly availed or utilised relates to
Page No.# 38/65
or within five years from the date of erroneous refund.
(11) Where any person served with an order issued under sub-section
(9) pays the tax along with interest payable thereon under section
50 and a penalty equivalent to fifty per cent of such tax within
thirty days of communication of the order, all proceedings in
respect of the said notice shall be deemed to be concluded.
(12)
[The provisions of this section shall be applicable for
determination of tax pertaining to the period up to Financial Year
2023-24.]
Explanation 1- For the purposes of section 73 and this section(i)
the expression “all proceedings in respect of the said notice” shall
not include proceedings under section 132;
(ii)
where the notice under the same proceedings is issued to the
main person liable to pay tax and some other persons, and such
proceedings against the main person have been concluded under
section 73 or section 74, the proceedings against all the persons
liable to pay penalty under [sections 122 and 125] are deemed to
be concluded.”
45. It is relevant to take note of the fact that Sub-Section (12) of
Section 73 and Sub-Section (12) of Section 74 of the Act of 2017
were inserted vide the Finance Act, 2024 w.e.f. 01.11.2024 and the
reason being the insertion of Section 74A vide the Finance Act,
Page No.# 39/65
2024 w.e.f. 01.11.2024.
46. A perusal of the above two quoted provisions stipulates the
procedure to be followed for the purpose of determination of tax.
The procedure stipulated in both the provisions appears to be
similar except the cause of action for initiation of proceedings
under Section 73 of the Act of 2017 is different from the cause of
action for initiation of proceedings under Section 74 of the Act of
2017.
47. A reading of Section 73(1) of the Act of 2017 would show the
cause of action for the purpose of issuance of a notice upon the
person chargeable with tax. The cause of action is when it appears
to the Proper Officer(a) Any tax has not been paid; or
(b) Short paid; or
(c) Erroneously refunded; or
(d)
Where input tax credit have been wrongly availed or utilized
for any reason.
Page No.# 40/65
Other than
the reason of fraud or any willful
misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax,
A notice would be issued requiring the person chargeable with
tax to show cause as to why the person chargeable with tax should
not pay the amount specified in the notice along with interest
payable thereon under Section 50 of the Act of 2017 and a
penalty leviable under the provisions of the Act of 2017 or
the Rules of 2017.
The difference between Section 73(1) and 74(1) is that in the
case of Section 74(1), when it appears to the Proper Officer that (a) Any tax have not been paid; or
(b) Short paid; or
(c) Erroneously refunded; or
(d) Where input tax credit have been wrongly availed or utilized.
By reason of fraud or any willful misstatement or
suppression of fact to evade tax,
Page No.# 41/65
A notice would be issued to the person chargeable requiring
him to show cause as to why the person chargeable with tax
should not pay the amounts specified in the notice along with
interest payable thereon under Section 50 of the Act of 2017 and a
penalty equivalent to the tax specified in the notice.
The distinguishing phrases in both the Sections have been
highlighted hereinabove in bold letters.
48. The difference between Section 73(1) and Section 74(1) of the
Act of 2017, is therefore clear that when it is a case of fraud or any
willful misstatement or suppression of fact to evade tax, Section 74
of the Act of 2017 would be attracted otherwise, Section 73 of the
Act of 2017 would be applicable. However, a perusal of both
Section 73(1) and Section 74(1) of the Act of 2017 do not specify
that the said notice should be against a single financial year or for
that matter, for each financial year, there has to be a separate
notice. The reason in the opinion of this Court is that the cause of
action for initiation of the notice under Section 73(1) or Section
74(1) of the Act of 2017 by virtue of the said Sub-Sections confers
a jurisdiction upon the Proper Officer to issue the notice on the
existence of the material facts satisfying the Proper Officer to issue
the notice under Section 73(1) or 74(1) of the Act of 2017 as the
Page No.# 42/65
case may be. In other words, the said Sub-Section (1) of Section
73 and Section 74 of the Act of 2017 do not impose any
restrictions when the conditions stipulated in Sub-Section (1)
satisfies the Proper Officer.
49. The curbs to the exercise of power to issue Notice under SubSection (1) of Section 73 or Section 74 of the Act of 2017 are seen
at Section 73(2) and Section 74(2) of the Act of 2017 whereby the
Proper Officer for the purpose of determination of tax can issue
notice under Sub-Section (1) of Section 73 of the Act of 2017 at
least 3 (three) months prior to the time limit specified in SubSection (10) of Section 73 of the Act of 2017 for issuance of the
order. Similarly, in terms with Section 74(2) of the Act of 2017, the
notice under Sub-Section (1) of Section 74(1) of the Act of 2017
has to be issued at least 6 (six) months prior to the time limit
specified in Section 74(10) of the Act of 2017 for issuance of the
order. It is however relevant to observe that Sub-Section (2) of
Section 73 and Section 74 of the Act of 2017 only imposes
restrictions on the time limit for issuance of notice and nothing
else.
50. Before further proceeding in seriatum with the other SubSections of Section 73 and Section 74 of the Act of 2017, this Court
Page No.# 43/65
finds it relevant to take note of Section 73(10) and Section 74(10)
of the Act of 2017 as there is a correlation between Section 73(10)
and Section 74(10) with Section 73(2) and Section 74(2) of the Act
of 2017.
51. Section 73(10) of the Act of 2017 confers the power upon the
Proper Officer to pass the order under Section 73(9) of the Act of
2017 within 3 years from the due date for furnishing of the annual
return for the financial year to which the tax not paid or short paid
or input tax credit wrongly availed or utilized relates to, or within 3
years from the date of erroneous refund. This Sub-Section
therefore provides two points for limitation for passing the order
under Section 73(9) of the Act of 2017.
Insofar as tax not paid or short paid or input tax credit wrongly
availed or utilized, the date within which the order under Section
73(9) can be passed for determining the tax, interest and penalty
is 3 (three) years from the due date for furnishing of the annual
return.
However, in respect to passing an order insofar as it relates to
erroneous refund, the order under Section 73(9) is required to be
passed within 3 (three) years from the date of erroneous refund.
Page No.# 44/65
52. Insofar as Section 74(10) of the Act of 2017 is concerned, it is
pari materia to Section 73(10) except the period of limitation for
passing of the order under Section 74(9) of the Act of 2017 is five
(5) years which is otherwise three (3) years in the case of Section
73(10) of the Act of 2017.
53. For the purpose of understanding the aforementioned aspect,
the following illustrations appear to be relevant:(A)
For the Financial Year 2017-18, the due date for filing the
annual return would be 31st of December 2018. In terms with SubSections (1), (2), (10) of Section 73 of the Act of 2017, when it
appears to the Proper Officer that any tax has not been paid, or
short paid, or where input tax credit has been wrongly evaded or
utilized for any reason, the notice has to be issued on or before
30.09.2021 and the order has to be passed in terms of Section
73(9) on or before 31.12.2021. However, insofar as refund made
erroneously, it would depend on the date of the refund. Similarly, a
case falling within the ambit of Section 74 in respect to the
financial year 2017-18, the notice has to be issued on or before
30.06.2023 and the order has to be passed on or before
31.12.2023.
Page No.# 45/65
Applying the said analogy, if a notice under Section 73(1) is
issued after 30.09.2021 for the financial year 2017-18, the notice
would be barred under Section 73(2). Similarly, for the same
financial year 2017-18, if the notice under Section 74(1) is issued
after 30.06.2023, the notice would be barred under Section 74(2)
of the Act of 2017. It is also relevant to observe herein what is
barred if the notice is issued beyond the period stipulated in
Section 73(2) and Section 74(2) of the Act of 2017. It would bar
determination of tax liability for that financial year in terms with
Section 73 or Section 74 as the case may be.
(B)
Let this Court take the example of three financial years i.e.
2017-18, 2018-19, 2019-20 in respect to a proceeding under
Section 73 of the Act of 2017. The due date for filing of the annual
returns for the financial years 2017-18, 2018-19 and 2019-20
would be 31.12.2018, 31.12.2019 and 31.12.2020 except in the
case of erroneous refund. The notice under Section 73(1) of the
Act of 2017 in terms with Section 73(2), for the Financial year
2017-18, 2018-19, 2019-20, has to be issued on or before
30.09.2021, 30.09.2022 and 30.09.2023 respectively. The orders
under Section 73(9) in respect to the financial years 2017-18,
2018-19, and 2019-20 are to be passed on or before 31.12.2021,
31.12.2022 and 31.12.2023. For the purpose of convenience, the
Page No.# 46/65
following table would be helpful:
Period
Due date for filing Period within which Period within which order is to
of annual return notice under Section
be passed under Section
73(1) is to be issued
73(9)
2017-2018
31.12.2018
30.09.2021
31.12.2021
2018-2019
31.12.2019
30.09.2022
31.12.2022
2019-2020
31.12.2020
30.09.2023
31.12.2023
From the above, it would be seen that for the financial years
2017-18, 2018-19 and 2019-20, separate notices under Section
73(1) can be issued on or before 30.09.2021 and separate orders
can be passed in respect to the 3 financial years i.e. 2017-18,
2018-19, 2019-20 on or before 31.12.2021.
The pivotal question which arises in the instant proceedings is
as to whether there is a bar in terms with the provisions of the Act
of 2017 for issuance of a consolidated notice for the financial years
2017-18, 2018-19 and 2019-20, on or before 30.09.2021 and a
consolidated order can be passed for the financial years 2017-18,
2018-19 and 2019-20 on or before 31.12.2021. The said aspect
would be dealt with in the later segment of the present judgment
after taking into consideration the illustration relating to Section 74
of the Act of 2017 herein under.
Page No.# 47/65
(C)
Sub-Sections (1), (2) and (10) of Section 74 of the Act of
2017 stipulates the period is 5 (five) years from the due date of
filing of the annual return except in the case of erroneous refund
when the starting period of limitation would be for the date of
erroneous refund. This Court would be taking up for illustrative
purpose 5 (five) financial years that would be the financial years
2017-18, 2018-19, 2019-20, 2020-21, and 2021-22. For the
purpose of convenience, this Court inserts the following table.
Period
Due date for filing
of annual return
Period within which
issuance of notice
under Section 74(1)
Period within which
order is to be passed
under Section 74(9)
2017-2018
31.12.2018
30.06.2023
31.12.2023
2018-2019
31.12.2019
30.06.2024
31.12.2024
2019-2020
31.12.2020
30.06.2025
31.12.2025
2020-2021
28.02.2022
28.09.2026
28.02.2027
2021-2022
31.12.2022
30.06.2027
31.12.2027
The above chart would therefore show that for the period 201718, 2018-19, 2019-20, 2020-21 and 2021-22, the notice under
Section 74(2) is required to be issued on or before 30.06.2023,
30.06.2024, 30.06.2025, 28.09.2026 and 30.06.2027 respectively.
Similarly, the order under Section 74(9) in respect to these 5
financial years are to be on or before 31.12.2023, 31.12.2024,
Page No.# 48/65
31.12.2025, 28.02.2027 and 31.12.2027 respectively. Therefore, it
would be seen that for the financial years 2017-18, 2018-19, 201920, 2020-21, and 2021-22, even separate notices can be issued
under Section 74(1) for all these 5 periods on or before 30.06.2023
and separate orders can also be passed in respect to these 5
financial years on or before 31.12.2023.
54. The question therefore is that, is there any explicit bar upon a
reading of Sub-Section (1), Sub-Section (2), Sub-Section (9) and
Sub-Section (10) of Section 74 or for that matter, any provision of
the Act of 2017 to issue a consolidated notice for 5 financial years
i.e. 2017-18, 2018-19, 2019-20, 2020-21 and 2021-22 on or before
30.06.2023 and pass a common order on or before 31.12.2023.
55. The above illustrations and a reading of Sub-Section (1), SubSection (2), Sub-Section (9) and Sub-Section (10) of both Section
73 as well as Section 74 of the Act of 2017 do not bar issuance of
a consolidated notice if for the periods for which the notice have
been issued is within the period permissible under Section 73(2) as
well as Section 74(2) of the Act of 2017. Likewise, if a consolidated
notice is issued in terms with Section 73(1) or Section 74(1) of the
Act of 2017 in consonance with Section 73(2) or 74(2) of the Act of
2017 as the case may be, in respect to the various periods, there is
Page No.# 49/65
no bar in Section 73(9) or Section 74(9) of the Act of 2017 to pass
a consolidated order if done so within the period stipulated under
Section 73(10) or 74(10) of the Act of 2017 respectively. This Court
also finds it relevant to observe that neither the learned counsels
for the Petitioners nor a perusal of the provisions of the Act of
2017, any explicit bar could be shown or noticed for issuance of a
consolidated notice in terms with Section 73(1) or Section 74(1) of
the Act of 2017, if such notice was issued within the period
stipulated in terms with Section 73(2) or Section 74(2) of the Act
of 2017. Similarly, there appears to be no bar in passing a
consolidated order for various financial years, if the consolidated
order is permissible within the period mentioned in Section 73(9)
or Section 74(9) of the Act of 2017.
56. For the sake of clarity, this Court finds it relevant to mention
that the illustrations at Clauses (A), (B) and (C) of Paragraph No.53
hereinabove are only for illustrative purposes and the same have
not
been made by taking into consideration the various
notifications issued by the Central Government under Section 168A
of the Act of 2017 whereby periods have been extended for
passing orders under Section 73(9) and Section 74(9) of the Act of
2017.
Page No.# 50/65
57. At this stage, it is relevant to take note of the submissions
made by the learned counsels for the Petitioners that a
consolidated notice causes prejudice to the Petitioners insofar as
taking up their defences inasmuch as for each financial year, they
may have a different defence. It is the opinion of this Court that a
prejudice caused if it comes within the mischief of Article 14 of the
Constitution would result in nullifying the provision but till the
provision remains, it would not divest the Proper Officer to issue
the consolidated notice or pass the consolidated order, if done so
within the limitation provided under Section 73 and Section 74 of
the Act of 2017, as the case may be.
58. This Court while analyzing the interplay between Sections
73(1), 73(2), 73(9) and Section 73(10) as well as Sections 74(1),
74(2), 74(9) and 74(10) of the Act of 2017, finds it relevant to deal
with an important aspect and more particularly in view of the
observations made hereinabove. The aspect pertains to the
consequence when a consolidated notice has been issued under
Section 73(1) or Section 74(1) of the Act of 2017 as the case may
be, in respect to a period which is barred by limitation. This aspect
is important inasmuch as, the power to issue notice within a
specific period of time is stipulated in Section 73(2) or Section
74(2) of the Act of 2017. Therefore, the jurisdiction to issue notice
Page No.# 51/65
is restricted to the period mentioned therein. Now what is this
jurisdiction conferred upon the Proper Officer under Section 73 and
Section 74 of the Act of 2017?
The jurisdiction so conferred is the jurisdiction to determine
the tax. Therefore what would be the effect of a consolidated
notice which pertains to various financial years of which in respect
to one or more financial years, no notice could be issued on
account of the bar contained in Section 73(2) or Section 74(2) of
the Act of 2017. The answer to the said question is available in
Section 73 as well as Section 74 of the Act of 2017 itself.
59. There is no quarrel with the proposition that for each financial
year, a notice can be issued under Section 73(1) or Section 74(1)
of the Act of 2017 within the period stipulated in Section 73(2) or
and Section 74(2) of the Act of 2017. Likewise, an order for each
financial year can be passed under Section 73(9) or Section 74(9)
of the Act of 2017 on the basis of a valid notice within the time
stipulated in Section 73(10) or Section 74(10) of the Act of 2017 as
the case may be. It is the opinion of this Court that if separate
notices for separate financial years and separate orders for
separate financial years can be passed, the consolidated Notice for
various financial years as well as the consolidated order for various
Page No.# 52/65
financial years together can also be passed by segregating the
financial years which are barred by limitation by applying the
doctrine of severability inasmuch as, each financial year constitutes
a separate cause of action. In this regard, it is relevant to observe
that Section 73 and Section 74 of the Act of 2017 are provisions for
determination of tax liability within the parameters stipulated in the
said Sections read with the Section 75 of the Act of 2017.
For the purpose of understanding the aforesaid principle, the
example of a suit for distinct/recurring causes of action seems to
be apt. Suits espousing distinct/recurring causes of action are suits
for Arrears of Rent /Installment Payment; suits on Running
Accounts; Suits for Accounts in Partnership/Agency etc. In suits for
Arrears of Rent, each rental period gives rise to an independent
cause of action. A suit may well be within time for later rents while
earlier rental periods are time barred. The entire suit does not
become time barred and the Court would grant the decree insofar
as the rental periods which are within time and deny the decree
insofar as those rental period which are barred by limitation.
60. At this stage, this Court also finds it relevant to take note of
the submission made by the learned counsels for the Petitioners to
the effect that Section 73 and Section 74 of the Act of 2017 is a
Page No.# 53/65
part of the assessment proceedings. This submission was made
with an intention to show before this Court that the Scheme of the
Goods and Service Tax Act is financial year specific and therefore
proceedings initiated in terms with Section 73 and Section 74 of
the Act of 2017 should also be financial year wise and not two or
more different financial years combined together.
61. The said submission though appears to be plausible at the first
blush but in the opinion of this Court, the said submission is
misconceived. The reasons for opining so are:
(A)
The Legislature had kept “Assessment” proceedings
separately
with
that
of
“Demand
and
Recovery”
inasmuch as, Assessment is at Chapter XII of the Act of
2017 whereas “Demand and Recovery” is at Chapter XV
of the Act of 2017.
(B) The definition of Assessment at Section 2(11) of the Act
of 2017 means determination of tax liability under the
Act
and
includes
Self-Assessment,
Reassessment,
Provisional Assessment, Summary Assessment and Best
Judgment Assessment. Section 59 of the Act of 2017
stipulates Self Assessment; Section 60 of the Act of
Page No.# 54/65
2017 stipulates Provisional Assessment; Section 61 of
the Act of 2017 stipulates Scrutiny Assessment; Section
62 and Section 63 of the Act of 2017 stipulates Best
Judgment Assessment and Section 64 of the Act of 2017
stipulates
Summary
Assessment.
In
the
previous
segments of the present judgment, this Court had
explained when the above forms of assessments are
carried out. It is of relevance to note that self
assessment is made by the registered person without
the involvement of the Taxing Authorities.
Scrutiny Assessment are inquisitorial in nature
where the Proper Officer scrutinizes the return to verify
the correctness and informs the registered person to
resolve the discrepancies or explain the discrepancies. If
the explanation is found satisfactory or the discrepancies
are resolved by the registered person, the assessment is
carried out.
Provisional Assessment is at the request of the
Registered person.
Summary
Assessment
and
Best
Judgment
Page No.# 55/65
Assessment are unilateral in nature whereby the Proper
Officer initiates steps for carrying out the assessment on
account of existence of grounds to carry out such
assessment.
It is to be noted herein that all these forms of
assessment are not adversarial in nature. However
proceedings under Section 73 and Section 74 of the Act
of 2017 are adversarial and adjudicatory in nature
inasmuch as, when the Proper Officer is satisfied that
any tax had not been paid or short paid or erroneously
refunded or where input tax credit had been wrongly
availed or utilized, the cause of action accrues upon the
Proper Officer to issue notice granting an opportunity to
the person chargeable with tax to reply, carry out a
hearing as envisaged in Section 75 of the Act of 2017
and thereupon pass an order of adjudication. The
scheme
of
the
Act
of
therefore
clearly
distinguishes between assessment and an adjudication
carried out in terms with Section 73 or Section 74 of the
Act of 2017.
(C)
Another pertinent aspect which distinguishes assessment
Page No.# 56/65
from adjudication made under Section 73 or Section 74
of the Act of 2017 is that a perusal of Chapter XII of the
Act of 2017 would clearly show that proceedings under
Section 73 or Section 74 of the Act of 2017 are an
aftermath proceedings post the assessment carried out
in terms with Sections 59, 61 and 64 of the Act of 2017.
Similarly, assessment carried out under Section 62 and
63 of the Act of 2017 are proceedings without prejudice
to the provisions of Section 73 or Section 74 of the Act of
2017.
(D) The
most
pertinent
distinguishing
factor
between
assessment carried out in terms with Chapter XII of the
Act of 2017 with the adjudication carried out in terms
with Section 73 and Section 74 of the Act of 2017 is that
assessments referred to in Chapter XII of the Act of 2017
do not conceptualize penalty whereas adjudication
carried out under Section 73 and Section 74 of the Act of
2017 empowers the Proper Officer not only to determine
the tax liability on account of the tax not paid or short
paid or erroneously refunded or input tax credit wrongly
availed or utilized but also impose interest and penalty.
Page No.# 57/65
(E) Another distinguishing feature between assessment made
under Chapter XII of the Act of 2017 and Section 74 of
the Act of 2017 is that while carrying out assessment the
element of fraud or willful misstatement or suppression
of facts to evade tax cannot be ascertained or decided
whereas it is only in a proceedings under Section 74 of
the Act of 2017 such aspect can be decided.
62. This Court now finds it relevant to take note of Sub-Section (3)
and Sub-Section (4) of Section 73 and Section 74 of the Act of
2017 which appears to be the basis of the judgments of the Delhi
High Court in the case of Ambika Traders (supra) as well as M/S
Mathur Polymers (supra). A perusal of Sub-Section (3) of Section
73 of the Act of 2017 shows that if a notice is issued under SubSection (1) of Section 73 of the Act of 2017 for any period, a
discretion is also conferred upon the Proper Officer to serve a
statement containing the details of tax not paid or short paid or
erroneously refunded or input tax credit wrongly availed or utilized
for such periods other than those covered under Sub-Section (1)
on the person chargeable with tax. This statement is issued in
terms of Rule 142(1)(b) of the Rules of 2017. It is apposite herein
to mention that the notice in terms with Section 73(1) of the Act of
2017 is issued under Rule 142(1)(a) of the Rules of 2017 and the
Page No.# 58/65
summary of the said notice is issued in FORM GST DRC-01. The
statement which is served by the Proper Officer in terms with
Section 73(3) of the Act of 2017 is in FORM GST DRC-02.
63. It is also very apposite herein to observe that Sub-Section (4)
of Section 73 stipulates that if the Proper Officer in his discretion
serves a statement in terms with Rule 142(1)(b) of the Rules of
2017 and in FORM GST DRC-02, the said statement shall be
construed to be a service of notice on such person under SubSection (1) however, subject to that the grounds relied upon for
the tax periods are the same as mentioned in the notice issued
under Section 73(1). The said two sub-sections i.e. Sub-Section (3)
and (4) of Section 73 of the Act of 2017 therefore envisages that
there is no necessity for issuance of a separate Show Cause Notice
under Section 73(1) of the Act of 2017 for other periods. A mere
statement in terms of Rule 142(1)(b) in the FORM GST DRC-02 is
sufficient for initiation of a proceedings under Section 73(1) of the
Act of 2017 for such other periods. The expression “for such
periods other than those covered under Sub-Section (1)” as
appearing in Sub-Section (3) and Sub-Section (4) of Section 73 of
the Act of 2017 and more particularly, the expression “those
covered under Sub-Section (1)” gives a pluralistic reference to the
period(s) covered in the notice under Section 73(1) of the Act of
Page No.# 59/65
2017.
64. Sub-Section (3) of Section 74 of the Act of 2017 is verbatim
similar to Section 73(3) of the Act of 2017. However, insofar as
Sub-Section (4) of Section 74 of the Act of 2017 is concerned, it
stipulates that if there is a service of statement in terms with SubSection (3) of Section 74 of the Act of 2017, this statement which
is given in terms with Section 142(1)(b) of the Rules of 2017 read
in the FORM GST DRC-02 shall be deemed to be a notice in terms
of Section 73(1) of the Act of 2017 provided the grounds relied
upon in the said statement do not constitute the ground of fraud or
any willful misstatement or suppression of fact to evade tax. In
other words, the service of a statement under Section 74(3) of the
Act of 2017 would be deemed to be a notice under Section 73(1)
of the Act of 2017 provided the grounds relied upon do not come
within the ambit of fraud or any willful misstatement or
suppression of fact to evade tax. The expression “for such periods
other than those covered under Sub-Section (1)” as appearing in
Sub-Section (3) and Sub-Section (4) of Section 74 of the Act of
2017 and more particularly, the expression “those covered under
Sub-Section (1)” gives a pluralistic reference to the period(s)
covered in the notice under Section 74(1) of the Act of 2017.
Page No.# 60/65
65. The other Sub-Sections i.e. Sub-Section (5), (6), (7), (8), (11)
and 12 are not necessary for the present discussion.
66. In the backdrop of the above, this Court now finds it relevant
to take note of the various judgments relied upon by the learned
counsels for the parties.
67. Upon perusal of the various judgments, this Court for the
analysis and finding arrived at hereinabove with great respect
disagrees with the judgment of the learned Division Bench of the
Kerala High Court in M/S Tharayil Medicals (Supra) and Dhanlaxmi
Bank Limited (supra). This Court also disagrees with the views of
the Madras High Court in M/S Oriental Lotus Hotel Supplies Private
Limited (supra) as well as Titan Company Limited (supra).
68. The proposition of law laid down by the Bombay High Court in
Milroc Good Earth Developers (supra) , Marfani Steel Impex (supra)
and Aasawa Brother Corporate Avenue (supra) have been doubted
by the learned Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in the
case of Rollmet LLP Vs. Union of India and Others reported in 2026
SCC Online Bom 2613. This Court had perused the reasons so
assigned by the learned Division Bench of the Bombay High Court
in the case of Rollmet LLP (supra). This Court agrees with the
Page No.# 61/65
reasons assigned in Rollmet LLP (supra) for doubting the earlier
decisions of the Bombay High Court.
69. This Court has also perused the judgments of the Delhi High
Court in Ambika Traders (supra) and M/S Mathur Polymers (supra)
and duly agrees to the proposition of law that there is no bar in
issuance of a consolidated Show Cause Notice in terms with
Section 73 or Section 74 of the Act of 2017. This Court further
agrees with the observations of the learned Division Bench of the
Karnataka High Court in the case of M/S Pramur Homes and
Shelters (supra) more particularly to the observations made at
Paragraph No.57. This Court also agrees with the conclusions
arrived at by the learned Division Bench of the Allahabad High
Court in the case of S.A. Aromatics Private Limited (supra) to the
effect that it is permissible to have a consolidated Show Cause
Notice.
DECISION ON THE JURISDICTIONAL ISSUES RAISED IN THE
PRESENT PROCEEDINGS:
70. Accordingly, this Court opines as under:
(a)
There is no bar in issuance of a consolidated Show
Cause Notice for different financial years together under
Page No.# 62/65
Section 73(1) or under Section 74(1) of the Act of 2017.
(b)
There is no bar in passing of a consolidated order for
different financial years together under Section 73(9) or
Section 74(9) of the Act of 2017.
(c)
The Proper Officer in the respective cases of the three
writ petitioners was within his jurisdiction conferred
upon in law to issue the consolidated Show Cause
Notices as well as pass the consolidated orders against
each of the petitioners in the three writ petitions.
71. This Court observes as well as clarifies that this Court had only
decided the jurisdictional issues raised in the present proceedings
and the merits in respect to the Orders-in-Original and Orders-inAppeal insofar as the Petitioners in WP(C) No.2922/2025 and
WP(C) No.20/2026 are concerned and the Order-in-Original passed
against the Petitioner in WP(C) No.1113/2026 have not been
adjudicated by this Court.
72. The jurisdictional issue raised in the present proceedings
having been answered against the Petitioners and taking into
account that the Petitioners in WP(C) No.2922/2025 and WP(C)
No.20/2026 have alternative and efficacious remedies available
Page No.# 63/65
under Section 112 of the Act of 2017 and the Petitioner in WP(C)
No.1113/2026 has alternative and efficacious remedies available
under Section 107 of the Act of 2017, this Court relegates the
Petitioners to avail the statutory remedies stated hereinabove.
73. This Court having perused the materials on record in the three
writ petitions is also of the view that the Statutory Authorities
would be in a better position to adjudicate the factual issues. The
question of fraud or any willful misstatement or suppression of
facts to evade tax are essentially factual adjudication and as stated
above, the Statutory Appellate Authorities would be in a better
position to adjudicate.
CONCLUSIONS:
74. Accordingly, all the three writ petitions stands disposed of with
the following observations and directions:
(i)
This Court grants liberty to the Petitioners in the three writ
petition to avail remedies before the appropriate forum under
the Act of 2017.
(ii)
This Court further observes that in the circumstance, the
Petitioners in WP(C) No.2922/2025 and WP(C) No.20/2026
Page No.# 64/65
approach the Appellate Tribunal within 30 (thirty) days from
the date of the present judgment, the Appellate Tribunal shall
decide the respective appeals so filed by the writ petitioners
in WP(C) No.2922/2025 and WP(C) No.20/2026 on merits
without insisting on the question of limitation in filing the
appeals.
(iii) This Court further grants liberty to the Petitioner in WP(C)
No.1113/2026 to approach the Appellate Authority in terms
with Section 107 of the Act of 2017 and it is observed that if
the Petitioner in WP(C) No.1113/2026 approaches within a
period of 30 (thirty) days from the date of the present
judgment, the Appellate Authority shall decide the appeal on
merits, without insisting on the question of limitation.
(iv) This Court further observes that the interim orders passed in
the three writ petitions shall continue till the consideration of
the stay application by the Appellate Tribunal/Appellate
Authority as the case may be subject to the Appeals being
filed by the Petitioners herein as per the liberty granted herein
above within the period of 30 (thirty) days from the date of
the present judgment.
Page No.# 65/65
(v) There shall be no orders as to cost.
Bijoy
Saha
Comparing Assistant
Bijoy Saha
Date: 2026.06.08
20:07:26 +05'30'
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review